@IRyu03 this is life.. not everything has a happy ending. Feeling pain of others makes you a better person, more sympathetic, more willing to help in real life. If you think about it, being selfish is thinking of only what makes you happy and sad.
This is not a good movie. A good movie is one which transmits goodness to the viewer even amidst tragedies or sorrow or whatever. But here this movie confuses the viewer. It is simply absurd to suggest in the colonel, a liking or anxiousness to meet the criminal villain of his and his mother's lives' spoiler. No this movie is a not good.
Interesting, Russians generally aren't as liberal about showing shirtless-scenes as say the Americans or the Germans, (Here's a real exception though around 10:32)
There must be two versions of this movie. It was show on Dutch tv, but after Sanja shoots Toljan he continues his life saying there is nothing, nothing. I am very suprised there is another version where Sanja is much older and sees the image of his real father again! Why is there two versions of this film?
Loved this film - spasibo bolshoi! Any chance of finding the following films with or without English subtitles? Серебряные озера (1980 ), Подготовка к экзамену (1979)? Would be really grateful!
One of the best films in the world! It is such a touching and serious movie!!! How the people lived in SOviet :(. But I like it very much. Thanks for uploading. P.S. Oscar naminate. It should be a winner film! :(
the movie is excellent yet it is very sad movie- it speaks about the reality of life- the pain is excruciating- the cast o the film is very effective. they had portrayed the character well-enough that the audience could relate into it. furthermore, Sonja, there is still hope- GOD will never left you nor forsake you!
@vorkutaman I think it was the case, that in some countries the ending was with Sanja shooting Tolyan and then an ending scene of him going to bed and with the voice in off saying something like 'I had to kill him so that I am nothing, nothing, nothing'... I do not recall the exact words, though. In any case, I agree that this ending is better. The scenes of Sanja as a grown-up man do not really add anything... And indeed good film!
Sorry, I meant an alternative ending in which there is no footage with Sanya as a grown-up man. Finishing with Sanya´s killing the Thief in the train. Is it possible that this was the end for some countries?? At least, in Spain...
Amazing film! Beautifully filmed and great actors. The three of them. I see the story as a metaphore of Russia during those times, mainly regarding Stalin, but everything is hinted in such a subtle way. Thanks for posting. Is it possible that there is an alternative ending to the movie?? I believe I have seen some more footage, when Sanya is already a man...
@PyccoTypucmo I very much enjoyed this vid ! It would be the best to watch it with RUSSIAN subtitles, too. I am studying Russian but I still cannot understand every word .
0:56:50 is the funnies moment of the film! The militiamen ask him his documments and he shows his chest, LOL! I think that I would do the same if cops here did the same. It must be quite annoying. I've heard that they still do the same in Moscow.
What do you mean "they still do the same in Moscow"? I work in Mosocw and I never heard that the citizens show own tits for cops. ;-) Though Russian cops are dark horses... :))))
@PyccoTypucmo И ЧЕГО???!!! Я конечно не гений в английском, но ничего дающего ответ на мой вопрос не заметила... И если Вам религия не позволяет корректно и информативно ответить на мой вопрос, то лучше его проигнорируйте или и вовсе удалите :) я не обижусь...
Вот сразу же надо обижаться. ;-) Я тоже не гений в английском... Там написано, что субтитры - DVDRip, то бишь с диска. Мне эти субтитры прислал один американец. Субтитры с официального релиза диска в Штатах. Вот и всё. ;-)
Memorable film. The little boy Philipchuk was incredible. Thank you so much for the continued exposure to excellent Russian cinema....and the Eng subs.
MY GOODNESS IVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS MOVIE FOR MORE THAN 8 YEARS AND HAVE FINALLY FOUND IT. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR POSTING IT HERE. THIS MOVIES BRINGS ME TO TEARS EVERYTIME I WATCH IT. DEFINITELY 1 OF MY FAVORITE MOVIES OF ALL TIME. P.S SANJA WENT THRU SO MUCH AS A CHILD...ANYWAYS ONCE AGAIN THANK YOU!!!!
Sorry but these movies are not better because they are "Russian",; They are better because the artists, the director or the photographer is better, nationality has got nothing to do whit art, nor with the life of human being.
@dormouse72 Alright, but it just so happens that in Russia they make many outstanding and moving films! Some nations are better than others at certain things!
Yeah, Eastern European film makers have been doing it right since the 1920s. The new version of Taras Bulba, for example, is a trillion times better than that atrocious Hollywood attempt.
@Vovk3 You are so right! I can watch the Russian version of Taras Bulba again and again. I like also Bodrov's films. The Hollywood version is just Western in Russian customs.
@Vovk3 you are so right! I can watch the Russian version of Taras Bulba again and again. The Hollywood version is only Western in Russian costumes, not worth watching at all.
supper
monishanand 3 weeks ago
Masterpiece
venkatmolugu 3 weeks ago
i don't wanna see movies like this when mother and child left alone and become miserable fuck this movie it made me sad
IRyu03 3 weeks ago
@IRyu03 this is life.. not everything has a happy ending. Feeling pain of others makes you a better person, more sympathetic, more willing to help in real life. If you think about it, being selfish is thinking of only what makes you happy and sad.
mrkv39 3 weeks ago
This is not a good movie. A good movie is one which transmits goodness to the viewer even amidst tragedies or sorrow or whatever. But here this movie confuses the viewer. It is simply absurd to suggest in the colonel, a liking or anxiousness to meet the criminal villain of his and his mother's lives' spoiler. No this movie is a not good.
prasadmt10 4 weeks ago
Wonderful, thanks for the upload.
mashhh 1 month ago
enjoyed the movie
1nirvanaseeker 1 month ago
awesome movie
Artiksin 1 month ago
fantastic movie
Violettasheikh 1 month ago
One of the saddest and most moving films I've seen in a long while! Extraordinary!
TheLightBearer1969 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Interesting, Russians generally aren't as liberal about showing shirtless-scenes as say the Americans or the Germans, (Here's a real exception though around 10:32)
Deader87 2 months ago
Comment removed
Deader87 2 months ago
That was lovely, I'm now in love with Russian movies. Goodbye Hollywood!
orientnayan 2 months ago
There must be two versions of this movie. It was show on Dutch tv, but after Sanja shoots Toljan he continues his life saying there is nothing, nothing. I am very suprised there is another version where Sanja is much older and sees the image of his real father again! Why is there two versions of this film?
MyTovarish 3 months ago
Я не отвечают превосходных степеней, чтобы описать это невероятно хороший фильм.
Браво всей команде!
Благодаря PyccoTypucmo для обмена его с английского subititles.
Просьба поделиться более такие фильмы с английскими субтитрами.
Rizwanbinriaz 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thanks PyccoTypucmo for the upload...... such a worth watching movie...........
flyovertheocean 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Really good film!
tmalisauskas 3 months ago
horoshii film' , spasibo
tig0rp00d 4 months ago
i came across this movie by accident... i watched it on a whim.. and i loved it.
renniepoo 5 months ago 2
its really best movie
cocosheno 5 months ago
ayayay
motodragon89 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i like when 55.03 minutes
msmudah1 5 months ago
i like when 55.03 minutes..hahaha
msmudah1 5 months ago
christ this was depressing. really good acting and cinematography and everything though.
rcmontecalvo 5 months ago
I thought it was reallly good!! I'm so glad there were english subtitles!
teresa93xxxx 5 months ago
Loved this film - spasibo bolshoi! Any chance of finding the following films with or without English subtitles? Серебряные озера (1980 ), Подготовка к экзамену (1979)? Would be really grateful!
suescrivs 5 months ago
Do you know the name of the song in the minute 30:00?
solimarra 6 months ago
@solimarra watch?v=M0UZL09kkAk
Raffida 5 months ago
the song is called Эх дороги
MsAlinkaDetelinka 5 months ago
@FunkyDudee93 wrong the irish did for hundreds of years in hands of brits and many more in africa
michealealn123 6 months ago
love to go their russia but they say it so dangerous one could be attacked in street or mugged thats a bifg fear pity
michealealn123 6 months ago
@michealealn123
nonsense...
Raffida 5 months ago
What a marvellous film ! I agree / 1000 times better than the US crap - That is ART
Greetings from France Russian great people !
mindxestep 6 months ago 12
@mindxestep Yeah who cares about The Godfather or Citizen Kane right? And who the hell is Kubrick or Scorsese huh?
iwbtssothy 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@iwbtssothy
We are impressed ! 2 US film directors amongst 100th of russians -
mindxestep 3 months ago
@mindxestep
Kiss their a _ _ !
Sorinocerul 2 weeks ago
tiazholyj film no horoshyj
VitalijKuzmin 6 months ago
PyccoTypucmo, youtube have done you a great injustice!!!!!!!!!!
TheThreeWeavers 6 months ago
One of the best films in the world! It is such a touching and serious movie!!! How the people lived in SOviet :(. But I like it very much. Thanks for uploading. P.S. Oscar naminate. It should be a winner film! :(
DimaNybakk 6 months ago
the movie is excellent yet it is very sad movie- it speaks about the reality of life- the pain is excruciating- the cast o the film is very effective. they had portrayed the character well-enough that the audience could relate into it. furthermore, Sonja, there is still hope- GOD will never left you nor forsake you!
charliebrown0591 6 months ago 2
¡¡¡Amazing film...!!!
miguel142857 6 months ago
This move is so sad ;.; why did they end it so sad :(
SnowMozart 7 months ago
@SnowMozart Because it's not fucking Hollywood!
TheLightBearer1969 1 month ago
@vorkutaman I think it was the case, that in some countries the ending was with Sanja shooting Tolyan and then an ending scene of him going to bed and with the voice in off saying something like 'I had to kill him so that I am nothing, nothing, nothing'... I do not recall the exact words, though. In any case, I agree that this ending is better. The scenes of Sanja as a grown-up man do not really add anything... And indeed good film!
natashkk 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
And the last question: where does the ending part take place?? Is it Chechnya??
natashkk 7 months ago
Thanks from Denmark!
Alphahumphrey2011 7 months ago
Sorry, I meant an alternative ending in which there is no footage with Sanya as a grown-up man. Finishing with Sanya´s killing the Thief in the train. Is it possible that this was the end for some countries?? At least, in Spain...
natashkk 7 months ago
Amazing film! Beautifully filmed and great actors. The three of them. I see the story as a metaphore of Russia during those times, mainly regarding Stalin, but everything is hinted in such a subtle way. Thanks for posting. Is it possible that there is an alternative ending to the movie?? I believe I have seen some more footage, when Sanya is already a man...
natashkk 7 months ago
amazing movie .......wow ..!!!! i found it trying to learn some russian , funny but it really touch me ....
metroid12376 7 months ago
amazing movie .......wow ...
metroid12376 7 months ago
Автар спасибо, посмотрел от души !!
678ytrewq 7 months ago
Интересно, только вот за "битте-битте" ему бы дали по рогам в то время :)
Cabal777 7 months ago
well..... what was inside this movie???
ThePeaceinworld 7 months ago
@ThePeaceinworld
??????????????
PyccoTypucmo 7 months ago 5
@PyccoTypucmo .. i need to marry sime russian girl can you help me?
ThePeaceinworld 7 months ago
@ThePeaceinworld I am not a matchmaker.
PyccoTypucmo 7 months ago 15
@PyccoTypucmo TRUST ME SIR. YOU CAN SEE MY PICTURES ,, I'LL BE A DOCTOR DON'T WORRY ABOUT MONEY,,,
ThePeaceinworld 7 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo I very much enjoyed this vid ! It would be the best to watch it with RUSSIAN subtitles, too. I am studying Russian but I still cannot understand every word .
RisingStarOfKorea 6 months ago
@ThePeaceinworld
mariadolapenta 1 month ago
@ThePeaceinworld I can help, im russian.......
TheBanuayla 2 weeks ago
@ThePeaceinworld You are an idiot that suspects that you are an idiot.
ScorpionFXC 4 months ago in playlist ScorpionFXC's favorites
@ScorpionFXC .. can you helpme in finding any russian girl for marry
ThePeaceinworld 4 months ago
@ThePeaceinworld i can help you find a good girl. just contact me.serious.
marafosnes 2 months ago
@marafosnes yes........ YES I NEED ANY!!!! YES I WANT TO CONTECT YOU.
ThePeaceinworld 2 months ago
@marafosnes I WILL BE DOCTOR!!!!!
ThePeaceinworld 2 months ago
@ThePeaceinworld And I will be a fireman!
TheLightBearer1969 1 month ago in playlist Watch Later Playlist
The actor who plays the thief looks like english actor James Purefoy and both of them are very good actors !!
03saddy 7 months ago
@03saddy and the girl is Russian Denise Richards
Cabal777 7 months ago
Товарищи, как называется фильм в 00:58:21 ?
Corvusdotensis 8 months ago
@Corvusdotensis
Это на 58-й минуте? Обалдеть! Я хотел бы помочь, но боюсь, что долго ждать придётся, пока буфер заполнится инфой. Хотя... я попробую глянуть. ;-)
PyccoTypucmo 8 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo
Просто нажми в других местах на видео.
Corvusdotensis 8 months ago
@Corvusdotensis этот фильм называется "Весна" 1947 года.
RedWhiteAnny 7 months ago
0:56:50 is the funnies moment of the film! The militiamen ask him his documments and he shows his chest, LOL! I think that I would do the same if cops here did the same. It must be quite annoying. I've heard that they still do the same in Moscow.
Corvusdotensis 8 months ago
@Corvusdotensis
What do you mean "they still do the same in Moscow"? I work in Mosocw and I never heard that the citizens show own tits for cops. ;-) Though Russian cops are dark horses... :))))
PyccoTypucmo 8 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo
You did not understand. When I said "they still do the same in Moscow", I meant that cops are used to ask for your documents. ^^
Corvusdotensis 8 months ago
@Corvusdotensis ja ja ja ja.... :D
Stoner075 8 months ago
Fantastico film, uno dei miei preferiti !!!! Grazie per averlo messo in onda :-)
federricoilgrande 9 months ago
amazing movie...
thanks you very much PyccoTypucmo !
vinyvinyboy 9 months ago
Spasibo! ochen horoshii film!!
Balticsea89 9 months ago
Great movie. Thanks for posting.
241hnd 9 months ago 2
I loved it...
lithprincess 9 months ago 2
Эй, а кто субтитры пишет? Я конечно понимаю, что идеального перевода быть не может, но друг=asshole (0:18:09) это уже через чур!!
catiyujin 9 months ago 3
@catiyujin
Эй, а поглядеть информацию к видео это как, не судьба? Или религия не позволяет? :-)))
PyccoTypucmo 9 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo И ЧЕГО???!!! Я конечно не гений в английском, но ничего дающего ответ на мой вопрос не заметила... И если Вам религия не позволяет корректно и информативно ответить на мой вопрос, то лучше его проигнорируйте или и вовсе удалите :) я не обижусь...
catiyujin 9 months ago
@catiyujin
Вот сразу же надо обижаться. ;-) Я тоже не гений в английском... Там написано, что субтитры - DVDRip, то бишь с диска. Мне эти субтитры прислал один американец. Субтитры с официального релиза диска в Штатах. Вот и всё. ;-)
PyccoTypucmo 9 months ago
@PyccoTypucmo Понятно. Спасибо.
catiyujin 9 months ago
Memorable film. The little boy Philipchuk was incredible. Thank you so much for the continued exposure to excellent Russian cinema....and the Eng subs.
lielle7 10 months ago 4
MY GOODNESS IVE BEEN LOOKING FOR THIS MOVIE FOR MORE THAN 8 YEARS AND HAVE FINALLY FOUND IT. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR POSTING IT HERE. THIS MOVIES BRINGS ME TO TEARS EVERYTIME I WATCH IT. DEFINITELY 1 OF MY FAVORITE MOVIES OF ALL TIME. P.S SANJA WENT THRU SO MUCH AS A CHILD...ANYWAYS ONCE AGAIN THANK YOU!!!!
sweetj15 10 months ago 4
exellent film
enrike71 11 months ago 3
one of my fav movies
svetlana0881 11 months ago 4
@svetlana0881 ya uchus russkiy yazik v universitete... i ya perecmotryu etot film vso i vso... vladimir mashkov horoshiy actor
SecretPrince 11 months ago
Thank you for uploading this. Great movie
kiazilla 11 months ago 14
These Russian films are thousand times better than any Hollywood production.
teresavivarium 11 months ago 44
@teresavivarium thats right.....Hollywood movies are too fake with no emotion and sense of the real things in life.
8187daytheory 11 months ago 2
@teresavivarium
Sorry but these movies are not better because they are "Russian",; They are better because the artists, the director or the photographer is better, nationality has got nothing to do whit art, nor with the life of human being.
dormouse72 10 months ago
@dormouse72
Culture has everything to do with art and with the life of a human being.
KarmicScales 10 months ago
@dormouse72 Alright, but it just so happens that in Russia they make many outstanding and moving films! Some nations are better than others at certain things!
TheLightBearer1969 1 month ago
@teresavivarium
The answer is quite simple:in Hollywood the films are made by MONEY, in Russia (and Europe, mostly), by TALENT.I agree with your judgement 100%
garybagrov 6 months ago
@garybagrov not really. there are plenty of art films in the US as well. Guys like P.T.Anderson or Coen Bros. never make movies for money.
iwbtssothy 3 months ago
@teresavivarium
Yeah, Eastern European film makers have been doing it right since the 1920s. The new version of Taras Bulba, for example, is a trillion times better than that atrocious Hollywood attempt.
Vovk3 5 months ago
@Vovk3 You are so right! I can watch the Russian version of Taras Bulba again and again. I like also Bodrov's films. The Hollywood version is just Western in Russian customs.
teresavivarium 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Vovk3 you are so right! I can watch the Russian version of Taras Bulba again and again. The Hollywood version is only Western in Russian costumes, not worth watching at all.
teresavivarium 5 months ago
Comment removed
teresavivarium 11 months ago