Not a regular visitor to You Tube but I've seen this video and another one of yours. The other being a cover of Brant and Larry's "I Don't Mind Mind At All". I'm not entirely sure what ppauly meant by "very americanized" given that (a), it isn't, and (b), Brent and Larry were both American anyway! I'm Manx/British so apologies if I should already know of you, but do you just keep to You Tube or do you have a recording contract? Cheers, Andrew.
@rstretch100 Honestly there's not much to see. My right doesn't move enough to pick out the finger/string relationship. However, have a look at the tutorial video - you might pick up some hints there.
Oh thank you so much for this excellent tutorial! My best friend and guitar partner died in his sleep this week. We were planning on working this song up when he got back from a business trip, and I knew it had to be the song I did for his memorial (which will be his friends gathering to play and sing and share stories) Thank you for helping me do this song, that was so special to us both, for him. I can't tell you how much it means to me.
You started off by saying that I'm somehow unworthy of performing this song...
You don't comment on the playing, the singing, the arrangement, video quality, etc. You've said nothing to either encourage or help me improve the performance, in your eyes.
I hadn't seen or heard a single solo guitar version of this song that tried to capture the nuances of melody. I enjoyed the challenge. Obviously you didn't. Keep it at that, and lose the personal attack.
yeahhh, that's cool. constructive critisism is always welcome from most musicians, but just saying that he doesn't deserve the song isn't right. but yeah, whatever haha, shouldn't be something we get caught up about, just wanted to say what i said. take care man x
thanks for the lesson.i thought that was good enough,but to scroll the chord voicings at the end was pure genius.much appreciated,cant wait to get started
I love it man. Id been trying to learn it from this video for ages. Guide made things a lot easier :) only 16 but im getting the hang of it. And the ending is brilliant. Keep it up
I have to learn this song for a new band and I usually employ Youtube to help. I recognized your name immediately. I had a small trio in Gander in the early 90s with Jim Griffiths and Wayne St. Onge. Anyway, we shared the stage a few times. Sounds great!
Awesome cover of a brilliant song beautifully played! If I could learn to play this just half as good as you I would die a happy man, have you any news on the promised video tutorial? Thanks.
Now that we're through the holidays I believe I can take the time to do it. If I don't have it out by the end of the month, grab the torches and pitchforks...
WOW ! Your presentation has inspired me. I'm putting on a new set of strings and will shortly start hacking this song out as best I can. Thank you, Sir ! ! !
Hey man, your playing is awesome! Please, put up a tutorial for the song, as there is nothing useful out there! Please! Think a lot of people would appreciate it.
Great song, one of my favorites from Peter, I also am learning this by ear, I will post my video when I get it down, and we can compare notes, ;) anyway, awesome job, thats not an easy one to play and sing, so...Bravo mate!
Will or do you share the tab to this perfomance and if so where? It made my day to see how sweetly it was played. Bravo! How about a slowed down lesson?
Very, very cool. I'm trying to learn to play the song, and you've got it just nailed. Now if I can only play it like you've showed us all how....Thanks, man.
man im jealous. ive looked everwhere online to try to learn this song. the best tab i could find is shitty an complicated. can you let me know the chord progression? i cant figure it out by watching. i'd rele appreciate it.
very nice dude.. i have a request..can you slow it down and kinda do an instructional of how you are playing it? otehrs on u tube didnt sound as good as this
excellent I followed the tutorial now I can impress my friends at parties (especially girls funnily enough) well done .
rindulus 1 week ago
Great version
annabatarowicz 2 weeks ago
Great job picking! Never mind the few brain dead comments.
geonuine 1 month ago
also i think youve great diction in your singing!
MrSkeff 1 month ago
expert job!
MrSkeff 1 month ago
That's freakin' awesome my man! Thank you for sharing this. Love your arrangement!
MyBadzs 2 months ago
Warren, this is great. I watch this regularly but still not able to play it like you. Your tutorial is great too but I will bow to your skills.....
MrJoreilly12 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
You play like heaven and have a wonderful voice. What else could anybody ask?
MrMrEFE 4 months ago
You play like heaven and have a wonderful voice. What else could anybody ask?
MrMrEFE 4 months ago
do u know who wrote the guitar parts of the song in the original?? its quality!!
chrischapman67 4 months ago
Well that was just fantastic.
fatchuk812 4 months ago
FANTASTIC!!!!!!!
joeypalooza 5 months ago
damn good! man! this is my favorite song of Peter Gabriel
RollingRizla 5 months ago
Very nice job!
stinger139 5 months ago
Hi Warren, Thank-You for the tuitional! I've posted a version on here under jonnyshockwave. Great song!
jonnyshockwave 7 months ago
Beautifully done. Thanks for sharing that. Your voice and style reminded me of Bruce Cockburn for some reason.
phildwstuff 9 months ago
Of all the versions I could find, the arrangement on this one is, not only the nicest, but the most rhythmically faithful!
I'd also be interested in your finger-picking pattern! Pleasepleaseplease! ;)
PmpknEtr 10 months ago
Great arrangement, nice left hand!
Tchutney 11 months ago
@Tchutney Thanks!
saffronboots 10 months ago
great job
malone1230 11 months ago
@malone1230 Thank you.
saffronboots 10 months ago
Fantastic job! Beautiful guitar and singing. What an amazing song and words, eh?
moroccanroller 1 year ago
@moroccanroller I really like this tune although I think I got some of the words wrong...
saffronboots 10 months ago
Very Canadianized
73magpies 1 year ago 3
@73magpies Extra maple syrup!
saffronboots 10 months ago 8
very americanized
ppauly 1 year ago
@ppauly I'm Canadian. You know - colonial...
saffronboots 1 year ago 3
Not a regular visitor to You Tube but I've seen this video and another one of yours. The other being a cover of Brant and Larry's "I Don't Mind Mind At All". I'm not entirely sure what ppauly meant by "very americanized" given that (a), it isn't, and (b), Brent and Larry were both American anyway! I'm Manx/British so apologies if I should already know of you, but do you just keep to You Tube or do you have a recording contract? Cheers, Andrew.
TheManxFella 1 year ago
@TheManxFella I just play for shits and giggles. Nobody special.
saffronboots 10 months ago
@ppauly What do you mean by 'americanized'?
GMcarsMAN 11 months ago
Nice guitar!
digitalis7 1 year ago
@digitalis7 The instrument or the playing?
saffronboots 1 year ago
@digitalis7 The guitar playing naturally. Great arrangement. Great sound.
digitalis7 1 year ago
@digitalis7 Thanks.
saffronboots 10 months ago
Very very nice. Wish I could do that.
theapocilip 1 year ago
@theapocilip Practice.
saffronboots 1 year ago
@theapocilip Practice.
saffronboots 1 year ago
Very Nicely done!!!!
I've been trying to find a reasonably accurate tab forever, any tips?
robertbhlr 1 year ago
Awesome.
media88shuttle 1 year ago
Love your cover....going to check out the tutorial...thanks :)
msbilliejos 1 year ago
Great, any info about the finger picking ?
Kridremarc 1 year ago
It could be Thom Yorke playing Solsbury Hill here.. Ha....
Very good version, well done man.
mannekinjohn 1 year ago
@mannekinjohn Another Radiohead reference. Is it the slanty eyes?
saffronboots 1 year ago
Excellent! Wish I could play like that. Loved the finger picking parts.
doctormozo 1 year ago
Very very impressive!
DanBennetto 1 year ago
Excellent work. You have great taste in cover material and you do it well. Best wishes.
MrChrisFloyd1 1 year ago
why are sexy bald men with goatees always so damn good at guitar?
coltonexley 1 year ago
@coltonexley Because of a lack of need for hair product application, we have the extra time to practice...
saffronboots 1 year ago 7
Very nice interpretation... would have loved to seen your right hand picking though.
rstretch100 1 year ago
@rstretch100 Honestly there's not much to see. My right doesn't move enough to pick out the finger/string relationship. However, have a look at the tutorial video - you might pick up some hints there.
saffronboots 1 year ago
great job dude
Hockeyplaya21921 1 year ago
very nice saffronboots makes me want to learn how to play it!........ well played sounds great!
jfdomega 1 year ago
@jfdomega Just do it!
saffronboots 1 year ago
What a cool version, has anybody told you that you have long spindly fingers, that make playing this song look so easy.
gsf67 1 year ago
Respond to this video...
saffronboots 1 year ago
Great version with excellent playing
piguitar1 1 year ago
@piguitar1 Glad you liked it.
saffronboots 1 year ago
That was beautiful. Thank you.
SarahGemini11 1 year ago
@SarahGemini11 Thanks Sarah.
saffronboots 1 year ago
Oh thank you so much for this excellent tutorial! My best friend and guitar partner died in his sleep this week. We were planning on working this song up when he got back from a business trip, and I knew it had to be the song I did for his memorial (which will be his friends gathering to play and sing and share stories) Thank you for helping me do this song, that was so special to us both, for him. I can't tell you how much it means to me.
LisaCarrell 1 year ago
@LisaCarrell You're welcome Lisa. So sorry to hear about your loss.
saffronboots 1 year ago
That's just downright amazing man.
deltaechoromeo515 1 year ago
@deltaechoromeo515 I'm glad you enjoyed it.
saffronboots 1 year ago
What a marvelous cover. Cheers from Argentina mate, that was an inspiration!
Aberinkulas 1 year ago
Muchos gracias.
saffronboots 1 year ago
Really nice work, man! This song makes me want an acoustic
seeenrulez 1 year ago 2
Acoustic rulez. ;)
saffronboots 1 year ago
You have just made my day!
I have been trying to find an arrangement for this song for ages, thanks mate.
Shame there's no tab anywhere similar and as good as this.
10/10 from me.
Well done. :)
whitto69 1 year ago
Have a look through the tutorial if you're unsure of the chords I use. Cheers.
saffronboots 1 year ago
That's a nice piece of work. Thank you for sharing it with us.
robertjameswade 1 year ago
You've got the best guitar playing version of this song on youtube that I've seen!
Matt Calder has a good one, but you do the main riff way cooler and cleaner!
jessisastoner 1 year ago
WELL DONE!!!!!!!!
Nice work man!
tyboy63 1 year ago
Thanks tyboy.
saffronboots 1 year ago
Beautiful job! Keep up the good work!
DrewFaron 1 year ago
Thanks. I'll try.
saffronboots 1 year ago
you dont deserve that song dude
OldSteamer 1 year ago
Ha ha! Is something lost in translation here? "Deservin's got nothin' to do with it... boy."
saffronboots 1 year ago
@saffronboots
there are people who will understand that, if you dont have an open mind you dont understand it, if you have you will.
OldSteamer 1 year ago
Circular argument.
You started off by saying that I'm somehow unworthy of performing this song...
You don't comment on the playing, the singing, the arrangement, video quality, etc. You've said nothing to either encourage or help me improve the performance, in your eyes.
I hadn't seen or heard a single solo guitar version of this song that tried to capture the nuances of melody. I enjoyed the challenge. Obviously you didn't. Keep it at that, and lose the personal attack.
saffronboots 1 year ago
@OldSteamer
sorry, but if you had an open mind, you'd accept that this guy enjoys music and has just as much a right as anyone to play this...
MaxRunham 1 year ago
@MaxRunham
sry man but i just didnt like him,thats all.
OldSteamer 1 year ago
yeahhh, that's cool. constructive critisism is always welcome from most musicians, but just saying that he doesn't deserve the song isn't right. but yeah, whatever haha, shouldn't be something we get caught up about, just wanted to say what i said. take care man x
MaxRunham 1 year ago
thanks for the lesson.i thought that was good enough,but to scroll the chord voicings at the end was pure genius.much appreciated,cant wait to get started
jpgr1234 1 year ago
merci à toi ! bravo
sellig 1 year ago
De rien. Merci.
saffronboots 1 year ago
This is seriously awesome.
kpettway1 1 year ago
Glad you liked it.
saffronboots 1 year ago
I love it man. Id been trying to learn it from this video for ages. Guide made things a lot easier :) only 16 but im getting the hang of it. And the ending is brilliant. Keep it up
LexxRash 2 years ago
Keep practicing, and don't forget to post.
saffronboots 1 year ago
just Great!!!
As soon as i find time i will try your tutorial...
REally Great...my favourite tune of Peter Gabriel...really great!
Spauchi 2 years ago
Thanks Spauchi.
saffronboots 1 year ago
SEI IL MIGLIORE..... hello from italy
soluzioneshoum 2 years ago
Hi!
saffronboots 1 year ago
Do you know of a tab for this song thats right? I found one but it doesnt seem right to me. Great song nice job.
dorodini 2 years ago
I don't know of a tab BUT I have just posted a video tutorial that may help.
saffronboots 2 years ago
Hi Warren,
I have to learn this song for a new band and I usually employ Youtube to help. I recognized your name immediately. I had a small trio in Gander in the early 90s with Jim Griffiths and Wayne St. Onge. Anyway, we shared the stage a few times. Sounds great!
Jeff Scott
Saint John NB
jepower 2 years ago
Hi Jeff, great to hear from you. I remember a few bands kicking around especially on Gander Day! What was the name?
saffronboots 2 years ago
great song and natural playing!!
trivalentlogic 2 years ago
Thanks!
saffronboots 2 years ago
78,640 views so far !!! im probably responsible for half of them. You are that damn good. cant wait for the video tutorial.
sammyboy5150 2 years ago
Tutorial done and posted. If there's anything, in particular, I've missed please let me know.
saffronboots 2 years ago
couldn't have done better myself! just kidding. kudos, outstanding
kerryd48 2 years ago
Thanks.
saffronboots 2 years ago
Epic interpretation Sir! Very well done and thanks; it's a pleasure to listen to.
jamet77 2 years ago
I'm glad you enjoyed it.
saffronboots 2 years ago
nice
tkotan 2 years ago
Sweet!
saffronboots 2 years ago
wow..congratulation from italy
alynore 2 years ago
Grazie!
saffronboots 2 years ago
WOW. awesome man!
diggy75 2 years ago
Thanks man!
saffronboots 2 years ago
Awesome cover of a brilliant song beautifully played! If I could learn to play this just half as good as you I would die a happy man, have you any news on the promised video tutorial? Thanks.
numbskull675 2 years ago
Now that we're through the holidays I believe I can take the time to do it. If I don't have it out by the end of the month, grab the torches and pitchforks...
saffronboots 2 years ago
S-P-E-E-C-H-L-E-S-S!
solitudinarian 2 years ago
T-H-A-N-K-F-U-L
saffronboots 2 years ago
Hi saffronboots,
it is a great cover ! Fantastic guitar playing !
Happy New Year ! Cheers, Professor Matzko
ProfessorMatzko 2 years ago
Thanks Professor!
saffronboots 2 years ago
Lovely played!
docteurneo 2 years ago
Merci.
saffronboots 2 years ago
Sir, very nice work!
jimfan08 2 years ago
wow.....lovely version m8....any chance of posting the tab for that please?
alldaces 2 years ago
Thanks. I'll probably post a video tutorial shortly.
saffronboots 2 years ago
you could search ultimate guitar tabs archive for it
foxlove224 2 years ago
fantastic really
MillionM00 2 years ago
Thanks, really.
saffronboots 2 years ago
Also das ist echt genial!!! Habe bei dem Lied genau das selbe gänsehautfeeling wie beim original...
nein ... ich finde es noch besser als das original weil die gitarre hier viel differenzierter durchkommt .... Hut ab :)
maxo986 2 years ago
I'm glad you enjoyed this rendition. Danke.
saffronboots 2 years ago
no problem Mr. Gabriel ;-)
FuTiPi 2 years ago
yes great playing...germany
greetings
FuTiPi 2 years ago
Danke!
saffronboots 2 years ago
Good job! :)
newsong99 2 years ago
Thanks.
saffronboots 2 years ago
actually not bad
JohnnyDeppigX 2 years ago
Thanks Johnny. Love your films.
saffronboots 2 years ago
great playing 5 * from germany
1wiesehoefer1 2 years ago
Danke!
saffronboots 2 years ago
sweeeet
johndeererule 2 years ago
Thaaaanks!
saffronboots 2 years ago
WOW ! Your presentation has inspired me. I'm putting on a new set of strings and will shortly start hacking this song out as best I can. Thank you, Sir ! ! !
Sitarfixer 2 years ago
Get to work! And enjoy!
saffronboots 2 years ago
this is too legit to quit
Ljohanns 2 years ago
Ha ha! I can't touch this comment!
saffronboots 2 years ago
Very Nice ! The best 1 guitar version I've seen of this great song.
bwayneo9 2 years ago
Thank you sir.
saffronboots 2 years ago
amazing. and thanks, it's possible to see and learn the tabs that you're using.
lucasdoc7 2 years ago
Thanks. I didn't use any tab.
saffronboots 2 years ago
Well done ! Like that one
tremon19 2 years ago
Thank you.
saffronboots 2 years ago
that was awsome man
2ndwest 2 years ago
Glad you enjoyed it.
saffronboots 2 years ago
....bravissimo!!!! complimenti
gigiocommodors 2 years ago
Grazie!
saffronboots 2 years ago
awesome!!!!!
gaurang3dec 2 years ago
i hate you! i'm jealous man ..... awesome cover
aurchis13 2 years ago
the guitar sounds like an iron and wine cover
joosjoos 2 years ago
Wow, cool cover, very nice voice, love the 7/4.
olevrijenhoek 2 years ago
AWESOME MAN, SERIOUSLY INSPIRING!
roti7777 2 years ago
Very nice work. Thanks.
TwirlinMartha 2 years ago
You nailed it!... Thats what she said
Kianus2 2 years ago 2
omfg!!!! u dont have the prettest voice... but jesus.. ur an amaysing guitar player!!
lik3s2spoog3 2 years ago
he's got a great voice... great voice...
trisnjok 2 years ago 3
compared to his guitar playing... he seems like an amature.but good none the less.
lik3s2spoog3 2 years ago
SWEEEET !!! I always think music is best stripped down to 1 acoustic guitar and this is a fine example. Thank You Warren
souswee 2 years ago
Hey man, your playing is awesome! Please, put up a tutorial for the song, as there is nothing useful out there! Please! Think a lot of people would appreciate it.
cheers from Germany
Elvislady77 2 years ago
You know, now that I have the time, I might have to do that.
saffronboots 2 years ago
Great video man, this sort of stuff is the reason I want to learn guitar, cheers for inspiring me!
heyimjoe 2 years ago
Thanks for showing the left hand so clearly. I want to learn this and I'm crap at reading tabs. Great song & great playing!
paulmercy 2 years ago
great job man. Killer gutiar playing
unbourne666 2 years ago
Wonderful man.... Good job
bungamukhti 2 years ago
Just accoustic and voice. Just gorgeous. Didn't know anything could sound that good in the key of A.
OliveDec2007 2 years ago 2
good licks, just what I wanted , thanks man
TheCore1616 2 years ago
mate this is amazing! any chance of a lesson?
BrainSpecialist 2 years ago
very nicee brotha
Texas93 2 years ago
you play the guitar very very good !! it sounds very nicely !!
Jankens007 2 years ago
Great song, one of my favorites from Peter, I also am learning this by ear, I will post my video when I get it down, and we can compare notes, ;) anyway, awesome job, thats not an easy one to play and sing, so...Bravo mate!
washburndaddy 2 years ago
Will or do you share the tab to this perfomance and if so where? It made my day to see how sweetly it was played. Bravo! How about a slowed down lesson?
Thank You so very much,
Joel from Baltimore
fatcatkaya 2 years ago
Very, very cool. I'm trying to learn to play the song, and you've got it just nailed. Now if I can only play it like you've showed us all how....Thanks, man.
Bharm420 - DAE, mostly, then Fsharpminor.
Markopolo57 2 years ago
man im jealous. ive looked everwhere online to try to learn this song. the best tab i could find is shitty an complicated. can you let me know the chord progression? i cant figure it out by watching. i'd rele appreciate it.
bharm420 2 years ago
Your surnames Gash? HAHAHA!
GREAT PERFORMANCE THOUGH, REAL TALENT.
ed1ss 2 years ago
molto bravo....chitarra quasi perfetta!!comunque complimenti
totodn10 2 years ago
LOUD APPLAUSE! Very well done. I appreciate your effort. Thanks for putting up the video.
tOneMASterB 2 years ago
sweeet! well done man! Loved it - Favourite for sure.
dB
rockabillyotis 2 years ago
very nice man
Willisgay99 2 years ago
the song was done with a synth. he's laughing.
hillybilly227 2 years ago
very nice dude.. i have a request..can you slow it down and kinda do an instructional of how you are playing it? otehrs on u tube didnt sound as good as this
augfive 2 years ago