Thanks, Lothor93. My version came from THE SONGS OF MAN by Norman Luboff & Win Stracke published in 1965. The interesting thing about this version is that, in a literary sense, it is the only version I have found that is complete. It is a frame tale— It starts, "One day as I wandered..."; i.e., first person POV. Then it shifts to the girl's lament. This is where the Carter version and most of the variations end. Luboff & Stracke's version brings it back to the original narrator. Cool, huh?
Sweet, Tim - I hope you're still doing this. One of my favorite memories is seeing The Smothers Brothers in Las Vegas in the 80's. They don't do it like that anymore, do they?
Very nicely done. It's true that the voice rumbles the song well, liked the rhythm too. It's always good to hear a more authentic version.
qbea5 1 year ago
@qbea5 Thanks for your comment. I appreciate it very much.
Tim
TimMcMullen 1 year ago
Very nice Tim. I too first heard this from the Smothers Brothers in the early 70's. You do very nice job on this obscure song.
Lothor93 1 year ago
Thanks, Lothor93. My version came from THE SONGS OF MAN by Norman Luboff & Win Stracke published in 1965. The interesting thing about this version is that, in a literary sense, it is the only version I have found that is complete. It is a frame tale— It starts, "One day as I wandered..."; i.e., first person POV. Then it shifts to the girl's lament. This is where the Carter version and most of the variations end. Luboff & Stracke's version brings it back to the original narrator. Cool, huh?
TimMcMullen 1 year ago
nice job! great voice!
amyprat 2 years ago
A song for the ages.
record1207 2 years ago
brilliant mate, good voice by the way perfect for the song, 5's
stevevox1 2 years ago
Thanks so much for your kind comment. I appreciate it!
TimMcMullen 2 years ago
I like this song.Very rare rendition.
14071902 2 years ago
Very nicely done, Tim. I enjoyed your rendition very much. Salute.
Rikki0 3 years ago
I have loved this song for such a long time, and it was a delight to find it here, performed so beautifully! Thank you!
nllleonard 3 years ago
very,very,good
psychodelicdragon 3 years ago
This is beautiful! Different from what i've heard before but I love it. 5*****'s Thank you for posting. Shirley
broncose1 3 years ago
Sweet, Tim - I hope you're still doing this. One of my favorite memories is seeing The Smothers Brothers in Las Vegas in the 80's. They don't do it like that anymore, do they?
dread66mon 4 years ago