Dick Clark had a stroke. He is a good guy. ALso where is the NYE (I think) of Christina Aguilera from 1999-2000 in 'leapord' pants, I think? 0:25 - 0:48 they may have had a small audio problem (echo? signal not 'near' but what the hey')
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
What a waste of a voice. If she would make a CD like 'Confessions of a Dance Floor' by Madonna. I would buy her album. This music is retarded. WTF. I want her to make electronic music. THEN she would make tons of money. Ohhh
Oh shut the fuck up stuid bitch. I didn't say she had a terrible voice. I know she has one of the best voices of our generation, but she's wasting that good voice on this music. It sucks. Your gay comment was a waste of time.
i think youre immature to say that the music sucked... because people have different tastes of music. and it's actually good in a sense for artists to switch around once in a while.
I like electro very much but it would be a waste of her voice she's just to good for this
! Trust me she makes enough money ;). she sold about 25milions cd's(and it's getting more and more and excluded the dvd's and parfums..) by the way did she get help by one of the background vocalist in the long candyman not== tunes a little bit like this hehe.
WOW her voice is amazin man and some of you had bad comments well bye and I'm so glad it is 2008!!!!! I also rated the comments and you know if you got a bad rate or good.
this is a true thing that happens! its not a chain letter! its kinda scary at first but it really works!! paste this message into 3 comments and press ALT F4 and your crushes name will appear on the screen!!! its soo wierd!
was it freezin?how far were u from the stage?my cuz said dey went last year in times square since 11 in the mornin and the cops kept movin them and dey were far from the stage ..they got pisseddddd!lol....anywayz diss year[jonas brohters,miley cyrus,carrie underwood are gonna be perofrming....i hope its funn...and not freezinnnn...im so frickin excited!lol.
It actually wasnt that cold at all. Just wear some layers. Well i was right infront of the marriot marquis between 45th and 46th. Right between both stages and right beside where carson dailey was doing his thing. We actually went into times square at about 8pm but we were staying at the marquis which is really worth it. Its usually hard to get close unless u go crazy early
Solo per la registrazione su Titanpoker com con il Codice Bonus CHAMP ti danno $650 al 125%! Per l´iscrizione nella sala poker questo è veramente tanto, no? Non c´è nessuna banca, dove ti trattano così, ne sono sicuro... Però bisogna sbrigarsi visto che probabilmente non lo fanno per tanto tempo!
omg i remember new years eve, smashed and remember half of the night ahahha, christina aguilera is a fabulous singer and performer. one of my favourites <3
and if u think dat she sucks, well i'd like to see u do wat she can do. cuz even if shes at her worst moment, she always surprises everyone by rising 2 da top again. so fuck off u xtina h8ers. y r u even here if u h8 her so much
if u havent noticed, in her song 'stripped' it says dat shes not a slut. da only reason she sings songs about sex is bcuz it shows dat shes not just a goody-goody. she can b badass, naughty and sexy and still not b a slut. dats the reason y her album stripped wuz and still is a multi-platnium one. bcuz it shows her tru self, not somthing dat ppl make up. and ppl luv dat shes imperfect. cuz even if she does seem naughty, she makes it look exciting and dats a good thing.
the whole times square thing is a scam, she's singing facing a building and a bank of cameras. about 50 people are put in front to make it look like she's actually performing to the million people there but nearly all of them can't even see here. totally for TV, typical american bullsh1t
no matter what you say guys shes the best... and why you hate her singing songs about sex? if i know your damn doing surffing sites about cyber sex! so please bugg off!
It's not about being a slut or not being one, It's about being her. She does what she wants and doesn't give a fuck what ppl think! >Thats why I love her plus she has an incredible voice.
Funny you say that. She has a song on her new CD titled "Still Dirrty". I think that would help explain the situation for ya. You should check it out.
so much hair 4 a lil woman LOL a walking mane of blonde hair LOL. i didnt like candy man, if its not sung st8 like the record u hear 2 many flaws but her high notes were OFF THE CHART. fighter was good, its the best li
great performance! and i love christina but wats up with keep flicking her head back in fighter? i mean that gals got attitude lol. but great perfomance especially of fighter. prob the best live performance of it
seven year olds shouldn't be listening to her songs. Why should she have to keep writing songs like her first cd? She shouldn't she's fucking 26? I think she's old even to write what the hell she wants. The little girl parents should of told her not to sing the song. Oh damn well.
I read wrong, so the song is about a guy and her fucking big fucking whoop. The little girl doesn't even understand what the fuck she is saying. Only people like you make it seem wrong. Oh well little girl shouldn't be up till midnight either. So you should be bitching out the parents not Christina.
Hmmm...she's always talked about sex in all her songs. Even from the first cd, Genie In A Bottle,What A Girl wants, Come on OVer,When you put your hands on me. All about sex. Then her Stripped jnly had dirty which was about sex, and get mines get yours was about sex. Pretty much all the others were just about her being heart broken. You gotta listen to her songs, before you said what you did
Beautiful, Fighter, Voice Within, Here to STay, Back in the DAy, Welcome, makes me wanna pray, Cruz, make me over, mercy on me, i turn to you, keep on singing my song etc. Those songs aren't about sex...
I gave some song out,if you ntoiced what I said. I know those songs don't have sex in them I was just saying she always talked about Sex. Please read what I wrote.
"Hmmm...she's always talked about sex in all her songs"
Well, if it was me writing this and I put a list of songs behind, you would make the same assumption i did, which is that you're backing your argument.
omg the performance was AH-MAZING i was in the 9th row to the left.. of course i got there at like in the morning. shes got the most awesome vioce ever.. i luv u xtina! <3
was there live on 43rd street right in front of the ball and right behind this stage but of course we waited there at 2pm that day!...she was amazing...she sounded best outta all the live performances! it kind of sucked being outside thought because you could barely hear the music but she still sounded great and this video just proved how awesome she was!
This just got ranked number 5 on the 40 greatest performances on New Years Eve!!!
peaceiswhatweneed1 2 months ago 2
Comment removed
eatsheetbeach 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
sexykatie90 HAPPY NEW YEARS
sexykatie90 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
date an Russain women and marry her gettop5.infoBookmark
criseldaprangehkg 1 year ago
Christina Aguilera has that kind of beauty that they always say you can't reach, and it's all natural. <3
OzJenj88 1 year ago
I think her hair is kinda over curled. Maybe too much for her to handle.
Sirentone 1 year ago
she does look like a doll
SlayerGod999 1 year ago
I HOPE EVERYONE HAS BOUGHT HER NEW ALBUM ITS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I <3 BIONIC
jaysere1990 1 year ago
SHE ROCKS IT
fibahotate 1 year ago
she looks like a perfect doll
viniceo 2 years ago 5
pardon some other peoples ignorance, but look up Dick Clark on WIkipedia...
TEMPmichaelhansen 2 years ago
Dick Clark had a stroke. He is a good guy. ALso where is the NYE (I think) of Christina Aguilera from 1999-2000 in 'leapord' pants, I think? 0:25 - 0:48 they may have had a small audio problem (echo? signal not 'near' but what the hey')
TEMPmichaelhansen 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Everyone who likes R&B should check out Jimi productionz song called Test me. Its a Scott Storch type beat
TheMickswagga 2 years ago
Shes amazing !
4:10-hahaha
3M1LYx6 2 years ago 4
what an audience -.- they are just clapping their hands when they see themselves at the screen.
I would be sooo excited to see this legend live!
Lizz2506 2 years ago 5
This girl sure can sing. I love her.
SableTheOriginalDiva 2 years ago 4
is the man in the beginning drunken?
x2k3MaxPayne 3 years ago
No. He had a really bad stroke, and came back with a vengeance. I'm very proud of him for his determination.
LindaDooWop 3 years ago 5
no the man in the video is dick clark. he is not drunk he just sadly had some kind of illness and it ruined his speech. he is a legend.
robinsonjamie04 3 years ago 2
wasn't he a presenter of some sort? i remember seeing him in a documentry about 2 autistic twins.
gordon051291 2 years ago
That mans name is Dick Clark.
KagomeHigurashi 2 years ago
im on cam and bored
CAN SOMEONE PLEASE TALK TO ME LQ
FRENKYtheJOKER 3 years ago
She is a legend:)
HegeChri 3 years ago
I watched this the eve it happend,great video thanks for posting.
TOURBOI30 3 years ago 5
is the best singer in the world...
I love her!!!
KraTShot 3 years ago 30
THE BEST ‹ 3
IdaaRenathee 3 years ago 5
i luv the note at 6:17- 6:20 :D i luv her! shes the BEST!
booty990 3 years ago 4
Christina is the best singer in the world .
I love her so much ‹ 3
IdaaRenathee 3 years ago 5
Lol IM in this Video Im the guy at 4-10-4:20 with the grey hoody
ldonbecrunk 3 years ago 4
ur the guy with the "i can't believe my girlfriend dragged me to see christina aguilera" look on your face! lol jk
mlystew 2 years ago
Thid Was One Freakinn Awesomee Performancee(Y)
FreakinnLoveedditt<33
PARAWHORExHERE 3 years ago 6
Christina is from my hometown of Pittsburgh!
padude64 4 years ago 8
she is soooooooooooooo awsome. Im in awe of everything she does
dubilloh7 4 years ago 4
I think you're right, cause this vid is made in 2006/2007 not this year ^^
Fennax3 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
What a waste of a voice. If she would make a CD like 'Confessions of a Dance Floor' by Madonna. I would buy her album. This music is retarded. WTF. I want her to make electronic music. THEN she would make tons of money. Ohhh
W1tchingHour 4 years ago
your a waste of time.
christina aguilera is one of the best voices.
and... her music isnt retard. deff. not.
itsxBrittanyyyy 4 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
Oh shut the fuck up stuid bitch. I didn't say she had a terrible voice. I know she has one of the best voices of our generation, but she's wasting that good voice on this music. It sucks. Your gay comment was a waste of time.
W1tchingHour 4 years ago
i think youre immature to say that the music sucked... because people have different tastes of music. and it's actually good in a sense for artists to switch around once in a while.
ekang321 4 years ago 19
I like electro very much but it would be a waste of her voice she's just to good for this
! Trust me she makes enough money ;). she sold about 25milions cd's(and it's getting more and more and excluded the dvd's and parfums..) by the way did she get help by one of the background vocalist in the long candyman not== tunes a little bit like this hehe.
luvdasexyass 4 years ago 4
how is a song like fighter RETARDED, YOU RETARDED?
SarahWalker25 2 years ago
this is last year....hence the '07!!! and yea she is still pregnant... shes due on my b-day!
KiMbErLyMaRiEs 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
uhm.. no she is deff. not pregnant.. cuz if she was.. she would have had her baby in 2007 and she didnt.. she had it in 2008
duhh.. learn you dates.
itsxBrittanyyyy 4 years ago
Thats true that but people have kind of put it down 4 for some very strange reason.
deathlyhallowsboy 3 years ago
christina is the best<3
Kkkatja 4 years ago 2
WOW her voice is amazin man and some of you had bad comments well bye and I'm so glad it is 2008!!!!! I also rated the comments and you know if you got a bad rate or good.
souljagirlyo 4 years ago
DAMN her voice is AWESOME!
DaytimeGH 4 years ago 4
Her Voice is strong and absolutely amazing
AkariLee 4 years ago 4
Fergie was there this year. I just watched it! She sang "Clumsy" and she wasn't to good! :) But I'm so happy it's 2008!!!
karaokestar78 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she ain't cool..
pagloota 4 years ago
who aint cool, you aint cool.bitch
paramorefanaddict 4 years ago
this performance was WAY better than carrie underwood's performance in times square this year......such a disappointment...:(
cggchen 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I had to try this
this is a true thing that happens! its not a chain letter! its kinda scary at first but it really works!! paste this message into 3 comments and press ALT F4 and your crushes name will appear on the screen!!! its soo wierd!
morganloulilly 4 years ago
I was there for that performance. It was an awesome new years in nyc!
thurbs1 4 years ago
was it freezin?how far were u from the stage?my cuz said dey went last year in times square since 11 in the mornin and the cops kept movin them and dey were far from the stage ..they got pisseddddd!lol....anywayz diss year[jonas brohters,miley cyrus,carrie underwood are gonna be perofrming....i hope its funn...and not freezinnnn...im so frickin excited!lol.
DEBUTS1992 4 years ago
It actually wasnt that cold at all. Just wear some layers. Well i was right infront of the marriot marquis between 45th and 46th. Right between both stages and right beside where carson dailey was doing his thing. We actually went into times square at about 8pm but we were staying at the marquis which is really worth it. Its usually hard to get close unless u go crazy early
thurbs1 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Solo per la registrazione su Titanpoker com con il Codice Bonus CHAMP ti danno $650 al 125%! Per l´iscrizione nella sala poker questo è veramente tanto, no? Non c´è nessuna banca, dove ti trattano così, ne sono sicuro... Però bisogna sbrigarsi visto che probabilmente non lo fanno per tanto tempo!
allineva12 4 years ago
i really like the old christina's...but i love the new christina..she is like Marylin Monroe..i love The Female Idols from the 50's
violenttemptress 4 years ago 3
AMAZING!!
flacilicious 4 years ago 7
She must have been having a good voice day... cuz these were good performances...
mlystew 4 years ago 3
i know...she usually doesn't hit the high notes, but she did in this one :)
AgeLova15 4 years ago
those people were crazy. the one black guy at... 4:08..
CryptonEncryption 4 years ago
Haha...the people at 3:15 and 3:21...the guy looks so bored.
misskoool 4 years ago
lol..i knoe and his girlfriend is enjoying it
Evry1TookTheNames 4 years ago
her voice was a lil shaky..but i guess cuz its super cold lol, i still love xtina aguilera, ive never bin to her concert id love to go
DiazSacul 4 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate her coat! too big for her
punkass23 4 years ago
what the heck you don't have to say that that just makes people mad keep your stupid commets to yourself!
souljagirlyo 4 years ago
nice video!!!
richube 4 years ago
omg i remember new years eve, smashed and remember half of the night ahahha, christina aguilera is a fabulous singer and performer. one of my favourites <3
babydolll6969 4 years ago
i was out there
Juanserz 4 years ago
fighter s best performance ever... she really rocked!.. and I love candyman!
telisol 4 years ago
I love her...she's truly amazing.
Sammy214 4 years ago
Did you notice one of her dancers hit the camera at 5:30. I know it hurt. But that's bomb she kept going.
dancetillithurts 4 years ago
weird that she sang fighter, older song and on other album!
oceansoflovewi 4 years ago
and if u think dat she sucks, well i'd like to see u do wat she can do. cuz even if shes at her worst moment, she always surprises everyone by rising 2 da top again. so fuck off u xtina h8ers. y r u even here if u h8 her so much
xlilxsherilyn95 4 years ago
if u havent noticed, in her song 'stripped' it says dat shes not a slut. da only reason she sings songs about sex is bcuz it shows dat shes not just a goody-goody. she can b badass, naughty and sexy and still not b a slut. dats the reason y her album stripped wuz and still is a multi-platnium one. bcuz it shows her tru self, not somthing dat ppl make up. and ppl luv dat shes imperfect. cuz even if she does seem naughty, she makes it look exciting and dats a good thing.
xlilxsherilyn95 4 years ago
she rock
Evifan 4 years ago
un duo entre cristina y shakira seria lo maximo!!!!!!!!!
rockangelwing 4 years ago
fuck you guys!!!! She is Amazing, she is the best singer in the world!!!!!!!!!! And so Beautiful""""
ashleetherobertl 4 years ago
the whole times square thing is a scam, she's singing facing a building and a bank of cameras. about 50 people are put in front to make it look like she's actually performing to the million people there but nearly all of them can't even see here. totally for TV, typical american bullsh1t
rjr2 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Free adult videos , youtube porn for adults
Visit now PORNOVUE COM is awesome!
monicablonde 4 years ago
She is so classy and sexy and also has real talent!!!
jayesonv 4 years ago
this is awesome !!!!
321654987asdfghjkl 4 years ago
is this presenter drunk lmao hahahaha after all its new year
XXDOOXX 4 years ago
lolz...
krisjenniferflores 4 years ago
If you mean Dick Clark, he's talking like that because he had a stroke.
mangopowerade 4 years ago
the best thing is that i was there, i am going this year too new york city
Juanserz 4 years ago
From 2:22 to like 2:35 sounds absolutely awful. But other then that it's awesome!
McDtNg4eva 4 years ago
i want to move to america!!!
msnmarina 4 years ago
what do you mean she sounds stupid? haha she sounds amazing
Dontxyouxmove 4 years ago
I was there I love her!!!! shes the BEST
jisraael 4 years ago
I love it!!!!!! I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE YOOOOOOOOOOOU CHRISTINA !!!!!!!!!
Att. Anthony y Jerusa
thevoicewithin24 4 years ago
I don't like her outfit. yuck
RagDollCandy 4 years ago
umm really you guys can say all they want to say about her she going to keep singing her songs! so stop
popluv 4 years ago
i totally missed this... shame on me. i was watching the other new years crap. this is pure gold. :)
CryptonEncryption 4 years ago
she didn't write the songs on the first album
and theres 2 songs about sex on the second one
and i think theres only 2 on back to basics
angelxglow 4 years ago
mmmm nice hair! :S
wdkittykat 4 years ago
i crossed that street a million times this weekend!!
studly92x 4 years ago
no matter what you say guys shes the best... and why you hate her singing songs about sex? if i know your damn doing surffing sites about cyber sex! so please bugg off!
xtinagodess 4 years ago
shit I got caught!!!!!
drxclassic 4 years ago
why?? lol☻
xtinagodess 4 years ago
I was just playin. I thought that ur comment was funny and so I just decided to go along. NICE ONE!!!
drxclassic 4 years ago
hehehe thanks i was laughin with the " i got caught" part too:)
xtinagodess 4 years ago
shut ur dirty ass-hole before saying about Christina like this, ass-holes like you just are so fucking damn free
boythichvietnam 5 years ago
she looks like she has a sheep on her head.baaaa
thevisionary28 5 years ago
It's not about being a slut or not being one, It's about being her. She does what she wants and doesn't give a fuck what ppl think! >Thats why I love her plus she has an incredible voice.
Russ88 5 years ago
Im in this video im in the Grey hoody
ldonbecrunk 5 years ago
if u don't like what she sings, then why the hell do you post a comment here???? she's got a wonderful voice, try to sing what she sings idiot
rock on xtina!
jadorebabyjane 5 years ago
Bite it. I think her voice and talent are amazing I am disappointed at the lyrics of this song. She's not a slut anymore right????
aromicdevil 5 years ago
Funny you say that. She has a song on her new CD titled "Still Dirrty". I think that would help explain the situation for ya. You should check it out.
gluclax 5 years ago
Thank.
LingsuCheng 5 years ago
what the hell are u on about aromic devil are you on drugs what you babbling on about?
ladylau20 5 years ago
Sweet sugar candy man
He really got me working up an appetite
He's a one stop jive, makes my panties drop
He's a one stop job, makes my cherry pop hot hit the spot tastes like sugar cane
He's a one stop, got me hot, my my egh pop
He's got ?hips? like sugar cane
He's a one stop job with a real big egh
WTF you think these lyrics are suggesting?? HOw bout the little girl @ 02:42 sing that shit a her talent show??
I think you just got your Cherry Popped Panty Dropper!!
aromicdevil 5 years ago
just thought id let ya no its lips like sugar cane lol
buffboyrich 5 years ago
u do know shes sayin LIPS like sugar cane right?!
ThickyThickgurl07 4 years ago
so much hair 4 a lil woman LOL a walking mane of blonde hair LOL. i didnt like candy man, if its not sung st8 like the record u hear 2 many flaws but her high notes were OFF THE CHART. fighter was good, its the best li
mmmxxxx 5 years ago
She is still hot and Britney can't find a gig no more christina is the best no doubt
solidyahoo 5 years ago
great performance! and i love christina but wats up with keep flicking her head back in fighter? i mean that gals got attitude lol. but great perfomance especially of fighter. prob the best live performance of it
buffboyrich 5 years ago
awesome performance!! yay for fighter and candy man lol yay for the old and new song. her voice is awesome like always lol
jtapangxx 5 years ago
At least we know shes not lip syncing
fiendishlypop 5 years ago
dirty slut my ass!! are you bloody mad u fuckin LOSER!
ladylau20 5 years ago
You obviously are deaf.. why don't you teach them lyrics to all the 7 year old little girls in attendance. IDIOT!!
aromicdevil 5 years ago
seven year olds shouldn't be listening to her songs. Why should she have to keep writing songs like her first cd? She shouldn't she's fucking 26? I think she's old even to write what the hell she wants. The little girl parents should of told her not to sing the song. Oh damn well.
CkyRocks 5 years ago
I read wrong, so the song is about a guy and her fucking big fucking whoop. The little girl doesn't even understand what the fuck she is saying. Only people like you make it seem wrong. Oh well little girl shouldn't be up till midnight either. So you should be bitching out the parents not Christina.
CkyRocks 5 years ago
I hope not but you make a good point It is a Dirrty style song though and I thought she has progressed past all that.
aromicdevil 5 years ago
Hmmm...she's always talked about sex in all her songs. Even from the first cd, Genie In A Bottle,What A Girl wants, Come on OVer,When you put your hands on me. All about sex. Then her Stripped jnly had dirty which was about sex, and get mines get yours was about sex. Pretty much all the others were just about her being heart broken. You gotta listen to her songs, before you said what you did
CkyRocks 5 years ago
Beautiful, Fighter, Voice Within, Here to STay, Back in the DAy, Welcome, makes me wanna pray, Cruz, make me over, mercy on me, i turn to you, keep on singing my song etc. Those songs aren't about sex...
asdfhuliashduflasihf 5 years ago
I gave some song out,if you ntoiced what I said. I know those songs don't have sex in them I was just saying she always talked about Sex. Please read what I wrote.
CkyRocks 5 years ago
"Hmmm...she's always talked about sex in all her songs"
Well, if it was me writing this and I put a list of songs behind, you would make the same assumption i did, which is that you're backing your argument.
asdfhuliashduflasihf 5 years ago
get ova ya self yee?
kaynie 5 years ago
what artist DOESNT have a song about sex in their album??
Radiomite 4 years ago
omg! get a life! your comments are so stupid! you talk like a puritan..."you mustn't talk about sex, it's bad bla bla bla"
heartburn17 4 years ago
OMG! GET A LIFE!
claudiamilhano1 4 years ago
like they know what tha hell tha shit means!! and if it was such a BIG problem..their parents wouldnt let them listen to it!! IDIOT!
ThickyThickgurl07 4 years ago
Aye im in this Video i have oon the Grey hoodie and moving around
ldonbecrunk 5 years ago
she SCREAMS, i don't like this
dfgu1654 5 years ago
she doesnt scream...its called a different octive..she has 4 different octive ranges..idiot
ThickyThickgurl07 4 years ago
omg i wish i was there :(
swirliegirlie07 5 years ago
omg the performance was AH-MAZING i was in the 9th row to the left.. of course i got there at like in the morning. shes got the most awesome vioce ever.. i luv u xtina! <3
garage09 5 years ago
I love Christina, such a great performance!
extrafly7 5 years ago
was there live on 43rd street right in front of the ball and right behind this stage but of course we waited there at 2pm that day!...she was amazing...she sounded best outta all the live performances! it kind of sucked being outside thought because you could barely hear the music but she still sounded great and this video just proved how awesome she was!
quickslvr1012 5 years ago
i wudda flew from ireland to see dis!
dizziewizzie89 5 years ago
So suck i was stuck in the fuckin 54th st, we couldnt even see shit, and i got there at 7pm!!!
Kevinhill514 5 years ago
i hated this performance
m6a6c6 5 years ago
try to do the same then criticize asshole!
mimilametisse 5 years ago
she not that dirty anymore, she changed her image
jtapangxx 5 years ago
You Idiots don't even understand the lyrics of this song.
aromicdevil 5 years ago
Why?
claudiamilhano1 4 years ago
ii lovee u christina :D
LondonGirlReena 5 years ago
What a naughty song. Congratulations Christina You still got it!!! You're still a dirty Slut. Drop those panties boys and girls!!
aromicdevil 5 years ago
HAHAHA!!! "you're still a dirty slut" LOL!!! Well said!
kelmac72 5 years ago
She's not a slut!
claudiamilhano1 4 years ago