Sorry, but kinda out of the tune, and pitchy. Your balance is not right, don't know if its because of the microphones. And the bass and tenor are blurry.
finde auch die Aufstellung nicht vorteilhaft... es gibt zwar klar die melodie/leadstimme, aber trotzdem ist es ein ensemblestück. kenne das stück gut...
manchmal nicht ganz in der intonation (lead) aber für laienensemble schön gemacht, v.a. der gesamtklang ist sehr angenehm!
habe es letzte woche noch live von rajaton gehört :o))
I really didn't like the fact she couldn't remember the lyrics... i didn't like her voice too! Though it was in tune... Well, sh*t happens, as it has been said here, and i'm sorry i heard this! =(
I have a strange feeling that you have a personal vendetta. I don't know these people, all was not perfect but you are definitely exaggerating the negative...or do you think you or your choir could do any better?
I"d like to think the next time they perform this that they remember the lyrics. There's no sense in singing a song if you can't recall the words.
Also, the swaying of the musicians back and forth is just distracting. They should have arranged themselves so that every singer was seen. That soloist would be nothing without the background crew and they should all be seen equally on stage together as a unit or not at all.
Also, the breathing from the soloist needs work. She's shaky on high notes
I thinks it's great! This piece is really hard work and the sound quality of the video is not ideal. It's a wonderful piece and they did a very good job!
honestly, the fact that a group is willing to get this arranged is congratulation-worthy in itself. This is a VERY difficult song to put together, and they pulled it off very well. Of course, Rajaton, having created the song, does it better, but they're a legend =).
But for any of you in this group here, good job! That was amazing.
Make sure you remember all the lyrics when you sing (I know it's hard to do, though). There was a little mixup about 3 minutes in. It still sounded nice, though.
My Dear Child, if you know nothing about a cappella music just keep your uneducated comments to yourself. This not Paris Hilton reloaded so I can understand if you don't comprehend let alone appreciate what you heard here.If Rajaton themselves would comment they'd say that this was a good rendition of their song
I sing a cappella, and the starting pitches were not that great.
I sing classical music and choral music, i've won many awards individually and with my choir, and i don't like your tone. I guess i didn't mean it like i said in my above comment, but it's not something rajaton would go crazy for. I meant, they have nice tone through out the song, but the beginning bitches are off.
It's actually pretty good. The beginning was a little pitchy and there was a little problem with balance, but otherwise it's a good rendition. It got better as it went. Out of all the renditions of Butterfly on Youtube I've heard, this is the best, and the truest to the Rajaton version.
okay, listen hun, everyone has their own opinions. my own choir did this and i thought they were not that great. these guys probably did better. but my choir is a high school chamber choir that has 14 people in it and their starting pitches were way off. This is my opinion. So fuck off.
They are quite good!
ThatOtherCaitlin 8 months ago
It really isnt as bad as people are saying it is.
I mean, they can't actually be Rajaton but this was a very respectable performance of the song.
Good job
1037pm 9 months ago
i find the song was really great and you are very good. like this version. :DD
simstro 1 year ago
old people with matching colored outfits shouldnt sing this
Jello31398 1 year ago
ooo... I would advise going back to the music and checking parts...this is just not right. the opening chord isn't even tuned well.
sopranosruletheworld 1 year ago
GOD NO1
hpiznxt2myheart 1 year ago
...oh no
hpiznxt2myheart 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is such a good song
MrStefanVidovic 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
THIS IS SUCH A GOOD SONG!!
MrStefanVidovic 1 year ago
THIS IS SUCH A GOOD SONG!!
MrStefanVidovic 1 year ago
For festival singing, no post production, maybe even picked up off of the event speakers, etc. This is a video of very good entertainment.
Wrong key? Gimme a break. Music is transposed, all the time.
EdwardWunder 2 years ago
Sorry, but kinda out of the tune, and pitchy. Your balance is not right, don't know if its because of the microphones. And the bass and tenor are blurry.
app9 2 years ago
this is in the wrong key.....
just so y'all know.
andrewoconnorblue 2 years ago
Mir gefällt es, es ist hat seine eigene kleine Note und es berührt!
1aPasta 2 years ago
its ok but compared to my junior high choir they blow.
sk8terguys1992 2 years ago
I love this song soooo much. I thought they did well. I'm not comparing them to Rajaton, I'm just enjoying the song.
quizdiet 2 years ago 7
finde auch die Aufstellung nicht vorteilhaft... es gibt zwar klar die melodie/leadstimme, aber trotzdem ist es ein ensemblestück. kenne das stück gut...
manchmal nicht ganz in der intonation (lead) aber für laienensemble schön gemacht, v.a. der gesamtklang ist sehr angenehm!
habe es letzte woche noch live von rajaton gehört :o))
arnolfini26 3 years ago
i think its just the vid .. like, its not the same as prefessionally recording it -.-... i think its great
puppiesluv52 3 years ago
Not even close...
iMake81 3 years ago 8
Gross.. =/
Viva Rajaton!!!
MaerdYsatnaf 3 years ago
gut für ein laien-ensemble.
allerdings ist das stück keine solo- sondern eine ensemblenummer, deswegen sollte die aufstellung demnächst anders sein.
orangejuice302 3 years ago
I really didn't like the fact she couldn't remember the lyrics... i didn't like her voice too! Though it was in tune... Well, sh*t happens, as it has been said here, and i'm sorry i heard this! =(
No offense.
QuasarRiceMints 3 years ago
Oh, sorry. Listening to this a second time, i withdraw my words on the fact she was in tune... she is NOT in tune in some parts... iuck...
QuasarRiceMints 3 years ago
I have a strange feeling that you have a personal vendetta. I don't know these people, all was not perfect but you are definitely exaggerating the negative...or do you think you or your choir could do any better?
Sylros49 3 years ago
I'm sure my choir could do better,.
anaisforlosers 2 years ago
i like the song, but not their take on it, right off the start it sounded flat
saturnknite 3 years ago 2
I"d like to think the next time they perform this that they remember the lyrics. There's no sense in singing a song if you can't recall the words.
Also, the swaying of the musicians back and forth is just distracting. They should have arranged themselves so that every singer was seen. That soloist would be nothing without the background crew and they should all be seen equally on stage together as a unit or not at all.
Also, the breathing from the soloist needs work. She's shaky on high notes
HHMgirl 3 years ago 3
I thinks it's great! This piece is really hard work and the sound quality of the video is not ideal. It's a wonderful piece and they did a very good job!
duckduck9 3 years ago
I dont like the one who sings the melody's voice
and the one after the first verse that you can hear
its not as good as it could be
katie1hamilton 3 years ago
this is bad for trained singing adults
yangster982000 3 years ago
honestly, the fact that a group is willing to get this arranged is congratulation-worthy in itself. This is a VERY difficult song to put together, and they pulled it off very well. Of course, Rajaton, having created the song, does it better, but they're a legend =).
But for any of you in this group here, good job! That was amazing.
EggTimerProductions 3 years ago 3
one last thing:
Make sure you remember all the lyrics when you sing (I know it's hard to do, though). There was a little mixup about 3 minutes in. It still sounded nice, though.
EggTimerProductions 3 years ago
pretty good
stlouis8 3 years ago 2
no offense, but that was pretty bad
kutiepie176 3 years ago
My Dear Child, if you know nothing about a cappella music just keep your uneducated comments to yourself. This not Paris Hilton reloaded so I can understand if you don't comprehend let alone appreciate what you heard here.If Rajaton themselves would comment they'd say that this was a good rendition of their song
Alieda16 3 years ago 2
Hun, Don't talk like that to me.
I sing a cappella, and the starting pitches were not that great.
I sing classical music and choral music, i've won many awards individually and with my choir, and i don't like your tone. I guess i didn't mean it like i said in my above comment, but it's not something rajaton would go crazy for. I meant, they have nice tone through out the song, but the beginning bitches are off.
kutiepie176 3 years ago
pitches**
kutiepie176 3 years ago
It's actually pretty good. The beginning was a little pitchy and there was a little problem with balance, but otherwise it's a good rendition. It got better as it went. Out of all the renditions of Butterfly on Youtube I've heard, this is the best, and the truest to the Rajaton version.
tennisnutter1987 3 years ago
ya, i agree.
i just meant the starting pitches are off.
but it's better than other ones.
kutiepie176 3 years ago
kutipie 176, go suck a fat dick to shut yourself up and perhaps choke on it and die. oh by the way, no offense on what I just said.
levesque2177 3 years ago
okay, listen hun, everyone has their own opinions. my own choir did this and i thought they were not that great. these guys probably did better. but my choir is a high school chamber choir that has 14 people in it and their starting pitches were way off. This is my opinion. So fuck off.
kutiepie176 3 years ago
after listening to this again, its pretty good.
crazyHSMgirl 3 years ago
Well done guys. Very nicely balanced and strong tuning.
StewNWT 4 years ago 2
haha I just noticed the garbled lyrics in the closing verse - oh well, sh*t happens!
StewNWT 4 years ago
man it hurt she said and the nighttime comes twice i think
JairajGeorge 2 years ago