Added: 3 years ago
From: Screamorulz9
Views: 119,415
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (203)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i love this song for one reason my ex dumped to me on this song and told me i wasn't worth it and know i am doing better then him he is in jail and i am happy to be a mother and wife

  • i like this song

    

  • "I'm not the one who hurt you, I'm the only one who cared" these lyrics ring so true to me as i have a friend I've always been in love with and she knows... and as much as she cares about me , we both know that we will never be anything more ......

  • i could not bring you back to life you where always where the sun could never go

  • this is my favorite song i love trapt!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Great vid I went through a dark time in my life I lost the love of my life my car and my license all at the same time and ive just recently come out of that place

  • great song... great band... not much more too say...

  • Most girls are bitches there very little good ones out there

  • Why do guys always go for the bitchy girls?? I don't know why people can't just find girls who actually care about them. We exist, you know, you only have to look.

  • I love this song. I walk down the hallways at school singing it <333.

  • it would be weird if a girl was a actual rose, if you picked her you would smash her spine XD

  • u know a rapper would argue and say that he would get more pussy the a rockstar,u know wat i would say? "u can have as much as u want,ill still be getting the better pussy"

  • thats why im staying away from girls now, girls are so fickle

  • you shoulda put an image in the guitar solo. but overall, awesome

  • my girlfriend passed away 6 years ago...and this song always makes me think of her....good job on the video btw. i like the random " :/ " face in the begining

  • I guess im going through this right now :(

  • people tend to relate to each other and its comforting to know that. i for one dont like to do that but others do and live and let live...

  • When did the Youtube comments stop being rude and racist, and become a fucking support group? I understand finding solace in the song, but are all these depressing anecdotes really necessary?

  • typo....*my story and this song*

  • (continued) So she got accepted to this college in Florida, which isn't that far from our hometown in GA. I broke up with her because I'm not a controlling person, it was kind of a mutual thing, like we still hung out and all that good stuff. Anyways a month or two after the breakup I found out she was back with that douchebag from earlier. He kept her from going to FLA. I guess the moral of my story and this song is that, you can't help anyone unless they are willing to help themselves.

  • im raping the replay button!! XD

  • there music is like soft wind in my ears , BEAUTIFUL!!!

  • "Black rose your thorns are cutting into me,

    For the last time.

    Black rose I watched your petals wilt away,

    I couldn't bring you back to life!"

    SO poetic!! SO beautiful!! X3

    LOVE TRAPT!!!!!

  • what cd is this one from does anyone know

  • @chrislostangel only through the pain

  • my ex girlfreind marie yarber one night told me how much she loved this song,i thought id listen to it and its good and hopefully if she reads this i just want to say i love u forever and ever :)

  • i love this song. me and my bf just broke up and this song is says it word for word. i couldnt help him nor did he ever listen. oh well. good luck black rose..

  • my bf got me hooked on this song and for me him and his family where the only ones i could count on fully and he has been helping me a lot i grew up with abuse of all kinds but he was there and made me strong he helped stop smoking and because of him i know i wont ever get addicted to anything again this song means a lot to me

  • happens to everyone guys cheer up. just become a manipulator like me :)!

  • how can df u make lyric videos am i wanna know l0l o yea and dis da sh!t

  • how can df u make lyric videos am i wanna know l0l

  • I can relate to this song is every way with my ex. She was on drugs such as weed, cocaine, and she was even addicted to alcohol and ciggarettes. I was with her for 5 months, I managed to get her to stop smoking weed and ciggarettes so much, and I was beginning to control her drinking. All her friends left her, so me and my family were the only people there for her. I did anything for her, I loved her with all of my heart. Then she turned on me and my family, I was hurt so much..

  • i love Grace Leonarda Rose Christine this song reminds me of her co'z she hase a black rose and she loves it

  • it happened to me, but it waz just all my best guy friendz, i sunk into deppression, and eventually snapped out of it a couple weeks ago, i feel alive, like theres a reason to live agian..... not everything iz back, somting died in me, but somthing new came from it, so, idk, but i still dont feel like i fit in..........

  • i absolutly love this song. i have never done this to any guy ever. i would be ashamed of myself but guys have dne this to me... i am with the one right now but ik it will tke a long time for me to trust again bc of all the pain but it doesnt mean anybody should just ignore the things tht happened u should face them and knw tht it wasnt ur fault and try to make it easier for yourself.

  • : / whenever i hear this song i think of the girl that broke my heart so recently...... and wonder if she felt like what the song is saying.....

  • @mormongamer im a girl like that, and i never used to be until i was in an abusive relationship, and yes i do feel like the girl in this.. and i feel horrible. but im still juust to work threw my trust issues and let him in other then the wrong people. So i garentee your ex feels like this.

  • i dont know why all you people are on here crying once you get your heart broken just let it ice over and turn dark then you can never be hurt.

  • @monkeyballsareyou1 it doesnt work becuz, you can look collected and calm, but on the inside itz just filling up,n waiting to spill over, wich can effect u more in the end...... thankz 4 ur time though

  • @monkeyballsareyou1 because they can.

  • tell me how the fuck this song doesnt have a music video. -_-

    love it.

    I've been with several girls who've cheated on me, or who've dumped me for some reason... it just seems no matter how hard i try it always happens..

  • @boba1mighty itll come brother!!

  • I think of someone close to me when I hear this song, I cry everytime I hear it, yet I love it. It's so beautiful, the lyrics, his voice, everything is absolutely perfect in this song. It makes for a wonderful breakup song.

  • i listened to this song when i was pissed with my ex before we broke up.

  • I love the lyrics to this song its so cute <3

  • love this song <3 love trapt <3 thank you danny for getting me into them x

  • @robotlatino23 idiot...

  • @lalaland7407 thnx:)...@iwkillall I'm srry u went thru that trus me I totally hear were ur comin frm I went thru that for years.But I learned not 2 put my self out there ne more.I took time out for da more important things in life.I left da relationship thing alone n put God 1st n now yrs later lol he blessed me wit sum1 special n yea it took lots of heart breaks tears n sleepless nites but eventually I got 2 my happy place n I'm sure u will 2 if u take my advice:)

  • Lol srry bout that. Well long story short he waited for me never gave up n now we are engaged. I love u baby ur my world n imma take good care of u cz u deserve it

  • @msmizzrose aww thats so sweet :)

  • So my fiancé told me to buy this song on iTunes so I I'd n it made me teary eyed. Then I was like let me look it up on here to read the lyrics cz I really couldn't hear em too well. N wen I watched it boy did I cry like a baby. Before we got engaged like 2 yrs ago we started dating but had to end for religious reasons I'm not gettin into cz u wouldn't understand. Ne wayz I misunderstood y he ended it n I thought he was like every other guy who played wit my emotions but I was wrong cz soon we

  • i a;wes saw trapt by there song head strong i dident no they wrote this kina stuff i love it its touching

  • i cry every time i hear this song :( im such a cry baby

  • He throws so much of his emotion in this song,it sounds like hes tearing up its an amazing song

  • i hope someday someone will make me trust him 100% and wont disappoint me...and him to trust me 100% also :( .It's very hurtful when someone says he loves you and than takes the words back...and says 'ofcourse i dont trust you'..T_T

  • @lonexwolf299 yep, and everytime you think you find somebody else, they end up screwing you over too right?

  • I miss Emily...

  • This is ironic for two reasons..

    It totally describes my relationship right now..

    And my girlfriend's name is rose. :/

  • I love this song...He has such an amazing voice.

  • im with JC518 its so...... real.... just discribes a break up or mine perfectly hahah itl neva change, nice guys will keep getten fucked ova and the dickheads/assholes will always get who they want when they want, maddest song

  • really beautiful song *__*

  • story of my life

  • @robotlatino23 Dude, that has to suck.

  • to find someone you really like beauty wont mater ive barely been in any relationships but ive helped so many people with theirs and i was never myself and i never found someone i liked untill now trust me be yourself and youlll be suprsed how many people you realize are like you. great song another good song is give me a sign by breaking benjamin

  • i love this song! :)

  • this song is just amazing

  • ich fühl mich jetz ausgeschlossen .. alle hier schreiben englisch ..

    naja egal

    der song is einfach nur HAMMA !!

    üübelst ich liebe den einfach <3

  • i was told this is my song..its so beautiful

  • The beginning almost sounds like BFMV's Tear's Don't Fall

  • yeah, it does:D

  • very good song :)

  • My Favourite Song (:

  • This song is exactly whats going on in my life........ It hurts so bad : (....... I was the only one who truly cared for this girl : /..........

  • To JC518:

    Dont be sad, its happened to everyone at least once. Hang in there! Hang onto your faith! xD

  • thanks, but it actually happened three times this past year and a half. like im not an asshole guy, i dont understand why these girls just keep using me and playing with my feelings. thank you though!

  • Be strong with your emotions and really have true confidence. Don't put a women in a pedestal. Don't overrate relationships or girls. Don't be an asshole but just follow what I just told you. You'll be fine kid. We all been through that, its about pulling through and learning from your mistakes.

    Be Cautious with your heart, its a mans weakness but it become your strength..

  • same here, man :/

  • @JC518 I will give you an honest reply. Girls play with your heart because you are a nice guy. I mean dont get me wrong all girls dream of the perfect sweet guys but in reality most go for the assholes. Just wait and your time will come and you will find one of those few young woman that want the sweet one now. Because in reality you just have to wait around for awhile and girls will wise up. Trust me I was one of the girls that went for assholes now im begging for something better :)

  • @AshweeBabyAlwaysMe you are probably right. Thank you. It just hurts so much righ tnow, it seems as if im not good enough for anybody. I ask myself if im really a boring person sometimes because im not as "outoging" as some of the assholes out there who are full of lies

  • @JC518 I feel you there bro! I've been used 3 times in the past year and a half as well, all I want is just a relationship but I'm either just a 1 night stand or i get put in the "friendzone" :(

  • @IWKILLALL i havnt been put thru tht (i honestly think im 2 young to have a boyfriend right now) so i wouldnt know but ive witnessed someone who has.multiple times. its crazy how they just ruin ur lives and just make u feel like theres nothing left. that taught me a lesson and now i swear that when im old enough and i get a boyfriend im going to be loyal to him.

    but im sry to hear that though i hope u feel better and i hope u find the right one :)

  • Comment removed

  • @JC518 maybe because you let them :P ?

    Lifes good bro , if a girl ''uses'' you , see it as a whole bunch of experience and move on. Being single rocks and theres enough fish in the ocean ;)

    I bet you thought '' OMG this wouldve never been this good if i stayed with any of my previous girls '' , well youll think that again :D

  • @JC518 you get used because either:

    A. you suck at choosing girls

    B.most girls in your area are bitches, or

    C.you're really unlucky

  • im the only one too.

  • @JC518 Your not alone. What i can"t understand is why do they hurt us the most? When I'm the one who loved him the most? I gave him my hart and sole. When he was a black rose, cut down used and abused, by all his "family" I showed him what it meant to be loved. All i got back was the thorns.

  • @REDGEMINI69 yeah this is why life is so harsh and cruel : / it just doesn't make sense to me. people can never realize the ones that truly care for them. its utterly depressing. watching them see other guys/girs makes ya feel even worse too : /

  • @JC518 and even worse yet is when they come back telling you that they realize there mistake. and your hart wants to believe them.

  • @JC518 but yet your the" fill in" until the other love decides they want them back. then there gone as fast as they come. to sit back as the "best friend" who picks them up and helps them out. only to watch helplessly as they go back again and again. now i feel its my fault for caring beyond reason, and sanity, as i drive him to the ER. I'm just beside myself as to what to do any more. it's been over a year. ;'-( I cant walk away but i cant stand this ether.

  • @JC518 but yet your the" fill in" until the other love decides they want them back. then there gone as fast as they come. to sit back as the "best friend" who picks them up and helps them out. only to watch helplessly as they go back again and again. now i feel its my fault for caring beyond reason, and sanity, as i drive him to the ER. I'm just beside myself as to what to do any more. it's been over a year. ;'-( I cant walk away but i cant stand this ether.

  • @REDGEMINI69 Its weird how your story is the EXACT same as mine...... i was in the same situation you are in. I drive her everywhere, i take her out and talk to her when sad, yet still goes for other guys whenevr they come her way...... she can not be smart and choose the one who cares for her the most..... me..... i am also that "best friend" or "brother" like you...... it sucks wtaching her do this and keep getting hurt and used

  • @JC518 Thanks for letting me know i'm not the only one caught in this vicious circle by my emotions. It relay does suck big donkt d**ks! lol

  • @REDGEMINI69 I will give you an honest reply. Girls play with your heart because you are a nice guy. I mean dont get me wrong all girls dream of the perfect sweet guys but in reality most go for the assholes. Just wait and your time will come and you will find one of those few young woman that want the sweet one now. Because in reality you just have to wait around for awhile and girls will wise up. Trust me I was one of the girls that went for assholes now im begging for something better :)

  • @AshweeBabyAlwaysMe Thanks sweets, I two was the used and abused woman. But he is the nice guy who keeps going back to his abusive x b**ch. I m the one waiting and saving him. Waiting for his cycle of abuse to end.

  • @JC518 wow, im going thru that with my boy friend. and this song makes me cry cuz it reminds me of him. anyway i hope u find a girl to treat u right and u dont sound like a asshole so no girl should think u r.

  • @XdarkangelmelX thanks, but the same thing happened again twice. i dont get it. they like me, then after a week or two they change their minds....... makes me feel awesome about myself.....

  • @JC518 well if you add me and stuff we cant talk and be friends. you seem really great!

  • @JC518 thats ecactly how i feel too :/ evryone have given upp this girl but i still love her :(

  • @JC518 been there bro. been. there.

  • I love this song alot ;)

  • you know, I really expected to like this song, especially considering the song shares a name with the comic series I'm writing. But, I really don't think this is as good as some of their other pieces. It has amazing lyrics, but the music with it just doesn't hit me as much as their other stuff.

    But still, not a bad song.

  • love it :D

  • Beautiful, so true that hurts.. But great song, love the melody, goes so well with the lyrics !

    Thanks

  • I love this song sooooo mutch.

    I ♥ Black rose...

  • love that song Y.Y

  • such a good song.

    such a good band.

  • i think everyone can relate to this song in some way whether they had to let a family member go or a relationship fall apart for their own sake. i absolutely love this song for that. it's open to any situation.

  • this song is deep.

    it has alot of meaning.

    it brings a tear to your eye when u listen to it.

    best song ever <3

  • Their name makes sense to me now...If you listen to the meanings of the songs you are forever trapt in their position of how they feel!

  • <3 it. Its sad to me. I think this is one of Trapts best songs. Ever.

  • verry nice song i almost cried !!!

  • it sounds like he is cring the song made me cry. I LUV IT!!!

  • This song reminds me of someone who called me his black rose.. I miss him so much..This was one of his favorite bands. I hope he's okay.

    This is a beautiful song though. And Trapt is a radical band.

  • hehe, soo selfconfident, right to be though :).

  • Then you must be a real heartbreaker or the girls that dumped you. Sorry to hear that though

  • Sooo..this song is abt a flower? Lmao jk! I love this song!!

  • Nice song, I never expected anything like this from Trapt. One of their best songs. Good job on the lyrics and the editing. :D

  • Amazing Song! Trapt are awesome! I would never except such a song from them!! The "new" album is so beautiful!!

  • this song is raly good and i realy can relate to it b/ i understand it and i just think this song is the best

  • this is one of the most beautiful songs i've ever heard *__*

  • this song is sooo sad.

  • My Girlfriend gave me this before she broke up with me... now I see why she did.

  • I'm sorry to hear that. =/

  • @EyesTheDevil  awwwww, hope everythign will end up ok.

  • @EyesTheDevil aww im so sry :(

  • Comment removed

  • ppl said this song was pretty much written for me... i understand now... i feel awful...

  • lalalalalalalalalalaluv this song with all of my heart o heck yesh i do

  • I'm very suprised someone I know hasn't sent this to me... it's almost like this song was written for me.

    Now I feel awful.

  • love this song so much i can soo totaly relate to it my ex says this song is for me x/

  • this is the greatest song in the world i realy love it and i hope it stays on utube forever

  • ...hmmmm pretty song *_*

  • T.T

    love, it stings with it's thorns, but the smell of the flower keeps me coming back for it over and over again.

  • thats deep....

    COPYRIGHT THAT SHIT! XD

  • trapt is the greatest band ever im glad they made this song i love it so much <3

  • i fall asleep to this song...and when iwake up i hav to here it agine and its stuck in my head all the time lol I LOVE THIS SONG SO MUCH!!!!!!

  • THE BEST SONG EVER!!!!

  • I love this song!

    " I couldn't bring you back to life " That part is breaking my heart.

    So damn beautiful! <3

  • I hate when you realize that the person that you believe in your heart is the one, then they turn out to not be the right person for you.. like, love is so blind when you come out of it you realize that person is only hurting you..

    Eh.. love is complicated.

  • wow...amazing... so much emotion

  • Comment removed

  • This reminds me of me and my girl Celena. She ain't exactly mine. This song is us basically.

  • <3 this song

  • i remember falling asleep to this song, then waking up two hours later to hear my cousin was dead. i couldnt bring you back to life</3

  • are u serious? that is so sad!T-T

    I fell asleep to this song to wake up and hear that my dog had gotten in the road and hit by a car!

  • i had this song stuck in my head all day.

    nice to hear it rather than sing it. *cant sing*

  • i kind a like this song its slow but nice :)

  • This is how every single one of my girlfriends has seen me.

    They just... can't bring me back to life. All because I lost the only one who I loved.

  • "I couldn't bring you back to life!"

    I always get tears in my eyes at that part... This is just so damn beautiful...

  • I <3 this beasty song!

  • i like how the smileys are put it tis nice to let me no when i need to feel bad (note sarcasm)

    BUT its a great song none the less

  • I want her to love me back.

    So much.

  • I've been on the recieving end of this song... ouch...

    ;p

  • This song honestly caused shivers to course through me... =0

  • TRAPT!!!!!!!!! <3<3</3 Dis song Rocks!

  • OMG!!!that song......it just like,,,,wow

    i cant even explain it....

    its so heart tearing and so....beutiful at the same time

    its amazing,,,i love it!!!

  • OMG!!! I wanna cry!! this song reminds me of my ef-bf...TRAPT is soo amazing!!

  • This song makes me wanna cry :'( its so good

  • Yeah Awesome song for Trapt! HIs voice is actually Phenomenal in this one...and the song itself puts you in a dreamy mood where you can see the events of it happening in your head! However i hated its official videoclip...It under estimated it very much! This one posted here is way better eventhough is just Lyrics & Visuals but allows us to still have the perfect image in our heads abt the story!

  • i love this song!!!!!

    TRAPT for ever!

  • i love his songs <3

  • Very well written!

  • i love this song! my boyfriend Manuel told me to listen to it :D i love him too...jk (inside joke) but yeah. dope song.

  • hey ppl gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg­gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg­gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg­gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggg­ggggggggggrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

  • I love this song and the video is pretty good!

  • the first time the other day that is...good shit