I bet half of you in here commenting on how beyonce is sounding horrible dont even know how to harmonize let alone sing. I'm actually majoring in musical performance and have been singing since I was 6 years. i believe josh and beyonce sounded beautifully together
@jeanneadele that has NOTHING to do with this. I wish to God ppl would stop bringing up gay issues on songs that are sooooo far from the issue. Who cares what they support. Beyonce supports gays b/c those are her biggest consumers. Just in case you didnt know.
These are two of my most favorite performers oddly enough, but Beyonce appears uncomfortable. Seems like there was little rehearsal. But josh can sing anything and it's ok.
This has got to be the worst duet of all time. I mean first Josh Groban did a much better job singing on the recording of it, and it seems like he doesn't want to sing this a duet, it is not like he is really trying.
@sailinsweetie135 how bout you stop hating. They are two differnt artist. One classical and the other R&B/Pop. You earn 20 grammys and then you can begin to critique people. That is all.
@sailinsweetie135 yeahhhhh remember she was in a group where she HAD to harmonize..... so what you're hearing that sounds off is that they have two COMPLETELY different voices and styles that don't mix :) don't hate
@sailinsweetie135 no offense. but don't tell people what to do unless you know better. any real musician can tell that its a mixing error. not bad harmonies. they've got her high end higher than josh's and she's set louder than he is. its not her fault.
@sailinsweetie135 I'd imagine harmonizing with a voice as amazing and beautiful as Josh's is probably quite difficult. Nothing against Beyonce, though. There are at least a few possibilities for why that sounded the way it did.
To all the HATERS saying that Beyonce voice doesn't go well or she doesn't believe in the song---how odd of a comment?!--you can't compare the two!!! Common sense. Overall, their voices blended beautifully. The irony of writing this is I don't usually like Beyonce but I had to say something to all those hating...I know good singing when I hear it ;)
@rater1000 we aren't saying she is a bad singer, we are just saying that josh is better lol he needs some who is as good as him... like celine dion! see now thats a good pair :)
I think the performance would have been a little better if Beyonce didn't add virbrato to every note she was singing. They both have great voices but I think it would have sounded better with Josh singing it solo.
Beyonce should not sing meaningful Christmas songs with amazing singers like Josh Groban. She sounds to poppy. She's obviouslyy a really good singer but... they're too different to make this sound good.
The only thing I don't like is how much they had to lower the song's key for it to suit Beyonce. When Josh sings it by himself, it's higher and you can hear him struggle a bit with the lowness in the beginning (0:26 ish). Other than that, it's okay. :/
Fantastic duet. You can't compare Groban's voice with Beyonce, so you technically can't say that one is better than the other, as both of their vocals were stunning.
@liljayfludd Dramatic - used of a singer or singing voice that is marked by power and expressiveness and a histrionic or theatrical style. Meaningful - having a meaning or purpose. :P
@sasukeluvr198 That little school session doesnt change anything I just said! Theres always a meaning behind being dramatic. And beyonce is a professional! Im sure she taps into every song and word she sings, thats why she is as big as she is! We're not about to sit here and discuss is she feels the music when she sings it, no one knows that but her...so why even put an ignorant comment like you did? Makes no sense
ouch please. Beyonce has incredible talent and a fabulous voice. Josh also has incredible talent and a fabulous voice. But together in this duet - NO. Their voices do not blend well in this performance. What were they thinking?
The emotions Beyonce gives off when she sings this song dont really compliment that of Josh Groban's. Dont get me wrong, I think Beyonce is great and has an amazing voice, but just not for this song.
Ag... please, Beyonce sounds beautiful so the jelousy has to end really otherwise she wouldn't the best selling artist she if she was so bad.What has she ever done everyone?
beyonces voice is too soft&sweet while josh's is too thick and dramatic.... both lacked a little of what the other had. They could have met halfway.... but they didn't :\
Beyonce ruined this. Not everything has to sound like her genre of music, and she killed it. She didn't capture the meaning of the song. I wish Josh just would have sang it by himself.
i think beyonce makes him sound like crap. His voice is wayy to heavy and her voice is smooth and well rounded. His is too abrasive with an intense vibrato
Beyonce sings it well, its just not her style... I agree with missanakin that they would be good separate. I can imagine Beyonce singing it in a higher key and prolly with more of an r&b beat behind it. She is talented and can make it work.... But I love Josh Groban for this song and think that he outshines Beyonce in this video
i don't know y, but i just like Beyonce (in spite of how annoying her voice is at times ) i love to her hear her sing, dance, speak. Beyonce is the artiste of the decade
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
alas...that was what i was going to say...he is a barititone/low to mid-tenor...and i think they have him singing either some high to mid bass notes...or he is sick.
hmmm...he sounds awfully nasaly? him, yeah...he does sound like he has a cold.
@F3ctom I completely agree, its like you can hear Josh's soul in it but its just words to Beyonce. They're both great singers too but this doesn't work. I love Josh!
coitada da beyonce nao chega nem aos pés do josh!
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk....
pedro2109877 5 days ago
Nossa, Vossa
É minha, tua e sua
pilboxers 5 days ago
BEAUTIFUL!
pilboxers 5 days ago
both were great...wow
raweeploy 1 week ago
THIS IS JUST ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL! I LOVE BEYONCE :-)
SuperGirlEbony 1 month ago
first time i heard this i just fell in love with them strait away,
sagala30 1 month ago
Her voice had become stronger with age:)
MRSVISHOUS2012 1 month ago
The perfect combination! =)
MaddieLace 1 month ago
Beyonce shouldve sang higher...
MakesMeSmile101 2 months ago
Been singing since I was 3, and this is a dynamic duo. Anyone who doesn't think so, your opinion is probably naive. Smh.
ohsnappitsCJ 2 months ago
I think it's just the tonal qualities. Beyonce's voice like.... pierces through Josh's. I think that's y she sounds like she's overpowering him IMO
Dragonx523 2 months ago
This song always gives me the chills :)
emie395 2 months ago
two powerful singers can't harmonize appropriately if their dynamics are executed at the same level
obstacleillusions 3 months ago
Josh should have sung with someone as ordinary as him in order to harmonize well. Don't blame it on Beyonce... She's too good to sing this song.
ikom35 3 months ago
thxxxxxxxxx
CMPxison 3 months ago
he doesnt need to duet with her. its sounds better with just him !
MollyMaGee06 3 months ago
@MollyMaGee06 I agree!
VolleyballQueen2016 3 months ago
@MollyMaGee06 yeah better without beyionce i want see josh singing naked
minttea1113 6 days ago
Yea guys if u hav a bass u cant hav a soprano it wont soynd right she had to go down to.an alto
allskulls100 4 months ago
I bet half of you in here commenting on how beyonce is sounding horrible dont even know how to harmonize let alone sing. I'm actually majoring in musical performance and have been singing since I was 6 years. i believe josh and beyonce sounded beautifully together
dannifan123 4 months ago
@dannifan123 we don't care
TheMskatie61 3 months ago
@TheMskatie61 if you dont care then why did you reply? Get a life!
dannifan123 3 months ago
i love josh, beyonce in this song, not so much...
nikimcn 4 months ago
Meh. I wouldn't say she's bad here, their voices just don't blend together.
drakkis 4 months ago
@drakkis
yes !! I think the same
kern110 4 months ago
love the song!!! but WITHOUT beyonce for christ sake!!!!!
MrKratos07 4 months ago
@MrKratos07 oh shut the fuck up you old fart!!!
Beyoncefan1000 3 months ago
@Beyoncefan1000 wahahahahahahaha.. BEYONCE SUCK!!! you old hag!!
MrKratos07 1 month ago
Wow pretty rude to Beyonce, let her sing as she wants, your not her parents o.x..
TheUnicornCookies 4 months ago
God, Beyonce, it's not a contest. Chill the fuck out and read up on that whole "blending" thing.
cmurphy2826 4 months ago
@cmurphy2826 she was not trying to compete you idiotic dumbass!!! unlike you, she can blend!!!
Beyoncefan1000 3 months ago
perfect match sounds awesome
they are called jonsa
sarahconley24 5 months ago 2
Check out this amazing version by NADINE BEILER:
/watch?v=NhucJsSBd10
dcrated 5 months ago
ik,koop,nieuwe,kleding,ik,ga,meer,over,op,truien,jeans,chiquer,langer,niet,zo,mini,te,mini,wel,zwart,met,kleur,ook,colbers,weer,aan,op,jeans,wel,hakken,myn,leren,rok,kan,niet,altyd,alhoewel,ik,een,vrouw,zag,als,ik,met,black,glanslegging,myn,style,ze,was,eind,50,het,kan,ik,ben,ook,dat,type,ik,draag,al,jaren,met,pauzes,olivia,legging,grease,wat,vind,jy,ik,hoor,hier,niets,kant,heb,ik,gehad,niet,ordie,deze,zomer,,zomaar
mollysangelique 5 months ago
josh's voice is incredible
geezelleflora09 5 months ago
Dont know what some of you are talking about her pitch was fine.
rickraustin 5 months ago
Okay Beyonce did pretty good in the verses, but wtf is with her off-pitch harmony on the chorus?
Totally butchered Josh's original version =_=
lilxleftee 5 months ago
Beyonce totally ruined it.
snootzie78 6 months ago
@snootzie78 she didnt ruin anything!!! quit trying to find fault when there's absolutely nothing wrong with this performance!! you dumb bitch!
Beyoncefan1000 3 months ago
All these comments coming from people with no singing talent of their own
MrExplor80 7 months ago 10
@jeanneadele that has NOTHING to do with this. I wish to God ppl would stop bringing up gay issues on songs that are sooooo far from the issue. Who cares what they support. Beyonce supports gays b/c those are her biggest consumers. Just in case you didnt know.
dsmitty882010 8 months ago
my heart just melts everytime i hear his amazing voice
candysmiles11 8 months ago
two greats singers two believers in Christ!!!!!!!!!!XDDDDDDD
MegaSlashfan1 8 months ago
@MegaSlashfan1 yes! and at least one of them also supports gay marriage. :)
jeanneadele 8 months ago
shouldve got celine dion!
Dormaninth14 8 months ago
eh i have respect for both, josh has a wonderful voice as does beyonce
gerrykenneth88 8 months ago
say what you want, they BOTH have GREAT voices!!!!!!
ryback1340 9 months ago 2
Haha The Key Is SOOO Lowered So She Could Hit The Notes xD
Yeah 2 Totally Different Voices xP
XxXxMoMoStewxXxX 9 months ago
i think beyonce wants to jump his bones...but this song is really suited for josh...he has the gifted voice
princeofdarknessxyz1 10 months ago 22
@princeofdarknessxyz1 well i want jump his bones too
minttea1113 6 days ago
fail beyonce
groban's always fab though
2603rach 10 months ago
beyonce didn't put much emotion to this song
princeofdarknessxyz1 11 months ago
se fosse a sarah brightman
teria ficado lindooooooo
mas ficou muito bom!
nosnemreh 11 months ago
These are two of my most favorite performers oddly enough, but Beyonce appears uncomfortable. Seems like there was little rehearsal. But josh can sing anything and it's ok.
Macsdaug 1 year ago
Beyonce's style really doesn't work in this song IMO. Josh, though...amazing. Love Beyonce, but it's not the right song for her.
morgained4 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
beyonce is amaizing as allways
beyoncekaty1 1 year ago
beyonce is amaizin as allways
beyoncekaty1 1 year ago
dammn she sings this song like.. if she were reading a (boring) book..
marleyfernandes10 1 year ago 2
@marleyfernandes10 yeah my thoughts exactly
princeofdarknessxyz1 11 months ago
beyonce has a strong vibrato, maybe thats why some say she ruined this.
tasiawood 1 year ago
Both of them have amazing voices, but they are not good together, Josh's sounds much better singing this song
i still love Beyonce though :)
LuckyCharms8D 1 year ago
Josh has one of the greatest MALE voices in the WORLD
AND Beyonce has one of the GREATEST ANGEL voices in the WORLD
They were FANTASTIC in this video!!!!
MIKE59780 1 year ago
I can't stop staring at her right eyebrow. o-o I wish I can do that..
TheWhiteGarou 1 year ago
idk why people are saying that Beyonce ruined this!
I was nervous at first but I love this song and Beyonce
but Beyonce did amazing!!!
Josh didnt sing this alone cuz its hard to sing live,
I love both Josh and Beyonce <3
Enchantedsecret 1 year ago
This has got to be the worst duet of all time. I mean first Josh Groban did a much better job singing on the recording of it, and it seems like he doesn't want to sing this a duet, it is not like he is really trying.
staggmovie 1 year ago
It was the sound guy's fault. The melody always needs to predominate, but Beyoncé's volume (harmony) was up higher than Josh's.
artsong24 1 year ago
beyonce ruined this hard core
HHSScheer10 1 year ago
beyonce spoils it :(
harithdemel 1 year ago
haha chris rock
WadeShady182 1 year ago
I think Celine Dion would make a REALLY good match for this song.
CaledoniaSilver 1 year ago
its better when they aren't singing together.
josh groban alone : great.
beyonce alone: great.
together: not so great
moshergirl14 1 year ago 4
Um...NO Beyonce.
mmrkham 1 year ago
I really like this.
katlynmarie94 1 year ago
This is in a different key than the original isnt it?
valiantvyse 1 year ago
@valiantvyse yup, they moved it down a half step
265aman 1 year ago
@valiantvyse Correct
geak81 1 year ago
She ruined the song, and I can harmonize better then her... I STILL LOVE YOU JOSH!!!!!!!!!!!!
CrownPrincessSasha 1 year ago
Dear Beyonce,
Learn to harmonize.
Thanx a lot.
I appreciate it.
sailinsweetie135 1 year ago 27
@sailinsweetie135 how bout you stop hating. They are two differnt artist. One classical and the other R&B/Pop. You earn 20 grammys and then you can begin to critique people. That is all.
dsmitty882010 8 months ago 2
@sailinsweetie135 yeahhhhh remember she was in a group where she HAD to harmonize..... so what you're hearing that sounds off is that they have two COMPLETELY different voices and styles that don't mix :) don't hate
R34P3RSgf2258 4 months ago
@sailinsweetie135 no offense. but don't tell people what to do unless you know better. any real musician can tell that its a mixing error. not bad harmonies. they've got her high end higher than josh's and she's set louder than he is. its not her fault.
RedStainedPoet 3 months ago 3
@sailinsweetie135 dear sailinbitch, beyonce can harmonize, dont be a bitch, thanks
darkrainianX 3 months ago
@sailinsweetie135 go suck on a cold dick!!!
Beyoncefan1000 3 months ago
Comment removed
pbfanful 3 months ago
Comment removed
pbfanful 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@sailinsweetie135 I'd imagine harmonizing with a voice as amazing and beautiful as Josh's is probably quite difficult. Nothing against Beyonce, though. There are at least a few possibilities for why that sounded the way it did.
pbfanful 3 months ago
@sailinsweetie135 she was clearly in a singing group where they harmonized all the time.. do your research. she CAN harmonize.
Auggy08 5 days ago
To all the HATERS saying that Beyonce voice doesn't go well or she doesn't believe in the song---how odd of a comment?!--you can't compare the two!!! Common sense. Overall, their voices blended beautifully. The irony of writing this is I don't usually like Beyonce but I had to say something to all those hating...I know good singing when I hear it ;)
rater1000 1 year ago
@rater1000 we aren't saying she is a bad singer, we are just saying that josh is better lol he needs some who is as good as him... like celine dion! see now thats a good pair :)
CrownPrincessSasha 1 year ago
they both did great jobs bravo :)
chrmdanglgrl 1 year ago
I think the performance would have been a little better if Beyonce didn't add virbrato to every note she was singing. They both have great voices but I think it would have sounded better with Josh singing it solo.
MiamiChicky 1 year ago
@MiamiChicky Especially all the trills that weren't needed.
bluebelt224 1 year ago
I love this song and the singers.. I think their voices just blend perfectly.. :)
labsciescorned 1 year ago
Beyonce should not sing meaningful Christmas songs with amazing singers like Josh Groban. She sounds to poppy. She's obviouslyy a really good singer but... they're too different to make this sound good.
dehottie11 1 year ago 4
not to bad :D lolz its ight even though beyonce didnt match right in that music
Maravilloso232 1 year ago
The only thing I don't like is how much they had to lower the song's key for it to suit Beyonce. When Josh sings it by himself, it's higher and you can hear him struggle a bit with the lowness in the beginning (0:26 ish). Other than that, it's okay. :/
dorkomatic318 1 year ago
Fantastic duet. You can't compare Groban's voice with Beyonce, so you technically can't say that one is better than the other, as both of their vocals were stunning.
RiotNoobs 1 year ago
Josh is way better than Beyonce, that's just my opinion.
OhMyGodSushiRoll 1 year ago
I think they sounded great together. Very nice!
simplysingin 1 year ago
Josh could've done without Beyonce. . . He is great !
klare559 1 year ago 2
This sounds awful. Two different singers!
ryguy8098 1 year ago
thumbs up if beyonce looks like an angelic mermaid :D
Lol. Anyways, I love this song! Esp the way they sing it :D
TheMusicalAmbition 1 year ago 2
I am sorry the two of them together is not cuting it
ANderson403 1 year ago
sounds like a disney song you see on the movies. Its actually really good. If u know what im saying
sepmidget777 1 year ago
Its funny how people saying that beyonce's not singing with meaning! WHEN SHES THE MOST DRAMATIC SINGER I HAVE EVER SEEN!
liljayfludd 1 year ago
@liljayfludd Dramatic isn't meaningful
sasukeluvr198 1 year ago
@sasukeluvr198 Ive never met anyone whos dramatic without meaning. Stop being a smartass.
liljayfludd 1 year ago
@liljayfludd Dramatic - used of a singer or singing voice that is marked by power and expressiveness and a histrionic or theatrical style. Meaningful - having a meaning or purpose. :P
sasukeluvr198 1 year ago
@sasukeluvr198 That little school session doesnt change anything I just said! Theres always a meaning behind being dramatic. And beyonce is a professional! Im sure she taps into every song and word she sings, thats why she is as big as she is! We're not about to sit here and discuss is she feels the music when she sings it, no one knows that but her...so why even put an ignorant comment like you did? Makes no sense
liljayfludd 1 year ago
i wish he sang alone or with Celine dion!!! Beyonce killed it, she didnt capture the meaning of the song
puertorico199112 1 year ago
@puertorico199112 oh please! Celine is great! But beyonce did this song justice!
liljayfludd 1 year ago 2
beyonce has a great voice, but this type of song dont match her, instead of her they should of put Celine Dion,now she has an AMAZING voice!!!!!!!!!!
puertorico199112 1 year ago 3
BEYONCÉ HAVE A BEAUTIFUL VOICE, PERFECT VIDEO!
Alinecpc 1 year ago
ouch please. Beyonce has incredible talent and a fabulous voice. Josh also has incredible talent and a fabulous voice. But together in this duet - NO. Their voices do not blend well in this performance. What were they thinking?
joelchummel 1 year ago 2
The emotions Beyonce gives off when she sings this song dont really compliment that of Josh Groban's. Dont get me wrong, I think Beyonce is great and has an amazing voice, but just not for this song.
wumeista4645 1 year ago
beyonce kinda killed this song its not her bhut it was still good though
Nezzi9RoCkAnGeL 1 year ago
Ag... please, Beyonce sounds beautiful so the jelousy has to end really otherwise she wouldn't the best selling artist she if she was so bad.What has she ever done everyone?
hazelro 1 year ago
beyonces voice is too soft&sweet while josh's is too thick and dramatic.... both lacked a little of what the other had. They could have met halfway.... but they didn't :\
AuditoryOssicle 1 year ago 2
Beyonce ruined this. Not everything has to sound like her genre of music, and she killed it. She didn't capture the meaning of the song. I wish Josh just would have sang it by himself.
RosesSontRouges 1 year ago
Love JOshhhhh...he's the best!!!
Saudyct 1 year ago
i think beyonce makes him sound like crap. His voice is wayy to heavy and her voice is smooth and well rounded. His is too abrasive with an intense vibrato
tallwonder 1 year ago
i love this song so much... when Beyonce doesnt sing it
ComedyKing28 1 year ago
Beyonce sings it well, its just not her style... I agree with missanakin that they would be good separate. I can imagine Beyonce singing it in a higher key and prolly with more of an r&b beat behind it. She is talented and can make it work.... But I love Josh Groban for this song and think that he outshines Beyonce in this video
gerbersbaby 1 year ago
I was PISSED!!! She totally ruined it for me. It's Josh's song, I don't know why they stuck her in there???
Shelby596 1 year ago
work bitch workkkkk!!
ceofreddyhollywood 1 year ago
That was pretty bad.
oriac1212 1 year ago
I feel this is not the type of music for beyonce....I dont feel it for beyonce no feeling from beyonce...Josh put his heart into hit...
mightyjoe911 1 year ago
@mightyjoe911 yes you right hi puts his heart here but out of tune!! yes is the singer here please!!!
jazzpopschool 1 year ago
awsome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SofiaPeaceLover 1 year ago
they sound good together
SluvsJ52948 1 year ago
god hes gorgous
missSINGINGISMYLIFE 1 year ago
GO JOSH GROBAN!!!!
BEYONCE DIE!
Badel888 1 year ago
mazing pair... Never heard Beyonce voice like it was at the begining and i loved it... I always Love Josh Groban
saydeesaurus 2 years ago 3
yes yes, this is Josh's song.. it didnt sound right together. Beyonce looked goregous tho!
peacexlovexMJ 2 years ago
I totally wasn't expecting this from Beyonce
mac13able 2 years ago 5
her hair is so beautiful
vicdematos 2 years ago 5
she's got a hell of a modofokin' voice !!
zinou022 2 years ago
Their voices don't really compliment each other in my opinion. They would be good separately though. Yay Josh!
missanakin 2 years ago 70
I agree!
jenberrybrown 2 years ago
This is Josh's song. Period. End of discussion.
:-P
mymusicalife 2 years ago 3
jay-z was watching his woman i need a chick like beyonce
A31319 2 years ago
go beyonce
A31319 2 years ago
She compliments this song very nicely and he's just amazing.
Kaitlynshh 2 years ago
i don't know y, but i just like Beyonce (in spite of how annoying her voice is at times ) i love to her hear her sing, dance, speak. Beyonce is the artiste of the decade
jspankin 2 years ago
♥ i love beyonce ♥
locoliomelenudo 3 years ago
i ♥ beyonce ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥ ♥
mint3mocha 3 years ago
They both sound pretty good to me.
disneychild4 3 years ago 2
i ♥ Beyonce
jollyrancherplz 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry but Beyonce outshines him..he struggles with those low notes, where as Beyonce's voice just flows
mjmendon 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
alas...that was what i was going to say...he is a barititone/low to mid-tenor...and i think they have him singing either some high to mid bass notes...or he is sick.
hmmm...he sounds awfully nasaly? him, yeah...he does sound like he has a cold.
brie5cheez5 3 years ago
Hey, if you ask me i think beyonce doesn't know what the song is singing about... Josh Groban means it, beyonce sings it
F3ctom 3 years ago 83
@F3ctom I completely agree, its like you can hear Josh's soul in it but its just words to Beyonce. They're both great singers too but this doesn't work. I love Josh!
bunnster16 1 year ago
@F3ctom agreed
peterdk11 1 year ago
@F3ctom thats an assumption. you could make that assumption maybe if you knew her. but most likely you dont so thats not really a fair judgement
kCmac141 1 year ago
He sounds perfect. It's originally that low. She just had to take it up a key or two.
Kaitlynshh 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
J Groban he sounds nasal and I don't like B vibrato sometimes is too much
simdisiwe 2 years ago
no it doesnt...dont you hear how much she struggles with her vibrato?...groban mastered this song
akwaffle 2 years ago 5