Added: 3 years ago
From: vansy24
Views: 252,204
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (294)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • wow one of hre best performances ever. how can anyone say it's lipped, it's alwyas sung in a different way, never exactly the same!!!! open your ears

  • celine the best singer

  • Her voice doctor tells her whatshe should sing and what she souldnt so seruously blane the doctor

  • Okay seriously tell truth it not up to her to lip and btw for everyone who says she "lip sings" is wrong and 2nd it "lip sych" so first get that right and celine dion is a mezzo so she can hold a note for a period of time without changing a pitch, the note is live, all by myself has never been lipped

  • She is the best!

  • I love this note!!!

  • seriously i dont get it..she lipped then lye on the floor..wtf

  • @babyjamesprieto this one is 100% live are you deaf?

  • @babyjamesprieto

    I don't get you! How the fu*king F do all of you deaf little kids who love Mariah say that every performance is lipped? Seriously! Clean your ears of all that Justin Bieber shit

  • @babyjamesprieto Eh she can do what she damn well pleases,she was in the moment I guess,she has an amazing voice.

  • This is one of her best performance of this song! Loved it

  • Celine-I have seen you live twice in Vegas. You are a gift. May you live forever and entertain the angels for eternity.

  • The high note is INCREDIBLY BEAUTIFUL AND CLEAR

  • all she says is all by my says, love her voice, but the song is kinda boring ---

    even thoe i guess it is easy to remember lol

  • That kind of artist can not make a lip singing..it would be too cheap.. they make all they concerts only 100% live.. with the band. And this is what I call a REAL MUSICIAN. This is a real MUSIC.

    keep your lip singing for that kind of circus makers like Britney Spears..

  • FOR IDIOTS WHO DONT KNOW, THIS IS A BILLION % LIVE!!!

  • wow she is amazing realy...no one does it live like she does still

  • At 1:59 she went up to a F5 with no problems and sustained it and then went down to an C5 and sustained that too! Amaaaazing

  • @SeveralMimi Actually she went up to a F#5. :)

  • @xXCelineDionXx Incredible! =D

  • She never ceases to astound me. Words can't express it...

  • Damn she's good.

  • Que voz maravilhosa!!!!!!!!

  • I hope she is well !!!

  • She is the best, no doubt about it

  • Who says that she lip songs is a jealous because your Diva no can do equal our Diva!

  • @lukinhascascavel hahhaha lmao you're probably right lol.........

  • After 20 years, she still stuns me every day! I'm so proud to be her fan!

  • Celine looks AMAZING here...perfect hair!!!

  • DAMN! Even after all these years, no one can hit the high notes like Celine.

  • she is the best... awesome performance of a perfect singer, I LOVE YOU CELINE

  • I like the way her hair and make look here, wow I'm so gay lol

  • fu*** who say she's lip-synch !

  • wish this was on the DVD

  • you can even see her struggglee. other than that ITS FINAL she's not lipping MAN.

  • THE VOICE

  • The people can say what they want but CELINE IS THE BEST  LOVE YOUUUUUUUUUUUU

  • pure voice quality..

  • The best voice live Ever !!!

  • no one mentions how poor the quality of this taping is? Celine is great, but to have such a poor recording of her talents.

    sorry.

  • how wonderful life is, there is a celine.

  • omgosh, in every video i see of her in recent years, she has the BEST hair ever! so healthy, bouncy, VOLUMOUS and sezxy! celine gets better looking with time i think!

  • Three words; She's my goddess.

  • i'm so sorry guys but here there is no wow part.THE WHOLE SONG IS WOW!!!and if someone tell this was lipsing then he must hurry to go to a doctor because there is nooooo way his ears to be fine!!!

  • plus you can tell if someone's lipping OMG. YOU CAN TELL IF THEY LIP IS THE SAME VOCALS EVERY TIME but as you can see at the end she made it different ! i am just wowed

  • @alleyaaa123 only the high note is playback, so she can do what she wants with the rest of the song

  • @ShuttleDiscovery A play back of the original?

  • @willsbob123 No, she recorded the high note before the tour started, along with parts of some other songs, to use as playbacks. However all of these (including the very old playbacks she uses) have been re-recorded for the DVD.

  • @ShuttleDiscovery Ohhh, I understand now, but couldn't some of the high notes have been actually live? I can understand if she uses a playback because her voice must get tired and all by myself is a big song, her voice just might not have recovered in time for the next song, but saying that she's one of the greatest vocalist of all time so she can bounce back :) Thanks! :D

  • @willsbob123 Only the big note (0:46 - 0:57) is pre-recorded.

    On some videos from the tour it sounds like there are 2 voices singing the 'any' (at the start). This is because Celine's mic is still on as the playback starts, then her mic is faded out.

    The reason why she still sang the 'any' part was in case the playback failed, so she'd have enough time to realise and do the rest live, without any embarrassment. Luckily this never happened, but at the first concert of the tour it was all live

  • @ShuttleDiscovery Do you know this as a fact? :P

  • @willsbob123 No, but I'm 99.9% sure :-)

    Any more questions about her playbacks I'll be happy to answer them. I've spent the past 2 years studying her pre-recorded tracks and have had information from others about the way her sound team do everything. It's very clever.

  • @ShuttleDiscovery This entire song was sung entirely live multiple times..Montreal, Phoenix, to name the two that I know off the top of my head.

  • @elrynx2 The first show of the tour was live, but since then every show was playback. Everyone thought the Phoenix video was live when they first saw it cos it sounded so raw as she was ill. The fact is, it was the normal playback, but they dubbed it with the original vocal recording, no effects etc. The crack in her voice during the note is heard in other concert vids, it's just less obvious with the echo and applause found in a bootleg video. Anyway she was ill why would she sing it live then?

  • @ShuttleDiscovery Because she converses with the audience during her shows, wouldn't it be strange to hear her talk with the audience with a sore voice and then flawlessly belt out her songs. Still, the scratch in her voice was my logic...

  • @elrynx2 Well just look at The Power of Love. That's been lipped to the same recording for 15 years. It sounds strange in every concert now cos her voice has changed a lot since the 90s. Anyway, back to Phoenix, Celine would never sing lipped songs live when she's ill just for the audience's sake. I don't think her voice sounded that sore during the show, so it wouldn't have sounded that odd during most lipped songs.

  • @ShuttleDiscovery Half of the song has been lipped for a long long time yes I know but that's just the Power of Love. Her voice changed a lot during the 90s and the POL recording fell right in between a big vocal transition period for her, which made the POL hard to sing. Most lipped songs? Only the high note is in discussion..if songs were lipped, which a ton of them weren't, her voice would sound perfect because of the lipping. Her throat was sore...

  • So lucky to have Celine. The best voice in music.

  • oh! my god, she recovering her voice after those five concert in Vegas

    Good for her and for us.....

    a big huf from Buenos Aires

  • Actually 1.59-2.02 is the ''wow'' part :P

  • Just Amazing..! ( 1.47-1.51 wow ! ) . . . . . There is no need to say this is live and that Celine always gives her best...Love her !

  • ok... im in awe whenever i listen to celine sing... i seriously believe that she is the BEST singer in the intire WORLD!!!!!

  • FUCKING AMAZING

    CELINE YOU ROCK!

  • The note at 1:42 so beautifull!

  • Comment removed

  • oh my god she is not human? listen this voice...incredible

  • She hardly goes out of tune when she sings live, that's a fact. And she reaches even higher notes (it's a man's world on this tour or Can't help falling in love from Vegas, to name a few).

    She is still flawless compared to many other contemporary singers.

  • ha. youre shitting me right?

  • Disgusting people?

    You can tell that she meant this quirp in one way or the other by the movement of her head at 1:58-1:59, she moves her head back and lets the note rip. She's gone lots higher than this, in chest or heavy mixed, and stayed in tune.

  • Well yeah you cann tell..thats more like what the album versoin is

  • OMG she lost a little bit of voice on 1:59 but she still the best singer of the world

    Sorry for my bad english.

  • are u nuts? i've never heard her go up on a note like that before.. that was amazing!

  • No, i'm not. I love her, i mean to say that the note on 1:59 was a little mistaken, íf you compare this perfomance with others on the same tour you will see the diference, i saw her in Puerto Rico, and believe me, she did it better than tokio.

  • at least it proves that she doesnt lip sing.

  • Of course, she never lips in her tours, I hate when people say that she lips her songs, maybe in tv shows but not at all and never in tours.

    P.S.

    Sorry for my bad english.

    I have videos of Céline, totally live, please come to see them to rate and comment.

  • OK, whatever

  • Saw this song live on TC tour-it is 100% live.

  • The best of the best!

  • Go CELINE!Love u so much..great performance!love it!

  • Celine Dion is amazing no matter

    how old she is she is the best and i love her so much!!

  • Tikihut1252, her voice doesn't crack, what she did was just displaying a wrong layer of high voice note...not alot of artists are able to do that without going off the actual note...amazing she is!!!

  • Celine is still the best! For those who says that she lipsynch,well "maybe" she did it just for tv shows.Why should she waste her impressive,powerfull,and unique voice for just a lil show? duh..

  • I can tell all the doubters and the people who think they know take it from me NO LIP SYNC, no back tracks no gimmicks what you see is what you get. Trust me I know! Only equip used by the sound enginner is a voice phaser, reverb with slight compression nothing else just the pure magic of Celines voice.

  • GO Céline, GO GO GO GO GO GO GO!:)

    Show business belongs to you!

  • of course she isnt lip singing

    her voice cracks at 1:58-2:00

    dumbshits!

    GO CELINE!

  • whats is wrong with you she dont lip anything in thios vid i no i no u think just cause she cant help sounding good

  • what are you talking about lucasode i said that she doesnt lip sing!

  • THIS GIRL IS SO AMAZING SINGING LIKE CELINE.

    HER NAME IS CHARICE.

    watch?v=mLkzDSo5g5I&feature=re­lated

  • well celine dion is better cause i coompared her to young celine dion and young celine was better

  • Okay, enough is enough...I have seen Celine sing live 4 times now, including opening up for Michael Bolton in the 90's and in Vegas. She does NOT lip-sync. Does NOT. Get it? And that includes "The Power of Love".

  • lip synching?saw her many times in the Vegas show;sometimes she forgot the words and had to be helped,kinda hard to be lip synching and forget your words; saw her also when she was sick,fifteen feet away from me she was blowing hard and struggling for every breath,lip synching?,at the soundchecks in Europe she was amazing;saw and heard her sing "My Love" walking round in a circle with no backing;only THE voice;absolutely pitch perfect the lady's a national treasure and we're lucky to have her

  • its amazing how even for this long she still has all that enegry and power!! and she look amazing

  • i love you celine amazing voice

    fuck all you celine haters!!!

  • 10000% live!!!

    its much complicate to understand???

    what a stupids!

    Celine´s voice is better than ever!

  • Sorry, but what you say is all very interesting, except that it sounds like whether this runner has run this distance is unclear til the runner themself says it. This is why we were given the 5 senses, not to let us make fools of ourselves. If you can't hear it or be bothered to compare it with a couple of other vids not to go to such great lenghts and ask Celine herself or her sound-engineers, well then sorry again... get a hearing-aid!

  • I am sorry but all this stories about singing live (or not) are hard to believe unless the statement come from Celine herself or the sound engineer (or professionals that work directly with her) as conclusion taken from video and other sources are not really reliable, are they? Let's face it for once and for all, it's all speculation without any realistic base. But what Celine has to proof by now?

    Just enjoy the show (and her voice) or then, change the "channel"! Get a life!

  • By way of conclusion I must say that I love Celine and was upset by that too when I found it out and was able to surface it myself thru close watching of her DVDs and a concert in Berlin. It is her job to be perfect, but as every human being she's not made of stone. But she's not the only one doing that (e.i Aguilera, Mariah but very little). She remains the great singer she was she just has to play by the showbiz rules, ladies and gents. Sad but true.

  • Mariah but very little? I don't care if I get thumbs down but you must be on crack.

  • The show was nevertheless better than Las Vegas, coz there she abused the prerecorded tracks to the extent that the only strong live song remained "river deep, mountain high", the rest - I drove all night (except for the very beginning), power of love (except for the first chorus), it's all coming back to me, to love you more, I surrender (except for the final passage), my heart will go on - were all prerecorded. Yuck, it's so bubble-gum-routine-love-machin­e fake ((( Sorry if I upset somebody.

  • And to end this little competition I will say that there is no bloody "contract" that says she "cannot lipsynch", at least none of which you might know. This video is 99% live coz the passage 0:55-0:59 (and only it!) is prerecorded, which you can all enjoy in ALL her "all by myself" vids. She always does a fake jaw vibrato when she lipsynchs, which she does not live. However the concert is half fake, coz "power of love", "my heart will go on", "eyes on me" "to love you more"... are lipsynched

  • Her jaw wavers when she sings live anyway... it's just a little more exaggerated when it's lip-sync. There is NO way any of the songs you mentioned are lip-synced, apart from 'The Power of Love' occasionally.

  • Sorry for ya, whoever u r. I was the same a couple of years too, blindly ignorant of what the technology is capable of nowadays. I really don't know what you mean by occasionally as far as Power of Love, I have perfect pitch, fundamental musical background and have been to her concert, plus have seen all her DVDs. She is a great singer, no doubt about it, but she protects her voice and does not sing demanding songs live on tour. Too bad, but it's true. Every word I said(((

  • Do really have perfect pitch? I do too. It's quite rare.

    As for the other stuff, I know Celine lip-syncs in parts on tour... however, when I went to see her, she only lipped the first song. The majority of what she does around the world is live- the performances of her songs are significantly different.

    Don't get me wrong, I know she lip-syncs, but I also understand and respect her reasons for doing so. :)

  • I have seen her in Cracow live!! :) She was awesome! And I'm sure that her voice's the best voice in this world! :)

  • this 100%live

  • it's in the Taking Chances contract that celine dion CAN NOT LIPSYNCH in any of her concerts during the tour. this is obviously live. listen to 1:39-1:41 and compare that to the orignial. it just goes to show how great she is at what she does when she's so flawless, ppl think she's lipsynching when she's not.

  • Granted some are pre recorded but this one is live, listen to all the different concert versions....all different

  • She is, without any doubt, the best: and she is singing better now as well. This is one of her best versions of this song and you can tell how much she is still holding inside. Amazing!

  • what a stupid comment!

    Hey nasty bitch! this video is 1000% LIVE!

    ok?

    Understand?

    regards queen of ugly bitches!

    kisses for you stupid hater mother fucker! hahahaha

  • Are you stupid???

    She sing 100 LIVE!

    The best lipsyncer is Mariah Scarey

  • She was singing live! You certainly must have some hearing problem for not noticing or even feeling that this was 100% Celine Dion signing LIVE!...Some people should better avoid posting nonsense comments when they don't even know what it's all about, Unbelievable!!

  • She is singing 110% live, her voice is real here! How can you say not? Gosh, please stop you're nonsense! Enough already! You cannot even tell when she sings live & when she lipsing/sing in play-back! SO SAD!!! Don't u have eyes to see and ears to listen or hear?

  • PRE-RECORDED

  • what a stupid ugly bitch!

    This is 10000% live LOOSER

    fuck off hater

  • wow

  • She she still got it! Still hit the high and long notes:)

  • really amazing!

  • UNBELIVEBLE!! she is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G! celine is the best!!!

  • Whow...not only can she sing...she is so sexy ! Love those red pants and her attitude in this song.

  • she's something!! :)

  • I saw her in Dublin last night .........SHE WAS AMAZING

    I could not stop crying when she sang this...... Xxx

  • i was der too she fuckin brilliant i was amazed by her...

  • Impresionante,genial.Celine,po­rque nunca vienes a España?????,es lo unico que le faltaria para ser perfecta,snif snif..

  • Holy amazing, love the last note. She is simply gorgeous and irreplaceable!

  • im kinda nervous 2 go c her in september at madison square garden. i love celine 2 death but idk if she can hold up 2 everyones highg standards 4 her. she looks amazing but her voice was best wen her air was short. i'm sure im jst being silly i mean its celine shes the best nugh said

  • you should definitely go see her, i mean if this video isn't proof of her amazing voice then i don't know what is, and i've looked through all the videos of the songs she is going to sing and they're all perfectly sung, Celine is in amazing vocal condition right now, mariah and whitney.....now thats another story

  • Hoooo My Godddddd!!!!!

    Celine, you are The best :)

  • I have seen her last night! Amazing!!!!!!!

  • after watching her live in my own country, i can bet no artist in this world would ever sing live like HER. she is superb and one of a kind. you go my girl! you rock our country and me for decade and now you gave me live performance which i never ever will forget. LONG LIVE MY QUEEN CELINE!

  • UWAGA!!zwracam się do wszystkich największych organizatorów koncertów w Polsce- Dlaczego Celin Dion jeszcze nie zagościła na POLSKIEJ SCENIE??...

  • Celine's voice is better than ever and she looks better than ever...totally live and amazing!Celine doesn't need to lipsync as some people posted here.She is THE VOICE and now has way better technique than before...

  • she is so so beautiful i can't believe it>!

  • Come on guys this is LIVE the reason you dont hear the ANYMOOOOORE lol, note echo is because its very high and sustained, if she just belts out a straight perfect note without any runs your not going to hear an echo since its so perfectly sustained it would just blend in.

  • I can not wait to see her live next year in January in Miami. This is my grandmother's favorite song. she is amaizing 100%.

  • I SERIOUSLY doubt with all my mind this IS NOT lipped.

    Her sustaining the note covers what echo there would be and there is a slight echo the whole time and right at the you can here it and when she goes high the second time its barely there again. When she sings with her chest, with more power backing it there is a large echo, when its in a high tone the echo is barely there throught. Check the ending higher notes.

    Celines hair is fake, her singing in this performance IS NOT.

    Love Celine

  • Hey!!!this is 100% live!!!im the one who posted this vid!!ive watched mariah carey,bonjovi,bsb,destinys child,but celines concert is the best concert ever!!!!!

  • hey!! Of cours Celine is the best !!

  • shut up!

    Fucking Celine´s haters!!!

    This is 100% LIVE!!!

    Admit!!

  • You can say whatever you want, I don't care

    She's the best and nothing's gonna change my mind. And that performance was incredible as always.

    Love you Celine, see ya in June!

  • You can say whatever you want, I don't care

    She's the best and nothing's gonna change my mind. And that performance was incredible as always.

    Love you Celine, see ya in June!

  • she's amazing!!!

  • from the first time i know until now. i was amaze with ur voice. Ur are my no one singer in my heart.Gud luck my lovely sister celine

  • unbelievable at forthy

  • I most definantly dont agree.

  • Harrison, I think you watch too much television with special effect!! :)

  • live-mime-live...

    Are you totally out of your mind?!

  • if someone cracks here, it's you harrison8082, you write so much crap!!! I think you know shit about music!! Celine is the best live performer in the world!!

  • I agree this was TOTALLY LIVE! The end note was in a different key to normal but because she didnt quite reach the note she just decided to sing that last note differently. She is the best performer EVER! I saw her in in the o2 and she took my breath away! She gives her all every second.

  • Let me put a thing VERY cleared... I know when she's miming or singin live.

    You can have a point in what you're writing. As what I can hear there's NO echo when she's singin the very hige note.

    Celine fans, it can be true, but what the hell. DO WE CARE?? NOOOOOOOOOO !!!! She's the best<3<3<3

  • obs. Almost missed out the point. Listen from the start, you can deff hear the echo to 0.48 then you can't hear it. And then at 0.54 she's singin live again.

  • you don't clearly hear the echo because the note is very high and SUSTAINED. and com'on .. live..mime 6 seconds and live again... far fetched huh!?

  • this is definitely live.. do you know why she almost struggles at the note at the end of the song? it's because, it's F#5 and definitely higher than the 'big note' itself because it's only E. one more thing, do u know why the echo in the 'big note' is not dominant?? it's because, it's sustained a

  • BULL SHIT!!! ITS LIVE !!!

  • je la trouver vraiment belle celine comme ca:)

  • Simply unbelievable. The woman just gets better and better - noone can touch Celine.

  • Amazing!Now we are witnessing history with this!

  • shes great

  • OMG!

    I just don't know what to say!!!

    I'm speachless!!=O

  • celine dion is the most beautiful woman in the world!!! dont care what they say , im in love with her!

  • Woah ! She goes to F# ! As they say in Québec: "C'est écoeurant" :o)

  • She is the best!!!! :)