I like this as a tribute, but the song just doesn't work as punk. The whole point of it is the contrast between the cheerful, innocent pop sound and the dark lyrics. Punk already has an edge to it, and it can't make that contrast.
@boberstrule.. i agree this cover does kick ass but this song will NEVER have to be brought back to life lol... this song will forever get people out of their seats, out of their bad moods/ruts, and jumpin up and down singing as soon as the little drum fill in the intro of the song is heard.
Regardless of whether or not you like it (i like it, and the original), they at least had the decency to put effort into it and make it their own, unlike some other bands (*cough* Runner Runner). This is the kind of cover that brings honor to the original and to the covering band.
I love four year strong, but I'm not diggin this cover. I think only third eye blind can correctly play semi-charmed life. Everything else just doesn't cut it in my opinion.
For all of you saying this cover is garbage you can gtfo. Yeah they changed the song up a bit but a cover is not supposed to be EXACTLY like the original. I think they did a great job covering this song. Both versions of the song are awesome so shut up.
@Carthsgtr it was never a happy song, third eye blind's original still sounded happy to me. Plus FYS plays pop punk amazingly, it cant sound sad, its a classic song that you obviously didnt like that someone decided to touch. You cant say it was a garbage cover because they kept chords and lyrics the same.
OOO chords and lyrics the same... So if I played Pachabels cannon with the lyrics of Don't stop believing it would be a cover? You don't know what the fuck you are talking about you dumb cunt.
@Carthsgtr Dude, listen to it. Forget the lyrics for a second. If you are strictly talking about the feel of the song, then it is a happy song. It is possible to sing sad lyrics in a happy way, Fall Out Boy does it all the time.
covers arent meant to copy the original version nd make it sound exsactly the same there meant to be played from the other bands style nd point of view
Why do people automatically think that covers have to be competition with the originals?! A cover is a band reworking a song in their own style, paying tribute to the original artist. That's especially the case with this album- it's an album of songs which the band are saying inspired them when they were kids- and thanking them for driving them to play well, and eventually play the songs they loved to the people that love them, NOT to make a better version
I like this as a tribute, but the song just doesn't work as punk. The whole point of it is the contrast between the cheerful, innocent pop sound and the dark lyrics. Punk already has an edge to it, and it can't make that contrast.
Still sounds good though!
delson84 1 month ago
@boberstrule.. i agree this cover does kick ass but this song will NEVER have to be brought back to life lol... this song will forever get people out of their seats, out of their bad moods/ruts, and jumpin up and down singing as soon as the little drum fill in the intro of the song is heard.
ssmd923 2 months ago
great spin on an epic song. nice cover. i f i saw you guys playing at a bar youd have me jumpin' to this
ssmd923 2 months ago
come on guys. how much ass does this kick? an older song, maybe a classic, brought back to life for the new generation
bobertsrule 3 months ago 3
murder of a good song!
robovalentine 3 months ago
Awesome cover!!!
amrito92 3 months ago
i wish it wasn't so "punky".
EthanJones08 4 months ago
@EthanJones08 This isn't punk at all.
Sutho666 2 months ago
@Sutho666 What the fuck kinda drug are you on? How is this not punk? Learn your genres :|
YoshiAteMySamurai 1 month ago
@YoshiAteMySamurai no way dude. punk is only dudes with mohawks and ill-formed anarchist symbolism.
Hinoirocks 2 weeks ago
holy shit....... how did it take me 3 years for me to find one of my favorite bands covered my all time favorite bands all time favorite song....
Cartr1dgeBased 4 months ago
@Cartr1dgeBased Same mate, same! Fucking love 3eb and FYS
ausnick2001 4 months ago
the guy on the bottom right looks like Harry Potter. haha
dude515151COD 5 months ago
great cover, especially liked the little lead guitar run into the 2nd chorus at 1:40
mrpeppermintman 5 months ago
third eye blind's is better just because its better when its slower
nahtanoj246 6 months ago
Cool song but those other dudes figured out the feel
unicursalhex 6 months ago
Sorry but third eye blind is so much better
reallyletsdoit 7 months ago
@reallyletsdoit and???
befon 7 months ago
@reallyletsdoit no four year strong is a far more talented band all around sorry
justyn3tears 6 months ago
gotta love em (:
WatchthisonUtube2011 8 months ago
the bridge is epic
2315Mitch 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
IF YOU GET THE CHANCE PLEASE CHECK OUT OUR CHANNEL :)
trashqueen10 9 months ago
Regardless of whether or not you like it (i like it, and the original), they at least had the decency to put effort into it and make it their own, unlike some other bands (*cough* Runner Runner). This is the kind of cover that brings honor to the original and to the covering band.
PersonMan1234 9 months ago 2
I'm related to Joseph. Boo to the Yea!
xAPratte00x 10 months ago
the first verse is siick haha
synystergates543 10 months ago
I'm not gonna say anything stupid, but the four people who disliked the video are crazy. Great song though :)
UltimateClassix 10 months ago
tu-tu-tu-tututututu-tututu-ru-tu-tu-tu!
I love this song and this band:D
WatchthisonUtube2011 10 months ago
Four year strong is a awesome band and they just got awesomer with this cover
Puffythemagicmatt 11 months ago
I love four year strong, but I'm not diggin this cover. I think only third eye blind can correctly play semi-charmed life. Everything else just doesn't cut it in my opinion.
bjpw1234 11 months ago
Hey you know what I've never heard of Four Year Strong but respect for doing such an awesome cover of my favorite band! =)
This band obviously has talent
connieeeeeeeeee 11 months ago
great version, great cover hell yeah!
nefix123 1 year ago
not a bad cover.
dizzyisme 1 year ago
A guy didn't like this song so much that he made to accounts to dislike it.
alskoy 1 year ago
For all of you saying this cover is garbage you can gtfo. Yeah they changed the song up a bit but a cover is not supposed to be EXACTLY like the original. I think they did a great job covering this song. Both versions of the song are awesome so shut up.
DoctaKing69 1 year ago
Thanks for butchering my favoite childhood memory song, yea it's cool :'(
KdogTheReelz 1 year ago
@KdogTheReelz then don't listen to the awesome cover dipshit
TehAwesomeness 1 year ago
real niggaz...
lordofallmatter 1 year ago
They totally cut out the last verse :(
BVisionProductions 1 year ago
awesome cover!
FrostByte10101 1 year ago
this cover is awesome, i feel it has more intensity and emotion than the original
Zain2040 1 year ago 3
@Zain2040
It's not exactly a happy song. They got the feel wrong and it's that simple. Garbage cover.
Carthsgtr 1 year ago
@Carthsgtr it was never a happy song, third eye blind's original still sounded happy to me. Plus FYS plays pop punk amazingly, it cant sound sad, its a classic song that you obviously didnt like that someone decided to touch. You cant say it was a garbage cover because they kept chords and lyrics the same.
blindassassin92 10 months ago
@blindassassin92
OOO chords and lyrics the same... So if I played Pachabels cannon with the lyrics of Don't stop believing it would be a cover? You don't know what the fuck you are talking about you dumb cunt.
Carthsgtr 10 months ago
@Carthsgtr ummm it uses the same chords and lyrics as the original is what im saying. you obviously dont know what youre talking about.
blindassassin92 10 months ago
@Carthsgtr Dude, Third Eye Blind's version of this is happy too, you have no idea what the fuck you are talking about...
xXxSmoexXx 8 months ago
@xXxSmoexXx
Happy? Do you even understand the fucking lyrics..?
Carthsgtr 8 months ago
@Carthsgtr Dude, listen to it. Forget the lyrics for a second. If you are strictly talking about the feel of the song, then it is a happy song. It is possible to sing sad lyrics in a happy way, Fall Out Boy does it all the time.
xXxSmoexXx 8 months ago 7
@xXxSmoexXx Fall Out Boy does it soooooo much it isnt even funny XD
ErictheSickist95 7 months ago
so much more my style than the original
muuusene 1 year ago
Eargasm xD
punknation101 1 year ago
I like both versions. I'll listen to one depending on the mood im in lol
Xiphas80 1 year ago
A brilliant cover, old elements and Four Year Strong's elements aswell =)
londunhill 1 year ago
covers arent meant to copy the original version nd make it sound exsactly the same there meant to be played from the other bands style nd point of view
SoothsayerXAngel 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
doin crystal meth will lift you up until you break you wont stop
saberwulf 1 year ago
Why do people automatically think that covers have to be competition with the originals?! A cover is a band reworking a song in their own style, paying tribute to the original artist. That's especially the case with this album- it's an album of songs which the band are saying inspired them when they were kids- and thanking them for driving them to play well, and eventually play the songs they loved to the people that love them, NOT to make a better version
TheMaggotChicken 1 year ago 137
@TheMaggotChicken I don't know! Why ya asking me!?
s10wcheetah 1 year ago
@TheMaggotChicken Fucking thank you!
allseeingeye925 6 months ago
@JennettexxLovato Whatever., Third Eye Blind sucks.! :). Four year strong is amazing.
giutar24 1 year ago
@giutar24 ...no.
finalconflictpro 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Wow. Fail. I think Third Eye Blind 's is WAY better than this.
JennettexxLovato 1 year ago
i love this
MCTproductionz 1 year ago
Comment removed
nonieownie 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i like four year strong but this sucks...
PutUpOrShutUp221 1 year ago
I'm pretty sure this is an album full of their Childhood Music Inspirations.
OpenlyClosed 2 years ago 66
@OpenlyClosed thats a good idea
Gussy7182 1 year ago
@OpenlyClosed im pretty sure this is shit.
guitaHer099 1 year ago
pretty sure FUCK YOU
lordsetts 1 year ago
@lordsetts im pretty sure you can dine on a hearty breakfast of cocks my friend.
guitaHer099 1 year ago
Comment removed
666Nami666 2 years ago