Patricia Kaas - Et S'Il Fallait Le Faire (France)

[MrSunlight79]

Cette chanson etait trop belle pour la Eurovision...

[MrSunlight79]

Simplement magnifique!!! Compliments!

[MoucheronTseTse]

Je n'ai pas eu honte du candidat français cette fois, ça change des autres années...

Sublime chanson/interprétation, j'ai même versé une petite larme à la fin.

Merci Patricia Kaas !

[Xabin22]

Bigger than Eurovision! The best song EVER! I just Thank to Eurovision, because I met Patricia and this beautiful, powerful and amazing song. THE BEST THE BEST THE BEST

In my funeral I want this song playing. (So big is this song)

[5727ilie]

real succes

[phbuhler]

OMG....what a great performer. The song & the show are perfect.

She was too good for the contest!! She was at a too high level...

[amandaferry9]

you don't need to understand the language if the song and performance are so good!!!

[bucur666]

205 people don't understand french language ;))



[jedancotube]

Jolie chanson... Patricia Kaas est une très grande et rare interprète !

[listentodutchhouse]

@Blakusss3 ce om fara valoare esti

[Blakusss3]

@listentodutchhouse o sa dau remove la comm nu eu am dat commu... i-am dat contul unui prieten si se pare ca a facut prostii pe cont :)) scz orkm

[narkotikoff]

beautiful poetry & gorgeous Patricia !!!!!!!

[LatvianBaalelinsh]

204 dislikes? Why do they even view this song then?!

[86chemist1]

Дива, Эдит Пиаф ! ! !

[AlevtinaKaden]

beautiful!!!!!!

[meliafa]

Salutations de la Turquie.

Nous vous aimons Particia Kaas.

12 points de la Turquie.

[shyic]

I love the song, the lyrics are very powerful, and you can never go wrong with French chanson.

However, I found her performance here rather AVERAGE! She had the opportunity to show some supported vocals at the end of the song, but everything was very weak and throaty. The dynamics were are also rather flat. I'd love to see more contrast between piano and forte, more drama build-up (listen to Jacques Brel's Amsterdam and you'll know what I mean). Average interpretation imho.

[chrysevstar]

@shyic this is the eurovision song contest not some classical music competition imho...

[katyanadym]

One of my favorite singers. This woman has power, class, elegance, beauty, you name it. I used to listen to Patricia starting from childhood. My favorite song by her besides this song is "Une derniere semaine a New York" and "Venus Abribous." Patricia really knows how to create gorgeous art. All of my respect. Without Patricia's art we really woudn't have a complete idea of how true feminity, elegance and passion look like in this world.

[AndyGagaMusic]

I dont understand French, but I love this Song...

[katyanadym]

This woman is amazing.

[MartinNRW1964]

oooh, I adore that song. it s absolutely georgious. My No. 1 in esc-history.

je t'adore Patricia et j'aime tes chansons, encore et encore.

haschde geheert?:-)

[LGSVENSK]

205 people are tone-deaf... sad for them. :(

[ELMEJOR673]

Demasiado Buena Esta Canción.!!!

[steph611987]

Patricia Kaas c'est la sensualité et la douceur à l'état pur...!!! Et cette chanson est juste...MAGNIFIQUE!!!

[AquaOinkOink]

At the upload date of this video Germany had decide that Lena will go to the ESC with Satellite and it was my birthday. xD

[trashpunk1979]

My favorite Eurovision entry. This version is better than the album/studio version imo

[teasememusic]

Hermosa..simplimente como Rocio Durcal.

[MrSpreadingthelove]

This is my favourite Eurovision song ever! I love it! Its amazing =)

[HousefreundX]

Breathtaking song! Ich liebe französische Musik!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[tomygu95]

that lady knows how to make music

[qwe2007rty]

202 dislikes?

C'mon guys, this is one of the best songs of Eurovision history

[MsDreamer2121]

great amazing.... greetings from Azerbaijan...

[Lusty487]

It's most beautiful song

[Hoeflichkeit]

but i agree, Patricia had to win =(

[ijlaldoc]

just wondeful



[cobalt73000]

J' ai vraiment été déçu de cette 8ème place à l' Eurovision. Même si Patricia Kaas n' a pas gagné, elle a honoré son pays, tout comme l'honorera Amaury Vassili en Mai prochain. Deux très grandes voix pour deux très belles chansons !

[roroka123]

a real Lady.

[91niros19]

la plus belle melodie de Patricia...

[MultiPUNKROCKS]

french it's such a beautiful language

[59MANDY]

tres belle chanson merciii

[greekbear79]

200 people don't listen properly! magnifique

[2011Bolt]

12 points!

[hervedenis1]

magnifique chanson

[WesleyGuijt]

My favorite french song. She sings it with so much feeling!

[LadyPurpugia]

She's so french! :P

[pippipop1337]

This song is so 2314%"¤ amazing!

[BatteredPiano]

boring

music for old grannies

[loumidis15]

@BatteredPiano xaxaxaxaxa

[DieKaiserin13]

※♥※ Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ ※ ♥ ♫.•:*¨♥¨*:•.♫ ♥ ※ Ƹ̵̡Ӝ̵̨̄Ʒ ※♥※

[Merdangeldijan]

When I listen to her I really want to study french. VERY BEAUTIFULL.

[Merdangeldijan]

she is a great woman. She is a great singer. RESPECT.

[croguy]

I don't like comparing artists with other artists,but this song was something else in the ESC.

[BryFerAl]

this song is SO much better than Eurovision Shit Contest! she is in another level..

[GeorgeTel100]

@BryFerAl Excellent point!!

[jokingmilad]

@BryFerAl

thats so true this is on higher level!

[MrDavidgabrielyan]

@BryFerAl Great Comment!!!

[secur4705]

impresionante

[An89Go]

I have no word. I am really proud that my country (Bosnia and Herzegovina) gave 6 points to France (as we ussually do).

This song and this woman are absolutely sign that Eurovision is still SONG contest.

I still cannnot believe that juries from some countries did not give any points to this. I understand that televoters did not vote (they usually like comerical crap).

[Nichrida]

Oh my God, I don't know how to say that in English, she's got so much attitude and amplitude,she comes up on the scene,she sings a single word and she captures the listener,I mean she is one woman singer among the BEST singers of all times....

[BryFerAl]

@Nichrida indeed!!!

[e64u]

Außergewöhnlich !!!

[eduardoz19]

She has so much class and poise!!! simply perfect!

[BryFerAl]

outstanding!!!!!!

[Amazonkaify]

Bravo !!!

[Martinofredwall100]

195 needs to visit Paris!

[corvicantus]

Евровидение - это конкурс политических симпатий ... Eurovision is a competition of political likings

[An89Go]

Fantastic...



[olgamu28]

она несравненна!

[Amazonkaify]

une deesse ! Merci !

[Misteron20]

I didn't want it to end...

[FlavioSousa35]

So wonderful! Magnifique!

[Escfin]

This is masterpiece!

[marclempernesse]

@Dutchandlovingit02

Merci, thanks for your opinion about the french songs at this european show... However, I think it's Time to quit this ridiculous european show. Everybody sing in english, except Spain and Italy, that's not Europe. We missed the occasion to make something great!! It's Time to build something new, but not these UE!! Many french think this.

However, thanks for your judgement. It's fine to see people reacting at the oposite of the money power.

[heppolo]

@marclempernesse I like Eurovision and, dare I say it, no matter what year it is there are 5 or 6 good songs anyway and fresh new faces around. It is a reminder that there is music outside the UK, US, Australia, France, Spain, Italy, Germany and Scandinavian countries.

It is necessary to re-think the voting system.

[Dutchandlovingit02]

there were 195 people from Eastern Europe who never realised Eurovision once was about music and not about the biggest dance act with fireworks.

France is one of the last nations who consistently sends quality.

vive la république française

[paris230410]

@Dutchandlovingit02 i agree

[ancaanton]

@Dutchandlovingit02 Don't be ignorant. I'm from Eastern Europe and I can tell you that you're wrong. People love Patricia Kaas ... and the Moldavian act was good as well, why do you even compare? A mon avis tu ne devrais pas parler des choses que tu ne connais bien.

[Dutchandlovingit02]

@ancaanton I'm not ignorant or biased, just bitter about the ratio good music/spectacular show.

The 'silly hats' were good in their own way, I guess, but their kind of entertainment isn't what Eurovision is about or ought not to be, in MY perspective. And as Italy became second this year, good taste can't be entirely dead after all. Or what MY idea of good music taste is, anyway.

Merci, mais je n'ai pas de besoin de votre avis.

[ThePatricia1008]

@Dutchandlovingit02 eastern europe?really?i m from eastern europe and i ve always loved patricia kaas

you're nothing but an asshole

[JKalama25799752]

@Dutchandlovingit02 East Europe loves Patricia what are you on about??

[jokingmilad]

@Dutchandlovingit02

thats true but the eastern countrys know her ver good. so is just that eu CRAP

[bogitospeca]

@Dutchandlovingit02

Don't put all the people into one bucket!!! I'm from Eastern Europe and I listen to retro and rock music and believe me, lots of people will find this song more than just a simple song ! But to be totaly honest, YES, many people have made a big and also wrong drift towards fireworks and foolish dancing styles and etc... But that's not only in Eastern Europe !!! So don't blame when you are not well informed of the situation :)

[cipriangeorges]

@Dutchandlovingit02 well, your opinion about Eastern Europe isn't available, i'm from Romania and i gotta say i love Patricia Kaas, i voted for her and Iceland. And if you saw, Romania doesn't get so many points from Eastern Europe, but from Moldova, Spain, Portugal and now Italy. Yeah, perhaps other slavic countries votes for each other, but Romania is a latin country caught up in an Eastern block.. which is sad

[HousefreundX]

WAHNSINN!!!WUNDERBAR!!! Ich liebe diese Frau!

[rod01000]

patricia félicitations...tu n'es peut etre pas arrivée premeire de l'eurovision mais tu restes la premiere dans mon coeur ( apres mon chéri bien sur ! ) tout le monde sais que tu es une artiste compléte,simple, reste comme tu es surtout et reviens vite nous voir en france car tu nous manques....je n'oubli rien de nos différentes rencontres à paris et surtout le verre que nous avions partager ensemble à l'hotel de reine à nancy mais encore lors de ton concert dans notre ville de forbach !!

[rod01000]

patricia félicitations...tu n'es peut etre pas arrivée premeire de l'eurovision mais tu restes la premiere dans mon coeur ( apres mon chéri bien sur ! ) tout le monde sais que tu es une artiste compléte,simple, reste comme tu es surtout et reviens vite nous voir en france car tu nous manques....je n'oubli rien de nos différentes rencontres à paris et surtout le verre que nous avions partager ensemble à l'hotel de reine à nancy mais encore lors de ton concert dans notre ville de forbach !!! bisou

[marclempernesse]

Magnifico !!! Classe et tendre !! Vivre la culture française ! But even if it's a good song, it's not in english, and we can win !!! Have you counted how many songs won at the Eurovision if there aren't in english ? ...

Portugal, Espana siguen cantando en su propio idioma y algunos otros lejos de nuestra europea !! I'm fed up with this world all all-inclusive English !! It's time to quit European songcontest and create a LATIN world... y quizas una nueva europa, que respeta varias culturas...

[Alex4u]

Voted for her and bought her Kabaret album. so proud of her for going to Eurovision and taking the chance to compete. She's a true artist. Thank you Patricia for representing France and for sharing your beautiful music to the rest of Europe.

[butterfly21138]

l like her freshness and beauty ))

[svetoczek]

BRAVOOOO!!!!

[amerussian]

Patricia is the best musician in the world. I wish she would do a concert in America. She brings light to my dim days

[maseniermanc]

I cannot believe that this song did not win Eurovision 2009. Surely Europe cannot ignore such beautiful art?

[poiataolesea]

tu sei super Patrizia

[FSY80]

sublime tout simplement ....... la pus grande artiste française !!!!!!

[mamabuasili1]

je veut le texte de cela

[Xabin22]

The BEST song EVER!! EVER!! EVEEEER!!

Sooo good for Eurovision!

(And I really like Eurovision)

[FSchragenheim]

Gorgeous! Can't get enough!

[BlueBoyRBD]

i`m sorry...yohanna was and is much much much better and ever will be than patricia! :)

[didders01]

she has a wonderfull voice,fantastic

[Schery09]

She is so amazing!

I'm looking forward to the

Best Of Christmas Concert in Vienna with Patricia Kaas.

The absolutely Highlight of Eurovision 2009!

It is a reason to start learning french.. ;-)

[2007jpn]

素晴らしい!!

Merveilleux

[giorgosrc]

Patricia Kaas is great.

Eurovision is NOTHING for her, she is too great for there.

She has a voice that touches you, gives you goosebumps, makes you wanna listen to her again and again.

[Otustelija]

je crois que cette chanson est la plus belle chanson à l'histoire d'eurovision ! elle est vraiment superbe !

[redhoted1]

The most beautiful song ever to come out of the Eurovision competition... Patricia Kaas is tough act to follow. Unfortunately, most of the songs that are voted number one are not necessarily the creme de la creme...

[Deolisful]

Love it - love it!!!

[123xaverius]

too good!

[woletspilein]

She really put the other performances to shame. Such a raw performance, and truly inimitable! Never fails to send shivers down my spine. Vraiment formidable, quel dommage qu'elle n'a pas gagné, c'était pas juste!

[mifez93]

SUPER SANSON

[elfeides]

vivielabretagne voudrais tu que l'on remete danarbraz digne breton et finir dans les choux...... pfffff

avec patricia nous sommes 8em et c'est un miracle que la france a réalisée bravo pour cette magnifique chanson

[ViamonteAndre]

What a tragic passion the same we see in Fado songs ... Beautifull and Raw!

[anaumia]

vivelabretagnelibre.....tu me fais pitié^^

[travattore]

Well sometimes I just wish that only certain countries would have the right to vote. Otherwise we'll continue to see nonsense circus freak shows on eurovision.

"Ça se chante avec tout son cœur. Tiens, regarde !"

[Vivelabretagnelibre]

pas étonnant qu'on ai perdu, c'est nul à chier, de pire en pire, à croire qu'on selectionne la PIRE chanson afin de PERDRE à tous prix ! ! ! !

[Stefy4u69]

@Vivelabretagnelibre Pour info 8eme c'est notre record depuis 2002

[LouTaat]

La nouveau Edith Piaf! Une voix unique!

[LABOULETTE26]

ouhhhh!!!!!!!! les français

[ChrissiDorleac]

ca, c'est encore la musique, c'est le style....douze points pour Patricia!

[MrRatybus]

Un des plus belles voix de la chanson Française. Elle est merveilleuse, sublime, l'élégance qui la qualifie n'a d'égale que sa voix superbe!

[SteamFanHannover]

One of the great artists of France.

I still remember a concert in Hannover in 1994, the ticket price was 75 DM and the acoustics were horrible - the worst ever. I wanted my money back! It was impossible to enjoy this concert.

[homesickkk]

the best voice ever. it is a very powerfull song

[jojoflorence]

merci beaukoup-kaunista....

[diaboliqueGR]

She's such a diva! She's great!

Yes, the best ESC song in the last decade!

[gatoupsy1978]

my prefer song of the last year Patricia sublime

[SwissMan73]

by far the best song last year

[Galacticmaster]

yeah, it was classical french, which i liked because they played to their strengths,

it was like the German song Miss kiss kiss bang bang,

that was classic american, at a time when germany envied american 1920s culture

[ednawalling]

This song is so much better than anything I have seen on Eurovision in the last few years.

I wish the voting system was more fair based on judges. The current system favours countries with 'friends'.

[Hoeflichkeit]

@ednawalling Germany has less friends than other countrys, but we won, because the poeople liked the music.

[ednawalling]

@Hoeflichkeit

That was a great win, well done Germany. Good luck to all countries this year, hoping it is based on the music and not having special friends. Music brings joy to all of us, and helps us all to transcend our different cultures. My best wishes to you all for 2011, from Australia x

[maligunduz]

junk

[OctMadeleine]

@maligunduz  you are so right :))

[Djoma85Sweden]

She sings beautiful!

[fazia59410]

tu as la chance d avoir un maman a ton écoute et qui t adore, moi rien le néant ,une maman qui t aime plus quelle meme prends soin d elle::::moi je nai rien juste mes yeux pour pleurer j en ai marre vraiment un jour je commettrais l iirréparable moi je suis seule au monde désespérement alors je vous dis adieu a tous

[K8RIM]

@fazia59410 tu c le suicide na jamai rien réslu lol il fo afronter ca peur é ca douleur é tu vera que tu né pa si seul que ca. é que la vi vo la peinne d'etre vecu je c de quoi je parle lol bizzz

[xxxTUBATUBExxx]

she didnt need to win anyway. I assumed that she attended to prove others what is it like bein a real singer.. she is already globalwinner. although i dont understand single word in this song, i can feel its meanin by heart. she is expressin way much better..

[CiemnyPolak90]

I Love Patricia Kaas !!!!!!

[hubblehub]

She's amazing!!! There it's so much true in her performance.

[vindemarque]

Patricia is perfect! The song is perfect! It makes me cry! Elle est magnifique!

[giladigital]

i saw her in concert

she is magnificiant

[arisgreece26]

i am so proud that i managed to sing this song along her...

[DonJeta0007]

ahh cette chanson est magnifique ou quoi... j'aime beaucoup le text, la music, la chanteuse,,, tous:-)

[lizavasil]

She is way too good for Eurovision!

[smilysheep]

@lizavasil exactly that

[gvidal666]

@lizavasil yeah i think so too, i love this song.

[tiviplayer]

@lizavasil AGREE !!! 1000%

[Exiistenz]

Should've won.

[LGSVENSK]

The absolute best song and performance on the ESC... love it!

[paredper]

Je suis espagnol, et d'après moi, c'était la meilleure chanson d'Eurovision 2009!!!

[Mycenaea]

What is this song about?

[HelloJejed]

title : "And if it had to be done"

this song is about a woman who says to her love that if it were necessary, she would do anything for him. For example :

"Et s'il fallait le faire, j"arrêterais la terre, j'éteindrais la lumière pour que tu reste endormie" means "And if it had to be done, I would stop the Earth, I woul switch off the light for you to stay asleep".

or another sentence says : "And if it had to be done, I would push back winter, with hard blows of spring and long clear morning

[imarhavel]

Je to nádherná pieseň. Som očarená.

[TheMus1cfan]

J'adore cette chanson! Je suis Gallois, et mon francais est nes pas tres bien, mais cette chanson est magnifique! J'espère apprendre plus francais! Les mots et le sens...doux-amer et joli!!! :D

[44Beats]

superb song patricia is Class. worthy of at least 2nd. Estonia 1st imo.

[steph611987]

Trop trop magnifiqueeeeee!!! J'adooore cette chanson!!!!

Merci Patricia!!! Quel talent et quelle classe... ♥

[guyvan1965]

Certainly, best song on eurovision 2009. Bravo, Patricia Kaas!

[Xabin22]

The best!! I love this song!! Love U Patricia!! It's so elegant (the song and Patricia)

[xflash2k1]

was that dance at the end really necessary??

[guyvan1965]

Certainly, is necessary, as accent finishing a song

[1welshdevil]

I LOOOOOOOVE this song, really into her after eurovision, to me she was the winner, i listen to her music, WHO won it again Finland???

[fcbcdl]

Norway won.

[INHEAT79]

Y DID NOT FRANCE WIN?!

[europa6954]

Parabens ! Bela como sempre, Patricia,nos do Brasil te amamos ! Beijos

[CharlePhilippeLafont]

Patricia CLASSE.