哭砂/张惠妹

[vivthegreat]

she sang this onstage with 黄莺莺 tonight (in Singapore) and it was so beautiful <3 so adorable seeing everyone's idol fangirling over her own idol!

[gemyang]

there will always be next one.

[sifng]

很好听

[0926133050]

嗐~~~很不懂 怎嚜那嚜喜歡比來比去

說誰唱的好 既然你喜歡聽原唱的 就去聽吧..

不要聽完阿妹唱的 就在那說原唱的好聽..

好聽就好啦 何必要比= =

那嚜無聊...

[jiero115]

一開始我還以為彈結他的是王傑

[saracsl]

阿妹靠的是实力，不是外貌~



[jimmy366527]

真正天后!!



[wunaide1]

听了几个版本的 还是阿妹的最好 ! 不愧是天后中的天后~~!!!!

[norva0001]

唱的很好,可是無法超越黃鶯鶯的版本....回憶是無法取代的

[Madagascar0229]

後繼無力阿.. 

[spacedoor]

唱得真好 美到不行.... 可為什麼我仍喜歡原唱呢?明明那樣完美

[lmwpassion]

awesome!!

[relationship223]

(天后)這個名詞...仍不足以形容張惠妹在華語歌壇的重要

[ajoe999]

我好愛阿妹 沒有一位歌手能讓我愛到15年 唯有張惠妹 !!!

[p25912197]

蔡依林...

天后  這才是天后

[Joelle2046]

@p25912197 這足以見的妹迷是比較理智的~方才我看了BAD BOY有人留言JOLIN好棒~可是沒有人去按什麼~FANS為­什麼那麼害怕別人批判她??一個藝人不就是公眾人物~誰都有權利­去發表感想~蔡依林FANS最愛在youtube說"如果是想來­批判就不要來看~"那怎麼現在在阿妹的歌這邊留言也要來參一腳?­??? 我們喜歡阿妹認同阿妹~所以我們只是感到不平~真正的天后不是只­有在舞蹈上琢磨~畢竟是歌手~不是舞者~

[scottxu]

录像跟声音根本毫无关系！不过喜欢这个版本超过黄莺莺的原版。

[scottxu]

录像跟声音根本毫无关系！

[mesukdeena]

ชอบเพลงนี้มาก

[starvvn]

聽到哭...

從小就愛她

會愛她到死

[198back]

PERFECT

[brzve1022]

我是阿妹超級粉絲

但讓我有流淚衝動的是黃鶯鶯的版本

但阿妹還是好讚XD

[brzve1022]

我是阿妹超級粉絲

但讓我有流淚衝動的是黃鶯鶯的版本

但阿還是好讚XD

[zealeliot]

38歲 阿妹蠻早出道的 到現在13年了吧 經典歌太多了

星光大道當然常聽到

[MegaBleachy]

阿妹到底几岁啊！？我不认识她时，以为她很老呢，因为她出了蛮多­的唱片，对吧？在星光大道，好多首都是她的歌呢。。。！

[Mrlightoller]

Amei的哭砂太有技巧了



[ajoe999]

我喜歡阿妹版本 尾音會勾人魂魄

[whymistake]

各有特色~~

但~~我喜歡Mei的版本XD~~

[aidsaids1542]

黃鶯鶯的才好聽。

[0989481125]

第一次在車上掉眼淚就是這首歌...那時候跟女友見面分手 就在回家的路上聽到廣播撥了這首歌.....我ㄒ.ㄒ.....­...

唉年少無知..珍惜好身邊的人阿~~

[TheHappyending99]

黃鶯鶯版本的配樂比較好,阿妹的唱功比較強,黃鶯鶯則是味道比較­足!

[m45588201118]

雖然阿妹的版本很棒~但還是黃鶯鶯的比較有味道,經典還是很難超­越的!!

就像是阿妹經典的歌別人也很難超越一樣~

[wly0471]

@m45588201118 +1  黃鶯鶯的比較好聽

但呼吸聲太大了

[bliz85]

The subtitle is wrong: 还 should be 海.

The interesting thing though, is that these two words are homophones (when sung, the tones are similar. when spoken they have different tones) and 还对你是那么难分难舍 seems grammatically correct, though 还是对你那么难分难舍 is probably more correct.

[bliz85]

@bliz85 edit: *when sung in this particular song to suit the tune.

[ajoe999]

阿妹的版本

唱的好

尾音的續航力滾滾而來

充分顯示她實力非凡

[playerof604]

好聽

但音質好差

[KIT7732KIT]

好聽 ... 

[usami0904]

我覺得別聽慣了誰的版本就失去了接納別人唱法的能力，幾個在那邊­唱的差遠了甚麼的......聽歌 就是唱到點就是有味道，在那邊隨意批判，我倒覺得這個版本比較慢­，也柔和了點...還不錯，包容力大點吧...

[LaCelestia]

還是林志炫唱得好。

[SHDC1234]

比黄莺莺差远了，声音没有张力

[unbelivable0256]

同意樓上大大說的~這個版本真的是最讚的!

[humandancer]

unique voice:) emotional performance! love Zhang Huimei Forever!

[rgb555]

A-Mei is AWESOME! Love her stylish and unique performance!

[robert8251]

虽然视频不对，不过听了还是让人心碎。还是这个版本最好。

[Chingwuuu]

沒錯

這條片段跟本不是在唱哭砂

有點瞎

[smoothwillie]

@Chingwuuu 妳才瞎哩, Chingwuuu...明明就不是難聽的, 故意要唱反調...

[taijeime]

她應該早點起床吊嗓子.

[gdgdboyz]

能爆发能细腻的歌手..所以才会红那么旧=）

[jhu11]

who is this song originally by?

[716549]

黃鶯鶯

[rgb555]

A terrific performance!

[zjdoudou]

每次听都能体会不同的感动。

[zjdoudou]

真的好美。

[sarchang1]

這條片斷跟本不是在唱哭砂吧~

[shue4175]

my idol of all time.. her vocal is the most powerful i ever seen in asian..

[ufo717212]

@shue4175 search "phoenix legend". You might change your viewpoint

[2006jingway]

這個真的是經典.我每次聽都忍不住讚嘆~~

[whsia]

真是唱得很棒.如果錄影能和她的歌配合那就更棒了.

[ivanlaukl123]

this is ready a good song, a mei sing this with too touching to me.. till i feel i want to cry.

[kinnicky]

真的很難找到一個女歌手和張惠妹相比...

太完美。。太感動了

[catcat2110]

始終都係黃鶯鶯唱得最好聽, 最動人心魄!

[dish19832001]

超级好听

[wakin618]

不知道a-mei 算是算是华语乐坛30年才能出一个的歌手。至少李宗盛认为她是华­语乐坛最后一个天后。

[tigertaitai]

寂靜夜裡

聽到這麼一首熟悉的歌曲

是很容易地讓人

眼眶出汗

[lin1984ii]

聽著聽著..........淚就流出來了

[MsNewfish]

@lin1984ii 不哭，不哭～

[ajoe999]

唱的真好 尤其是尾音及低音的轉音處裡的真棒!!!

[slonm1]

this song is ok

[crossfig]

唱的真好，最好的版本！

[arvinhokc]

One of the best songs in the world.. Whoever wrote the song, is really great. My heart is crying ,whenever  I hear this song.

[wallismcfadden]

亚洲最棒张惠妹！！！

LOVE U 4ever ...

[Joows]

经过磨练，唱出自己。。。

阿妹加油！很棒！

[taijicheng]

i love her version too

[77446633]

他真ㄉ狠戾還!

超級巨星!

台灣之光!!!!!!!!!!!

[angelajuicy]

You must be insane,who said that she doesnt have fans in China?! I'm Chinese and a big fan of her. I know quite a lot people fancy on her in China,dun say something so childish, respect people who work so hard on their career,惠妹 have been singing for more than 10 years..such an experienced singer OMG bring your brain with you~ I bet u cannot sing imaginaryboy~ha

[downinflames01]

if she doesn't have fans in China, i don't know why her CD sales in China is like.. omg?

[alias91919]

you're such a dick. arrogant piece of shit. the only thing you dirty whores are good at is producing poisonous food.

[yawenalice]

he may be a dick, but you just offended everyone else... now ur the dick.

[77446633]

比原唱好!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[bubunehneh]

i love this song so mcuh... but is it ah mei is the original song? cos i heard the sally yap also sing this song...

[hyseik]

黃鶯鶯 is the original singer

[tyz228]

wow. i love liu fang's version of this song...but ...well, this is A-MEI!!!!!!!. she is so good.

[cdy1234567]

如果不看视频，只听声音，很美很美。

只是这个视频和这首歌似乎十分不协调。

[lincolnl16]

編曲很棒

[wenggor]

very beautiful version of already very beautiful song

[peteraucs]

This is the best interpretation of this song I have heard !

[SweetSista]

who is the original singer of this song?

[kevin270979]

黃鶯鶯,but i love the interpretation most.

[0980366649]

great sound

[laoshuboluo]

我喜欢阿妹现在的唱法和声音！！

[jta0123]

Me too!