wow, i've just discovered this song all over again, i always doubt that the power of his voice will return to me if i listen to him over and over again but he always surprises me! i love him so much! Idina is beautiful as always! :)
Breathtaking, I love Idina and Josh. I've loved Idina since she was on Broadway as Elphaba, and to see her perform with him is beauty. total perfection. I wish they would do an album together!!
I actually don't think their voices mesh well together. Her voice sounds so light and weak against his rich and heavy voice. It is a shame because alone I understand her to have a very powerful voice. He outshines her in this performance. Just goes to show that celebrity pairings are not always magic.
The lyrics were very appropriate for Florence and Anatoly...this is my favorite Idina/Josh duet by far (even more than "Mountain Duet" or "You and I")
im writing a song that this helped inspire. it is a lot more pop than slow. and the tempo is alot faster. i wanted to put this much emotion to it. i want people to feel the love and listen and understand the bitter sweet lyrics. idina menzel and josh groban i believe make the best duet couple. i also like idina and adam pascal. expecially in Chess. sorry its really long.
Not so sure I like the two of them together. I love Josh. I like Idina. but together???
I don't think I like the arrangement they chose for this , one of my favorites. First time ever not crazy about something that had Josh in it. I don't think their voices area good blend. :(
oh dear. i didnt plan on crying today. i love love love idina from the first time i seen her. she is just so amazing. and i wont even get started on josh. gorgeous version of this song. some one pass me the tissues.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Hum.... I find Idina a little annoying... Josh Groban and Idina are very different ranges of voices and she appears to be nasely and shreekish... sorry if I have offended the fans of Idina.... but Josh Groban is irreplacable..... take her out of this one.
@pwitht actually, their vocal ranges are pretty easily comparable...josh is a baritone and idina is a mezzo-soprano....they should be pretty comfortable octaves apart...ntm they both handled their harmonies wonderfully. If you know about vocal placement you know she isnt being nasal or "shreekish"...she just has a forward belt...a rare talent and it sounds beautiful.
So ... Josh Groban has been my absolute favorite male artist for years. I'm a musical theatre performer, and Idina is a goddess. And this song, I've loved since Josh toured with it before Awake was even released.
All together ... OMG ... I'M DEAD! I just DIED! Absolutely! Why am I JUST finding this!?
But... I think the original is better of course. Yet this isn't that bad... just that there were certain parts of the song where she just didn't fit in very well with his voice... like at 3:49 and 0:53. But then there were parts that were good too like at 2:16 and 3:38.
everytime i listen to Idina sing she always sends shivers through my body. She has just a wonderful voice and is also you can tell she is such a nice person! She is my role model, i love her!!!
whoever's idea it was to put them together on stage is my new hero. they are my two favorite singers of all time and together they're just...... beyond words.....
Sigh. I know she's supposed to be this really great singer -- and she does a good job blending with Josh -- but I just don't like her style of singng at all. Love him, though.
@carizbo you so can! I did it! You can download this video in Mp3 shape, on VDownloader -It's veeery easy, quick, no virus threats, and altought the volume's a little low, It does work out. You're life can be complete ;) If you need help to download the program or to use it, email me. Good Luck :]
I can't stop watching this again and again and again. It's soo winderful. breathtaking. there's so much emotion in it. listening to it makes me fall in love with idina more and more and more.. She's the best! i love you Idina!
So, this is basically the best video I've ever seen O.O two of my favorite people in the world singing one of my favorite Josh Groban songs. Wow... MIND BLOWING.
Idina menzel is extremely talented! She has an amazing, beautiful voice. I'm am really jealous of Josh groban because he had the opportunity to meet her and sing with her! I am excited to see her perform in San fransisco in July!!!
iceprincess275 your an idiot. idina menzel has an amazing voice. she met josh groban and is now a superstar. shes done broadway, movies, and music. and your sitting in front of a computer screen bashing her. shes amazing. she owns :) youu dont. gettaa life, idiot! YOU go hannah and wild fire! man your deaf and really mean. you need a good five finger fresshy :D
wow, i've just discovered this song all over again, i always doubt that the power of his voice will return to me if i listen to him over and over again but he always surprises me! i love him so much! Idina is beautiful as always! :)
loulie1997 1 day ago
I didn't know J Grob played the piano. Is there anything he can't do?
ozama630 2 weeks ago
this is sooooooo beautiful! <3 them!
ekvk120608luv 1 month ago
Her voice sounds good for country music
Lucero2405 1 month ago
@Lucero2405 I agree. :) I love country
ekvk120608luv 1 month ago
She has crazy eyes.
liljee16 2 months ago
Breathtaking, I love Idina and Josh. I've loved Idina since she was on Broadway as Elphaba, and to see her perform with him is beauty. total perfection. I wish they would do an album together!!
manthamonroe91 2 months ago
one of my fave songs sung by two of my fave singers! the best!
TheCharmedbabe 2 months ago
13 people are sleeping.
sadicaoleary 2 months ago
Comment removed
mollysangelique 2 months ago
Where is the EARGASM button?
luthiem17 2 months ago 4
I actually don't think their voices mesh well together. Her voice sounds so light and weak against his rich and heavy voice. It is a shame because alone I understand her to have a very powerful voice. He outshines her in this performance. Just goes to show that celebrity pairings are not always magic.
IElizabethM17 2 months ago
I have to say that even when their voices match so nicely together... I much prefer to hear this song just with Josh
aleth017 3 months ago
The lyrics were very appropriate for Florence and Anatoly...this is my favorite Idina/Josh duet by far (even more than "Mountain Duet" or "You and I")
ss74656 3 months ago
Great harmony!! Go Josh! ;)
VolleyballQueen2016 4 months ago
i love my choir director for making this one of our graduation songs :)
ItsMeMimiLi 4 months ago in playlist IDINA MENZEL
@ItsMeMimiLi So jealous!
Sakina1222 3 months ago
beautiful <3
taylor13loveswift 4 months ago
The ten people who disliked this will perish
SavvyDowning 5 months ago
this literally gives me chillls!!!! i love them both so much!!! wish they recorded a studio version!!!!!
weenz05 6 months ago 2
I love both of them so much.
HPlover37 6 months ago 3
im writing a song that this helped inspire. it is a lot more pop than slow. and the tempo is alot faster. i wanted to put this much emotion to it. i want people to feel the love and listen and understand the bitter sweet lyrics. idina menzel and josh groban i believe make the best duet couple. i also like idina and adam pascal. expecially in Chess. sorry its really long.
OpenMindsAreKey181 7 months ago
Not so sure I like the two of them together. I love Josh. I like Idina. but together???
I don't think I like the arrangement they chose for this , one of my favorites. First time ever not crazy about something that had Josh in it. I don't think their voices area good blend. :(
Macsdaug 7 months ago
beyond brilliant
harmonywho1 7 months ago
shes more pop and hes more classical. but the blending will have to take some getting used to. overall, not bad.
GoddessOfShips1 7 months ago
i absolutley LOVE josh and idina!!!! they should definately do more duets together!!!
meldawn21 8 months ago
:') Words can not express!!!
famosyyo 8 months ago 4
So beautiful, Idina Menzel and Josh Groban's voices just melt together is such perfectness
defyinggravity40 8 months ago 19
As soon as Idina started singing, I started to tear up. SO GOOD.
SavvyDowning 8 months ago
This song is so beautiful! love it!
msonlykote 8 months ago
EARGASMIC!
xfranc1n3x 8 months ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow! She almost ruins it. He's alot better off on his own, or at least with someone with a good voice.
AsusG73 9 months ago
@AsusG73 well someone obviously hasnt got a clue. idina is amazing. id like to see you do better.
livismummy 8 months ago 3
@AsusG73 Are you serious!? Idina has one of the most stunning voices in the world!
unshallowifyable 8 months ago 9
@AsusG73 Just leave.
defyinggravity40 8 months ago 3
@AsusG73 you fucking suck
potatoeking124 7 months ago
Their voices are a match made in heaven!
Una7654 9 months ago 2
She is gorgeous! This is amazing.
theatrechick3434 9 months ago 2
One of my favorite duets of all times, if not my favorite. This song gives me chills every time i listen to it. Beautifully done. <3
GiovannaClapis 9 months ago
oh dear. i didnt plan on crying today. i love love love idina from the first time i seen her. she is just so amazing. and i wont even get started on josh. gorgeous version of this song. some one pass me the tissues.
livismummy 10 months ago
Can I cry now? Ohnestly I feel paralized!
famosyyo 10 months ago
Josh Groban sings 'keep your eyes wide open' with his eyes closed...
WeasleyIsOurKing93 10 months ago
josh groban should've been fiyero in wicked next to idina as elphie !!!!!!!!!!!!
gabeeta 11 months ago 3
i love them both so freaking much! They're the two most played artists on my ipod:) and they're both coming to where i live! Cue freak out :D
romeinanegg 11 months ago
9 people are asleep...
19person895 1 year ago 3
DID I MENTION THAT I MET THIS BROADWAY PRINCESS <3 <3
Princess1Poppy 1 year ago
@Princess1Poppy Broadway Queen you mean.....
defyinggravity40 10 months ago 2
Watch them sing the big notes. Idina Menzel just flows through them effortlessly and Josh Groban has to kind of work at it!!!
bonegirl72 1 year ago
Why wasn't he in Wicked? :/
cambeatsmusic10 1 year ago 5
...WWWOOOOWWWWW BREATHTAKING!!!!!! ... I'm speechless.. :-)
Leillah17 1 year ago
this was amazing:)
drygravity795 1 year ago
Okay, two of the best freakin' singer on one stage. I feel like I'm dying because I wan't there!
JesusSaves017 1 year ago
My two favorite musical angels together on the same stage = symphonic ecstasy!!
LiveSimplyLoveLife 1 year ago 3
Awww, they should have sung together on Glee.
goldengal1989 1 year ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
This duet is great! Idina is amazing as always!
uthornboy19 1 year ago 3
This duet is great! Idina is amazing as alwas!
uthornboy19 1 year ago
I always hate the "XYZ people didn't manage to push the right button"-comments, but guys, 9 people don't know what music is...
FriFroJones 1 year ago 3
Unreal!
TyGleason 1 year ago 2
aaw I'm actually gonna cry :') just beautiful!! xxxxx
TigerLuver2k10 1 year ago
Idina Menzel and Josh Groban is basically the best combo since Peanut Butter and Jelly.
BroadwayBoundBecca 1 year ago 67
@BroadwayBoundBecca
That is so true. Idina and Josh are AMAZING !
lauramcpetrie 1 year ago 2
Oh this video just oozes class
NoAbacus 1 year ago 4
this is amazing... there voices together just make me want to cry... in a good way :)
kirbymcc1812 1 year ago
@kirbymcc1812 Me too. I loved them in Chess!
Princess1Poppy 1 year ago
two most talented people i've ever heard.
MAEOshow 1 year ago
Josh is a genius! and Idina is so talented. They acomplished a really beautiful and full of emotion duet. I just love it.
ruizmorelos 1 year ago
HOW DOES THIS NOT HAVE 1 TRILLION VIEWS I DONT KNOW
mastermindxxx7 1 year ago 7
Idina has never been more gorgeous. WOW!
janemansfield73 1 year ago
Two of the best singers ever together!!!! YES!!!!
JesusSaves017 1 year ago
this is pretty cute- I like how josh and idina have really different voices, but they work well in this song. It makes it really cool.
mcneeze2 1 year ago
chills.
greeneyedactress92 1 year ago 6
Idina is vibrant with life, paired with Josh, they are sensational in this song.
Pattifish 1 year ago 2
Elphie Lives!
Moonwatcher19 1 year ago 4
FABULOUS!!! one thing though.. when idina humms the hoooohhh something.. her eyes go big.. she doesn't like blinking or closing her eyes doesn't she?
Cute15tricia 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Hey people check out my version of Feburary song! tell me what u think! Niall O Halloran Feburary song!
NiallOHalloran 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Hum.... I find Idina a little annoying... Josh Groban and Idina are very different ranges of voices and she appears to be nasely and shreekish... sorry if I have offended the fans of Idina.... but Josh Groban is irreplacable..... take her out of this one.
pwitht 1 year ago
@pwitht actually, their vocal ranges are pretty easily comparable...josh is a baritone and idina is a mezzo-soprano....they should be pretty comfortable octaves apart...ntm they both handled their harmonies wonderfully. If you know about vocal placement you know she isnt being nasal or "shreekish"...she just has a forward belt...a rare talent and it sounds beautiful.
yupp40 1 year ago 4
This song + both their harmonies = absolute pure beauty that's straight from heaven.
markcohen6969 1 year ago 5
I cry everytime.... its soooo touching, it gives me goosebumps : /
TheBritt66 1 year ago
Thanks for sharing!!! Wonderful!!!!!!!!!! I love both - saw them by CHESS live...
Pelznase 1 year ago
classic is classic
senhor33 1 year ago
Goosebumps all over!
amjPeace 1 year ago
My two favorite artist! I love them! Them inspire me!
cocobeanznk 1 year ago 2
I love this song anyway, Josh is amazing! The only way to make it better? Add Idina Menzel! Man! SUCCEED!
bamagirl1115 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
RentHead56 1 year ago
So ... Josh Groban has been my absolute favorite male artist for years. I'm a musical theatre performer, and Idina is a goddess. And this song, I've loved since Josh toured with it before Awake was even released.
All together ... OMG ... I'M DEAD! I just DIED! Absolutely! Why am I JUST finding this!?
samerz816 1 year ago 5
Look! It's Idina!!!! ~Wicked references! xD
And Josh!!!!
I love this song!!
GiovannaClapis 1 year ago 4
Idinaaaaa!!!
vanityfair24 1 year ago
love both of them so much!
any idea where i can get that dress?
kingssingersgirl 1 year ago
Love this so much
Idina Menzel is my ALL TIME idol. She was INCREDIBLE in RENT and WICKED also her duet with Rhydian Roberts 'What If' gives me chills.
JOSH... well i have a soft spot for that lovely guy. On Chess, and when he performed with Beyoncé singing 'Believe' oooooooh AMAZING.
I love the fact they did Chess in Concert together, this and they were together again in Glee!
My two favourite people in the world. I hope they always continue to do things like this.
I LOVE YOU GUYS
XXXX
ElaynFraser 1 year ago 43
OMFG This is one of the most amazing duets i have EVER heard! TOTAL FABULOSITY! Where can i download this song?
zaashleyfan 1 year ago 5
Absolutely beautiful!!! One of my favorite Josh songs and I adore Idina! This is beautiful!
beckefunsized 1 year ago
where and when was this recorded
abbyrocks100 1 year ago
wow, talk about those amazing voices! Such a gift!!
Lizco77 1 year ago
two of my favorite people :D
kickmyask82 1 year ago
I love this song. I love Idina and Josh. <3
But... I think the original is better of course. Yet this isn't that bad... just that there were certain parts of the song where she just didn't fit in very well with his voice... like at 3:49 and 0:53. But then there were parts that were good too like at 2:16 and 3:38.
Yet it mainly depends on you...
I'm sorry if I offended anyone!!! :(
But I still love them both :D
aznluvlol808 1 year ago
superb duet
unalegeli 1 year ago
Comment removed
aznluvlol808 1 year ago
So jealous of Josh right now... He gets to sing with my wife!!
MrIdinaMenzel 1 year ago 2
im in tears.... if i met either one of them i would probably just start crying and bowing at their feet
Ttime143 1 year ago
everytime i listen to Idina sing she always sends shivers through my body. She has just a wonderful voice and is also you can tell she is such a nice person! She is my role model, i love her!!!
ashleighdrummond 1 year ago
my two absolute favorite people!!!!!
marshmallowfool 1 year ago
Incredible!
katnip075 1 year ago
Two of my favorite singers in one song!? Heaven.....
wiserangel 1 year ago
gaga is fucking shit this is music!
Piwus1 1 year ago 3
wow.... i have goosebumps all over my legs and arms:O so beautiful<3
ninskimig123 1 year ago
whoever's idea it was to put them together on stage is my new hero. they are my two favorite singers of all time and together they're just...... beyond words.....
wolfchic011 1 year ago 3
Sigh. I know she's supposed to be this really great singer -- and she does a good job blending with Josh -- but I just don't like her style of singng at all. Love him, though.
straightarrow372 1 year ago
is that a weave Idina is wearing? they sounds gorgeous.
ShanteParadigm 1 year ago
@ShanteParadigm not it's her natural hair.
lou1893 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@ShanteParadigm no it's her natural hair.
lou1893 1 year ago
has anyone found this mp3 anywhere? i really really want it for my ipod
brim1810 1 year ago
@brim1810 VDownloader! *-*
LinyCullen1901 1 year ago
perfect. :D
elphieandidina 1 year ago
If I could have this on my ipod my life would be complete.
carizbo 1 year ago
@carizbo i must agree with you :) this version is much better than Josh's solo
bonnkaa 1 year ago 3
@carizbo you so can! I did it! You can download this video in Mp3 shape, on VDownloader -It's veeery easy, quick, no virus threats, and altought the volume's a little low, It does work out. You're life can be complete ;) If you need help to download the program or to use it, email me. Good Luck :]
LinyCullen1901 1 year ago
holy crap, how have I never seen this?! Awesome :)
daniosugirl078 1 year ago 2
I love them both and Idina is seriously stunning. Had me in tears.
marciavandecamp 1 year ago
I think my brain may have just EXPLODED.
sophab0656 1 year ago 2
just beautiful, brings a lump to my throat and a tear to my eye
horseyheathy 1 year ago
what an awesome pairing! wow.
fullofblah 1 year ago
I can't stop watching this again and again and again. It's soo winderful. breathtaking. there's so much emotion in it. listening to it makes me fall in love with idina more and more and more.. She's the best! i love you Idina!
opticalworld 1 year ago 2
made me cry, wonderful!
jutubfany1 1 year ago
wow it's really.. WOW. i love you idina!
opticalworld 1 year ago
that was just beautiful!
agrainne24 1 year ago
I love this song just like this josh and idina!! :D
FlOoOoO211 1 year ago
why cant i buy this anywhere??
swim1012 1 year ago
@swim1012 i want to buy it soooo badly its amazing!
SweetLittleSong 1 year ago
MINDBLOWING, my mind is blown
Ttime143 1 year ago 67
@Ttime143 It's not mindblowing.. it's MINDBLASTING! lol
perrrrrtNESS 9 months ago
amazing x
trentsteel1 1 year ago
both my favorite people together :) Idina is amazing and she is my hero & what isn't there to love about Josh ? :P
samilauramarie 1 year ago 4
just bawled my eyes out
lnc0119 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Idina Menzel kills the song!!! She fails in comparison with Josh's voice. Luckily Josh Groban saves his own song.
Beyjean 1 year ago
why am i only finding this now?! they are so amazing, wow. i wish i could've found this video ages ago!
mgoudeyx 1 year ago 2
So, this is basically the best video I've ever seen O.O two of my favorite people in the world singing one of my favorite Josh Groban songs. Wow... MIND BLOWING.
RENTfanatic2011 1 year ago
mmmm two of my favorites!
lnc0119 1 year ago
amazing!
alexandavril 1 year ago
i love this .. <# :)
samilauramarie 1 year ago
Idina makes this amazing song even better. It's great a a duet, and these two... wow! so amazing.
vegishishkabab 1 year ago 3
OMG the most amazing duo in the world!!
my two favourite singers sounding flawless together :)
I love watching chess just for these two to sings together
makes life beautiful!! :D
MetalMuse77 1 year ago 3
Idina IS musical theatre! She is the most amazing person.
kaytee94 1 year ago 3
Two of my favorite male and female voices together... Wow.
jealousmaenad 1 year ago
This is beautiful!
danrdrewf 1 year ago
Idina menzel is extremely talented! She has an amazing, beautiful voice. I'm am really jealous of Josh groban because he had the opportunity to meet her and sing with her! I am excited to see her perform in San fransisco in July!!!
ablooda 1 year ago 28
@ablooda GAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA I MISSED IT!!!!
ritsfata 1 year ago
brb DYING <3
beforecolor 1 year ago 2
Calm down, folks. This is not a competition between Josh and Idina. They are both extremely talented and this is a great duet. Enjoy it.
vernieistooold 1 year ago
this is EPIC
roose85723 1 year ago
your right bout 3:01... Really llove this duet.
SteeleMina 2 years ago
How do I find mp3iiify to download this song? I was told to google mp3iiify.
carollluterh45 2 years ago
Love it! Although, I do think Idina is slightly too good for him. :) In a way that is complementing Idina, not putting down Josh.
Soon2beonbroadway 2 years ago
idina... 3:01! damn! hit that note girll! WOOOO! go idina! shes maa bitch :D
defygravitybewicked 2 years ago 4
AMAZING
Wind4Dancer 2 years ago 3
I absolutely love this song!! Enjoy every moment with that special someone..
mommystan 2 years ago 2
Idina and Josh? My two favorites! I love-love-love it! I love the harmonies. Their voices sound flawless.
jferrante42 2 years ago 5
best duet ever love them both so powerful
tlc090192 2 years ago 4
god i love this song
Moonwatcher19 2 years ago 2
this song is amazing
bluproject 2 years ago 3
hahaha comment below me....u love her that much that u dont no how to spell her name??? IDINA
cassideez 2 years ago
I LOVE U INDINA!!!
Blupaprika 2 years ago
This is one of my all time favorite songs..and I like both versions =D
TheCuddlySoprano 2 years ago 2
I'm so addicted to this song its so beautiful! Josh and Idina both have amazing voices!
SweetLittleSong 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
JOSH WHYYYY. this is such a beautiful song and he is so talented. IDINA RUINS EVERYTHING.
iceprincess275 2 years ago
you're an idiot
HANNAHlovesBROADWAY 2 years ago
@HANNAHlovesBROADWAY well thats not very nice...I have my opinion. no need for name calling!
iceprincess275 2 years ago
@iceprincess275 You're a fucking deaf retard.
wildfiretgh 2 years ago
iceprincess275 your an idiot. idina menzel has an amazing voice. she met josh groban and is now a superstar. shes done broadway, movies, and music. and your sitting in front of a computer screen bashing her. shes amazing. she owns :) youu dont. gettaa life, idiot! YOU go hannah and wild fire! man your deaf and really mean. you need a good five finger fresshy :D
defygravitybewicked 2 years ago
f you iceprincess... idina is probably over a million times better than you, let alone anyone else. SHE IS THE BEST
kaytee94 2 years ago
I'm trying to find an audio/mp3 of this and can't find one. Does anyone know where I can? I don't care how much it costs...
aikenclaymate1 2 years ago 2
try with torrent ;)
darcoolio 2 years ago