@Amimi150 I'm playing in A flat, because that is the key used for this published piano arrangement. I can't remember what key the original vocal version is in.
I've just watched Jackie Evancho's interpretation so I decided to search a home piano version and I found yours ... heavenly, congratulations, excellent tune ! Cheers from Mexico !!
My 13 year old son attedns an arts academy school and will be playing this beautiful piece for the end of the year school recital. I can't wait!!! I love your music!
After another few times listening to this I sought out a couple of the vocal versions you referred to - Saragh Brightman etc - and I found Sissel! No doubt you have heard of her as she is on your side of the world - if you haven't listened to her singing Pie Jesu please do - it is beautiful - I have now subscribed to your beautiful channel
Thanks for your comment, and good luck with your study of the piece. I am always likely to take a piano solo version of a vocal item a little faster than one would sing it, because I can't sustain the melody in the same way that you can!
I don't think I said that the piano version was better than the vocal version (and certainly do not think that)- all I said was that of the piano arrangements in the book, this worked better than the arrangements of show extracts. This arrangement might of course be of use to someone learning the piece who wants something to sing along to!
I played this song in G major :)
rawrximaxtoaster 2 months ago
@rawrximaxtoaster Maybe that is the original key?
PSearPianist 2 months ago
What key are you playing in?
Amimi150 3 months ago
@Amimi150 I'm playing in A flat, because that is the key used for this published piano arrangement. I can't remember what key the original vocal version is in.
PSearPianist 3 months ago
@PSearPianist Thanks! And I just looked it up and the original is in A flat :)
Amimi150 3 months ago
You amazing and great to sing along to because i have a audition tomorrow to sing for a scolarship :D
Plasticgirl1000 7 months ago
@Plasticgirl1000 Thank you. I'm glad this helps with your preparation for the audition, and I hope you 'sail through' it and get the scholarship!
PSearPianist 7 months ago
@PSearPianist Thank You :)
Plasticgirl1000 7 months ago
@PSearPianist Thank you i did get the scolarship ;)
Plasticgirl1000 6 months ago
@Plasticgirl1000 Well, congratulations, and if my video helped you, I'm delighted!
PSearPianist 6 months ago
@PSearPianist Yes it did help very much thanks you
Plasticgirl1000 6 months ago
I've just watched Jackie Evancho's interpretation so I decided to search a home piano version and I found yours ... heavenly, congratulations, excellent tune ! Cheers from Mexico !!
ReNoir20 1 year ago
@ReNoir20 Thank you very much - and greetings from UK!
PSearPianist 1 year ago
My 13 year old son attedns an arts academy school and will be playing this beautiful piece for the end of the year school recital. I can't wait!!! I love your music!
kjnangel2001 1 year ago
Thank you for your kind comment - and I wish your son success with his performance!
PSearPianist 1 year ago
After another few times listening to this I sought out a couple of the vocal versions you referred to - Saragh Brightman etc - and I found Sissel! No doubt you have heard of her as she is on your side of the world - if you haven't listened to her singing Pie Jesu please do - it is beautiful - I have now subscribed to your beautiful channel
52dinosaur 2 years ago
Thank you! I have to say I have never heard of Sissel - but I will look out for her!
PSearPianist 2 years ago
you have a beautiful piano, too. :D
SissiStrakovinch 2 years ago
Thank you!
PSearPianist 2 years ago
Comment removed
SissiStrakovinch 2 years ago
beautiful, but try it slowly. PS: I'm a Russian singer and I'm training with your performance. :D Thank's.
SissiStrakovinch 2 years ago
Thanks for your comment, and good luck with your study of the piece. I am always likely to take a piano solo version of a vocal item a little faster than one would sing it, because I can't sustain the melody in the same way that you can!
PSearPianist 2 years ago
You filled (and feel...) it out right! This is a beautiful piece, done perfectly. Thanks for uploading.
Babejuda 2 years ago
Thank you - that's very kind.
PSearPianist 2 years ago
You play so beautifully - and you obviously love it - and of course this is a very beautiful and emotive piece of music
52dinosaur 2 years ago
Thank you very much - I certainly do enjoy playing (most of the time!).
PSearPianist 2 years ago
wonderful
Octavin2 2 years ago
Thank you!
PSearPianist 2 years ago
That's a very gentle song.
diasdm 2 years ago
It is indeed!
PSearPianist 2 years ago
I have to disagree, I think the original with voice is the best... just piano doesn't say enough for me.
KARINADIVA 2 years ago
I don't think I said that the piano version was better than the vocal version (and certainly do not think that)- all I said was that of the piano arrangements in the book, this worked better than the arrangements of show extracts. This arrangement might of course be of use to someone learning the piece who wants something to sing along to!
PSearPianist 2 years ago
"Sonata, what do you want of me?"
Bernard le Bouyer de Fontenelle (1657-1757)
EdwardWhelanPiano 2 years ago