A video like this wouldn't even be popular today in 2011. They'd find something bad to say about it like "their outfits are ugly" or some b.s like that. Ugh I hate what the music industry has become
@91realist I totally agree. I gotta say this is ART, music is ART. This comes from a real place. Today's "music" is all about sex and stupi and trivial things. I'm happy you realize how things have changed.
beyonce cant help tht her voice was better than everyone elses...she was born with a strong vibrant voice and sexy ass good looks....the other girls weren't(except kelly) so get off her jock and leave her alone. Those girls left because they were jealous....so what...they aint got no money and no stardom so they can hate all they want
I love this album cuz this is when bey didn't over sing like she does now. And everyone can complain about her singing lead in all of the songs but guess what? God gave everyone of us freewill and every one of these girls stuck around, knowing that Bey had the leads. I don't feel bad for them. If it was that big of an issue, they could've left. I never hated on Bey for that very reason. Cuz they DECIDED to stick around.
i wonder if destiny child was famous i mean in my opinion i only liked bootilycious tts all nd ya the girls are sexy..bt other songs are nt tt good...im happy beyonce is singing widout a group :) <3 u beyoooooooooooooooooooo u rock
@MultiSusmitha They are the best selling female group of all times, so they most have been famous. And dont make a judgement based on the fact that you only liked bootilycious. Are you the whole world.
@tim4whit hey u!!!! i kno tt im nt the whole world tt is just my opinion y in the world ur concerned abt ma opinion if i say like this no one will change there opinions rite?? so ya tt is ma opinion u dnt interfear it tts all..
I feel like Old School DC was just a back up group for Beyonce. She sang everything while all the other girls did harmonies in the back. It's no wonder members kept leaving.
@Cellifical Agreed. They should have been more fair with the rest of the members. They should have sang equally as a group from the start and not during the last few years that they were together before they broke up.
@Cellifical Actually if u notice back in the 90s wen music groups became popular again they used the same formula as they did in the 50s & 60s, putting the better looking & sounding members in the front, and this was with alot of groups in the 90s like DC and NSYNC. The first 2 members of DC got kicked out 4 going behind the others back and trying to sue Beyonce's Dad and that other girl left the group because the music life wasnt what she thought it would be. All of DC sang more when they wer 3
lol since when is being an atheist offensive? I'm an atheist too and i'm proud of it, you shouldn't judge the world by your narrow-minded religious opinions... There's this human right called freedom of believe, it means you can believe whatever you want, even if that means you believe there's nothing at all
1.Your reading my comment 2. Now your saying/thinking thats a stupid fact. 4. You didnt notice that i skipped 3. 5. Your checking it now. 6. Your smiling. 7. Your still reading my comment. 8. You know all you have read is true. 10. You didnt notice that i skipped 9. 11. Your checking it now. 12. You didnt notice there are only 10 facts Copy and paste to 1 video, tomorrow will be your best day ever! no matter what
Umm Using Negro in the way you did is a racist pun, and should be avoided. You are putting the Aryan race above African Americans and that is against the Civil Rights Amendment, even saying there is an Aryan race is wrong.
That's not really true everywhere. I wouldn't say that in America, but in less "politically correct" areas of the world, those terms aren't considered racist.
I didnt start this ok?dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actully wrks ths really wrks
WoW.. I was in like 7th or 8th grade when this came out! LaTavia looks really pretty.. and so does Bee.. I usually think Kelly is gorgeous, but she had some interesting moments in this one. LoL, still luvvs her. LeToya has always looked a little odd to me. Pretty, but in a unique way.
I miss the old lineup, even though I love Michelle (my belle).
PLEASE DONT READ THIS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR%uFEFF LIFE. TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN DIS DUNT STOP THIS IS SO SCARY. SEND THIS OVER TO 5 VIDEOS IN 143 MINUTES WHEN UR DONE PRESS F6 AND UR CRUSHES NAME WILL APPEAR ON THE SCREEN IN BIG LETTERS. THIS IS SO SCARY BECAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKs
a smile leads to a laugh a laugh leads to a high 5 a high 5 leads to a hug a hug leads to a kiss a kiss leads 2 a finger a finger leads to a hand a hand leads to a lick a lick leads to a suck a suck leads 2 a fuck.right after u read it, something good will happen at 2:25 tomorrow. Get ready for the biggest shock in your life!! Whoever breaks this chain will be cursed w/ relationship problems 4-10 years. If you post this on 5 vids in 15 mins, your safe
a smile leads to a laugh a laugh leads to a high 5 a high 5 leads to a hug a hug leads to a kiss a kiss leads 2 a finger a finger leads to a hand a hand leads to a lick a lick leads to a suck a suck leads 2 a fuck.right after u read it, something good will happen at 2:25 tomorrow. Get ready for the biggest shock in your life!! Whoever breaks this chain will be cursed w/ relationship problems 4-10 years. If you post this on 5 vids in 15 mins, your safe
kelly looks really boyish here. and yes, beyonce is pretty here but wow - she does look young. i know that they always make singers (teens) look older but wow, what a diff...
1997 And is always Good !! DESTINY'S CHILD FOREVEEEEER <3
ines01101 6 months ago
I thought Beyonce was a Mexican chick when they first came out.
Jaay1000s 9 months ago
I remember when pleather was hot, I used to wear it. Hahaha....Those certainly were the days.... ;o
MsMotownSoul 10 months ago
never heard this before BUT LOVE THE SONG!!
lotje33 10 months ago
NO!!!!the other girls left cause they picked beyonce and they all wnted to make their own money b is the best and she still is
MrBabyies 10 months ago
A video like this wouldn't even be popular today in 2011. They'd find something bad to say about it like "their outfits are ugly" or some b.s like that. Ugh I hate what the music industry has become
91realist 1 year ago 2
@91realist I totally agree. I gotta say this is ART, music is ART. This comes from a real place. Today's "music" is all about sex and stupi and trivial things. I'm happy you realize how things have changed.
BreenSN 11 months ago 2
this comments for the 26 people that have no no no idea
kawasakikid800 1 year ago
they were 16 !!
MennoMmM 1 year ago
this was the song
fashion1392 1 year ago
This was their FIRST hit!!!
MeetMeHalfWY 1 year ago 6
dnt lyk dis remix compared 2da original
chikiwings 1 year ago
How old were they? They look super young..
MunrochambersFTW17 1 year ago
this needs airg time again
overnitesinsay 1 year ago
I remember when they did a concert at Fort Sill, OK while I was there for basic training. That was sh......!
AnuthaLevel 1 year ago
How Many Of you Didnt Know there were 4 Girls in Destinys child . there Was
homersimpson691 1 year ago
this beat is one of my fav...
pimppimp187 1 year ago
hahha i remember singing this in 4th grad talent show lol
darkjuggalo2000 1 year ago
luv this song
tracegnet 1 year ago
beyonce cant help tht her voice was better than everyone elses...she was born with a strong vibrant voice and sexy ass good looks....the other girls weren't(except kelly) so get off her jock and leave her alone. Those girls left because they were jealous....so what...they aint got no money and no stardom so they can hate all they want
Matchmakeroflove 1 year ago
@Matchmakeroflove they left because they felt used and that was the case.
mbotenana 1 year ago
I love this album cuz this is when bey didn't over sing like she does now. And everyone can complain about her singing lead in all of the songs but guess what? God gave everyone of us freewill and every one of these girls stuck around, knowing that Bey had the leads. I don't feel bad for them. If it was that big of an issue, they could've left. I never hated on Bey for that very reason. Cuz they DECIDED to stick around.
songbird143 1 year ago
funni how this video aint had nothing to do with the song
rello2fine 1 year ago
LOOOOOOVE LATOYA @ 1:49....I've always loved her!
sangnboy 1 year ago 2
beyonce and kelly formed the group,, thats why they sang the most
SmileyGirl0000 1 year ago
this is not a GIRL GROUP this is BEYONCE and other girls singing in the back ...............it's not fair....no wonder the other two girls left
ScorpioToxic16 1 year ago 5
Who was that fourth girl in tge group that was in this vid??
VictoryFire88 1 year ago
i like it
shannon2tuck 1 year ago
show
BenaiaMarinhoModel 1 year ago
i wonder if destiny child was famous i mean in my opinion i only liked bootilycious tts all nd ya the girls are sexy..bt other songs are nt tt good...im happy beyonce is singing widout a group :) <3 u beyoooooooooooooooooooo u rock
MultiSusmitha 1 year ago
@MultiSusmitha They are the best selling female group of all times, so they most have been famous. And dont make a judgement based on the fact that you only liked bootilycious. Are you the whole world.
tim4whit 1 year ago
@tim4whit hey u!!!! i kno tt im nt the whole world tt is just my opinion y in the world ur concerned abt ma opinion if i say like this no one will change there opinions rite?? so ya tt is ma opinion u dnt interfear it tts all..
MultiSusmitha 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 nooo ya think!! dumbass she grew her hair in 5 min 28 inches long lmao she is the only human being to do so..
houseofrules 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 nooo ya think!! dumbass she grew her hair in 5 min 28 inches long lmao she is the only human being to do so..
houseofrules 1 year ago
is this beyonce in the singing the leading umm part ??! with that strange haircut
kir4OthAclowN 1 year ago
old school Destiny's Child is like modern day Pussycat Dolls..
one female lead and the rest are just back-up vocals..
aisharaiqah 1 year ago
@aisharaiqah a very sad thing
leycorbin4ever 1 year ago
love this song
beyoncebff1 1 year ago
original dc will always be the best.
k0k0jamb0 1 year ago 3
wen was this song made?
henrygib 1 year ago
2:02 has always been my favorite part.
E1819 2 years ago
That's my favourite part too:)))
madziunia875 1 year ago
they were at the ages 16 and ^ and this was ok but everyone wants to call miley a slut......doesnt make sence
TheLovegoddess91 2 years ago 3
who's miley??
yharyhar8 2 years ago 2
are you serious?
LSecret 1 year ago
@TheLovegoddess91 Was the same for Britney Spears back in 99.
E1819 2 years ago 2
Brings back memories...
tolufrost 2 years ago 2
Latoya Luckett in her hay day.....LOL ....
legalgirl2003 2 years ago
Beyonce must have had some voice coaching since this video because she sounded so terrible compared to how she sounds today.
crjones1208 2 years ago
LeToya and Kelly are still my favs. One of my favs from DC4 =D
LetoyaLuckettFan 2 years ago
Tight ...yep
edleew 2 years ago
B and Kelly look so pretty!
girlscott411 2 years ago 2
beyonce was always my 3rd fav of the group...i liked LaTavia and Kelly better, still do
boyofmusicall 2 years ago
un groupe mais ya kel ki chante pfff merci le papa producteur!! pff
lilniza75 2 years ago
best video of destiny child
MyClw 2 years ago
wow its funny to watch this clip (15 ) and the nsingle ladies (27) she changed so much :D i love both
ToFierce2handle 2 years ago
omg b looks so good
AshleighxRxB 2 years ago
they look so different
eeveyy 2 years ago
no she was 17 this song came out in '98 she was born in '81
kenny071896 2 years ago 2
Wow Kelly is wearing a wig at 2:14
misscordelia03 2 years ago 35
Dude, it's a weave! Extensions = magic.
tishak 2 years ago
Comment removed
misscordelia03 2 years ago
Oh shit, you're right! I didn't realize how short her hair was back then. :D
tishak 2 years ago
i think she looked better with the wig then the short hair
keonta81 2 years ago
Comment removed
misscordelia03 2 years ago
They shouldn't have changed it in the same vid though, lol...especially 4 a debut video, they should of kept the hair one way thru out.
Meedifyufosho88 2 years ago
@misscordelia03 they all was
jcooper135792468 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 nooo ya think!! dumbass she grew her hair in 5 min 28 inches long lmao she is the only human being to do so..
houseofrules 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 nooo ya think!! dumbass she grew her hair in 5 min 28 inches long lmao she is the only human being to do so..
houseofrules 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 nooo ya think!! dumbass she grew her hair in 5 min 28 inches long lmao she is the only human being to do so..
houseofrules 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 lol OKAY!
smart99guy 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 everybody was wearing wigs ans weaves just not kelly
jazsan222 1 year ago
@misscordelia03 Like the others =)
Michoko113 1 year ago
yes, right that she was 15yo's in this Video ! ! !
alihaydarC 2 years ago
Is it right that Beyonce was just 15 years old in this vid????
JipsyTipsy 2 years ago
No she was like 17 lol!
Repatillia 2 years ago
@JipsyTipsy no this came out around the end of 97 so all the girls where like 16 maybe latavia was 15 depending on when this was taped
keonta81 1 year ago
i always thought latavia was ugly anyway.
ipromiseme 2 years ago
@ipromiseme She looks better than you
1Nbillion817 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Sorry but Latavia is still the sexiest. But K, B, And M held it down after the break up
illisticusmc 2 years ago
letoya, latavia & farrah sould make a group!!!
Destiny's aborted
boy8605 2 years ago
lmfaoooooo
agiftfromvirgo21 2 years ago
Letoya and Latavia
lilniza75 2 years ago
Her name was Latavia
Hody26 2 years ago
I love dis video
memi5555 2 years ago
this is the song they used for making a video in the show smart guy ! man i miss that show haha
minigasneice 2 years ago
those were the days man!
iiiiiccccc 2 years ago 31
does anybody noe the other girls name the 1 that isnt kelly,beyonce or letoya
liaahbabie14 2 years ago
michelle williams
sami1987sami 2 years ago
or did she come later?
sami1987sami 2 years ago
latavia
futureoscarwinner85 2 years ago
Latavia
shayla1790 2 years ago
The other girls name is LaTavia
xoxlovestruckxox 2 years ago
they look like grown women not teenagers
scitzjo 2 years ago 4
love the song how old are they anyway
ARLYCIAROBERSON 2 years ago
16 i think
uLuVmE0994 2 years ago
Yesssss! The REAL DC4. Beyonce, Kelly, Letoya and Latavia!
heartandsoul22 2 years ago
kelly rowlands surgey did her no favours ...she was cute ..now eeek!
anhayla 2 years ago
sik tune ladies get controll
mizzSEC4eturnity 2 years ago
yah she sang everythin...hmmm
dunno why coz the other girls got voices too
lozzymagoo 2 years ago 2
i love beyonce
OnDrekus 2 years ago
brap brap luvin this song to da max!!
ishragaibrahim 2 years ago
I feel like Old School DC was just a back up group for Beyonce. She sang everything while all the other girls did harmonies in the back. It's no wonder members kept leaving.
Cellifical 2 years ago 43
@Cellifical Agreed. They should have been more fair with the rest of the members. They should have sang equally as a group from the start and not during the last few years that they were together before they broke up.
leycorbin4ever 1 year ago
@Cellifical yeah i feel you but then again the agreed
laydeelishxp 1 year ago
@Cellifical Actually if u notice back in the 90s wen music groups became popular again they used the same formula as they did in the 50s & 60s, putting the better looking & sounding members in the front, and this was with alot of groups in the 90s like DC and NSYNC. The first 2 members of DC got kicked out 4 going behind the others back and trying to sue Beyonce's Dad and that other girl left the group because the music life wasnt what she thought it would be. All of DC sang more when they wer 3
JrodLuvn 1 year ago
@Cellifical yeah .. mostly because her voice is 2x better than all of theirs.
Natebeats 1 year ago
@Cellifical What do you expect? Her dad was the groups manager and her mom was the groups stylist. LOL.
AnuthaLevel 1 year ago 2
@Cellifical well..................she was lead singer so it was kinda like her role plus she had the most sex appeal!
DEECHICK23 1 year ago
theyd ef do not luk 15 or 16 here esp beyonce
DonleXXy 2 years ago
they r 18 here not 15
DonleXXy 2 years ago
no theyre actually 16
mujaahid123456 2 years ago
naw they is.
ShamarraeBoo 2 years ago
luv this!!!!!
Mzbowwow95 2 years ago
je les adore. ;******** !!
majtosia 2 years ago
lol since when is being an atheist offensive? I'm an atheist too and i'm proud of it, you shouldn't judge the world by your narrow-minded religious opinions... There's this human right called freedom of believe, it means you can believe whatever you want, even if that means you believe there's nothing at all
polyke 2 years ago
Since when is having beliefs considered being narrow minded?
sopo144 2 years ago
putain c'était moche cette mode! ...
sans commentaire --_--"
morovaches 2 years ago
i cant belive they were lyke 15, 16 in this video
minie2minnie 2 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
XxD3ARxT0KY0xX 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ø„¸¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨ post to 3 other vids
¨°º¤ø„¸ Copy „ø¤º°¨ press F5 twice
¸„ø¤º°¨Paste ``°º¤ø„¸ OK
¸„ø¤º°¨¸„ø¤º°¨¨°º look at ur background
amazing!! :)
OR ULL die Today
MIZZSW4GG2 2 years ago
I LOVE THEM GYAL I WANT THEM LOL
kruickshank 2 years ago
athiest that is really affensive and hurtful dont ever ay thing like that ok and i really like this song!!
00MoAndJo 2 years ago
I love Negroes. They sing so much better than us Aryans.
Atheist2007 2 years ago
Umm Using Negro in the way you did is a racist pun, and should be avoided. You are putting the Aryan race above African Americans and that is against the Civil Rights Amendment, even saying there is an Aryan race is wrong.
XbeautifulxtradgetyX 2 years ago
Why must you Afro-Americans always be so touchy?
Actually, I have even put your race above mine.
Atheist2007 2 years ago
That's not really true everywhere. I wouldn't say that in America, but in less "politically correct" areas of the world, those terms aren't considered racist.
amandazig 2 years ago
spoken like a typical self-hating athiest, Atheist2007... this song sounds like just another one of destiny's child's 4 minute hiccups.
blueeyesofice 2 years ago
Atheism... the last bastion of true discrimination!
amandazig 2 years ago
LOVE them
Hoeknew 2 years ago
damn song stay my head after all these years
never gets old
webbrowser22 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
ru a good kisser
1 hold ur breath
2 go on to another video
3 add this comment but still holding you r breath
4 did you make it if you did then ur a good kisse r
mckenzieanderin 2 years ago
De quelle année ?
LATIT3C3RIS3 2 years ago
les années 90
LSecret 2 years ago
Great song! Memories...
randomistaken 2 years ago 2
Love This! I was soo young when this came out!
gogobergie2000 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
I didnt start this ok?dnt read this(cuz it really wrks). u will gt kissd on the nearest frieday by the love of ur life. 2mara wll b the bst day of ur life hwever if you dnt post ths comment 2 at least 3 vids u will die withn 2 days nw uv startd readn this dnt stp this is so scary snd ths ovr 2 5 vids in 143 mins when ur done press f6 nd ur crush's name wll appear on the screen n big letters ths is so scary cuz it actully wrks ths really wrks
Sonia234 2 years ago
was there a 4th destinys' child??
Qasrija 2 years ago
wow
yochick 2 years ago
Yes. If you check out the writings on the wall video I think she's in it there as well
trins123 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
1 cover ur mouth wit hand
2 make a wish into it
3 close ur hand[make it into a fist]
4 hold ur hand[the fist] to ur heart for 5 sec
5 send diz to 3 more videos
6 tomorrow is going to be the best day
xLetitiaBajanBabiiex 2 years ago
WoW.. I was in like 7th or 8th grade when this came out! LaTavia looks really pretty.. and so does Bee.. I usually think Kelly is gorgeous, but she had some interesting moments in this one. LoL, still luvvs her. LeToya has always looked a little odd to me. Pretty, but in a unique way.
I miss the old lineup, even though I love Michelle (my belle).
PKDJsQueen 2 years ago
very goodd
cuquis123456 2 years ago
cool
Gymnastics97 2 years ago
tfoe
BlackBarbie9 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I remember this. This was before Beyonce became a blonde!
hahahaaaa
1superNATURALwoman 2 years ago
Comment removed
1superNATURALwoman 2 years ago
no no no elle est tro bien mieu que toute
mounia194 2 years ago
elle est tro bien cette chanson
mounia194 2 years ago
and why is beyonce singing in their FIRST ever song
slimshortii208 2 years ago
why couldn't they have all sung?
calispartan 2 years ago 12
i kno i always felt bad 4 letoya lan latavia...............i felt like i couldnt get to see wut THEY can bring to tha table
slimshortii208 2 years ago 2
omg...late 90s at it's finest LOL
holla06 2 years ago 4
beyonce is so fine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
busby5988 2 years ago
Where´s her ass in this Video..?? haha
SweETyLiCiOussssssss 2 years ago
Uhhhmmm... Probably at the doctors office chillin' out with her boobs!!! LMBO
1superNATURALwoman 2 years ago
hahah baddest hair styles
bcx1982 2 years ago
lmao!!!!
holla06 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
tiafranklin8 2 years ago
Oh, who is that at 2:50?
DupeCity 2 years ago
kelly rowland
brittanybbbbbb 2 years ago
Beyoncé never looked so good.
DupeCity 2 years ago
esta cancion es la ostia chavales
cristfan 3 years ago
ya gotta love beyonce an em...i mean destiny's child
shatown 3 years ago
beyounce doesnt have a big booty
saloya2712 3 years ago
no just huqe hips .
zip11420 3 years ago
beyonce does not have huge hips.
she's a normal shaped woman.
if you think beyonce's hips are huge you obviously haven't been around many shapely women.
deesibecool 2 years ago 2
umkay thanxx . . .
zip11420 2 years ago
Wyclef is right, you need a phat beat for the club... hell yeah
cumpex 3 years ago
i like this song. i saw it on "smart guy" on bet on tv this afternoon. :P but yes i have heard it before.
imweirdsowat 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
How sex starts!!!
a smile leads to a laugh a laugh leads to a high 5 a high 5 leads to a hug a hug leads to a kiss a kiss leads 2 a finger a finger leads to a hand a hand leads to a lick a lick leads to a suck a suck leads 2 a fuck.right after u read it, something good will happen at 2:25 tomorrow. Get ready for the biggest shock in your life!! Whoever breaks this chain will be cursed w/ relationship problems 4-10 years. If you post this on 5 vids in 15 mins, your safe
cjmaxium 3 years ago
why is it they are 4 singing.??
i tot destiny's child had only 3 members.???
jasark02 3 years ago
it was 4 of them in the beginning
lilcutie4sho 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
How sex starts!!!
a smile leads to a laugh a laugh leads to a high 5 a high 5 leads to a hug a hug leads to a kiss a kiss leads 2 a finger a finger leads to a hand a hand leads to a lick a lick leads to a suck a suck leads 2 a fuck.right after u read it, something good will happen at 2:25 tomorrow. Get ready for the biggest shock in your life!! Whoever breaks this chain will be cursed w/ relationship problems 4-10 years. If you post this on 5 vids in 15 mins, your safe
BbyphtbP100 3 years ago
kelly looks really boyish here. and yes, beyonce is pretty here but wow - she does look young. i know that they always make singers (teens) look older but wow, what a diff...
snootylittlecutie 3 years ago 4
i agreee..its weird cuz she was 16 or 17 at the time...n here she looks like, 20! but still young lol
chaenel1989 3 years ago
songs were so simple, yet sounded so good back then. What happened?
LisaGrimsley 3 years ago 5
i knew her eyes (beyonce)wasnt hazel
tunaboona123 3 years ago 3
they still aren't, her eyes are brown...and with flash and photoshop they can enhance their appearance.
Nellz1986 3 years ago
lol i saw Sasha Fierce at 1:10
01nonlyparis 3 years ago 9
LOL!!
akdphi93 3 years ago