@Abdelbaasit. Yes, the hadith in question is "weak" but I think that the way it has been used in this short discussion is valid since this video clip is on a matter relating to Fada'il. Thank you for providing the takhrij of the hadith. Baraka-Allah fik wa jazak khayran
أحبوا الله لما يغذوكم به من نعمه ، وأحبوني لحب الله
has a lot of problems in its chain of narration (and was therefore declare 'weak' by many scholars). See Abu Nu`aym in his "Hilyah Al-Awliyaa", 3/245. And Al-Khateeb Al-Baghdaadi said in his "Taareekh Baghdad", فيه أحمد بن رزقويه غير معروف عندنا والذراع لا تقوم بقوله حجة
Futhermore, in "Minhaaj As-Sunnah" (5/396), Ibn Taymiyah said: إسناد ضعيف . And Imaam Adh-Dhahabi said in his "Siyar A`laam An-Nubalaa`", غريب فرد & then in "Meezaan Al-I`tidaal" 2/432, Adh-Dhahabi said about this same hadeeth: فيه عبد الله بن سليمان النوفلي فيه جهالة
Also, Al-Albaani has declared the hadeeth ضعيف in "Da`eef Sunan At-Tirmidhi", and also in Muhammad Al-Ghazzali's "Fiqh As-Seerah", 20.
*However, it can be argued that the meaning of the "hadeeth" -- though it may not be authentic from the Prophet himself -- is correct and there is nothing wrong with it.
Wonderful response by the way, to the new Muslim :) :) ما شاء الله, الله يحفظك, أكثر الله من أمثالك
Masha'Allah. Thanks Shaykh! May God bless you and your household with Happiness in this world and akhira. Insha'Allah Ameen.
Pharmentist 11 months ago
@Abdelbaasit. Yes, the hadith in question is "weak" but I think that the way it has been used in this short discussion is valid since this video clip is on a matter relating to Fada'il. Thank you for providing the takhrij of the hadith. Baraka-Allah fik wa jazak khayran
uthman72 1 year ago
The "hadeeth of the Prophet" quoted at 0:37
أحبوا الله لما يغذوكم به من نعمه ، وأحبوني لحب الله
has a lot of problems in its chain of narration (and was therefore declare 'weak' by many scholars). See Abu Nu`aym in his "Hilyah Al-Awliyaa", 3/245. And Al-Khateeb Al-Baghdaadi said in his "Taareekh Baghdad", فيه أحمد بن رزقويه غير معروف عندنا والذراع لا تقوم بقوله حجة
abdelbaasit1 1 year ago
Futhermore, in "Minhaaj As-Sunnah" (5/396), Ibn Taymiyah said: إسناد ضعيف . And Imaam Adh-Dhahabi said in his "Siyar A`laam An-Nubalaa`", غريب فرد & then in "Meezaan Al-I`tidaal" 2/432, Adh-Dhahabi said about this same hadeeth: فيه عبد الله بن سليمان النوفلي فيه جهالة
Also, Al-Albaani has declared the hadeeth ضعيف in "Da`eef Sunan At-Tirmidhi", and also in Muhammad Al-Ghazzali's "Fiqh As-Seerah", 20.
abdelbaasit1 1 year ago
*However, it can be argued that the meaning of the "hadeeth" -- though it may not be authentic from the Prophet himself -- is correct and there is nothing wrong with it.
Wonderful response by the way, to the new Muslim :) :) ما شاء الله, الله يحفظك, أكثر الله من أمثالك
abdelbaasit1 1 year ago
Amazing masha'Allah.
What's that white book with the red border by the Sheik's soldier?
IbraheemPasha 2 years ago