@ashutoshjape Thanks Dr. Jape...it is a real pleasure to know that I can play a small part of coveying the heavenly poetry of Tagore to someone who doesn't know Bengali...
1 more thing infinitytobeyond,i hav bn thru d translation of dis song by robi thakur himself.n i honestly feel dat ur translatun is more beautiful.i hope d lovers of rabindronath(i'm 1 of dem)wil not b offensd.
@Anubhavshunya First kudos to you for speaking up your mind..Second let me assure you that you are not alone in the club(including many great people) who thought Tagores own translation of his songs were very weak compared to the richness of the original..I read many old and new ..Tagore and others..none of them satisfied me and thanks for your appreciation
A very sublime song of robi thakur.it raises my nerve in awe-a direct commncn.wd god,nature.srikanto has sung it realy wd his soul.thnx fr upload'n infinitytobeyond.n d translation is v.beautiful.
Too much is going into discrediting a perfectly well rendered song .... everyone is welcome to his or her opinion .... music is completely subjective I like a particular genre smone else likes smthing else there are further sub divisions of that liking ...but this rendition as such is excellent ... we are all evolving ... from Pankaj da to Hemonto da to Srikanto we are doing fine I think we haven't lost n e thing .... what we have lost is Bengali films we hv lost ruchi, lost Uttam Suchitra !!
@inmukherjee I agree it is a flawless rendition. yes everyone has opinion and as an uploader I welcome them either way. atleast it is a healthy conversation. thanks for watching..
@saharajiv I will give you my opinion. The words of these songs are so powerful. If someone has good diction and open expressive melodious voice that is good enough for me most times to enjoy rabindra sangeet. Sometime though mannerism (both old and new artists) puts me off. Acceptance of the style of rendition of Rabindra Sangeet has changed its form many ways from the days of Punkaj Mullick to my generation (which belonged to Hemanta). So I prefer to keep a open mind.
@infinityTObeyond True, the style has changed a lot, I actually belong to Srikanta's generation. But then I find the singers of the present generation lacking in something, probably they are not elusive as the older generation. That's what used to hold the listeners onto them. Tagore, to me, is more of a mystic than a poet and if you take away the mysticsm, you take away the aura, the fragnance, the essence of a rabindra sangeet. Few things are best not tinkered with. What do you say?
@saharajiv part 1-Tagore , in my opinion was one of the foremost intellectuals of the world in his time far beyond a poet or a mystic. The label mystic was propagated by the British elite intellectuals to market him to the wider world (in which they succeeded) as western world would be in utter disbelieve if in those days one says a man with razor sharp mind and finer sensibility has emerged from a downtrodden colonized country only known for poverty and considered as uncivilized. plz see part2
@saharajiv part 2 - contd. I refuse to see him through those lenses. To me personally Tagore is man of flesh and blood and someone very close to my heart. I can only say this much in 500 character. but I respect your feeling and i have nothing against it. after all it is your perspective. Thanks for your comment.
@roganjosh2008 thank you for your comments..yes Srikanto is doing a great job bringing Rabindra Sangeet to new generation with his melodious voice.... I agree
Oh! What a lovely Selection. Superb. The Extra ordinary selected Rabindra Sangeet in a extra ordinary voice, the particular song will have a excellent effect to the all video watchers.
The depth of the voice of the singer given real soothing effect of hearing the song. Translation will have effect on the all real Rabindra Sangeet lovers.
amazing thanks it helps to hear his poem too. I have his book too. it has all his poems in it. my grandfather's grandfather went to his college thats how i have it
@combatmaster1O3 hey it is good to know that you are listening to his songs thru generations. thanks. btw i am curious to know what book you have which has all his poems. anyway thanks again.
@infinityTObeyond: My words are true for the poet as well as the singer! Think Srikanto Acharya has reinvented Rabindra Sangeet for current sensibilities. Am slowly growing to be his biggest fan. Pl post more songs.
@infinityTObeyond : I have some rare audio recordings in mp3 format. The singer is simply amazing and I have a feeling it is a much younger Srikanto Acharya though I am not musically literate enough to identify him +vely. Perhaps I should find ways to upload them and share too....
nice song
punamkarmakar 1 week ago
@punamkarmakar thank you
infinityTObeyond 1 week ago
I loved the experience of listening to one of my favourite songs sung by one of my favourite artists
amireeti 2 weeks ago
@amireeti most welcome..
infinityTObeyond 2 weeks ago
apurba.
srlii65 1 month ago
@srlii65 dhannobad
infinityTObeyond 1 month ago
This is a splendid rendition by Srikanto----Kudos to Srikanto and all those who have helped him render it!!!
parna714 1 month ago
@parna714 yes thanks
infinityTObeyond 1 month ago
superb song of shrikanto acharya...
tulika24021987 1 month ago
@tulika24021987 thanks....
infinityTObeyond 1 month ago
I wish if i can get more translations of geetanjali from you!
ashutoshjape 3 months ago
@ashutoshjape I have many more in my channel..please search my channel ..with key word rabindra sangeet
infinityTObeyond 3 months ago
I am marathi, but since last one month i listen to this song everyday. the song and translation is great and so is shrikantos voice. Dr Ashutosh Jape
ashutoshjape 3 months ago
@ashutoshjape Thanks Dr. Jape...it is a real pleasure to know that I can play a small part of coveying the heavenly poetry of Tagore to someone who doesn't know Bengali...
infinityTObeyond 3 months ago
1 more thing infinitytobeyond,i hav bn thru d translation of dis song by robi thakur himself.n i honestly feel dat ur translatun is more beautiful.i hope d lovers of rabindronath(i'm 1 of dem)wil not b offensd.
Anubhavshunya 3 months ago
@Anubhavshunya First kudos to you for speaking up your mind..Second let me assure you that you are not alone in the club(including many great people) who thought Tagores own translation of his songs were very weak compared to the richness of the original..I read many old and new ..Tagore and others..none of them satisfied me and thanks for your appreciation
infinityTObeyond 3 months ago
Indeed frnd ur channel has a gr8 collection-d pleasure will b entirely mine.thnx
Anubhavshunya 3 months ago
A very sublime song of robi thakur.it raises my nerve in awe-a direct commncn.wd god,nature.srikanto has sung it realy wd his soul.thnx fr upload'n infinitytobeyond.n d translation is v.beautiful.
Anubhavshunya 3 months ago
@Anubhavshunya thanks.. you are welcome. listen to other tagore songs in my channel if you like.
infinityTObeyond 3 months ago
superb singing and translation.thansk alot.also request you to come up with other songs like tomaar kola hawaa,shedin dujone with translation
sunil2611 4 months ago in playlist rabindrasamgeet1
@sunil2611 Thanks for listening..I will try your other request
infinityTObeyond 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
তুমি কেমন করে গান করো হে গুণী,
আমি অবাক হয়ে শুনি কেবল শুনি।।
সুরের আলো ভূবন ফেলে ছেয়ে,
সুরের হাওয়া চলে গগন বেয়ে,
পাষাণ টুটে ব্যাকুল বেগে ধেয়ে
বহিয়া যায় সুরের সুরধুনী।।
sazzadimran 6 months ago
Too much is going into discrediting a perfectly well rendered song .... everyone is welcome to his or her opinion .... music is completely subjective I like a particular genre smone else likes smthing else there are further sub divisions of that liking ...but this rendition as such is excellent ... we are all evolving ... from Pankaj da to Hemonto da to Srikanto we are doing fine I think we haven't lost n e thing .... what we have lost is Bengali films we hv lost ruchi, lost Uttam Suchitra !!
inmukherjee 6 months ago
@inmukherjee I agree it is a flawless rendition. yes everyone has opinion and as an uploader I welcome them either way. atleast it is a healthy conversation. thanks for watching..
infinityTObeyond 6 months ago
I just wanna say, I like the way how Srikanth delivered this song heavenly. It's simply amazing.
pbarua09 6 months ago
@pbarua09 Thank you for your comment. I agree he has an amazingly melodious voice.
infinityTObeyond 6 months ago
the mysticsm is missing in the way he has sung the song .. I don't how many of you would share my view
saharajiv 7 months ago in playlist Amar priyo gaan
@saharajiv I will give you my opinion. The words of these songs are so powerful. If someone has good diction and open expressive melodious voice that is good enough for me most times to enjoy rabindra sangeet. Sometime though mannerism (both old and new artists) puts me off. Acceptance of the style of rendition of Rabindra Sangeet has changed its form many ways from the days of Punkaj Mullick to my generation (which belonged to Hemanta). So I prefer to keep a open mind.
infinityTObeyond 7 months ago
@infinityTObeyond True, the style has changed a lot, I actually belong to Srikanta's generation. But then I find the singers of the present generation lacking in something, probably they are not elusive as the older generation. That's what used to hold the listeners onto them. Tagore, to me, is more of a mystic than a poet and if you take away the mysticsm, you take away the aura, the fragnance, the essence of a rabindra sangeet. Few things are best not tinkered with. What do you say?
saharajiv 7 months ago
@saharajiv part 1-Tagore , in my opinion was one of the foremost intellectuals of the world in his time far beyond a poet or a mystic. The label mystic was propagated by the British elite intellectuals to market him to the wider world (in which they succeeded) as western world would be in utter disbelieve if in those days one says a man with razor sharp mind and finer sensibility has emerged from a downtrodden colonized country only known for poverty and considered as uncivilized. plz see part2
infinityTObeyond 7 months ago
@saharajiv part 2 - contd. I refuse to see him through those lenses. To me personally Tagore is man of flesh and blood and someone very close to my heart. I can only say this much in 500 character. but I respect your feeling and i have nothing against it. after all it is your perspective. Thanks for your comment.
infinityTObeyond 7 months ago
cool song
sazzadimran 7 months ago
@sazzadimran thanks
infinityTObeyond 7 months ago
তুমি কেমন করে গান করো হে গুণী,
আমি অবাক হয়ে শুনি কেবল শুনি।।
সুরের আলো ভূবন ফেলে ছেয়ে,
সুরের হাওয়া চলে গগন বেয়ে,
পাষাণ টুটে ব্যাকুল বেগে ধেয়ে
বহিয়া যায় সুরের সুরধুনী।।
sazzadimran 7 months ago
@sazzadimran Thanks for coming to my channel...
infinityTObeyond 7 months ago
This is nice. Very nice. Clear diction, perfect speed - far surpasses the one by veteran Dwijen Mukherjee...
Except the sudden strumming in between - that piece of accoustic cud hv been eschewed.
roganjosh2008 7 months ago
@roganjosh2008 thank you for your comments..yes Srikanto is doing a great job bringing Rabindra Sangeet to new generation with his melodious voice.... I agree
infinityTObeyond 7 months ago
This is nice. Very nice. Clear diction, perfect speed - far surpasses the one by veteran Dwijen Mukherjee...
roganjosh2008 7 months ago
I can here this song over and over, all day long. This song melt my mind, feeling something different which I can't discribe in language.
waliur97 9 months ago in playlist Tagore Blues
@waliur97 thanks for listening
infinityTObeyond 9 months ago
AMAZING VOICE
pollybardhan 9 months ago
@pollybardhan true..thanks for visiting
infinityTObeyond 9 months ago
AMAZING VOICE
pollybardhan 9 months ago
@swadesranjandhole thanks
infinityTObeyond 10 months ago
Oh! What a lovely Selection. Superb. The Extra ordinary selected Rabindra Sangeet in a extra ordinary voice, the particular song will have a excellent effect to the all video watchers.
The depth of the voice of the singer given real soothing effect of hearing the song. Translation will have effect on the all real Rabindra Sangeet lovers.
SUBHASHBASU 10 months ago
@SUBHASHBASU Mr Basu thank you so much for your spirited comment..
infinityTObeyond 10 months ago
amazing thanks it helps to hear his poem too. I have his book too. it has all his poems in it. my grandfather's grandfather went to his college thats how i have it
combatmaster1O3 10 months ago
@combatmaster1O3 hey it is good to know that you are listening to his songs thru generations. thanks. btw i am curious to know what book you have which has all his poems. anyway thanks again.
infinityTObeyond 10 months ago
amazing thanks it helps to hear his poem too. I have his book too.
combatmaster1O3 10 months ago
Superb voice
arunavamaitra69 10 months ago
@arunavamaitra69 thanks
infinityTObeyond 10 months ago
no words to say...am speech less......simple awesome....
niamja12345 11 months ago
@niamja12345 thank you my friend ...
infinityTObeyond 11 months ago
@fariaDravid thank you!
infinityTObeyond 11 months ago
awesome voice.......... srikanto is so good, and i don't have words to describe the song..........
sabhigo25 11 months ago
@sabhigo25 yes he is , no doubt, check the latest another rabindra sangeet by Srikanto uploaded in my channel today
infinityTObeyond 11 months ago
What was wrong with Tagore's own translation of the song?
kundumn 1 year ago
@kundumn thanks but sorry to disappoint you it is my translation :-)
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
in fact I will like to say the same to the singer/writer
jerkosome 1 year ago
@jerkosome thank you very much. plz keep coming back for more
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
awed
jerkosome 1 year ago
Fantastic song. Thanks for the transalation
goutomm 1 year ago
@goutomm always welcome thanks
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
we must promote beatiful rabindra sangeets like this 1
TheZack201 1 year ago
@TheZack201 true.thanks
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
excellent....
dhrubodg 1 year ago
@dhrubodg thanks
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
bhison sundor hoyeche....
mouandtangku 1 year ago
@mouandtangku thank you..
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
this is just WOW.... adbhut bhalo geyeche....
dithi3 1 year ago
@dithi3 thanks for watching
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
Srikanto Acharya is marvelous.
masud6854 1 year ago
@masud6854 true..thnx
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
Ami abak hoye shuni...
nandbo 1 year ago
@nandbo me too..abak hoye shuni..thanks for dropping by..
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
@infinityTObeyond: My words are true for the poet as well as the singer! Think Srikanto Acharya has reinvented Rabindra Sangeet for current sensibilities. Am slowly growing to be his biggest fan. Pl post more songs.
nandbo 1 year ago
@nandbo I agree he is a natural in rabindra sangeet..I will post more sure..pls stay tuned
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago
@infinityTObeyond : I have some rare audio recordings in mp3 format. The singer is simply amazing and I have a feeling it is a much younger Srikanto Acharya though I am not musically literate enough to identify him +vely. Perhaps I should find ways to upload them and share too....
nandbo 1 year ago
@nandbo sure why not please share..someone here might have better knowledge
infinityTObeyond 1 year ago