Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (205)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • his eyes make me go weak!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I LOVEEEE how he does his eyes! His voice is flippin' amazin' too!

  • He is soo amazing! He is soo hot! Hes just perfect!

  • I believe Scotty has an amazing voice and he will go farther than anyone can imagine... America did a good job picking him... not saying Lauren is bad because she ain't.. she has a beautiful voice and she will go far as well.

  • He's so funny... lol I used to live by him and he's honestly the nicest guy... go Scottymac!

  • @stephiek290 seriously?

  • @stephiek290 you are soooo lucky!!!! i just went to his concert and i probably wouldve had a panic attack if i met him

  • Ruined a Good John Anderson Song!! John Anderson is a stylist, doesn't ave an average voice like this Joker!! George Jones, Keith Whitley, John Anderson, Vern Gosdin, Ken Mellons, etc.. have distinctive voices, that's what makes them great. This guy sounds like everybody else. 2 thumbs down!!!

  • @lwms135 You are an idiot bro.. if you listen to all of his songs he has the same deep voice in all of them.. even when he does Gone he still has that deep voice.. he may get some high notes in there but mostly he sings the same pitch as josh turner and numerous older country singers... (the artists who originally sing Gone have higher pitched voices BTW) . So do some research before you voice an opinion.. otherwise you will look like you do now... like an idiot.

  • @2pheonix You're the idiot if you think this guy's even in the same class as Keith Whitley, or Jones, Vern , or Mellons. It's about singing with feeling and emotion, not just singing, which this guy has NONE, so you're the idiot!!!

  • @lwms135 go shove it threw a f****ing hole we dont want to ur bs and btw he has an amazing voice u prob. cant even tlk bout bad singing go look in the mirror ! oh wait u cant becuz you will break it with ur ugliness! a**hole!

  • @carolbear23 You're a moron , that just don't doesn't get it either!!! It's not about a voice. It's about singing with feeling and emotion, and makes you feel something. I feel nothing when this guy sings. All todays singers and songs are weak, compared to real lyrics, by great singers. There's a guy you've probably never heard of named George Jones, one of the greatest singers ever. McQueery aint even a pimple on the possums ass!!! God Bless!!!

  • ok i have to admit it.he is hot!

  • the way he does his voice, and his eyes, ehen he says shes the apple of my eye.... danng its fine(: <3 like if u agree!!

  • AHHHHH!!! this kid is amazing!! he's cute and his voice gives me goosebumps everytime(: god sure did a number on him(:

  • AAAHHHHHH!!!!! :D! His EYES ALWAYS get me EVERY yime!!!!

  • Oh my god, I LOVE how he sings out of the corner of his mouth and does that crooked smile..so sexy!

  • He makes those jeans look good(;

  • I fell in love with his voice!

  • his worst performance but its still better than the original =P

  • Outstanding job on this song.

  • hi scotty :p

  • this kid will gooooo verry far!! im glad i got his artograph when i could cuz hes going to be the next big country singer out there!! im going to buy all his CDs! love you scotty!!

  • I'll be your lover!!! :D

  • I was I was charlotte:(

  • i love the part when he sings good and the way he looks at that time. Oh and if you pay attention to his feet the first time he's going down the stairs he almost tripped

  • i cant believe he won! he was amazing! he was my favorite!

    

  • i cant believe so many people dislike this :O i voted for Scotty like 100 times

  • @hawknelson123456789 I agree. I did too!!!

  • his little laugh kills me !! it is to cute!!! :)

  • I wish I was Charlotte Johnson.....

  • @singergirl1413 ikr awwwwwwww

  • i find him more cute on the way he holds the mic every time.....

  • I love this song and he makes it even better :) <3

  • He is officially our American Idol! :) I'm so proud of him, and I'm proud of Lauren too!

    And to think it all started with him saying "Baby lock them doors and turn the lights down low..." <3

    Team McCreery!!!

  • he holds the mic like a retard

  • @EndyZnuts it is a joke between him and lauren they where joking about it on the show

  • @EndyZnuts hello they have there own style how to hold the mic ... u idiot

  • @EndyZnuts stupid u r a retard he holds his mic cute.

  • ILU SCOTTY-3 scottys gonna win tonight(:

  • Super!!!

  • He has such an amazing voice for a 17 year old ! omg hes like one of the best singgers that have been on American Idol ! hes so cute and he sings like josh turner and also he can sing like elvis when he did one if elvis songs !

  • OMGGGGGGGGGGG <3333333

  • Ok I dont even LIKE country music and i like Scotty.. THATS REALLY SAYING SOMETHING!!!

  • Awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • THIS KID IS GONNA GONNA GET SO MUCH PUSSY. lolz

  • We are behind you Scotty!! <3 <3 Love your voice!!! You are amazing<3 Blessings from "McGranny" <3

  • I like that he's making all these funny faces haha!!

  • @susancalhoun100 High notes... Scottie doesn't do high notes. If you want high notes listen to Lauren

  • Ugh.. Let vote Lauren, much more versatile country artist

  • SCOTTY FANS..........HE IS THE WHOLE PACKAGE so Wednesday vote until the end!!

  • SCOTTY FANS......VOTE SCOTTY VOTE SCOTTY VOTE SCOTTY

  • He's good!! This is the best performance I've heard on the song ever!

  • i love his voice its soooo deep hehe

  • @Susancalhoun100 ......I ditto that a 1000 x over! Scotty's music is soothing to the soul.

  • country singers don't need to be able to sing anything else. country is its own kind of music. ever heard brooks and dunn try and sing scremo? or brad paisley try and sing rap? no. becuase they don't need to. they're country. <3

  • @MissVee143 fuck off no one likes u

  • SCOTTY U HAVE A AWESOME DEEP VOICE AND UR HOT!!! I LOVE YOU!!

  • Scotty has the most star potential because of his unique voice. People seem to be like "He can't hit high notes" Blah blah. But can any of the other contestants hit those low notes? I don't think so. He'll make millions singing country while the others are singers who unfortunately probably wouldn't make an impact in the music scene even though they're all talented.

  • @i0luv0kesha Very classy. How old are you 12?

  • Stop hating on Scotty! I don't see any of you haters on that stage making it half as far as he has. Country is his thing so he should stick with it. I honestly think the way he sings and performs is adorable, it melts my heart![:

  • I believe Scotty will win!

    He's my favorite, I also like James and Haley. I don't like Lauren at all, sorry..

  • I LOVE SCOTTY <3

  • I LOVE SCOTTY MCCREERY BE MAN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • OMG. I think Scotty McCreery can win! I think it's between Scotty and Jacob and James and maybe Haley

    ...I don't see Lauren Alaina winning...I dunno. I'm a little unsure on that one...

  • lol 116 likes and dislikes :p

  • I love the way he sings, but every time i see him he reminds me of the dude from MAD magazine, lol!

  • HE'S STILL HERE, MAN!

  • I haven't watched American Idol seriously,but I do watch the videos on Youtube...Scotty is BY far my favorite because he's country and he knows it..And people who call him one dimensional,at least he's stayin' true to himself and not trying to be somethin' he ain't...And I don't see why people are so high on Pia,while she was an amazing singer,her stage presence sucked.

  • LOL @ more dislikes than likes. This is horrible.

  • For some reason, the way he sings... It's really BEAUTIFUL(:

  • I wonder how long the country crowd is gonna carry this kid. Its a shame that great singers like Pia and Stefano got send home, and Scotty, a one dimensional singer is still in the competition. At least Im glad the judges FINALLY ripped him this week.

  • @mexbum42 if you havent noticed scotty has more personality than stefano and pia put togeter .....

  • @shelbymustanggGT I didnt realize this was a personality contest. And even if it was, thats not true. Stefano is a very polished speaker, and you can tell he doesnt get stage fright. Just listen to his interviews. All Scotty does is make stupid smirks that make him look like george bush.

  • @mexbum42 listen, im not from the country crowd but i think he is an AMAZING singer with great star potential! so just fuck off and stop hating

  • @pixistix3000 Well thats your point of view. And youre a dumbass if you think hes an "amazing singer". Hes a good country singer with a nice tone in his lower register. Other than that, hes completely one dimensional.

  • OMFG he's such a cutie <3 I love his singing alot, this was his best. glad to see scotty is still on AI :D

  • So who's this Charlotte Scotty? Should I be jealous?

  • I loved this performance! Anything he sings is amazing. Him and Casey were my favorite performances last night<3

  • .... and he looks like howdy doody but worse

  • he sings out the side of his face like a retard, and the way he holds the mic annoys me. i hope this DORK gets voted off.

  • @JerryNichols70 fuck you! you are the retard!

  • @barbidoll0 i dont look like a inbred dork, he cant sing, and whats with him singing out the side of his face ???????????????

  • @JerryNichols70 It's just his style. Don't hate on someone, just because of the fact, they're different.

  • @barbidoll0 you make a good point.

  • @regsroom1 NOOOO, he's a country guy, he's not supposed to hit the high notes, you retarddddd. He's amazing, the way he is. & can sing. Haley & Jacob have no chance against Scotty! & you can't even spell his name right? Go to some other freakin' video. K? Thanks.

  • @DanielleMcCreery Love the user name

  • He is awesome. Just saying.

  • people only like him cause he's country and alot of people LOVE country! personally i'm tired of him already i want himm to leave!

  • scotty rocks i vote for him all the time

  • I liked Lee Ann's version of this song. This one not at all.

    The ego is falling taller then the talent. He is better then Jacob and Stefano and Casey though.

  • Cry baby little girls responding to peoples opinions by throwing around childish insults at people for pointing out the truth need to grow the fuck up or shut the fuck up.

  • I'm voting for Scotty and I'm a lot older than 15 !!! Good job, Scotty.

  • he acts like he's "So Good" but really he's not...lol it makes me laugh...it's gonna be jacob, stefano, and either scotty or lauren in the bottom three...oh wait i forgot, little girls vote for scotty b/c of his looks, not talent, so he will prob. win b/c of that. pathetic.

  • @MusicForeverrrrrrrrr I know. It's really pathetic. Yeah, Kris Allen and Lee DeWyze were definitely the most talented of their seasons. I mean, this show is not about talent anymore.

  • I love him so muchhh!!!!!!!-3

  • It bothers me how annoying this kid is. What's worse? He will probably win because of all the little girls that vote for him because he's cute, not because he can actually sing.

  • @MissVee143 you better watch what you type. He is perfect.

    ~McCreerian who understands music

  • @MissVee143 he is not annoying and if you dont like him dont watch his videos

  • Oh boy, teeny boppers unite!!!! So sorry for bursting your bubbles, teens. You guys are getting angry for someone who SUCKS!!!! lol

  • @MissVee143 yeeeeeh fuck off, i'm no 'teeny bopper'' whatever the hell that means. and if he sucks, why are you youtubing him huh?

  • I really don't like this kid, but he chose a great song and did a good job of it, so well done, McCreepy!

    ps: you know he's gonna win this thing.

  • Will someone just shave off his damn eyebrows already??! and will he sing some actual good country music please? His karaoke covers is making a joke out of country music, which is a shame 'cause there's some gorgeous country music out there. Wish he'd sing an acoustic "Help Me Make It Through the Night"

  • daymnnnn!1 we got summ haterrrsss!!! <3 u SCOTTYYY!!!!!

  • OMG i just went to dialidol.com and it said he got the most votes!!:( U PEOPLE ARE SO STUPID STOP VOTING FOR SCOTTIE!!!! He cant sing like all the other contestants. he will never be able to hit notes like James, Jacob, or Haley you onyl vote for him cuz hes cute...WOW

  • @regsroom1 No, people vote for him because he's a genuinely good singer. And singing on AI shouldn't only be about hitting the high notes. He has phenomenal talent for someone his age and I would find it a disappointment if he doesn't win

  • @regsroom1 That thing about the votes makes me want to cry. Doesn't it proove that the most votes are from twitterpated little teenyboppers? James, Jacub and Haley are ok i'll admit, but Casey is the best!! We need a Casey Abrams in the music industry for his uniqueness.

  • @regsroom1 You are so ignorant. I'll admit, he's very cute, but thats not the reason I vote for him. I vote for him because he has great star potential. Have you ever listened to Josh Turner? He has a deep voice just like Scotty and he's a very widely-known country singer. And just because you can't hit "high notes" doesn't mean you can't sing. Obviously he's on the show for a reason-because he's good. Did you hear Randy the other week? He said a star was born on that stage.

  • @bethanielxx I agree with you completely! And if people don't like Scotty, then why do they go and watch his videos? I don't like Casey, but you won't see me going to his videos and start bad-mouthing him.

    Scotty FTW!!

  • @bethanielxx OMG, I agree so muchh with you.

    He is very cute and sexy but I vote for him because he is VERY GOOD ! (: <3

  • @bethanielxx Are you ignorant hes only freakin seven teen so shut up

  • @regsroom1 U shouldnt judge people they way he sings his personality is great and apparently u dont have one. Scotty jacob casey and all the others besides pia CANT SING!!!!!!!!! im sorry if u goes like them but i dont in my opinon scotty and Lauren are the best SoReg plz get a life and stop judging ppl

  • Worst performance of the night and I get a feeling this one trick pony will win the whole thing which really, really sucks. Yuck! God, can I please get rid of this guy?

  • If I have to watch Scotty smirk his way through another song I will stop watching American Idol....Ok I won't...but I'll continue to fast forward through his performances.

  • @glassjawdave Perfect solution for you!!! I have to leave the room for all the growling, screaming & hyperactivity some of his fellow contestants are performing!!!!

  • i'm "swingin" over to Casey and Haley's "Moanin" video.

  • @MArijawizard Good place for you Hater!!!! You haven't been welcome here since your hateful & disqusting remarks have been here on Scotty's sites! The best way to get rid of a nuisance is to ignore them! GOOD RIDDENCE!!! (Scotty wanna be)

  • @bie2414 Eat cok you fucking bitch. You haven't seen h8 yet. I haven't nothing to say to fucking douche bag trolls like you. 

  • SCOTTY! If you listen to the comment below and try to sing Jazz or opera, I'ma make a roadtrip to Garner and it won't turn out nice. LOL

  • SCOTTY! You can sing ANYTHING...rock, jazz, opera, ballads and I bet you can even sing salsa. Do it Scotty, just do it! You are the best. #1

  • Love your voice ! But I don't like this song. .... I'm not American .... If I can vote , I'll vote you.

  • Hey Scotty when you get through to next week step it up; how about some Tim MCGraw. You will go far and Lauren too.

  • He needs voice training.

    Sure he's not the best but I love country music, and Scotty doesn't ever sound bad singing it.

    God blessed him with a deep voice and good looks, and luckily for him singing can be taught.

    Hope you go far Scotty, but for now, I think it's time to go home.

    FOR PEOPLE TRASH TALKING: Poor kid is 17 years old and nervous as hell. He's up against Casey Abrams, the guy that can do everything.

    Give him a break show some respect for his bravery.

    BUT VOTE CASEY ABRAMS

  • @MArijawizard If you advocate for Scotty to go home now, then Stefano still stays in the competition. I disagree. Personally, I'd want to see Stefano leave, then Lauren, then Jacob, then Haley, and have Casey and James as the two finalist.

  • Scotty sweetheart, I love you and I love your voice....but honestly, you could've picked a better song suitable for your range. Step it up! If you make it to next week, show these haters what you have in store!

  • I used to like him. but now he's kinda boring

  • Time to beam yourself home scotty. So boring!!!

  • This guy is like the george w. bush of the show. Kinda looks like him too

  • Why so many dislikes? I loved it and thought it worked really well for his voice! I know he didn't quite step it up like the others, but he's still my favorite! Shoot me, but GO SCOTTY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!

  • why scotty!!!!! why???!!! i love you!!! but i did not like this performance! you are great but you have got to step up your game! this song is just not for your voice!

  • Terrible! Please somebody get this guy off the show! And yes I like country music!

  • omg i can't believe all of the dislikes on this!!!!!

  • I'm extremely shocked that there are so many dislikes for this video. Shoot me, but I thought that he did this very well. I had never heard this song before, and I perosnally don't think it's all that bad, and with the way Scotty sang it, I think he deserved more credit from the judges and from America. You also have to consider that he stepped out of his confort zone and sang something that wasn't country.

  • I did not like any of the song choices from the contestants last night...But Scotty is the best performer this year..

  • Well this guy has a great voice ...but swinging.. wow.. why... that song sucked when it first came out and it still does..lol..i mean thats a song you want to forget..whats he going to do next achey brecky heart..lol....he does have a great voice..i wish i had it........haley did put on the best show last nite

  • @gravycakes33 Haley did wonderful last night, but she lost to James Durbin in the "wow" factor.

  • garbage performance...this dude has no range what so ever. Too bad the voters are all 11 year old girls who don't know a good singer (Haley Reinhart) when they hear one

  • @20byrd i've never heard more clear words!!! i tell you something else haley is okay but pia was FUCKING AMAZING!!!!

  • @MsThebeMoon what if the scotty fan base voted for the underdogs too then what would happen to Scotty???!!! This close to the end of the competition every contestant needs their own undivided attention and as many votes as they can get to stay through!!!!! Vote-splitting is really risking at this stage of the competition!!!!! I'm Scotty all the way!!!!(:

  • Ilovehimsofuckingmuch~ <3

  • i did not like it and i love scotty

  • Scotty has to bring out every big gun he has to win!! I had the'82 version of this by John Anderson!! He has the other contestants really squirming at this point! I will support him until the end! This is really a catchy song but I was hoping to see him so McGraw, Paisley, Alan Jackson etc.etc. You have my votes Scotty! Love you & good luck tonight !  "McGranny" in Virginia

  • Scotty is hot and an amazing singg <3

  • Personally, I love this performance ! <3.

  • My name is charlotte and this is one of my favorite songs(: I love the way he says charlotte in the song so cute! I hope he wins!(:

  • How can peoplee have a problem by thee way he holds the mic , he does his mouth to the sidee when he sings so that's probablyy whyy , and besides its adorablee :D I reallyy like how he sang this song , when he did his low voicee.. Ahh beautiful :)

  • I love Scotty <3 <3

  • *sigh* Why bother looking up the video, taking time out of your day, if you already know you don't like him and just want to yell at him and his fan following? People who just hunt down vids to gripe -- please stop.

    That said: not my favorite from Scotty. But then again, I know plenty of country artists who have a few songs I don't like. Nothing new. Keep truckin', Scotty. You'll do just fine.

  • He's always so fun to watch. I love his swagger! So comfortable on stage!

  • I was feeling this song, Leanne Rhimes cover of a John Anderson song, he did it better but with a little Scotty swagger! I'm diggin it! How he uses his voice, amazing, didn't need drum props or famous guitar idols to accompany him, just Scotty singing life into a great song...haters hate the good stuff, o well!! I voted Scotty!-xoxo-Meda

  • I love his voice and singing but the way he holds the microphone is getting annoying to me :/

  • He's just a not quite as good Josh Turner, nothing special there. And so far in the season his personality leaves a lot to be desired.

  • Ruined that Chris Young :-(

  • I just LOVE this boy to DEATH!! And for ya'll haters: SCREW YA'LL!! I GUESS YA'LL ARE SOME OF THEM DAMN YANKS!! SCOTTY IS AN AMAZING SINGER, SO WHAT, IF HE HOLDS THE MIC OFF TO THE SIDE WHILE HE SINGS HE IS STILL EXTREMELY TALENTED!! SO DON'T TALK CRAP ABOUT HIM, CAUSE LAST TIME I CHECKED I DON'T SEE YA'LL S ASSES UP THERE ON THAT STAGE!!!

  • @meghan1250 i no i am to lol!

  • Comment removed

  • lol i love scotty and this song has always been SO cute..i don't know why people hate so much..my god!!! he is adorable :D

  • Canta muito ,e tem uma voz maravilhosa,vai ser dificil tirar esse cara

  • scotty is the $hit!!! im a huge randy travis/josh turner fan. doesnt matter what facial expressions he makes as long as he can sing and you best believe he can

  • He’s only seventeen haters.. Good greif...

  • Really??????? His facial expressions make my stomach hurt...he's a little young to be leering. Or maybe it looks like he has a facial tic. His voice is great, but I can't stand to watch him...

  • how do people honestly like this?

    

  • @upssniper I'm wondering too