If this film had been made it would of been easily one of the best films ever created. Jodorowsky, Giger, Dali, Orson welles, and Moebius. You couldnt of gone wrong with this line up
jodo is an artistic genius. we should just erase lynch's dune and the miniseries from our minds and let him bring his own version to the screen, an immortal version.
Why didn't he made Dune comic book when he alredy had the sketches, the screenplay, the rights and comic book artist? He should do that, instead of Incal and similar stuff...
People who think this should be made today with CGI are missing the point. Go and actually watch "El Topo" and "Holy Mountain". Before you go on about what you can do with CGI, take a good look at what you can do with the REAL. Most modern CGI-feasts are dull and ugly as hell compared to what guys like Jodorowsky put out in the 70s.
Yes this would have been better than David Lynch's 47 million dollar turd of an adaptation, i'm a hardcore Dune fan since i was 12 back in 93 when i read the books and disappointed by the movie. Now if only Ridley Scott would have done it then it would have been better but Lynch knows nothing of Dune. Can't wait for the 4-part big screen movie done by a director who cares about the novel.
This dude needs to make this movie, forget everyones else these guys had it right, and now that the technology is made, I think they should really do it. That looks totally futuristic.
With CGI and movies like Beowulf and Avatar plus companies like Pixar Jodorowsky's version of Dune could still be made for a fraction of the cost. Providing he keep his ego and budget in check.
This film may have been very interesting as an original work but I'm very happy it didn't happen as an adaptation of Frank Herbert's Dune. It is so ridiculously far removed from Herbert's vision it should never be called "Dune". "Hill Made Of Sand" perhaps, but not "Dune"
The presence of Peter Gabriel here also reminds us of another great "unmade" movie: The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway - which Gabriel wanted to recruit Jodorowsky for.
I like the Lynch version for the most part, but I cant help thinking about the surrealistic masterpiece that Jodorowsky was working towards. Id give anything to track down the screenplay he created for it.
Well Dune by Lynch is a cult classic for the wrong reasons in a Showgirls kind of way. Us fans of the novel shun Lynch's abortion of an adaptation for it's a Lynch movie and NOT a dune adaptation, he was the wrong man. Jodorwsky or Ridley Scott could have been perfect but NO they hired David fucking Lynch, i'm glad that movie bombed and got bad reviews including Lynch disowning it as he refuses to speak of the movie or would walk out if Dune is ever mentioned to him.
@Johnlindsey289 : I disagree, at least in part. DL's Dune has an otherworldly feel to it, and it's satisfyingly dark and 'dangerous' in places. Definitely not Disney, which I think would have been the worst of all routes. I do however agree about R.Scott. I've often thought he would have been the best director to realise much of what Herbert imagined. I think Lynch disowned it and refused to talk about it primarily because it was a terrible experience. It was a failure, but a v. interesting one.
Well still Lynch's movie was still Showgirls in Space. I hope that made hollywood realize when it bombed at the box-office with audiences and critics is to NEVER EVER hire David Lynch to do big budget movies ever again. Do you think the new movie could be good like Lord of the Rings?
There has been plenty of Dune-esque movies over the years that captured the spirit of the novel such as Star Wars, Star Trek movies, Avatar, The Matrix movies, Stargate, The Dark Crystal etc.
@Aueneye When I was a child I fell in love with Dune from watching Lynch's version, since then I read the book, played some of the games of it, watched all movie adaptions. I don't know why Lynch's version was met with such a horrid outcome, I haven't watched it since a kid but from what I can remember it wasn't bad, it seems a hard story line to pull off in other formats for some reason, although the RPG game is pretty good. I think you're right about him not getting his full creative powers in
All in all, its a damn shame that they worked so hard, produced the script, the set designs, the concept art for characters, vehicles, environments, plus the storyboards, and yet the project was abandoned.
The only problem is that Dune, as an idea, after Star Wars (that was it's rip-off), Lynch's Dune and the Dune TV series doesn't look NEW anymore. This project, however, could be pursued as a fresh approach to the subject, the likes of which no one had seen in sci-fi cinema.
Dunno bout Jodo's health, but I think HE COULD still do it. He has everything in place, and Moebius is still around. Orson Welles and Dali aren't, but he could find someone else. Plus, with CGI, he could do it at a fraction of the cost that would have been incurred if he had done it in the 70s. He would only have to agree to work with CGI, not insist on life-size spaceship props etc. I think with today's technology he could pursue his dream to the fullest.
@miljenko1 I agree, he COULD still do it. The movie project itself, however, has served its purpose. All those involved grew and learned from it, and they touched many others who touched many others still... so even though it was never actually finished, it has had a real, tangible impact on this world and the people in it. :)
If this film had been made it would of been easily one of the best films ever created. Jodorowsky, Giger, Dali, Orson welles, and Moebius. You couldnt of gone wrong with this line up
baragon2001x 1 week ago
jodo is an artistic genius. we should just erase lynch's dune and the miniseries from our minds and let him bring his own version to the screen, an immortal version.
WakingParadise97 2 months ago
In fact the metabaron saga is his take On his work On Dune but adapted to a new story
ThomasJeromeNewton 6 months ago
Why didn't he made Dune comic book when he alredy had the sketches, the screenplay, the rights and comic book artist? He should do that, instead of Incal and similar stuff...
14NSBM88 6 months ago
@14NSBM88 Instead of Incal and the metabarons saga? are you crazy, that comics are so good as Dune
JulioLeonFandinho 4 months ago
People who think this should be made today with CGI are missing the point. Go and actually watch "El Topo" and "Holy Mountain". Before you go on about what you can do with CGI, take a good look at what you can do with the REAL. Most modern CGI-feasts are dull and ugly as hell compared to what guys like Jodorowsky put out in the 70s.
Metamusik 8 months ago
Is there a way to get those story boards? have they been published?
jpdt007 11 months ago
Yes this would have been better than David Lynch's 47 million dollar turd of an adaptation, i'm a hardcore Dune fan since i was 12 back in 93 when i read the books and disappointed by the movie. Now if only Ridley Scott would have done it then it would have been better but Lynch knows nothing of Dune. Can't wait for the 4-part big screen movie done by a director who cares about the novel.
Johnlindsey289 1 year ago
ha! Magma would be an awesome choice for music in Dune, would be strange to see Lynch's version re-scored somehow
tyrannicoystercult 1 year ago
just hearing about all of the awesome shit they had lined up for this movie makes me sick. I wish it had happened.
01234V43210 1 year ago
This dude needs to make this movie, forget everyones else these guys had it right, and now that the technology is made, I think they should really do it. That looks totally futuristic.
Charlyz4u 1 year ago
what are you basing your CGI costs on???? CGI heavy movie budgets are huge and even adjusted for inflation cost more them shooting models.
blastandboom 1 year ago
With CGI and movies like Beowulf and Avatar plus companies like Pixar Jodorowsky's version of Dune could still be made for a fraction of the cost. Providing he keep his ego and budget in check.
johnyzero2000 1 year ago
This film may have been very interesting as an original work but I'm very happy it didn't happen as an adaptation of Frank Herbert's Dune. It is so ridiculously far removed from Herbert's vision it should never be called "Dune". "Hill Made Of Sand" perhaps, but not "Dune"
Audioepics 1 year ago 8
The presence of Peter Gabriel here also reminds us of another great "unmade" movie: The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway - which Gabriel wanted to recruit Jodorowsky for.
sex6cult9revolution 2 years ago
"King shot" project was abandoned. "The sons of el topo" will be he's next movie.
cherchebruit 2 years ago
woildve been the greatest movie ever imo
Scytale0facedancer 2 years ago
Dune could never be a film
a video game perhaps but not a film
Skinnyoompalumpa 2 years ago
Hey wow Jodorowsky yeah!! molto loco
Je t'aime Jodorowsky
JuanbagGala 2 years ago
he's doing king shot, plus spare me marilyn manson as a harkonnen
ThomasJeromeNewton 2 years ago
I find amusing how he says dune. 'Doone'
filmfanatic99 2 years ago
I like the Lynch version for the most part, but I cant help thinking about the surrealistic masterpiece that Jodorowsky was working towards. Id give anything to track down the screenplay he created for it.
cinemavirtualis 2 years ago
Jodo's version was going to be sexual, odd hwo that phallic imagery moved on to star wars
ThomasJeromeNewton 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
Aueneye 2 years ago 10
@Aueneye
Well Dune by Lynch is a cult classic for the wrong reasons in a Showgirls kind of way. Us fans of the novel shun Lynch's abortion of an adaptation for it's a Lynch movie and NOT a dune adaptation, he was the wrong man. Jodorwsky or Ridley Scott could have been perfect but NO they hired David fucking Lynch, i'm glad that movie bombed and got bad reviews including Lynch disowning it as he refuses to speak of the movie or would walk out if Dune is ever mentioned to him.
Johnlindsey289 1 year ago
@Johnlindsey289 : I disagree, at least in part. DL's Dune has an otherworldly feel to it, and it's satisfyingly dark and 'dangerous' in places. Definitely not Disney, which I think would have been the worst of all routes. I do however agree about R.Scott. I've often thought he would have been the best director to realise much of what Herbert imagined. I think Lynch disowned it and refused to talk about it primarily because it was a terrible experience. It was a failure, but a v. interesting one.
Aueneye 1 year ago
@Aueneye
Well still Lynch's movie was still Showgirls in Space. I hope that made hollywood realize when it bombed at the box-office with audiences and critics is to NEVER EVER hire David Lynch to do big budget movies ever again. Do you think the new movie could be good like Lord of the Rings?
There has been plenty of Dune-esque movies over the years that captured the spirit of the novel such as Star Wars, Star Trek movies, Avatar, The Matrix movies, Stargate, The Dark Crystal etc.
Johnlindsey289 1 year ago
@Johnlindsey289 The only reason why David Lynch's film bombed because he was forced to cut so much from it. It wasn't his fault AT ALL.
TheBackseatJesus 6 months ago
@Aueneye When I was a child I fell in love with Dune from watching Lynch's version, since then I read the book, played some of the games of it, watched all movie adaptions. I don't know why Lynch's version was met with such a horrid outcome, I haven't watched it since a kid but from what I can remember it wasn't bad, it seems a hard story line to pull off in other formats for some reason, although the RPG game is pretty good. I think you're right about him not getting his full creative powers in
Sadochrist 10 months ago
All in all, its a damn shame that they worked so hard, produced the script, the set designs, the concept art for characters, vehicles, environments, plus the storyboards, and yet the project was abandoned.
miljenko1 3 years ago 2
The only problem is that Dune, as an idea, after Star Wars (that was it's rip-off), Lynch's Dune and the Dune TV series doesn't look NEW anymore. This project, however, could be pursued as a fresh approach to the subject, the likes of which no one had seen in sci-fi cinema.
miljenko1 3 years ago 2
onto the metabarons then
ThomasJeromeNewton 2 years ago
Dunno bout Jodo's health, but I think HE COULD still do it. He has everything in place, and Moebius is still around. Orson Welles and Dali aren't, but he could find someone else. Plus, with CGI, he could do it at a fraction of the cost that would have been incurred if he had done it in the 70s. He would only have to agree to work with CGI, not insist on life-size spaceship props etc. I think with today's technology he could pursue his dream to the fullest.
miljenko1 3 years ago 13
@miljenko1
There is another Dune movie in the works
Johnlindsey289 11 months ago
@miljenko1 I agree, he COULD still do it. The movie project itself, however, has served its purpose. All those involved grew and learned from it, and they touched many others who touched many others still... so even though it was never actually finished, it has had a real, tangible impact on this world and the people in it. :)
ROTTERDXM 5 months ago