You are supposed to play the first Shadow Hearts, let Alice die, play the second Shadow Hearts, and then play the first again, but this time, save Alice. That is how the story goes.
I think the I.D thing is true and ,that karin lossed her memories when she woke up in the past ... or maybe she still had her memories which means yuri's not russian and that's why he couldn't pronouns the russian letters ....wait either way he's not russian .I really think she lossed her memories . but were did she get the photo?
I think that's a simple loophole to overlook. My guess is that Karin probably lied about her heritage upon meeting Yuri's father. "My name is...Anne. I'm from Petrograd in Russia. I don't know how I got here". There's a part in the game where Yuri failed to correctly pronounce any Russian letters correctly whatsoever, and Anastasia had to correct him. I think this may have been a hint from the game developers that Yuri is not Russian. She probably lied to keep the flow of events needed true.
@JayViewer Actually, Karin propably had her fake Russian ID with her. Anastasia gives her a fake ID at one point, and Karin says "Anne?" to which Yuri replies "Anne was my mom's name." Anastasia said something about it being easier for them to travel if they hid the fact that Karin was German. So she had a Russian ID with the fake name 'Anne'.
hmm there are a few problems with the thought that Karin is Yuri's mother, for the fact that in "Shadow hearts I" it states that Anne was Russian but in "Shadow hearts II" it clearly states that Karin is German... not to sure bout the whole making ends meet idea but hayy maybe karin was a russian decendant on her farthers side????
it actually makes sense if Karin is Yuri's mother besides looking at the ending of SH II . In this picture you can look into Karin's eyes and see she's more motherly. I'm more a fan of Alice than Karin because Alice is more pure hearted and she kicks ass with a book! >:D
Alice and Karin don't seem very alike to me. Karin is actually Yuri's mother; when she appeared in Japan at the end, her memory was sketchy, so it would seem that she remembered just the "in" part of her name, or "en," depending on who you are, so calling herself "Anne," would make sense. Why marry Yuri's father? He was probably a lot like Yuri.
lol i know i thought about that and maybee when alice died a piece of her soul went to reside in karen ^ ^* a stretch i know but they really are so similar
well you are right, but you know what Karen's "destiny" is, so it would be kinda weird/disturbing if she possessed a part of the soul of Yuri's girfriend. Then again, with Japanese games, everything is possible ;-)
You are supposed to play the first Shadow Hearts, let Alice die, play the second Shadow Hearts, and then play the first again, but this time, save Alice. That is how the story goes.
RoxYou1990 1 week ago
SH2 was such a good game...minus the kiddiness of some parts
AnimechaX 10 months ago
thanks guys for spoiling xD
TuRnuAsian 1 year ago 3
@misterveriah I just thought that she was somewhat ugly and I think that Yuri can do alot better than her xD
SoraInsanity 1 year ago
I'm.. kinda glad that Alice died.....
SoraInsanity 1 year ago
@SoraInsanity you and me both..... i hated her with her stupid book that did bareley any damage....
misterveriah 1 year ago
@misterveriah Idiot, shes good for Healing people.
Reinko96 1 year ago
@Reinko96 yeah thats a good stat but what about attack and defence.... not good there.... and there are other people who heal just as good......
not tryin to start an argument but still........
and don't call me idiot.....
im actually fairly smart :)
misterveriah 1 year ago
@misterveriah Teehee, sorry xD
But yeah, she sucks at attacks and defense. But shes a great person in healing xD
Sorry again xD;
Reinko96 1 year ago
@Reinko96 lol its chill man i forgive you :)...
now i will heal you *ding*
misterveriah 1 year ago
@misterveriah Heehee, I am now cleanse xD
Reinko96 1 year ago
Comment removed
Reinko96 1 year ago
I think the I.D thing is true and ,that karin lossed her memories when she woke up in the past ... or maybe she still had her memories which means yuri's not russian and that's why he couldn't pronouns the russian letters ....wait either way he's not russian .I really think she lossed her memories . but were did she get the photo?
kitty221pink555 1 year ago
@kitty221pink555 Yuri's aunt gave her (Kurando's mom) but they never show until the end of the game (Go watch the walkthrough then ya remember)
Raymetrious 1 year ago
I think that's a simple loophole to overlook. My guess is that Karin probably lied about her heritage upon meeting Yuri's father. "My name is...Anne. I'm from Petrograd in Russia. I don't know how I got here". There's a part in the game where Yuri failed to correctly pronounce any Russian letters correctly whatsoever, and Anastasia had to correct him. I think this may have been a hint from the game developers that Yuri is not Russian. She probably lied to keep the flow of events needed true.
JayViewer 2 years ago
@JayViewer Actually, Karin propably had her fake Russian ID with her. Anastasia gives her a fake ID at one point, and Karin says "Anne?" to which Yuri replies "Anne was my mom's name." Anastasia said something about it being easier for them to travel if they hid the fact that Karin was German. So she had a Russian ID with the fake name 'Anne'.
Hapusuburugu 1 year ago
hmm there are a few problems with the thought that Karin is Yuri's mother, for the fact that in "Shadow hearts I" it states that Anne was Russian but in "Shadow hearts II" it clearly states that Karin is German... not to sure bout the whole making ends meet idea but hayy maybe karin was a russian decendant on her farthers side????
itsmejames12221 2 years ago
it actually makes sense if Karin is Yuri's mother besides looking at the ending of SH II . In this picture you can look into Karin's eyes and see she's more motherly. I'm more a fan of Alice than Karin because Alice is more pure hearted and she kicks ass with a book! >:D
hanna456 2 years ago
Alice and Karin don't seem very alike to me. Karin is actually Yuri's mother; when she appeared in Japan at the end, her memory was sketchy, so it would seem that she remembered just the "in" part of her name, or "en," depending on who you are, so calling herself "Anne," would make sense. Why marry Yuri's father? He was probably a lot like Yuri.
Themadisraeli 2 years ago
I totaly forgot about this game...beat Shadow hearts the new world last year it was alright...
Darkman1233 2 years ago
I love all SH games, Iv got the soundtrack to SH and really need to get SH2 as its my fav.
Grog3471 2 years ago 12
wish Alice was alive in SH II D=
OneWingedMenace 3 years ago 23
you know I still wonder if karen isn't a reborn alice... their soulds are very much alike
ShadowHeartsFlight07 2 years ago
Karen is just as old as Alice, so that would be tricky :)
DeLachendeWolf 2 years ago
lol i know i thought about that and maybee when alice died a piece of her soul went to reside in karen ^ ^* a stretch i know but they really are so similar
ShadowHeartsFlight07 2 years ago
well you are right, but you know what Karen's "destiny" is, so it would be kinda weird/disturbing if she possessed a part of the soul of Yuri's girfriend. Then again, with Japanese games, everything is possible ;-)
DeLachendeWolf 2 years ago
well i still haven't finished the game so... I think it might be weird but not disturbing really..
ShadowHeartsFlight07 2 years ago
Actually, Karin is closer to Yuri's age then Alice's.
Summonearth 2 years ago
@OneWingedMenace she is but only for a brief moment. :]
ThreeWickedWonders 1 year ago
@OneWingedMenace she is alive it basically restarts
kinslayer037 9 months ago