Added: 4 years ago
From: nicole0659
Views: 177,144
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • looks like i draw it

  • Not sure the censored lyrics were necessary. But good anyway.

  • :/

  • wow...AmerIKKKA'S GOT TALENT!!

  • LOL oh, gosh, I'm glad I never saw this before. Kind of ruins the song.

  • ROFL! This is awesome! I love the song, but this is just on its own level of hilarious and amusing.

  • Thumbs up if you agree that this vidoe pis pitiful, but it doesn't even matter because the song is just THAT AWESOME

  • LOve the song video is class!!!

  • Shut Your Signal [Of Porcelain vs. Garbage] is waaaaay better.

  • @HeRo4qUAD Yes :DD

  • awesome i love GARBAGE

  • this is totally awesome

  • I like how the characters are portrayed as twoo-dimensional and flat, probably saying that media/popular culture is shallow and temporary.

  • Wow, I've loved this song for ages but never seen the video. Thanks for uploading, I always prefer the original videos so I can see for myself (and usually fan-made vids are lower quality). They would have had enough money at this point of the band's career (for the Beautiful album) to create awesome videos, like Go Baby, but this is just awful flipping from two different animation styles. The hand-drawn animation is interesting.

  • This song is about Christina Aguilera. Shirley hated her so much that time.

  • @cheapotimo ???

  • I love this song, awesome bru..nice nice

  • It looks like parrapa de raper

  • Ok....

  • I hate it when media puts word into celebrity's mouth like this interviewer.

  • esta cancion se la dedico a un tipejo que me lastimo mucho, va para ti amorcito hehehe

  • It's a cool video and a great song! and who sayS that It was a bad video well.... SHUT YOUR MOUTH!

  • Man, the ugliest animation in the world plus censoring the lyrics. What were they thinking.

  • not the best video but, as always, the song is cool

  • Eh. Not the worst artsy fartsy clip i've seen. The 2 dimensional square block headed people is lacking in subtlety. Usually i'm more annoyed by counter culture artsy fartsy short films.

    Normally they show their mac computer - its soooooo counter culture and hip, then talk about evil anti-competitive corporations, while i *facepalm* how much of a tool they are. Mac is more imperialist and anti-free market then Microsoft. Tools.

    Damn i hate hippies.

  • Into the favorites it goes, thanks for uploading.

  • be a good boy

  • this video is really cool, im an animator and i think that there something more than just having an awesome animation, this video has that thing.

  • it is quite unfortunate that it's real :(

  • this is the actual video you tards. rofl

  • A 15 year old with Flash could do better than this piece of shit. Song is still good though lol.

  • You could go far, make a landmark, make a shit load!!

  • damn... that's one badass dog... i want one of those for christmas....

  • That dog is Badass

  • Woah, this vid is kinda fucked up...

    But great song ^_^

  • I love the lyrics and the all song .

  • I loved when her hair looked like that!

  • that is a great song,

    the video is um, ya unseemly I would say

  • amazing!

  • i love the vid, really is like how twisted and weird life can be. fit the song perfectly SHUT YOUR MOUTH again if you don´t like it

  • interesting video.

  • the grotesqueness of the animation is really fitting i think. the song and video describe the dumbing down of the mainstream media (particularly in america) and the fickleness of celebrity, so having the video look essentially like a crappy child's drawing is a pretty withering put-down.

    plus: the band look hilarious and the dog playing guitar is a pretty funny moment.

  • great song. stupid video

    good thing they remade it

  • For a fan vid, it would be brilliant. Too bad it's not a fan vid.

  • Bad bad low budget video . Even Garbage weren't happy with this , that's why they decided to make another video for Shut Your Mouth and didn't include this on Absolute Garbage Dvd

  • I think that this is a great video actually

  • the video isn't that bad, just for garbage it is

    it's better than all those stupid rap videos that are only considered good cos there are half naked girls in them!!!!!at this moment in time im bidding for all 3 shut you mouth singles on ebay, i hope i win

  • love it lol

  • Comment removed

  • I didnt like it but thanks :)

  • Wow. 80s flashback! It looks like the artists who were rejected from "Beavis and Butthead" drew those pics.

    Well, whatever. Every lasting artist will eventually have a terrible video. I love Garbage regardless and they should tour again!

  • it really sucks as a ieo..i love garbage, but this is a shit

  • i like it

  • If this is the official video, how come this is the ONLY upload of it on youtube?

  • It is not the only upload! Go check the two versions on AbsolutGarbage channel :)

  • maybe because nobody else thought it was good enough to upload XD

    haha i love garbage but this vid sucks and from what i read they were really not happy with it either

  • it not the only upload, it is on NorthDakotamegageek's channel, + Absolutgarbage's channel

  • whats with the square head people

  • what this video is great, how can you hate it?

  • Watch Shirley Manson on the Sarah Conner Chronicles. She's a Terminator!

  • yeaah callateee !!!!!!!!

  • YEA PPL SHUT UR FUCKING MOUTH!!!!

  • When you talk, other people get hoarse just listening.

  • you give band geeks a bad name

  • You give everything you come in contact with a bad fucking name!

  • "I wanted to be something

    Just shut your mouth"

    good!)

  • don't they also do a non-animated version of this video?

  • He he, I love this music video.

    Reminds me of the 80's and 90's for some reason...

  • you figured good nicole.....

  • Love the song. They could have made such a bad ass video with this song though :(

  • I love this video - it meant to be crappy, and that's why I love it!

  • Hey actually I like it, think it's a very innovative that i didnt expect AT ALL. That's one thing I like about this band, THEY FAIL RARELY IN creating VERY DIFFERENT (but still rocking videos) every single time.

    I will be a garbage fan until the day I die.

  • Waitwaitwait!!

    I agree. But just think that even garbage hated this video!! They didn't make it!

    So they decided to make the other version of the video called internet version

  • I don't like this video as much as like when we made it. It's meant to be crappy, but now I think it's crappy in a way that it was not really meant to be. Thanks for all comments, /S

  • this video is lame. D:

  • just shut your mouth!...if you can do it

  • genial!!

  • you suck haha

  • LMAO, coming from you, that statement doesn't mean much. Go cut yourself now please???

  • I spam your comments cause you're a fucking tool. I guess to you all bands that have ACTUAL talent suck, LOL. If you hate Garbage so much why the fuck would you be listening to them?? Fool.

    A 15 year old little girl who cuts herself because her bf likes her bestfriend better :( is calling me garbage??? HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

  • LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

    Get an education you stupid American little girl. Maybe you'll learn the words "sarcasm" and "stereotype".

  • Hehehe.

    I agree

  • haha , kewl name. emowoman, SHUT YOUR MOUTH !!!!!!!

  • bet you're fat.. and what are you doing watching this vid anyway ? I love garbage :D

  • haha i am fat

    fuck you

  • well if you're not ill gladly hit that ... ooohh u like dimmu, i takemy insults back. *Wink.. where u live , we can make babies

  • yeah ok. thanks but no babies...

  • ILL RAPE U !

  • yeah i am fat remember!

  • fat people are hard to kidnap thats why i said rape :D

  • yeah good luck with that

  • rofl xD

    ahahaha too funny

    *dies laughing*

  • haha

  • You know this song is meant for you sweetheart, "just shut your mouth, you can do it" ;)

  • wooo u tell that biatch ... girl fight !!!!! get the hoes and white t shirts

  • I'm not a girl.

  • ...special :|

  • Also my first acquintance with this video ^^

  • Love the song. And the cartoon... lol wonderful!

    But the frames that really strikes me are the zoom-in frames with the drummer, I've always been a fan of that cartoon style.

  • is it fake man rite man we dont give a fuckin damn!!

  • Best song from Garbage

  • yeiy!!! i luv it, thx!!

  • This Song is the best on that album!!!

  • okay not a lot of people are posting good comments on this video, so i will because i like both this song and video:

    this was an awesome video i love the song-it has a good beat to it, who else agrees with me that the old lady in it looks like the granny from Proud Family?

  • love the song but not the video

  • Look, if you don'nt like the video,

    scroll down, listen to the music

    and "Shut Your Mouth [keyboard], Try

    Not to Panic"

    Great Music, video or no.

  • the worst video ever garbage is great but I remember how dissapointed I was when I saw it the first time, I just listen to the song and try to to not watch it at all it really makes me feel embarrassed

  • Garbage didn't like it too!

  • Lov da song its class...rocks...lol

  • BG was a strange era

  • totally.

  • I love it :D

  • IDK I love the song but this is freakin lame.

  • good job

  • that video was wicked, duno what your on about, low budget videos always are when they keep it honest.

  • i know what you mean and i agree, like with Queen, or even Vow or OHWIR, they have a rather simple concept but they rock, this one on the other hand looks like a bad copy of Radiohead's Paranoid Android, but this one doesn't portray the feeling of song at its best. This is my opinion anyway.

  • Queer* lol

  • i like this video its crappy but in a wierd way i like

  • dont like the video hey? SHUT YOUR MOUTH.

  • Ok, the censored bit is really weird!!

  • this video is sooo good ! i love how shitty it is,,, just like the name of the band, Garbage... Such a wicked idea, so simple ... Just SHUT YOUR MOUTH if u dont like it, you just dont get it !

  • ughhhh! that just slightly killed me on the inside. such a good song. such a crapy video! that just makes me sad in my heart.

  • This upsets me.

    This is such a good song, but the video does not do it justice.

  • Then you'll probably like the version 2 better with live footage!

  • thanks for the tip.

    I so want to see shirley live when she releases the solo stuff.

    x

  • Same here.

  • I so hope she comes to the UK.

    Well, she is scottish, so she has to at least go to scotland...

  • When I first got into them, they had just finished the BLM tour, man I was pissed. Although I think they cancelled the european leg or something so I probably wouldn't have got to see them anyway.

  • Bueno Amigos La verdad concuerdo con todos ustedes la cancion es buenisima pero el video deja mucho de que hablar jeje

    I Love the song, but i don´t like the video it´s very ugly euw......

  • La cancion es muy muy buena pero el video es super malo....

  • Who commissioned the nursery kids to make the drawings?

    Awesome song, anyway :P

  • es la mejor de todas las mujeres

  • Well if you can find the online version of this video on the Absolut Garbage collection you'll be doing yourself a major favor as that video far surpasses... this... uh, clip...

  • The video was strange, but honestly I found it good in a weird way.

    It was more interesting than most videos.

    and if you don't understand how it goes with the song then you need to think a bit harder

  • agreed

  • the video is way too random and doesn't even fit with the song. not to mention what in the hell was with that weird animation style? they didn't really try with this one, that or they tried to hard. god that was awful.

    i love the song though^^

  • lol the video had a certain quality, but I LOVE the song!

  • I thought that the video would be good... but its worse then any other video that I have EVER SEEN!!!!

  • Love the song, but I can't bring myself to watch this fucking video cuz is really bad, man, I mean, it just hurts my eyes. Anyway, that's what I think, if you like it, good for you.

  • Shirley, if I had been there, I would have kicked their ass.

    L.

  • quite original, but honestly i prefer seeing the real shirley and the guys.

  • WOW! The video is freakin retarded

    BUT I LOVE ALL OF GARBAGE'S MUSIC

  • nice video

  • the song is good, but,,,,,naaah, that video is a shit, ,,

  • I dig it, its very clever.

  • lol, sounds like "dick load"

  • I luv this song.....it's one of the best ever made...

    And the video is soooooooooo cool...;)

  • love the song! <3

  • love the song. hate the vid.

  • This isn't the actual music video. The real video was released with their DVD "Absolute Garbage" and is not animated whatsoever. It's comprised of live footage of the band during the beautifulgarbage tour.

  • I recant my previous statement. There are apparently two videos! I feel like a retard now. Heh.

  • i think the video is supposed to have a sarcastic tone to it. that's what i love about it.

  • yes it is, but i still think they could've done better

  • People r complaining that this video sucks, but I predict that this was actually intentional. I mean intentionally, this was made to look like a bad video from the beginning. If you listen to the lyrics of the song you'll know what I'm talking about :)

  • Actually they have broken up. Shirley's going solo.

  • she is making a solo album but that only puts the band on hiatus until they state otherwise. just like gwen stefani (who shirley is friends with), she did her solo stuff and now no doubt is making a new album.

  • NO!!!! shirly is the front of the band anyway, why does she need to make her own album too? i hate when the band's front breaks away. *sigh* they're so good together!

  • they didn't break up. two words: absute garbage it's their new album. sadly it only has one new song on it. they will probably break up soon though.

  • I rlly hope this isn't the same director as the "Push it" video...

  • what album is this off of?

  • beautifulgarbage

  • I like the originality they kick ass as long as they keep rocking and don't play behind a curtain like tool it's cool.

  • this video sucks!!!

  • I Like The Video,I Understand Why You Dont Like It..But I Think Its Kool,Its Different.

    To Show What This Video Is Saying,It Would Be Very Hard Using Actual People If You Think About It.

    =]

    Very Good Song,Id Love To Be Able To See Them Live Again =[

    Thats Nvr Gna Happen.

  • they're not broken up so i'm sure you will.

  • they're on a hiatus, not broken up

  • why do u hate it?

  • I don't like the concept, I prefer videos with actual people.

  • but u like the song?

  • garbage is one of my favorite bands, this isn't their best but yes, i like the song.

  • i only know this one.. i m a metal fan ^^

    lol

    : )

  • i love this song, and you're right, they could've given the exact same message in a better way