Carl Schuricht: Schumann symphony nr 3 Rheinische part1

[shishirth]

Schumann at his most magnificent!

[GaolisVideoLog]

Too fast. Leonard Bernstein was better.

[lokeoajsiekh]

energetic! 

[arrrrrow]

the first concert I ever attended was Schuricht conducting Bruckner 8th and a piece by his friend Frederick Delius, whom he had promised on his death bed to champion his music

[callasnuts]

Wich version is he following? Its not the original and its not Mahlers.

[MrYosefmenachem]

I like it this fast, especially at the end. I don't know why people seem to think that slower is always better. The Bruno Walter recording of Beethoven's 3rd, first movement, is sooooo slow that I felt as if I had aged a few years before it was finished.

[exodusx599]

Too fast.

[IceIsNice286]

If ever you find yourself playing this song...

Hope to God you don't play the second violin part. Your arms WILL hurt.

This piece is all kinds of awesome to me. :D

[classifieds103]

I just got into this orchestra and we played this piece. I played seconds and I couldn't believe how numb my arms were from all the tremelows and divded notes lol

[IceIsNice286]

Oh God yes, but all that energy certainly does bring an air of vigor to one's soul.

Even listening to it could bring such feelings.

And that is why Romantic Composers are my Favorite.

[nemo1620]

Otterhouse, you did a good job of restoring this recording: no pops/clicks, skips, or hissing. Merci!

[SCHUMANNasaSACRAMENT]

I AWARD THIS 3 1/2 CLARAS...as this has fine quality about it that much better than most,

communicates this fabulous rhetoric.The swellings they make in the quick turns of phrase and well as the finely honed individuated phrase dynamics make this feel

exciting-yet resigned,ominous-yet optimistic,

fierce-yet lyrical,adventurous-yet stationary.

This rhetoric is a strange alchemy and Schuricht knows the spells.

[vint22]

les nuances musicales, et, surtout si vous parlez de l´emotivite...ca n´a pas de sence sans la folie schumanienne.

[vint22]

et quelle putain de vieillard emerite vous etes, vous, le filisteur ardent? au debut c´est marque:"Lebhaft". Vif.

[icetwo]

Its the in tro of "Hier und Heute" and "Zwischen Rhein und Weser"

[menuires]

Hormis le respect que les années vous obligent à reconnaître, cette symphonie n'est pas une polka pour prodige, trop vite interprété elle perd beaucoup de ses nuances musicales, de son émotivité.

[tausendgold]

ja so muß schumann klingen,hoffentlich gibt es diese aufnahme schon auf cd.

[alexmaglor]

Hehehehe...James Horner's Willow sounds like this!!

[nickfox2]

HA HA HA!!! I always thought I was the only one who ever noticed this. The Willow soundtrack main theme (which I loved when I was a kid) is a half-step lower and in a different meter, but essentially outlines the same melody.

[abcdfgh123]

YEP! I just heard the symphony played on television and I immediatly thought: hey, they're playing the Willow-theme! Turned out it was Schumann... Hahaha Horner sure knows how to plagiarize!