From 1990-1996 Mariah did thousands of shows even little promo's like this in various little countries where her songs pretty much tortured her voice! Never ever once lipped... People think why her voice has changed stop being so blunt! She delivered more than any other female she never said NO!
MARIAH AND CELINE HAVE DIFFERENT VOICE YOU MEEN,MARIAH I NO SHE SING GOSPEL,R&B SOUL, POP, SO THAT THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,CELINE SING R&B,SOUL,POP,SO THIS THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,I DONT NO WY WHEN CELINE SING WHITE POEPLE CANT BELIEVE T,THEY TALK LIKE SHE DHO WONDER,THEY SHEY BEST SINGER,WELL I LOVE CELINE,BUT I CANT SHEY SHE IS THE WON SINGIN WHITE POEPLE MUSIC?BUT CANT SHEY SHE CANT SING,BUT THAT ANT NEW FOR BLACK POEPLE,THEY NO ALL THE NOOT SHES HIT.
MARIAH AND CELINE HAVE DIFFERENT VOICE YOU MEEN,MARIAH I NO SHE SING GOSPEL,R&B SOUL, POP, SO THAT THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,CELINE SING R&B,SOUL,POP,SO THIS THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,I DONT NO WY WHEN CELINE SING WHITE POEPLE CANT BELIEVE T,THEY TALK LIKE SHE DHO WONDER,THEY SHEY BEST SINGER,WELL I LOVE CELINE,BUT I CANT SHEY SHE IS THE WON SINGIN WHITE POEPLE MUSIC?BUT CANT SHEY SHE CANT SING,BUT THAT ANT NEW FOR BLACK POEPLE,THEY NO ALL THE NOOT SHES HIT.
@tasha9976 Only God knows what you wrote there, but from what i have understood i have to tell you this has nothing to do with being white or black, is wayyy much simple than that, it is as simple as this: IF YOUr TRYING TO BE A SINGER TO BECOME ONE YOU HAVE TO BE ABLE TO SING VERY WELL. All the rest are singer wannabes that may sound not too bad, like Britney does,shes sounds Ok but she can't b named a singer, as an example.
@rociofg finally someone is saying what i feel! Everyone bash Mariah now and days because she cant sing like this no more and its not fair! Mariah paid her duties all ready we all know she cant belt and sing amazingly! I hate how compared Mariah with Beyonce!! Beyonce will never be as big as Mariah because Beyonce does not sing like Mariah! I hate when people praise Rihanna and all does wanna bees! many now and days singers should be called performers not singers!
you kow, even if mariah cant sing great now, she still made some of the most amazing music in the world in the past and it will be around forever. im still waiting for some of these new pop stars to sing ANYTHING as good as Mariah sang all her songs 15 years ago. 15-20 years and still no one (except Celine Dion) has come even close.
@Jzend001 no way you're writing celine dion - mariah - and singing on the same sentence, celine dion seems like a horrible singer to me, what is it that her fans like so much about her ? please tell me so i can understand !!!
@rociofg celine is a horrible singer?then how did she make all of those hits MHWGO, BYLM, ABM and a lot of other stuff, im sure you can recognised at least these 3 songs of hers, yes she can be nasally at times, but i wouldn't horrible, im sure its her persona when she's on stage that gets to people, and of course the voice as well, when it is less nasal if that's what u want to hear, i would say mariah HAD a better voice, but celine NOW i would say has a better voice, of course that depends
@Jzend001 You're quite right, but actually Celine Dion is much more popular than Mariah. Celine is a diva all over the world and in Ukraine there's no person who doesn't know who celine is. Mariah is super popular in the USA and some other countries and she will never be as popular in France as in the US, because of the kind of music she does.
We all are waiting for a new singer, who can be as pretty as Mariah, Celine, Lara, Whitney! Nowadays singers don't make good music.!
The quality of the video is terrible, but seriously during this era her voice OWNS. She has perfect control of her flawless voice, be it low or high registers. Even her expressions and signature hand gestures, they make everything about Mariah just too beautiful to watch. I wonder what the music industry would've been like without her.
the old days but surely after her tour cause it was when she started to cut down her songs while performing live. What a voice!!! I love to see those videos cause they show me what a liar she is when she says that Tommy forced her to wear clothes from neck to ankles, of course she wears more clothes than now that she barely dresses but she had on a mini skirt, really mini, the boots, the belly blouse, cleavage, etc., she had no boobs back then and her attitude was lovely. Nice looking back then
@cinqoctaves HEr Voice Is Gone Lol You Must Be Tone Deaf!! She might not have the exact same voice she did 20 yrs ago but she still remains number 1 far as vocals and impresses me everytime!! but than again she still human voice might be superhuman but who would have the same voice after 20 yrs no one and wheres your album
mottola didn't like her using it very much in this era, besides it's hard to whistle when you just belted out a lot and this song contains lot's of G5's
@dreamdate How do you know that he didn't like it? I never heard anything about anyone telling her when to hit it. If you heard some live performances of Emotions she avoids the high notes. Sometimes she can't ever pull them off. That part of your voice is very unpredictable. Plus the fact that the only time Mariah sang live was on TV, she didn't sing live too often, compared to other pop singers of that time so her ecperience was not very good.
@promisuous88 well she stated it in interviews he told her to do that, remember the can't let go video and radio edit, they cut out the whistle. But that refers mostly to her songwriting and studiowork, when it comes to live performances it is indeed very unpredictable, but if you use chest voice a lot it gets hard to hit them nicely those high notes. x
She used more whistles in the past, if you don't know. And presently, she don't even use the whistles in every song. You are creating a hyperbole here. Listen her albums carefully before commenting next time. Don't just hear singles, there are OTHER good songs that didn't become singles after such a long time.
you know you're a fan when you notice Mariah, accidentally or otherwise, singing a line in a different way, and you can predict exactly how she'll sing the next line to save it, haha.
Regarding everyone talking about lip syncing - the sad truth is that everyone does it at some point in their careers. All the huge artists, including Mariah, do an impossible number of performances a year, so it would be a miracle for their vocal chords to remain intact. With that said, Mariah is just amazing. Everyone has their opinions, but her 18 number one songs speak for themselves.
sorry but i can't stand u saying mariah makes a lot of lipsync, because that is a huge LIE, and if u want to try, count the live performances and the lipsync ones, when u got the result , come and tell me. have a nice day
i can't remember the animal/person but you are both using the same templates. his/her page is full or mariah but he/she hates mariah so much. ur delusional. ur a regine velasquez fan am i correct?
I've never, ever heard anyone whistle like Mariah.. I've listened to so many identical whistlers, and NONE of them sound like her! She is something else..
lol mariah sucks? AHAHA that's CRAZY to say. Beyonce SUCKS her whiney ass melisma makes my ears bleed. Beyonce does NOT sound good. She can SING but she doesn't SOUND good
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
She WAS one of the best singers BUT NEVER WAS the one and only best. There were great singers also same league as hers. With her current voice, She def WILL NEVER be the BEST. Her voice is CRAPPY, CRACKS A LOT, HARSH as if she is grating something in her throat. Seeing her perform makes people nervous she might get off-key. Live performance, she SUCKS a lot, STIFF, BORING. Worst, she DESPERATELY turned into a TRYING HARD, SEX ICON WANNABE to get people's attention. YUCK! PATHETIC!
um yeah beyonce really does rule shes the best there is nowadays. but mariah is still amazing, her voice is alot different to how it used to be when she was younger, but when she hits a note in her newer songs it doesnt crack or sound harsh to me, it sounds crisp and still a good note. if she really was as crap as ur making out then she wouldnt still be getting songs in the chart and selling loads of albums would she?
I hate when people critize Mariah's singing. The woman has the best voice and her songs are so hard to sing that u will never hear anyone try to re-sing her songs because they all know that they wouldn't even come close to her abilities.
true. But it's not the 90s voice they critisize. If anyone (for example idol contestants) tries to sing her songs it just reminds us of how unique and extroadinairy Mariahs voice was. No on can outsing Mariah in her prime. But her voice has changed. Her live performances now obviously have a lot more flaws and it takes a lot more effort to hit certain notes. As a huge fan, it even frustrates me. But it is what it is. She's still amazing.
its just my opinion but i dont think either MC or WH tried to outshine each other. its just the way the song goes.. at the part where they both belt MC was hitting a higher note than WH and at that point in time MC's voice was on a breakdown so her power just wasnt there, while WH was doing an easier lower belting note that didnt cause her voice to break. ps I'm not saying that either ones a better singer than the other just coz i said mc's voice broke or wh hit a lower note. i luv them both
your both right on the oscars mariah's voice was struggling, but, and im not a whitney basher i love whitney but did no-one think she tries to act sort of condescending towards mariah especially on the oprah performance when mariah starts singing you can see that she's just smiling into the audience which i think is kinda rude of her!! but they both amazing mariah my fav!!! :-)
did u see the look of HORROR on mariah's face when Whitney tried to BELT on her at the Oscars, classic moment, Mariah Carey has always been classy, she NEVER tries to vocally outshine anyone, not Aretha, Not diana ross, not Whitney, Not Joe, Not Nas, no one.
Whitney Houston really was triflin with that. not cool.
Again, this is a HARD song to sing, it goes from pop to gospel with a swooping vocal. This is hard. mariah has long been known as a "secretive studio singer", other than UNPLUGGED, and her early performances, she's never been an INCREDIBLE live singer. But she's adored because her vocals are human, emotional, passionate, full of fear, hurt, and passion. She sings like a beautiful bird, she has never been a belter. She's a graceful singer.
No no no i have to stop you know!Mariah was an INCREDIBLE LIVE SINGER during her prime.She was a belter from 1990 to 1996, just watch Tokyo Dome or MSG,her voice was awesome live.She was a beast before and too many people tend to foget that!
calm down, before you explode, lol. i agree. mariah has NEVER been much of a belter, she's a songbird, she sings in soft keys, until the end then she belts, she's not a FULL Time belter like a Whitney or Debra Cox, she's more gifted. Mariah was a Great Singer until the Rainbow CD, then thangs changed, she's More soulful now. Which I like.
there is no way this is in argentina, the guy is the presenter of wtten das,and obviously , he speaks german. and i think it's also the same stage of the wetten das show
If you watched Mariah's interviews, when she speaks, her voice is really in a low-pitch. Maybe her low pitch voice could help her hitting very low notes. Whitney is not gifted as Mariah but they are both great singers.
He´s only saying that Mariah had sung this live and had asked the other guest if they like it. They said yeah and a little blabla. nothing really important.
it is VERY pure! that's what i try to explain to most peeps who don't understand how clear her voice is. unlike christina's who's voice is muffled and not pure to me.
while it is a fact that Christina Aguilera can BLOW, and on songs like Loving Me 4 Me, she sounds like a mariah-wannabe. Mariah's voice is just Incredible and soft as a whisper and powerful when she needs to be. I would NEVER mention These two in the same sentence, Mariah is an Icon. Christina Aguilera is still tryin to find her way. The record sales pretty much give the answer.
christina screams her high voices. there was a poll a few weeks ago and i know it's prob just opinion but ms xtina was on the list as one of the most overrated singers out there lol she was in top 10 . i was surprised not the fact that she was on there but that other people noticed too lol.
Honey I knwo Mariah by heart and I've seen all the ATYNAF performances.She never sounded as powerful and impressive and never hit the numerous G5 notes at the end like in the studio.
The Proctor's Theater is the most impressive, but the key was lowered.The Tokyo Dome version is also awesome(especially the ad-lib on some words),but the key is once again lowered and the end is totally changed,so no comparison can be made.
she may have lowered the key on each live prformance of this song but even thou each live prformance was great and she changed some notes around which she hit the G5 on as well...
oh sorry heheh.. got a bit carried away... well if u wanna see some of her live prformances which were much more impressive than her studio versions check out some of her tokyo dome prformances in 1996
Whitney has power... mariah has a beautiful voice but at mariah's BEST she was BETTER than whitney's best... check out her early 1990's performances they make you cry
LOL. That's Thomas Gottschalk. Yeah, he often displays a touchy preoccupation with various body parts of his femal guests.. Lives in a castle nowadays.
and this is y she is the best in thw world...leona beyonce xtina cant touch this bitch...whitney is the only one who comes close...infact they tie but the others dont come close
actually i think xtina is closer than whitney, some people is goig to kill me ... but i think WH is not AS GOOD as we were said she was, i have never seen performances of WH as good as mariah's Tokyo Dome, for example... but i'm a huge fan of WH too.
in this lifetime only TWO women will be left standing WHITNEY and MARIAH. XTINA has NOT gotten the awards or sold the amount of records that Whitney and Mariah has. and to be honest she DOES NOT HAVE THAT SINGLE yet, Whitney has I Will Always Love u, mariah has HERO & W.B. Together. Xtina is Incredible but her song choices are disappointing, Her music DOES NOT match her voice.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
not true at all, Christina sometimes sounds like whitney on certain notes and her lower register sounds a little like Mariah, her nuances. even her hand gestures on ballds.
oh please, she SO does not sound like either. Her low notes sound like mariah? no way Whitney and mariah have such distinct sounds and so does christina I've seen a ton of xtina performances as I am a fan of her
Her hand gestures lol, yeah she copies mariah because she looked up to mariah. Her annoying hand ticks that she constantly does by slapping the microphone with her two fingers... that's her own invention, but the other hand flailing is from mariah , that's my opinion. I've heard xtina's song infatuation and all of her "stripped" album songs as well. I like that album but when she uses her upper register she sounds nothing like mariah or whitney, and even in the lower register. I just disagree
@rociofg I'm sorry but WH is by far the best known singer on record, Mariah is a close second. Christina has no control over her voice and is all over the place when she sings. 1. Whitney / Aretha 2. Mariah / Patti 3. Tina Turner / Beyonce 4. Celine / Christina
@kingtrapper06 WhatQ? are you retarded?? Mariah is known by all generations bc she re-invents herself. NOONE in this generation knows who the hell Whitney or Aretha is!!
@petergriffin9901 The fact that you have to immediately jump to baseless insults shows you true intellect. Who are you to speak for this generation? When did you become the ambassador to speak on behalf of this generation? There are plenty of people within this generation who are aware of Whitney and Aretha.
@rociofg agree 100 %. I think WH is a little overrated, and Mariah a little underrated. WH had a hell of stage presence and a powerful middle and upper chest register, But Mariah (at her peak) owns her in every register.
It's mad how she sings in the upper register like it's nothing. Really, I mean what the fuck?
RanjitMorey 2 weeks ago
From 1990-1996 Mariah did thousands of shows even little promo's like this in various little countries where her songs pretty much tortured her voice! Never ever once lipped... People think why her voice has changed stop being so blunt! She delivered more than any other female she never said NO!
TheMickj23q 5 months ago
Unbelievably incredible performance. I love the G5 towards the end on "YOU can shine!"
stardusth2o 6 months ago
those legs!
JudeSantana 8 months ago
I don't know which one is better - to listen or to look at her.
MMarianne9 8 months ago
Love it !
omaralani1 9 months ago
everyone is wrong when they say that mariah can not sing as great as before Mariah Best ever <3 I love so much this music <3
ekiiim 11 months ago
I Swear The Host Guy Reminds Me Of The Movie Willy Wonka And The Chocolate Factory.
1marisolmc 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Lady GaGa stands around topless and in her panties - Naked Lady Gaga. C00M -
Tomasine2009 1 year ago
She looks so confident in this performance!! Love it!!
MariahCareyAngel1 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
MARIAH AND CELINE HAVE DIFFERENT VOICE YOU MEEN,MARIAH I NO SHE SING GOSPEL,R&B SOUL, POP, SO THAT THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,CELINE SING R&B,SOUL,POP,SO THIS THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,I DONT NO WY WHEN CELINE SING WHITE POEPLE CANT BELIEVE T,THEY TALK LIKE SHE DHO WONDER,THEY SHEY BEST SINGER,WELL I LOVE CELINE,BUT I CANT SHEY SHE IS THE WON SINGIN WHITE POEPLE MUSIC?BUT CANT SHEY SHE CANT SING,BUT THAT ANT NEW FOR BLACK POEPLE,THEY NO ALL THE NOOT SHES HIT.
tasha9976 1 year ago
MARIAH AND CELINE HAVE DIFFERENT VOICE YOU MEEN,MARIAH I NO SHE SING GOSPEL,R&B SOUL, POP, SO THAT THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,CELINE SING R&B,SOUL,POP,SO THIS THEY CALL BLACK MUSIC,I DONT NO WY WHEN CELINE SING WHITE POEPLE CANT BELIEVE T,THEY TALK LIKE SHE DHO WONDER,THEY SHEY BEST SINGER,WELL I LOVE CELINE,BUT I CANT SHEY SHE IS THE WON SINGIN WHITE POEPLE MUSIC?BUT CANT SHEY SHE CANT SING,BUT THAT ANT NEW FOR BLACK POEPLE,THEY NO ALL THE NOOT SHES HIT.
tasha9976 1 year ago
@tasha9976 Only God knows what you wrote there, but from what i have understood i have to tell you this has nothing to do with being white or black, is wayyy much simple than that, it is as simple as this: IF YOUr TRYING TO BE A SINGER TO BECOME ONE YOU HAVE TO BE ABLE TO SING VERY WELL. All the rest are singer wannabes that may sound not too bad, like Britney does,shes sounds Ok but she can't b named a singer, as an example.
rociofg 1 year ago 22
@rociofg finally someone is saying what i feel! Everyone bash Mariah now and days because she cant sing like this no more and its not fair! Mariah paid her duties all ready we all know she cant belt and sing amazingly! I hate how compared Mariah with Beyonce!! Beyonce will never be as big as Mariah because Beyonce does not sing like Mariah! I hate when people praise Rihanna and all does wanna bees! many now and days singers should be called performers not singers!
pimpjoker2005 1 year ago
@rociofg "Only God knows what you wrote there" I know right?!?! lol thanks for that laugh
JudeSantana 8 months ago
you kow, even if mariah cant sing great now, she still made some of the most amazing music in the world in the past and it will be around forever. im still waiting for some of these new pop stars to sing ANYTHING as good as Mariah sang all her songs 15 years ago. 15-20 years and still no one (except Celine Dion) has come even close.
Jzend001 1 year ago 6
@Jzend001 no way you're writing celine dion - mariah - and singing on the same sentence, celine dion seems like a horrible singer to me, what is it that her fans like so much about her ? please tell me so i can understand !!!
rociofg 1 year ago 6
@rociofg celine and mariah have very different voices, but they're both great. celine can hit some pretty awesome notes.
Jzend001 1 year ago
@rociofg I agree with you about Celine and Mariah.
tipofmytongue1024 1 year ago
@rociofg i agree. celine's voice is very common. i can name so many singer that sounds like celine dion
nathan2600 5 months ago
@rociofg celine is a horrible singer?then how did she make all of those hits MHWGO, BYLM, ABM and a lot of other stuff, im sure you can recognised at least these 3 songs of hers, yes she can be nasally at times, but i wouldn't horrible, im sure its her persona when she's on stage that gets to people, and of course the voice as well, when it is less nasal if that's what u want to hear, i would say mariah HAD a better voice, but celine NOW i would say has a better voice, of course that depends
kamal6991 3 days ago
@Jzend001 You're quite right, but actually Celine Dion is much more popular than Mariah. Celine is a diva all over the world and in Ukraine there's no person who doesn't know who celine is. Mariah is super popular in the USA and some other countries and she will never be as popular in France as in the US, because of the kind of music she does.
We all are waiting for a new singer, who can be as pretty as Mariah, Celine, Lara, Whitney! Nowadays singers don't make good music.!
Forever1Charmed 8 months ago
The quality of the video is terrible, but seriously during this era her voice OWNS. She has perfect control of her flawless voice, be it low or high registers. Even her expressions and signature hand gestures, they make everything about Mariah just too beautiful to watch. I wonder what the music industry would've been like without her.
BBQJester 1 year ago
the old days but surely after her tour cause it was when she started to cut down her songs while performing live. What a voice!!! I love to see those videos cause they show me what a liar she is when she says that Tommy forced her to wear clothes from neck to ankles, of course she wears more clothes than now that she barely dresses but she had on a mini skirt, really mini, the boots, the belly blouse, cleavage, etc., she had no boobs back then and her attitude was lovely. Nice looking back then
baretreemty 1 year ago
she´s the best female singer in history (for me)!!! she made music history like no one else ... I love her ... :)
croatia93 1 year ago
One of my favourite Mariah songs ever! She sounded just amazing!
feeklv 1 year ago
@cinqoctaves HEr Voice Is Gone Lol You Must Be Tone Deaf!! She might not have the exact same voice she did 20 yrs ago but she still remains number 1 far as vocals and impresses me everytime!! but than again she still human voice might be superhuman but who would have the same voice after 20 yrs no one and wheres your album
aaron3063 1 year ago
anyone know what they were saying after her performance? all I could make out was "without you" and "cd player" :p
fallingfirenze 1 year ago
:48, 49, 50...that b can SING!
jerseydime10 2 years ago
bizarre - the hesitant pause before the applause - what does the audience want - blood ;0)
maxipowers22 2 years ago
She's a freakin money machine. How I miss the old Mariah
ramdodgetruck 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
Aleeshaee 2 years ago
mottola didn't like her using it very much in this era, besides it's hard to whistle when you just belted out a lot and this song contains lot's of G5's
dreamdate 2 years ago
@dreamdate How do you know that he didn't like it? I never heard anything about anyone telling her when to hit it. If you heard some live performances of Emotions she avoids the high notes. Sometimes she can't ever pull them off. That part of your voice is very unpredictable. Plus the fact that the only time Mariah sang live was on TV, she didn't sing live too often, compared to other pop singers of that time so her ecperience was not very good.
promisuous88 1 year ago
@promisuous88 well she stated it in interviews he told her to do that, remember the can't let go video and radio edit, they cut out the whistle. But that refers mostly to her songwriting and studiowork, when it comes to live performances it is indeed very unpredictable, but if you use chest voice a lot it gets hard to hit them nicely those high notes. x
dreamdate 1 year ago
This shows how much you don't know her.
She used more whistles in the past, if you don't know. And presently, she don't even use the whistles in every song. You are creating a hyperbole here. Listen her albums carefully before commenting next time. Don't just hear singles, there are OTHER good songs that didn't become singles after such a long time.
minghaoxD 2 years ago
you know you're a fan when you notice Mariah, accidentally or otherwise, singing a line in a different way, and you can predict exactly how she'll sing the next line to save it, haha.
gloomyoutlook 2 years ago 36
@gloomyoutlook OMG UR SOOOO RIGHT hahahahahah im putting that on my facebook status hahah
Hea7enOnEarth 1 year ago
@gloomyoutlook I know EXACTLY what you mean!
Crzymofo69 3 days ago
wonderful!
brunodussoni 2 years ago 5
The backing vocalist at 1:03 WRONG! and did the second voice for "No No No..." But Mariah sunged another part! ahahahah!
BiDiO 2 years ago 3
You mean around 2:01
Zoroastrianistic 2 years ago
Comment removed
WilmaMHolla 2 years ago
Comment removed
WilmaMHolla 2 years ago
Regarding everyone talking about lip syncing - the sad truth is that everyone does it at some point in their careers. All the huge artists, including Mariah, do an impossible number of performances a year, so it would be a miracle for their vocal chords to remain intact. With that said, Mariah is just amazing. Everyone has their opinions, but her 18 number one songs speak for themselves.
subsido 2 years ago
WOW AMAZING!!!!!!!!!
orangecarrotcake 2 years ago
"the Lambs" are gonna attack you, and then i'll be reciting "i wish u well to u". lol
Ty2phine 2 years ago
sorry but i can't stand u saying mariah makes a lot of lipsync, because that is a huge LIE, and if u want to try, count the live performances and the lipsync ones, when u got the result , come and tell me. have a nice day
rociofg 2 years ago
OMG! this is the first time i've seen this GEM. !
artookhey 2 years ago
i can't remember the animal/person but you are both using the same templates. his/her page is full or mariah but he/she hates mariah so much. ur delusional. ur a regine velasquez fan am i correct?
artookhey 2 years ago
try hard haters.. but u can never put mc down... haha
magayonx 2 years ago
Mariah's whistle is different because she uses the vocal nodules on her larynx to do it. NOT everyone can do it like mariah :)
XforeverlongingX 2 years ago
I've never, ever heard anyone whistle like Mariah.. I've listened to so many identical whistlers, and NONE of them sound like her! She is something else..
roojooroojoo 2 years ago
lol mariah sucks? AHAHA that's CRAZY to say. Beyonce SUCKS her whiney ass melisma makes my ears bleed. Beyonce does NOT sound good. She can SING but she doesn't SOUND good
XforeverlongingX 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She WAS one of the best singers BUT NEVER WAS the one and only best. There were great singers also same league as hers. With her current voice, She def WILL NEVER be the BEST. Her voice is CRAPPY, CRACKS A LOT, HARSH as if she is grating something in her throat. Seeing her perform makes people nervous she might get off-key. Live performance, she SUCKS a lot, STIFF, BORING. Worst, she DESPERATELY turned into a TRYING HARD, SEX ICON WANNABE to get people's attention. YUCK! PATHETIC!
BEYONCERULES
HuShism 2 years ago
um yeah beyonce really does rule shes the best there is nowadays. but mariah is still amazing, her voice is alot different to how it used to be when she was younger, but when she hits a note in her newer songs it doesnt crack or sound harsh to me, it sounds crisp and still a good note. if she really was as crap as ur making out then she wouldnt still be getting songs in the chart and selling loads of albums would she?
louis1phoenix2 2 years ago
you have no idea of what ur sayin, i'm bee fan too, but she will never be mariah , sorry
rociofg 2 years ago
Omgsh. Her voice is flawless here. This is just wonderful.
Coolbeanz19 2 years ago
Is that Naomi Campbell in the middle of the 3 guys
Mar1fan 2 years ago
Yes!!
ricobhi 2 years ago
your voice sounds like today
kouldeliee 2 years ago
just not right. :)
officialmacmillan 2 years ago
why are u watching this video then
smartguy1013 2 years ago
Maybe you are enable to see that this Video is from 1994, so this is the Mariah I love......
ANd yes sometimes I can watch a video just to see how much I dislike it!
cinqoctaves 2 years ago
mariah sings like today here
kouldeliee 2 years ago
I hate when people critize Mariah's singing. The woman has the best voice and her songs are so hard to sing that u will never hear anyone try to re-sing her songs because they all know that they wouldn't even come close to her abilities.
Mariahis1 2 years ago 23
its so true!
matthewsparkes300 2 years ago
true. But it's not the 90s voice they critisize. If anyone (for example idol contestants) tries to sing her songs it just reminds us of how unique and extroadinairy Mariahs voice was. No on can outsing Mariah in her prime. But her voice has changed. Her live performances now obviously have a lot more flaws and it takes a lot more effort to hit certain notes. As a huge fan, it even frustrates me. But it is what it is. She's still amazing.
MissJayG 2 years ago 4
the best mariah
alpurod 2 years ago 2
its just my opinion but i dont think either MC or WH tried to outshine each other. its just the way the song goes.. at the part where they both belt MC was hitting a higher note than WH and at that point in time MC's voice was on a breakdown so her power just wasnt there, while WH was doing an easier lower belting note that didnt cause her voice to break. ps I'm not saying that either ones a better singer than the other just coz i said mc's voice broke or wh hit a lower note. i luv them both
jamm210 2 years ago
your both right on the oscars mariah's voice was struggling, but, and im not a whitney basher i love whitney but did no-one think she tries to act sort of condescending towards mariah especially on the oprah performance when mariah starts singing you can see that she's just smiling into the audience which i think is kinda rude of her!! but they both amazing mariah my fav!!! :-)
kiki86no1 2 years ago
this fuckersª that deserved a standing ovation
darkslayer0218 3 years ago 2
the guy at the beginning looks like willy wonka
star21893 3 years ago 2
but on oprah mariah killed whitney during their performance, but ur right on the oscars mariah lost
MCFan20000 3 years ago
did u see the look of HORROR on mariah's face when Whitney tried to BELT on her at the Oscars, classic moment, Mariah Carey has always been classy, she NEVER tries to vocally outshine anyone, not Aretha, Not diana ross, not Whitney, Not Joe, Not Nas, no one.
Whitney Houston really was triflin with that. not cool.
Ty2phine 3 years ago
lol there is no HORROR face in that performance... in that part, is whitney who sings always...
I dunno... I think it is just a nice face to say... it's your turn, cam on sing...
furacarles1 3 years ago
It is however possible to hit G5 notes, thing Mariah never did on this song.
I don't blame her for that,but here her voice was obviously weak and she was not in the best vocal conditions!
But her tone is always amazing!
cinqoctaves 3 years ago
Again, this is a HARD song to sing, it goes from pop to gospel with a swooping vocal. This is hard. mariah has long been known as a "secretive studio singer", other than UNPLUGGED, and her early performances, she's never been an INCREDIBLE live singer. But she's adored because her vocals are human, emotional, passionate, full of fear, hurt, and passion. She sings like a beautiful bird, she has never been a belter. She's a graceful singer.
Ty2phine 3 years ago
No no no i have to stop you know!Mariah was an INCREDIBLE LIVE SINGER during her prime.She was a belter from 1990 to 1996, just watch Tokyo Dome or MSG,her voice was awesome live.She was a beast before and too many people tend to foget that!
cinqoctaves 3 years ago
calm down, before you explode, lol. i agree. mariah has NEVER been much of a belter, she's a songbird, she sings in soft keys, until the end then she belts, she's not a FULL Time belter like a Whitney or Debra Cox, she's more gifted. Mariah was a Great Singer until the Rainbow CD, then thangs changed, she's More soulful now. Which I like.
Ty2phine 3 years ago
how ccan u say she's not an incredible singer ? who is it for u ? i mean, mariah on that time was HUGE on her vocals !
rociofg 2 years ago 3
of course she did check the one at the tokyo dome out..she even hits a higher note there and I think on the D.L. show she does hit a G5
MCFan20000 3 years ago
Um sorry, but you're wrong check out this performance: Mariah Carey Anytime You Need A Friend Live At Mega Hits Argentina 1994
She's extraordinary.
Coolbeanz19 2 years ago
there is no way this is in argentina, the guy is the presenter of wtten das,and obviously , he speaks german. and i think it's also the same stage of the wetten das show
rociofg 2 years ago
If you watched Mariah's interviews, when she speaks, her voice is really in a low-pitch. Maybe her low pitch voice could help her hitting very low notes. Whitney is not gifted as Mariah but they are both great singers.
ninawilliams023 3 years ago
The tone is one of the reasons people fell in love with her voice! It's so angelic.
Sall80 3 years ago
обожаю эту песню!!!
senik1991 3 years ago
What the hect are those German folks saying??
Marvinglz 3 years ago
He´s only saying that Mariah had sung this live and had asked the other guest if they like it. They said yeah and a little blabla. nothing really important.
Alessia1978 3 years ago
Every performance of this song is amazing!! Mariah is unparalleled in terms of singing.
shakeitoff219 3 years ago 6
I love how she sounded amazing...and the audience is so dead.
bewander 3 years ago
its prolly cause most of them dont speak english lol!
trmc1990 3 years ago
she sounds so pure and clear!!
iglesianuevoamanezer 3 years ago 5
just listen to how clean and pure her voice sounds. its breathtakin...
stphnmunroe 3 years ago 5
it is VERY pure! that's what i try to explain to most peeps who don't understand how clear her voice is. unlike christina's who's voice is muffled and not pure to me.
sripeat 3 years ago
while it is a fact that Christina Aguilera can BLOW, and on songs like Loving Me 4 Me, she sounds like a mariah-wannabe. Mariah's voice is just Incredible and soft as a whisper and powerful when she needs to be. I would NEVER mention These two in the same sentence, Mariah is an Icon. Christina Aguilera is still tryin to find her way. The record sales pretty much give the answer.
Ty2phine 3 years ago
christina screams her high voices. there was a poll a few weeks ago and i know it's prob just opinion but ms xtina was on the list as one of the most overrated singers out there lol she was in top 10 . i was surprised not the fact that she was on there but that other people noticed too lol.
sripeat 3 years ago
watch the one on david letterman. she has a couple of live performances of this song on here. she kills the song live.
star917 3 years ago
Honey I knwo Mariah by heart and I've seen all the ATYNAF performances.She never sounded as powerful and impressive and never hit the numerous G5 notes at the end like in the studio.
The Proctor's Theater is the most impressive, but the key was lowered.The Tokyo Dome version is also awesome(especially the ad-lib on some words),but the key is once again lowered and the end is totally changed,so no comparison can be made.
cinqoctaves 3 years ago
she may have lowered the key on each live prformance of this song but even thou each live prformance was great and she changed some notes around which she hit the G5 on as well...
jamm210 3 years ago
I never said that the fact of lowering the key makes the performance bad, all I know is that she never sound as impressive as the studio version.
But some live of this song are truly great!
cinqoctaves 3 years ago
oh sorry heheh.. got a bit carried away... well if u wanna see some of her live prformances which were much more impressive than her studio versions check out some of her tokyo dome prformances in 1996
jamm210 3 years ago
magistral
daslive 3 years ago
hehe
der gottschalk noch ur jung :D
globe1globe1 3 years ago
love her hand haha cute and funny
hipshak 3 years ago
I'm not her fan but know all the lyrics of her old songs !!!
hipshak 3 years ago
LOVE ALL THOSE SONGS THE BEST VOICE OF THIS PLANET EARTH EVERYTHING !!
but not now!!
everytime you need a friznd I'll be here !!
never be lonely there !!so don't you fear!!!
....am I your side !!!!;;;;;;
hipshak 3 years ago
is this the same day as the letterman perf cuz its the same outfit??
genius3495 3 years ago
i love this song and her voice
randdss 3 years ago 3
xtramc your comments i agre...haaa whitney is the only on e vocallt at par with the great Mariah carey
valthaa 4 years ago
Whitney has power... mariah has a beautiful voice but at mariah's BEST she was BETTER than whitney's best... check out her early 1990's performances they make you cry
foreverlonging 3 years ago 7
What a perv the presenter is
gdewa 4 years ago 4
LOL. That's Thomas Gottschalk. Yeah, he often displays a touchy preoccupation with various body parts of his femal guests.. Lives in a castle nowadays.
zendakk 4 years ago
speachless.
VelvetNick 4 years ago 3
and this is y she is the best in thw world...leona beyonce xtina cant touch this bitch...whitney is the only one who comes close...infact they tie but the others dont come close
xtramc 4 years ago 5
actually i think xtina is closer than whitney, some people is goig to kill me ... but i think WH is not AS GOOD as we were said she was, i have never seen performances of WH as good as mariah's Tokyo Dome, for example... but i'm a huge fan of WH too.
rociofg 2 years ago
in this lifetime only TWO women will be left standing WHITNEY and MARIAH. XTINA has NOT gotten the awards or sold the amount of records that Whitney and Mariah has. and to be honest she DOES NOT HAVE THAT SINGLE yet, Whitney has I Will Always Love u, mariah has HERO & W.B. Together. Xtina is Incredible but her song choices are disappointing, Her music DOES NOT match her voice.
Ty2phine 2 years ago
xtina is also not easy to listen to, the yelling she does is really always sounding like she is straining so hard.
XforeverlongingX 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Listen to Xtina's Loving me for me, infactuation, sung well and not in full voice, almost in a deeper, passionate voice. take a listen
Ty2phine 2 years ago
neither of them sound like each other. Mariah whitney or xtina or celine ALL sound like themselves.
XforeverlongingX 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not true at all, Christina sometimes sounds like whitney on certain notes and her lower register sounds a little like Mariah, her nuances. even her hand gestures on ballds.
Ty2phine 2 years ago
oh please, she SO does not sound like either. Her low notes sound like mariah? no way Whitney and mariah have such distinct sounds and so does christina I've seen a ton of xtina performances as I am a fan of her
XforeverlongingX 2 years ago
Her hand gestures lol, yeah she copies mariah because she looked up to mariah. Her annoying hand ticks that she constantly does by slapping the microphone with her two fingers... that's her own invention, but the other hand flailing is from mariah , that's my opinion. I've heard xtina's song infatuation and all of her "stripped" album songs as well. I like that album but when she uses her upper register she sounds nothing like mariah or whitney, and even in the lower register. I just disagree
XforeverlongingX 2 years ago
@rociofg really?? Than you probably haven't really searched for old whitney performances, cos she was amazing.
ofizs 1 year ago
@rociofg I'm sorry but WH is by far the best known singer on record, Mariah is a close second. Christina has no control over her voice and is all over the place when she sings. 1. Whitney / Aretha 2. Mariah / Patti 3. Tina Turner / Beyonce 4. Celine / Christina
kingtrapper06 1 year ago
@kingtrapper06 WhatQ? are you retarded?? Mariah is known by all generations bc she re-invents herself. NOONE in this generation knows who the hell Whitney or Aretha is!!
petergriffin9901 1 year ago 2
@petergriffin9901 The fact that you have to immediately jump to baseless insults shows you true intellect. Who are you to speak for this generation? When did you become the ambassador to speak on behalf of this generation? There are plenty of people within this generation who are aware of Whitney and Aretha.
kingtrapper06 1 year ago
@rociofg agree 100 %. I think WH is a little overrated, and Mariah a little underrated. WH had a hell of stage presence and a powerful middle and upper chest register, But Mariah (at her peak) owns her in every register.
mcdamian17 1 year ago
@mcdamian17 Totally agree!!!
petergriffin9901 1 year ago
@mcdamian17 COMPLETELY agree! At her peak she can pretty much kill any singer with any note!
krazyshorty89 11 months ago
awesome thanks for posting
kevinlee127 4 years ago 5