I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
if you can't hear him singing but you can the crowd then i suggest you get new speakers, i can hear him clearly enough and i think the crowd adds to the song if anything, adds a bit of atmosphere to it.
The guy's mad right? He plays electric songs acoustic and this is an acoustic song which he's playing on an electric! What is this opposite land?! lol
I think it's pretty absurd to think, assume or imply that anyone would expect an audience to be completely quiet. There's no disputing the fact that the audience was either completely outsinging him or your camera's audio is super sensitive. Or perhaps your seat was fantastic for visual recording but not the best for audio recording. Either way, it's obvious that the audience overpowers and deflects from the entire performance. Why be offended by something you couldn't control?
Never been to a show in my life where the audience didn't sing along. Shame on them, they should have been considerate for all those who would later watch a video of the show they paid for!
@ShadowWolf9 Shame on you for thinking that I should be QUIET for a show that I PAID FOR and I WANT TO ENJOY AND SING ALONG WITH WHILE I AM THERE. Fuck off.. if you want to watch it, youtube is right here. If you want to sing along and be part of the music, go to a show.
@gpburr I'm confused at what you are saying. This is my video and I sure as hell sang along. My above comment was to the other poster arguing with me. I was being sarcastic in the post I think you're referring to.
@luvR4babes6 The song has 4 different key changes in it. I'm not surprised he said that. As for him sounding good, he DID but you can't really tell as the audience was singing along pretty loud with him. :/
but if you watch alot of his concerts...like their homecoming dvd...he likes to bring his crowds into it...what singer doesnt feel awesome knowing people knows their lyrics word for word....i know i would love it.
@ShadowWolf9 to be honest with you, i know every lyric to every BB song, and im sure that theres a bunch of people who are hardcore fans like me.. i would have shot myself in the foot to be able to go to this show..
I think the audience sung this beautifully, Along with ben <3
Yourmomhardcore17 1 week ago 2
hell yeah!!!! :)
djaramillo09 1 month ago
woooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooottttttt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
rockerchic3012 2 months ago
Why doesn't Ben just hire the other guy who's playing with him? And get a new bassist. There's a lot of hidden talent.
MrDead67 3 months ago 6
ohhh ben i love you♥
YunaIna1 4 months ago
♥♥♥
69EVOMAN 6 months ago
you were so damn close. Lucky to be you. thanks for the post it is my favorite song on heavy rotation.
jennysmith5677 7 months ago
Just my favourite BB song!!!!
leobalestrin 9 months ago
Hell Yess finally a acoustic version of my favorite song!!!!!!!
TheFuture1919 9 months ago
I think the singing actually adds a lot to it. There's probably nothing like singing for people and have them all know every word.
Kristivas 10 months ago
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
StephSingerGirl23 10 months ago
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
StephSingerGirl23 10 months ago
I would like to think that Ben and the band would have been very humbled by the fact that the crowd was singing along with him. Gavin DeGraw has let the crowds sing entire songs for him live before. It's very humbling for many artists, The Ataris included. I even asked Kris once when I met him this past February... so you can't really argue on that one.
StephSingerGirl23 10 months ago
was he mumbling sumting else?!
formerkid 10 months ago
breaking benjamin la rja!!!!!!!!!!!!
yamibakura9856 10 months ago
if you can't hear him singing but you can the crowd then i suggest you get new speakers, i can hear him clearly enough and i think the crowd adds to the song if anything, adds a bit of atmosphere to it.
Spawny06 10 months ago
why is every live video i find on youtube, the crowd has to ruin it by over singing him.. i cant freaking hear!!!!!!!!
cafeledavid 10 months ago
The guy's mad right? He plays electric songs acoustic and this is an acoustic song which he's playing on an electric! What is this opposite land?! lol
SDADSDSFDSGDA 11 months ago
Why are they wearing same shoes ? :D
Barto1361 11 months ago
stfu crowd I wanna listen lol
TeamIRaMpAgE 11 months ago
@TeamIRaMpAgE yeah they need to, if i want to hear bad singing ill watch american idol auditions
cafeledavid 10 months ago
@cafeledavid My first concert was from these guys and it was amazing aha
TeamIRaMpAgE 10 months ago
sry just accidently press the dislike button,,:(
sorry guys!
2012siukit 1 year ago
I love the way the audience sings along with him, shows how much they love Breaking Benjamin! Wish I could've been there.
ClawsVSFangs 1 year ago
he is really enjoying this beautiful music, its really from his heart.omfg
2012siukit 1 year ago
I think it's pretty absurd to think, assume or imply that anyone would expect an audience to be completely quiet. There's no disputing the fact that the audience was either completely outsinging him or your camera's audio is super sensitive. Or perhaps your seat was fantastic for visual recording but not the best for audio recording. Either way, it's obvious that the audience overpowers and deflects from the entire performance. Why be offended by something you couldn't control?
lonnarific 1 year ago 17
@lonnarific
I'm not. That's also why I don't expect anything different than the inevitability of the crowd singing.
ShadowWolf9 1 year ago 9
@lonnarific they should have had the sends go to a preamp that could record it direct instead of this cell phone camera stuff.
jmd11185 10 months ago
UGH this video is so badass but the audience won't STFU and I can't even get half way thru before I have to stop it and just listen to the mp3.
lonnarific 1 year ago
@lonnarific
Never been to a show in my life where the audience didn't sing along. Shame on them, they should have been considerate for all those who would later watch a video of the show they paid for!
ShadowWolf9 1 year ago 20
@ShadowWolf9 Shame on you for thinking that I should be QUIET for a show that I PAID FOR and I WANT TO ENJOY AND SING ALONG WITH WHILE I AM THERE. Fuck off.. if you want to watch it, youtube is right here. If you want to sing along and be part of the music, go to a show.
gpburr 2 months ago
@gpburr I'm confused at what you are saying. This is my video and I sure as hell sang along. My above comment was to the other poster arguing with me. I was being sarcastic in the post I think you're referring to.
ShadowWolf9 2 months ago
Whoever clicked dislike needs to go eat a bullet! Ben Burnley FTW!
mastrlegacy 1 year ago
wish audience would shut the mouth so i can hear him...
pocketsssJuri 1 year ago
I can't believe they started playing this live. What a great song!
runningcow13 1 year ago
@runningcow13 Why weren't they playing it live??? its a great song!
drpeper1996 1 year ago
@luvR4babes6 The song has 4 different key changes in it. I'm not surprised he said that. As for him sounding good, he DID but you can't really tell as the audience was singing along pretty loud with him. :/
DC11961 1 year ago
who's playing with him, please message or reply to me.
gntrihg 1 year ago
@gntrihg Aaron Burch from OurAfter.
bbfreak9 1 year ago
@bbfreak9 thanks
gntrihg 1 year ago
beautiful song
dos2029 1 year ago
u've got a really good camera! XD
justinx1103 1 year ago
@justinx1103
Thanks! It's just a little compact Sony Cybershot, but it captures great audio and video at shows.
ShadowWolf9 1 year ago
Such a beautiful song.
jayrawd 1 year ago
I had a dream about this song
xsporadicx 1 year ago
Grr, I can't hear him!
DizzyDior12 1 year ago
this is my fav bb song from their we are not alone album.
bbfreak9 1 year ago
@bbfreak9
It's probably my favorite song from them overall.
ShadowWolf9 1 year ago 7
who is the other guy?
Danz2003 1 year ago
thanks for the upload.
MarkCresswellMusic 1 year ago 3
the crowd ruined the song since they were singing -.-
DarkTragedyLife 1 year ago
@DarkTragedyLife
You don't expect the crowd to sing along to a song like this? Especially when they've never played it live before? Singing was a must, my friend. :D
ShadowWolf9 1 year ago 44
@ShadowWolf9 Hmmmm i guess i could agree with you mate
DarkTragedyLife 1 year ago
@ShadowWolf9
When it's an acoustic set, no-one should sing along and just listen, couse it overpowers the music... I agree, the crowd ruins it.
GraZmus 1 year ago
but if you watch alot of his concerts...like their homecoming dvd...he likes to bring his crowds into it...what singer doesnt feel awesome knowing people knows their lyrics word for word....i know i would love it.
DavidJern 1 year ago 4
@ShadowWolf9 actually, this was their second time singing it live!
Shiek200 10 months ago
@ShadowWolf9 to be honest with you, i know every lyric to every BB song, and im sure that theres a bunch of people who are hardcore fans like me.. i would have shot myself in the foot to be able to go to this show..
i wouldve sang too haha
jaredwhorton41 10 months ago 2
@jaredwhorton41 Ha, well I'm sorry you couldn't make it. It was truly amazing. Hopefully they actually tour again.
ShadowWolf9 10 months ago
@ShadowWolf9 he was prob the lone dislike haha
seanposten 8 months ago
Comment removed
1996Al3x 1 year ago
y cant they play this live! my fav song in the world and i missed it live! DAMNIT!!!! FUCK! SHITCAKES!
mememe154222 1 year ago
He actually thought this song was out of his range 2 sing live? 2 words: NAILED IT!!! Ben ur freakin' amazing!!
luvR4babes6 1 year ago 2
Awesome song.
Yankefanatic317 1 year ago