Added: 2 years ago
From: JEWISHWEEKONLINE
Views: 4,426
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (38)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • What some people won't do for MONEY

    I think he is a phony

    What better way for success in show business: PRETEND to be Jewish, display your conversion as entertainment, RAKE IN THE $ from a half witted show which isn't very funny, IMHO. There is much better TRUE comedy out there. This isn't comedy. There is nothing sadder than poorly written comedy.

  • Likely the ancient practice of Jewish circumcision is an imitation of the castration of the Egyptian neteru Osiris. Many practices in Abramic religions appear to have been borrowed from ancient Egypt's religion.

  • @xxyc21 yes circumcision was an old practice...

  • @smoochielipz21

    I found one site which dated 2400 BC from ancient Egypt showing male circumcision. Some other near simarlaries in both Torah and New Testament writings, like the Ten Commandments, resurrecting the dead, concept of heaven and hell and messiahs/saviors, all were in existence in ancient Egyptian texts thousands of years before the claimed birth of Abraham of 2000 BC.

    I do not hin it negates the newer traditions but provides a forerunner tradition from which idea were borrowed.

  • Respond to this video...

    also Wikipedia has some even more ancient claims, that some forms of male circumcision may have been practiced in sub-Sahara Africa. I't health benefits are up for modern debate.

    I am quite glad, I do not remember my own circumcision. LOL

  • Forced circumcision is a barbaric primitive practice that should be outlawed in civilized nations.

  • @MindofaJedi haha eww

  • if a kike cuts his cock he turns into a mizzer banker robber zionist

  • Sometimes removal is mandated by logic and science, but in the case of one who believes that the Torah, the Hebrew Bible, is Divine content, the removal of the foreskin is a Chok in Hebrew, a law not meant to be understood, meant to subjugate the human intellectual ego. For after all, if we were to completely understand and appreciate ALL of G-ds laws fully, we would only be serving ourselves in keeping the Torah due to the great Joy we would get from it.

  • @pshapiro1029 That is where you lose me completely. The Torah was physically written by Man, not by god himself. Even the most devout Jew understands this. As such it is easily understandable that the Torah could have been corrupted by it's Authors.

    Circumcision is against the basic tenets of Judaism. Harming a newborn infant is a most vile and unforgivable crime.

    No loving and caring god would ever force it's followers to mutilate their children's genitals.

  • @drealgrin A closed mind and an angry heart will never be convinced. I guess myself and virtually everyone I know were horribly mutilated at eight days old. You should really tell my community, the poor people, they all seem to be happy healthy people. I guess we just don't know how much we've suffered.

  • @pshapiro1029 Angry? Yes, of course. I certainly hope a regular person would be angry at a group of people who continually abuse their own children by inflicting permanent disfigurements upon their genitals.

    Health doesn't excuse the fact that you're abusing your children. If i cut off my hypothetical daughter's clitoral hood she could very well still be very healthy. It doesn't excuse the fact that i abused her sexually and permanently denied her a part of her own body.

    Circumcision is abuse.

  • @drealgrin No, cutting off your daughters clitoral hood would certainly make her an extremely unhealthy person-health is as much psychological and spiritual as physical. But of course, I don't know why I bothered replying. You have made your decisions, circumcision is abuse and religion is evil and no amount of logical discourse or intellectual inquiry will change that for you.

  • @pshapiro1029 Religion isn't evil. People are evil. Religion provides evil people with a safe haven for which to explain their evils.

    Nothing you have said is logical. If you amputate a female's clitoral hood at birth she will be none the wiser as an adult what she has lost. Much like you yourself who have had your foreskin amputated at birth you fail to see how vital a foreskin is.

  • @drealgrin Poor me, I will never know how vital a foreskin does. O well, at least I have happiness, love, and truth, instead of skepticism and anger. If you want logic you must study Torah, but to truly study Torah you must face it with a pure heart. How can you consider yourself intellectual honest if you refuse to even consider the possibility that circumcision was divinely mandated by a loving God? Open your heart or you'll be bitter all your life; not everything is meant to be understood.

  • @pshapiro1029 The consternation you face is the product of the clash every human faces; the clash between man's immense power to understand and create, the power that has produced modern science and philosophy, and his absolutely meaninglessness and powerlessness in the face of infinitude, eternity, and nature. If you're looking on YouTube for answers, you'll never find them. Hard work, meditation, and study are the only ways.

  • @pshapiro1029 This is fine that you believe all of this. And it's even fine that you think that having the most sensitive parts of your body amputated at birth is ok for you.

    But Don't pretend to believe you have any right to decide that for another human being. You only have the right to guide them in your beliefs. Not to forcibly amputate a part of their body in the name of your beliefs. That is Child Abuse. Child Abuse so severe as to permanently disfigure an infant's genitals.

  • @pshapiro1029 No loving being would ever take a person when they are at their most defenseless and torture them by amputating their most sensitive body parts.

    No amount of justification short of saving their life from immediate danger could ever be sufficient enough to excuse Infant Genital Mutilation of infant boys.

  • @drealgrin Thank or showing me the light. I guess I live in a community of malicious, unloving, child-abusing, disfiguring people. Its so sad how ignorant we are as to how horrible our lives are and how terribly disfigured we are. Woah is me. And all this time I thought I lived in a loving community and my genitals were quite fully functional...

  • @pshapiro1029 I was referring to the Jewish God in that previous post. Jewish people are just as loving and caring parents as anybody else, But so are African parents who cut off their daughters clitoris. And so were Chinese parents who had their children footbinded.

    IT doesn't change the fact that what they were doing to their children was unethical and torturous.

  • You say that the fact that most people have this extra foreskin on their genitals makes it something that is beneficial? Then why do people cut their toenails, or rub the skin off the bottom of their feet, or have an appendix removed, or have tonsils removed, or have a wisdom tooth removed.

  • @pshapiro1029 Toenails = Grow back, Would grow to unruly lengths if not trimmed. I don't know what you're talking about rubbing skin on bottom of feet because i've never experienced this.

    Appendix removal, we don't do this to infants. Nor do we remove tonsils of infants nor remove the wisdom teeth of infants. all of these are done now to reduce and prevent imminent pain. The foreskin however causes pleasure. It's purpose is to aid sexual function. And if taken care of properly causes no problem

  • The fact that you lump all faiths together under the title "religions" shows how little you know about Torah. You hate because you know close to nothing about Judaism. Maimonides admits that circumcision's purpose is to reduce pleasure? I highly doubt that, having learned some Maimonies myself. Please supply a source and a location so that I could look that up. What Maimonides have you learned? Have you studied ANY Jewish texts? Please stop speaking from ignorance

  • @pshapiro1029 All religions are the same. Set aside your ethnocentric views for a moment and consider that most religions rely on faith and lack of proof with astounding claims of immortality or in Christianity's case punishment for non-believers.

  • Haha thanks for letting me know that my epistemological view needs work based on a YouTube comment. FEMALE circumcision? We're talking about male circumcision here, female circumcision (more accurately female mutilation) is COMPLETELY different, and not practiced in Judaism. It involves removal of the genitalia, while Jewish circumcision is simply the removal of extra skin that hangs of the penis. Bbmarble, you're an excellent example of the ignorance surrounding this issue.

  • @pshapiro1029 it's not extra skin. It's an entire body part. It's just as barbaric and disgusting as FGM.

    Male Circumcision is FAR more alike to female Circumcision than it is different. Both is removing an essential part of the genitals from a non consenting individual who is defenseless. Both are done for cultural and medical reasons. Both are blatant assaults on sexuality I'm sorry your cultural goggles don't allow you to see how all forms of genital mutilation are barbaric atrocities.

  • @drealgrin Perhaps you should think rather than jump to an anti-religious bias that the irrationality of the Christian belief system has created. I believe your cultural goggles are the problem here my friend. 1) an "essential part of the genitals"-how exactly is it essential? 2) Assaults on sexuality? I don't even know where you get that from. Nothing in all of Jewish philosophy suggests that. (If you know something I don't please enlighten me.

  • @pshapiro1029 it's essential to the complete sexual experience. thousands of species of animals have them, women have them. They are beneficial.

    Even Maimonides admits that circumcision's purpose is to reduce pleasure for both the male and the female.

    I don't really care for religion, but when i see Child abuse being inflicted in the name of religion that's when i start to HATE it. Religion is not an excuse to cut off parts of a newborn child's genitals. it's a barbaric blood ritual that maims

  • @drealgrin

    Completely agree. AND I'm from a Jewish family. I hate the fact that part of my penis was cut off.

  • @drealgrin All I ask is that you don't speak from ignorance like you just have. Don't judge all religious beliefs based on your own personal of what belief means and what G-d is.

  • How can you make judgments about a practice that you know nothing about, neither its legal foundation nor its philosophical meaning. Its "extremely damaging?? Where do you get that from? Everyone I know i circumcised, including myself, and I assure you we're not damaged or scarred. Jewish law is ancient and rooted in esoteric theology. You don't have to believe that, but don't speak ignorantly.

  • @pshapiro1029

    I know very little about female circumcision or the practice of suttee, but I know enough that they are to be condemned. I am circumcised myself but I have little knowledge of esoteric theology. Your epistemological world view needs some work, I do know that though.

  • Jewish jokes are funny (I was raised Jewish), and you did them well, but I agree, genital mutilation is irresponsible, and extremely damaging, not funny.

  • @SamsRawTruth I am a male and was circumcised. The doctor tied the stiches too tight so i had to go back and have another operation because it hurt every time i had a piss....Not a perfect scenario but have not hated the bible because of that. Some childhood things are over rated. Parents shouting endlessly has effected me more.....

  • Genital mutilation is freakin' hilarious.

  • non-consensual genital surgery is no laughing matter.

    The other jokes were funny though.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more