Added: 3 years ago
From: 000fifi
Views: 156,960
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (379)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I have heard Neil Diamond's version, Glee's version but David Archuleta's version blows them all away.

  • puck's version is THE BEST,.!THUMBS UP SO THAT VIEWERS CAN SEE THIS! XD

  • Like if you've been in love with this guy since Star Search. The day David was voted off star search was the last day I ever watched that show. I cried. God, that was years and years ago. I had a mini seizure when he showed up on Am Idol.

    PS- like if you hear this cause you're a hockey fan (;

  • David is awesome and should have been American Idol winner.

  • haha I don't like him at all

    gag reflex.

  • poor Neil...

  • Oh my... :O...<3

  • Wow, this is the best version I've heard. DAVID ARCHULETA HAS A VOICE!

  • David Archuleta. <3

  • SWEET! ARCHULETA ROCKS!

  • Whooo Hoooo. My name's Caroline :)

  • ommgosh ilove david archuleta.♥

  • Comment removed

  • iuuuk so bad

  • @posetionxxxjonas really bitch, really?

  • @lettuce2O11 Really bitch

  • @posetionxxxjonas well..."jonas" LOOL.

  • @LacuteMonkey Me too!!! My fave song<3 (:

  • his good

    

  • David has a nice voice for a young singer. He might want to consider singing other classic "pop rock" songs to get a real influence on songs of the 1970's and 80's. Since remake off the original Neil Diamond song. :)

  • neil diamond's version is by far the best. there is nothing compared to the originals

  • @ashtonlove09 nowadays, you can find ppl making better cover than the originals. you're just in denial. not that the original version of the song suck, but it is old fashion.

    i see ppl sing katy perry songs better than her, and a lot more other artists too.

  • i liked this version but I think Neil's version is better

  • when puck sings it its much better

  • This song has been sang by like everyone- and actually as much as I like David- Elvis and Neil are wayyyy better for this. (elvis had his own version and Neil was the orig. singer)

  • Ridiculus

  • My name is Caroline- and I have officially became obsessed with this song. Especially the glee version.

    :)

  • One thing I don't like about this song is instead of the note being this long -- it's like this long ------- get what I'm saying? He's a good singer, but I think that some of the notes are too long.

  • I don't like this...its whack, his voice drags too much...where's the subtle but sexy tone?

  • He's nothing compared to puck. Thumbs up if you agree

  • <3 love it so much., 

  • @SteelersGirl1985, keep your thoughts to yourself :)

    if you dont like david archuleta, then why waste your time watching/commenting on his videos?

  • @shbsoftball28 umm, did you happen to read my previous post from a month ago?.. calm down killer..

  • jajaja mejor que los jonas! canta esta cancion muuucho mejor q los Jonas brothers jajaaa wao! cuando escuche a los jonas ay no! todo desubicado! gritaban no cantaban!no no! encambio escucho la voz de mi amado David y recien pude apreciar la dulsura de esta cancion =)

  • Neil diamond is way better

  • This is with the Glee one the best version.

  • better than jonas bros..!!

  • I used to love this version.. but when I heard the Glee version I fell in love with it.. But.. I love you David <3

  • LOVE LOV LOVEIT BUT JONAS IS STILL ON TOP!!!!!!!!! never ever better than jb anyone!!!! not possible!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • @xoDxo123 what does this have to do with JB? 

  • @awritingstory thy have a version of this song 2... haha its sooooo good!!! <333333

  • i felt like he was staring at me it was freaking me out

  • best version ive heard so far

  • his voice is so smoooth

  • @daydreamsforever Like warmed butter compared to that jonas bros crap! Clearly this kids got talent & potential whereas WTF were producers thinking marketing those other 3 children with undisciplined voices.

  • this kind of reviving songs will keep the beautiful songs alive... a new era of music should began and that is reviving the good lyrics of before. Innovations can be done to catch the taste of the modern youth!

  • @wwffredwayne

    What I'm dreading is the day that some kid comes up to me thinking that Archuleta WROTE this song.

  • @Haelis so what if they do? This is an excellent rendition.

  • @blkwhtrbbtX How WELL this song is done is not the point. He does just dandy as a singer o.o

    But I mean, what if you made some great song that everyone loves, then 30 years later people don't even remember you made it? It'd be like a Beatles cover band being more popular than the Beatles. An Elvis impersonator being more popular than Elvis. Yeah, Archuleta is a good singer, but let's not give him credit that isn't his.

  • @Haelis That's fair, and I totally agree. Haha, I thought you were one of those Archuleta haters at first, and thought I'd aggravate you a little. I really did not expect such a reasonable response.

  • @blkwhtrbbtX Lolz. You find pockets of not-crazy people like you and me from time to time on Youtube.

  • Can't anybody just sing a song without adding all this "ooohhh aaaa" crap? god

  • @fromdaburgh07 Of course you can, we will be happy to watch your post. (",)

  • good, but only neil diamond sings sweet caroline .oh.oh.oh.so good.

  • I loved it in Glee :)

  • david rulezz

  • David he has a gr8 VOICE!!!!!!!!! sweet caroline

  • sucks cock

  • Neil Diamond did the best...just putting that out there.

  • @SamuraiKosto wow, it's just a cover, just type in neil diamond or something instead of david lol

  • @SamuraiKosto what a hater. Was that really necessary? that achieved nothing, and left a bad mark on your name. It was a great cover of a great song.

  • fuck this poser. neil diamond is the true god of this song

  • caroline is like the luckiest nameee pretty much everyone sang this :| my sister is a caroline lol <3 uu

  • happy new york

  • my song :)

  • omg this is a horrible remix.. it's a classic rock & roll song and gay david made it into pop?.. ughh.. some songs just should NOT be remixed.. this is terrible!..

  • @SteelersGirl1985 Why does everyone compare it to the original? The point of American Idol is that each contestant uses prewritten songs to explore their tastes as an artist. I heard this one before I listened to the original, there is NOTHING wrong with it. Different ≠ bad. As for the homophobic remark there, hater, off of what do you justify your accusations? if leaving adolescence means that I'll turn into a tasteless, accusatory, hating jerk, then I should stop looking forward to it.

  • @SteelersGirl1985 I just listened to the Neil version. It isn't even that different! This one has a more upbeat tempo and a more orchestral sound, but that's IT! If you're going to hate, at least be reasonable about it.

  • @blkwhtrbbtX haha, not that different?.. what are you, deaf?.. the only thing that's the same are the words!..

  • @SteelersGirl1985 It's a little faster. It's a little more childishly cheerful. It does sound less nostalgic. It does sound like a passionless cover of another's work. But past that, I don't think he deviated that much from the original. So this version is a little different. How does that make it terrible? I think the brass accompaniment was a nice touch. I think the vocals were great. I honestly doubt he's gay. If I am proven wrong(by canon), you have full rights to rub it in my face.

  • @blkwhtrbbtX i think the reason why i can't listen to anyone else's version of sweet caroline is b/c it was my dad's karaoke song.. we sang it at his funeral at the cemetery, etc.. it's just a classic song by neil diamond that will always stay in my heart b/c of my dad..

  • By the way, apologies for the nasty tone I adopted posting earlier. I suppose that was a little more than slightly over the line.

  • Everyone PLEASE VOTE for David ARchuleta in this years 2010 TEEN CHOICE AWARDS!! he is nominated for American Idol ALUM & Fanatic Fans! It is tough competition this year, so PLEASE VOTE EVERYDAY & TELL OTHERS TOO! Let's do it for david! :D EVERY VOTE COUNTS!! <3

  • song about me!!! :D

  • @KVkarro me too!

  • I LOVE THIS SONG !!! and the bast part is that my name is CAROLINE !!! ^.-

  • His version is so sweet... I can't help but smile as I listened!! :)

  • He Sang it well but i Love the way Puck well Mark Salling sang it

  • -OhMyGosh!, I Absolutely Love This One Out Of All The Rest!! This Is Like My Favorite Song Ha And Its Weird Cuz My Name Is Caroline Haha I Love David! <33

  • David Archuleta should be on Glee!!:)

  • i would love to hear this than glee version..no offense but david's voice is sweet, soft and beautiful in this song..

  • I prefer glee's version!!

  • david archuleta, der kam doch mal bei iCarly. der is voll gut :D

  • epppp my name!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • excellent version

  • OH MY GOD!

    i can't believe i never saw this!

  • victor wood's version is much greater! search it!

  • omG hes singing a song with my name its so exciting!!!!

  • @LacuteMonkey not really. my sister's name is caroline

  • i like it but pucks version was so much better

  • eccchhhk, get your hands off this song whiney monkey child. Same with glee, this is one song that i can't stand to be modernized or redone.

  • his voice floats through this song. Too well. A bit of a shame to the original... he is a great singer tho... just wrong song for him.

  • wow his voice is soooo powerful, and soulful.

  • sounds like hes got a cock in his mouth...

  • best song EVER check my usrname

  • wow...this is epic fail :( He's trying to hard to sing a simple song.

  • Glee version rocks harder than ever!

  • I LOVE your music and I LOVE Sweet Caroline because my name is Caroline.

  • Red Sox song

  • i love the song

  • his voice is too smooth for this song.... but he still is very good

  • a faggy version of the original one : /

  • I like puck better, but this one's good cuz its the whole song.

  • has a nice beat to it but there's nothing like the original

  • this version is awesome!!!congratz david!!!:)

  • super!

  • Execellent!

  • puck did better but credits to david he did very good :)

  • puck from glee is better

  • dieser song ist der schönste song von David Archuletar

  • i like this version but Puck ftw :)

  • He can sing,and done a pretty good version

  • his voice is too faggoty and preppy for this song.

    you need a guy with a deeper voice. like a tenor. or wait...MAYBE THE GUY THAT ORIGINALLY WROTE THE SONG.

    YOU WILL NEVER COME CLOSE!

    STOP TRYING TO DO STUFF BETTER THAN OTHER PEOPLE! ITS NOT WORKING!

  • @thespiffman

    How DUMB is your comment - David wasn't trying to "do it better" - just getting the sheer joy of doing a Legend's legendary song, what have you done lately besides being a couch critic??? manohmighty

  • @thespiffman No offense, but you're a fucking idiot. A tenor is the highest adult male voice. God, all these idiots on youtube...such a tragedy...

  • ..better than jonas brothers

  • @lovingiswhatigot  way better !

  • He is too good for everything haha

  • Yeaaaah he was on icarly!

  • david was on icarly!

  • Je m'appel Caroline ! ♥

  • glee! this version is far to theatrical!

  • David's and Glee's versions are both good but David's version is rather creative while the Glee's is just kinda copy-cat.

    Love both though :D

  • @Zhen99 Glee is a copycat agreed but however Puck pointed out that the orignal artist was Jewish and he was singing to Rachel to prove something What I do not remember.

  • he was proving that he could sing alone on the stage cuz that's what Rachel said she liked about the other guy (forgot his name)

  • @Zhen99 oh yeahh I remember that. I think its the guy that got that girl pregnant. Yeah sorry I don't watch Glee much but thats on my list of things to watch when I get my computer back. The order of things I need to watch online is BONES, JAG, HOUSE and now GLEE.

  • Neil Diamond has the best version !

  • @ZKJonathan i beg to differ puck dose

  • Sorry, but I prefer the glee version :)

  • David's version is my absolute favourite of any of the vesions there are. the Glee version is pretty good, but David is the best singer ever, sooo..... You know. :D

  • @hplotrpotcfanatic You are such a fag. Neil all the way baby.

  • @hplotrpotcfanatic Still can't beat our marching band version, but this is amazing. lol

  • This is better then Neil Diamonds Verison. Because Neil's voice is rough and this type of song needs a soft voice like David's.

  • OMJ great. I love the original the JB and this version. They're amazing. I'm adding this to my MP3 Player.

  • better than the jonas bros ...but not better than puck's ...

  • Pretty good.

  • I love David Archuleta, but I have to admit, the version from "gLee" is better than this one. I still love this version, of course. :)

  • I agree. I think Mark Salling's version is amazing, but I love David's too:)

  • i think The Glee version is the best one

  • Puck's voice fits the song perfectly. Not to mention he's a hot singer. :)

  • Agreed.

  • have to agree with you there

  • i blame my mom for getting me hooked on this song. its so good! uplifting to!

  • i love David Archuleta

  • hey! he isnt ugly

  • haha my sisters think he's so hot

  • his voice is lovely. but he lost that "classic" taste of the song which is what special about it. -> sweet voice, but not a good cover.

  • Glee sang this very well

  • i like this one i think its better than glee. different though

  • I agree. Puck slides his notes on "sweet" and it bothers me.

  • r u like annoying?

  • Lol it's always funny when people get mad about opinions of people they don't even know. ;-) Ease off a little. If you don't agree with me, tell me why and I'll be happy to listen.

  • @liljee

    im not annoyed with u. :)

  • I thought you were saying it to me. My bad.

  • Puck did VERY well will this song. Plus he looked really hot while doing it!

  • Glee is awesome and they sang it awesomely

  • This is very well sung, and listen to the orchestra!!!!!!!!!!! Rock from Montreal.

  • this was my papa's favorite song. i miss him so much

  • i love u song dis.u ultimately fame dis song

  • english plz

  • Puck is good, but David's good too.

  • wow am i the only one who agrees with u hear

  • Agreed

  • He is amazing!!!!! I LOVE HIM and have ever since his first American Idol audition. <33333333333333333333333333333­333333333333333333333333333333­333333333333333 But, I still love Glee too. :)

  • Haha, I agree.

  • canta ala altura de los grandes como Nield y Elvis....

  • IMO, David Archuleta sang this better. But I think the glee version still rocks! :D

  • he is so amazing. His voice is extremely pure and awesome. He just has that natural amazingnesssss to him. Sorry glee lovers but davids version is better but still big ups to puck or whateva his name is

  • damn.. thats was Amazing.

  • xoxo :]