I love both of them! Tarja's voice made me fall in love with Nightwish and she helped make the band famous but she is also doing really well on her own. A lot of people don't like Anette because they want Tarja and it's a little irritating. "She turned NW into a pop BS band." No she didn't! There is still NO band that compares with NW. Anette only brought a different energy. If you truely are a NW fan you won't abandon them just because they have a new voice. It's been 5+ yrs now get over it!
i just became a fan of this band like two months ago and i gotta say that i like both of them. yes, tarja made the band famous, but anette is keeping it alive today. i can't choose because in their own way, they are both super awesome! :D
2:06 reminded me of ikuto and utau from shugo chara. That line , Just reminded me of it. It would be so cool is tarja and annete did a duet! Did you use photoshop premiere pro? If you did I have a question foryou :)
the formula that made nw famous is with tarja! at that time nw was something completely different, because not many bands had an mezzo-soprano as a singer
they are equal, they both have their amazing styles, and they both have amazing voices! (however, anette trying to sing like tarja just doesn't work, especially live...)
I like that you used the old sleeping sun, that is easily where Tarja sounds the best. Her mezzo stuff is SOOOOOO good.
I don't really think the song choices are fair with Anette, you did slowish songs for Tarja. You should have used The Poet and the Pendulum, Eva, and Meadows of Heaven.
has anyone seen annette singing this beautiful song? i havent cuz annette CANT sing this, a new singer who cant reach the level of the main singer is a terrible mistake, its so sad.
Both singers ( of course Tarja and Anette) are very good :D i loved Nwish with Tarja and i love Nwish with Anette :D but its a fact that i hate yuna... so i choose Lenne with Tarja ^.^ (sry Anette its not because of u )
Yeah. I thought thats how it was. But it might be one of those names/words that are slightly altered from language to language. Maybe in Finnish "Olzon" and "Olzen" are interchangeable.
I love Anette!!! Er... Yuna in this one LOL But I think Anette has a much stronger voice than Tarja and she's got more character in it. I'm not saying that Tarja has a bad voice, or anything, just that Anette is better for the band.
i cant choose like tarja nd anette are completely different tarja a fab opera/metal singer but anette kinda punky emo kinda thing goin on you cant choose maybe if they joined forces that would be mega
I think that they have totally opposite styles so I cannot make a choice. Tarja have her voice and Annette have hers. But they're bot really good singers.
Ya Really good one. Both real good but tarja got the most beatufuil voice,more like anette got this screaming thing anette good but she makes night wish to a can we call in pop metal band.
Trop Hot!! Vive Tarja pis Anette :) Je vote Anette mais si Tarja chante bien je préfère le style d'Anette
AngeliqueSkywalker 1 year ago
Trop Hot!! Vive Tarja pis Anette :)
AngeliqueSkywalker 1 year ago
I love both of them! Tarja's voice made me fall in love with Nightwish and she helped make the band famous but she is also doing really well on her own. A lot of people don't like Anette because they want Tarja and it's a little irritating. "She turned NW into a pop BS band." No she didn't! There is still NO band that compares with NW. Anette only brought a different energy. If you truely are a NW fan you won't abandon them just because they have a new voice. It's been 5+ yrs now get over it!
DhampirVampyre 1 year ago
@DhampirVampyre
I dislike Annette because I've never liked that sound. It's nothing to do with replacement. So I don't listen to Nightwish pass Tarja.
AyashaYumi 11 months ago
Wow, this video was great even though I've never liked this 'Tarja vs Anette'-thing...
RiverInk 1 year ago
Great :)!
zanyagem 1 year ago
Maybe they should redo FFX-2 with Amaranth in place of that opening song, lol.
Scioneer 1 year ago
Tarja of course
but i am tired of this videos
we all know that tarja won...
missjessnw 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
anette olzon wins
myworld548 1 year ago
annette olzon wins
myworld548 1 year ago
annette olson wins
myworld548 1 year ago
i just became a fan of this band like two months ago and i gotta say that i like both of them. yes, tarja made the band famous, but anette is keeping it alive today. i can't choose because in their own way, they are both super awesome! :D
BellaDonnaMorte 1 year ago
2:06 reminded me of ikuto and utau from shugo chara. That line , Just reminded me of it. It would be so cool is tarja and annete did a duet! Did you use photoshop premiere pro? If you did I have a question foryou :)
RackHopper 2 years ago
Comment removed
RackHopper 2 years ago
Comment removed
RackHopper 2 years ago
oh man this video is really stupid. youtube is full of this videos.
lopezcaoReloaded 2 years ago
I prefer Annette is better to the pop music. Tarja is the best operatic voice.
Berdimfed09 2 years ago
the formula that made nw famous is with tarja! at that time nw was something completely different, because not many bands had an mezzo-soprano as a singer
diana17rock 2 years ago
tarja for sure!
diana17rock 2 years ago
Tarja rocks
chopantura 2 years ago
they should have kept both!!!!!!
but, kinda off topic, i think tarja definately wins coolest name.
L33tprincess 2 years ago
tarjaaa!!!!!!!!!!!
alythevempire 2 years ago 8
anette ..
DarkToxicQueen 2 years ago 2
anette !!
she rock on stage
korpiklaanifolkmetal 2 years ago
anette
nic19913 2 years ago
they are equal, they both have their amazing styles, and they both have amazing voices! (however, anette trying to sing like tarja just doesn't work, especially live...)
silversunned 2 years ago
ANEETE!
NightWishOwning 2 years ago
Lol Anette Because See here Dancing What Tarja Doesnt Do
NightWishOwning 2 years ago
yeah shes making an idiot out of herself not a singer...lol
07dimeo 2 years ago
tarja is the best !
arti454 2 years ago 2
Anette Owns anette the best:)
NightWishOwning 2 years ago
Yay Tarja
The0Seventh0Sage 2 years ago
Obviously Annette!
RockingHinaSasu7 2 years ago
I love the way tou made the videos!
I think they both are great at their own way.
I prefer Tarja singing Ghost Love Score (despite of the fact that Anette does it fine) but I can't imagine Tarja singing Amaranth.
Un saludo!^^
LupusOculi 2 years ago
tarja was 1000X better than Anette. Anette can´t sing.
LadikSlama 3 years ago
Anette has a good voice but its just not Nightwish. Tarja is in a whole different league than Anette.
0Rox0 3 years ago 2
I like that you used the old sleeping sun, that is easily where Tarja sounds the best. Her mezzo stuff is SOOOOOO good.
I don't really think the song choices are fair with Anette, you did slowish songs for Tarja. You should have used The Poet and the Pendulum, Eva, and Meadows of Heaven.
Hemanthemannequin 3 years ago
i don't think one of these videos will ever be fair considering somebody who wasn't biased wouldn't be making it.
LindziBrap 2 years ago
has anyone seen annette singing this beautiful song? i havent cuz annette CANT sing this, a new singer who cant reach the level of the main singer is a terrible mistake, its so sad.
morrigan77 3 years ago
Actually, Anette has performed Ghost Love Score, I was there and she was incredible.
By the way great job on this video Venetiam, I really enjoyed hearing Tarja and Anette's voices coming out of Final Fantasy character's mouths. :)
Tyurru360 2 years ago
si scrive Olzon, non Olson, e la foto che hai messo sopra yuna è di Vibeke Stene dei tristania
E comunque sceglierne una è impossibile, io le amo entrambe *_*
annasukasuperfans 3 years ago
Ooops...non volevo essere così grossolana ^^'
Venetiam 3 years ago
Why Did They This To Us ?
Tarja Out Of Nightwish !!??
I Still Like The Old Songs ./
Anette Sucks And Her Voice Is Nothing With Tarja's Voice!!
But There Is Still One Thing I don't Understand ..
It's Selfish From The Others .. They Should Know That Nightwish isn't Nightwish Anymore!!
But Tarja's New Cd My Winter Storm is also beautiful ..
It's Still Not Nightwish .. !!
x
MetalChiick 3 years ago
I saw in this video a picture of Vibeke Stene, the ex-Tristania singer?!
Raisilwen 3 years ago
Both singers ( of course Tarja and Anette) are very good :D i loved Nwish with Tarja and i love Nwish with Anette :D but its a fact that i hate yuna... so i choose Lenne with Tarja ^.^ (sry Anette its not because of u )
zimi13laura 3 years ago 3
genial trop bien fais
seb10021983 3 years ago
Pretty sure between 40-50 seconds when you used a picture of "Anette" you used a picture of Vibeke.
Otherwise, this is pretty cool. I don't like comparing the two, but this is nice for fun.
ladyglass 3 years ago
Yeah. I thought thats how it was. But it might be one of those names/words that are slightly altered from language to language. Maybe in Finnish "Olzon" and "Olzen" are interchangeable.
playtagwithasemi 3 years ago
Can i vote them both? :D
amazing vid!
nimeaa 3 years ago
It's hard to chose one they are both good.
dragonmaster6551 3 years ago
TARJA 4EVER!!
aribeth14 4 years ago
I love Anette!!! Er... Yuna in this one LOL But I think Anette has a much stronger voice than Tarja and she's got more character in it. I'm not saying that Tarja has a bad voice, or anything, just that Anette is better for the band.
ReelaChaktovex 4 years ago
And you spelled Olzen wrong... But that's ok! ^-^
ReelaChaktovex 4 years ago
i actually dont know about that. In alot of the interviews, its spelled with an "o". confusing last name.
playtagwithasemi 4 years ago
i think tarja is more beautiful
but as its about the music,
anette i think her stuff is more tasteful , no offence.
TENRECORDS 4 years ago
i cant choose like tarja nd anette are completely different tarja a fab opera/metal singer but anette kinda punky emo kinda thing goin on you cant choose maybe if they joined forces that would be mega
placeborfuckingclass 4 years ago
Wow, It's amazing. And I don't care about who wings between Anette and Tarja but wow those first few seconds I was like AHHHHHHHHH!
CptJackSparrowLove 4 years ago
That's great !
I think that they have totally opposite styles so I cannot make a choice. Tarja have her voice and Annette have hers. But they're bot really good singers.
am47 4 years ago
GG for this video^^
I vote without hesitating for Tarja, fuck Anette.
bougredeconne 4 years ago 2
really good vid really well done :) i like it a lot....anette sings awsome but so does tarja
...i mean some songs are just not suitable 4 anette and she sounds strange singing tarja's old songs.. but both are really good! :)
CherryBlossom1820 4 years ago
Anette sucks!!!
argiesky123 4 years ago
Oh wow! Great idea, masterfully done! Well done especially for the Lenne bits, as there isn't really much footage of her
5/5 and favourite
BloodAndAshes666 4 years ago
really good!!! congratulations from brazil!!
well done, and shows that nightwish became evanescence = metal pop
spawnrose 4 years ago
very unique and well done.
humanslushi 4 years ago
ROFL XD Masterfuly done, I Like it. [I fall.] [A chocking heart, eternity torn apart.]
xxUltraFreakxx 4 years ago
tarja fa venire i brividi *.*
anette fa cagare :s
xXSeAngelXx 4 years ago
omg It's amazing o____o
prisslolxisde 4 years ago
oh my god! I love Tarja!! the one soprano that enchanted the young people!
Cutarrita 4 years ago 2
Ya Really good one. Both real good but tarja got the most beatufuil voice,more like anette got this screaming thing anette good but she makes night wish to a can we call in pop metal band.
fap777 4 years ago
Wow that was awsome and well made for the limted clips of Lenne.
NakiaTakai 4 years ago
bello davvero...complimenti
Maximus1vs100 4 years ago
this great! really well made, great lipsyncing and I love nightwish! 5/5 and fav.
miezieMiES 4 years ago
Lol this is great :D
headofshinobi 4 years ago
that just proves taht they both real good!
mystiquesword 4 years ago
really well presented, love it :)
esper109 4 years ago