Added: 2 years ago
From: FUNimation
Views: 145,334
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (1,520)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • poor cat at 21:15

  • Ling should keep his eyes open more often <3<

  • On Scar's Background....

    Is anyone else reminded of Bakura, or is that just me?

  • Um, Hello! Scar! You're target is standing there, just watching and listening to her talk..... Why the HELL did you not attack?! That goes for the Elrics, too. Why not attack when Scar isn't paying attention to you?! People can be so dumb.

  • winry is so damn useless in this episode

  • Does it make me a terrible person if I laughed when Winry burst into tears? It just seemed too dramatic!

  • @tsunadetsunami yes it does

  • Poor cat 21:15

  • *Winry starts sobbing uncontrollably*

    let it all out...

    let it all out....

  • GAWD winrys annoying

    ED, TAKE ME INSTEAD

  • I can't stand it when Winry starts crying -__-

    It was really sad and touching, then she ruined it by bawling her eyes out on Ed's shirt.

  • First time watching this episode: Oh yeah man dats pretty sad

    Second time watching it: *sniff* Oh god...

    Third time watching it: *insert winry crying* THIS IS SO SAAAAAAAAAAD

  • Comment removed

  • 22:26 - 22:44 is the most ironic thing EVER!

  • @Eyeshield21wannabe

    What's ironic about it? As the song suggests, Winry's crying her eyes out.

    Wouldn't that be the complete opposite of irony?

  • i never knew scar might fell sorry for winry.

  • @MrJmulk Hes less of an asshole in FMA

    But this is good, anime needs to be traumatizing like this :P

  • 21:17 KITTY O_O

  • @SoberEire74 LOL nice eye! Didn't notice he bombed the cat as well xD!

  • blonde hair blue eyes ........HITLER MUCH! O_O

  • @treyday993 probably a troll...but i'll bite. Hitler had black hair and brown eyes.

  • @Falawk hitler had a rule where members of his army or reich had to have blond hair and blue eyes thank you sir and no im not a troll

  • @treyday993 if you ever saw the movie, you can basically compare the amnistrans to the nazis. only here theyre good.

  • @SoberEire74 there's a movie O_O

  • "Let it all out." An appropriate sentiment for that moment especially.

  • Ed's automail fingers , made by Winry , prying her fingers from the gun and hugging on the ground ?

    HE IS SEDUCING HER !

    either that or i find it oddly hot and romantic...

  • lol @ the cat at 21:10

  • wait! shouldnt Ed and (maybe not) Al be in school by now???

  • @xerothehunterwolf They're in the military, they don't need no school!,xD

  • damn it ed why didnt you bone winry at the end OR NOW that works to

  • The first line of the credits song matched the end of this episode SO perfectly!

  • i never supported ed x winry

    i wuz more into ed x roy >;)

    but that ending wuz super sweett

  • @fartyoubucko99 Ed X Roy?! God, you're gay man!!!!

  • @BurningNeons it's called yaoi .

  • @fartyoubucko99 What the fuck is your problem . O.o

  • the thumbnail is winry holding a gun

    now i'm scared O.O

  • poor kitty...

  • @Animepersonidk haha!! you noticed that cat too!! damn you scar!!

  • I like how the first few words of the ending song fits perfectly with the situation at the end of the episode.

  • @blahrawrhehe thats exactly what i thought! O_O

  • wait, the furer (or however its spelled) is wrath? so its not the kid that izumi created?

  • @DragonAce1999 Kid-Wrath is in the original anime, which didn't follow the plot due to the fact FMA wasn't even halfway done when they started animating it,, so they went with their own plot. Though, by this point, you probably should have known it was different. -_-' They also stated the Fuhrer's Sin in the episode with Greed's death.

  • Summary of this episode --> :(

  • *Winry grabs the gun*

    (Me)You can's shoot yourself at this time Winry.

    *Aims at Scar*

    (Me)Okay now shoot.

  • 19:48 That's ALOT OF BLOOD.

  • anybody know the name of this fullmetal alchemist brotherhood song opening? please tell me >,<

  • @iaianimedot1317 Hollogram.

  • Around @19:00 Scar was maiking some pretty flippen scary noises o_o

  • Poor Winry!

  • This was supposed to be the last episode I watched...

    DAMN YOU SCAR!!!! D:< NAOW I MUST WATCH MOOR

  • @Silvericewarriorcats oh!! you are in for a ride! this anime is amazing! each episode gets to the point :D

  • 21:17 - That cat is like, "OH SHIT, SON!"

  • What's batshit about Wrath, is that his physical abilities (which include the ability to cut tanks in half) are NOT part of his Homonculi powers: his Stone has only one soul in it instead of many, allowing him to age and have children.

    He just trained until he could do that shit naturally, whereas all the other Homonculi have superhuman physical bodies.

    His Ultimate Eye lets him perfectly read body movements, giving him limited precognition in fights: he knows what you do just before you do it.

  • 10:26 wow how coincidental is it that a handgun was "accidentally" put right there at her foot!!

  • = -- =

  • lol poor cat 21:15

  • King Bradly has teh sharingan...

  • tired of ads breaking your show? watch them before you start watching the vids themselves :P

  • thumbs up if this made u tear up

  • @drewgoldson then thumbs down if this didn't make you tear up?

  • gotta love the conveniently place handgun right beside winry

  • @spike584 the gun was from the previous soldiers that fell in the alley from Scar's attacks.

    They were waiting for the signal to engage Scar and died waiting in the alley.

  • @spike584 yep, gotta love conviniently placed items

  • WW2 T.T

  • AHH CRAP now the ad video plays twice on me. Once with the video and then again right over the top of the video im watching. Now i have to pause until the ad is done playing

  • I like the way brotherhood is taking its time and re-telling this story, i feel like i know the story better.

  • "Your hands are not hands that kill others. They're hands that give life to others."

    Aww Ed <33

  • @ItsJustSugarRawr i bet someone somewhere can turn that into a sexual referance

  • This ending theme just got we more suitable. I think... I'm not even sure...

  • Why is Winry holding a gun in the thumbnail... WINRY!!!

    Eeep (fluttershy style)!

  • if only Scar knew the psychological damage that war did to some alchemists...I dont think any of them wanted to do that...well....except for Kimbly...

  • watz that episode wen hughes mixed his lil girl and their dog???

  • @TheWolfgirl1234567

    ok maybe it wasnt hughes, idk the dad's name xD

  • @TheWolfgirl1234567 that wasnt in the brotherhood series, just the origional

  • @TheMacCheeze it was definitely in both dummy

  • @25PDHarmon well duh but you didnt see what happened in brotherhood, if someone were watching brotherhood and havnt seen the original, they wouldnt know a thing about the girl and her dog >_> iv been watching and reading FMA for years, i know what im talking about

  • now there are ads at the middle of an episode ....fuck!

  • This episode really shows the quality of the voice actors who play Winry and Scar.

  • after pulling that line out of his ass...he is defiantly getting some....

  • @jshowa4 Yeah. That's why I watch the dubs. I wanna watch the anime, not read it. That's what Manga's are for. XP!!!

  • @jshowa4 Its Ishvalens actually, and they weren't in black and white! Not completely anyway. You can tell very clearly who is Ishvalen, and who is Amestrian just from they're skin color, and what they wear.

  • @supercoolmanable Most likely to reference the WWII German Nazi army who did something somewhat similar to the Ishvalen War of Extermination (The Halocaust)

  • at 14:04 why do they all have blue eyes?

  • the ending song is so appropriate :'(

  • The poor Cat

  • does anyone know the sound track or ost at 10:26?? the chanting oohh thing?

  • @andrewvolcum16 Its an altered version of "Dissident's Creed"; two people have the song on here.

  • i prefer this version over the english sometimes cuz i dont hav to turn up the volume but i can still read the words(people im my house wont shut up)

  • my god im not preordering noir i dont care!!!!

  • If i have to sit through that fucking xfinity ad ONE MORE TIME i'm going to kill something!

  • The end was sad =/

  • got damn ads!

  • Am I the only one who thinks Winry seems... kind of expressionless when she finds out Scar killed her parents?

    I can definietely HEAR it, but the animation and facial expressions aren't doing her any favors.

  • @Kari166 the first FMA is better at showing expressions, but then this one is better at plot/story wise

  • @Shoot1ngStar, meh, I liked the first one better. XD

  • @Kari166 ya i did too but the ending sucks

  • @Shoot1ngStar, but then we wouldn't have gotten that awesome movie. ;D

  • @Shoot1ngStar The art for the first one is different, especially when it comes to the faces so things like expressions came out better. However, as you said Brotherhood is better storywise. And its movie is most likely going to be better than Shamballa was too.

  • Comment removed

  • 13 people were the cat on 21:16

  • Scar is such a fucking ASSHOLE :<

  • FUCK winry got me crying. I love this anime so much, that's why. ):

  • The whole Scar thing suddenly becomes so easy to solve, yet they say "no, don't"

  • Yes I know ads pay for this but they ruin the mood completely aragharhaghh

  • fucking AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA­AAAAAAAAAAAAAAADDS!!!!!!!!!!!!­!

  • That poor cat T.T

  • I watched and rewatched that cat fly through the air. I'm literally rofling xD

  • This show makes me cry and laugh and everything in between. So glad I decided to watch it <3

  • lawl. that cat just goes flying x3

  • i perfer the ending when there cartoons :/

  • This is starting to piss me off.. Why is all the english dub private

  • @KimberlyJTV I like the japanese version with subs better for some reason. They just....sound better and the character's emotions portrayed better

  • @fruityXCL17 The english actors do a great job, your just being a stupid Japanophile

  • @Volf99 I didn't say the english actors didn't do a great job. I think both versions are amazing. It's just I like the japanese version better (:

  • This anime reminds me of other animes. The powerful boom with Scar and Ed's arms clashing together- Naruto and Sasuke. Ling being so free and when he opens his eyes,he is very serious- Lau from Black Butler.

  • seriously, whenever winry cries all Ed does is look at her, he should really just give her a hug LOL

  • Ending:

    Winry:*cry* *cry* *cry* waaa waaa

    Music settling in : Let it all out, Let it all out, Let it all out.....

    Perfect

    This is the best anime ever i wish it didn't end i love it soo much!

  • @shamil1998 I have a feeling that if it "didn't' end, we probably see something like what Bleach, Inuyasha, or One Piece did. A bunch of pointless fillers. Not to mention, the story would be dragged out and become uninteresting to watch any further because of no more good ideas or plot twists.

  • Whenever Ling opens his eyes, he's serious.

    Whenever they're closes, its just fun free Ling~

  • @Shuuwai Like Lau from Black Butler! He opens his eyes,it's serious shitt.

    But when he closes, it's just fun free Lau.

    and umm...Lau is Chinese too xD

  • Why don't mr. and mrs. rockbell walk side by side? 4:52

  • why cant i watch ep 23?!?!

  • first episode i actually like the 2nd ending *sniff sniff*

  • the ending fit so well with the end song.... well, to me it did

  • @ForestTreeDragon you're right

  • @ForestTreeDragon Just thinking the exact same thing

  • Has anyone else noticed that there are virtually no commercials anymore?

  • hmm.... so im too young to watch episode 23???

  • Comment removed

  • DAMMIT THE NAZIS R EVERYWHERE

  • Winry: *crying*

    Edward: there there... let it all out.

  • 21:16

    Wtf did the cat ever do?

  • @Smash4Tress2 lol

    

  • the ending was just..... BEAUTIFUL!!! ;___;

  • Oh shit, he opened his eyes.

  • lol winrys crying into edward and then all of a sudden "Let it all out,let it all out"

  • I find it weird how just at the end, when Winry is crying and Ed holds her, it starts the credits singing "Let It All Out."

  • plus on top of that the transmutation circles are demonic with their inverted pentacle signs which they are pertaining to blasphemy plus the ouroboros tattoo is that of a demonic symbol the serpent eating its tail snake or dragon referring to the belief of infinity and that everything is a cycle It can also represent the idea to something existing in or persisting before any beginning with such force or qualities it cannot be extinguished..it has been in alchemy illustrations years before

  • @fishsthirdaccount yeah i noticed all that stuff about fma too but thats what made it intersting and the history and a lot of this is tied in with latin/german/american/greek/et­c. history and science too with a lot of fiction mixed in with it. and dealing with religous backgrounds. ._. all in all TOO MUCH HIDDEN SHIT.

  • its actually a story of america with the corrupt military keeping secrets form the civilians and militia thus until ed which is a symbol of the youth finds out the truth about the world the homuncul r considered immortal jus like the illuminati and theres only a few of the homunculi jus the the elite and they worship the antichrist jus like the skull and bones society hellloooo open you eyes!!

  • @fishsthirdaccount plus the transmutation circle and ouroboros tattoo deal with another religion that not of the holy trinity, those of the ancient egypt

  • @fishsthirdaccount finally someone gets the message of this whole show

  • @fishsthirdaccount Or maybe it's a fictional story in a fictional setting.

    OH RIGHT I forgot everything's about America. We're the only ones whose government lies. DERP

    Seriously, is it impossible that the author just took some ideas from history and integrated them into a new setting? The author even said that her idea for the people of Ishval came from the Ainu people of Hokkaido. It looks like Western Europe post-WWI, but these things have been happening for MILLENIA--it's just human nature.

  • @uuuuunnnnhhhhhblah Human nature is a poor excuse for misunderstanding, why things occur.

  • @fishsthirdaccount, uh, what? No, it's not.

  • Man, when Winry started sobbing in Ed, I was about to sob. 00-

  • Full metal alchemist is basically set in Prussian Germany. Its not quite Nazi Germany. It more resembles the Prussian Empire given the weapons being used. Given how young Edward was recruited as a state alchemist and exams they had to go through. Somewhat resembled the revolutionary introduction of public education that the Prussians introduced to the world. Fuhrer Bradley is essentially Hitler on steroids.

  • All the shootings of the Isval citizens reminds me of WW2 with tthe Germans and Jews!

  • This is random, sort of, but I miss Greed and his ORIGINAL body... He doesn't look that cool in Ling's body...

  • @Mgm0999 my last name is ling. acually its Lin. WAT A GIRLISH LAST NAME!

  • lol at 22:18 xD i just laughed and laughed poor cat lol

  • @Rangeala oops i ment 22:16

  • @Rangeala i mean 21:18 lol

  • DUDE! I've been waiting for Winry to hug him...

  • Lol the cat..

  • fullmetal alchemist has the most epic fighting scenes <3 gawh i love this anime

  • This shit just got real at 4:40

  • I know alot of people like Scar but he just deserves to die i'm sorry

  • yes Ed Al. Winry Mustang Riza Havoc Fury....they're all actually based off the Nazis

  • HOLY SHIT THERES 1337 COMMENTS!

    Oh wait....

  • This is why Scar is the ultimate badass.

  • Haha I like how in the middle of the episode when they say "FULL METAL ALCHEMIST!" Winry is holding a gun ready to shoot scar...then we see scar holding his arm out like he is gonna kill her first or somethin lol

  • LanFanxLing :DDDD

  • 2:30 reminded me of Gakupo from Vocaloid..........except without the blood ~_~

  • To all you people who complain about ads, there is an easy solution (I think)

    Make a playlist of all the episodes and play them on your channel. I don't know if it will work for everybody, but I've just been watching the entire series without ads, so it should be worth a try.

    Thumbs up if this was helpful!

  • Interesting (scar) an Isbalan warrior equals the strength of ten Amestrain soldier.

  • The ending song fit this episode nicely. I cried along with Winry too.

  • i always thought scars arms didnt look rite together now i kno y

  • i always thought scars arms didnt look rite together now i kno y

  • 14:37 Did Scar just make a soldier accidentally shoot a fellow soldier?

  • when they put the emphasis on the blue eyes, it was like they were Germans and the Ishvalans(is it isbal or ishval? cuz originally it was ishbal) were Jews, so it was not a pretty sight for me

  • anyone think winry's mom looks like Riza? ITS THE EYES!!!

  • @superspider64 No, Winry's mom looks like Winry

  • @chainhead1 the way she looked in the flash back made me think of that thats all

  • Ling's music at 2:30 - JUMANJIIIIIIIIIII