【リリィ・蓬猫】trick and treat【まくまく・はるちん】

[taishou89]

i dont care about gender,i play this video for their music!

[Argrond]

By the way, it's better than original. Live voices are much better, than electronic ones of Ren and Rin. ^__^

[Sherilism]

Guys or girls? No problem ;D I'm in love with this frog ==> 1:21 !

Perfect... everything is perfect!!!

[iancool21]

wooowww this is GREATEST SONG !!

[yuki000122]

男じゃん

まくまくって...

[MandoOwnsPie]

i hate to say this but the hottest girls are actually guys ..

[vulgarcowpower]

what the fuck is he doing singing into a fucking apple? !

[GreenishV]

ok guys.. please tell me they are girls

[someguyinwales]

@GreenishV I have some bad news for you...

Mako Mako is a guy. He was the male singer, and the 2 witches (I assume thats what they were)

I dont know who the female singer who played the piano is (I think the name is hiruchin, dont know much japanese sorry), but she is a girl. You dont really see her much in the vid though. Wel I assume she is from her voice.

Anyway, why does it matter ? The music is good, thats all that matters.

[someguyinwales]

Actually im not sure if the red witch is him. That could be a girl for all I know.

[Argrond]

@someguyinwales How did you figure that? I never heard Makmakmakochan singing! O_O

[someguyinwales]

@Argrond I just assumed becuase of his name. But Now I actually pay attention to the credits, Mako isnt singing... Ooops.

Well the vid is still mostly guys, im not totally wrong :P

[Argrond]

@someguyinwales

Actually, who cares about gender? They can sing and play very well, it's all that matters! ^__^ まくまく rules with mixing and programming (and guitar, of course!), that's pretty enough to ensure good quality. :) She simply can't fail.

So let's just enjoy this!

[someguyinwales]

@Argrond But I dont care about gender... It just annoys me when people keep assuming its a guy because they wont show thier face, or others assume its a girl when its proven otherwise.

I do just enjoy the music, but some comments I just cant ignore.

[viperfang18]

@someguyinwales Mako Mako is the black witch who hammered guitar...

haruchin is the red one, lily(lilie? or Yuri Nazuka) is the singer with dolls.

蓬猫 is the guy.

[someguyinwales]

@viperfang18 Thanks, I only just noticed the names/credits at the end of the vid.

Didnt know what some of the names where in english though.

Damn I wish I noticed them sooner.

[duongngocvuminh]

@GreenishV Dont really know if the red one is a girl or not,the one who singing is a guy,and the black witch with the wood guitar is Makmakmakochan,she's a girl

[uetzel]

@GreenishV he's a dude, a pretty one though *wink*

[xRnChrisx]

240p, so we meet again..

[ninawang2846]

全部都很正 ! 連偽娘的背影都很正  !

[TheOneTwo555]

ทั้ง เพลง มีคนเดียว

ร้อง กีต้า เบส 

[iCortoz]

Quiero su cabello...

[TsukiFullMoonChannel]

the boy its soo sexy *////* ♥

[natumi2218]

←　男なのかっ！

[HookshotHero]

Why do they wear a mask?

[crazedk1ll3r]

@HookshotHero It is considered an internet etiquette in Japan where they would cover their face when posting stuffs online, unless say its a celebrity. If they don't, it is deemed as haughty or something in their culture. Can't be 100% sure, but it is along that line

[HookshotHero]

@crazedk1ll3r That's pretty messed up imo lol. That's similar to the women having to cover their faces in Middle Eastern countries...

[crazedk1ll3r]

@HookshotHero Hahas, well it is only over the internet, not in real life, so chillax ^^

[crazedk1ll3r]

Anyone else think these four people should form a visual kei group? :o

[ZERO01269]

他是男的 也無所謂

不會怪怪的就好~

[FallingSky7]

I always wonder what with a mask on the their mouth?

[dReeXDD]

The left one is guy (MakoMako/Mako-Chan). The right one is a real girl (Haruchin/haruchin@ba)

[aiLiriaici]

the guy looks sooooo much like a girl...i couldn't tell until he started singing...wooooahh

...0////0

[emanueljesus]

there are two guys in this vid, just guess who :))

[TheHazakura]

This.... is cool

[sakurafanluv]

That song wuz awesome and theres no mask on when sibnging yay lolz

[EmoMetalHead6666]

Speechless. The good kind.

[dannielbernal]

i think the left side is a man while on the right is a girl, but i doesnt matter the video and the music is AWESOME!!! SUGOI!!!

[dufeshmir1493]

LOLLL

[TheZero696]

i listen to this 6x still i didnt got fucking bored this is amaazing WWOOWWW

but still one douche-baggg attention seeker disliked this video fuck you whoever disliked this video ...

[cArLoS51647]

wow....woow..wooow....WOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOW :D

[monstrinsh]

HOT

[ArisaHarumi]

Great video. I love their clothes, regardless of whether or not they are cross dressers.

[darkrosesgirl1]

Mp3 plz! I LOVE IT!!!!

[kiuti0000]

まくまくきもい

[dollars0420]

よかったら使ってるギターの種類詳しく教えてください。

[lovesky0223]

とてもおもろっかたですｗｗｗ

thanks very much

[estivareilles]

originale

[CanoPinto]

They fool no one, the only true japanese player girl, in youtube, is hjfreaks <3

[lovesky0223]

@CanoPinto

ごもっともですねｗｗ

[emanueljesus]

@CanoPinto You sir are a genius

[chenyuan6093]

i think the keyboard player is a girl? anyone agree?

[snotcat]

@chenyuan6093 its the same person..

[lMllAllPl]

かわいいいいいいい~~~~ >w<

[jessekeyes40]

Where would i find the tabs for this song please!

[jamescuacatan]

hm.....is the the one with shorter hair a guy or girl, cuz there are two voices (girl and guy)

[FallenPrey33]

Absolutely wonderful!

[ZaffiroCremisi96]

I love your songs ^ ^ you are very good (although at first I did not realize that one of you was a boy: D)

P.S. I have had to say that one was a boy or I thought you were both girls (and also very beautiful I must say :°°°D)

[FrancescoCasta]

INCREDIBLE! Most original video I have seen in 4 years on youtube!

[wongyutaka]

omg....izzit a guy over there?

[sunshinebabys]

is this all the same person? i'm like omg! :)

[TenshiNoAme]

Don't tell me... That's a guy?!



[kevynspeed]

the sexiest traps are all here

[natumeg10]

やばいかっこいい！！

[marumaru396]

これは本人が歌っているのですか？？＞＜

[marumaru396]

これは本人が歌っているのですか？？(ノ∀<o)♪

[marumaru396]

これは本人が歌っているのですか？？？(ノ∀<o)♪

[marumaru396]

これは本人が歌っているのですか？？？(ノ∀<o)♪

[marumaru396]

これは本人が歌っているのですか？？？(ノ∀<o)♪

[natumeg10]

@marumaru396

そうじゃないですかね？

流石に口パクはキツイかと…；

[marumaru396]

@natumeg10

なるほど！！これは凄い♪・・・・・・てか自分がした同じコメン­トが何故にこんなにもｗｗｗｗ一回しか投稿してないのに・・・・­；；

[natumeg10]

@marumaru396

ｗｗｗありますよねｗｗ

私も一度一回しか投稿していないのに１０件くらい……ｗ←

[marumaru396]

@natumeg10

ああはｗ自分だけじゃなかったのねｗｗ少しホッとしましたｗｗｗ­＾＾

[natumeg10]

@marumaru396

ははｗｗ

こういうのでスパムされたらキツイですよね；＾＾；



[kagaminekyun216]

They're both girls. it's impossible for a guy to have that pronounced curves. Seriously. Curve of the hips. Look at em.

[targetxd40]

keep up the good work

[targetxd40]

really like your composition! keep up the good wrk. for u non asians...they are girls. asian girls who don't grow up on macdonalds grow up to be fat like most american girls.

[Xyuuuu]

I truly love this play~

[ppyporpeem]

superb <3 i love how they crossdress what not

[zekada]

Love the bad ass trumpet xD

[seaweevil]

the bassist really kicks ass

[chunkpug]

i LOVE the bass for this....

[syokyured]

あの赤いベースの人って女っぽいねｗ

ってかこの曲何気に怖いけどはまるというｗ

[Calimera07]

it's not her singing .. xD

playback '-'

[Buzzramjet]

I don't care that it's a guy. I just keep trying to figure out why all these great Japanese guitar players dress like schoolgirls. Great players all of them but why the need to do this?

Anyone.

[Cl0udyDayz]

@Buzzramjet its called visual kei in Japan its quite popular before but it seems to have started to die down. some popular visual kei bands still out there include: Versailles

[Buzzramjet]

@Cl0udyDayz I'm very familiar with Visual Kei.(thanks hide) I've been a fan of Versailles for awhile and understand the entire idea & support it. Nonetheless it's just kind of weird for guitar players on youtube. There is a great guitar player on youtube name of gorillapapa and he is outstanding but he just plays behind a mask. Like I said, they are great and I really could care less. If one of them showed up to audition for my band and played like that I'd get them all the outfits they wanted.

[ppyporpeem]

@Buzzramjet not just you i'll defenitely do the same!!!!

[MiraXMomone]

@hazirarizah If you look at the shape of the body (torso) at 1:56 Im pretty damn sure thats a guy XD

[papercut32]

You can usually tell whether it's a guy or girl by the size of their hands, which is why so many of them wear super long sleeves or gloves. Obviously the voice is a pretty big give away too.

[xxaq11xx]

@papercut32 uh if u didnt notice at the beginning it said voice alteration for creds.... im not saying that 1 of them couldnt be guys but yea...

[Artgo]

@papercut32 its not always that easy. my sister has really big hands

[snotcat]

@papercut32 Pity its not this person singing at all. o.O Its a cover with lip syncing seeing as the plug is PLUGGED into an APPLE lol..which was amusing.

[crazedk1ll3r]

@snotcat You know, that APPLE could possibly just be a cover for an actual microphone. You know how Japanese comes out with the weirdest product. Their technology is well a few years ahead of most country. I mean, just look at their phone industry!

[monkeywrenchization]

@crazedk1ll3r The wire comes from the guitar and is plugged into the apple.

[TheRyuka1]

@papercut32 i THINK THE ONE THAT SINGS FIRST IS A BOY...

[smartanimegirl]

I WANT THAT BLACK BEAR.

But wow, not bad.

[xxdray2xx]

@hazirarizah its a girl look at the legs ._.

[twinkie15432]

@xxdray2xx haha you can't tell by the legs for cross dressers on niconico sadly xD unless they say something, its VERY hard to tell. esp with the wigs+face masks

[EcstasyDarks]

FFFFF-vkei crossdressers. I can see it from a mile away before I'm asian. LOL

[Brinillow]

@hazirarizah By the voice and the body shape as much as I can see, I think it's a guy. I was pondering over that fact for a bit too. But I bet it's a guy.