reshma g is really very good....her voice makes you feel the presence of divinity inside her soul, but lata g has also sung it very well, she has done full justice to original one.....:P
Comparing Lata to Reshma is like comparing a rose to a gardenia - they have their own beauty and fragrance but one cannot exactly replace the other. Both the singers are a blessing to our countries and we should savor their voices.
As for the song, yes, the tune is the same and the opening line has the same words, but rest of the song is quite different and both versions convey much heartfelt sentiments. It is not copying; it's complimenting!!
Latas version may not be the 'original' but i prefer it 2 Reshma Jis. And b4 all u ppl start hating I am a pakistani & punjabi.and If u know anything about songs & quality of voice then this version is sung more beauitiful
Don't know why people are so hung up on who sang the song first or whether Lata should have sung it in Punjabi. You guys spoil it for everyone with your mindless bickering over non-issues.
This is a movie song. Lata had no control over which language to sing it in. And how should she have acknowledged Reshma? It was a movie song.
Reshma's version is truly amazing. But even as a Punjabi, I prefer Lata's version.
BTW, many people may not know this. Reshma was born in India.
WTF i am indian i say this really hurts me , that lata is bitch according to this song . she must sing this in punjabi ., she must give tribute to reshma .
WTF i am indian i say this really it hurts me , that lata is bitch according to this song . she must sing this in punjabi ., she must give tribute to reshma .
the nightingale of india regales once again with a super duper song in bobby..kudos to her as she sings this with such a high pitch voice that no one on this earth can even attempt to sing even one single line.. thanks for uploading this song.. does anyone have full video of this song? raju shahani dubai
<3
kawarera12 2 days ago
reshma g is really very good....her voice makes you feel the presence of divinity inside her soul, but lata g has also sung it very well, she has done full justice to original one.....:P
TheSwati88 3 weeks ago
awesome song
geethsudha2010 1 month ago
True singer :) music respect from Pakistan .. thumbs up
maxpain0007 1 month ago
Comment removed
AnnaThayil 1 month ago
Oh God thank you for letting this devine voice and music travel in my brain's corridors!
128eoi 1 month ago
doesn't have the soul or depth that Reshma's version does ...
ssmadan 1 month ago
very nice song !
but one thing i would like to say
RESHMA is the original singer of the song and this is jst a copy
and it's not that good
Reshma singss the songs with feeling
and Lata is a great singer no doubt
but INDIA ATLEAST APPRECIATE PAKISTAN FOR ONCE !
Lata herself is a fan of Reshma and this is an example :P
MsZano69 2 months ago 7
@MsZano69
Agreed ! :)
ssmadan 1 month ago
@ssmadan :D thanx
MsZano69 1 month ago
@MsZano69 Enjoy the music.
Thank whoever made it if you like it.
shaks921 1 month ago
@MsZano69
Who Says We Dont Appriciate Pakistan ,,, How cant you appriciate your Other Half of the Body ?
With full regards to Pakistani Fankars and Gulkars ,, Pls Dont Say this
India give full Respect to All the Pakistani Artists. Brother.
Some of my favourits are Ghulam Ali Sa'ab , Ustaad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan Sa'ab. Mehdi Hasan Sa'ab, etc tec ,, there are thousands of them ,,,,,,
drsumantr 1 month ago 6
@drsumantr, Thanx dear,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
In this way public of both countries force their governments to come closer.
MrShahid121212 2 weeks ago
this is shit
TheMrinevitable 2 months ago 2
qudratulain baloch sung that song aussumly. check out. this is damn shit
MrFimi007 2 months ago 2
in any case original is far better then this. Reshma has feeling emotions in her voice. "Chan pardesiya bol bhavain na bol"
billraj 2 months ago
lata ji is nightangle of india and her voice is mind blowing wah!
dikshant108 3 months ago
Reshma is 1000 time better then Lata.
Indian media is full of lousy b******** specially News channels. They don't have a heart to appreciate Pakistan.
even a baby born in their country. They will accuse Pakistan for this event..
ishaqaziz1 3 months ago
aha ! superb ..
saleem9855 3 months ago
love u lata ji........!!
cursedsandy1 3 months ago
Lata is a great singer but this song still belongs to Reshma..........I agree with Vinit Kumar.
paracha620 3 months ago
@paracha620 Lata never appears to be great. prove it !!
ishaqaziz1 3 months ago
nice song boddy
TAHATAHA72 4 months ago
Comparing Lata to Reshma is like comparing a rose to a gardenia - they have their own beauty and fragrance but one cannot exactly replace the other. Both the singers are a blessing to our countries and we should savor their voices.
As for the song, yes, the tune is the same and the opening line has the same words, but rest of the song is quite different and both versions convey much heartfelt sentiments. It is not copying; it's complimenting!!
morphnw 4 months ago
copy song !!!!!!!!!!!!
rehanbutt277 4 months ago
Reshma's version is better. After all originals remain original.
MrTopazstar 4 months ago
Lata is lata. And Reshma is reshma. Do not compare both. They are legend there own way.
munnibillu 5 months ago
Latas version may not be the 'original' but i prefer it 2 Reshma Jis. And b4 all u ppl start hating I am a pakistani & punjabi.and If u know anything about songs & quality of voice then this version is sung more beauitiful
sanamo86 5 months ago
Don't know why people are so hung up on who sang the song first or whether Lata should have sung it in Punjabi. You guys spoil it for everyone with your mindless bickering over non-issues.
This is a movie song. Lata had no control over which language to sing it in. And how should she have acknowledged Reshma? It was a movie song.
Reshma's version is truly amazing. But even as a Punjabi, I prefer Lata's version.
BTW, many people may not know this. Reshma was born in India.
aayou 5 months ago
ths song is a disrespect to Reshma...
waheedtdin 6 months ago
WTF i am indian i say this really hurts me , that lata is bitch according to this song . she must sing this in punjabi ., she must give tribute to reshma .
gagan1947 6 months ago
WTF i am indian i say this really it hurts me , that lata is bitch according to this song . she must sing this in punjabi ., she must give tribute to reshma .
gagan1947 6 months ago
this is a copy of a punjabi pakistani song by reshma!!
they merely translated it... hahaha WTF!!
ranaasif299 6 months ago
Lata cannot be Reshma!
ranausman143 6 months ago
@ranausman143 reshma can neva be lata
sanamo86 5 months ago
Awesome rendition by Lata, it is soul stirring.
paragrk1 8 months ago
Lat Jee you are a school of learning singing. God keep you alive forever. I compare you with Um e Kulsum the legendary Egyptian singer.
KDURRANI 8 months ago
nice song...................
HardevKanwar 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i dedicate this song to my love shumaail scb Lahore ican't express my feelings about thissong
09matif 9 months ago
lataa ji u r great....
karankumarbali1 10 months ago
lataa ji .. no bdy can sing like you
its awosm......
karankumarbali1 10 months ago
PUNJABI version is Awsum!!! its copy and fell like it!!!!!!!!
SMOKEYahsan 10 months ago
i love this song
puppybudy 1 year ago
@vinitkumarr1 : absolutely correct
karnamit 1 year ago
the nightingale of india regales once again with a super duper song in bobby..kudos to her as she sings this with such a high pitch voice that no one on this earth can even attempt to sing even one single line.. thanks for uploading this song.. does anyone have full video of this song? raju shahani dubai
sunderajent 1 year ago 8
yah----no can be like lata ji
MegaSohani 1 year ago 2
i like this songs..i'm giving thanks to lata ji for this song..no one can be like lata ji...
navneet4884 1 year ago
Can some one post the Bobby video for this song. I like the song very much.
apirani100 1 year ago
Original singer Reshma???
Anyways, LP and Lataji has left us with this ever lasting song which will be heard till eternity
rhythmhouseNZ 1 year ago