Added: 4 years ago
From: dombower
Views: 180,880
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (269)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Awesome review, thanks!

  • hey dom a cuestion what name or code that  sigma use for call the pro line "APO" "DG" or or God knows what?

  • @hanzeln that would be EX, for excellence. but its not always true to tell the truth

  • @dombower "MASTER you LIGHT ME UP!! "but its not always true to tell the truth" golden words a pearl of knowledge .... ;) ommmmm little apprentice say Thx maSTA!!! ommmmm

  • Well i have just bought this lens,so thank you for this review as i think i have made the right choice

    {"_*}

  • hey mate what would you suggest the best lens for taking video on a canon 60d

  • @PuffSmelly 50mm 1.4 amazingly sharp!

  • Erm ur wrong. the tokina 12-24 F4 DOES have filter thread. if not my filter wun be screwed in.

  • @technoglitz87 yep my mistake

  • great and long video :9 thank you ...I will buy this great lens next month *__* !

  • Sorry if I sound noob, but I plan to use UWA lens for landscapes purpose and using the f/2.8 aperture won't give the shallow depth of field? Usually, I will use f value around f/8 till f/16.

  • @antonioreyes1987 eh? f/2.8 gives you a very shallow depth of field, i think you mean deep depth of field….

    if you are shooting landscape and you are using a uwa lens anything beyond about 3 meters from your camera will be at a hyperfocal distance so everything will be in focus no matter what the aperture.

  • @dombower Thanks for the prompt reply. So, do you think that the Tokina 11-16mm is the best UWA lens for APS-C camera?

  • I do like this lens but it doesn't seem to focus correctly on my Canon 450D. I might have to send it to the manufacturer.

  • Thanks for the info, my heads been spinning looking at so many lenses!

  • Hi Dom! Thank you so much for this review! I've been looking for a great wide angle lense for my Canon Rebel T1i with inexpensive price. I will definitely get this lense because of your review. Goodluck and more power!!!

  • where r u from i cant recognise ur accent. north england-wales?

  • @2009korte

    he's scottish

  • @stroma1988

    i see

  • where abouts did you find this lens so cheap? im wanting a canon fit, and for any model fit i can only find around £350?

  • nice review!

  • glare, flare, ush, hsm lol its just bullshit terms and patents

  • I have had one of these on my Nikon for sometime its a good value lens definitely not up to the Tokina standard but for the price and with a little bit of post processing its very expectable

  • is this lens good for taking a photo of you and a friend by holding it out infront of you?

  • @Kassie15soccer hahahahahaha this is an expensive lens for only wanting to have for facebook and myspace pics. . . .

  • great review! Thank you, gonna buy one =)

  • so you can put a Filter on it? 

  • Love your accent.

  • good video, can you tell me where to buy this lens at a good price?

  • i had to choose between this or the nikon 12-24mm f/4 . Got me the nikkor and never looked back.

  • great review

  • Good review,

    but I won't buy another Sigma lens. Had one years ago for a couple of hours and sent it back immediately. Focusing in low light was a big problem. That was years ago. Just today I checked a friend of mine's Sigma lens on his Canon 60D. He was complaining of the same problem.

    I'd prefer to pay double and get the real Canon lens. But that's just me.

  • I had this lens, used it for skate / Bmx photography. Then it got stolen along with my flashgun :( well worth a go especially if you can pick it up for £285

  • wow it was gr8 n very useful information thx for sharing

  • Which one you recommend Dom? TOKINA 11-16mm or SIGMA 10-20mm?

  • @Cybercreeps i'm not dom but i would strongly recommend you get the tokina if you have not bought one already.

  • @jugadeez I wonder why the tokina? is it about the sharpness or something else.... very appreciate the reply.. thank you. :)

  • When I'm in a dark room, the shutter speed is very slow and doesnt pick up on too much light at all even with an ISO at say 1600. Any way I can get some better lighting?

  • @Jespatrimorra either use flash or alternativly get a tripod and dont worry about the slow shutterspeeds.

  • @Jespatrimorra

    sure turn on the lights

  • @Jespatrimorra

    also underexpose as the metering trying to compensate for average.

  • @Jespatrimorra do you even know how to use a camera you moron

  • Quick question, did you find that the auto selection caused the flash to hit the top of the lense causing a shadow effect? I did, and brought it in to the camera store I bought these items at and they basically said to adjust the ISO to a higher sensitivity to pick up more light without the need of the flash. I'm new to camera terms, I don't know the depth of them but I can operate the ISO and minor basic features.

  • I tried e-mailing you. Here's my message:

    Hey Dom,

    I had to buy the D80 today, used, for a nice price since my D50 ran out of life and needed servicing. Anyhow, I bought the Sigma 10-22mm lense as well. We do custom stairs and railings so aside from our 2 other lenses, this wide angle will work nicely for our shots.

  • tokina 11-16mm or sigma 10-20mm

  • IS IT A SHARP LENS ??

  • will the lens work on a canon camera?

  • watch 0:55 a couple times in a row :)

  • is this lens compatible with my Canon 550D? Thanks

  • Hi Dom, This is probably a stupid question but will it fit a Nikon D90?

    Cheers!

  • @dombower

    Cheers!

  • nickon...

  • which is better, 10-20 3.5 or 10-20 4-5.6

  • @jidee1 having a constant aperture is always beneficial

  • @jidee1 it depends what you're shooting. if you shoot landscapes, you're going to be at f/11 or so anyways.

  • hi Dom! i have a question: i got this lens and turned out to be a bad copy. the quality was even worse than the kit lens that came with my Rebel Xs. now i am again reconsidering which one of the UWA to buy. what really matter for me is really good image quality and really good performance at around f4, because i like to shoot star trails a lot. which one out of the canon, sigma, tokina or tamron would you suggets me? thank you! C:

  • Love this lens, I use it for both video and photo. Nice review.

  • I bought this lens (F4-5.6) about 2 years ago and its now part of my "walk-around kit". I have had some issues with flare during night shots, but because of the wide angle of the lens, its impossible (almost) to miss any bright street lights etc. Mostly I shoot riverside, coastal & woodland shots, with shipping and heavy plant & machinery thrown in there as well. The lens works very well on my Sony a350. Awesome review :)

  • this would suit a nikon d5000?

  • Learn how to hold your camera first

  • @Mozo901 tell me where does he hold camera wrong...

  • @Mozo901 If that remark was aimed at Dom I would take a look at his channel and see the amount of pro shoots he has done and the work that has been comissioned from him by lucrative customers.

    If it was not aimed at him but someone else you need to "learn" how to reply clearly and efficiently to whomever you are aiming your comment at.!

  • Also where can you find it at £280 onwards? I cant seem to find it that low :P

  • @dombower I understand it's primarily for scenic shots, but as an alrounder lens does it give out good medium length portraits? In a studio etc.

    *From one Dom to another* :)

  • @luckyd0m Not sure if Dom answered your question or if you've found out the answer by yourself already, but in any case, an ultrawide lens is not suited to half-length portraits. Or portraits in general. Maybe (just maybe) some full length portraits if you're getting down low. It distorts perspective and accentuates the distance between foreground and background. A decent portrait lens for half-length (a bit too short for headshots) would be a nifty fifty :). (50 1.8 / 1.4) on Aps-C or even FF.

  • HI Roy from Ireland, Great video. I am looking for some advice. I am slowly (when i have the money) putting together a selection of good lens for my Canon 7D. I have the Sigma you showcased as well as a Tamron 70-200mm 1:2.8. What lens would you recommend to compliment the above mentioned lenses, I could use for city breaks (e.g. shooting people, moving cars, some nice buildings, that sort of thing). A small aperature number at about 20/25 metres range, or so. Ask me any question to clarify.

  • Favorite lens I own! 

  • Hey Dom great video im really looking into getting this lens could you tell me where you saw it the cheapest I know you mentioned seeing it under £300 somewhere in this video

  • @lukeMcGowann cheapest place i've found online for a lens is simply electronics. i've saved £200 on the tokina 12-24mm mk 2 compared to somewhere like jacobs. only downside of this seller is, if your looking for it next day, unless you pay extra on postage, expect to wait at least 7 working days for the lens to get to you, and if you message asking where your package is. dont expect anything more than a standard computer generated reply

  • f22 is minimal aperture not maximal mr reviewer ;)

  • hi whats the best lense for wedding photography for my nikon d3000

  • Hi Dom, have you tried the Sigma 8-16mm and what are your thoughts?

  • send it to meeee pleaseee ;]

  • Hey Dom,

    what do you think of the new Sigma 10-20mm 3.5? Is it worth getting or get the Tokina AT-X 124 AF PRO DX II AF 12-24mm?? cheers dude! Rob

  • @rob888uk tokina has no hsm or afs so you need a body that has a motor.  best go have a play with both in a shop and see which one you like the most

  • Bought one today for my Canon 7D. Great lens, very robust and firm. I was expecting a more plasticy feel so I'm positively surprised.

  • Do you like Tokina 11-16mm over this lens? I'm planning to buy one of these lenses but not too sure which one I should get.

    Thanks for the video

  • What a brilliant review have been looking around for a wide angle for my Pentax K20D this looks it will be at the top of the list,

    Really good presentation and kept my attention thoughout will view again many thanks .

    Now all I have to do is the last part go and find one at arund that price

  • Hi, Would you recommend this over the Tokina 12-24mm? Which one do you think is better? Right now I have a 20mm prime but it is not wide enough in some cases because of the dx crop. Thanks.

  • i got a question: so, i have a canon eos 450d and i want/have to take pictures for some commercial thing and the pictures have to be taken of rooms so i dont want to use photoshop to merge the images together, so my question is: is the quality got and would you recommend the lens for that type of photography (ofcourse with using a tripod)

  • @Froopish this single lens is around 500 pounds, if it didnt take good pictures on a tripod then why would anyone buy it?

  • What do you think of the Sigma 8-16. Have you (or anyone else) used that lens?

  • Hello Dom, very nice review specially if you're not a pro which is my case :)

    So I want to buy a wide angle lens for my nikon d60 but I can't really chose between this one or the tamrom SP AF10-24mm F/3.5-4.5 Di-II LD Aspherical [IF].

    I'll mostly fotograph architecture and I read that the tamrom has less barrel distortion and it's also sharper however sigma is worldwilde used and people seem to be pretty happy with it.

    Can I get your advise? thanks

  • Use the Tamron 10-24 3,5-4,5 !!!!!

  • Just curious will this lens work with the Nikon D60? It seems that not much will work with this model Nikon??? I am very interested in a wide or ultra wide lens could you shed some lite on this (I would be doing some wedding and landscape photography with)? Thanks I love your videos they are very informational!! Keep them coming

    Regards, Melissa

  • im buying this lens soon for my nikon d5000

  • @Kara899 same

  • @illuzn88 sweet =) im buying it this weekend

  • Hey Dom, What type of dropin filter system can you use with this? I think you have a Cokin 4x6 drop in system in one of your other reviews... Does the Cokin Z-Series filter system work with this lens? Or do you simply hand-hold the filter flush with the lens while you take a 'landscape photo'? I cannot figure out what filter system I can use that will not have a vignetting effect. :(

  • Good review mate :) was worth watching

  • holy crap thats a fast lens!!!!!

  • should I get the nikon 10-24mm or the sigma? thanks!!

  • @ dombower would this be a good lens to get for close up action photography, like skateboarding. or what other alternatives would there be

  • @killiandarcy42023 close up action photography..... thats a difficult one... ie you can have a long telephoto so it looks like you are more close up, you could have a macro so you could get close up or you could have a wide angle so you can be close but still have the whole scene. or a fish eye. impossible question to answer

  • Thanks for that... what would you say about this VS the tamron 10-24? I want to get one soon... but can't decide it's driving me a little insane.

  • Thank you very much!

  • Hi Domb would you help me which wide angle lens is better for my D90, between sigma 10-20mm or Tokina 11-16mm?

  • @DBOATYZ if i said the tokina is better but it cost an extra 300dolla, what would you go for?

  • @dombower Hi,u've done good video so far.anyway i'm beginner Nikon D300s & i plan2 buy some lenses 2 serve many purposes(wild angle&zoom lens with nice supper blur background). one by one i going to buy fist nikon 18-200 vrII(for beginning learn), then Tokina 11-16(after i review ur) wild angle4 interior building,then the last one Nikon70-200(delivering nice blurred background for portraits f2.8).between nikon18-200&70-200,should i've both or just only one, if so which one u will recommend?

  • i smiled when you took the photos!

  • @macgamer22 nice comment to get blocked straight away.

  • great review! Also i love ur pictures.. :)

  • How are the Sigma lens next to the Nikon lens. I used to use Minolta lens a 28-85 and the Nikon zoom lens 35-105 was a lot sharper lens.

  • great lens I love it.

  • How did you take a picture into my bedroom!?

  • Hi Doom.i've got a Nikon D700 full frame camera and i m doing landscape photo and interior photograph, and what do you suggest ?Tokina 12-24mm f4 or This Sigma lens 10-20. Thanks Doomm.

  • The focusing was a lot faster than I though though. I think it's even faster than my EF 28-80mm USM for my old SLR.... XD

  • i like my canon 10-22 but imo the next lens i would buy after the canon for a wide would be the tokina 11-16 2.8 not the sigma

  • I used this for a couple of years now and I love it. It's good quality and reliable. The only drawback (very rarely) is that its not the fastest lens in the box. But for this price and quality who can complain. Would NOT hesitate buying it again.

  • the widest lens i know of in terms of viewing is the 12-24 on a full frame

    15 vs 12

    10x 1.5

    12X 1

  • @ThePismoPat thats odd, the 12-24 is a dx lens meaning it is only for the cropped sensor,

    sure youwere not meaning the 14-24 lens?

  • @dombower the tokina 11-16 when zoomed in to 15 works on a full frame camera though. so when i go frull frame i wont be spending the fortune for the 14-24 lens

  • You are just like.... AWSOME!! :D

  • Great review! Im getting one in 2 days. Cheers!

  • now i have one ^_^ fells good in hand

  • I am looking at getting the Sigma 10-20mm f/3.5 or f4-5.6. I am not sure if the difference is worth the extra $230. Any opinion on this. I was using the lens in wedding photos.

  • When it hunts for the focus, it is a bit loud. Im speaking as if I were to be using this on my T1i's video recording capabilities. I tend to run-in to this problem becaus the mic is right by the lens. I use Tamron's 18-270 on my dslr and a great way to avoid that, I've found, was to simply use manual focus at your own speed. Thus quieting the friction sounds.

  • Dom,

    Thanks for the review, just picked one up, very nice lens (in the sub $500 range)

  • Sooo...your video just stopped about half of its range.. sooo....nice review. Sooo..thank u!!!

  • oh gosh i want one

    so much money though

    about 700 dollars here in canada

  • Cracking lens, and a very good review

  • I use this goal for over a year, really good

    search lo_straniero on flickr

  • glare is very strong light that shows in some materials, such as mirrors or glass. "lens-flare" you get when you expose your camera-lens to that strong light, i don't know why :P but that's the difference i think. glare = strong light, flare = the round things made up when exposing the lens to that glare.

  • will this autofocus with a d3000?

  • yes it will, It works on all Nikon DX camera, because it uses HSM. Which also means it got inbuild motor

  • i am looking to get this lens for a 20 days trip to Europe.. any thoughts?

  • @JJtheJaxartosaurus should be good.

  • do you choose

    Sigma 10-20

    tokina 11-16

    Tokina 12-24

    Nikon or tamron???

  • well i chose sigma then i got the tokina 11-16 which is the best

  • £280? I was given this for free because no one was using it. !WIN!

    The lens is made for APS-C chips, so shouldn't it be close to true 10-20mm?

  • Comment removed

  • I just purchased this lens, I'm not at all concerned about the 4.0 at the widest end because I plan to stop down to F22 for the sharpest images possible (greatest DOF), why use a wideangle unless you want a wide DOF? unless you're doing cheesy portraiture.

  • at f22 you wont have the sharpest images, the glass starts suffering from diffraction which lowers quality. it optimal range is f8-11. also if anything is more than a couple of meters away f5 will be reaching the hyperfocal range so no need to stop down further for wider depth of field.

  • I shouldn't have used the word sharpest. What I mean is generally greatest DOF for landscape.

  • @tylershoemakeri I think you need to read some books before buying any lens.

  • or some magazines. Dof is... wait I did a video on it. have a check.

  • sure wish this lens was a 2.8 :C lol

  • check out the tokina 11-16mm then

  • 285GBP where??? pls link :-)

  • cheers dom very thorough ......does it wor on ff cameras

  • Comment removed

  • I have had this lens for a couple of years on a Canon 20D and I think it is fantastic. I hardly use my canon L series lenses now!

  • Great review Dom, thank you ☺

  • I want this lens for Christmas. Will it work on the Nikon D90?

  • yep. ive got that combo, its really nice, not as sharp as tokina 11-16 but thats only if you look into the pictures pretty damn close.

    i think Jacobs are stocking it at £389, and not sure if this is still on but there may be 3year warranty on EX lenses from Sigma

  • You have such a nice camera and you even know that? Buy a book of photography for christmas.

    Peace.

  • This lens is no good for full frame sensors.

  • Not strictly true - it can be used with little/no vignetting from around 11-12mm

  • whats it like, in low light?

  • @Haruhide86 difficult to see. being black and all that. bet turn your llights on if your trying to find it in your room

  • i dont get it?

  • Thank you! I guess Im gonna buy it!

    =)

  • does it work on d60?

  • yea it does.

  • yes i just bought it for mine

  • That's almost 500 USD. Wow.

    Photography is an expensive hobby. Thanks for the video!

  • dombower - wer do you buy ur stuff from off the internet

    thanks

  • yer dom same question, cheapest i can find is £350

  • @davidimon em its prob more expensive due to echange rates now. 350 is an awezome price now

  • does this work of canon models?

  • yeah think so.

  • such a helpful tutorial

    im asking for this for christmas!

  • thanks for the tutorial. I got the 10-20mm f3.5 EX DC

  • hey, im a newbie at cameras and i only just purchased the Canon G10 and i do know i cant get extra lenses like u can for SLRs but apparently theres a telephoto lense!

    Is there any point of me getting it?

  • Hey Dom Great reviews and howtos as always. I was wondering if you have tried lensbaby products. Is it good?

  • tried one in a shop, thought it made some funny looking images but not wanting to spend 200 pounds on somethng which is that much of a novelty. rather make images like that afterward in phothshop/gimp

  • I see. 200 pounds? wow lensbaby is expensive. You are right. I can blur the backgrounds using gimp tnx to your Howtos. Tnx Dom.

  • GREAT VIDEOS Mr. Bower! I been anticipating on a video of Sigma 70-200mm 2.8 HSM II any comment on that?

  • em still super unsure. but i did see the sigma 50-150 f2.8 for 450 pounds in a second hand shop in edinburgh and am a bit tempted with that.... but probibly not

  • gear porn !

    this lens for me was only so so, sharp but its a bit of a toy the barrel distortion is really nasty in my opinion.

    Its a good lens but it really was not for me, I also find that sigma lenses do not deliver in terms of colour and contrast as much as canon, zeiss and nikon lenses !

  • Thank you very much, you said all the things that I need to know about this lens .

  • Very well done. Thanks for taking the time to help all who need it.

  • Thanks for a very informative review. Ignore those stupid comments, this was worth watching!

    By the way, a glare is what you see with the human eye, a flare is the what you see through a lens. The resulting effect is pretty much the same. :)

  • hey ..great review..i m planing to buy sm wideangle lens nd m stuck betwn this one nd nikon 10-20mm..which one is bettr?? nikon is F3.5-4.5..a lil faster..