The Rosetta Stone (like many egyptian's antiquitys) has been stolen by the britishs to Napoleon/ So, the british museum can say: "Thank you Napoleon!"/
FYROM PRESIDENT KIRO GLIGOROV: "WE ARE SLAVS - THERE IS NO CONNECTION BETWEEN US AND ALEXANDER THE GREAT .. WE CAME HERE IN THE 6TH CENTURY AFTER CHRIST"
Alexander the Great speaking with Diogenes, "I desire that victorious HELLENES SHOULD DANCE AGAIN - in India.."
MAKEDON - GREEK NAME AND HOMELAND FROM THE ORIGINS OF BEING GREEK AND HELLAS.
THE MIDDLE TEXT FROM ROSSETA STONE HAS BEEN WRITEN ON ANCIENT MACEDONIAN! THE LANGUAGE WHAT HAS BEEN USED BY ALEXANDER OF MACEDON,CLEOPATRA,PTOLEMEY...AND TODAY THE PEOPLE FROM REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA....AND ALL MACEDONIANS AROUND THE WORLD!
We were and are still Macedonians. We are not Slavs never will be! We will be united by 2020 drinking Turkish coffee idn Solun holding my Macedonian flag or maybe dancing Zaramo in my Selo with my Macedonian Brothers. Carma is a Bitch Malakas.
The FYROM Slavs came to the Greek homelands from far away, now they want to steal an ethnic Greek name - only a Greek is an ethnic Macedonian.
Krste Misirkov - expressed the ethnicity of the Slavs living in "Macedonia" including his own ethnicity, calling them pure Bulgarians.
Makedon is an ethnic Greek name and Greek homeland from the origins of being Greek and Hellas. Not accidentally did Greeks have the Gods' abode on the Macedonian mountain, Olympus.
i cant believe you people actually believe in this nonsense!! the ancient greek font that was used to decipher the text didn't even have a foundation. Greece has been book burned countless times over the span of a few thousand years. there is no BASES for the text * meaning there has to be an interpreter of some sort a cheat sheet a human or someone of that time that is corresponding with present time *. i mean WAKE THE FUCK UP!!!
The middle text from Rosseta Stone was written on the ANCIENT MACEDONIAN LANGUAGE,which was used by ancient Macedonians...one more prove is that,that we find,same letters in Macedonia,in our ancient observatory.."Kokino"
The Rosetta Stone is inscribed in three languages: Demotic (the everyday script, used to write documents), Greek (the language of Ionian Greeks, an administrative script), and Hieroglyphs (for priestly business
@CAKIMacedonian Every arceologists in the world, exept the peasants at Scopie, will tell you that the middle text in the rosetta stone represent a form of early Coptic language.
dude so if the slavs destroyed your language, culture and civilization how do you say now that you are macedonian like alexander the great when there is nothing similar? Alexander the Great was Greek his father was participating in the olympic games (Only greeks had the right to do it)... You guys seem a bit confused... you try to find a link with people who existed 2500 years ago when your people came to balcans around 7th century after Christ... read history
"...This decree shall be inscribed on a stela of hard stone in savres and NATIVES and GREEK characters and set up in each if the first, second and third rank temples beside the image of the ever-living king."
Thanks to the Greek passage we now can read the two Egyptian scripts. The Rosetta stone proves the purest testimony of the Greek origin of Macedonia. FYRoMs scientist are now trying to turn the Rosetta Stone into another one of their lies..
Who is the facist here is for others to judge. What science can easilly proove is that the writer of the previous comment is an uneducated imbecile who believes in proto-slavic inscriptions in Hellenistic Egypt. When a Greek looks at the Rosetta stone, can easily read one out of the three scripts, the ones the Macedonians of Egypt wrote. Which one can you read? If you do not know Egyptian and you refuse to learn the language of the ancient Macedonians, Greek, you are out in the cold!
Tendov & Boshevski have been ridiculed and shunned by their own comrades in the Academy of Sciences in Skopje. They are a MAJOR embarrassment to your own REAL and serious scientists.
Before you start this joke about invitations to British, Russian or American "academies", would you mind telling us which SCIENTIFIC PUBLICATION ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD has accepted to publish these lunatic psedoscientific claims! Name ONE serious Egyptologist or Historical or Linguistic publication, ANYWHERE!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Thats why web page of Aristotel and Boshevski is visited from Pentagon,all inportant Academies from all World!;)Becose thay don't know what thay are doing!;)
Keep babling bla bla bla!We will keep working and showing your real face liers!
You are partially right: I would never underestimate the entertainment value of reading through such utterly nonsensical bullshit: Serious people need a laugh or twoo on ocassion.
On the other hand, did you check to see how many Martians and other aliens visit your web page? You'd be surprised!
On a serious note: You can make any claims you want: it is proof that counts!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
A basic assumption of our research is that in writing the text on the Rosetta Stone three scripts were used, but in three languages: ancient Egyptian, written in the hieroglyphic script, ancient Macedonian, written in the demotic script, and ancient Greek written in the ancient Greek alphabet.
A basic assumption of your joke might as well be that the Chinese spoke Hindi and that you can translate French out of Arabic script. Science does not care what Tendov and Boshevski's assumptions are, Science cares that what you do is scientifically reproduceable. By the way: you do NOT have to ASSUME that Greek is written in Greek Alphabet in the Rosetta...IT STARES YOU IN THE EYES in Greek letters! Same with Egyptian! It is the Slavic that you have to make an idiot of yourself to believe in!
But we read that scripts on Macedonian language for the first time like is written and correct,and Aristotel and Boshevski were been invited from USA academy,Russian academy and British academy for there work,thay say that is what thay needed.
I'm sorry for you greeks but your lies not work!;)
I am sure you can find "old stones" in the "ancient" land of FYROM where tiny humans are depicted prooving that hieroglyfics were actually derived from the "ancient macedonian" language a strongly slavic language of a nation that uhmm came to balcans in the 6th century... oops
If FYROM is trying to establish a window to the path via these silly and totally non-scientific arguments, I suggest we should let them make an ass of themselves. You do very well guys indeed... congrats tell us more... I think that hieroglyfic were also derived from "ancient macedonian" how about that? Sounds even cooler!
The Rosetta Stone is a stone with writing on it in two languages (Egyptian and Greek), using three scripts (hieroglyphic, demotic and Greek). Why? Hieroglyfic was a dead language and this stone used the two dominant scripts of Egyptian and Greek to decode the hieroglyfic script.
A basic assumption of our research is that in writing the text on the Rosetta Stone three scripts were used, but in three languages: ancient Egyptian, written in the hieroglyphic script, ancient Macedonian, written in the demotic script, and ancient Greek written in the ancient Greek alphabet.
well nice hypothesis... I'm sure you'll have to try very hard to prove the hypothesis of this "research". Of course everyone has the right to write science fiction, but it's different than science. You can believe in aliens if you like too...
What Tendov and Boshevski have "proven" is a total joke of a "decipherment" making up words as they go: a mumble jumble that makes no sense. They cannot come up with a coherent translation because they start with the WRONG assumptions: that the rulling class of Ptolemaic Egypt was not Greek speaking Macedonians but that their language was...Slavic similar to the idiom spoken in Skopje. The Demotic script of the Rosetta is EGYPTIAN, NOT Slavomacedonian & it has been translated since the 1840's!
You say it is odd that Egyptians used two diferent scripts for their language...but let's remember for a second, in your own Yugoslavia, you had Serbocroatian, by all accounts the same language written in latin script by Croats and Cyrilic script by Serbs.
Hieroglyphs were only read and written by the prielstly class in Egypt, while merchants and others wrote their contracts and letters in the demotic script which derived from hieroglyphic.
I know, many languages use or used different scripts. Egyptian is one of them: Four different scripts: Hieroglyphic, Hieratic, Demotic and Koptic, all for the same language. There are two nationalistic pseudo-"scientists" in Skopje, Tendov and Boshevski who claim that the Rosetta stone's Demotic script is not Egyptian but some supposed ancient macedonian language similar to the Bulgarian-Slavic language of FYROM. They try to "prove" that ancient Macedonians did not speak Greek but Slavic.
Do you have any idea how much Bulgarians, who speak a similar (if not identical) language as you do, laugh at your idiotic attempts to find pre 6th century roots in Macedonia? You seem as ridiculous as Turks claiming that they are Hittites and Albanians claiming they are Epirotes or Illyrians...
I do not need to come to Kokkino...I am in Chicago and the University of Chicago's "Oriental Institute" is here. Would you like me to send you their Dictionary of the Egyptian Demotic? Yes, that disctionary your pseudo-"scientists" say they dismiss, because it contradicts their lunatic frindge theories!
Let me also make a comment here: You guys make it SO DAMN EASY for us Greeks to push you in the corner...why can't you (FOR A CHANGE!) start basing yourselves on truth, reality and science?
Even odder, because we have this language here - in Macedonia.
You have what? Egyptian? I thought you speak Urdu...having read some of your websites about finding your cousins in the Pakistani mountains...relax, people: self ridicule should have a limit, and you do not respect even that limit!
VERY ODD, indeed, dear volk2234, for people who are clueless...of history.
Turkish has been written in three different scripts (Arabic, Greek and Latin), Romanian in two scripts (Cyrilic and Latin), Albanian in two scripts (Greek and Latin).
Hieroglyphic was the Hieratic script of ancient Egyptian. Then arround 600BC Demotic came into being based losely on the hieroglyphic, until 400 AD. In the Christian era Coptic was invented based on Greek & it is still being used in the Coptic Church now.
What about the curse tablet of Pella. It is from 400BC. The writing is older than the Rosseta Stone. Did Macedonians changed the alphabet? Did this spell was more official than the Roseta stone and was written by educated Macedonians who didnt speak Greek in everyday communication?
Demotic script derived from the earlier pictographic hieroglyphic inscriptions and the cursive hieratic script, and it began to replace hieratic writing during the reign of Psamtik I (664--610 bc). By the 5th century bc, demotic script had come into use everywhere in Egypt for business and literary purposes, although hieratic remained in use for religious texts. The demotic script began to be displaced by Greek during the Ptolemaic period (304--30 bc).
the issue of Rosetta. I feel sorry on behalf of decent and serious Slav Macedonians for the garbage these pseudoscientists are coming up with: The languages in Rosetta are Two: Hellenistic Greek and Egyptian, the last written in both Hieroglyphic and Demotic Script.
Used to historical falacies, they have now gone overboard, from fantasy into historic lunacy.
Questions : if there was an "ancient macedonsky" language and writing / alphabet WHY Alexandros did not keep and spread HIS ancestor's language & culture in his territories? Why he acted as a traitor to his nation.?
WHY Alexandros and his race betrayed their ancient history, heritage, culture etc, by choosing a foreign language taken FROM HIS ... GREEK ENEMIES who has destroyed ?
A basic assumption of our research is that in writing the text on the Rosetta Stone three scripts were used, but in three languages: ancient Egyptian, written in the hieroglyphic script, ancient Macedonian, written in the demotic script, and ancient Greek written in the ancient Greek alphabet.
How pathetic can some people be to try and falsify history by claiming that the middle text in the Rosetta Stone is Macedonian. Seriously people, get a life! The more you try to spread lies the more you make people look at history and the more they don't trust a word you say. Everyone knows the middle text is Demotic Egyptian and had nothing to do with Macedonians who spoke Greek anyway.
How can anyone doubt the Greekness of Macedonia? Some people have no brain at all :D
deedeegr100 5 months ago
The Rosetta Stone (like many egyptian's antiquitys) has been stolen by the britishs to Napoleon/ So, the british museum can say: "Thank you Napoleon!"/
verobinful 1 year ago
one of the tree languages on the ROSETA STONE is ANCIENT MACEDONIAN!!
men001full 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FYROM PRESIDENT KIRO GLIGOROV: "WE ARE SLAVS - THERE IS NO CONNECTION BETWEEN US AND ALEXANDER THE GREAT .. WE CAME HERE IN THE 6TH CENTURY AFTER CHRIST"
Alexander the Great speaking with Diogenes, "I desire that victorious HELLENES SHOULD DANCE AGAIN - in India.."
MAKEDON - GREEK NAME AND HOMELAND FROM THE ORIGINS OF BEING GREEK AND HELLAS.
SMYRNAfreedom 1 year ago
THE MIDDLE TEXT FROM ROSSETA STONE HAS BEEN WRITEN ON ANCIENT MACEDONIAN! THE LANGUAGE WHAT HAS BEEN USED BY ALEXANDER OF MACEDON,CLEOPATRA,PTOLEMEY...AND TODAY THE PEOPLE FROM REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA....AND ALL MACEDONIANS AROUND THE WORLD!
CAKIMacedonian 1 year ago
@CAKIMacedonian
if you ever mentioned that outside Fyrom. ALL of world Academic world will LOUGH with you
2005defender 1 year ago 2
I have a question : How is it possible to decipher a whole language only having these few lines in hieroglyphs?
hilbert2547 1 year ago
Skopian you are either crook or cretin.
You can talk directly with a Slav-speaking person (especially a Bulgarian).
Your language is Slavic.
PPOLL01 2 years ago
We were and are still Macedonians. We are not Slavs never will be! We will be united by 2020 drinking Turkish coffee idn Solun holding my Macedonian flag or maybe dancing Zaramo in my Selo with my Macedonian Brothers. Carma is a Bitch Malakas.
88reltih88 2 years ago
@88reltith....
Are "Macedonians" Slavs?
If YES? Then why Gruevski and your new schoolars books said you are not Slavs?
If NO? The why Tentov show that the rosetta stone is an evidence that Ancient MAcedonians were Slavs?
hoplitespao 2 years ago
@88reltih88
The FYROM Slavs came to the Greek homelands from far away, now they want to steal an ethnic Greek name - only a Greek is an ethnic Macedonian.
Krste Misirkov - expressed the ethnicity of the Slavs living in "Macedonia" including his own ethnicity, calling them pure Bulgarians.
Makedon is an ethnic Greek name and Greek homeland from the origins of being Greek and Hellas. Not accidentally did Greeks have the Gods' abode on the Macedonian mountain, Olympus.
SMYRNAfreedom 1 year ago 3
i cant believe you people actually believe in this nonsense!! the ancient greek font that was used to decipher the text didn't even have a foundation. Greece has been book burned countless times over the span of a few thousand years. there is no BASES for the text * meaning there has to be an interpreter of some sort a cheat sheet a human or someone of that time that is corresponding with present time *. i mean WAKE THE FUCK UP!!!
PharaohII 2 years ago
Yes, the answer is yes.
All these peoples are Arabs.
Didn't you hear an organisation by the name: THE ARAB LEAGUE ?
PPOLL01 2 years ago
The middle text from Rosseta Stone was written on the ANCIENT MACEDONIAN LANGUAGE,which was used by ancient Macedonians...one more prove is that,that we find,same letters in Macedonia,in our ancient observatory.."Kokino"
CAKIMacedonian 2 years ago
@CAKIMacedonian
Languages of the Rosetta Stone:
The Rosetta Stone is inscribed in three languages: Demotic (the everyday script, used to write documents), Greek (the language of Ionian Greeks, an administrative script), and Hieroglyphs (for priestly business
ancienthistory about com
[][]
2005defender 1 year ago 11
@CAKIMacedonian Every arceologists in the world, exept the peasants at Scopie, will tell you that the middle text in the rosetta stone represent a form of early Coptic language.
erevos111 1 year ago
Heraclea is a Greek word for a Macedonian Greek city.
Heraclea means the city of Heracles.
Heracles is the Greek name of Hercules (Hercules is latin).
Hercules (Heracles in Greek) was the father of the Macedonian Nation.
Now, are you Greek or not?
PPOLL01 2 years ago
So if you are not Slav then stop speaking Slavic ! !
If you speak Slavic as native language then you are a Slav.
PPOLL01 2 years ago
All people from North Africa,has spoke,Arabian language...are the Arabs??? What king of stupid logic is this...LOL go buy some new brain,blacky!
CAKIMacedonian 2 years ago
I 'm glad you understand that you cannot be Slav and Macedonian at the same time.
You are either Slav or Macedonian.
PPOLL01 2 years ago
hhh stupid....are you all stupi in your Hell ass..or you just pretend to be?Slav is not ethnicity..so your logic about that has falling down!
CAKIMacedonian 2 years ago
!! Makedonija only makedonija.
We are not slavs. We are Macedonians like Alexander the great.
Alexander the great was not slav, he was Macedonian like Makedonija today.
Slavs destroyed our original Macedonian language culture civiliation.
I am from heraclea, not from bitola.
BitolaHeraclea 2 years ago
dude so if the slavs destroyed your language, culture and civilization how do you say now that you are macedonian like alexander the great when there is nothing similar? Alexander the Great was Greek his father was participating in the olympic games (Only greeks had the right to do it)... You guys seem a bit confused... you try to find a link with people who existed 2500 years ago when your people came to balcans around 7th century after Christ... read history
greekmanos 2 years ago
So write in NATIVES (2 systems of egyptian language: demotic and hieroglyphic) and GREEK
hoplitespao 2 years ago
Last sentences from the stone:
"...This decree shall be inscribed on a stela of hard stone in savres and NATIVES and GREEK characters and set up in each if the first, second and third rank temples beside the image of the ever-living king."
hoplitespao 2 years ago
So why the stone address to natives and greeks? Unless ancients macedonians were Natives? Or were they Greeks?
hoplitespao 2 years ago
give us back our Parthenon Frieze
hoplitespao 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Return the stolen marbles from Parthenon!
Prove you respect History.
Restore your lost honor!
WanderingOdysseus 2 years ago
Thanks for the video! Too bad when it comes to history it brings out racists from all sides.
fegu 2 years ago
FYRO'M''s scholars say that the egyptian peasant's language on the Rosetta (a kind of ancient arabic) is the 'lost' Macedonian language!
So let's sing:
Salam El Aleksandar Makedonov-ski!
King and Seikh of Al Makedonja!!
PPOLL01 3 years ago
Thanks to the Greek passage we now can read the two Egyptian scripts. The Rosetta stone proves the purest testimony of the Greek origin of Macedonia. FYRoMs scientist are now trying to turn the Rosetta Stone into another one of their lies..
There is only one Macedonia-Greek and proud.
thawk01 3 years ago 15
Who is the facist here is for others to judge. What science can easilly proove is that the writer of the previous comment is an uneducated imbecile who believes in proto-slavic inscriptions in Hellenistic Egypt. When a Greek looks at the Rosetta stone, can easily read one out of the three scripts, the ones the Macedonians of Egypt wrote. Which one can you read? If you do not know Egyptian and you refuse to learn the language of the ancient Macedonians, Greek, you are out in the cold!
eismakedon 3 years ago 4
its just spanish. god! lol
mafiaboy797 3 years ago
PTOLEMEOVIC??? KLEOPATROVA?????
corfu75 3 years ago
Tendov & Boshevski have been ridiculed and shunned by their own comrades in the Academy of Sciences in Skopje. They are a MAJOR embarrassment to your own REAL and serious scientists.
Before you start this joke about invitations to British, Russian or American "academies", would you mind telling us which SCIENTIFIC PUBLICATION ANYWHERE IN THE WORLD has accepted to publish these lunatic psedoscientific claims! Name ONE serious Egyptologist or Historical or Linguistic publication, ANYWHERE!
eismakedon 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thats why web page of Aristotel and Boshevski is visited from Pentagon,all inportant Academies from all World!;)Becose thay don't know what thay are doing!;)
Keep babling bla bla bla!We will keep working and showing your real face liers!
MacedonianZariza 3 years ago
You are partially right: I would never underestimate the entertainment value of reading through such utterly nonsensical bullshit: Serious people need a laugh or twoo on ocassion.
On the other hand, did you check to see how many Martians and other aliens visit your web page? You'd be surprised!
On a serious note: You can make any claims you want: it is proof that counts!
eismakedon 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The science proofs that you got persian,ethiopian,turkish genes and that
people of Republic of Macedonian are the real descendants of ancient macedonians
get life propagator! and stop calling yourself macedonian you pathetic fashist
you can only dream to be macedonian
UberMaKedoN 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
A basic assumption of our research is that in writing the text on the Rosetta Stone three scripts were used, but in three languages: ancient Egyptian, written in the hieroglyphic script, ancient Macedonian, written in the demotic script, and ancient Greek written in the ancient Greek alphabet.
MacedonianZariza 3 years ago
A basic assumption of your joke might as well be that the Chinese spoke Hindi and that you can translate French out of Arabic script. Science does not care what Tendov and Boshevski's assumptions are, Science cares that what you do is scientifically reproduceable. By the way: you do NOT have to ASSUME that Greek is written in Greek Alphabet in the Rosetta...IT STARES YOU IN THE EYES in Greek letters! Same with Egyptian! It is the Slavic that you have to make an idiot of yourself to believe in!
eismakedon 3 years ago
But we read that scripts on Macedonian language for the first time like is written and correct,and Aristotel and Boshevski were been invited from USA academy,Russian academy and British academy for there work,thay say that is what thay needed.
I'm sorry for you greeks but your lies not work!;)
/watch?v=wad1uP191Ns&feature=related
MacedonianZariza 3 years ago
tell us where you find this information apart from your propaganda websites
Staygold1gr 2 years ago
I am sure you can find "old stones" in the "ancient" land of FYROM where tiny humans are depicted prooving that hieroglyfics were actually derived from the "ancient macedonian" language a strongly slavic language of a nation that uhmm came to balcans in the 6th century... oops
greekmanos 3 years ago 3
The science proofs that you got persian,ethiopian,turkish genes and that
people of Republic of Macedonian are the real descendants of ancient macedonians
get life propagator! and stop calling yourself macedonian you pathetic fashist
you can only dream to be macedonian
UberMaKedoN 3 years ago
If FYROM is trying to establish a window to the path via these silly and totally non-scientific arguments, I suggest we should let them make an ass of themselves. You do very well guys indeed... congrats tell us more... I think that hieroglyfic were also derived from "ancient macedonian" how about that? Sounds even cooler!
greekmanos 3 years ago 3
The Rosetta Stone is a stone with writing on it in two languages (Egyptian and Greek), using three scripts (hieroglyphic, demotic and Greek). Why? Hieroglyfic was a dead language and this stone used the two dominant scripts of Egyptian and Greek to decode the hieroglyfic script.
greekmanos 3 years ago 2
A basic assumption of our research is that in writing the text on the Rosetta Stone three scripts were used, but in three languages: ancient Egyptian, written in the hieroglyphic script, ancient Macedonian, written in the demotic script, and ancient Greek written in the ancient Greek alphabet.
MacedonianZariza 3 years ago
well nice hypothesis... I'm sure you'll have to try very hard to prove the hypothesis of this "research". Of course everyone has the right to write science fiction, but it's different than science. You can believe in aliens if you like too...
greekmanos 3 years ago 3
What Tendov and Boshevski have "proven" is a total joke of a "decipherment" making up words as they go: a mumble jumble that makes no sense. They cannot come up with a coherent translation because they start with the WRONG assumptions: that the rulling class of Ptolemaic Egypt was not Greek speaking Macedonians but that their language was...Slavic similar to the idiom spoken in Skopje. The Demotic script of the Rosetta is EGYPTIAN, NOT Slavomacedonian & it has been translated since the 1840's!
eismakedon 3 years ago
VOLK2234 , you said: 2 languages.
Thats very odd.
You say it is odd that Egyptians used two diferent scripts for their language...but let's remember for a second, in your own Yugoslavia, you had Serbocroatian, by all accounts the same language written in latin script by Croats and Cyrilic script by Serbs.
Hieroglyphs were only read and written by the prielstly class in Egypt, while merchants and others wrote their contracts and letters in the demotic script which derived from hieroglyphic.
eismakedon 3 years ago
Modern Japanese uses two scripts: Kanji (ideographic) and Kana (phonetic).
Hottides 3 years ago
I know, many languages use or used different scripts. Egyptian is one of them: Four different scripts: Hieroglyphic, Hieratic, Demotic and Koptic, all for the same language. There are two nationalistic pseudo-"scientists" in Skopje, Tendov and Boshevski who claim that the Rosetta stone's Demotic script is not Egyptian but some supposed ancient macedonian language similar to the Bulgarian-Slavic language of FYROM. They try to "prove" that ancient Macedonians did not speak Greek but Slavic.
eismakedon 3 years ago
Do you have any idea how much Bulgarians, who speak a similar (if not identical) language as you do, laugh at your idiotic attempts to find pre 6th century roots in Macedonia? You seem as ridiculous as Turks claiming that they are Hittites and Albanians claiming they are Epirotes or Illyrians...
eismakedon 3 years ago
eisakedon@@@
As we all know, Demotic script was invented 600 BC, nothing to do with the petroglyphs of Kokkino!
hehe. ok
I invite you to come in Macedonia and to Kokino!!!
You take a sample of the Rosseta stone, compare with that one in Kokino, and there you go!!!
VOLK2234 3 years ago
I do not need to come to Kokkino...I am in Chicago and the University of Chicago's "Oriental Institute" is here. Would you like me to send you their Dictionary of the Egyptian Demotic? Yes, that disctionary your pseudo-"scientists" say they dismiss, because it contradicts their lunatic frindge theories!
Let me also make a comment here: You guys make it SO DAMN EASY for us Greeks to push you in the corner...why can't you (FOR A CHANGE!) start basing yourselves on truth, reality and science?
eismakedon 3 years ago
Volk says:
3 scripts - 2 languages.
Thats very odd.
Even odder, because we have this language here - in Macedonia.
You have what? Egyptian? I thought you speak Urdu...having read some of your websites about finding your cousins in the Pakistani mountains...relax, people: self ridicule should have a limit, and you do not respect even that limit!
eismakedon 3 years ago
We have scripts with same letters on stones found near the cities of Macedonia from 4600 B.C.
As we all know, Demotic script was invented 600 BC, nothing to do with the petroglyphs of Kokkino!
Translations according them:
A water gived from God, for people to drink.
(translation according to me: apo tin poli erhomai kai stin korfi kanella!)
you mention that: The one in Kokino is around 3200 B.C.
Then this is proof that it is unrelated to the MUCH later demotic Egyptian script!
eismakedon 3 years ago
3 scripts - 2 languages.
Thats very odd.
Even odder, because we have this language here - in Macedonia.
-The current translations of the middle language are like this:
ashckl ashslapqwk vnsowpqnxc nviytnw jcjgn
The language in the Middle is Ancient Macedonian - or Pre-Slavic language.
We have scripts with same letters on stones found near the cities of Macedonia from 4600 B.C.
Translations according them:
A water gived from God, for people to drink.
The one in Kokino is around 3200 B.C.
VOLK2234 3 years ago
VERY ODD, indeed, dear volk2234, for people who are clueless...of history.
Turkish has been written in three different scripts (Arabic, Greek and Latin), Romanian in two scripts (Cyrilic and Latin), Albanian in two scripts (Greek and Latin).
Hieroglyphic was the Hieratic script of ancient Egyptian. Then arround 600BC Demotic came into being based losely on the hieroglyphic, until 400 AD. In the Christian era Coptic was invented based on Greek & it is still being used in the Coptic Church now.
eismakedon 3 years ago
What about the curse tablet of Pella. It is from 400BC. The writing is older than the Rosseta Stone. Did Macedonians changed the alphabet? Did this spell was more official than the Roseta stone and was written by educated Macedonians who didnt speak Greek in everyday communication?
en(dot)wikipedia(dot)org/wiki/Pella_curse_tablet
Anemovroxis 3 years ago
Demotic script derived from the earlier pictographic hieroglyphic inscriptions and the cursive hieratic script, and it began to replace hieratic writing during the reign of Psamtik I (664--610 bc). By the 5th century bc, demotic script had come into use everywhere in Egypt for business and literary purposes, although hieratic remained in use for religious texts. The demotic script began to be displaced by Greek during the Ptolemaic period (304--30 bc).
Britannica
eismakedon 3 years ago
en. wikipedia. org /wiki/Rosetta_stone
puffpuffdragon 3 years ago
If i get it well: Egyptians were talking and writting a Bulgarian dialect?
Does Egypt agrees with this?
Does Bulgaria knows ?
Does FYROM belong in this Earth?
HellenicNemesis 3 years ago 3
the issue of Rosetta. I feel sorry on behalf of decent and serious Slav Macedonians for the garbage these pseudoscientists are coming up with: The languages in Rosetta are Two: Hellenistic Greek and Egyptian, the last written in both Hieroglyphic and Demotic Script.
Used to historical falacies, they have now gone overboard, from fantasy into historic lunacy.
OmegaAlfaDelta 3 years ago 2
Good Point : your official alphabet & grammar appeared for first time on the first issue of Nova Macedonja in 1944.
Till then your grandfathers had NO writing or grammar.
Your "lamguage" is a Bulgarian dialect.
So if we put down together all data
then Egyptians were talkning and writing .. SLAVIC ( Bulgarian).
Well exept the problems you have created with Bulgarians, Greeks and Albanians now you are provocing and insulting EGYPTIANS too..
HellenicNemesis 3 years ago 2
Questions : if there was an "ancient macedonsky" language and writing / alphabet WHY Alexandros did not keep and spread HIS ancestor's language & culture in his territories? Why he acted as a traitor to his nation.?
WHY Alexandros and his race betrayed their ancient history, heritage, culture etc, by choosing a foreign language taken FROM HIS ... GREEK ENEMIES who has destroyed ?
Any rational Question?
OmegaAlfaDelta 3 years ago
If there was an ancient monkeydonian language and writting/ alphabet WHY Alexandros did not SPREAD HIS language & culture in his territories?
WHY he betrayed his history, heritage, culture etc, by choosing .. a foreign language taken FROM HIS ... GREEK ENEMIES?
OmegaAlfaDelta 3 years ago
Monkey_Donian...macedonianchorba.
There is no Macedonian Language...
The text at Rosetta Stone, written in two Egyptian language scripts (hieroglyphic and Demotic), and in classical Greek...
divxakias 3 years ago
Doesn't the second language look a bit arabic?
ekateri28 4 years ago
exactly what i thought
it looks like a mix of arabic and ancient hebrew
MRSUMONE 3 years ago
You slav macedonians are deluding yourselves but continue posting your the only ones that look idiotic....
WRX2001 4 years ago
A basic assumption of our research is that in writing the text on the Rosetta Stone three scripts were used, but in three languages: ancient Egyptian, written in the hieroglyphic script, ancient Macedonian, written in the demotic script, and ancient Greek written in the ancient Greek alphabet.
MacedonianZariza 4 years ago
haha realy can you read it NO every one says is egyptian except you brain washed
kreb7 3 years ago
How pathetic can some people be to try and falsify history by claiming that the middle text in the Rosetta Stone is Macedonian. Seriously people, get a life! The more you try to spread lies the more you make people look at history and the more they don't trust a word you say. Everyone knows the middle text is Demotic Egyptian and had nothing to do with Macedonians who spoke Greek anyway.
gproso 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
three diferent writings
three diferent lanuage
egiptian
macedonian
greek
macedonianchorba 4 years ago