@HaistaPaska92 It's playable but i have to keep my left hand flat. My guitar isnt cut below the neck so you cant access 15 and 17 without pulling your thumb our from below the neck
@RealKengeki with enough practice you can stretch the ring finger to the 15th fret without moving your thumb, the bend is quite tricky but still doable. And this solo doesn't go below the 15th fret. The second solo is a different matter altogether
Hi Justin. Thanks for doing this video. This is one of my favorite solos. Quick question. The 7th fret to 9th hammer-on pulloff at 4:44. Is that a 16th note triplet and then regular 8th notes on the a's and e's? I just started playing guitar, but have been playing the drums for 9 years. It is a litte bit difficult making the adjustment keeping time on a guitar. Any suggestions?
I'd just like to say thanks....... to you justin, for all your hard work you put in for all of us learning guitar. I and others really, really appreciate this so much and are very gratefull....................
All I see is rosewood and frets, and you don't really over-talk this one. I have to say that this is a great job. I have commented on a few of your other "Less-Good" vids and suggested a job...well, just like this??? And you were, shall we say less than grateful for the suggestion last time. But hey I don't care if your rude as a person, as long as you turn on the great close up less talk vids like this. Again great job here. Feel free to say something classy like last time if it helps you.
dude, i went on your site. those publishing basterds... they threatened to sue him unless he removed the tabs for the songs so that they could make a few extra $. don't they realise that we can get the tabs elsewhere...
could some one tell which key is this in and over what chord this solo is being played ? i think its minor pentatonic but what chord those notes that we play for the very first lick are member of ?
are u sure? it seems to me (im just an intermediate blues minor pentatonic learner) that the first lick (@2:20) is part of a F# chord by looking at the bend he is making. the first note he uses to introduce the lick is also F# .. any thoughts ?
Great job Justin, I think we should remember that not even Gilmour played the exact same notes all the time. That is why we have different versions, if you listen to Hendrix play, His music changed from concert to concert, depending on how he felt. As long as we get fairly close people will know what the song is.
WOW..I play guitar only four months and Justin taught me this in only one hour..well it isn´t sound perfect and I have only accoustic guitar but this is so awesome..thanx alot..
they are simple...you must not really study other solos...compare this to led zeppelin or kiss or clapton and you will see that gilmours solos are the easiest to transcribe and play...
yea ofcourse lol. But it isn't true that they are the easiest to play... That are solo's like smells like teen spirit... This has a lot of feeling in it and you realy have to make sure the bends are right etc... It's slow and easy, but playing it exactly right isn't as easy as it looks...
true but bends are in every good solo.... what i meant by my comment saying that gilmours solos are the easiest to transcribe and play was that gilmours solos are the easiest out of the list of bands that i mentioned....i didnt mean he has the easiest solos ever...lol...but when people want to learn solos i always say start to transcibe solos from pink floyd or zz top because they are really easy to hear and their solos are based on basic guitar scales....
Yea that's true. And most solo's are basic guitar scales... But the details in this, there is more on guitar then fretting the right frets you know :p
yea thats what i said :D If you think gilmore is easy to play, you're totaly wrong xd This might be slow but evry detail has to be right or it sounds terrible. In fast solo's you can even play a wrong note and don't hear it...
"Justin" you have actually excelled your self this time. Hope you got as much enjoyment from making these lessons, as i am getting out every second of them. HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY TOP THIS ONE. *********
You are a wonderful teacher and give us all great lessons nevertheless this one is not up to your standard. It's rushed and sloppy, not up to your standards.
Come on! Give the man a break he is probably busy but still takes the time to put this up for free. He says you have to listen to the song yourself a lot of times to really get the Gilmour tricks.
"I love this song. It's great that you've done this lesson Justin. I would like to watch it over and over again, but I'm helping Brendan with your new Begginers Course! So take care, I'll go and translate another bit :) Cheers
justin ur a legend bud, what a great surprise it was to login and find lessons dedicated to this awesome awesome track, i spent ages learning these solos and now cant wait to watch ur vids and polish up on my mistakes, thx mate.
2nd solo (part 1) is uploading now... part 2 of it is still compressing in Final Cut, so that will be a while yet I'm afraid. Then I have to edit the chord video, and then scan in the tabs and make the web pages. Been a nightmare doing all this and taken all day! :) So you better like it, or I'll set my cat onto you :) ha ha
I wish - Jedi only edits stuff for things that are going to DVD, he did the beginners course cos that is going onto DVD, but otherwise I do all the editing and web pages and all that...
bravissimo
dantes1964 1 week ago
Thanks alot mate
skaterboy077 2 months ago
Damn it I can't wait to get an electric to play this on.
My acoustic guitar doesn't even have access to frets past 14, it's pretty impossible.
RealKengeki 3 months ago
@RealKengeki I can play this solo on an acoustic
HaistaPaska92 2 months ago
@HaistaPaska92 It's playable but i have to keep my left hand flat. My guitar isnt cut below the neck so you cant access 15 and 17 without pulling your thumb our from below the neck
RealKengeki 2 months ago
@RealKengeki with enough practice you can stretch the ring finger to the 15th fret without moving your thumb, the bend is quite tricky but still doable. And this solo doesn't go below the 15th fret. The second solo is a different matter altogether
HaistaPaska92 2 months ago
Proud to say this is the first solo I just learned to play! :')
TheAmbitioned 3 months ago
@TheAmbitioned good for you bro :)
Keegan3005 3 months ago
Hey you-Justin
id just like to say thanks alot for all of your lessons
ive been learning from you for over a year now and ive progressed very much thanks to you
we really need more people like u in this world
peace brother.
PinkGilmourFloyd 6 months ago
lets talk effects?
ryank1esko 7 months ago
you are my fucking hero ! aweosme guy ! cool ! funny as shit! love you
Suley52 8 months ago
Hi Justin. Thanks for doing this video. This is one of my favorite solos. Quick question. The 7th fret to 9th hammer-on pulloff at 4:44. Is that a 16th note triplet and then regular 8th notes on the a's and e's? I just started playing guitar, but have been playing the drums for 9 years. It is a litte bit difficult making the adjustment keeping time on a guitar. Any suggestions?
lpr5269 10 months ago
Comment removed
radiohm3 11 months ago
Gilmour is the only reason I bought a Fender Stratocaster
radiohm3 11 months ago
@radiohm3 Me too.
tteu123 5 months ago
awsome job fella...great tutorials....
nice showbiz name too.
JustinJamesUK 1 year ago
at last!!! i knew it!! not all justin likes crap music :D
MARK0TAKER 1 year ago
I'd just like to say thanks....... to you justin, for all your hard work you put in for all of us learning guitar. I and others really, really appreciate this so much and are very gratefull....................
rhondaw1 1 year ago
i'm a begginer and i want to play this fantastic song by pink floyd...but without justin i can't do it....thank you very much...you're fantastic
andra28ful 1 year ago
humm ?; new guitar ?
whitewidow1981 1 year ago
exelent my friend
cirotiziano 1 year ago
im glad that somebody can actually teach, rather than just playing it in slo motion. well done
xXLIVE4THEMOMENTXx1 1 year ago
hi i have a few question,s what type of gear did you use? and second what gauge strings are u using 8 or 9? btw nicely done you are a great teacher.
darkarchon777 1 year ago
good job . . .
gilmoure is one of the best . . .
nbiok 1 year ago
All I see is rosewood and frets, and you don't really over-talk this one. I have to say that this is a great job. I have commented on a few of your other "Less-Good" vids and suggested a job...well, just like this??? And you were, shall we say less than grateful for the suggestion last time. But hey I don't care if your rude as a person, as long as you turn on the great close up less talk vids like this. Again great job here. Feel free to say something classy like last time if it helps you.
adamsmithwastheman 1 year ago
that double no pick bend is a tough one...
Vzzzm 1 year ago
What pedals were you using???
mbcNOOFS 1 year ago
this is such a bitch'n song
mbcNOOFS 1 year ago
once again fantastic lesson justin, really appreciate all of your videos.
great teacher
bazmaiden 1 year ago
you're so cute :3
VanHalenGirl25 1 year ago
If there are more people like you...
Ashevale 1 year ago
Thanks for this GREAT lesson! now i finaly know how to play it right.. i just have to put more feeling in it! :)
Goosebottle1908 1 year ago
good job as usual
MBGUITARMANIA 1 year ago
justin youre great is there a way to have the tabs for tis solo please great job from mexico
elpistolerin 1 year ago
You are Fito!
cazurro92 1 year ago
great lesson as always. ... gonna take me a lot of practice but it will be worth the effort.
Thank you.
jeffr765 1 year ago
Very good job mate
Imohtepson 1 year ago
Comment removed
Ropenius 1 year ago
dude, i went on your site. those publishing basterds... they threatened to sue him unless he removed the tabs for the songs so that they could make a few extra $. don't they realise that we can get the tabs elsewhere...
SnowyCamel 1 year ago
realy the best teacher and utube guitar lesson
Bikerr02 1 year ago 2
its actually 2 frets over to the right of the A pentatonic.. Not sure y i said one to the left. wasnt really thinking.
XHolySchnikiesX 2 years ago
its in the key of Bm. a half step down from your A pentatonic. everything goes over one fret to the left.
XHolySchnikiesX 2 years ago
thank you...this helps me out alot...you are the man.
42Caza 2 years ago
what effects?
aishdamn 2 years ago
THAT GUITAR SOUNDS SWEET M8
musiluna 2 years ago
superb thanks
solankiankit16 2 years ago
could some one tell which key is this in and over what chord this solo is being played ? i think its minor pentatonic but what chord those notes that we play for the very first lick are member of ?
kasra82 2 years ago
@kasra82 I think its the key of A.
iplayrock100 2 years ago
are u sure? it seems to me (im just an intermediate blues minor pentatonic learner) that the first lick (@2:20) is part of a F# chord by looking at the bend he is making. the first note he uses to introduce the lick is also F# .. any thoughts ?
kasra82 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck your a good cunt justin
a1s11 2 years ago
Great job Justin, I think we should remember that not even Gilmour played the exact same notes all the time. That is why we have different versions, if you listen to Hendrix play, His music changed from concert to concert, depending on how he felt. As long as we get fairly close people will know what the song is.
iplayrock100 2 years ago 4
WOW..I play guitar only four months and Justin taught me this in only one hour..well it isn´t sound perfect and I have only accoustic guitar but this is so awesome..thanx alot..
honzabur 2 years ago
My friend...YOU ARE THE BEST !!!
amopollon 2 years ago 9
good Job Justin!
denit2005 2 years ago 5
thx
JoeBidenFTW1 2 years ago
nice stat!!!
yahyamed 2 years ago 2
Thank you Justin!
rocklover2000 2 years ago 5
hey does anyone know how i can set my amp up to make it sound right when im playin these solos? like the bass, treble, mid, gain,?
JoeBidenFTW1 2 years ago 4
are you actually using the mesa amp, or is it just in the background?
GetBorn800 2 years ago
just in the background. End of last vid in series shows my set up! J
JustinSandercoe 2 years ago 2
Unbelievable. Fantastic job. Even if its not 100% correct.
SeismicRipTide 2 years ago
ur god...!
wn i get my first salary..
am donating 2 ur site....!
kanokyusuki 2 years ago 44
but you have echo, i dont:S
Renegadesays 2 years ago
YEAH!
XtremeVenom 2 years ago
lol i've been waiting for that lesson for agaes, thank you so much!!!!
Rozq87 2 years ago
Comment removed
jakerulezzzz 2 years ago
wait i wanna know how to do the grace nooootes!!
laus102 2 years ago
even though pink floyd solos are not fast they do have alot of bending and vibrato and that to do perfectly requires tons of practice
strangemongo88 2 years ago
This guy is great
strangemongo88 2 years ago 4
i love this solo.... you can really see the influence of this in the solo to "everything changes" staind.
findinghomer 2 years ago
i love gilmours solos...they are so simple yet so bad ass...
cobracarg 2 years ago 30
Lol simple? Yea they ain't fast or anything. But it's something diffrent to play it with the same feel as he does!
Slashrocks111 2 years ago
they are simple...you must not really study other solos...compare this to led zeppelin or kiss or clapton and you will see that gilmours solos are the easiest to transcribe and play...
cobracarg 2 years ago
yea ofcourse lol. But it isn't true that they are the easiest to play... That are solo's like smells like teen spirit... This has a lot of feeling in it and you realy have to make sure the bends are right etc... It's slow and easy, but playing it exactly right isn't as easy as it looks...
Slashrocks111 2 years ago
true but bends are in every good solo.... what i meant by my comment saying that gilmours solos are the easiest to transcribe and play was that gilmours solos are the easiest out of the list of bands that i mentioned....i didnt mean he has the easiest solos ever...lol...but when people want to learn solos i always say start to transcibe solos from pink floyd or zz top because they are really easy to hear and their solos are based on basic guitar scales....
cobracarg 2 years ago
Yea that's true. And most solo's are basic guitar scales... But the details in this, there is more on guitar then fretting the right frets you know :p
Slashrocks111 2 years ago
true they may be slower but u have to focus more to make it sound just right
Virtuoso883 2 years ago
yea thats what i said :D If you think gilmore is easy to play, you're totaly wrong xd This might be slow but evry detail has to be right or it sounds terrible. In fast solo's you can even play a wrong note and don't hear it...
Slashrocks111 2 years ago 3
"Justin" you have actually excelled your self this time. Hope you got as much enjoyment from making these lessons, as i am getting out every second of them. HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY TOP THIS ONE. *********
wakefieldyorkshire 2 years ago 2
End of the day it sound great, its free and very well explained, as a floyd fan this solo is probably the best that gilmour ever did!!
Cheers!!
TheProcoman 2 years ago
Thank You .
lesanne2 2 years ago
great lesson mate gottit in no time
longie350 2 years ago
thanks a ton justin.... great lesson...
noelmenon 2 years ago
Thanks mate, you are excellent.
nickofromsydney 2 years ago
You are a wonderful teacher and give us all great lessons nevertheless this one is not up to your standard. It's rushed and sloppy, not up to your standards.
Mr2nd2nun 2 years ago
Come on! Give the man a break he is probably busy but still takes the time to put this up for free. He says you have to listen to the song yourself a lot of times to really get the Gilmour tricks.
Stumblestrum 2 years ago
It's true he is profoundly kind to give so much knowledge away.
Mr2nd2nun 2 years ago 2
wish there were more teachers like you in the world
BEYONDILIMIT 2 years ago 2
its G major or B minor i now their relatives, but he seem to mix then in some part , he plays C and and then C#
pliskinn0089 2 years ago
really good
666ritchieblackmore 2 years ago
thanks
666ritchieblackmore 2 years ago
could you do cannon rock in one of your lessons please
Flablord2000 2 years ago
Thanks! great solo
Edmeirelles 2 years ago
thx 4 da help dude. u rock da house! (and play a mena guiatr as well). ;)
PabloLOVESMorlacha 2 years ago
amazing lesson and just a beautiful solo great job!
BEYONDILIMIT 2 years ago
Wow!! This is perfect! The best teacher on the internet teaches one of the best solos in the universe.
M55ikael 2 years ago
Thaks a lot my Fried i tried to play this solo many times and i Could´t before this Video,You´re my Hero Justin
THANKKKKKKKKSSSSSSSS!!!!!!
Rosesnails 2 years ago
"I love this song. It's great that you've done this lesson Justin. I would like to watch it over and over again, but I'm helping Brendan with your new Begginers Course! So take care, I'll go and translate another bit :) Cheers
WoodenMosquito 2 years ago
Justin you are a great teacher and you also have great music tastes!:) I love those solos and I'll learn them soon...thank you very much
uizzACDC 2 years ago
You're no David Gilmore, but who is?
mattyoz0 2 years ago
Arise, Sir Justin. ;)
LCFCTravis 2 years ago
Comment removed
WoodenMosquito 2 years ago
hey justin nice guitar i would love to know what guitar that is or if any one could tell me that would be great thanks
guitarG321 2 years ago
Fender Stratocaster, white.
LesPaulDX 2 years ago
I'm about 99% sure it's a Fender Custome Shop Jeff Beck Strat.
AfterMidnightRider2 2 years ago
It that the new guitar you were talking about buying a while ago Justin?
Bluebuthappy182 2 years ago
you only learnt it a few hours before making this video and you can play it that well!
You are a legend Justin.
markie101uk 2 years ago 2
not that hard at all, but that is because justin is the teacher............. Justin for King of the world!!!!!!!
arsenalfanforlife 2 years ago
Isnt the first tone suppose to be played as an harmonic?
sangolt88 2 years ago
Justin, you rule! 5*****
Petro67 2 years ago 2
Hey J, you're developing a unique style with the hat and T-shirt man. We'll soon be recognising ya from style as well as top teaching & performing!
Is your CD out yet? I'll go look on Amazon.
5 stars.
Topdoginuk 2 years ago
Awesome 5*
XxGuiitarist 2 years ago
apply for a partnership
cardshark87 2 years ago
my favorite solo
WonderBread006 2 years ago
Another great lesson.
ONE suggestion. when you perform the solo at the start, if you could do it to a backing track it would really help it sort of glue together.
deadlychickenxop 2 years ago
justin ur a legend bud, what a great surprise it was to login and find lessons dedicated to this awesome awesome track, i spent ages learning these solos and now cant wait to watch ur vids and polish up on my mistakes, thx mate.
DirtyCs 2 years ago
David gilmour ftw! nice lesson!
Darkdestroyernl 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
pretty sloppy playing but great teaching.
fleetwoodsucks 2 years ago
a new guitar out there
nice fender dude :d
yahyamed 2 years ago
2nd solo (part 1) is uploading now... part 2 of it is still compressing in Final Cut, so that will be a while yet I'm afraid. Then I have to edit the chord video, and then scan in the tabs and make the web pages. Been a nightmare doing all this and taken all day! :) So you better like it, or I'll set my cat onto you :) ha ha
JustinSandercoeSongs 2 years ago 6
I've been looking for a Comfortably Numb video for a LONG time!! Thank you so much!
naughtykoolaidman 2 years ago
lol of course we like it i already KNOW the solos but i will watch this lessons on comfortably numb so a i can MASTER it
TigzaMigzatesPT 2 years ago
i loved it..... dont u have people that edit for you so that u can consentrate on ur playing?
arsenalfanforlife 2 years ago
normally he has,
he calls him/her "jedi-master"
He also does a lot of the website work...
Hope I answerred your question.
cheers
1Messiah4All 2 years ago
u did thanks
arsenalfanforlife 2 years ago
I wish - Jedi only edits stuff for things that are going to DVD, he did the beginners course cos that is going onto DVD, but otherwise I do all the editing and web pages and all that...
JustinSandercoeSongs 2 years ago
Your really putting an effort in for this, its great
arsenalfanforlife 2 years ago
Comfortably numb !! :D
Best solo ever, thanks so much for this lesson Justin!
xxqcwaslukxx 2 years ago
I will wait for solo#2 ;)
xxqcwaslukxx 2 years ago
wooo nice! waiting for the 2nd solo!
saccottinogio 2 years ago
It doesn't work. It says "an error ocurred, please try again later" :(
anyone else has this problem or is it just me?
dosttemam 2 years ago
go back a page and come back to the video then it will load it happens to me all the time
ghosthuntertango 2 years ago
awesome lesson :)
Isanion666 2 years ago
Thanks for the lesson Justin!
Aytan72 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
awesome video justin
takerold12 2 years ago
awesome video!
takerold12 2 years ago
yea justin!
AXmichigan 2 years ago