Added: 4 years ago
From: danielyp29
Views: 104,877
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (148)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • He played unstable in tune;

    he need practice more.

  • guess what...IM PLAYING THIS AND THIS SONG IS AWESOME!

  • your violin has such a nice sound!

    i had to play this piece today for audience~ i kinda fucked it up -got all sick by nervs- :3

    well done! ;D

  • he have to work at intonation. sometimes it's off pitch

  • Gosh he's so young and he can play like this? I'm 14 and I'm playing this piece, and I was blown away by this performance

  • I want to sound that good

  • the cadenza was amazing!

    but everything else was really out of tune!

  • @musicluvr416 the cadenza wasn't any more in tune than the rest of the peice

  • @orrinaleron

    what? oh, for fuck's sake, i must have left the youtube without logging-off on school campus.

    I'm sorry, but what has been said above is defintely not my opinion of classical music whatsover.

    Rap on the other hand, is a different story. That is real nonsense.

  • ahhh i'm doing this for my high school competition solo, D=< if i get the song down, and dnt get nerve wrecked i should be good enough for a 3!

  • cornista hdp.

  • Not the best performance, but if you're at the age I think you are, I would like to commend you on your bow control. Your intonation needs work, but you're bow control is a lot better than most other high school violinists I have watched. Overall decent. Keep practicing scales 'cause you're on your way :)

  • @zacharyrod1st Thanks, I think this was right after I turned 17... I had quit violin for 2 years and had picked it back up about 4 months before this concert.

  • i commend you for what must have been a nerve wracking performance,

    interestingly, the difficult parts of the cadenza worked quite well but it's the easy stuff that eludes you

  • at 8:15 - 8:19 you can hear a man laughing in the backround. Personally i thought this was a terrible performance

  • Very sad performance.Intonation is poor, rythmically it insecure. Sadly, I thought it came across as an moderately talented high school orchestra. In Mozart, purity of intonation is essential. This sad little performance; listen and then listen to Artur Grumiaux and London Symphony. Day and night difference.

  • @TheMmesser You try playing it then; youtube is for CONSTRUCTIVE criticism, not flat out rude comments that are just really stupid to begin with.

    At least he tried.

  • You'd want to get the 'Flesch' scale book out quick.... That'll sort out your intonation problems... There some CONSTRUCTIVE criticism

  • i wish there was more feeling into it. but quite good

  • @MyHaloFan117 I like the fact that you mention this. Few people ever even put thought to the emotions in the music. :)

  • awesome! beautiful!

  • the intonation is....questionable.

  • id like to know who this kid is. hes pretty good, but a little scratchy in places.he would have been better if he didnt screw that 1 note up.

  • haha at 6:34 he screws up a note and and makes me want to puke lol, I played this solo for an audition to all-state in Maine... it was a fun time :) But I can't blame him you know, only because he is younger than I am by a lot lol

  • some bits are a bit out of tune. but good job overall, this piece is really hard to master.. i would know been playing it for 5 months and it's still nowhere near perfect. :P

  • I'm working on this piece and its a beast but I love it. Good job. This is a very difficult piece to master so I'm sure you spent a great deal of time on this! and you sound better than I do on it right now and you are younger, I'm sure...so you go Daniel!

  • i'm getting ready to play this on the viola for my semester test at my school!! :D so far i pretty much like it... except my cadenza could be a bit easier XP yours sounded pretty =] it sounded great :D

  • you're pretty good, from what i can tell~ youtube's not the best quality though.

    dont let those critics get you down! youre probably better than most of them! (most prolly cant even play violin =))

    ehh, mozarts concerto in g is pretty standard though (right?). heh, my allstate did tchaikovsky's 4th. now THAT was a *&%&

  • hmm, it's so so, and the french horn, he needs to practice more.

  • ahh everyone's harsh analysis of this is freaking me out! i have an audition in a month and i'm definitely not as good as this guy!!

  • FLAT AT 2:20!!!!!!!!!!!

  • ya!!!! :D

  • отстой

  • it's so painful to listen to this. jesus, that french horn....

  • Me sorprende un poco al notar que no existe ningun hispano comentando acerca de una sinfonia tan notable y tan hermosa como esta, sencillamente es un privilegio poder disfrutar de una sinfonia como esta.

  • gracias

  • to blackninja14...of course you can hear the solo violinist, so maybe by saying 'not to sound like a total douche' deep down you know you are - LISTEN!!!

  • ii...nnn......................­tonation

  • not to sound like a total douche, but im ignorant to this: how r we able to so clearly hear the sound of the violinist (even though he's playing something different) over the orchestra? wouldnt they blend somewhat?

  • he's out front. that's one ( the entire shape and seating of the orchestra effect the sound, not to mention that 100k shell around them). and two. he's essentially playing his ass off while the accompaniment is playing at a lower dynamic. if you wanted to get technical in terms of the physics of sound, i can keep goin. haha.

  • coool i just finished learnin this!! its such a fun piece

  • wonderful violin

  • when it gets kinda minor.. u kinda went out of tune the first entrance. but thats ok

    otherwise.. good job

  • I'm just learning this piece for a violin exam XD

    Ryuyasha13

  • which violin exam? do you mean audition

  • Grade 9 RCM exam, and nope, it's not an audition.

    Ryuyasha13

  • I also am studying this piece for the grade 9 RCM. Hardest piece I ever had to learn.

  • What's RCM? Is highest level 10?

    How does it compare to CM test? In CM test Lalo Symphonie Espanole is considered to be level 8

  • it's on grade 9?

  • By the way, I couldn't listen long enough to get to the solo violin part, so don't take that as an insult to yourself. :p:

  • Christ, my ears are bleeding - this version is truly appalling. Makes the Isaac Stern one currently on YouTube seem flawless.

  • that's not fair to compare a legend and a professional symphony to some random guy and a community orchestra....

  • And Mozart did not know a Stradivarius.That remained for the ones who would pretend to be Mozart

  • Fantastic! I've just started studying this piece too. I'd love to play it as a concerto. I envy your skills: I can't play it as well as you.... yet!! ;)

  • I'm actually studying this piece for a college audition next spring. Keep up the good work. It's coming along nicely.

  • wow yay i am too! i'm glad i found someone who also played it at my age (or around there), as everyone i've found who's played this is like 9 years old lol.

    this was a year ago...how'd your audition go?

  • I have a question is the candenza in this particular movie is diffirent on other movie but also the same piece??? because the cadenza of my score is different from this though its the same piece

  • cadenza prolly because yours is a different version, prolly arranged or edited or reduced, it may be his markings his bowings, and his cadenza

  • Actually, the cadenza is the Franko. Not only is it not reduced, but Perlman plays the exact cadenza on his record MINUS the 16th note arrpegios at the end. It's the same version I'm playing, and it's quite difficult. Good job!

  • don't listen to people, i think you did well =]

    a few intonation errors, but you are by no means sucky.

    if you people think you genuinely suck they obviously are just stupid. if you sucked you wouldn't be playing with a symphony O.o

    i think yo did a good job ^^

  • I love the moonlight sonata!

    (Also, totally agree with what you just said)

  • Did you ever think that because you've posted this, that it could be detrimental to you future career in violin? (If you plan to do so.) No one likes a sucky violinist.

  • nope, never thought about it that way.

  • may i have your e mail i want to chat with you hehe

  • O burdi....ma non vi vergognate? Siete come delle pere in frack facendo i fighetti e non mettete una nota..

    E' uno schifo di dio....ASCU...e baccagai

  • i meant to say a little nervous srry

  • Recording is also poor, makes him sound worse than he would if better equpt was used

  • nah, i doubt it

  • yea.. i have intonation problems. i played it a loooong time ago and just kinda brought it back but my intonation still sucked :|

  • You're quite funny to actually say Mozart is easy to play. FEW people can actually play Mozart properly. I figure you're not one of them because you think it's easy. It doesn't matter, likewise, if the piece is 'easy': MOZART wrote it; EVERYONE has played it.

    Stop criticising poorly and post a recording of yourself.

  • Are you joking? You sight read it? Even Venergov would not dare call his sight reading perfect... I guess you are better than him.

  • sight read*

  • my bad

    i take back all thhe replies i wrote

    my bad

  • I can play better than that guy. But your getting there, keep up the good work.

  • wat?

    um unless u r perlman or some other famouse violin player u r not better than issac stern

  • that's not isaac stern, its a high school kid whose intonation is off and has some work to do before he can say he's mastered this piece. I don't claim to be better than stern, very few people in history can do that.

  • i know

    i said my bad

    i tookit back

    i kept on watching this video andi guess i lost my mind

    my bad

  • good job

    work on it more though

    :D

    i can prolly play better but i need the music

    XD

  • u 2

  • No offence, but I can do better than the concertmaster!

  • I believe you lol

  • wat ever

  • Kinda out of tune

  • yeaaa.....i kinda suck at playing in tune as well as other parts of violin playing

  • nah dont worry it was pretty good screw all them haters u were probably just a little. Its all good.

  • I can do it better!!

    :)

  • me too..:)i guess its not so difficult to do it better:p

  • What a fucking orchestra!!man!!!....

    but dont be nervous in future...youre not bad...good luck

  • the orchestra sucks. no offense. you're good:)

  • luv ur playing....not so much of the orchestra

  • the violin sorta sounds like a toy...or is it about the recording system?

  • i think it's just my playing and the recording cuz that violin is supposed to be too good for me

  • Is this orchestra professional? Do they get paid to play like that? Daniel you have have good assertiveness for your level and it is good to see someone who knows what they want to do in a Mozart concerto and I'm sure in five years you will be at a very high level. I would be extremely disappointed if an orchestra played like that if I was the soloist.

  • Nope it's a community orchestra... I actually play in the symphony if I have time. I know it's not the best orchestra, but it was still a good opportunity to be able to perform with one. And as for performing at a high level... I'm considering switching to viola or even just going into conducting. I'll get back to you on that in 5 years lol

  • You have to be a good musicians to "go into conducting" - rofl. That's all I'm gonna say. No professional musicians are going to respect the "Maestro" that has to apologize after performing Mozart's 2nd easiest violin concerto. Have I got you back to practicing? Good. Let me tell you, in 5 years, you're going to be better than me. Stick to it.

  • i'm pretty good at understanding music, i just can't use that to be a better violinist. i always thought i was somewhat better at percussion also.

  • what's mozart's easiest concerto?

  • Well the 2nd was published as "concerto facile" - easy concerto. So I can't call it easier than the 3rd really since Mozart didn't think it was.

  • my class is doing this one rite now. It's not that bad. My friend said the solo is not as hard as other concerto.

  • so i thought you might've wanted an update on how my music stuff is going? violin is still improving... but i aced (like literally) ear training and theory.

  • That's great. Ear training is going to take you very far! Spend extra time learning your intervals and I guarantee it will pay off.

  • i tested out of a semester of ear training already and i'm pretty good with the intervals... i still need to work on my intonation on the violin though :/

  • umm

    im a violinist myself, but ive never really heard of ear training...

    and for music theory, well, forget that stuff. =P

    just practicing and getting yelled at by my teach is plenty

  • Comment removed

  • i wont bother responding to your insults... or profanity.

    music theory:

    i know how to read music, and the styles in which pieces from different periods were played. but all the things like ABA form to explain a certain series of note just seems silly to me.

    ear training. i looked it up, and yes, i do do what's called "ear training", though not for some time. my intonation is quite good up to around 6th position.

    im 4th seat in LA allstate, and my current working piece is tchaikovsky's first.

  • as a performer, you should be aware of theory. it's not just about the forms of the piece and which time period it's from, but understanding the phrases and playing things differently to bring out something that isn't normal. you have to understand the chordal structure to emphasize a cadence or something, or even something that isn't part of the diatonic sequence, maybe like a secondary chord or if it modulates. music's not just about playing the notes, but understanding it.

  • And ear training, or also called "aural skills" isn't just about intonation, although it is something that you should have as a musician but also being able to recognize sequences, motives, themes although that's more related with theory, and cadences. just playing notes probably won't get people anywhere . and the combination of theory and aural skills can make people better musicians

  • There, that's a response I can work with!

    I lack training in... pretty much everything except actually playing the violin. If I need to play something a certain way, my teacher will tell me. : )

    Note that while I am a decent enough violinist by most standards, I do not plan to make a career out of it. As it is, I struggle to find time to practice.

  • just remember that you are an artist and you can interpret music how you see it based on the forms and stuff. some people will playing a piece differently than others because of how they analyze it and stuff, and your teacher will tell you how to play it now, but eventually as you understand music more with theory and stuff, you can choose your own way to interpret it as long as it's not too terribly out of context and stuff

  • @patricake I am completely like this.

  • LA = Louisiana?

    Just wondering ahha=]

  • @patricake WOW GOOD JOB! I Hope you're mom is proud of you like i am!

  • holy crap.... this is what happens if you leave your youtube account logged in at a community library. I am really sorry that someone impersonated me and did this shit. this opinion has nothing to do with me, and i like classic music anyways. its good for meditation.

  • Not to be intrusive, but are you "danielyp29"'s teacher or something?

  • nah he was just giving me some tips and stuff

  • French Horn failiure at :46!

    LOOOOOOOOL I'm wondering how I thought this was a vengerov clip.

  • Wow!  That bass in the back is pretty cool! I've never seen one like that. Did it never get painted or something?

  • Wonderful ... thankyou. Great to hear it live like mozart would have wanted it.

  • too flat and scratchy...and loads of wrong notes

  • yup

  • overall very good for 17yrs old...intonation problems in areas. double stopping and chords in some areas problem. but bow tecnique and timing good.

    ermmm..there was just a slight problem in the cadenza...the shift at 08.27 - 08.28,terrible! and cadenza could do with being faster. but no enjoyed it,young talent is always good,and people will slate u for being young talent,believe me i know..iv been there,keep it up :)

  • cadenze by Franco.

  • Careful at that one shift I think you know which one. But otherwise it was really good.

  • aferin la kerata

  • Muy desafinado....

  • That was pretty good:)

    you sound better than i do

  • Pues se nota que Usted no entiende nada en esto ....

  • god they suck.

    im in high school and our orchestra is ten times better

  • i agree

  • I'm learning this solo now, and it sucks! I don't really like Mozart violin concertos, I prefer Haydn. But good job anyways. It does get old fast.

  • yea speaking of getting old... i played it like 5 years ago but i just brought it back because i felt like it... i like mozart better than haydn personally

  • I live near DEs Moines...is this orch a professional orchestra? I've never heard of this orchestra.

    anyway, I am doing this piece for a competition.

    Iowans rule!!!!!!

  • it's a community orchestra in AMES

  • ummm....this isn't bad....I don't know what everyone is talking about....but yeah....this is very good....even if there are a few wrong or flat notes. I commend you! I wish I could play this with an orchestra....maybe I will....I'm learning it right now? Do you want to attend a Conservatory?

  • probably not.. i didn't think it was that either though

  • first chair concert master moves like carzy

  • hey danielyp how did u get to perform this with a orchestra ?? reply back 2 me

  • terrible - phrasing, dynamics, TUNING !! Why dont u do a bit more practise

  • dude, chill. i suck. I didn't practice because I was sick of playing this because I already played this a long before this concert, and they rescheduled this to the day before my SATs, so I was pissed off and didn't care much about it

  • no offence, but for the cadenza, 2 of the chords are a little out. Also in the beginning the high D is kind of flat. Overall, a very good try =)

  • How old are you? It's pretty bad, don't you think? I guess you were really nervous or something, but your vibrato is fine so I guess..you were a little calm or something.

  • yea i know it's pretty bad.. i guess thats what happens when you stop taking lessons for 3 years

  • omg ... soz but it really sux.... ur technic ur music...omg...

  • i know

  • How old are you? I'm working on this right now and it sound almost identical. A few things I do better, however there are things that you do much better.

    Overall: good playing. Nice bow technique, vibrato, etc.

    Yea, community orchestras usually have fair intonation.

  • i played it 4-5 years ago and i brought it back after not taking lessons for like 2-3 years and i was just getting sick of playing this. i'm 17, but yea i lost a lot of my skills during that time i didn't take lessons

  • no strong

    no power

    no musician

  • daha ne kadar pis calabilirim diye zorlamis arkadas...

  • I agree with littlecelt.. you should practice more before the concert...

  • yea i probably would've practiced a little more if i wasn't sick of playing it; i played it like 4 years ago and just brought it back after not taking lessons for couple years, and they rescheduled the concert after a winter storm to couple weeks later so it's a day before my SATs

  • sounds nice but check out sum intonation problems :)

  • yea... this is a community orchestra/symphony... but it's still kinda "formal" i guess. but yea, can't blame them for intonation and etc.

  • Hey, next time make sure to get a better orchestra. Especially in the first tutti, there's a horrible intonation!!!

    Your imagination of Mozart is nice, but try to practice more before the concerto and what's more important, try to hit better ;) Some tones are not hit properly... Don't bang on the one that much and try to define legato notes better, then it would be very nice...

  • wow. that was good.

  • the cadenza would definately work better faster. it tends to drag on a bit. but good job! it's fantastic. :)

  • i mean, you look like aznmusicmaster

  • hey very nice, enjoyed that

  • thanks

  • you might want to speed up the cadenza some.

  • i had it faster, but my teacher told me to take it slow

  • whoa you look exactly like my sister

  • LOL

  • dude, you look like my brother...

  • you look a lot like my brother

  • your brother must be really cool

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more