Thanks I really needed this! I was tired of were the lipsticks that match my skin color. I did try that frsh brew with liner and Iove and i wear it everyday. I think I'm going to try that neo sci fi and shag next.
hey Sis, Wat kind of lipgloss do you use for each look? if they are different . What kind of lipgloss do you use for chestnut lipliner with mac siss lipstick look? This is one of the best tutorials. thx alot.
@iheartmakeuplv hey sweetie i really appreciate the love at the time now im using mac clear lipglass over everything i love it or u can use any clear lipgloss to add sheen but i also try using the same color gloss or something similar when its a color like red pink etc
just cam across this video..I love it. You have some lipstick I never even thought to try. Are any these limited edition? I think they are so pretty. Lvoe it .
@honeylove9470 well hello amd im glad u came by the lippies that were in special packages were the pnly ones that were limites edition the rest u can get anytime .... thanks for the love:)
@PhasionQueen27 when you stated two toned lips, did you mean lips with a natural dark lip line? and should you use Concealer or foundation in a lighter shade or one that matches your skin?
@MysticDiamond hey sis yes cause i have darker color on the top lip and its lighter at the bottom i use a concealer that is the same sahde for the lips
@transplantclub thanks hun its viva glam v and its a very soft creamy sof pinky beige color the mac ipliner (hestnut)paired with it makes it have the plummy affect so if thats the look ur going for then id pair the 2 tgether ....=]
@respectmypretty heeey sweetie thank u so much and there is never a dumb question cause if u dont ask u wont know then u will be looking crazy hahaha anyway sweetie i line them b4 i put the lipstick on and then i touch the line up after blending the lipstick in ...thats my way different strokes for different floks ..xoxox.muha
@VannersHEARTSMakeup ahahahahaha.. u too much i think hat color will be veeery neutral on u like very sheer so if thatsthe look u want it will be great for u sis
@makeupgemz aww thank u o much i appreciate it let me know what u get and if u recommend anymore cause i need ...well u know i dont need LOL but i would like a nice red one i ws looking at the new toxic tale from the new collection but idk
@PhasionQueen27 No problem. Okay I sure will. I know what you mean everyone need a few reds in their collection. Me too i've been checking out the holiday collection but not sure yet.
@kokofemme aww thanks koko that means alot i really do appreciate it ...yes by all means go check em out i just started getting more into mac im enjoying all there lippies he most !! be blessed sis
see now you know i'm having issues with mac right now LOL seriously though, great vid. liner does make a difference. i have a few from mufe, but don't use them much, gonna have to start pulling them back out
@stilajunkie07 hahaha dont do mac wrong sis they alright lol=) thanks fo the love and i got my calenders and im starting to get yalls news letters as well thank u so much sweetie God bless u De
@PhasionQueen27 oh no, sista, watch my recent mac attitude question update vid, mac has been doing me wrong, big time! but, it's good, the situation is almost over, i hope :-/
you're welcome for the calendars! enjoy your weekend :-)
I like seeing swatch video for the product on the actual area because it gives a true representation of the color. This especially goes for makeup on women of color because colors show up different on us. Also I like that you showed the lipcolors with and without lipliner because it does make a difference. IMHO, a lot of those colors reminded me of NYX colors.
@BargainClipper hey sis me too it def gives you a better idea on how the produxt will show on u because like u say they can look so different on a w.o.c thanks for the love sis i also think some of the nyx lipliners can go 4 dupes on some of the mac liners !!!
@holmique thanks Mo so much im glad it was requested because it allowed me to use more of the ones i havent touched in awhile u know how that goes lol luv ya much sis God bless
@KISSseventyseven honey let me tell you the carmex just makes ur lips so soft and i like the extra tingle it give IDK (im crazy like that )lol but if u do the boyfriend/hubby will def be glad u did lol=)
@ladydee78 hey sis thank u so much i loooove chestnut but i have nyx chestnut and to be real they can go for the same i love them both just the mac is a lil more smooth (just a tip) love ya hun thanks fo rthe support
@MissDeenaDiva aww thanks sis they are really nice yes def try one i cant recommend cause ill be telling u 3or 4 lol but im a neutral lady so i do wear fresh brew alot !! love u sis
Fantastic video! I was going to stop by the MAC store tomorrow to see if they still do that empty container exchange and get me some new lipsticks. The colors you showed will help me decide which ones to get. I have a lot of empties that I never turned in. Thanks for showing me the different colors.
@prisskitajoe wow thanks mizz joe i think they still do at least mine does the empty container exchange and now at least youur very welcome glad i could be of help=) have a head start on which ones would be great for u
@BabyTigga23 anytime tigga like you i love more of there lipglasses but at least when u do venture out to the lipsticks u have a better idea of how they look on dark skin btw cant wait for ur mac haul i need to spend more money (or hubby does)lol=) i see u been mac -n- it up lately thats whats up!
Very pretty. That's what I use to is the MAC Chestnut liner too. Im trying to stop shopping so much, but now you got me wanting to go to my local MAC counter & buy a couple of those lipsticks if their still available. lol Love ya sis. Great vid. Thanks
@ElavatedStatus anytime sis and u right about that i was amazed myself without liner they look plan and sorta ashy lol but once the lipliner is applied ......BAM WONDERS lol=)
ohhhh great colors mamas..and a few of these look good on us latinas too but wow i love how some of these look amazing on ur skin color soooo beautiful im jeolous :) i can never pull of a creamsheen formula cux of my understones :( great video mamas love it :)
@kikilovesmakeup6 oh yes i would imagine but u fall in with the w.o.c. dept =)so i know they ook just as good but the only way i get away with creme sheen is i haaaaaaaave to line my lips hahahaha if not HOT MESS!!! thanks kiki luv ya much
@XxDarkSkinBeauty aww anytime sis im glad it was a help to u now u know fanfare is so prett but u might have to use a lipliner cause on me it looks a lil ashy by it self lol ...luv ya sis thanks again for the request
@mignondee thanks sis the mac lipliners are pretty good and sooooo soft but i only have a few nyx is comparable to them so if u have anynyx they will do just fine luv ya sis
@urjnsmd aww thank u so much sis although i had ppl ask me to do the collection as well which i have up as well not a vid i would of done on my own but you know lol anyway luv ya much
@wilderjmc thanks lexi u know i do i looooove me some chestnut i think cork on me is too light idk mayb becasue i used to wear the blk lipliner thing and im still wanting that darker lip look lol but i also am crazy about mac vino lipliner the 2 of them are the ones im having to replace the most i need to try nightmoth have u tried ??
@wilderjmc i appreciate u giving me the heads up lexi i have current dont use it half as much as i do chestnut & vino i just bought half red thiking i could work it with my pink lippies uuuuh NO!! LOL
@PhasionQueen27 lol i have not done one since the last vid i posted, but what i do atleast 3 times a week is drink green tea and wheww thats all u need child...
this was the best lipstick video. can u do another just like this with other lipsticks? thanks
Justafox305 1 month ago
@Justafox305 hi there thank u so much i have done one and its called fall lipstick colors for women of color hope it helps xoxox
PhasionQueen27 1 month ago
Thanks I really needed this! I was tired of were the lipsticks that match my skin color. I did try that frsh brew with liner and Iove and i wear it everyday. I think I'm going to try that neo sci fi and shag next.
mzcomplicatedlady 2 months ago in playlist lipstick
@mzcomplicatedlady hey sweetie thats awesome to hear & since u have tried the fresh brew combo i know youll love the other 2 ♥
PhasionQueen27 2 months ago
@labonneruerouge thanks for UR OPINION THERE JUST LIKE ASSHOLES HAHA THANKS 4 the compliment ...LOL have a great day SMH :)
PhasionQueen27 3 months ago
Great video thanks so much!!!
thisizme82 4 months ago
@thisizme82 thank u so much so glad it helped xoxo
PhasionQueen27 4 months ago
hey Sis, Wat kind of lipgloss do you use for each look? if they are different . What kind of lipgloss do you use for chestnut lipliner with mac siss lipstick look? This is one of the best tutorials. thx alot.
iheartmakeuplv 5 months ago
@iheartmakeuplv hey sweetie i really appreciate the love at the time now im using mac clear lipglass over everything i love it or u can use any clear lipgloss to add sheen but i also try using the same color gloss or something similar when its a color like red pink etc
PhasionQueen27 5 months ago
These are some good colors you chose! They look just right...not too light or ashy at all.
LadyofWar1980 6 months ago
@LadyofWar1980 i love them thank u so much i hope u try a few :)
PhasionQueen27 6 months ago
just cam across this video..I love it. You have some lipstick I never even thought to try. Are any these limited edition? I think they are so pretty. Lvoe it .
honeylove9470 6 months ago
@honeylove9470 well hello amd im glad u came by the lippies that were in special packages were the pnly ones that were limites edition the rest u can get anytime .... thanks for the love:)
PhasionQueen27 6 months ago
love these looks...i think they all look better with the liner...ur right
mzprnce 7 months ago in playlist Makeup tutorials
@mzprnce thank u so much i think so too sum can be tweeked a lil by them selves but i perfer liner
PhasionQueen27 7 months ago
Thx, that gave me ideals to try....nice
Lovpin 9 months ago
@Lovpin u are welcome im so glad i could help... :)
PhasionQueen27 9 months ago
very beautiful! I love it :)
beehivenyc 10 months ago
@beehivenyc HEY GIRL THANK U SO MUCH ...I LOOOVE ALL THE COLORS ON MY DARK SKIN =]
PhasionQueen27 10 months ago
like it more with the liner but looks good both ways
quettaism1 11 months ago
@quettaism1 me too i def put liner on it makes a huge difference in my opinion ...thanks for the love
PhasionQueen27 11 months ago
@PhasionQueen27 when you stated two toned lips, did you mean lips with a natural dark lip line? and should you use Concealer or foundation in a lighter shade or one that matches your skin?
MysticDiamond 1 year ago
@MysticDiamond hey sis yes cause i have darker color on the top lip and its lighter at the bottom i use a concealer that is the same sahde for the lips
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
wow you beautiful can you do the smooch ill crate a video response
rabbidscool 1 year ago
I LOVE THE FIRST LIP LOOK. Is that Viva Glam VI or VJ? Is it a plummy color? How would you characterize the color? I wanna buy it...thanks!!!
transplantclub 1 year ago
@transplantclub thanks hun its viva glam v and its a very soft creamy sof pinky beige color the mac ipliner (hestnut)paired with it makes it have the plummy affect so if thats the look ur going for then id pair the 2 tgether ....=]
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
I'm loving these colors, very hot!
BeeBlakeLee 1 year ago
@BeeBlakeLee AWW THANK U SWEETIE VERY MUCH HOPE U SEE A FEW U WILL TRY =}
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Love these sis I like mine with lipliner too lol. Very pretty!
sherikaprince 1 year ago
@sherikaprince thank u sis its the only way i can where it =}
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
you know i love lipstick! nice vid
MsNylia 1 year ago
loved this! & btw i know this may be a dumb question but do u apply the liner before or after the lipstick?
respectmypretty 1 year ago
@respectmypretty heeey sweetie thank u so much and there is never a dumb question cause if u dont ask u wont know then u will be looking crazy hahaha anyway sweetie i line them b4 i put the lipstick on and then i touch the line up after blending the lipstick in ...thats my way different strokes for different floks ..xoxox.muha
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
okay you got sum good stuff im not into makeup in all but i love Women who take care of themselves so yea keep it up
YGxSlade 1 year ago
@YGxSlade aww thanks my young t.i LOL thats whats up i really appreciate it ..tes gotta take care myself i will sweetie B E-Z!!
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
omg that color looks beautiful i must have it lol
VannersHEARTSMakeup 1 year ago
@VannersHEARTSMakeup soryy sis just saw this comment ..thak u what color lippie where taling bout??
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 The fresh brew one sis :o must have it must have it *in robot voice lmao*
VannersHEARTSMakeup 1 year ago
@VannersHEARTSMakeup ahahahahaha.. u too much i think hat color will be veeery neutral on u like very sheer so if thatsthe look u want it will be great for u sis
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Thnx for this vid..I ahve been lookn for Mac swatches 4 woc, I reallly appreciate this!!!
77ProfeChanel 1 year ago
@77ProfeChanel aww ur very welcome so glad icould help sweetie =}
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
All the colors looked really pretty on you. Theres a few I dont have but will pick up...Thanks
makeupgemz 1 year ago
@makeupgemz aww thank u o much i appreciate it let me know what u get and if u recommend anymore cause i need ...well u know i dont need LOL but i would like a nice red one i ws looking at the new toxic tale from the new collection but idk
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 No problem. Okay I sure will. I know what you mean everyone need a few reds in their collection. Me too i've been checking out the holiday collection but not sure yet.
makeupgemz 1 year ago
I truly enjoyed this vid. Not only do these lipsticks look fab on you but they are definitely some colors that I wouldn't mind checking out!
(✿◠‿◠) Kokofemme
kokofemme 1 year ago
@kokofemme aww thanks koko that means alot i really do appreciate it ...yes by all means go check em out i just started getting more into mac im enjoying all there lippies he most !! be blessed sis
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
see now you know i'm having issues with mac right now LOL seriously though, great vid. liner does make a difference. i have a few from mufe, but don't use them much, gonna have to start pulling them back out
stilajunkie07 1 year ago
@stilajunkie07 hahaha dont do mac wrong sis they alright lol=) thanks fo the love and i got my calenders and im starting to get yalls news letters as well thank u so much sweetie God bless u De
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 oh no, sista, watch my recent mac attitude question update vid, mac has been doing me wrong, big time! but, it's good, the situation is almost over, i hope :-/
you're welcome for the calendars! enjoy your weekend :-)
stilajunkie07 1 year ago
I like seeing swatch video for the product on the actual area because it gives a true representation of the color. This especially goes for makeup on women of color because colors show up different on us. Also I like that you showed the lipcolors with and without lipliner because it does make a difference. IMHO, a lot of those colors reminded me of NYX colors.
BargainClipper 1 year ago
@BargainClipper hey sis me too it def gives you a better idea on how the produxt will show on u because like u say they can look so different on a w.o.c thanks for the love sis i also think some of the nyx lipliners can go 4 dupes on some of the mac liners !!!
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 You're welcome!
BargainClipper 1 year ago
I see a few I'm liking:-) Great vid!
holmique 1 year ago
@holmique thanks Mo so much im glad it was requested because it allowed me to use more of the ones i havent touched in awhile u know how that goes lol luv ya much sis God bless
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
never thought about using carmax under my lipstick... I use the MAC lip primer but this sounds way more moisturizing... Thanks !!
KISSseventyseven 1 year ago
@KISSseventyseven honey let me tell you the carmex just makes ur lips so soft and i like the extra tingle it give IDK (im crazy like that )lol but if u do the boyfriend/hubby will def be glad u did lol=)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
love the vid and that chestnut liner is the business can't wait to go shopping this weekend to pick up a few more colors. thanks for sharing.
chocolatechild72 1 year ago
@chocolatechild72 aww thanks sis how u been?? im with u i love the chestnut its my fav mac liner ...dont go shop crazy this weekend lol
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Thank you for sharing. I like them all better with lip liner. I am going back to my makeup grave draw and try some of those lipsticks with liner.
divinedivak 1 year ago
@divinedivak hey thanks for the comment im def with you on this one ....lol@ ur makeup grave u have one too lol?? i gotta do the same =)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
love all the colors
UniqueTrendz 1 year ago
@UniqueTrendz thanks love i appreciate it so much
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
LIPLINER MAKEZ IT LOOK WORSE AND OBVIOUZ DARLING
IAMFABULOUZ 1 year ago
@IAMFABULOUZ thanks for the comment ill have to apply it a lil lighter next time but i most def have to have a liner .thanks again God bless
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
All these colors look great on you...I might have to go pick up that chestnut liner
ladydee78 1 year ago
@ladydee78 hey sis thank u so much i loooove chestnut but i have nyx chestnut and to be real they can go for the same i love them both just the mac is a lil more smooth (just a tip) love ya hun thanks fo rthe support
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
This was a great video sis!!! One of these days I'm going to definitely have to invest in MAC lipstick..all the colors looked great on you!
MissDeenaDiva 1 year ago
@MissDeenaDiva aww thanks sis they are really nice yes def try one i cant recommend cause ill be telling u 3or 4 lol but im a neutral lady so i do wear fresh brew alot !! love u sis
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
HELLO SIS....COOL VID.... AND YOU KNOW I DONT CROSS DRESS OR WEAR MAKE UP SO MY COMMENT IS SINCERE!!!
DONYTV1 1 year ago
@DONYTV1 aww thanks brah i know nothing about you speaks femminie lol so u know i appreciate he love thank u so so much luv ya much God bless
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Fantastic video! I was going to stop by the MAC store tomorrow to see if they still do that empty container exchange and get me some new lipsticks. The colors you showed will help me decide which ones to get. I have a lot of empties that I never turned in. Thanks for showing me the different colors.
prisskitajoe 1 year ago
@prisskitajoe wow thanks mizz joe i think they still do at least mine does the empty container exchange and now at least youur very welcome glad i could be of help=) have a head start on which ones would be great for u
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
I absolutely love Chestnut Lip Liner by Mac! lol get them grly. the golds without liner looks ok :j
adelicaterose 1 year ago
@adelicaterose hey sis ur right about that i have to use liner with mostly all of them but the bronzey gold colors ...i love chestnut its the biz!!
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Thank you for sharing very pretty colors I am more of lipglass girl but will venture out to there lipsticks more
BabyTigga23 1 year ago
@BabyTigga23 anytime tigga like you i love more of there lipglasses but at least when u do venture out to the lipsticks u have a better idea of how they look on dark skin btw cant wait for ur mac haul i need to spend more money (or hubby does)lol=) i see u been mac -n- it up lately thats whats up!
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Very pretty. That's what I use to is the MAC Chestnut liner too. Im trying to stop shopping so much, but now you got me wanting to go to my local MAC counter & buy a couple of those lipsticks if their still available. lol Love ya sis. Great vid. Thanks
myskyy08 1 year ago
@myskyy08 hahaha i feel you sis i try to stop but i just cant see what youtube does to you lol but the chestnut is the biz isnt it =)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Wow love these colors on u. U worked them out. Now I gotta make a Mac run. Thanks girl
2339235 1 year ago
@2339235 lol hey thanks sweetie i love the colors as well but i def have to put on a lipliner for some hahaha thanks for the love ...happy shopping
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
is amazing how much just adding a lip liner make a difference,thanks for sharing=)
ElavatedStatus 1 year ago
@ElavatedStatus anytime sis and u right about that i was amazed myself without liner they look plan and sorta ashy lol but once the lipliner is applied ......BAM WONDERS lol=)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
ohhhh great colors mamas..and a few of these look good on us latinas too but wow i love how some of these look amazing on ur skin color soooo beautiful im jeolous :) i can never pull of a creamsheen formula cux of my understones :( great video mamas love it :)
kikilovesmakeup6 1 year ago
@kikilovesmakeup6 oh yes i would imagine but u fall in with the w.o.c. dept =)so i know they ook just as good but the only way i get away with creme sheen is i haaaaaaaave to line my lips hahahaha if not HOT MESS!!! thanks kiki luv ya much
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
They all look amazing! My fav is the the Fan fair creme sheen!!
misssandycandy 1 year ago
@misssandycandy thank u so much i like it too but my fav is fresh brew i guess cause im a neutral gal lol=)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
I Love This Video ! Thanks So Much For Doing It For Me. I Def Running Out To Try Thee Fanfare And Chestnut Combo ! Luv Ya
XxDarkSkinBeauty 1 year ago
@XxDarkSkinBeauty aww anytime sis im glad it was a help to u now u know fanfare is so prett but u might have to use a lipliner cause on me it looks a lil ashy by it self lol ...luv ya sis thanks again for the request
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Thanks for that, sis! I only have a few mac lipsticks and no mac lipliners, so I may go get me one. Luv ya!
mignondee 1 year ago
@mignondee thanks sis the mac lipliners are pretty good and sooooo soft but i only have a few nyx is comparable to them so if u have anynyx they will do just fine luv ya sis
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 Well thanks for that money saving tip!
mignondee 1 year ago
This is a neat video, I like how you applied the different lipsticks instead of just showing us your lipstick collection. Thumbs up, girlfriend
urjnsmd 1 year ago
@urjnsmd aww thank u so much sis although i had ppl ask me to do the collection as well which i have up as well not a vid i would of done on my own but you know lol anyway luv ya much
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
hey my yt dsughter. beautifuls lips and colors. I am a lipliner too. Be Blessed
09grandnana 1 year ago
@09grandnana me and you both ma i just cant have it anyother way my lips look too ashy without it lol=)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Loving the colors missy.. great job
khandyissweet 1 year ago
@khandyissweet aw thanks khandy glad to hear you feeling alot better
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Pretty lipstick colors
xstacy2 1 year ago
@xstacy2 thanks sis =)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Im lovin It !
pinkpornstar1 1 year ago
@pinkpornstar1 aww thanks pink appreciate it !
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Great video!
GIANNKI6 1 year ago
@GIANNKI6 thank u sweetie =)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
Thank you for sharing. Great video request!
Brena1971 1 year ago
@Brena1971 aww anytime hope u found it helpful
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
I love that color very pretty !!!
BeautifulDiva37 1 year ago
@BeautifulDiva37 thanks ms kim so much =)xoxox
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27
you welcome !!!
BeautifulDiva37 1 year ago
Very nice, Maranda! i love to add liners too, especially to the nudes. LOL! Hugz!
2luvlikidz 1 year ago
@2luvlikidz im right with you onthat one mary if i dont look like i have ashy lips lol luv ya sis=)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
The liners do make the lipstick look so beautiful. Love the colors. Thank you for the video
58cocopuff 1 year ago
@58cocopuff thans sweetie anytime and u see y i have to line my lips first they make a heck of alot of difference=)
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
love them all! u must run through chestnut like crazy......i need to use mines more but i love Cork so everytime i pick up a brown its Cork lol
wilderjmc 1 year ago
@wilderjmc thanks lexi u know i do i looooove me some chestnut i think cork on me is too light idk mayb becasue i used to wear the blk lipliner thing and im still wanting that darker lip look lol but i also am crazy about mac vino lipliner the 2 of them are the ones im having to replace the most i need to try nightmoth have u tried ??
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 I just swatched Nightmoth at MAC the other day and its too close to MAC Current l/p so i passed on it but it is really nice!
wilderjmc 1 year ago
@wilderjmc i appreciate u giving me the heads up lexi i have current dont use it half as much as i do chestnut & vino i just bought half red thiking i could work it with my pink lippies uuuuh NO!! LOL
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
lovin these!!!!!!!
treejay01 1 year ago
@treejay01 thanks sis they pretty but i always have to put on a lipliner lol ...anyway i meant to ask u do u still do the epsonm salt flushes lol
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 lol i have not done one since the last vid i posted, but what i do atleast 3 times a week is drink green tea and wheww thats all u need child...
treejay01 1 year ago
@treejay01 hahahaha that too funny ill have to try because im trying to do that ...oh my bad was that TMI HAHAHAHA =) luv ya
PhasionQueen27 1 year ago
@PhasionQueen27 lol no it was not TMI we can do that. girl did u see what happen to me at walmart yesterday, go look at the vid,
treejay01 1 year ago