Added: 3 years ago
From: outoftowners2008
Views: 84,978
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (214)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • mto bom!!!!

  • I hadn't listened to this song before she sang it... Made me look for the original and fall in love with it. Thank you Katharine!

    I must say, her rendition of this classic is beautiful, smooth and really emotional.

  • anyone no where i can download her version of this song

  • Damn shes good. Super gorgeous too

    My fav Beatles song

  • can i download this anywhere?

  • @midwiferiesx578 yοu ϲaո wаtϲh tv frοm аll over tհе ԝοrld on your рϲ jսѕt by dοwnloadinց ѕοmе рrogram, іt's ցοt tհοսsаոdѕ of ϲհаnոеlѕ oո it. jսst gο to linevid com (put а . beforе thе ϲοm οbvіously, іt won't lеt me рοѕt lіոkѕ for some rеaѕοո) it'ѕ ոοt еxactly frеe bսt it'ѕ jսѕt one time paymеոt aոd it ԝοrkѕ reаlly wеll

  • she's soo pretty and talented!! :)

  • She really made a lovely version of this song, which is my Beatles favorite. I remember watching it alive... Something in the way he moves.... :D

  • I could listen to her sing all day.

  • chills

  • lovely version but i think those gender changes are quite annoying. just let the song be :)

  • @leoniess15 you do realize that if she said "something in the way she moves" she'd probably get accused of being a lez by all those immature freaks out there, so she was just being on the safe side. let her be, it's just one fricken word that she changed, its not like she changed the tune or quality of the song :)

  • @thebeatleslover108 yeah sure but still. if youre an actress youre not gonna change the script to fit your life right?

  • @leoniess15 but she's not an actress, she's a singer... good singers usually feel and think about what they're singing

  • george would be proud of thi version of this song. rest in peace george.

  • why do i love her so much!!!!!

  • RIP George Harrison- the genius who wrote this and so many other classics

  • WOW.. I cant stop watching this video.. Its Amazing to hear her sing... And Shes Absolutely gorgeous!! Kathy is truly one of the Greatest Singers Ever!!!

  • i wonder why they haven't had her back since then? she's special!

  • This one was beautiful! She rocks

  • A REAL STAR

  • There is nothing wrong with her changing he to her... It would sound wierd if she kept it as she. Screw disrespecting the song she did what was best.She is great! and surely deserves more than she is getting from fans. She is a top artist.

  • Good voice, everything was okay except for 1 thing.

    You DO NOT change up the lyrics to a great song. yes im aware she's a girl. I'm aware this song was written for a girl, and her singing it how it was written would result in sounding homosexual. But when you cover a song by a great, like a beatle, you don't change the lyrics. In my book it's disrespect.

    If she sings it like it was written, it's not like people would call her lesbian, so no need to change a perfect song by a historic musician

  • @TheKarimDream I beg to disagree. Changing something like pronouns in a song to suit the gender of the singer DOES not make a song any less beautiful. I would definitely mind if the singing is horrific but this one rocks.

  • I Officially Love This Song Cause She Sang It!!! And I Love Her!!

  • I love this girl!! why she didnt in American Idol is beyond anyone, best singer in Idol history!!! she for sure better than any of the girls!!! We love you kathy!! awesome voice!!!

  • Not only is this a stunning vocal, but I believe Katharine is a very skilled musician as well. Most trained singers can play the piano, its part of music theory. Not to mention the ability to sing this good is more challenging then most instruments .

  • good thing is tht geoge isnt rolling in his grave with this preformance, nice job

  • Based on that assumption about beatles preference, they would include Ella Fitzgerald, doris day, whitney houston, and many others in that same category. None play an instrument

  • I put aside Judgments from others on music talent regardless of their background. I decide and choose for myself ( as most do) vocal ability and what i like to hear. And this young woman is gifted with superb talent. Love her doing this beautiful song.

  • I quite agree with Frank Sinatra about this song. One the best love songs in all time!!

  • @playmymusicNOW Brilliant song!

  • love to reminisce....an outstanding performance, indeed.....miss Katharine collaborating with Foster

  • She needs to perform on Idol this season... my god this is aamazing.

  • i always come back to this video. i love it. she's gorgeous and i love her voice

  • loved it. and I was a big skeptic.

  • the last bit was AH-MAZING

  • The best

  • Love her ;)*

  • Along with "I Have Nothing" this is my FAVORITE performance by her! <3

  • so damn good

    agh this bugs me so much.

    why do the judges have to be so rude? I notice that they only STAND UP and applaud after the performances from those who WON. I did research - They stood up and clapped for David Cook, Carrie Underwood, and Jordin Sparks when they were on. They did not stand up for Katharine or Kimberley Locke... why? she's no less than them... that shit just bugs the eff outa me. it's completely rude

  • I agree!

    This was a Grammy moment and judges should give an "O"...

  • @qg6ff they stood up for adam lambert... and he didn't win!

  • @NeNiNha13 that's prbbly coz they wanted him to win instead of kris allen.. i can't remember whether the judges stood up for kris.. but i do remember randy, steven n j.lo stood up for fantsia, but not jennifer hudson a week earlier when she sang where u at amazingly!

  • she´s a very good singer and a beautifull girl!!

  • argggg i wish they had this in kareoke!!!!

  • she looks like vicky beckam!!

  • She has an amazing vocal skills ..

  • She should have won. AMAZING. Perfect pitch AND timing. WOW....

  • she's amazing! and drop dead gorgeous!

  • omg the piano player is that one guy that gets to play with all these different celebs isn't he?? like he's on kpbs or something, anyways katharine is so successful that i didnt' remember at all her on american idol

  • I miss this kind of pure talent! AI sucks now! Theyre focusing so much to rock thing! And it sucks!

  • I totally agree...season 8 is a complete and utter waste of time and money...

  • Couldn't agree with you both any more!

  • She is just gorgeous and has an amazing voice. I could listen to her sing this all day long.

  • stunning voice and sexyyy girl

  • this is amazing...

  • god, ur not a lesbian if you sing she. SHE/THEY SHOULDNT HAVE CHANGED IT TO HE! :(

    pretty gud. LOVE GEORGE :)

  • lol... so true

  • Thanks.

  • Haha, I noticed you got some negative remarks w/ that, but I totally agree!

  • Thankyou. I don't know why people gave me thumbs down, they probably didn't understand what I was saying. I was saying there's nothing wrong with her saying 'she'. It didn't have to be changed. Why the thumbs down?

  • this song makes me wanna cry..especially when she sings it. she's truly amazing-no doubt about that

  • she has one of the best voices ever on the show. I am surprised she hasn't become a bigger recording artist.

  • Her first record labeled mishandled her, but she's got a new label album and an album dropping soon. Her time might be coming.

  • Such a good song!! One of George Harrison's bests!!

    I was afraid she was gonna do it bad, but she did it really wel!!

    such a good version!!!

  • you can't sing the bridge enough times. it's waay too fun if you do it right.

  • I can watch this over and over. Phenomenal voice!!!

  • she's SO gorgeous

  • She is blessed with her maginificent voice and outstanding face! And I love her for that!

  • good song, beautifull singer, what a perfect combination

  • I didn't watch the year Katherine was on but i saw her do this song on the show and became a fan...stunning version!

  • she should have sang these types of songs on idol... she would have easily won.. i don't know whey she kept going for huge songs

  • she was the best i think

  • she should had win!

  • just beatiful.

    that ending is amazinggg

  • wow she sang her ass off with this song!!

  • Wow! What a great rendition of this Beatles classic! Awesome job Katharine! George is smiling down on you!  He would be so proud!

    Dara

  • @Dara604 We all know George is smiling down because she has nice legs. : )

  • @NicNac13c Lol, why do you think George would like her legs?

  • @Dara604 In Pattie Boyd's book, she said that George was (consciously or unconsciously) modeling himself after Krishna, and Krishna had 16,108 wives. George loved the ladies and would have had a keen appreciation for such gorgeous gams.

  • ya i agree with jaymejean28...seriously fantashia sucks compared to katharine and carrie...but hey at least the last time she performed simon had that blank wtf face...lmao..

  • She was the best!

  • personally I think its rude how the judges never stand for Kat or Carrie. But then when Fantasia comes on and screeches and bounces around they stand for her. I don't get it.

  • she sang beautifully

  • stunning performer! What a God-given voice.

  • Katharine McPhee has finally come back. (:

    I'm so happy.

  • she's so beautiful!

  • I've never really cared for her, but she needs to record this immediately! Amazingly done with my all-time favorite song.

  • great cover!

    anyone feel the same way, but did the lyrics seem awkward as hell when a girl sings it, replacing the "hers" with "hims" etc. lol

  • I don't get it....who won then??

  • holy!!!!!!!!christ!!shes hot!!!!

  • the ending was excellent... let's just call it like it is....she won season 5! Well it'd make more sense..... since taylor almost doesn't exist in the music world...

  • well i'll give you this much, they should have been in the finals together. however although chris was my fav. guy that year, i am not sure he was 'the winner' that season. katharine though, was

  • I agree. Chris and Katharine should've been the final two. I didn't like Taylor at all.

  • she is singer she in love(little mermaid) in a album for disney.Beyonce,Alicia Keys,Rihanna and Carrie Underwood also is in it!

  • love her ! should have won

  • I love kate. She is great. She should have won in season 5. Anyway, beautiful beautiful song.

  • kat.

  • You know you see those male contestants jocking her from their seats, lol.

  • that song rulssssss!!!!

    the beatles ruls!!!!!!!!!<---- george harrison

  • stunning voice.

    and looks.

  • Good God she's beautiufl.

  • love this

  • i love it!! i hope its on the new album!!!!

  • Beautiful Song!

    Beautiful Voice!

    Beautiful Girl

    I LOVEE IT!!!! :D

    xoxoxoxxx

  • she is such a gorgeous and flawless performer! still and always will be in love with her!

  • Woops didnt know she got hitched :o

  • David Cook should hook up with this lady. Kathrine is so pretty and her voice is just pure in tone.

  • I love Katharine McPhee! Her voice just melts my heart! :D

  • omg ...it has been 2 years since AI5 is over and i'm still in love with kat !!!!!!

  • this is the one and the only katharine we love...so much better than the rest...IMHO

  • at least they sing good music not like whats out there today

  • deffiantly didnt top harrisons version but great job

  • she never said "im gonna try and top the orginal"

  • I agree with you. Some things are so classic, they shouldn't be touched. Theres at least 200 Beatles covers released every year, and there is a reason they don't do very well on average.

    There is only one cover I like, and that is Fiona Apples' 'Across The Universe'.

    This version is too overdone, its a subtle song, and thats why I love it. This version is not bad, but not great. If she got rid of the Mariah Carey notes, the reverb and did a acoustic version then that would be more powerful.

  • goshh i love this song!!!! n i like the version that she sings... beautiful!

  • i really like her, and i love this song.. can't wait for the next album( anyone know when that is??)

  • Her album is supposed to come out sometime this fall.

  • Katharine is comparable to Mariah, Leona, Whitney and others. Basically in a different league then others. You can't really say she's "BETTER" or worse, just in the same league (as their all different)

    I hope her album with David Foster gets her the accolades she definitely deserves because she's under everyones' radar right now.

  • love katharine so much!!

  • i honestly love the contestants of season 7. amazing voices..........omg!

  • leona's bleeding love is not the best performance in this season...

    mariah carey's fly like a bird is...

    and i love katharine so much!!! i cant wait for her new album!! actually her voice is better than leona.. really!!! for real!!!

  • better than she ever sounded on season 5. she needs to gain weight, fast!

  • i dont really like this season contestants

  • im really really surprised this video didn't get a ton of hits..it was one of the best performances for either contestant or celebrity to perform on that stage. this and 'bleeding love' were the best

  • There were approximately 100,000 hits. There were about 10 different posters who were suspended causing the original videos to be removed.

  • I love her last note...chills...

  • Katharine is the perfect idol. Magnificent voice, amazing stage presence and she is really beautiful.

  • I love her sultry voice.

  • This was awesome! katharine is the best contestant to ever hit idol!!!!!!!!!!

  • I love her and her voice. Amazing.

  • beautiful...david and katharine...

  • I'm so happy American Idol invited her back! She's amazing and has grown as a performer so much.

  • This was awesome--the bomb!!!!!!! The richness of her voice makes this the best cover

    I've ever heard of this song.  Bravo.

  • Why did they throw in that echo around 3:14/3:15? And how do they do that? Is it through software that alters the voice as she sings into the mic?

  • I think that part was pre-recorded on the track.

  • It's probably reverb. You can set how much you want when dealing with sound. They may have upped the reverb right there for effect. I could be wrong... but that's my 2 cents. :)

  • Something is my favourite Beatle's song and Harrison is my favourite Beatle. That being said I really did not enjoy her version of this song. I did enjoy some of the other versions some of the "Idol's" did.

  • damn where can i find a recorded version of this, katharine is amazing with this song!

  • If you've heard the actual ORIGINAL song you'll think both are crap.

  • Where can I find an MP3 version of this???

  • i love this performance!! ^_^

  • .

    03:26 . magic moment.

    .

  • Katharine is simply stunning. Shes the epitome of what I think of when I think of a superstar. Elegant, classy, beautiful and talented. I have ALWAYS been a fan since day 1. I will support her thru WHATEVER she does! Shes a gift in every way

  • She sounded much better in her lower notes. It's rich and very soothing. High notes tend to get a bit shrilly and thin though...

  • this was beautiful

    i love how soft but high is her voice

  • she is so pretty and her voice is so soothing

  • she is sooo amazing!!

  • BEST ENDING EVER

    she sounds like celine dion.. i think her new stuff with this guy is gonna be a hit

  • I really like Katharine..ALOT...but c'mon she is nothing like Celine Dion!

  • You are right...she's not Celine Dion, she's KATHARINE MCPHEE!!! Perfect just the way she is ;)

  • Yes she is....why whenever there is a new female singer people compare her with Celine, Mariah, Whitney, Christina??? Everyone is different...it does not mean she is any less of a singer then any of the above. The thing I love about Katharine is that she doesnt just sing....she tells a story through her voice and really makes you want to listen to her!

  • i dont think she's trying to be like celine dion, i just can hear some similarities in the way she's singing to celine that has clearly rubbed off by working with this guy who has worked with celine dion before

  • I agree, Celine and Katharine share something in their singing... I don't know what exactly it is but during certain parts I could imagine Celine singing it.

  • I think she was incredible. This performance gave me chills, she's undeniably AMAZING.

  • im so glad they're letting idol alumni perform on results shows instead of having someone that is NOT from idol @ all. and also they have less celebrities and mentors. last year was a complete disaster. it was just a pointless parade of celebrities and guest judges. season 7 is the best yet! i hope carrie underwood gets a chance to per4m her new single "all american girl" soon.

  • Well, David Foster thinks shes got something, as do I, and I dont doubt David Foster. Hes worked with greats, such as Whitney, so...there's no denying she can't sing.

  • That's cuz the American public likes singers like Fergie and Hannah Montana. When they hear a pure voice like Kat, they are afraid because it's too beautiful. Kat's CD was released before its time. Her next one will certainly go Diamond.

    The record label she signed to is just dumb and stupid. They wanted her to sing songs that were just not right for Kat and she has morals and won't degrade herself to that just to stay on a record label. You are a class act, Kat!!

  • angel I think you are a very jealous person. shut the hell up no one wants to hear your shit so stop posting on every video of this performance.

    <