Added: 2 years ago
From: musicfromgleeVEVO
Views: 369,799
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (361)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • that awkward moment when one of the top comments is about what the top comments were when the comment was posted

  • this is great my 3rd fav song shes ever sung

  • she did okay but there isn't enough anger

  • @BeastSabrinaLoveYou it doesn't HAVE to be a break up song with anger, it could just be a regretful vibe

  • Stop comparing and pointing out the differences. This is Glee's version. Glee and Lea did it THEIR way. If it's not the 'original', go listen to that. Leave.

  • cory's sexy

  • Rachel doesn't do this song justice

  • Nono no she didnt just say "Hey" >:

  • Glee. Saved Me. It Helps Me Through The Hardest Times. Glee Inspired Me.

    Like If Glee Changed You. <3

    -Angie

  • This would've been better than the original if Rachel/Lea wasn't singing like this was an opera song. -_-

  • @RainSorcex you've clearly never seen an opera

  • @RainSorcex it's not opera lol. i love it. it's pop just like this song is originally supposed to be. i love lea.

  • Lea needs to take a bow because this performance is amazing!

  • omg...the irony

  • Snap i have to find obmiddle's comment..... D:<

  • i actually like how she sounds more heartbroken and less scornful; it actually presents a little more emotion and vulnerability, which is REALLY hard to do when you're singing

  • oh, how I miss the good old days of glee. ):

  • what episode is this from? i remember watching it but i cant remember the name....can someone help me?

  • @Uzmamoomoo Showmance :)

  • i'm not a fan of Glee,but even I have to say,well done.

  • funny how comments talking about comments get first

  • I love glee so much!*(:

  • @obmiddle its ok *gritts teeth with fake hate smile* glee isnt for EVERYBODY....*underbreath* asshole

  • this is better then rihanna's  .. dont kill mee....

  • It is ! (:

  • @jess8441 Wow you need to take a chill pill and calm down, I'm just stating my opinion on the song. You sound like a crazy person.

  • @dawnywany555 hahahaha right...

  • I usually like the glee remakes of songs, but this one is horrible compared to the original. They should have had mercedes sing this song and it would have been ten times better. I still love glee :]

  • she sings it better but rihanna had more emotion

  • U SOUND BETTER THAN RIHANNA NO OFFENSE RIHANNA

  • i think hers sound better then rihannas <3

  • beautiful song <3 i like her performance and rihanna's both

  • Lea actually said she would never picture herself singing this song but this is actually one of her favorite songs to sing on glee now

  • lol.. i love her and i love the way she says "please"

  • i was just saying she wants to become more independent as an artist and she doesn't just want to be thought of as Racheal from glee. she is more than just that character and i didn't google the cast . its called watching the show

  • normally its good but she ruinedit.....;(

  • her name is lea not rachel

  • @DisneyLoverLily who cares. . . on here we all no the character names. its easier. youre not cool just cuz u googled the cast -_-"

  • attitude*, i hate auto-correction...

  • I think that Rachel hits every emotional point of this song; not saying that Rihanna's version is horrible, but her "too much" attribute kinda ruined the soul of this song.

  • Rihanna Has More Anger..And Attitude In Her Voice...Rachel Dont Have That..If She Worked On It...It'd Be Better (:

  • how many in the world is a gleek

  • Comment removed

  • Personally, i think this show is horrible, but the cast is so talented. They should move on to bigger and better things...

  • Comment removed

  • I love this version of this song. I love Rihanna's too! :)

  • i dunno if it because of the Lea's amazing voice or the fact that i'm sitting in front of the a/c vent but either way i got goosebumps :P

  • I love how contradictory the top comments are: against comparing and comparing hahah

  • i love this version as well as rihanna's! But the way she says "please" always makes me laugh :)

  • wait this is a rihanna song? sorry idk i hate rihanna

  • both rihanna and lea are amazzing singers and each of the have there stongest points i think lea is good for this as geraldphord says because she has innocence and hurt in her voice but i also think rihanna is good because she has the strong, bitch please kinda voice

  • "baby, when i know you're only sorry you got caught" - uunnff aint that the truth. amen to that. anyways, great song, great voice.

  • I wanna see the movie SO bad :p

  • @MinnieMouseCuite the movie was great

  • It seems as if every song I go to Rachel is singing it.

  • @Puglover918 me 2

  • @Puglover918 Well, she is the main character.

  • Lea is a wonderful singer but i feel that her voice just isn't quite fit for this song.

  • i once met a girl and we became the best of friends. one day i showed her this song. she said lea michelles voice sucked. the next day she mysteriously disappeared.

  • Nice one Lea :) Take a bow

  • This song isn't really for Lea or Rihanna but for some reason it works and that is what music can do. Get over yourselves people if you don't like it don't watch the show or don't listen to a song that sounds like shit in your ears.

  • whoo! Glee rules

  • Loving this forever :D

  • this is much better than the original *gets slushied*

  • @torileesrocks09 this is not at all better than the original...anyone with taste would know that

  • @torileesrocks09 yes yes yes it is

  • I actually like this better than the original version. (Ducks behind monitor to avoid fanatics)

  • This is my fav Rachel song.

  • I love this song!!!!!

  • she has a very nice voice including the background singers

    thumbs up if u agree

  • what episode is this in ?

  • @KortniiE306 I think its in the one when Finn makes her believe he likes her so that she would come back to glee and then she found out quin was pregnant by him so obviously she's upset.

  • @KortniiE306 this is when Finn kisses her while he's still with Quinn i think it;s the 2nd or 3rd ep

  • @KortniiE306 its in episode 2 [: season 1.

  • @KortniiE306 second episode first seson

  • thumbs up if youre a gleek!!!!!!! i am!!!!!! ^_^

  • THIS IS WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY BETTTTTTTTTTTTTER THAN ORIGINALLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!

  • Lea gets so emotionally involved to ever song she starts crying ever time she sings... thats not pathetic that is true talent in every way... she is amazing and in Kurt's words in an episode of Glee "She may be irritating but boy can she sing... BRAVO!"

  • PEOPLE if you watch the show its about expressing yourself through song every does that in differnt pitches and stuff... NO ONE CAN SOUND JUST LIKE RIHANNA!!!!!!!!!

  • TROLOLOL.

    But no, I love Lea's voice.

  • raped the replay button for two days in a row now

  • horibble...

    

  • @emornomoreno93 fuck you.

  • I love how she sings it! Her voice is amazing! Glee is my FAVORITE show!! :D I admit it...I'm a gleek! :)

  • Ummm...thumbs up if you got confused because a Spanish song came on.

  • awh omg this was the song that got me hooked on glee ..nolie<3

  • what episode was this on?

  • @ODST1O26

    Episode 1, Season 1. =D

  • @Mika26062 actually i think it's episode 2 season 1?

  • @WizardlyDog Oh...XD You're right, my bad.

  • 537 people took a bow...

    16 people curtaceed! ;)

  • i think rihanna has a better RnB /Pop voice obviously but Glee singers aren't usually vocal trained for these kind of genres.

  • 16 people didnt take a bow! They did a croutesse! ;D

  • This is random and all, but did anyone else notice that some of the newer songs have WAAAAAYYYYYYY more views in like a week than some of the older songs like this that have been out for a year???

  • @HugglepuffOboeGirl lol...because when those old songs were released, there was no VEVO or youtube. if those youtube videos had been there since then, the views would have been miles more than those of new ones

  • I WANT HER VOICE!!!

  • I just Love her voice, she does it better than Rhianna. Her voice is more softer and she can hit them notes reall good

  • she has the most amazing voice EVERR

  • i always watch this show at gleeonline. org

  • @bxhudson  I went on that sight and a thingy popped up. It said find out if you are not a bot. How did you get past it? And can you get to season 1 on there? If so, how.

    Thanks, Please Help

  • Don't hate on me or nothing, but this is a great cover don't get me wrong, but i like the original better.. But Glee has made a lot of other songs that are waaaayyy better than the original

  • @undertakerocks  i agree with u

  • SHUT UP COX .!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i will always like Rihanna's version better.. :/

  • Glee is the best because glee always makes the "way better" of the song!! i <3 noah!!!!(puck)

  • i love rachel but for once can someone else sing?

  • @tammycon1 ikr true dat

  • @tammycon1 she sang this because finn broke her heart but i kinda agree

  • oh rachel i love you<3 i love finchel!!

  • Great song!

  • i like both rachel and rihanna-- but i think rachels voice has more innocence and hurt in it... it sounds real....

  • @GeraldPhord Yeah but Rihanna's face has more hurt in it

  • @GeraldPhord i guess it's Cause rachel is an actress and rihanna isn't

  • i dont like how she says plzz thats the only thing wrong with this song

  • she sings nice this one is good

  • nice i lie this one alot!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Lea Michele has an amazing voice.

  • sorry but its funnt when it says ur so ugly when u cry lol

  • i don't understand why people constantly compare the glee singers to the original artists of the songs they cover. lea and rihanna have completely different voices and styles! they're both great singers in their own right! it's not fair to compare them to each other when they're so different. how about we just appreciate her talent for what it is?

  • @najae808 i so agree its so hard to compare two artists when they have completely different styles. they are both amazing in their own genres.

  • @najae808 agreed this should be on every glee song because there is always someone comparing the glee cast's singing to the original

  • @najae808 Or even better, if you don't like the song no one is forcing you to listen to it... just don't click the link and go listen to music you like

  • @UnfoldingSquid totally agree! i'm all for hearing others' opinions, but some people are downright rude. it's totally ok if someone doesn't like the song, but there's no need to be disrespectful >_<

  • I like this version more. &hearts; :3

  • This is better than Rihanna!

    I love it <3

  • She has a innocent voice and sounds like shes been hurt. so its really good.

  • I actually like this version a lot better then Rhianna's. I like the innocence in her voice more.

  • rihanna's version is way better

  • i love rachel's voice, but not this song by her..i prefer rihanna's, but her voice is good in this song, just maybe not her type :)

  • I like this version way better than rihannas for some reason. and i luv rihanna

    h

  • I like this version way better than rihannas for some reason. and i luv rihanna

  • I prefer how Rihanna says "Please", But Rachel sure has a great voice.

  • everyone who covers this song sounds way too white

  • (insert sarcasm here)

    Yes,

    1.) Glee ruined this song.

    2.) The original song isn't just ONE click away.

    3.) They sang this song JUST to disgrace it and ruin it.

    4.) Everyone who hates this is being FORCED to watch it.

    (sarcasm very much intended)

  • @PurpleAndSparkly96 if u hate glee so much than y the hell r u watching it

  • @Mynameisferny97 Whoa, whoa, whoa. SARCASM. I'm imitating the haters. lol Sorry if I wasn't clear enough there- thought the (insert sarcasm here) would indicate that I am infact quite a big Glee fan.

  • @PurpleAndSparkly96

    they actually make it better so shhhhh

  • @cowgirl392 Shh, that's us Gleeks' little secret. ;)

  • @PurpleAndSparkly96 I don't care if your using sarcasm or not but GLEE is an awesome show w/ amazing actors that portray everyday teen life,and they use music to express themselves!!!!!!!!! I don't get why people hate on Glee.........I mean it's not like the original songs are still there it's not like as soon as Glee does a cover of a song it's not like the original is going to be erased permanently! And besides if you don't like Glee or it's songs don't watch it just to write mean things!!!!!!

  • @mpbush Obviously, you don't understand. Why don't you try calming down enough to realize that i was MOCKING the people who hate Glee? I am a huuuge Glee fan. You must be an idiot to not realize I was making fun of how stupid all the haters sound. I am probably one of the biggest Glee fans, I'm not "hating on Glee", I LOVE Glee. So go take some anger management classes and some reading classes and come back and read this again and then MAYBE you'll understand the meaning. MAYBE.

  • @mpbush She wasn't hating on Glee. Her sarcasm is completely relevant here Einstein.

  • story of my life

  • Fuckedd uppp lett rihanna singg thiss!

  • This is better than rihanna's version. Haters can suck my imaginary cock.

  • hey wolfgirl that was me i was sign in to my other account! but ok i wont do it anymore!

  • Top 3 Rachel solo!! Along with Papa can you hear me and Get it Right. Anyone agree? <3

  • fuck you glee i hate you i liked it when rihanna did it! shes the best so go suck a dick!

  • @cmd4513 lol srry i was sign in to my other account that was me that said that lol hahah(:p

  • @cmd4513 well if you hate them why are you listening to the music? ok keep your opinion to yourself if your going to be rude. no one likes a troll and your being one. so don't listen to the music of you don't like it. how stupid do you look commenting on the video about how you dont like it when your listening to it?...

  • @cmd4513 chill your hormones glee is awesome, if you dont like it dont listen

  • Yeahhhhh, it might be good but she just doesn't have the same feeling as Rihanna

  • i like both versions but this one just a lil bit more

  • ah, rachel... one part of me wants to sympathize for her but the other part wants to smack her REALLY hard.

  • @penlove12 Hahaha i wanna do the same :)

  • i love it when youtube is just dark, for earth day. random i know; i've been listenin' to this song all day though! (:

  • she may be annoying...but shes good O.o...

  • i never saw the episode for this so this is my first time hearing this song, and being a new "gleek". im just like wow, of course its rachel. im really getting sick of her. and yu know who else i dont like. QUINN! seriously i just want to walk up to her and say blow your nose for christs sake! the girl talks like she has a cold. FOR REAL!

  • I'm assuming that God is being shoved down our throats because we're watching the REPUBLICAN Fox station. Just sayin'.

  • @bailie3513 I think its because she came from musical theater background, and they tend to enunciate a lot. Love this version!

  • I love Rihanna's version, but this is really good too.