Added: 10 months ago
From: IGNentertainment
Views: 482,366
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (6,630)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • where the hell is TheBadBuffalo's post

  • 9.5? then wats a 10?

  • @GuyOnTheInternet53 it's impossible because there's no such thing as perfect xD

  • Source engine is a very good engine even though it's old. The graphics are amazing and objects look very realistic.

  • @kevindegraaf2 I'm smart enough not to waste my money on an overpriced arcade game like you, dumbass

  • @all ppl who don't like this game.

    You're just dumb.

  • WoW, no falling damage?(x

  • @christopherrusch You have special boots which saves you from drops. The puzzles wouldn't work without them.

  • @christopherrusch Aperture invented long fall boots.

  • god damnit youtube commercials

  • @gamegloss Okay bu u know some big words u want an award?, and this is and never will be a real game when u compare to skyrim, arkham city and gta u realize portal 1 and 2 are just arcade games at the least

  • @Rbeals2012 play it and you'll shut up.

  • First video game I've ever played that made me laugh out loud, get mad (at the characters, not at difficulty), and be creeped out all at once.

  • 9.5 definitely, one of the best games I've ever played-but skyward sword gets a 10?!? No game is perfect, and this is better than skyward sword.

  • * twitches* either I say it wrong or,.................he BUTCHERED GLaDOS's name XD

  • @avaflava1

    You say it wrong.

  • This isn't even a real game haha

  • @Rbeals2012 It's one of the few games that can be considered to epitomise the medium.

    In other words, it ticks most of the boxes necessary to be considered a "perfect game", or a model of what video games can and should be.

    So your comment, "this isn't even a game", is hopelessly redundant. It's more of a game than most games. You don't have to enjoy it to appreciate its value, just like you don't have to enjoy Beethoven or Bach to appreciate that it is definitive music.

  • @Rbeals2012 Oh shut the hell up man, just by looking at portal 1 gameplay you judge this as the same?

    It's a game. Just because you cant get past level 2 dosent mean its not a game ;)

  • @AGentertainment portal got goty cause it runs well on all platforms. Skyrim didn't get it cause it's only good on pc. Plus U3 and skyward can't get it cause bein an exclusive.

  • Really different and unusual let's just say "weird" game here we see.

  • I don't understand why you guys are complaining. If you've actually heard this guys review of Portal 2, It has a quality which neither Skyward Sword nor Uncharted 3 give you; Portal 2 Makes you feel smart and gives you an unbelievable sense of completion.

  • Pussies are afraid of giving an exclusive game GOTY

    Uncharted 3 and Skyward Sword both got 10's

    Why couldn't one of those 2 win? Oh that's right, because Xbox 360 exclusive games didn't get a 10, so they're afraid of the loser xbox fanboys.

  • is the game worth it.?

  • batman arkem city should have won not this

  • @2thegamemaster Did you play this game?

  • mmmm Uncharted 3 and Zelda got 10 and they said this is the game of the year??? COME ON IGN

  • deserved game of the year... this is coming from someone who loves zelda but this is better

  • The clip at 4:17 pretty much ruined the whole review. A huge spoiler for the game

  • lol its not about the score that gives a game "game of the year". theres other things that factor it.

  • @AGentertainment Iwould agree that IGN are complete utter morons but there awards arent related to ratings.

  • Isn't it Glad-oh-s and not glad-aww-s

  • @Chongomonkey1234 its literally "Glad- os" (o as in orange)

  • @7pulford Well I was putting it in phonetic terms. I hate when people mispronounce things!

  • @Chongomonkey1234 lol, I should have clarified what I meant: There are two sounds for the letter "o", which sound like the "o" in Orange, or Obese, right? One is a short sound, the other long. Well I believe Gladdos is the first one: sounds similar to orange, obstacle, fox, operate, popular etc etc. ; )

  • Where can i get this game

  • Where can I get this

  • This game should get a 10

  • This game is better than battlefield 3 and modern warfare 3 I agree

  • cant wait to get live n play multiplayer online!

  • I WAS DOWNLOADING AND IT SAID 1 year till done I'm like WHAT???????

  • @Zambelimama you can pretty much just jump in, but it's still nice to play the cheap old portal 1 ;)

  • Should I play portal 1 first.... Please help I don't know what to to

  • @BLU3beatsY3LL0W I played the demo (from steam) And I just went on and got Portal 2 without getting/playing FULLY Portal 1, its still as fun, I think.

  • @BLU3beatsY3LL0W You should or watch a letsplay to get the story

  • I have a question do I have to play portal 1 to understand portal 2 or should I just jump in???

  • This game is flawless. 10/10

  • WOA! Huuuge spoiler 4:17

  • @Ayphen it is actually

  • @Ayphen Yes but people not knowing anything about portal 2 going into it will have no idea that it's a spoiler. So by telling everyone that its a spoiler they know its one and you just spoiled it for them.

  • @Ayphen He should say SPOILERS not POSSIBLE SPOILERS

  • I dont understand: this game got GOTY and yet games like U3, arkham city and many others got the same/higher score?

  • @jayso449 Its because everyone at ign votes on their favourite games to get a range of opinions, its not influenced by scores

  • IGN aren't idiots. They're actually smart because they know that they'll get more money from some developers if they give their games a high score.

  • He didn't say anything bad but it got a 9.5 instead of a of a 10

  • @megamike62098 "Short and lacks replay value"

  • @Psychroc oh yeah 

  • IGN

    Idiot

    Governed

    Nation

  • Skyward Sword receives a 10 but this game, with a lower score, receives game of the year from IGN.

    Typical IGN logic.

  • @AGentertainment GOTY is a team decision decided by all of IGN (right?) but this is one person's opinion.

  • @AGentertainment from what I understand, ratings given out to each game is left completely to the discretion of the reviewer, whereas GOTY titles are actually based on votes from many IGN Reviewers. Remember God Hand getting 3/10? That was the opinion of one reviewer. IGN still put God Hand in their top 100 PS2 games list. See what I mean?

  • @AGentertainment Ratings are relative. Zelda was compared to other Wii games and it deserved a ten compared to the other crap that came out on the Wii in 2011. Mario galaxy 2 got a ten in 2010 but didn't get GOTY either

  • @AGentertainment Thats not how it actually works, everyone at ign votes on goty, Its not decided with scores

  • @AGentertainment Skyward Sword was nowhere near a "Perfect Game" there were plenty of flaws

  • @SuperLuigiBros1 The point is that IGN's score system is meaningless if their 10, which designates MASTERPIECE, doesn't win Game of the Year over a game which only receives 9.5

    I made a video about this very matter and how their score system is meaningless, as well as not letting them influence what you think.

  • @AGentertainment Well it's pretty stupid because both Portal 2 and Skyward sword got all +'s so it was unfair to give Portal 2 a 9.5 which, according to IGN, was flawless

  • @AGentertainment It got a 9.5 from IGN same as this game skyward sword and uncharted 3 goit a 10

  • @AGentertainment

    >Zelda

    >good game

    no.

  • @narutoLT Next time, write a sentence. I'm not a damn robot.

  • @AGentertainment its probably cause skyward sword didn't work great on all consoles but portal 2 does. Its kinda like U3 , scored 10/10 buts only on ps3

  • @AGentertainment They are reviewed by different people all of the time.

  • @AGentertainment Different reviewers

  • @AGentertainment Despite that, i still think that skyward sword deserved a 10

  • @AGentertainment skyward sword sucks shit

  • @DaDevilWorshipper Wow you're pretty stupid. Proof? Your username.

  • @TheBadBuffalo no im pretty smart

  • @DaDevilWorshipper Smart people don't brag about their intelligence.

  • @TheBadBuffalo yes they do

  • @DaDevilWorshipper But that's being rude, and rudeness and definitely not a good thing. (I'm trying to be as nice as possible, and I'm trying to not explode with anger)

  • @TheBadBuffalo ok dud chill, i was just joking. I was just bored :)

  • @DaDevilWorshipper Did you see Einstein brag about his intelligence? Nope, in fact, he said of himself that he was dumb.

  • @AGentertainment Just cause it got a 10 means it gets GOTY right?

    Right, dumbass?

    Typical 13 year old logic. Don't bother telling me you're some older man in college with a job or anything, just look back at your comment and wonder if it was worth the attention you wanted.

  • @AGentertainment I'm convinced that all Standard 3D Zelda games get 10/10s, since games like Super Mario Galaxy get close to 10s, without any reasons why they're not 10s.

  • @AGentertainment Well, Skyward Sword I must say is a really great game though. IGN giving Mario Galaxy 2 a 10 was a bit odd if you ask me.

    I still think they should have given this game a higher rating, however. Portal 2 is by far one of my most favourite games of all time.

  • @AGentertainment maybe because ign isn't just ONE person doing all the reviews, whats that thing called again... oh yeah a range of opinion

  • That really should of been a 10

  • I used to play Portal 2, then I took a bad video card driver to the knee.

    True story.

  • @FreakE93 look around you. Has there been anybody saying that this game is bad? No so get your ass to a store and buy this game!

  • Should I get this? I really want a great single player game for ps3. Does it have any replay value? This is probably one of the few games I will play for a while. I wonder if I'm better off doing something like Skyrim...

  • I just finished Portal 2 and came here to weave a big and thought out comment. Screw it, this game is just too good. I LOOOOOOOOOOVE PORTAL 2 !!! HELL YEAH ! GAME OF THE YEAR INDEED !

  • I just finished playing Portal 2 and came here to make a big thought out comment.

    Well, screw that, I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE PORTAL !

  • Funny how this game only got a 9.5 and won GOTY. I think Legend of Zelda got a 10. I'm not saying that it should have won. I never played it before don't own a wii. I'm just pointing out that these reviews may not be all the factors for what they choose as the best game of the year.

  • I remember all the Jackasses that complained about Wheatley having a different actor, go onto old Portal 2 videos and read the comments, what morons.

  • @locarinaoftimeDN I thought the game was visually stunning, even though i got it after playing Crysis, Crysis 2 and Battlefield 3.

  • i hate how he cant say GLaDOUS right haha

  • @Lilfish43 You can't spell it right lol

  • @MrSingingPizza OH NO I PUT A U RAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

  • @Lilfish43 Its alright. We can put our differences behind us. For science. (You monster).

  • @Lilfish43 Well you cant exacly spell it

  • @Sillywomanproduction you have confused me

  • @Lilfish43 You say he cant say it right but you cant spell it

  • this game is so easy. I played through in one week

  • @ATTV98 I played threw MW3 in a day!

    this took me 5 days!

    buy this!

  • I feel smarter when i play this game

  • amazing game is amazing

  • what failed it with the 0.5 minus from 10? I played and did not find a single flaw nor glitch.

  • @theevil090 plenty of flaws with the story, especially at the end.

  • @555usdollars For example? No, really, I'm curious.

  • 263 people didn't get to go to SPAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAACE

  • when portal 3 comes out i wanna play as chelle ...even if i walk through wheat feilds for 8 hours

    lmao

  • i fust beat the first game for the first time MOVING ON!

  • AWESOME FUCKING GAME... ON MY 2ND TIME THRU

  • @downwitursyztem Just because you arent getting triple kill streaks and headshots doesnt mean it cant be amazing.

  • @downwitursyztem it's different. you have to play it to get the essence of it. i was skeptical too, and i thought it was just a boring puzzle game. but after playing it, I found out why this game is so popular. Its because its fun, funny, and not another fucking call of duty

  • @SMG2fanatic lol. true story. i think im just gonna try it out for myself then and see whats the big thing about it. thanks for the resonse bruh!

  • @downwitursyztem no prob

  • this game is overrated

  • @ROCKSTAR378 Because your parents won't buy you it?

  • @ROCKSTAR3788 just like your mom

  • @ROCKSTAR3788 this game is underrated.

  • @legorocks3 something 1000th

  • Is portal 2 fun on PS3 as well?

  • @aleksanderlj I've never played it on the PS3, but why would it be any different?

  • @B00m3r38

    I was just thinking that you need to move your charecters head fast around in portal, and you move faster on pc than on PS3. Soooo... Is it?

  • @aleksanderlj No, there's not much platforming and when there is you can move your head fast enough. Answering your question, yes this game is extremely fun no matter what platform you play it on. I extremely recommend this game.

  • @B00m3r38

    Thanks :D i've played the first one on computer and i think that it's a great game, but i don't think my computer can run portal 2, so thanks for answering :)

  • @warheadsteel7 Exactly

  • 9.5??? it should be 10!!!

  • evolution of turrets. just a huge lie created by turret satan.

  • goty ....WTF

  • @bai3283 what do you mean WTF?

  • got to play this, nough said. :D

  • IGN I HATE YOUR FUCKING VIDEO PLAYER ON YOUR HOME PAGE

  • there wont be a portal 3, because valve cant count to 3...

  • @ThoseWhoGame There CAN be Portal 2: Episode 1

  • @ThoseWhoGame HA! HAHAHAHA! very well crafted.

  • @ThoseWhoGame Awd otn be mean to VALVe... :)

  • GAME OF THE YEAR! there better be some more dlc

  • @EPICJAMBOREE theres going to be a dlc with an in game map editor as well as a way to share and download them online

  • In my view, Skyrim deserved GOTY. Though this game is good, it is one of those games that once you finished it - thats it. Overall, more work was put into Skyrim, from the detailed world to even the dialogue. Hundreds of hours were spent on it to make the great game it is. IGN, you have to take more thought into GOTY awards

  • @warheadsteel7

    I can't see any reason to agree with you.

  • @warheadsteel7

    As you stated that is your view (opinion) just because a game is shorter does not make it easier to make, I would say that portal 2 would have been harder to develop than skyrim because of how they have to make challenging but not frustrating puzzles (making the puzzles is harder than solving them). skyrim had more dialogue but it was no were near portal 2 level (I've fin it 3x). and don't forget the ever growing amount of user created portal 2 maps from sdk. both great games tho

  • I love this game I want more!!

  • Thumbs up if you're watching this because it was IGN's GOTY

  • @GNRlova23 It was? Good, at least it wasn't Skyrim for the 50th time

  • skyrim is more overrated

  • HOW THE FUCK THIS GOT GOTY!!!!!!!

  • @ZAINTHEGAMER skyrim or skyward sword deserved goty not portal (even though portal is great).nough said

  • @Vrockstech i totally agree but i think uc3 also deserve the goty

  • Id never heard of this before now. Think id still get frustrated. LIL my girl and I have enuf trouble with little big planet as it is. Haha

  • Is Ur Main Cgaracter a human?

  • GOOD, BUT NOT GOTY.

  • congrats ign goty

  • I didn't really like Portal or Portal 2. Well I enjoyed Portal more because it was just a simple puzzle game, but I didn't love it. I think people blew this stuff out of proportion for Portal 2 because I just hated it. Everybody said it was so good but when I played it my eyebrow was raised constantly at the story and the levels. BUT the puzzles were nice, but if I were to say just open Portal 2 up to see what made it tick I'd just find Portal with a pretty dumb story imo.

  • I felt so weird after finishing Portal 2. So happy about the game but so sad Portal is ending :/

  • they should make a portable version on Apple and Android

  • is this game good

  • @aguilaralbert are you kidding me its amazing

  • i knew cave sounded familiar its fuckin jameson!

  • HUGE SPOILERS!!

  • Do want

  • I don't know why I sold this... now I want it again...

  • Solid performance? I don't want solid, I want pictures. PICTURES OF SPIDERMAN!

  • Can you have local play? I mean does anyone play this online anymore??

  • @Guitarfollower22 yep but probably want friends with a mic

  • @Guitarfollower22 You're just gonna be playing with friends, so yeah.

  • I'd give this game the same score. The only thing holding it back IMO is the fact it has no replay value.

  • i cant find where you can built ur own levels

  • @NYballer11725

    Inside steam your need to go to the "Tools" section. And find the Portal 2 Authroing Tools Beta. You should have added in the installation process. If you haven't do so, it only takes a few seconds. Then go find a tutorial online.

  • @SnowfireGames Thanks!!!