israel is not a country and should not be recognized as one. Zionism is leeching off Europe and us. oneday soon enough ... good times will arrive when nobody dies from their bomb and brutality
Hey , Why dont you address these questions to the Malaysian PM too.
Coz they are doing just as what you assume lsreal is doing, the only difference is that the malaysian public or citizens are not in any form of danger that the State of lsreal face daily. They do it here with impunity
@Thomasseah1 Malaysia has 2 laws, sharia for muslims and another law for non-muslims. Israel has 1 law that applies for everyone and it also does not have whipping, torture or death penalty. I think Malaysia has a lot to improve as a 'democracy'. btw. Israel stands with Taiwan forever :)
@Thomasseah1 hrmm.. I still wonder what has Gov do to the chinese in Malaysia.. ohh.. i remember.. Gov accept Chinese immigrants from China as part of Malaysian citizen.. what more??.. hrmm.. Chinese can do business without problem and among top 5 Billionaire in Malaysia in Chinese... and Gov still not good??.. ohh bitch! you such a asshole!
It amazes me that people come on here and say " ZIONISM IS EVIL, which of course =+ ISRAEL MUST GO, and then they say they don't support Hamas.
Reminds me of the Germans that helped the Nazi's then played dumb afterwards.
The amount off lives (millions in fact) Israel saves every year by thwarting off those that wish the end to it and massive Jewish blood spilled is what people never seem to care about.
The more I see the Jew hate in this world, the more I see Israel and Zionism as a very beautiful thing. Zionism is no more racist than a battered woman shelter.
They cut out the first question because it makes Israel seem like a racist country, which it is. And Israel cannot have people believing that it is racist. If them cutting out your first question is not evidence that something is going on, then I don't know what is. Keep this video up on youtube to show how they censored your question and that the interview was biased.
@initialdrift86 Israel is not racist, arabs are in the Parliament (knesset) and can vote. Israel spent millions rescuing tens of thousands of BLACK Ethiopian Jews. You will burn in hell for lying.
@jpeditor Israel is racist. Why does it only allow Jewish people from around the world to come into the country for FREE and to be provided for? Because they are Jewish. That is called racist buddy. By the way, Ethiopian Jews are looked down upon by the typical Israeli. Israel "rescued" these people just so they can populate their country and fill up the houses that they built after demolishing Palestinian homes. You will burn in hell for supporting a racist country.
@theresmoretoit1 We demonize Israel for a reason. Not just for shits and giggles. We criticize Israel because it has violated so many of the Palestinian Arab's human rights. Wouldn't you criticize a country that was trying to destroy the natives of that country?
@initialdrift86 As I recall you said Zionism was evil. So Islam evil for stoning people to death, forcing woman to wear burkas, strapping bombs to kids? Do you spend any time on criticizing human rights abuses in Islamic countries? Israel has been trying for a long time to give The Palestinians a country, much better than any other Arab country, a true democracy, side by side theirs, but the extremists don't want that. Do you want Israel wiped off the map?
@theresmoretoit1 Yes, Zionism is evil because it displaces Palestinian Arabs out of their homes and massacres them mercilessly.
Islam does not do any of those horrible things. People do. No where in Qur'an does it say to do any of those things. Go educate yourself on the subject. And second point, Arab governments are evil. This is why there are so many protests in Arab countries today. Arabs impose fake Islamic laws on these people, the people don't want it!
@initialdrift86 You are aware of course that Muslims have also misplaced many from their homes and in fact it was Muslims that caused many Palestinians to leave Israel? You are aware of course aware that Muslims have massacred many people?
@theresmoretoit1 Sure I'm aware that Muslims in the past have done some horrible things. But do you realize how long ago that was? Unfortunately, that's something we can't change anymore, it's in the past. But Israel is doing all of this genocide of Palestinians in the present, something that is not inexcusable by any means. And people like you are completely closing their eyes to it and allowing for it to happen. Because to you, Palestinian lives are worth less than the lives of an Israeli.
@initialdrift86 Guess you haven't heard about Gaddafi and the current situation in Libya?
I disagree Israel is doing genocide, they are preventing genocide. Guess you haven't heard Hamas has called for a genocide on Jews? Guess you haven't heard that Hamas has killed many Palestinians?
@theresmoretoit1 You're a silly person. Just because I said Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians, it doesn't mean that NOBODY ELSE in the entire world is committing genocide. I never even said I supported Hamas. Your assumptions are so stupid. And bulldozing homes of thousands of Palestinians is not exactly what I call preventing genocide. Israel has killed 5 times the amount of Palestinian civilians than Palestinians have killed within the last 15 years. I'm done with you.
OK, I'm really disappointed that they edited the first question out because I think that's the main reason why this video is the most popular in the project, not the second one. My apologies for even asking the second if you are as well more interested in the first as I am.
Basing on informations I see, there are Arabs living with complete rights in Israel but there are also Arabs who don't. I guess I will just have to be there and find out by myself.
@ariel0785 Last but not least, thank you all for the votes and for sharing all kinds of opinions. I found out that I shared the same name with Israel's ex-PM Ariel Sharon years ago when news about he's order to withdraw from Gaza came out when I was in high school. That's when I started watching closely on this issue. It's been years since then and I'm glad to have finally gotten a chance to have Israeli people discussing this with me; and it's been a humbling experience.
@ariel0785 All Arabs in Israel have citizenship rights. In Jerusalem, all Arabs can apply for citizenship, but most don't, so they have permanent residency status.
@MeAreTrees My assumption is, most people who voted for this video are interested in the first question, so without the second it would still be at least one of the most voted and it would be irresponsible of the producers not to select it. But this is just my assumption, of course =)
Netanyahu answered her very clearly that Israel is the only democracy from India to Morocco. As for being "racist and religious state" as lady Ariel (an Hebrew name) asked I might add that a "Jewish" state has nothing to with religion and of course not racism. Judaism is nationality which is bordered by its own religious laws, one of the only nations on earth that can be defined by its own unique religion. Israel is Jewish exactly as Taiwan is Chinese and Britain is British.
@BadSantaXx1 LOL I know! It's my first time speaking to no one but a camera so, there it is. I so wanted to reupload another one but ther are already so many votes casted here, so I decided to stick to this one. :P
@bupvids Well, Netanyahu is their PM and he's supposed to take care of all kinds of problem for them, right? Rather than our relation with China, my first question for my own president might probably be about my survival after graduating this summer, too... =]
well im actually israely too and im living in israel
what they asking is not problems, they expect for things that nothing to do with him and can't be realistic
they expect to buy an apartment for 20% of its price and want a rise in the salary for 100% and i bet while they will get there, they will want another 150% rise again
complaining about how can they live from a 1500$ salary per person per mounth
i think he should answer the questions today in the evening here
@bupvids ; Your assumption is baseless because almost 100,000 questions had been sent to Netanyahu and I'm sure you haven't red all the questions that the Israelis asked ! So enough with your silly Falsetinian proPALganda shiite !!!!
jews will be jews/ they dont like to mix and are evil.. look at belgium antwerpen. they do the same there. look at amsterdam holland. same o. look at america. u have nice questions but he wont answer
i thumbed you up cause it is a nice thought. but they keep doing it. and unfortunate we cant say peace all the time wehen they keep killing. u get me? it stops at a certain extend. i do love your thought tho. i would love to have an ideal world like u do to.
@TheYugilicious And let's also not forget that Israel was 'born' after WW2, while the land was under goverment of Great Britain at the time... (in other words Palestina never really existed to begin with :s)
Most of the areas overtaken from palestinians was done so because other muslim nations began attacking Israel from these regions.
there is a history of violence between muslims and jews that started right at the 'birth' of Israel, but only the jews, in my eyes anyways, get the full blame
@TheYugilicious This handful of Muslim countries you refer to have their ethnic and religious divergence; it's the governments who insist that only one religion is allowed and discriminately treat people of different background and I oppose as well as I oppose Israeli government asking PA to recognize Israel as a "Jewish state." It's not about Palestinians blowing themselves up or Israel bombing Gaza. It's about citizen of Israel of all descent being recognized equally.
@ariel0785 No body suggests that all none Jews will be derived out of Israel. The only thing that Israel wants it is recognition as a state for the Jewish people, thats very different
@TheYugilicious Don't be, it was me who should have made the question more specific. And Thanks for pointing out that a state for the Jewish can be a safe haven protecting Jewish people from being persecuted elsewhere. I didn't think of it this way before. However, in my opinion, you don't need to be recognized to protect your people; you protect them anyway. A Jewish state and a state for the Jewish people are very different. ThePM himself said: PA must recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
@ariel0785 Why is the phrase "Palestinian State" raises no objection and the phrase "Jewish State" does?
What is the diffirence between a Jewish state and a state for the Jewish people according to you? a Jewish state does not mean a state that is run by Jewish laws.
The difference is, is that Palestinians want the Jews dead. The Jews want the rockets fired from schools and suicide bombings using women and children to stop.
@toddclemmer "jews" Israel uses jews to prove that they deserve the country. Nobody deserves the country Israel and Hamas have both proven that they are assholes and retards that are causing problems for the rest of the world both of you do not deserve the country
@ariel0785 And I myself certainly do not agree with Israel treating a million and a half people (about 20% of the population in Israel) as if they are not 'full citizens' of Israel just because they are not Jewish.
On the other hand I understand that the Jewish people search for recognition in this region which has a lot of hate towards them, hoping this recognition will bring them some sort of peace.
arabs in israel have equal rights...they have representitives in the israel parlament and enjoy everything a jew can... and they dont need to do army service nor civil service
@doritela2008 hm I've heard otherwise, but I have never actually been there, so your words get the benefit of the doubt.
From my own, pro-Israel, point of view I really don't understand how people can be so negative about the jews when so many arabs are putting such simplistic and stupid comments everywhere on the internet and the news... islam religion of peace... my ass =/
well it depends... if you speak about the arabs living in the west bank and gaza so yes they have no rights in israel because they are citiziens of palestine not of israel.... but you can find on the web even youtube the fact that there are arabs in the israeli parlament (there are 3 arab political parties in the parlamet: Hadash, raam-taal and balad.) and also most of the arabs in israel said that they want to remain citiziens of israel according to recent polls.
@doritela2008 Seriously the arabs in Israel have the same rights (if not more!) as the Israelis do and they are STILL unhappy. It's BS how the world looks at Israel when all they are trying to do (in my eyes) is protect & keep their land but end up giving up parts of it because of other countries pushing for it. Am Israel Chai
What do you mean by "do not agree with Israel ...". Netanyahu said it clearly that Arabs in Israel are full citizens and they are growing and developed each day by their partnership in building the Israeli society. All that occurs although the ruthless battle of the Arab Palestinian brothers against the very existence of Israel, as a non-Islamic state in the pure Islamic Middle East! No other nation would have treated their minority in times of war better than Israel!
@ariel0785 ; ….Because "Jewish" means Nationality and Religion people who are not proficient in the Jewish history tent to mix up and making mistakes, as you do. In that sense "a Jewish state" means "a state for the Jewish people", exactly as "a French state" is "a state for the French people".
And why shouldn't a country prefer its own people when accepting immigrants?
I believe the idea for a country has alot to do with the separation of different national cultures. Even in multiethnic countries like Russia, India, Brazil, etc. people of different ethnicities live mostly segregated in different areas of the country..
@bLaffix Just because it is doesn't mean it should be. That is the reality in most places in the current world, but is this kind of separation - separation that is based on something that one cannot make choice by themselves but fall into the national culture he/she is borned into - always a good way for us to decide who's one of us and who's not, especially when it becomes one of the criteria of citizenship and all rights that come with it?
@ariel0785 And the idea that you should make all choices in your life by yourself is simply madness. Did you chose to be born of a particular sex? Did you chose to be born to these particular parents? Did you chose your native language?
You can't chose everything in life and that's what makes life interesting.
@bLaffix No, I didn't choose all these things, therefore, under circumstance that I fulfill my obligations, I shouldn't be discriminated for these qualities I have. This is what I'm trying to say here. Accepting people of different backgrounds makes life interesting, too.
@bLaffix Or, to put it even more simply, isn't that one of the things that led to one of the biggest tragidies in human history before and during World War II?
@ariel0785 Then how do we solve this "problem"? Erase all cultures and impose a single language and culture on every nation? Because if a group of people has a different culture and ethnic identity than another group, then these groups would most probably want to coexist separately.
And WW2 was not started because of territorial disputes. The reasons were alot different.
@bLaffix Why do you think people of different cultures and ethnic identities would inevitably want to coexist "separately"? Have we not enough examples in the world of different people living together peacefully? I believe there are people like this in Israel, too. The point is, Difference is OK and people shouldn't be discriminated for being different.
@ariel0785 Ariel, you are naive, which is nice, but not very realistic. We, in Israel, have no problem to coexist with anybody but take a minute and look at the big picture. We are the scapegoat of the Arab&Muslim societies and in some extent other peoples as well.
It's very convenient for dictatorships to have a "ruthless enemy" that justifies having emergency laws and a secret police and that you can blame for everything (from 9.11 all the way to shark attacks in Egypt (for real)) (cont)
@ariel0785 Take a look on Egypt, a state that got pretty much everything they wanted for peace but still the people there is taught to hate either in schools or on govrement TV. Dictators have no real interest in having a REAL peace, that’s real politic, and unfortunately all of the Arab world is ruled by dictators. Some might be persuaded to sign a peace deal if offered enough carrots from the US/EU (cont)
@ariel0785 such as Jordan and Egypt but it is not a real peace and will probably not last so long, as the one with Egypt that is not very certain now (not mentioning the religious motive which is harder / impossible to appease)
And it is also very convenient for countries with large Muslims minorities to buy peace and quiet by attacking Israel (UK, Scandinavia etc.), not to mention oil as a major factor.
@bLaffix And the tragidy I'm referring to is the Holocaust, not the war. Didn't it happen because of the claim that one is superior and the other inferior and that it is impossible to let live the Jews so they must be killed?
Well done young lady! I worked in your country for six months once and really enjoyed it. I'm so happy that there are people like you living there. Keep up the good work!
@sueandoscar Thanks so much! It's awesome to hear someone having been in my country and I'm glad that you enjoyed it!
I do think that maybe I should have specified my questions, especially the first one with facts and Israeli policies that I've seen and that concern me. But anyway, we'll see! Thanks again =]
@ariel0785 I myself am a Jew planning to move to Israel, and I can tell you that yes, it is healthy. A country is more bound together when the people have something in common, such as culture, religion, or ethnicity. These states can serve as homelands and safe haven when their ethnic or religious counterparts are persecuted anywhere else in the world.
You are from Taiwan? Your own country has special laws giving immigration preferences to ethnic Han Chinese.
@warpedcomedy What about acountry in which there are people of different origin? Should the country serve more as a homeland and safe haven to some of its people and less to others? And thank you for pointing out some similar problems that we have here in Taiwan. I'm not sure what counterparts of Han Chinese you hold here are, but I would tell you, yes, we have discriminatory regulations towards foreign spouses (mainly towars those who come from South East Asian countries for economic reasons)
@warpedcomedy - continued - and these regulations affect their civil rights. I'm not happy with that as well since these women are the mothers of our children, too, and that's what I'm trying to point out here: Palestinians and Israelis / Taiwanese and South East Asian all try to make a living and contribution here, why should only some of them be recognized and others not? And for Israel, it's not only about immigration, it's also about a huge number of people who already live on this land.
Probably Netanyahu says the same thing as the chinese said to the native taiwanese. "We will have peace when you go screw off...were taking over....thank you."
(1) Dozens of countries base their immigration on origin and religion (a) EVERY MUSLIM COUNTRY. (b) Half of Europe has laws restricting/favoring immigration to descendants of the original citizens, and many European country's flags have Crosses on them. So either you're going with a double standard for Jews or you really didn't think hard before asking.
2/ Go read the koran & ask muslims that question.
@jpeditor Me posting only one video on YouTube questioning Israel does not mean I never question other countries and people about the same problem. When I pose these questions in front of PM Netanyahu, they are also questions for myself and the rest of the world. There's no double standard here.
@jpeditor Of course all countries have the right to decide who live in the country and who don't, but not basing on race and religion. The current reality is that most countries do that in practice, with or without such rules written in laws, but just because it is like this right now doesn't mean it should be this way. For me, by doing so a state sends out the message to its public that people can be discriminated simply because of differences.
Israeli hypocrisy would have stopped a long time ago if truth prevailed.
But because they own all the media, the politic and the culture, and WE ALL KNOW IT, I could ask any of my american, french, german, asian, hispanic, black or arabic friend, WE ALL KNOW IT.
And that's why Youtube, one of the most modern propaganda tool although subtle a discreet is giving a huge tribune to one of the smallest yet dangerous country of the world...
@greoar "Israeli hypocrisy"? are you joking? The hypocrite here is you and I will explain: you live in Bangladesh , a place where extrajudicial killings and tortures are done by the state's RAB (Rapid Action Battalion), a place where several hundred thousand Buddhists, Hindus and Christians have left the country for persecution and a place where Intimidation of human rights defenders, journalists, and the opposition is the norm (wiki / Human_rights_in_Bangladesh).
That's like saying Nazi Germany's invasion of Poland and France in WWII were justified due to Poland once being a significant part of Prussian territory and Alsace-Lorraine having German territory. If you value multiculturalism as much as your greatest benefactor the US does, then stop the pathetic fighting over religion and 1,000 year old territorial claims. It's only a waste of money and human lives and is frighteningly similar to Nazi Germany's attitude on the "superior" race.
then i guess the native americans also have a right to their homeland and that everyone who came after 1492 should just go back right? no one deserves a homeland, you fight for it and earn it, and the Israelis earned it, whether for good or bad.
the US fought native americans in many battles and skirmishes for land. Jackson marched them off in the Trail of Tears. Geronimo waged a campaign against US troops. Native americans fought for their lands and lost. And the areas US gave were lands that were useless. And when resources such as gold was found on land given to Indians, they were kicked out again.
all are not created equal, what a ridiculous thing to say, occasionally people strive to create equality of OPURTUNITY, however all are not created equal.
Also, Israel undeniably belongs to the jews, but of course we shouldn't be bombing gaza and of course they shouldnt be bombing us.
3. And what do you say about people who criticize Israel about the way they treat others when those criticizers don't pay attention to the fact that the "oppressed minority," the Palestinians, have a better rate of living than any Arab in the middle east. Where gays have a right to parade their cause but would get killed for the same thing in any other Arab country. Where women are allowed to go out in public in complete freedom and equality w/o fear of being raped, unlike any Muslim country,
It is so annoying when people like you have no clue of what is happening in the middle east and make up false accusations and assumptions against the only free democratic and peace wanting nation in the middle east. Do you know that a family of 5 israelis were murdered in the west bank by a palestinian , they murdered a 4 month old baby! Please help me understand what you think you know by giving me examples and not just spewing the usual anti-israel rhetoric.
@Gfunkadunk22 These are not anti-Israel rhetoric and I do not want to trigger hatred. I just cannot agree with what the Israeli government have been doing to Palestinian people. Yes, I do know there are always Israelis attacked and murdered every once in a while by Palestinians but so are there always Palestinians murdered, by the state of Israel. If you check the statistics you'll find the numbers of two sides' people killed is extremely unproportioned.
@ariel0785 Does a peace-wanting nation bomb civillians? Does a peace-wanting nation build illegal settlements on illegally occupied lands?
I hope I'm making myself much more clear. I didn't state in such length in this video because it's made and submitted to YouTube World View in hope that the PM would answer it next week in the interview. I do thank you for asking especially for that you have first hand knowledge about Israel since you live there.
@ariel0785 Hi, I think Gfunkadunk22 remarks are correct. Where do you get your information/concept about the situation?
It is not a question of who kills more, rather the intentions and capabilitis of each side. Israel is facing continuing terror campaign (even before it was established) and it very hard to fight it "cleanly" when your enemy is trying the opposite ( targeting civillians on purpose) and doing so from within its own civillian population.
@eyalalmog1 BBC, Al Jazeera (which you probably would say something about), NYT, Economist, Reuters, Ynet News, Jerusalem Post, LeMonde.fr, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and other NGOs, writings by Edward Said and by journalists, I Saw Ramallah by Bargouti, Mornings in Jenin by Abulhawa, documentary films.... I can go on and on and on.
I agree with you here. I don't justify killings by Palestinians, no matter what they try to achieve by doing so. But I do believe that Israel...
@eyalalmog1 ...cont... is the one in power of changing the way things are. If they allow Palestinians to live more properly, Hamas or other groups/orgs wouldn't stand a chance of spreading extreme messages and recruiting people.
in connection with immigration laws I do not think you or anyone have the right to dictate Israel the stance or its own rules there are many ways to immigrate to Israel and certainly more than Japan for example
Especially Palestinian Muslims have not shown any desire to a state and peace near and with the Israelis
The fact they have rejected every proposal to end the conflict by israel
Dropped any attempt at peace talks by ridiculous demands
@ariel0785 What are you basing your opinion on? Since the Oslo accords Israel has done a lot to help the Palestinians and with the financial help of the US and EU they had the chance to go for peace but they prefered to "invest" their money in building rockets digging tunnels and producing TV shows that fuels their children minds with hate /watch?v=gi-c6lbFGC4.
It takes two for peace and the Palestinians are not willing to make the necessary concessions
@orochipet First of all regarding resolution 446: Security Council resolutions do not create international law. They may, under certain circumstances create binding legal obligations, but Resolution 446 is not even a binding resolution.
The concessions are:
1. recognising Israel as the state for the Jewish people
2. stop the claim for the "right of return" into Israel itself
3. stop the teaching of hate and violence
4. willing to accept border changes for security and civilllians reasons
@ariel0785 BTW did youo check how many civillians were killed in Chechnya, Iraq or Libya in the last year? Much much more than in the West Bank and Gaza, why don't you reffer your question to Putin, Obama or Ghaddafi? The Palestinians in the west bank are having much more rights than any other civillian population in any other Arab country. Where are your questions for them?
@eyalalmog1 First, This is a video made for YouTube's World View event of asking PM Netanyahu. If there are events for other leaders for whom I have questions, I would love to make videos for them.
Second, you have no idea how much attention I've been paying to things that happen in places you mentioned and did not mention, and this video is just one of the ways that I use for expressing my opinions. It is what it is here, there's no need to drag other issues into this.
Can you clarify your first question? If I understand you correctly, you think that Israel is a racist state ? If that is true , would you mind giving some examples? Because as an American living in Israel at the time of this posting , I can tell you that the Israeli's are a very tolerant people, more than most anywhere in the world. There are almost 1.2 million arabs living within israel and I go to school here and there are plenty of non-jews (mostly arabs and bedouins ) living here.
@Gfunkadunk22 Yes there are many many arabs in Israel but do they sure equal rights in the society? There are Palestinian villiges that have no water supply, no proper roads and no access to education and health services. Israeli government also asked PA to recognize Israel as a Jewish state, but what about people in Israel that are not Jewish?
@ariel0785 As I said before the Arabs in Israel don't always get equal rights defacto. It is not a descision by the State rather a situation that is caused because they see themselves as Palestinians and see Israel as enemy.
The "facts" about education, health etc. are just not true. They often get health services in Israel itself though a woman from tried to explode in a hospital in Israel where she got treatment. Israel wants to be recognised as a state for the Jewish people just as the...
@eyalalmog1 Is it not a decision by the Israeli state? According to reports by Human Rights Watch, many Palestinians face severe systematic discrimination and are unable to live properly. They can be forced out of their lands, not given house building approvals and store licenses, and blocked from roads. Yes, there are people who get education and health care, such as people in cities like Nablus and Ramallah, but there are also people who live in minor villages for whom schools, hospitals...
@eyalalmog1 ...cont... and other basic services is just too difficult to get to. Some have to walk 1.5 kilometers to get to the nearest - not service but - road.
As for the recognition of a Jewish state, I recommend you "Out of the Ashes: The Search for Jewish Identity in the Twenty-first Century” by Marc H Ellis, which illustrates how Israel differs from other nation states. The idea "Jewish" used on the state is very exclusive.
@ariel0785 Judaism is both a religion and a nationality and I cannot understand from you why the Jewish people is not entitled for a state (not to mention that there are many states with a formal religion, but that is another issue).
The world (and many human rights organizations) are hypocrites. can you please tell me how many condemnations of Israel have been in the UN's human rights council since its establishment in 2006? (cont)
@ariel0785 Let me help you 32, that’s over 47% of the total condemnations. Do you really think that Israel is responsible for about half of the human rights violations in the world? I guess that you don’t have a problem that Libya which kills its own civilians by the thousands was heading that council until the world suddenly remembered that Ghadaffi is a brutal dictator (cont)
@ariel0785 Actually there is not much difference between the people and the state as Israel is a democracy, something that you don't find in Israel's enemies which you see as so right and pure victims
israel is not a country and should not be recognized as one. Zionism is leeching off Europe and us. oneday soon enough ... good times will arrive when nobody dies from their bomb and brutality
mrkhoros 1 month ago
ariel you are a very good girl
alienmode 4 months ago
Hey , Why dont you address these questions to the Malaysian PM too.
Coz they are doing just as what you assume lsreal is doing, the only difference is that the malaysian public or citizens are not in any form of danger that the State of lsreal face daily. They do it here with impunity
Thomasseah1 5 months ago
@Thomasseah1 Malaysia has 2 laws, sharia for muslims and another law for non-muslims. Israel has 1 law that applies for everyone and it also does not have whipping, torture or death penalty. I think Malaysia has a lot to improve as a 'democracy'. btw. Israel stands with Taiwan forever :)
JossyHadash 5 months ago
@Thomasseah1 hrmm.. I still wonder what has Gov do to the chinese in Malaysia.. ohh.. i remember.. Gov accept Chinese immigrants from China as part of Malaysian citizen.. what more??.. hrmm.. Chinese can do business without problem and among top 5 Billionaire in Malaysia in Chinese... and Gov still not good??.. ohh bitch! you such a asshole!
umlarmy 1 month ago
It amazes me that people come on here and say " ZIONISM IS EVIL, which of course =+ ISRAEL MUST GO, and then they say they don't support Hamas.
Reminds me of the Germans that helped the Nazi's then played dumb afterwards.
The amount off lives (millions in fact) Israel saves every year by thwarting off those that wish the end to it and massive Jewish blood spilled is what people never seem to care about.
theresmoretoit1 10 months ago
@theresmoretoit1 Just another butthurt supremacist. Get over it, racism is dead and gone.
XSilvenX 6 months ago
@theresmoretoit1 its because the fucking kikes do the same as nazis did, you fucking retard
xdroon3 3 months ago
The more I see the Jew hate in this world, the more I see Israel and Zionism as a very beautiful thing. Zionism is no more racist than a battered woman shelter.
theresmoretoit1 10 months ago
@theresmoretoit1
UK Col. Richard Kemp
Israel conducts a blockade of Gaza creating a humanitarian crisis;
used illegal phosphorus bombs on civilians in the last war;
targeted UN installations in Gaza in the last war;
committed an act of piracy in recent days on foreign ships in international waters, murdering 9 people.
And this rogue state posses nuclear weapons!
flumoxed2 9 months ago
They cut out the first question because it makes Israel seem like a racist country, which it is. And Israel cannot have people believing that it is racist. If them cutting out your first question is not evidence that something is going on, then I don't know what is. Keep this video up on youtube to show how they censored your question and that the interview was biased.
I hope that man burns in hell btw =D.
initialdrift86 10 months ago
@initialdrift86 Israel is not racist, arabs are in the Parliament (knesset) and can vote. Israel spent millions rescuing tens of thousands of BLACK Ethiopian Jews. You will burn in hell for lying.
jpeditor 10 months ago
@jpeditor Israel is racist. Why does it only allow Jewish people from around the world to come into the country for FREE and to be provided for? Because they are Jewish. That is called racist buddy. By the way, Ethiopian Jews are looked down upon by the typical Israeli. Israel "rescued" these people just so they can populate their country and fill up the houses that they built after demolishing Palestinian homes. You will burn in hell for supporting a racist country.
initialdrift86 10 months ago
@initialdrift86 If you don't want people to demonize Muslims, why is it right then for you to demonize Israel?
theresmoretoit1 10 months ago
@theresmoretoit1 We demonize Israel for a reason. Not just for shits and giggles. We criticize Israel because it has violated so many of the Palestinian Arab's human rights. Wouldn't you criticize a country that was trying to destroy the natives of that country?
initialdrift86 10 months ago
@initialdrift86 As I recall you said Zionism was evil. So Islam evil for stoning people to death, forcing woman to wear burkas, strapping bombs to kids? Do you spend any time on criticizing human rights abuses in Islamic countries? Israel has been trying for a long time to give The Palestinians a country, much better than any other Arab country, a true democracy, side by side theirs, but the extremists don't want that. Do you want Israel wiped off the map?
theresmoretoit1 10 months ago
@theresmoretoit1 Yes, Zionism is evil because it displaces Palestinian Arabs out of their homes and massacres them mercilessly.
Islam does not do any of those horrible things. People do. No where in Qur'an does it say to do any of those things. Go educate yourself on the subject. And second point, Arab governments are evil. This is why there are so many protests in Arab countries today. Arabs impose fake Islamic laws on these people, the people don't want it!
initialdrift86 10 months ago
@initialdrift86 You are aware of course that Muslims have also misplaced many from their homes and in fact it was Muslims that caused many Palestinians to leave Israel? You are aware of course aware that Muslims have massacred many people?
theresmoretoit1 10 months ago
@theresmoretoit1 Sure I'm aware that Muslims in the past have done some horrible things. But do you realize how long ago that was? Unfortunately, that's something we can't change anymore, it's in the past. But Israel is doing all of this genocide of Palestinians in the present, something that is not inexcusable by any means. And people like you are completely closing their eyes to it and allowing for it to happen. Because to you, Palestinian lives are worth less than the lives of an Israeli.
initialdrift86 10 months ago
@initialdrift86 Guess you haven't heard about Gaddafi and the current situation in Libya?
I disagree Israel is doing genocide, they are preventing genocide. Guess you haven't heard Hamas has called for a genocide on Jews? Guess you haven't heard that Hamas has killed many Palestinians?
theresmoretoit1 10 months ago
@theresmoretoit1 You're a silly person. Just because I said Israel is committing genocide against Palestinians, it doesn't mean that NOBODY ELSE in the entire world is committing genocide. I never even said I supported Hamas. Your assumptions are so stupid. And bulldozing homes of thousands of Palestinians is not exactly what I call preventing genocide. Israel has killed 5 times the amount of Palestinian civilians than Palestinians have killed within the last 15 years. I'm done with you.
initialdrift86 10 months ago
@theresmoretoit1 I don't want Israel to be wiped off the map because that would cause the death of many innocent people.
initialdrift86 10 months ago
Hey, when the host say "I must admit that..." was she trying to say "there's another question from her?" ='(
ariel0785 10 months ago
OK, I'm really disappointed that they edited the first question out because I think that's the main reason why this video is the most popular in the project, not the second one. My apologies for even asking the second if you are as well more interested in the first as I am.
Basing on informations I see, there are Arabs living with complete rights in Israel but there are also Arabs who don't. I guess I will just have to be there and find out by myself.
ariel0785 10 months ago
@ariel0785 Last but not least, thank you all for the votes and for sharing all kinds of opinions. I found out that I shared the same name with Israel's ex-PM Ariel Sharon years ago when news about he's order to withdraw from Gaza came out when I was in high school. That's when I started watching closely on this issue. It's been years since then and I'm glad to have finally gotten a chance to have Israeli people discussing this with me; and it's been a humbling experience.
ariel0785 10 months ago
@ariel0785 What do you think of Netanyahu's answer to your question?
warpedcomedy 10 months ago
@ariel0785 All Arabs in Israel have citizenship rights. In Jerusalem, all Arabs can apply for citizenship, but most don't, so they have permanent residency status.
warpedcomedy 10 months ago
Damn it's sad to see that the first question was cut out :/
MeAreTrees 10 months ago
@MeAreTrees I feel the same way, too.... Now I so wish that I have never even asked the second question... So foolish... =[
ariel0785 10 months ago
@ariel0785
Well I think If you wouldn't have asked the second question you wouldn't have been chosen at all !
It's understandable on their side that they only want questions which are soft and easy to answer... but still ^^
MeAreTrees 10 months ago
@MeAreTrees My assumption is, most people who voted for this video are interested in the first question, so without the second it would still be at least one of the most voted and it would be irresponsible of the producers not to select it. But this is just my assumption, of course =)
ariel0785 10 months ago
Netanyahu answered her very clearly that Israel is the only democracy from India to Morocco. As for being "racist and religious state" as lady Ariel (an Hebrew name) asked I might add that a "Jewish" state has nothing to with religion and of course not racism. Judaism is nationality which is bordered by its own religious laws, one of the only nations on earth that can be defined by its own unique religion. Israel is Jewish exactly as Taiwan is Chinese and Britain is British.
Salamwamat 11 months ago
Your video got some of it cut!!
MrValzen 11 months ago
you sound like a talking computer XD
BadSantaXx1 11 months ago
@BadSantaXx1 LOL I know! It's my first time speaking to no one but a camera so, there it is. I so wanted to reupload another one but ther are already so many votes casted here, so I decided to stick to this one. :P
ariel0785 10 months ago
your questions is much better then the israeli's
they asking how can they buy apartment if they students that have no money and other questions ask him to raise their salary
LOL
bupvids 11 months ago
@bupvids Well, Netanyahu is their PM and he's supposed to take care of all kinds of problem for them, right? Rather than our relation with China, my first question for my own president might probably be about my survival after graduating this summer, too... =]
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785
well im actually israely too and im living in israel
what they asking is not problems, they expect for things that nothing to do with him and can't be realistic
they expect to buy an apartment for 20% of its price and want a rise in the salary for 100% and i bet while they will get there, they will want another 150% rise again
complaining about how can they live from a 1500$ salary per person per mounth
i think he should answer the questions today in the evening here
bupvids 11 months ago
@bupvids ; Your assumption is baseless because almost 100,000 questions had been sent to Netanyahu and I'm sure you haven't red all the questions that the Israelis asked ! So enough with your silly Falsetinian proPALganda shiite !!!!
Salamwamat 11 months ago
@Salamwamat
man come down
read what i said
i have nothing to do with falastines pro shittie
im israeli
bupvids 10 months ago
I hope he answers your questions :) he'll probably lie tho haha
ILUVFFANDKH 11 months ago
jews will be jews/ they dont like to mix and are evil.. look at belgium antwerpen. they do the same there. look at amsterdam holland. same o. look at america. u have nice questions but he wont answer
unspokentopics 11 months ago
@unspokentopics I'd rather believe in the good in humankind and the possibility of a world changing for the best. Hope you would, too. =)
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785
i thumbed you up cause it is a nice thought. but they keep doing it. and unfortunate we cant say peace all the time wehen they keep killing. u get me? it stops at a certain extend. i do love your thought tho. i would love to have an ideal world like u do to.
unspokentopics 11 months ago
Awesome questions! You go girl!
juliaisafilmbuff123 11 months ago
@juliaisafilmbuff123 Thanks! Let's see if Mr. PM answers it. =]
ariel0785 11 months ago
let me answer nr1. with another question
Is it healty for a country NOT to do so?
TheYugilicious 11 months ago
@TheYugilicious And I'll answer you with another question: How many countries are there left today who have people of only one race and one religion?
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Funny enough the answer would be a handfull of muslimcountries... ;-)
TheYugilicious 11 months ago
@TheYugilicious And to add a bit to this: There isn't a law in Israel that would stop me, being an atheist, to go live in Israel nor to visit it.
What u are describing is a stop that came about when palestinians decided to blow themselves up in public places, causing many deaths.
This causing Israel to decide to shut out the whole of the palestinians as much as possible to stop these cowardly acts.
TheYugilicious 11 months ago
@TheYugilicious And let's also not forget that Israel was 'born' after WW2, while the land was under goverment of Great Britain at the time... (in other words Palestina never really existed to begin with :s)
Most of the areas overtaken from palestinians was done so because other muslim nations began attacking Israel from these regions.
there is a history of violence between muslims and jews that started right at the 'birth' of Israel, but only the jews, in my eyes anyways, get the full blame
TheYugilicious 11 months ago
@TheYugilicious This handful of Muslim countries you refer to have their ethnic and religious divergence; it's the governments who insist that only one religion is allowed and discriminately treat people of different background and I oppose as well as I oppose Israeli government asking PA to recognize Israel as a "Jewish state." It's not about Palestinians blowing themselves up or Israel bombing Gaza. It's about citizen of Israel of all descent being recognized equally.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 No body suggests that all none Jews will be derived out of Israel. The only thing that Israel wants it is recognition as a state for the Jewish people, thats very different
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@ariel0785 I am sorry for misinterpreting the question.
TheYugilicious 11 months ago
@TheYugilicious Don't be, it was me who should have made the question more specific. And Thanks for pointing out that a state for the Jewish can be a safe haven protecting Jewish people from being persecuted elsewhere. I didn't think of it this way before. However, in my opinion, you don't need to be recognized to protect your people; you protect them anyway. A Jewish state and a state for the Jewish people are very different. ThePM himself said: PA must recognize Israel as a Jewish state.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Why is the phrase "Palestinian State" raises no objection and the phrase "Jewish State" does?
What is the diffirence between a Jewish state and a state for the Jewish people according to you? a Jewish state does not mean a state that is run by Jewish laws.
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1
The difference is the Jews are originally from Israel and the "Palestinians" are from Jordan and Saudi Arabia.
There is no such place as Palestine. Its a human shield set up by racist muslins.
toddclemmer 11 months ago 2
@toddclemmer It's not a competition of who arrives in this place first. Both Jews and Palestinians lived there.
ariel0785 10 months ago
@ariel0785
The difference is, is that Palestinians want the Jews dead. The Jews want the rockets fired from schools and suicide bombings using women and children to stop.
toddclemmer 10 months ago
@toddclemmer shut your fucking jew mouth
xdroon3 3 months ago
@toddclemmer "jews" Israel uses jews to prove that they deserve the country. Nobody deserves the country Israel and Hamas have both proven that they are assholes and retards that are causing problems for the rest of the world both of you do not deserve the country
guperyuper99 1 month ago
@ariel0785 And I myself certainly do not agree with Israel treating a million and a half people (about 20% of the population in Israel) as if they are not 'full citizens' of Israel just because they are not Jewish.
On the other hand I understand that the Jewish people search for recognition in this region which has a lot of hate towards them, hoping this recognition will bring them some sort of peace.
TheYugilicious 11 months ago
@TheYugilicious
arabs in israel have equal rights...they have representitives in the israel parlament and enjoy everything a jew can... and they dont need to do army service nor civil service
doritela2008 11 months ago
@doritela2008 hm I've heard otherwise, but I have never actually been there, so your words get the benefit of the doubt.
From my own, pro-Israel, point of view I really don't understand how people can be so negative about the jews when so many arabs are putting such simplistic and stupid comments everywhere on the internet and the news... islam religion of peace... my ass =/
TheYugilicious 11 months ago
well it depends... if you speak about the arabs living in the west bank and gaza so yes they have no rights in israel because they are citiziens of palestine not of israel.... but you can find on the web even youtube the fact that there are arabs in the israeli parlament (there are 3 arab political parties in the parlamet: Hadash, raam-taal and balad.) and also most of the arabs in israel said that they want to remain citiziens of israel according to recent polls.
doritela2008 11 months ago 6
@doritela2008
Her questions are a nice way of accusing him of being a racist.
toddclemmer 11 months ago
@doritela2008 Seriously the arabs in Israel have the same rights (if not more!) as the Israelis do and they are STILL unhappy. It's BS how the world looks at Israel when all they are trying to do (in my eyes) is protect & keep their land but end up giving up parts of it because of other countries pushing for it. Am Israel Chai
spdyrel 2 months ago
@TheYugilicious ;
What do you mean by "do not agree with Israel ...". Netanyahu said it clearly that Arabs in Israel are full citizens and they are growing and developed each day by their partnership in building the Israeli society. All that occurs although the ruthless battle of the Arab Palestinian brothers against the very existence of Israel, as a non-Islamic state in the pure Islamic Middle East! No other nation would have treated their minority in times of war better than Israel!
Salamwamat 11 months ago
@ariel0785 ; ….Because "Jewish" means Nationality and Religion people who are not proficient in the Jewish history tent to mix up and making mistakes, as you do. In that sense "a Jewish state" means "a state for the Jewish people", exactly as "a French state" is "a state for the French people".
Salamwamat 11 months ago
His answer to your question will be to find out where you live and have Mossad cone round to shut you up !
EdBinx 11 months ago
@EdBinx Yeah, I'm pretty worried about this possibility, too. Let's hope that it doesn't go this way... :P
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 We're beyond hoping these days my friend, gear up & prepare for the worst !
EdBinx 4 months ago
And why shouldn't a country prefer its own people when accepting immigrants?
I believe the idea for a country has alot to do with the separation of different national cultures. Even in multiethnic countries like Russia, India, Brazil, etc. people of different ethnicities live mostly segregated in different areas of the country..
bLaffix 11 months ago
@bLaffix Just because it is doesn't mean it should be. That is the reality in most places in the current world, but is this kind of separation - separation that is based on something that one cannot make choice by themselves but fall into the national culture he/she is borned into - always a good way for us to decide who's one of us and who's not, especially when it becomes one of the criteria of citizenship and all rights that come with it?
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 And the idea that you should make all choices in your life by yourself is simply madness. Did you chose to be born of a particular sex? Did you chose to be born to these particular parents? Did you chose your native language?
You can't chose everything in life and that's what makes life interesting.
Regards.
bLaffix 11 months ago
@bLaffix No, I didn't choose all these things, therefore, under circumstance that I fulfill my obligations, I shouldn't be discriminated for these qualities I have. This is what I'm trying to say here. Accepting people of different backgrounds makes life interesting, too.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@bLaffix Or, to put it even more simply, isn't that one of the things that led to one of the biggest tragidies in human history before and during World War II?
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Then how do we solve this "problem"? Erase all cultures and impose a single language and culture on every nation? Because if a group of people has a different culture and ethnic identity than another group, then these groups would most probably want to coexist separately.
And WW2 was not started because of territorial disputes. The reasons were alot different.
bLaffix 11 months ago
@bLaffix Why do you think people of different cultures and ethnic identities would inevitably want to coexist "separately"? Have we not enough examples in the world of different people living together peacefully? I believe there are people like this in Israel, too. The point is, Difference is OK and people shouldn't be discriminated for being different.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Ariel, you are naive, which is nice, but not very realistic. We, in Israel, have no problem to coexist with anybody but take a minute and look at the big picture. We are the scapegoat of the Arab&Muslim societies and in some extent other peoples as well.
It's very convenient for dictatorships to have a "ruthless enemy" that justifies having emergency laws and a secret police and that you can blame for everything (from 9.11 all the way to shark attacks in Egypt (for real)) (cont)
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Take a look on Egypt, a state that got pretty much everything they wanted for peace but still the people there is taught to hate either in schools or on govrement TV. Dictators have no real interest in having a REAL peace, that’s real politic, and unfortunately all of the Arab world is ruled by dictators. Some might be persuaded to sign a peace deal if offered enough carrots from the US/EU (cont)
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@ariel0785 such as Jordan and Egypt but it is not a real peace and will probably not last so long, as the one with Egypt that is not very certain now (not mentioning the religious motive which is harder / impossible to appease)
And it is also very convenient for countries with large Muslims minorities to buy peace and quiet by attacking Israel (UK, Scandinavia etc.), not to mention oil as a major factor.
I hope you understand what I am talking about
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@bLaffix And the tragidy I'm referring to is the Holocaust, not the war. Didn't it happen because of the claim that one is superior and the other inferior and that it is impossible to let live the Jews so they must be killed?
ariel0785 11 months ago
This made me cry thank you the world runs on people like you! BLESS YOU i'm a pigass so I don't know right from rong sniiffle sniffle oink oink!
Lavron4151 11 months ago
Well done young lady! I worked in your country for six months once and really enjoyed it. I'm so happy that there are people like you living there. Keep up the good work!
sueandoscar 11 months ago
@sueandoscar Thanks so much! It's awesome to hear someone having been in my country and I'm glad that you enjoyed it!
I do think that maybe I should have specified my questions, especially the first one with facts and Israeli policies that I've seen and that concern me. But anyway, we'll see! Thanks again =]
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 I myself am a Jew planning to move to Israel, and I can tell you that yes, it is healthy. A country is more bound together when the people have something in common, such as culture, religion, or ethnicity. These states can serve as homelands and safe haven when their ethnic or religious counterparts are persecuted anywhere else in the world.
You are from Taiwan? Your own country has special laws giving immigration preferences to ethnic Han Chinese.
warpedcomedy 11 months ago
@warpedcomedy taiwan and israel is not the same jews stealed palestinian land
but taiwan don;t isteal han chinese
israel don't alowd palestinians back thay homeland and given back thay land
but person like you who hard home in some where thay w'll give home becouse thay need so mani people
to keep that land
addan76 11 months ago
@warpedcomedy What about acountry in which there are people of different origin? Should the country serve more as a homeland and safe haven to some of its people and less to others? And thank you for pointing out some similar problems that we have here in Taiwan. I'm not sure what counterparts of Han Chinese you hold here are, but I would tell you, yes, we have discriminatory regulations towards foreign spouses (mainly towars those who come from South East Asian countries for economic reasons)
ariel0785 11 months ago
@warpedcomedy - continued - and these regulations affect their civil rights. I'm not happy with that as well since these women are the mothers of our children, too, and that's what I'm trying to point out here: Palestinians and Israelis / Taiwanese and South East Asian all try to make a living and contribution here, why should only some of them be recognized and others not? And for Israel, it's not only about immigration, it's also about a huge number of people who already live on this land.
ariel0785 11 months ago
I don`t think he would reply to childish questions like that ;-))
ainanor 11 months ago
He will answer you in a God-chosen way.
raficsulejmanovic 11 months ago
Probably Netanyahu says the same thing as the chinese said to the native taiwanese. "We will have peace when you go screw off...were taking over....thank you."
qigong1001 11 months ago
Great questions. Let's see if he'll answer them honestly.
CHOZENVEZL 11 months ago
(1) Dozens of countries base their immigration on origin and religion (a) EVERY MUSLIM COUNTRY. (b) Half of Europe has laws restricting/favoring immigration to descendants of the original citizens, and many European country's flags have Crosses on them. So either you're going with a double standard for Jews or you really didn't think hard before asking.
2/ Go read the koran & ask muslims that question.
jpeditor 11 months ago
@jpeditor Let me know which so called country has rule which says every muslim is its citizen?.. which chapter of quran says so?
SeekerofTaqwa 11 months ago
@jpeditor Me posting only one video on YouTube questioning Israel does not mean I never question other countries and people about the same problem. When I pose these questions in front of PM Netanyahu, they are also questions for myself and the rest of the world. There's no double standard here.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 So you don't believe ANY nation should have the right to decide who can live in their country as a citizen?
jpeditor 10 months ago
@jpeditor Of course all countries have the right to decide who live in the country and who don't, but not basing on race and religion. The current reality is that most countries do that in practice, with or without such rules written in laws, but just because it is like this right now doesn't mean it should be this way. For me, by doing so a state sends out the message to its public that people can be discriminated simply because of differences.
ariel0785 10 months ago
Great questions! thank you, I hope they select you.
headydanger 11 months ago 4
@headydanger Thank you! I'll be thrilled if he answers my questions =]
ariel0785 11 months ago
peace and love...lol, btw whats the point asking him a question knowing they are heavily pre-screened , but you go girl
DesmosediciAlice 11 months ago
please vote for my friend to if you can Pro Israel please Like on youtube watch?v=D4GA6vD2j5M trying to spread the word for Israel please help
advertisebibireport 11 months ago
Israeli hypocrisy would have stopped a long time ago if truth prevailed.
But because they own all the media, the politic and the culture, and WE ALL KNOW IT, I could ask any of my american, french, german, asian, hispanic, black or arabic friend, WE ALL KNOW IT.
And that's why Youtube, one of the most modern propaganda tool although subtle a discreet is giving a huge tribune to one of the smallest yet dangerous country of the world...
greoar 11 months ago
@greoar "Israeli hypocrisy"? are you joking? The hypocrite here is you and I will explain: you live in Bangladesh , a place where extrajudicial killings and tortures are done by the state's RAB (Rapid Action Battalion), a place where several hundred thousand Buddhists, Hindus and Christians have left the country for persecution and a place where Intimidation of human rights defenders, journalists, and the opposition is the norm (wiki / Human_rights_in_Bangladesh).
eyalalmog1 11 months ago 2
the jews have a right to their homeland, their human rights were violated for thousands of years
afromanola 11 months ago
@afromanola
That's like saying Nazi Germany's invasion of Poland and France in WWII were justified due to Poland once being a significant part of Prussian territory and Alsace-Lorraine having German territory. If you value multiculturalism as much as your greatest benefactor the US does, then stop the pathetic fighting over religion and 1,000 year old territorial claims. It's only a waste of money and human lives and is frighteningly similar to Nazi Germany's attitude on the "superior" race.
Auriono 11 months ago
@Auriono
well u see,i wasnt saying that Israel had to be a homeland for the jews.
they at least deserve one
afromanola 11 months ago
@Auriono
also,dont understand ur comparison, there was no aspect of persecution there and kind of ironic how you compare the aryan race to the jews
afromanola 11 months ago
@afromanola
then i guess the native americans also have a right to their homeland and that everyone who came after 1492 should just go back right? no one deserves a homeland, you fight for it and earn it, and the Israelis earned it, whether for good or bad.
Hamlet137475 11 months ago
@Hamlet137475
the us gave them areas to live in, I think that would be considered a homeland-they didnt fight for those
afromanola 11 months ago
@afromanola
the US fought native americans in many battles and skirmishes for land. Jackson marched them off in the Trail of Tears. Geronimo waged a campaign against US troops. Native americans fought for their lands and lost. And the areas US gave were lands that were useless. And when resources such as gold was found on land given to Indians, they were kicked out again.
Hamlet137475 11 months ago
Thank you for this. I hope these questions will be addressed.
NeoItoh 11 months ago
all are not created equal, what a ridiculous thing to say, occasionally people strive to create equality of OPURTUNITY, however all are not created equal.
Also, Israel undeniably belongs to the jews, but of course we shouldn't be bombing gaza and of course they shouldnt be bombing us.
rafstergrant 11 months ago
What do you think about people who try all the time to sow discord ... Give me a break ... we all know what your goal
avivteck2 11 months ago
3. And what do you say about people who criticize Israel about the way they treat others when those criticizers don't pay attention to the fact that the "oppressed minority," the Palestinians, have a better rate of living than any Arab in the middle east. Where gays have a right to parade their cause but would get killed for the same thing in any other Arab country. Where women are allowed to go out in public in complete freedom and equality w/o fear of being raped, unlike any Muslim country,
mbkfox 11 months ago
Of course Jews can marry but not through the Jewish Institute
Israel will receive this
TheUria24 11 months ago
It is so annoying when people like you have no clue of what is happening in the middle east and make up false accusations and assumptions against the only free democratic and peace wanting nation in the middle east. Do you know that a family of 5 israelis were murdered in the west bank by a palestinian , they murdered a 4 month old baby! Please help me understand what you think you know by giving me examples and not just spewing the usual anti-israel rhetoric.
Gfunkadunk22 11 months ago
@Gfunkadunk22 These are not anti-Israel rhetoric and I do not want to trigger hatred. I just cannot agree with what the Israeli government have been doing to Palestinian people. Yes, I do know there are always Israelis attacked and murdered every once in a while by Palestinians but so are there always Palestinians murdered, by the state of Israel. If you check the statistics you'll find the numbers of two sides' people killed is extremely unproportioned.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Does a peace-wanting nation bomb civillians? Does a peace-wanting nation build illegal settlements on illegally occupied lands?
I hope I'm making myself much more clear. I didn't state in such length in this video because it's made and submitted to YouTube World View in hope that the PM would answer it next week in the interview. I do thank you for asking especially for that you have first hand knowledge about Israel since you live there.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Hi, I think Gfunkadunk22 remarks are correct. Where do you get your information/concept about the situation?
It is not a question of who kills more, rather the intentions and capabilitis of each side. Israel is facing continuing terror campaign (even before it was established) and it very hard to fight it "cleanly" when your enemy is trying the opposite ( targeting civillians on purpose) and doing so from within its own civillian population.
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 BBC, Al Jazeera (which you probably would say something about), NYT, Economist, Reuters, Ynet News, Jerusalem Post, LeMonde.fr, Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and other NGOs, writings by Edward Said and by journalists, I Saw Ramallah by Bargouti, Mornings in Jenin by Abulhawa, documentary films.... I can go on and on and on.
I agree with you here. I don't justify killings by Palestinians, no matter what they try to achieve by doing so. But I do believe that Israel...
ariel0785 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 ...cont... is the one in power of changing the way things are. If they allow Palestinians to live more properly, Hamas or other groups/orgs wouldn't stand a chance of spreading extreme messages and recruiting people.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785
in connection with immigration laws I do not think you or anyone have the right to dictate Israel the stance or its own rules there are many ways to immigrate to Israel and certainly more than Japan for example
Especially Palestinian Muslims have not shown any desire to a state and peace near and with the Israelis
The fact they have rejected every proposal to end the conflict by israel
Dropped any attempt at peace talks by ridiculous demands
TheUria24 11 months ago
and After Israel fulfilled their demands They avoided for 9 months
About minority rights
I would like to see the article of these organizations
Most of which are in possession of countries hostile to Israel that deny their own human rights
I would suggest you to see critical articles of UNW
Now the chances are unlike in your state most of the land belonging to the state in israel
and the state rents the land to the Citizen
TheUria24 11 months ago
Now if you build a house or any structure with a roof stayed on the ground you have to pay taxes even if the land taboo
If you do not pay they take your house to pay off your debt
In addition to that the Arabs think that because they do more than 10 children per family deserve more land
So they build on land not their and Israel demolishes
TheUria24 11 months ago
Here are some rights that Arabs have and Jews not
Arabs can work on Saturday without getting a fine
Arabs are not required to serve in the army
Arab can marry anyone a Jew not
TheUria24 11 months ago
@ariel0785 What are you basing your opinion on? Since the Oslo accords Israel has done a lot to help the Palestinians and with the financial help of the US and EU they had the chance to go for peace but they prefered to "invest" their money in building rockets digging tunnels and producing TV shows that fuels their children minds with hate /watch?v=gi-c6lbFGC4.
It takes two for peace and the Palestinians are not willing to make the necessary concessions
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 how many more concessions should they have to make to live in peace. just look up UN resolution 446.
orochipet 11 months ago
@orochipet First of all regarding resolution 446: Security Council resolutions do not create international law. They may, under certain circumstances create binding legal obligations, but Resolution 446 is not even a binding resolution.
The concessions are:
1. recognising Israel as the state for the Jewish people
2. stop the claim for the "right of return" into Israel itself
3. stop the teaching of hate and violence
4. willing to accept border changes for security and civilllians reasons
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@ariel0785 BTW did youo check how many civillians were killed in Chechnya, Iraq or Libya in the last year? Much much more than in the West Bank and Gaza, why don't you reffer your question to Putin, Obama or Ghaddafi? The Palestinians in the west bank are having much more rights than any other civillian population in any other Arab country. Where are your questions for them?
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 First, This is a video made for YouTube's World View event of asking PM Netanyahu. If there are events for other leaders for whom I have questions, I would love to make videos for them.
Second, you have no idea how much attention I've been paying to things that happen in places you mentioned and did not mention, and this video is just one of the ways that I use for expressing my opinions. It is what it is here, there's no need to drag other issues into this.
ariel0785 11 months ago
Can you clarify your first question? If I understand you correctly, you think that Israel is a racist state ? If that is true , would you mind giving some examples? Because as an American living in Israel at the time of this posting , I can tell you that the Israeli's are a very tolerant people, more than most anywhere in the world. There are almost 1.2 million arabs living within israel and I go to school here and there are plenty of non-jews (mostly arabs and bedouins ) living here.
Gfunkadunk22 11 months ago
@Gfunkadunk22 Yes there are many many arabs in Israel but do they sure equal rights in the society? There are Palestinian villiges that have no water supply, no proper roads and no access to education and health services. Israeli government also asked PA to recognize Israel as a Jewish state, but what about people in Israel that are not Jewish?
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 As I said before the Arabs in Israel don't always get equal rights defacto. It is not a descision by the State rather a situation that is caused because they see themselves as Palestinians and see Israel as enemy.
The "facts" about education, health etc. are just not true. They often get health services in Israel itself though a woman from tried to explode in a hospital in Israel where she got treatment. Israel wants to be recognised as a state for the Jewish people just as the...
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 ...cont...just as the Palestinians want to have a state for the Palestinian people.
The woman in my last reply was from Gaza.
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 Is it not a decision by the Israeli state? According to reports by Human Rights Watch, many Palestinians face severe systematic discrimination and are unable to live properly. They can be forced out of their lands, not given house building approvals and store licenses, and blocked from roads. Yes, there are people who get education and health care, such as people in cities like Nablus and Ramallah, but there are also people who live in minor villages for whom schools, hospitals...
ariel0785 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 ...cont... and other basic services is just too difficult to get to. Some have to walk 1.5 kilometers to get to the nearest - not service but - road.
As for the recognition of a Jewish state, I recommend you "Out of the Ashes: The Search for Jewish Identity in the Twenty-first Century” by Marc H Ellis, which illustrates how Israel differs from other nation states. The idea "Jewish" used on the state is very exclusive.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Judaism is both a religion and a nationality and I cannot understand from you why the Jewish people is not entitled for a state (not to mention that there are many states with a formal religion, but that is another issue).
The world (and many human rights organizations) are hypocrites. can you please tell me how many condemnations of Israel have been in the UN's human rights council since its establishment in 2006? (cont)
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Let me help you 32, that’s over 47% of the total condemnations. Do you really think that Israel is responsible for about half of the human rights violations in the world? I guess that you don’t have a problem that Libya which kills its own civilians by the thousands was heading that council until the world suddenly remembered that Ghadaffi is a brutal dictator (cont)
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Btw here is a list of Palestinian “civilians” killed in operation cast lead according to PCHR (Palestinian centre for human rights).
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@eyalalmog1 /watch?v=hmmulhoT48Q
eyalalmog1 11 months ago
@Gfunkadunk22 Correction: ..."share" equal rights...
I believe that most Israelis are tolerant but there are huge differences between the people and the state.
ariel0785 11 months ago
@ariel0785 Actually there is not much difference between the people and the state as Israel is a democracy, something that you don't find in Israel's enemies which you see as so right and pure victims
eyalalmog1 11 months ago