Finally some life back in the world of Boyband Kpop; really SNSD really did bring the boy's out ^_^; Now bring back H.O.T, G.O.D, Sechskies then music will be good again ^_^
Comparison comes naturally and obviously covers can't be as good as the original.. shinhwa is legendary but you have to admit snsd has their worth in the music industry. Replying to one of the top comments, isn't it based on your own opinion? you can't really make a general statement when its so apparently biased. In your opinion snsd can't beat shinhwa but in reality who's making more money? Who is more popular in present time? Stop the argument no?
@fanyfany0801 hm...as u can see, the comments r around 3 yrs ago...around the time SNSD 1st covered T.O.P. & a bunch of 'SNSD is better' comments were left on every other TOP Shinhwa videos, so rather than comparisons, I think these are natural rxns to those kinds of comments (especially during time all members are in the army). If I went into a bunch of SNSD vids & did the same, I'd probably get the same kind of rxn. Basically, u r seeing the fruits of your fellow fans' labour ^^;
@fanyfany0801 Not that I am condoning that kind of behavior of course. It's wrong all around. But you also do not see these same kinds of comments regarding other groups covering this song, no? Respect begets respect. Unfortunately, the opposite is true as well.
In the Korean music industry, idol groups barely survive the 5 year-curse but SHINHWA has withstood the test of time, and they'll be returning March 2012, after a 4 year long hiatus due to their military commitments. 14 years and running.. I wonder if anyone can ever beat that. :)
and it's funny that shinhwa fans actually had to bring down snsd first to praise the group and you guys accuse us for not respecting you? That's really hypocrite btw.
And sones, please do not bash Shinhwa because it's only the fans that are the problem here.
Im one of the sones worldwide, n i do accept that shinhwa is way better than snsd in TOP; but its unworthy insulting either snsd/sone. obviously shinhwa's performance is better since its their song, n its not end of the world if little amount of sone saying snsd is better. i mean stop fighting!
WTF?!! Why u guys keep comparing SNSD with Shinhwa? Did SNSD says they are better then Shinhwa? SNSD is a girls group... Think properly.. U guys are totally dumb...
That's the reason why i hate Sones.. they keep think that SNSD is that some "goddess" and they never show any respect to other groups. Shinhwa was once part of SM company and they earned tons of money for SM. Without groups like Shinhwa, I doubt SNSD will achieve what it has today. Shinhwa's success wasn't an easy one, show some respect, Sones..
@Braxton5385 I agree, we too, SONES, respect SHINWHA, Of course, no one can beat them. It is because it's there own song. SNSD performed T.O.P. just to remind the audience of SHINWHA. I definitely agree. SHINHWA is one of the legends I've known so far in the history of KPOP.
Cmon guys! Me, as a SONE, Don't want to have a fanwar between the legends and the new group.. I also love SHINHWA, H.O.T., Jewelry, S.E.S. and others.
I watch Teen Top and SNSD cover and i agree with 'garnetcess' that INFINITE's cover is the best. Those guys are awesome, I hope that they should make a remake of this song!
@leastcommondinominat yes, i agree with @AhhhDaebak, INFINITE's version is REALLY GREAT and AWESOME! THey sang it LIVE so it really is powerful. I think it's the best cover of T.O.P. out there. But no one could defeat ShinHwa's of course.
@athiruppi back in the 90s lipsync is not a BIG DEAL. You can see all of IDOLS back then are lipsyncing.. but you can also see live performances of them, and it's not much of a difference when they lipsync...
are you crazy?why are you comparing SNSD with Shinhwa ?,it's the most stupid thing i've ever heard . Snsd sang this song for fun,not for beating your Shinhwa,leave our girls alone . stupid antis
Ok. Who said snsd is better then shinwa come on I go check out they perform they nothing like shinwa they dance weak is not power like shinwa they can't beat shinwa maybe next life this life shinwa better then anyone out there who perform TOP
@AsianLoveuz Despite the lipsync practice and somewhat atrocious sound/camera system back then, there are actually quite a few live perfs of t.o.p. (of course, being more than a decade old, not all of them are on YT and you really have to dig to find them) ^_^ original versions /watch?v=pCtHwVziSgQ /watch?v=-HuTh1L-vu0 /watch?v=_bgx1bo8spU /watch?/v=iKdDLhYSbzg later versions /watch?v=SzEVWC5Cnlc /watch?v=2yUncUr1988 /watch?v=pa32L5dn5Ek Enjoy~
freakin dong wan was sooo cute!... he went from cute, to buff to slim..hahaha.. i liked it when he was.. like in Only one and i pray 4 u... he's still hot to me
I love their T.O.P dance i can still rem how i try to learn this dance way back and i like it when they perf this song by wearing white it juz make them look ^^)
nothing is better then a korean concert, no musicians (like drummers and guitarist theres sometimes those violinist but u get wat i mean right?) anyway it's just the actual band, background dancers, sometimes other people fall down when theres only one person singing, and very colorful lighting effects oh sweet i like the guy's hair thats black and has blond strips of hair : P man thats one crazy crowd loudest i ever heard! : P 5* thanks alot
SNSD? psh! the only reason I actually listened to their version was because of Eric's rap in the beginning, otherwise I would've said they sucked...bad.
And of course, "SNSD can never beat SHINHWA at their own song, not in 10 years, not in a lifetime!"
It's so...emotional to watch this perf!! brings back the past!! It's crazy how the fans were screaming their name and singing along with them lol^^ they r still as popular tho^^
LoL some fans are just too funny. why compare a GIRL GROUP to a MALE GROUP? of course their moves will be different..DUH!
khim3013 5 days ago
Finally some life back in the world of Boyband Kpop; really SNSD really did bring the boy's out ^_^; Now bring back H.O.T, G.O.D, Sechskies then music will be good again ^_^
LJkAze 1 week ago
눈물나도록 그립다.
kamikazeyu98 1 month ago
Comparison comes naturally and obviously covers can't be as good as the original.. shinhwa is legendary but you have to admit snsd has their worth in the music industry. Replying to one of the top comments, isn't it based on your own opinion? you can't really make a general statement when its so apparently biased. In your opinion snsd can't beat shinhwa but in reality who's making more money? Who is more popular in present time? Stop the argument no?
fanyfany0801 1 month ago
@fanyfany0801 hm...as u can see, the comments r around 3 yrs ago...around the time SNSD 1st covered T.O.P. & a bunch of 'SNSD is better' comments were left on every other TOP Shinhwa videos, so rather than comparisons, I think these are natural rxns to those kinds of comments (especially during time all members are in the army). If I went into a bunch of SNSD vids & did the same, I'd probably get the same kind of rxn. Basically, u r seeing the fruits of your fellow fans' labour ^^;
crystalis0324 1 month ago
Comment removed
crystalis0324 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@fanyfany0801 Not that I am condoning that kind of behavior of course. It's wrong all around. But you also do not see these same kinds of comments regarding other groups covering this song, no? Respect begets respect. Unfortunately, the opposite is true as well.
crystalis0324 1 month ago
In the Korean music industry, idol groups barely survive the 5 year-curse but SHINHWA has withstood the test of time, and they'll be returning March 2012, after a 4 year long hiatus due to their military commitments. 14 years and running.. I wonder if anyone can ever beat that. :)
SHINHWA FOREVER :)
nglkt5 1 month ago
Apparently the two tops comment are made because SNSD is a nobody at that TIME! But now, look who's on TOP of the world? hahaha...
fatihahtesl9 2 months ago
@fatihahtesl9 Shinhwa remains a legend, for their talent and craziness. I doubt anyone can beat that :)
nglkt5 1 month ago
@nglkt5 they are a legend back then. there will be a new legend as time goes by... just wait...
fatihahtesl9 1 month ago
@fatihahtesl9 of course new legends will arise but it doesn't mean that the 'old' legends are no longer legendary :)
nglkt5 1 month ago
Shinhwas' fans have to insults SNSD first so that the great Shinhwa can look good.
hahaha!
nice one, original is always the best but when a girl group can pull it great compare to present group, that is GREAT too...
fatihahtesl9 2 months ago
OHMAHGAH seriously!? another argument!? this is useless, just enjoy the video. aigoo
i1speak1british 2 months ago
woah. loud fanchant!!!!! Shinhwa jjang!!!! and Shinhwa Chanjo daebak!!!!!!!
freezzaholic11 2 months ago
Did anyone else see Dongwan counting 123^^
peace15ify 2 months ago
oops *corrected* It's not the shinhwa fans but the fans that jump on the bandwagon of bashing snsd lol
firefly9x9 2 months ago
and it's funny that shinhwa fans actually had to bring down snsd first to praise the group and you guys accuse us for not respecting you? That's really hypocrite btw.
And sones, please do not bash Shinhwa because it's only the fans that are the problem here.
firefly9x9 2 months ago 2
hay. guys stop comparing! leave SNSD alone (top comments)
of course ordinary is better! dud but stop with the hatting and stupidness.
nhigin 2 months ago
Of course shinhwa is better its their moves lyrics and style there is no debate
TheKreamKing 2 months ago
Im one of the sones worldwide, n i do accept that shinhwa is way better than snsd in TOP; but its unworthy insulting either snsd/sone. obviously shinhwa's performance is better since its their song, n its not end of the world if little amount of sone saying snsd is better. i mean stop fighting!
TheM1llion 3 months ago
Comment removed
lavitadicoconsofia 4 months ago
Shinhwa forever!
HanFanyVal 5 months ago
WTF?!! Why u guys keep comparing SNSD with Shinhwa? Did SNSD says they are better then Shinhwa? SNSD is a girls group... Think properly.. U guys are totally dumb...
Braxton5385 6 months ago 2
That's the reason why i hate Sones.. they keep think that SNSD is that some "goddess" and they never show any respect to other groups. Shinhwa was once part of SM company and they earned tons of money for SM. Without groups like Shinhwa, I doubt SNSD will achieve what it has today. Shinhwa's success wasn't an easy one, show some respect, Sones..
YJohnstar 6 months ago 4
Comment removed
Braxton5385 6 months ago
@YJohnstar Not all Sones are the same... Watch ur word dude...
Braxton5385 6 months ago 2
@Braxton5385 I agree, we too, SONES, respect SHINWHA, Of course, no one can beat them. It is because it's there own song. SNSD performed T.O.P. just to remind the audience of SHINWHA. I definitely agree. SHINHWA is one of the legends I've known so far in the history of KPOP.
Cmon guys! Me, as a SONE, Don't want to have a fanwar between the legends and the new group.. I also love SHINHWA, H.O.T., Jewelry, S.E.S. and others.
OhJiYeonnie 5 months ago 2
I love me some Shinhwa!
imsoicy072486 7 months ago
i like this song
meme27463 7 months ago
love them.<333
Burgerfin 8 months ago
Infinite did a great cover for both T.O.P/Shinhwa songs!
Rosheen22 8 months ago
I have to admit, Junjin's and Dongwan's hairstyles made me gigglesnort. They look so cute!
peterkinsg 9 months ago
@leastcommondinominat
I watch Teen Top and SNSD cover and i agree with 'garnetcess' that INFINITE's cover is the best. Those guys are awesome, I hope that they should make a remake of this song!
8BKuRo 10 months ago
i can TOTALLy imagine yuhno, changmin, jaejoong, yoochun and junsu watching this and thinking : "WE WANT TO BE LIKE THEM...WHOA...SO COOL"
Poor...they have NO IDEA...no idea...
princesskanu 10 months ago
@princesskanu Yeah. They didn't think they'd end up more like...H.O.T.
Islander809 7 months ago
Comment removed
princesskanu 10 months ago
this is how I rate the performances of T.O.P (the song, not the artist :P)
1. Shinhwa (no duh.)
2. Teen Top (this is also slightly a no brainer bc. one of the member of shinhwa made this, very cute, boyband :3)
3. SNSD (erm, it was ok :/)
leastcommondinominat 10 months ago
@leastcommondinominat infinite also made a cover for this song ! i think it wass greeaatt ! :)
AhhhDaebak 10 months ago
@leastcommondinominat yes, i agree with @AhhhDaebak, INFINITE's version is REALLY GREAT and AWESOME! THey sang it LIVE so it really is powerful. I think it's the best cover of T.O.P. out there. But no one could defeat ShinHwa's of course.
garnetcess 10 months ago 2
@garnetcess I agree 100% with everything you just said XD
DancerFun40 10 months ago
lip sync much..
athiruppi 11 months ago
@athiruppi back in the 90s lipsync is not a BIG DEAL. You can see all of IDOLS back then are lipsyncing.. but you can also see live performances of them, and it's not much of a difference when they lipsync...
shinkumi4ever 11 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
are you crazy?why are you comparing SNSD with Shinhwa ?,it's the most stupid thing i've ever heard . Snsd sang this song for fun,not for beating your Shinhwa,leave our girls alone . stupid antis
ppahama 11 months ago
Ok. Who said snsd is better then shinwa come on I go check out they perform they nothing like shinwa they dance weak is not power like shinwa they can't beat shinwa maybe next life this life shinwa better then anyone out there who perform TOP
aznlove183 1 year ago 4
so what are the fans yelling?
Johnaja 1 year ago
.... Why are you guys comparing SNSD with Shinhwa ?
Vampire98Knight 1 year ago 8
i thnk at tt time rarely have live singing performance unlike now..
cardinmei 1 year ago
SHINHWA JJANG !..SHINHWA JJANG!..SHINHWA JJANG!..
farashinhwa 1 year ago 2
<33 shinhwannnieee : )))
the bestest kpop!
mzKiiaVaj 1 year ago
Again a playback -_-
But good dancers :)
AsianLoveuz 1 year ago
crystalis0324 1 year ago 5
they are really the original beastly idols ^^ SHINHWA JJANG! i am excited for RICWAN comeback ^^
evangelistalen 1 year ago 7
lol they lip singed this song =p
rune2hko 2 years ago
i think that they are singing along to the song..
sin089 2 years ago
Their coreography was pretty cool, song seems to be pretty catchy even though I don't understand a single thing they said. A thumbs up!
MissFlower84 2 years ago 8
this is when i was 2nd grade
lol wow i remember
sghsing 2 years ago 2
wow.......sing along crowds have come LONGGGG way since then......still love shinhwa and their fans....there are the seniors in the industry
sparklop 2 years ago 2
jesus christ the crowd is going berzerk in the background noiselol
RSixBoy 2 years ago
freakin dong wan was sooo cute!... he went from cute, to buff to slim..hahaha.. i liked it when he was.. like in Only one and i pray 4 u... he's still hot to me
lucyxiong 3 years ago 3
I love their T.O.P dance i can still rem how i try to learn this dance way back and i like it when they perf this song by wearing white it juz make them look ^^)
jama35 3 years ago
Im seeing de perfection made human, just love this performance... and shinhwa too xD
doyoubi18 3 years ago
shinhwa still remember this dance until now
admya4ver 3 years ago 3
I personally didn't like the audience singing as they were, it kinda ruined their sound.
010110134 3 years ago 6
Wannie is so cute! ^^
6Dahlia6 3 years ago
T.O.P. : Twinkling Of Paradise
D.O.P. : Delight Of Passion
D.O.G. : Delight Of Gorgeousness
M.I.L. : Millenium Innocent Love (??-_-;; maybe they wanna say "the pure love that lasts even after 1000 years")
D.R.C. : Dangerous, Risky, Chaos
some explanations don't make any sense.
but I LOVE this song. totally beautiful. it's one of my favourite song in 신화's album.
Choi216 3 years ago 6
thanks!
xhslrjf7 3 years ago
I like SNSD but I think its wrong to say their version is better considering they copied Shinhwa.
Covers are never as good as the orginal.
verypoorboy 3 years ago 17
This has been flagged as spam show
snsd way better..I thought I was watching shin hwa version doing snsd's own t.o.p.. not the other way around..
musicasia87 3 years ago
ok wat does D.R.L. mean really???
asiandude814 3 years ago
DRL...
u mean DRC
there's no drl is the song
but if DRC if would be dangerous, risky, chaos
nicquenadine 3 years ago
nothing is better then a korean concert, no musicians (like drummers and guitarist theres sometimes those violinist but u get wat i mean right?) anyway it's just the actual band, background dancers, sometimes other people fall down when theres only one person singing, and very colorful lighting effects oh sweet i like the guy's hair thats black and has blond strips of hair : P man thats one crazy crowd loudest i ever heard! : P 5* thanks alot
asiandude814 3 years ago 2
SHINHWA SHINHWA SHINHWA!!!!
TwizToyzFactory 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
So boring. SNSD better
sweetliverty 3 years ago
snsd can never beat shinhwa at their own song
Sportsjkl 3 years ago 81
Seriously?Seriuosly?SERIOUSLY???
I fainted watching SNSD performance, and it's not because it's great..
Erm, SNSD can NEVER beat SHINHWA not in 10 years not in a lifetime..
ShinYunRa 3 years ago 55
SNSD? psh! the only reason I actually listened to their version was because of Eric's rap in the beginning, otherwise I would've said they sucked...bad.
And of course, "SNSD can never beat SHINHWA at their own song, not in 10 years, not in a lifetime!"
misszsp 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shinhwa lip-synch too
단 한번도 라이브 한적 없다.
sweetliverty 3 years ago
???????
misszsp 3 years ago
dude they lived like 40 percent of there perfs.
wheesungwheesung 3 years ago 2
love this song so much
lovehina887 3 years ago 2
they look so cute ^^
i love the audience singing along
MinwoosLovelyGirl 3 years ago 4
omg dongwan was sooo cute
shinhwa980324 3 years ago 2
so cute XD
6Dahlia6 3 years ago 2
wow..tat's so cooool!!
xystanfordxy 3 years ago 5
Does anyone know the name of the song at 0:09 to 0:15 ???
treeofheaven7393 4 years ago
hae gyul sah, the debut song
(in english) a trouble solving broker
gaiamizar 4 years ago
Thank you so much ^^
treeofheaven7393 4 years ago
uhhmm, i thot i was called, YO - by Shinhwa
aznxboix188 3 years ago
I found out that Yo was another song by Shinhwa but not the one from 0:09 to 0:15 =D
treeofheaven7393 3 years ago
what da meaning of M.I.L
azzeda 4 years ago
millenium innocent love... strange, i know
kamusperibahasa 4 years ago
thanks...
sooo u lyk peribahasa??...
its strange...
azzeda 4 years ago
erm no... it was on my table as i was thinking of a nick. lol.
go shinhwa
kamusperibahasa 4 years ago
T.O.P. : Twinkling Of Paradise
D.O.P. : Delight Of Passion
D.O.G. : Delight Of Gorgeousness
M.I.L. : Millenium Innocent Love
Choi216 3 years ago 2
WHAT IS D.R.C?
CanLanka 4 years ago
whats the name of the song in the beginning
Chaoswitch93 4 years ago
hae gyul sah. they debuted with this
kamusperibahasa 4 years ago
i'v never seen them perform that first dance in the black coat.
and with regards to the actual TOP dance, the arm movement before the 'flapping' movement is so weird!!
jkchen88 4 years ago
Eric is soooo cute!!!! SHINHWA FOREVER!!!!
ShinhwaBoA101 4 years ago
i LOVE this song! man they are still together after all these years, that´s great !!
multiaveraged 4 years ago
zzang is pronounced like chang
so gaxlod is correct
app13xxch33ks 4 years ago
omg they were sooooooo cute back then
Minwoo was so hot *drools*
angel4all 4 years ago
wth is da crowd saying ???
carriesunx3 4 years ago
I'm not Korean but I think the crowd is saying. Shinhwa-San.
MikeDirntFan 4 years ago
Shinhwa-zzang.
jjzzim 4 years ago
omg. shinhwa's so good! : ) i love dongwan with that hair!! ITS AWESOME! <3
icecoldscandinavian 5 years ago 2
It's so...emotional to watch this perf!! brings back the past!! It's crazy how the fans were screaming their name and singing along with them lol^^ they r still as popular tho^^
thanx for the vid btw :)
Swe3t108 5 years ago