Heartbreaking. How do we address the world citizen? Hi I am an American. My govt uses me to to fund the murder of your children if your leaders refuse to bow down to the plunder". We hear you Palestine. Many of us are working tirelessly to stop the bombing.
Gos is supposed to be love, must be a jehovah, nothing wrong with that except the whole fear thing.
Fear keeps the mind in a state of LOW iq.
Put it together.,,, YOur not fearing god in my book, your fearing Satan as only Satan feeds off of fear.
Figure this out.
Past this, id rather skip any biblican discussions as FEAR is always BAD, Respect god, trust or love god, sure, but to be afraid of him is never going to help you learn anything.
First off sounds like a little kid throwing a bitch-fit. Who the fuck cares you can't use the sunglasses your dad bought you. Maybe if you guys took some time off from building IEDs and smuggling arms into Afghanistan maybe the world would send some relief, right now If an American goes and tries to help Palestine they'll end up on Al-Jazeera getting they're fucking heads chopped off. It's bullshit. And @ yutubesexy: Go yourself. Hooah!
@megapaiman I share some of your sentiments but Zionism is VERY different from Judaism, TRUE Jews do not support this and some (albeit not enough) speak out against it (search 'Jews against Zionism' on here...) I have nothing against Israeli people but I agree fuck their govt...the Israeli govt are the modern day Nazis, as ironic as that is...
@brucenitro And where do you think these peoples would be able to GET condoms??? Or any form of birth control? Maybe no one should even be allowed to marry over there and then they can all just die out.. GOD what stupidity.. Unless you've actually been there you have no idea what its like. I've been on both side of the border there and most of the people would manage to get along if outsiders quit enabling either sides nutcases to keep waging war on the normal people there..
@brucenitro Unfortunately for the Palestinians The Nutcases on the Israeli side are in the government and are masters of PR.. They can twist facts so easily to make primitive homemade missiles that can barely jump the fence look like nuclear missiles and give them an excuse to bomb out whole cities in retaliation, drop white phosphorus and shot children at point blank.. Opps the child ran into my bullet 28 times. Most normal Israeli have no idea what their government is doing in there.
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! that really got me crying hard, I"M SORRY and I feel a shame to tell that to Palestinians, I'm a shame of myself of being Muslim, Arab, Human being which has a brain to think and heart to beat, hereby I aske the Almighty lord I ask allah either to give the honor of immortallity or death
يا رب يالنصر يالشهادة يارب يالنصر يالشهاده يا رب يالنصر يالشهادة
O you Soildiers of the Jews are YOU proud of killing KIDS and women?These kids can be your own daughters and sons.Just because they came out from the wombs of Palestinians that doesnt mean that they are not YOUR children!!!Are you not HUMAN?Have you no shame?Are you really the chosen people where our Prophets were chosen from your people or are you the sons of devils?or Synagogue of Setan claiming yourselves as JEWS!!?
the live of the palestinen children is very cheap in the eye of the west.. because they are muslim.. in the mind of the west muslim is terorrist but the truth is they are the terorrist..
@guscaldas2 they were the chosen, but alot of their fore father decided to not recognize Jesus as the Christ (messiah) and cruisified Him. Its all in God (Jesus's) plan. He knows all things past present future. It's all a test for us to have faith and find Him. We are all Sinners not one is good according to the 10 Commandments. If your not following the new covenent with faith in Jesus he willl not grant you Grace to enter Heaven.
@guscaldas2 If your not followers of Jesus then by default your a follower of the enemy the fallen ones, satan and, the people who will not bow down to the Creator. IF you think that by not taking sides your ok like I thought. your going to hell like i was and hell is not what i defined it as. Its what the Creator made it as.
@guscaldas2 If your worried about following the wrong word of God (Bible). I would suggest you start with 1611AD King James Version with all 66 books, old and new testiments (history), the true Christian source. The Roman Catholic Church has been trying to add there twisted belief to the original bible since 300AD and did succeed after 1611AD. God has set it up to make us work (study) for the truth. the door to heaven is narrow ,few there be, that will find it
@guscaldas2 Its beleived that 144,000 Israelis in Jeruselim (the believers in Jesus) will be taken before the Great Tribulation. the rest of them will be hell bound. Its nothing for the Creator to distroy his creation. He let man kill His Son, to prove He could bring life back, showing us believers that we will have everlasting life either in body or in spirit.
look at this is horrible these children have gone through more suffering then most of us has in are whole life they probally seether neibors and stuff getting killed on the streets almost every day,,,,,THE absoultley horrible thing though is most of are tax dollors is paying,,,,, Makes you re think if you havent already who the real terroist are
American media hides this..we live in a idiot bubble with Dancing with the Stars and American Idol, not having a clue what our tax dollars are supporting.
This is from Occupation 101 isn't it? Those children are so amazing. That little girl...wow. I made everyone I know watch that scene (if they wouldn't sit down for the whole thing that is.)
@daizee106 Agreed! Man, as an individual & not an individual nation, is responsible for what he brings about & also allows to happen. When we sit by & choose not to show others compassion or respect by giving of our time, finance's, wisdom & understanding, we are joining in as part of the problem. If we rely on our nation or even those within our community before we rely on ourselves, to begin a kind effort, it's strength & impact will never last or change many lives. Remain Watchful & Ready =)
@wasssuppp08 , the US and Israel are the terrorist nations of the world.. the MSM sells the poor me stories to the sheople and they buy into it. if there is a god he would put an end to the palestinian genocide perpetrated by Israel with the blessing of the USA.. How could any god fearing individual regardless of race be brainwashed enough to take innocent lives.?. the US and Israel have no problem doing that.
@navtel Hey Bro! I commend you for taking the time to understand the major institutions that support terrorism, yet when seeking out corruption, the elitist causing it would love you to believe there is no God because there is so pain, destruction, etc. This is not the way life was intended to be lived, personally or socially. Mankind has been given choices, some would rather try & take this free will away. God's word is unfolding & there will be Great Tribulation before a brighter time ahead!
It is really horrible that countries, fight senseless wars, think of nothing but Greed and Corruption, forsaking the essence of Life within their cultures. Children are stripped of their values, dreams, and most of all HOPE for peace within their families. Once everything is taken from them, Countries have complete "Control" of everything including their existence.
@KingKong1ooo what Israel needs is a bomb dropped on them to give them a real taste of war. those bastards have been holding the world guilty for what happened in the second world war.. sorry boys, the guilt has gone. you are now the aggressors and need to be stopped.
I am refusing to buy any goods made in Israel. If we all start to do the same maybe we can make a difference....if only a small one ......and it will send a message out to shops and Governments. Enough is enough but we have to change things with peace not violence, we have to turn our outrage and anger at what we see into positive peaceful action.
The only problem i have with this video, is the little red box in the end saying "free Egypt" Egypt, the traitor who has turned its back on Palestine for decades!!
u see this shit. this is what those damn israeli are all about and they wont stop and the sad part is america is backing israel on killin millions upon millions of ppl. fuck america and those fake ass jews over there in israel. and be aware because the same thing is commin to america
@sisqo2k7 The answer is not blame somebody, we should ask why they do this ? England and Unites States LEADERS belong to a dark power, they are the ILLUMINATIS , dark entities of power, they dont care killing people, they want us to keep us in LOW VIBRATION , we have to fight against it , just BELIEVE , all this will stop , believe humanity is not bad , who make the wars are these dark power
RESPECT AND LOVE ARE OUR WEAPONS " KNOWLEDGE " OUR MAIN ONE
the man had a point ...this film has been made but, there is almost nobody filming this...he said because the reporters are either scared or it just too difficult (to get there). i have met amateur newsmen on my travels years ago in the past who were very brave, but, usually not paid for a story until it was used. w/ our media being controlled, over 96% by "you know who",these stories essentially "have no money in them".
@medini2 yes you are right , controlled by the dark side, and they soon will lose their power , the resitance is working on it, also light entities, the madia is controlled but this is most on europ and america, south america will soon face them too, and russia is taking position, there is a lot of information that is on the internet already , put there by indeendent people.
PRAY LETS RAISE VIBRATION , LOVE RESPECT AND FORCE IS NEEDED
@latinonyc7 thanks for that message. so turn off the tv's, if you can , stop paying federal taxes...that might mean stay unemployed if you can and learn and spread the truth.
No child should have to live in this fear ,Its heart breaking. How could anyone look at those childrens faces and not have a lump in their throat. The GOVERNMENTS SHOULD BE WELL ASHAMED OF THEIRSELVES FOR NOT PUTTING AN END TO THIS. SHAME On all Involved
@medini2 If I could and thought it would do any good I would But we would be probably hunted down too For getting in the way.
The Militaries need to know whats really happening in this world. I had one soldier on another video tell me i should sign up and do whats right for my country, I told him never I am not a murderer my eyes are wider open than his ,I told him you are being brainwashed . They are being lied to.
@UkTruthSeeker2009 The "middle class" & the educated iraqi's are being irradicated, not rescued from anything. It's unspeakable, all of it. just read a stunning interview at fourwinds10 dating back from 1976 w/ benjamin rosenthal. it was quite revealing. you should take a peek at it. it explains what is happening in no uncertain terms.
@medini2 pardon me, that would be the interview w/ harold rosenthal in 1976 called "hidden tyranny". you'll have to google it, but, i wish everybody would read it.
i wish could give that little girl some hope, and some clothes that don't smell like gas.
the girl in the green clothing was wonderfully articulate. It's all sad and ridiculous that this is allowed to go on and the baloney "peace" talks that go on forever that the public buy.
Heartbreaking. How do we address the world citizen? Hi I am an American. My govt uses me to to fund the murder of your children if your leaders refuse to bow down to the plunder". We hear you Palestine. Many of us are working tirelessly to stop the bombing.
izzysykopth 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
God does not exist!
noobtubegamer 7 months ago
@yutubesexy well said
MilitiaMackMusic 9 months ago
@yutubesexy Fear god?
Gos is supposed to be love, must be a jehovah, nothing wrong with that except the whole fear thing.
Fear keeps the mind in a state of LOW iq.
Put it together.,,, YOur not fearing god in my book, your fearing Satan as only Satan feeds off of fear.
Figure this out.
Past this, id rather skip any biblican discussions as FEAR is always BAD, Respect god, trust or love god, sure, but to be afraid of him is never going to help you learn anything.
Fear Teachers/parents?
RobMonty248 11 months ago
If none of you can get along, were all fucked.
This is what they want..
RobMonty248 11 months ago
@yutubesexy Nah, well i wont disagree, how about we get them to raid congress/senate?
The congress and senate are not gonna be able to defend themselfs much, lol.
Old farts with nothing but coffee and a mouth to speak from.
American forces, please save us today, take our country back!
RobMonty248 11 months ago
First off sounds like a little kid throwing a bitch-fit. Who the fuck cares you can't use the sunglasses your dad bought you. Maybe if you guys took some time off from building IEDs and smuggling arms into Afghanistan maybe the world would send some relief, right now If an American goes and tries to help Palestine they'll end up on Al-Jazeera getting they're fucking heads chopped off. It's bullshit. And @ yutubesexy: Go yourself. Hooah!
Nelsonpenify 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck Israel!!!!!
fuck their people!!!!!
and fuck their Jewish religion and fuck their soldiers...............
megapaiman 1 year ago
fuck Israel!!!!!
fuck their people!!!!!
and fuck their Jewish religion and fuck their soldiers...............
megapaiman 1 year ago
@megapaiman I share some of your sentiments but Zionism is VERY different from Judaism, TRUE Jews do not support this and some (albeit not enough) speak out against it (search 'Jews against Zionism' on here...) I have nothing against Israeli people but I agree fuck their govt...the Israeli govt are the modern day Nazis, as ironic as that is...
xxstarchildxx 1 year ago
wow! it's a modern day holocaust! sleep well.
burdog309 1 year ago
Fuck them all. Israel is a land of peace, unlike Islam.
CelticJobber2 1 year ago
@CelticJobber2 you are a fuckin dick and isreal is land of terror and jewish people kill innocent people!!!!! we all know that motherfucker
megapaiman 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@CelticJobber2 you are a fuckin dick and isreal is land of terror and jewish people kill innocent people!!!!! we all know that motherfucker
megapaiman 1 year ago
Hmmm 14 kids? Sounds like you should have used condoms.
brucenitro 1 year ago
@brucenitro And where do you think these peoples would be able to GET condoms??? Or any form of birth control? Maybe no one should even be allowed to marry over there and then they can all just die out.. GOD what stupidity.. Unless you've actually been there you have no idea what its like. I've been on both side of the border there and most of the people would manage to get along if outsiders quit enabling either sides nutcases to keep waging war on the normal people there..
Mashaalaa 1 year ago
@brucenitro Unfortunately for the Palestinians The Nutcases on the Israeli side are in the government and are masters of PR.. They can twist facts so easily to make primitive homemade missiles that can barely jump the fence look like nuclear missiles and give them an excuse to bomb out whole cities in retaliation, drop white phosphorus and shot children at point blank.. Opps the child ran into my bullet 28 times. Most normal Israeli have no idea what their government is doing in there.
Mashaalaa 1 year ago
this is not america you fucks this is the jews killing them ITS THE FUCKING JEWS
DogMeatJesus 1 year ago
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! that really got me crying hard, I"M SORRY and I feel a shame to tell that to Palestinians, I'm a shame of myself of being Muslim, Arab, Human being which has a brain to think and heart to beat, hereby I aske the Almighty lord I ask allah either to give the honor of immortallity or death
يا رب يالنصر يالشهادة يارب يالنصر يالشهاده يا رب يالنصر يالشهادة
AKAMACK10 1 year ago
O you Soildiers of the Jews are YOU proud of killing KIDS and women?These kids can be your own daughters and sons.Just because they came out from the wombs of Palestinians that doesnt mean that they are not YOUR children!!!Are you not HUMAN?Have you no shame?Are you really the chosen people where our Prophets were chosen from your people or are you the sons of devils?or Synagogue of Setan claiming yourselves as JEWS!!?
111256able 1 year ago
the live of the palestinen children is very cheap in the eye of the west.. because they are muslim.. in the mind of the west muslim is terorrist but the truth is they are the terorrist..
butuhusa 1 year ago
Comment removed
xxstarchildxx 1 year ago
@butuhusa You're right, what most people don't realise is that the biggest terrorists are in govt...in this case the Israeli govt, for the most part.
xxstarchildxx 1 year ago
I want to chop every isreali's dick off
lapatria100 1 year ago
Yeah...I am afraid of those evil toddlers! Help Me Infantry Soldiers!! Go kill them before they come here and get me...Ya Cowards!
ChemTrailSkys 1 year ago
Hell my words want help this just so dam sick!!!!!!!!!!!
peoplestandup 1 year ago
this child c/o gas smell on her clothes died a terrible death. 2 minutes into this vid, the details: watch?v=vjLeRNQIHcU
medini2 1 year ago
Thank you for posting this. We must take off our blinders to the unspeakable horrors
of this situation.
stay2uned 1 year ago
9:02 Add to queueAdded to
queue tax revolution,abuse, & death 3.wmv
to the evil white house-- the evil D.C. Capitol, the evil State Capitols all 50 of them and all counties,
and cities of the United States of America, if JOE STACK Gave his life in an insane act, then so be it because all American tax payers murder ...
realitiesupremebeing 1 year ago
<<<<<huge lump in throat
SpreadingAwareness 1 year ago
this is israel war crimes
ahmedtsection1 1 year ago
Comment removed
bluesoul227 1 year ago
this is an outrage.
areyoulookinatmepal 1 year ago
Aren't the Israelis the chosen people of God? If so, how can they do this?
guscaldas2 1 year ago
@guscaldas2 they were the chosen, but alot of their fore father decided to not recognize Jesus as the Christ (messiah) and cruisified Him. Its all in God (Jesus's) plan. He knows all things past present future. It's all a test for us to have faith and find Him. We are all Sinners not one is good according to the 10 Commandments. If your not following the new covenent with faith in Jesus he willl not grant you Grace to enter Heaven.
XRRep 1 year ago
@guscaldas2 If your not followers of Jesus then by default your a follower of the enemy the fallen ones, satan and, the people who will not bow down to the Creator. IF you think that by not taking sides your ok like I thought. your going to hell like i was and hell is not what i defined it as. Its what the Creator made it as.
XRRep 1 year ago
@guscaldas2 If your worried about following the wrong word of God (Bible). I would suggest you start with 1611AD King James Version with all 66 books, old and new testiments (history), the true Christian source. The Roman Catholic Church has been trying to add there twisted belief to the original bible since 300AD and did succeed after 1611AD. God has set it up to make us work (study) for the truth. the door to heaven is narrow ,few there be, that will find it
XRRep 1 year ago
@guscaldas2 Its beleived that 144,000 Israelis in Jeruselim (the believers in Jesus) will be taken before the Great Tribulation. the rest of them will be hell bound. Its nothing for the Creator to distroy his creation. He let man kill His Son, to prove He could bring life back, showing us believers that we will have everlasting life either in body or in spirit.
XRRep 1 year ago
This shiit just doesnt make any sense ... -_-
Poor babies!!! FuCK our GoV'T 4 backing up and FUNDING this terrorism
XratedBarbie 1 year ago
re. that wall, in constructing it the Israeli's should remember they have built their own prison too.
cicatrixta 1 year ago
look at this is horrible these children have gone through more suffering then most of us has in are whole life they probally seether neibors and stuff getting killed on the streets almost every day,,,,,THE absoultley horrible thing though is most of are tax dollors is paying,,,,, Makes you re think if you havent already who the real terroist are
highinthesky231 1 year ago
American media hides this..we live in a idiot bubble with Dancing with the Stars and American Idol, not having a clue what our tax dollars are supporting.
fgrfgfg 1 year ago 2
This is from Occupation 101 isn't it? Those children are so amazing. That little girl...wow. I made everyone I know watch that scene (if they wouldn't sit down for the whole thing that is.)
tritestatic 1 year ago
Sad :-(
7895225789 1 year ago
Those are some fearsome looking terrorists. This is what we support in the u.s., with our deafening silence. So Sad
daizee106 1 year ago 15
@daizee106 Agreed! Man, as an individual & not an individual nation, is responsible for what he brings about & also allows to happen. When we sit by & choose not to show others compassion or respect by giving of our time, finance's, wisdom & understanding, we are joining in as part of the problem. If we rely on our nation or even those within our community before we rely on ourselves, to begin a kind effort, it's strength & impact will never last or change many lives. Remain Watchful & Ready =)
GODLOVESUSSOMUCH 1 year ago
Evil Jew bastards.
ZyklonBunny 1 year ago 3
@wasssuppp08 , the US and Israel are the terrorist nations of the world.. the MSM sells the poor me stories to the sheople and they buy into it. if there is a god he would put an end to the palestinian genocide perpetrated by Israel with the blessing of the USA.. How could any god fearing individual regardless of race be brainwashed enough to take innocent lives.?. the US and Israel have no problem doing that.
navtel 1 year ago
@navtel Hey Bro! I commend you for taking the time to understand the major institutions that support terrorism, yet when seeking out corruption, the elitist causing it would love you to believe there is no God because there is so pain, destruction, etc. This is not the way life was intended to be lived, personally or socially. Mankind has been given choices, some would rather try & take this free will away. God's word is unfolding & there will be Great Tribulation before a brighter time ahead!
GODLOVESUSSOMUCH 1 year ago
And the US Supports this Bull$hit.....America and Israel will burn for this...
DirtyVegas7 1 year ago
Pray for Palestine
DirtyVegas7 1 year ago
It is really horrible that countries, fight senseless wars, think of nothing but Greed and Corruption, forsaking the essence of Life within their cultures. Children are stripped of their values, dreams, and most of all HOPE for peace within their families. Once everything is taken from them, Countries have complete "Control" of everything including their existence.
jamkmorun 1 year ago
@jamkmorun to wage war is to be man
cbr6864 1 year ago
makes me sick to my stomach
Jason310M 1 year ago
isreal need people to hate them and they need war -inorder to justify the ethnic clensing of palestine
KingKong1ooo 1 year ago
@KingKong1ooo what Israel needs is a bomb dropped on them to give them a real taste of war. those bastards have been holding the world guilty for what happened in the second world war.. sorry boys, the guilt has gone. you are now the aggressors and need to be stopped.
navtel 1 year ago
I am refusing to buy any goods made in Israel. If we all start to do the same maybe we can make a difference....if only a small one ......and it will send a message out to shops and Governments. Enough is enough but we have to change things with peace not violence, we have to turn our outrage and anger at what we see into positive peaceful action.
beltanebabe55 1 year ago
The only problem i have with this video, is the little red box in the end saying "free Egypt" Egypt, the traitor who has turned its back on Palestine for decades!!
TheBaByG 1 year ago 3
@TheBaByG
Good point.
Jason310M 1 year ago
u see this shit. this is what those damn israeli are all about and they wont stop and the sad part is america is backing israel on killin millions upon millions of ppl. fuck america and those fake ass jews over there in israel. and be aware because the same thing is commin to america
sisqo2k7 1 year ago
@sisqo2k7 The answer is not blame somebody, we should ask why they do this ? England and Unites States LEADERS belong to a dark power, they are the ILLUMINATIS , dark entities of power, they dont care killing people, they want us to keep us in LOW VIBRATION , we have to fight against it , just BELIEVE , all this will stop , believe humanity is not bad , who make the wars are these dark power
RESPECT AND LOVE ARE OUR WEAPONS " KNOWLEDGE " OUR MAIN ONE
WE ARE THE RESISTANCE AGAINST THE NWO
latinonyc7 1 year ago
the man had a point ...this film has been made but, there is almost nobody filming this...he said because the reporters are either scared or it just too difficult (to get there). i have met amateur newsmen on my travels years ago in the past who were very brave, but, usually not paid for a story until it was used. w/ our media being controlled, over 96% by "you know who",these stories essentially "have no money in them".
medini2 1 year ago
@medini2 yes you are right , controlled by the dark side, and they soon will lose their power , the resitance is working on it, also light entities, the madia is controlled but this is most on europ and america, south america will soon face them too, and russia is taking position, there is a lot of information that is on the internet already , put there by indeendent people.
PRAY LETS RAISE VIBRATION , LOVE RESPECT AND FORCE IS NEEDED
WE ARE THE RESISTANCE
latinonyc7 1 year ago
@latinonyc7 thanks for that message. so turn off the tv's, if you can , stop paying federal taxes...that might mean stay unemployed if you can and learn and spread the truth.
medini2 1 year ago
No child should have to live in this fear ,Its heart breaking. How could anyone look at those childrens faces and not have a lump in their throat. The GOVERNMENTS SHOULD BE WELL ASHAMED OF THEIRSELVES FOR NOT PUTTING AN END TO THIS. SHAME On all Involved
UkTruthSeeker2009 1 year ago
@UkTruthSeeker2009 100 % with you
latinonyc7 1 year ago
@UkTruthSeeker2009 why the hell don't a bunch of us fly to israel and go to gaza. would it do any good?
never can figure a damned thing out.
medini2 1 year ago
@medini2 If I could and thought it would do any good I would But we would be probably hunted down too For getting in the way.
The Militaries need to know whats really happening in this world. I had one soldier on another video tell me i should sign up and do whats right for my country, I told him never I am not a murderer my eyes are wider open than his ,I told him you are being brainwashed . They are being lied to.
UkTruthSeeker2009 1 year ago
@UkTruthSeeker2009 The "middle class" & the educated iraqi's are being irradicated, not rescued from anything. It's unspeakable, all of it. just read a stunning interview at fourwinds10 dating back from 1976 w/ benjamin rosenthal. it was quite revealing. you should take a peek at it. it explains what is happening in no uncertain terms.
medini2 1 year ago
@medini2 pardon me, that would be the interview w/ harold rosenthal in 1976 called "hidden tyranny". you'll have to google it, but, i wish everybody would read it.
i wish could give that little girl some hope, and some clothes that don't smell like gas.
medini2 1 year ago
the girl in the green clothing was wonderfully articulate. It's all sad and ridiculous that this is allowed to go on and the baloney "peace" talks that go on forever that the public buy.
stuartambient 1 year ago
@stuartambient 100 % WIHT YOU
latinonyc7 1 year ago
i weep to here children ask these questions
i weep that the adults consenting to allow this to happen are not asking these question
i weep
i weep
i weep
psychodrilla 1 year ago
@psychodrilla 100 % WITH YOU
latinonyc7 1 year ago
Thank you for posting this!
LoneRaven01 1 year ago
@LoneRaven01 100 % WITH YOU
latinonyc7 1 year ago
no, i can not imagine, and these chidren deserve new life , really please God
lucyinclonmel 1 year ago
@lucyinclonmel 100 % WITH YOU
latinonyc7 1 year ago