The Moon, Islam is bollocks

[decent104]

IF U GUYS SAY THAT ISLAM IS FAKE THEN WHY DON U ASK UR IDOLS TO CREATE A FLY???????? IF U SAY THERE IS NO GOD THEN JST TELL ME CAN U CREATE A SINGLE MOSQUITO ... CERTINLY U WILL NOT... HATERS WILL ALWAYS HATE

[12september1683]

@decent104 Go google robotic insects. You should claim down.  Just because your religion is proven false is no reason to type in caps

[0MrBlue]

Saying one thing in one language and then translating it in another changes the full meaning. the lord sent the messages to earth in a way so all can know the reason of life and give us meaning, spirituality, hope, belief. Mankind is truly blind to the forces of the universe. do your research you will find out that the way we perceive things is not how they truly are. Tell me a bit about yourself ?

[12september1683]

@0MrBlue m Allah can't get his point over. Allah fails again

[0MrBlue]

@12september1683 Tell me a bit about yourself ! who are you and how does god fail, please explain

[12september1683]

@0MrBlue You said "Saying one thing in one language and then translating it in another changes the full meaning" so Arabic was a bad chose then.

Allah needs a Messeger (gabriel) to tell Mohammad ( Muslim killer) So it is written down by Abdallah bin Sa'd. who then he apostatized. So Mohammad had him murdered. Then the half remembered verse are collected (at least 30 after Mo's death) and all other Korans are burnt.

Now so how it would be easier for Allah to tell us directly. Allah fails again

[0MrBlue]

@12september1683 You said: God doesn't tell us directly and he fails, You know nothing at all, Your in a delusional state your not trying to understand anything but you just hate everything, negativity. You are truly blind and you can say as much bullshit as you want but it still doesn't make it right. You still won't tell me a bit about yourself. wow it really makes me laugh.....

[12september1683]

@0MrBlue An ad hominem is an attempt to link the validity of a premise to a characteristic or belief of the person advocating the premise. The ad hominem is a classic logical fallacy,

You prove the wealness of your arguement with this Ad homimem attack. If you had a good arguement you would deal with it directly.

Please stop abusing this comments section. It is for comments on the film and not for you to get brownie points with Allah. If you want to question me, write a private message.

[0MrBlue]

@12september1683 you don't get brownie points with the lord, just to state what is right and wrong. i understand i wont ask anymore questions. I usually like speaking face to face with people, so i can see directly in to the person and be able see what makes them tick in a certain way.

[0MrBlue]

You are saying these things are false, what about the bible which has been changed many times. why don't you put your knowledge to good use and learn to live your life in peace and harmony. The one who seeks vengeance must dig two graves one for his enemy and one for himself. I try not judge people but to see where they are coming from. man doesn't not have the capacity to understand the full extent of the lord.

[12september1683]

@0MrBlue yes these things are false

"man doesn't not have the capacity to understand" No that is just you

[0MrBlue]

@12september1683 explain, you cant just say no, give me some details why you think this

[12september1683]

@0MrBlue Do not abuse this comments page. It is for commits about the film. It is not for your defence of Islam.

The film has nothing about Christianity. If you want go into detail send a private message.

[givethanks1314]

Muhammad on human blood circulation:

"Satan circulates in the human body as blood does." ~Muhammad (Bukhari 9.283, 3.255, 8.239)

[wassup0012]

go to hell

[123backinyerface]

Another great video, SUB'D !

[SOA4ever]

THE TRUTH IS OFTEN HARD TO HANDLE ISN'T IT, MAY ALLAH GUIDE THE IGNORANT!

[zeroweaver13]

@SOA4ever

may allah smite the pedophile mohammed

[SOA4ever]

@zeroweaver13 NO, HOW CAN YOU SAY THAT!?!, MUHAMMAD S-A-W ISN'T A PAEDO! NO, smite you!

[ahmology]

ok this is wat i found out about the verse DR zakir is talking about ... the first word seraga means a lamp (and it is a metaphor) .. the second word describing the moon is moneera which means glows so its rather vague to judge i assume ..

[TheWithoutForm]

They really are funny. They also believe that Mo split the moon in half, that the world is flat with the mountains upon it preventing it from tilting and that the sun sets in a murky puddle...

[tompointzero]

fuck crusaders and zionists, bunch of dirty rats

[1234mirko]

hehehe another islamic scientist:)))))))))))))))))))h­ehehehhehheeehhehehehheehehehe­heheheheh

[Wrath0fKhan]

Zakir Naik = idiot

[irishxxkelt]

I never saw this Hadith before. It is as hilarious as the sun sits under the throne of Allah every night and asks him he can risein the morning.

[irishxxkelt]

@irishxxkelt Typos....sorry "he asks him IF he can rise in the moring. Someone else has put up a video with a cartoon of a little sun asking an old guy with a beard about going round the earth again. It really is very funny

[nabo2i0z1q7uzv1z]

Was Mohamad too as stupid as this Mullah?

[MumblingMickey]

@nabo2i0z1q7uzv1z There is evidence given the actions of mohammad... (who incidentally really did exist, unlike the evidence for Jesus) that he was obviously as educated as any at the time... pretty poorly... but moreover that he suffered from schizophrenia..

In the orient at the time people with crazy ideas were considered to be prophets even if they were stark raving mad! They even outlawed 'math' which is why the greatest of the worlds civilizations failed in less than 50 years! Sad...

[alemcodon]

Anaxagoras may have said it before but what did THEY do to him? imprisoned him!!! Cus everyone else was too dumb to understand him.

SO why would a muslim say the same shit that got next man sent to prison if it was a popularity contest?

The point is not who said it first.....the talmud is a holy book for muslims also and the point is its a fact!!

The moon reflects the sunlight.

Its a message from God and u cant refute its wrong.

[12september1683]

You do not need a God to understand the moon is a reflects the Sun, However, you do need a God to believe otherwise.

Tabari 1:233 Sun amd the moon are good Muslims and obedient servants Allah creates two suns.blotted out one of the Suns to make the moon.

Tabari 1:234 Gabriel drags his wings three times to reduces the light of the smaller Sun making it into the Moon

Koran 17.12 Allah has blotted out the sign of the night and the sign of the day (Sun) something to see by

[alemcodon]

@12september1683 your quoting verses from a historian/scholar who has nothing to do with islamic laws or teachings, and the quraan verse..whats ur point?

i cant understand why u guys have conjured up so much hate for muslims!?!? tell me how has any muslims harmed you in any way?

[12september1683]

@alemcodon Google AL-TABARI get some education on the religion you follow

I do not hate Muslims. It is Islam which is false and causes pain and hurt in the world, I don't like

[alemcodon]

@12september1683 [17:12] We rendered the night and the day two signs. We made the night dark, and the day lighted, that you may seek provisions from your Lord therein. This also establishes for you a timing system, and the means of calculation. We thus explain everything in detail.

[12september1683]

@alemcodon Hmm not much detail here is there. So is this verse saying 1: 2 signs I assume the moon and the sun, I know this from Hadith etc. 2 The sun for the day and moon for night. 3 Allah establishes the timing. Moon for the night and the sun for the day.

This shows the Koran is false. Why? sometimes you can see the moon in the day. Maybe Allah's timing off or the Koran is false.

[MumblingMickey]

@alemcodon It was copied... from other books... books which are online... what are you talking about?... God didn't inform people of this... it was discovered...

just like embryology... a discovery made centuries before the qu'ran...The qu'ran copied Galen...and even copied the errors he made!! lol

That would be like me claiming I discovered the laws of gravity because most people in the 18th century were stupid. Despite newton pointing out the laws of gravity before me!

[perrik7]

This concept was already In the Talmud long before Quran

[GangaSoota]

Islam ....religion of piss

[MumblingMickey]

@GangaSoota I wouldn't worry about religion... to be honest what none of these idiots understand is the concept of 'technologoical singularity' anyone under the age of 40 has a very high chance of seeing this come to pass... What the hell will happen to their religion then..when humans are no longer the masters of this world! lol

Religion will fall apart in the face of such a singularity event... all human philosophy will!

[asifmasih1]

These rat look ugly zakhir naik is so fukkin shhit lier like mohammad(piss on him)that when he twist and makes up story to make a shhit prophet look good,i feel like pissing in his mouth,to give him camelcola.

[dodyfarhaad]

U study is very good hope u will study more but Allah will accept u only the day u ask him for help .

I love Hitlor , but he forget to kill u r father .

[12september1683]

You can't take when your hero is exposed.

Who is Hitlor? You can't mean Hitler. We know how evil he was

[dodyfarhaad]

My hero is a man how respect others ,and not spend time to find mistakes in others , And my hero is HITLER or HItlor , i love hin caz he kill idiots like u . if he stay few more years may be this world is free from fool like u ,get lost ,u r not fromUK caz British man not writing like u .Study English too .

[12september1683]

lol at you!

[dodyfarhaad]

Sleep fool its late night , Did Hitler come in u r dream or u r mother visit him before u born .

any way u r sick man ,spend lot of time for others but for me easy to fuck u caz i know how are u , fool .

Sleep i want sleep with u r mother ,

[12september1683]

In a ditch, covered in petrol, on his wedding day. And he only had one ball!

[12september1683]

o yes on fire.

Hitler. We beat him like we will beat you.

Dodyfarhead Jew hater

[irishxxkelt]

@dodyfarhaad Well dodyfarhaad talking about having sex with another man makes you gay. Talking like that about someone else's mother really shows what Muslim men think of women.

[camelhawk]

Fuck medina and mecca, may the bones of muhammed(shit be upon him) be broken, piss on allah, shit on the mahdi.

[bornemix]

Also:

"Blot out", which is one of the translations from Sakhr Dictionary for the word Ma-haa, which you probably used, is not equal to "blood out" which is in your description of this video.

In any case, defining ma-haa, is really is up to the old known-to-be-authentic arabic dictionaries like Lisan Al-Arab.

Also, one needs to look at the traditional interpretation of the verse to conclude that your understanding of this word was the one used by the early muslims (who mohammad tought).

[12september1683]

The is clear and is backed up by other hadiths. Please stop making up lies. I have the research. You do not understand. As you admit saying, in your commit "which you "probably" used

this proves you do not know the hadith, or translation.

[bjbjbjbjbj]

islam is bollocks

[EncompassedRunner]

Many Muslims try to defend Islam by arguing Quran is full of scientific wisdom, & they cite examples from famous book by Maurice Bucaille: "The Bible, The Qur'an, and Science" -- but Muslims: that book & the alleged scientific proof from the Quran has been debunked, debunked! (see: "The Qur'an and the Bible in the Light of History and Science" by William Campbell)

[lalamusa1]

see debate between william campbell and zakir naik LOL. Campbell was raped on stage.

[EncompassedRunner]

Thanks, lalamusa1, will check for that debate, good info.

[breakskid]

@EncompassedRunner yes please listen to this mans advice, go to youtube and watch this debate "The Qur'an and the Bible in the Light of Science?" It's Campbell vs Naik. Eye opening stuff, I couldn't have said it better myself. :D

[givethanks1314]

@breakskid hey, eye opening stuff–– Mohammed on medical science:

Bukhari 4.537 The Prophet said "If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink), for one of its wings has a disease and the other has the cure for the disease."

Bukhari 1.234 Anas said, "Some people of `Ukl or `Uraina tribe came to Medina and its climate did not suit them. So the Prophet ordered them to go to the herd of camels and to drink their milk and urine (as a medicine).

[breakskid]

@givethanks1314 it's a good debate aye? :D

[givethanks1314]

@breakskid debating with muslims are debating with satan the liar, a sheer waste time.

[givethanks1314]

@breakskid more eye opener for you:

Muhammad on human blood circulation:

"Satan circulates in the human body as blood does." ~Muhammad (Bukhari 9.283, 3.255, 8.239)

[bornemix]

Tabari reports a good percentage of unauthentic hadiths. You should know this before making videos, asserting different things.

Also, that someone observed, or theoreticized (?) about a thing which is true, doesn't diminish from other ones telling it. This means that you can argue that Mohammed (S) was some kind of astronomician (?), but not from this point can you allege him to be a false prophet.

Please add to the video: Statements that authenticate the hadiths.

[12september1683]

Tabari is one of the most importent sources of evidece on Mohamad.

I know my film has hit the spot when Muslims say "these hadith are false.

[bornemix]

I didn't say that these hadith are false (?), not even falsely reported.

*Actually, you never even claimed that they have been authentically reported.*

So, to conclude that they ARE authentically reported, please bring some kind of research material supporting this.

UNTIL THIS IS DONE, THE HADITHS YOU HAVE BROUGHT CANNOT BE REGARDED TO BE AUTHENTICALLY REPORTED.

That is if you don't regard ALL hadiths from Tabari to be authentically reported.

BUT THIS ALSO NEEDS PROOF!

...

Best of wishes!

[12september1683]

Al-Tabari is a history, called the Ta'rikh, was written by Abu Muhammad bin al-Tabari between 870 and 920 A.D. Google it. May do your own research and not make un reasearched commits.

This monumental work was translated and published in 1987 through 1997 by the State University of New York Press.

abari's History consists entirely of Islamic Hadith. It is arranged chronologically. Tabari is Islams oldest uncensored source.

[bjbjbjbjbj]

islam is bollocks

[hannahr77]

islam is a load of crap period and 1 day the muslims will se that muhammad and ill-allah is but liars and will burn mecca to the ground