You did a great job. All the criticisms about your take on this song is really unwarranted. I saw Elliott play live more times than I can count or even remember. He always played his own songs with different cadences and even tuned them differently at times. He even made a hell of a lot of mistakes. That was the charm of Elliott. You have your own charm and your own way - don't change.
Accenting in music is some completely different. I'm the stupid one? If you like it that's fine; I have just as much of a right to say why I don't like it.
I discovered you with this cover of Elliot Smith... Since, I visited your myspace and your website and your blog... Your music is pretty cool, I love especially "Try to understand"... Keep going on and come in France to play for us ! Bye
I never ever usually comment on things on youtube, mainly because it's like shouting in a room of deaf people who are also shouting. I feel that this warrents some for of comment. If you want to feel the emotions of the original song listen to that, I think the job of someone covering a song is to bring a new perspective to it, so what if the perspective is slightly whimsical? How can a 22 year old girl convey what a 28 year old man with substance abuse problems felt anyway? I quite liked this.
@smiffskid ,I think I understand sentiments. Interpretations are meant to be personal not an echo of the original. That being said, if you take Please Please Please, speed up the tempo and an uppity voice to the mix, you'd most likely take away from the song.
seriously i love your voice and you play guitar very well. you got talent. the only thing is that i don't feel like you understand what you are singing. i know that this isn't your song but you're covering it anyways and i think that it's important to know not only the chords and the words, but their meaning too.
you do well out of the few chords you can play and your voice fits nicely. BUt if your gonna do elliott dont ever try and make it up beat! its like its like Obama being the first white president! I think you can propel sadness through your voice! so if your gonna cover him do it how hed want it!
You have a good voice and you play the guitar very well, but it's supposed to be slower and be more sad. Like someone said, the emotion is wrong. But, otherwise good job.
good point. You're a great musician with a great voice. I would listen to your music but this song... listen, shoot some heroine for a few years then try singing this song again.
This was a great cover, but if you prefer this version over the original, maybe you should stick with the Jonas Brothers, since you're obviously eight-years-old.
I've watched most of your videos, and I was excited when I saw you'd covered this song... I liked the rest of your stuff, but this was disappointing as an Elliot Smith fan. It lost it's feeling in your happier voice and faster playing..
This was a great cover. Elliott Smith was so unique and talented that no one can do his songs better than he did, but you still impressed me with this. Keep it up!
i liked this quite much miss weiss. isn't elliott smith just gorgeous? the music i mean. he put just the perfect amount of emotion into his songs don't you think?
i listen to this when i wake up in morning, ure amazing =) I usually dont watch Elliott Smith covers, cause i usually am not impressed. but this is something special, i think u feel what he felt, though no of us could understand who to write such amazing emotions into song. keep it up!
Hello Allison! I think this is a great cover of Elliotts song (may he rest in peace). Maybe you'll take a minute to check out my original songs too. Take care, and always beware ;-)
hey lady your voice is off the hook and i love this song so right off the bat id like to say you did a realy good job but just to let you know you might want to put that capo between the frets as opposed to on the fret it would make your projection qualitly alot better just giving you a heads up! thanks for the cover i realy enjoyed it!
From what i hear is : A stiff voice... like.. don't pull your voice soo far... sing as ur singing to someone you really love.. not for a piece of plastic filming you.
I just found out about you when I was searching for "In My Room" covers. You have a wonderful voice & a very nice guitar technique. This cover is wonderful. you got a new fan.
I really liked the way you sang the chorus,but I think the metric was a bit too fast and syncopated for the rest of the song.I am nobody to say this,but if you work on that, it's gonna be perfect.Nice job!
Very nicely done! I live in Athens, haven't seen you perform live since you were playing the sidewalk near Heery's on Clayton and handing out stickers one late night several years ago. I reckon I'll come to a proper show one of these days.
Wait, You live in Athens!!! And you perform...I was looking through the flagpole today, and I was like "don't I know this person?" and now I'm like....OH right!
This is a risky song to cover.. not only because alot of people have done it, but because it's an elliot smith song. You did a great job, dont let anyone tell you different.
but, im a huge Elliott fan and im not so fond of this cover, the subtle way you changed the vocal phrasing.. ah, i just dont like it. alot of what makes the song great is that kind of chilling flow the vocals have, which is completely gone on your version
please take that as nothing more than constructive critisism! i love all your other covers and think theyre better than the orig, i think its just hard to live up to a smith song
Someone once played this song for me and sang it in such a way that I can never forget it. I chose to sing it this particular way because it was the way that affected me most.
I love Elliott's version too, of course...but I'm also not Elliott, obviously...so...I guess this is a rendition. Thanks for watching!
ive watched loads of covers of this song- i love the emotion you put into it..no one seems to really think about the lyrics when they sing this, you did- great job.
I hope you can come do concerts in Canada someday! Especially Vancouver, BC. But Victoria, BC would also work... :D
theplaidpirate 2 weeks ago
God i love Elliot Smith, you're like the only other person who knows about him =[
QuickLilNews 2 months ago
@QuickLilNews i know how you feel but that extreme is just silly... cmon now...
Heathathnasoodua 3 weeks ago
I listened this song, put it on tubereplay, and now- I've discovered I played 211 times. <3
saturdaynoodles1 7 months ago
ps you totally captured the es essence in the most feminine way and i love you for it
needleintheHEEY 8 months ago
SO BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!!!!!
needleintheHEEY 8 months ago
Good Job!
WatchItClickItEnjoy 8 months ago
Good Job!
WatchItClickItEnjoy 8 months ago
Not a bad cover. Keep up the good work.
LetThereBeXenu 8 months ago
Not a bad cover. Keep up the good work.
LetThereBeXenu 8 months ago
Your so adorable and your voice is Awesome! Keep it up. (:
beckyolive18 8 months ago
you are a real star!!!!!!
MsCaleb79 9 months ago
Comment removed
sachababs 9 months ago
cool!! love ellioth
MrPrincipedestronado 10 months ago
emily haines cover of this made me liiike freaking lov her :<
lmao
anyways, good song choice :]
lilsheep68 1 year ago
Emotions are what make this song.
TheCelicagtsman 1 year ago
lol - "I never ever usually comment on things on youtube, mainly because it's like shouting in a room of deaf people who are also shouting"
ClassicRemo 1 year ago 4
weiss is german and means white
BombardWithMuffins 1 year ago
I think I'm in love. Don't tell my wife.
SirWilliamIdol 1 year ago
babe'in it up on guitar
gooman989898 1 year ago
I think you sound like Hanne Hukkelberg. That's a compliment, by the way.:) Nice job.
yourdogsmusic 1 year ago
naaaahhh.
btgreenwaldo 1 year ago 2
I like your voice pretty girl. :-)
FreeAmericans 1 year ago
i think your pretty cute. good work
mierrozerote 1 year ago
hate
KaitlynHooligun 1 year ago
one of my favorite artist
VcookiemonsterV 1 year ago
You did a great job. All the criticisms about your take on this song is really unwarranted. I saw Elliott play live more times than I can count or even remember. He always played his own songs with different cadences and even tuned them differently at times. He even made a hell of a lot of mistakes. That was the charm of Elliott. You have your own charm and your own way - don't change.
SalvatorePDX 1 year ago
of all the cover's on youtube your's got to me the best. I almost cried ._.
EndOfTheW0rld 1 year ago
it's different from the original...but i think i like the original version too much to enjoy anything changed around.
at least u have a nice voice.
LipSyncLover 1 year ago
absolutely stunning, i'm watching it on my iPhone and couldn't resist telling you that this cover is certainly one of the best :)
tristansproductions 1 year ago
Can't stand the staccato vocals, or just your accenting in general. Takes away from the feel of the song.
assassinloki090 1 year ago
Comment removed
tilatequila809 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@assassinloki090
I don't see your cover assjackal090.
tilatequila809 1 year ago
@tilatequila809
That's cute. Please fail at insulting me for having an opinion.
assassinloki090 1 year ago
Yeah but if you opinion is stupid...what should people say? It's a good, different version. And you attack her accent? Stupid you.
HeyJaw 1 year ago
@HeyJaw
Accenting in music is some completely different. I'm the stupid one? If you like it that's fine; I have just as much of a right to say why I don't like it.
assassinloki090 1 year ago
that is fuckin steller
thekohlton 2 years ago 3
Hi Allison
I discovered you with this cover of Elliot Smith... Since, I visited your myspace and your website and your blog... Your music is pretty cool, I love especially "Try to understand"... Keep going on and come in France to play for us ! Bye
pichtashe 2 years ago 2
Brava!!
Pulcino84 2 years ago
I never ever usually comment on things on youtube, mainly because it's like shouting in a room of deaf people who are also shouting. I feel that this warrents some for of comment. If you want to feel the emotions of the original song listen to that, I think the job of someone covering a song is to bring a new perspective to it, so what if the perspective is slightly whimsical? How can a 22 year old girl convey what a 28 year old man with substance abuse problems felt anyway? I quite liked this.
smiffskid 2 years ago 46
@smiffskid ,I think I understand sentiments. Interpretations are meant to be personal not an echo of the original. That being said, if you take Please Please Please, speed up the tempo and an uppity voice to the mix, you'd most likely take away from the song.
thomxAristy 2 years ago
seriously i love your voice and you play guitar very well. you got talent. the only thing is that i don't feel like you understand what you are singing. i know that this isn't your song but you're covering it anyways and i think that it's important to know not only the chords and the words, but their meaning too.
bravo anyways!
arielsosic 2 years ago 17
Comment removed
sachababs 9 months ago
you do well out of the few chords you can play and your voice fits nicely. BUt if your gonna do elliott dont ever try and make it up beat! its like its like Obama being the first white president! I think you can propel sadness through your voice! so if your gonna cover him do it how hed want it!
raggywoo 2 years ago
You have a good voice and you play the guitar very well, but it's supposed to be slower and be more sad. Like someone said, the emotion is wrong. But, otherwise good job.
LaughterIsEvrything 2 years ago
Great job really.
Adilisawesome 2 years ago
really goood :) x
bjh14player 2 years ago
you have an amazing style and taste in music, based on your covers
stfut90 2 years ago
THAT WAS REALLY FUCKIN GOOD!!! i woshirp your greatness! lol you rox my sox =]
kagome620 2 years ago
LOL! ES is rolling in his grave!!!! NO WAY!!! DONR DO ANY MORE ES COVERS> EVER>
oktotx 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hahaha... yea bitch way to turn it into a poppy turd sandwich
noisez13000 2 years ago
you're sooo awesome!
adobento 2 years ago
It's really funny to hear this song come from someone so young. It's like Jonny Lang singing the blues. Very cute, but I don't buy it.
cretine 2 years ago 2
wow elitist prick.
jonnymohawk 2 years ago
good point. You're a great musician with a great voice. I would listen to your music but this song... listen, shoot some heroine for a few years then try singing this song again.
teddy5549 2 years ago
lol, Heroin does make some damn good music despite it's disastrous effects.
purpledrohaze777 2 years ago 5
seconded.
you have a good voice,
and the guitar is pretty close,
but the emotions are all wrong.
sorry, but that's my opinion.
good cover otherwise,
though.
Lawlsrsly 2 years ago 3
what guitar do u use.. the model name??? does it have a pickup
sydestand 2 years ago
awesome.
jennadrums 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I definitely prefer this version to the original.
fadoogle 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
stfu
TakeItEazy3 2 years ago
This was a great cover, but if you prefer this version over the original, maybe you should stick with the Jonas Brothers, since you're obviously eight-years-old.
peteXfacundo 2 years ago 2
I've watched most of your videos, and I was excited when I saw you'd covered this song... I liked the rest of your stuff, but this was disappointing as an Elliot Smith fan. It lost it's feeling in your happier voice and faster playing..
MadiBucket 2 years ago
I do a cover of this too!! Hmmm i should post a vid of it too :)
ariellebryant 2 years ago
i hate when people cover this, but at least u played the second part of the chorus correctly. most people just repeat the first part but nope.
stevepaul1231 2 years ago
weiss SAME NAME WOOT
SlanderInYoFace 2 years ago
nice nice! lol it's weird cuz you look like a younger version of my former english teacher and I could never picture her doing this song haha
sstrunks8000 2 years ago
This was a great cover. Elliott Smith was so unique and talented that no one can do his songs better than he did, but you still impressed me with this. Keep it up!
Basram 2 years ago 4
"hello internet!" haha :) I love it. And the music. nice job
AlexStevens42 2 years ago 3
i liked this quite much miss weiss. isn't elliott smith just gorgeous? the music i mean. he put just the perfect amount of emotion into his songs don't you think?
theaestheticmovement 2 years ago 2
i listen to this when i wake up in morning, ure amazing =) I usually dont watch Elliott Smith covers, cause i usually am not impressed. but this is something special, i think u feel what he felt, though no of us could understand who to write such amazing emotions into song. keep it up!
Zubby3002 2 years ago
Hello Allison! I think this is a great cover of Elliotts song (may he rest in peace). Maybe you'll take a minute to check out my original songs too. Take care, and always beware ;-)
//Mick
Sonofsoil 2 years ago 2
Excellent cover. You have a great voice and have definately done the song justice. Cheers, and good luck with your future musical endeavors
bobz0r 3 years ago
why are you tearing up? i take it that you have some history with the song. very emotional, i like it very much.
mephis 3 years ago
I tear up every time I hear it.
mikecallahan 2 years ago
i really liked that cover nice work. :) xo.
WolfToHula 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
YO NIGGA BITCH, YO MUFUCKIN' CAPO IS ALL WACKED OUTTA WACK, FIX IT OR NO LOAD IN YOUR EYE SOCKET wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink wink.
TheDigitalEric 3 years ago
die.
chibustin 3 years ago
I like it very cute cover- slow it down a bit, it isn't a race.
MondayBlues22 3 years ago 2
♪♫♪♫ 5 Stars
psihopatmc 3 years ago
hey lady your voice is off the hook and i love this song so right off the bat id like to say you did a realy good job but just to let you know you might want to put that capo between the frets as opposed to on the fret it would make your projection qualitly alot better just giving you a heads up! thanks for the cover i realy enjoyed it!
RedlvRum 3 years ago
you are so annoying!
xwallinx 3 years ago
im sorry but.. i didnt like it.
From what i hear is : A stiff voice... like.. don't pull your voice soo far... sing as ur singing to someone you really love.. not for a piece of plastic filming you.
callmemister 3 years ago
this is far more than a fav to me
it hurts and it bleeds
and when i hear you singing i can feel that...
thank you allllison
mismaling 3 years ago
♪♫♪♫ 5 Stars ☆☆☆☆☆
gunsandroese 3 years ago
luv it
pixichick420 3 years ago
I like your voice<3.
mansfieldbp 3 years ago
wow...
Dominantss 3 years ago
I like what you did with the tempo. Very nice
Bombdiggity207 3 years ago
I just found out about you when I was searching for "In My Room" covers. You have a wonderful voice & a very nice guitar technique. This cover is wonderful. you got a new fan.
CokeMachineGlo 3 years ago
such a beautiful cover of this song.... thank u so much
smartymarty82 3 years ago
slow down a little bit
tj3nixen 3 years ago
well done! :)
RevolvingDoors01 3 years ago
dont cry :(
sophalax 3 years ago
y do u hide those beautiful eyes behind those glasses ? u as beautiful as your voice is !!
ollyuzr 3 years ago
nice
relmz441 3 years ago
wow, you're amazing, you have a cute little voice. i like it a lot, you're a great singer, sing me to sleep :)
kristineyweenie 3 years ago 3
Most depressing song ever. But I love it! And you're amazing!
D3clanb 3 years ago
I really liked the way you sang the chorus,but I think the metric was a bit too fast and syncopated for the rest of the song.I am nobody to say this,but if you work on that, it's gonna be perfect.Nice job!
parasshilton 3 years ago
Very nicely done! I live in Athens, haven't seen you perform live since you were playing the sidewalk near Heery's on Clayton and handing out stickers one late night several years ago. I reckon I'll come to a proper show one of these days.
davefranklinmartin 3 years ago
Awesome now teach me!! A good inspiration to us girls :)
cominguproses22 3 years ago
Beautifully done. Don't stop singing.
CMaddox34 3 years ago 3
don't listen to the haters. good work. keep it up.
evelynwaugh9 3 years ago
man .. youtube wouldn't be that lively without haters !!
ollyuzr 3 years ago
simply amazing
falcostrife 3 years ago
get off my computer.
washingtonerving 3 years ago
i think your voice is pretty awesome.I dunno if I like how fast you played though. way cute =D
kaylacook1 3 years ago
sweetz! that was better than most i've seen!
jairusbilo 3 years ago
beautiful!
mikecallahan 3 years ago
Wait, You live in Athens!!! And you perform...I was looking through the flagpole today, and I was like "don't I know this person?" and now I'm like....OH right!
Fabulous cover, thank you!
Zeldreaisme 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Okay does everyone know this song was written by Chris Garneau and originally sung by him as well. Who the hell is Elliot Smith!!!!
b4lue35 3 years ago
yeah you're definitely wrong dude... this one's by elliott smith. You should look him up.
jjohnse 3 years ago 2
Yeah you're right I did look it up Chris Garneau did a cover of the song
b4lue35 3 years ago
Eeek! Sorry, that was harsh. And I didn't read your reply. Excuse me.
KaitlynHooligun 3 years ago
What the hell are you doing, b4lue35? Don't say shit if you don't know anything.
KaitlynHooligun 3 years ago
Idiot.
HibikiRush 3 years ago
wow im in love with your voice. please bless me with another cover =]
rollershoer4life 3 years ago
great try with this. as the other guy was saying, ease up a little. i suggest a swig of Jack Daniels or Jim Bean.
taynghi 3 years ago
yah it was really good, and good choice of a song, keep it up i say
falcostrife 3 years ago
this is amazing
this is like the best song ever
but your the only person who actually changes the guitar any
and that makes it so much better
and
haha
"my microphone was jacked up"
wowandrew5243 3 years ago 2
god!!!
you are good!!! =)
you have a great voice
and you play very good
(and you are beautiful btw)
come down to mexico lol
Ponko666 3 years ago
Ease up and lean back on the beat a little. I like your voice.
twcatube 3 years ago
This is a risky song to cover.. not only because alot of people have done it, but because it's an elliot smith song. You did a great job, dont let anyone tell you different.
boarderbc 3 years ago 2
theres was nothing good it was plain and nothing good there was nothing that gave any indication that you actually liked singing
crazymonkeydrummer 3 years ago
very great and clear voice , great.
potential , hope you see it.
LinerFrenchElectro 3 years ago
Umm I meant rhythm
gth838n 3 years ago
Nice Rythym
gth838n 3 years ago
thanks allison :)
joeburton77 4 years ago
i think you have a great quality in your voice. a bit hoarse, (which i love) but also exact and precice.
yngvildg 4 years ago 2
i love all your songs
but, im a huge Elliott fan and im not so fond of this cover, the subtle way you changed the vocal phrasing.. ah, i just dont like it. alot of what makes the song great is that kind of chilling flow the vocals have, which is completely gone on your version
please take that as nothing more than constructive critisism! i love all your other covers and think theyre better than the orig, i think its just hard to live up to a smith song
nosis106 4 years ago
I thought she nailed it... :-D
ziggystardust125 4 years ago 2
I agree there are some subtle (but important!) differences with the rhythm of the singing. Great cover though.
xskinyx 3 years ago
Someone once played this song for me and sang it in such a way that I can never forget it. I chose to sing it this particular way because it was the way that affected me most.
I love Elliott's version too, of course...but I'm also not Elliott, obviously...so...I guess this is a rendition. Thanks for watching!
amlingisrad 3 years ago
I don't listen to Elliot Smith (not my thing).
You though, are good. I like your music and the music you cover. I hope you keep up the good work.
(I found you lookin' for BTMI).
anythingannoying 1 year ago
Adorable; I really enjoyed this. :)
mynamejonas 4 years ago
I love this song!! Great interpretation!!
Carpediemeuh 4 years ago
That was such a nice cover. Just because of that, I have to go look up that song now XD
LynD11 4 years ago
Allison, I feel like you really honored his vision with this. Good work!
lkcaz 4 years ago
You play the F differently than I do. I add a G on the high E string.
Either way, you sound great.
NINandNirvana 4 years ago
ive watched loads of covers of this song- i love the emotion you put into it..no one seems to really think about the lyrics when they sing this, you did- great job.
rikki444 4 years ago
i am a huge Elliott Smith fan. You sound so great.
doozer1200 4 years ago
i love what i love to think you are! your incredible. do you write poetry?
damiensomen 4 years ago
great cover
krikros21 4 years ago
Wow, i'm not normally a huge fan of your covers but this is wonderful, I can't get enough of it.
vDanteSinfernOv 4 years ago
hey a faster version, I love your voice hun.
rizzy81 4 years ago
nice cover miss weiss (your name means a color in german :))
haltdenmund 4 years ago
wahh... your voice.. its gorgeous
i just wish it was a little bit slower?
aca94030 4 years ago 2
me too.
satomipanki 4 years ago
your super awsome at guitar and have a fricken beautiful voice
kingdork1212 4 years ago
I love your voice miss weiss. bravo. encore. great cover. wonderful. honestly
DRockT123 4 years ago
<3 More plz.
I like a lot of your stuff.
xoxo
theasianyee 4 years ago
Did you loose weight?
LizardsMoo 4 years ago
I hope so!
amlingisrad 4 years ago
It sure looks like you did.
Very pretty.
LizardsMoo 4 years ago
First BTMI, now Elliott Smith?
Sweet!
Ulfs 4 years ago
You're awesome.
NickSerpa 4 years ago
Keep posting! you are one of the few musicians I really look forward to on this site.
theryaner 4 years ago
Elliott Smith for the win!!!!!!!! great song choice. keep up the good work =]
standardbreak97 4 years ago
I always give you five stars before I even watch your vids for the first time.
I like anything you do.
and I don't know what the hell you're talking aboot, it sounded great the first time.
RuckusAmsel 4 years ago
I haven't ever heard this song before, which is probably a shame - it's hauntingly beautiful, especially with your voice.
capillaryveins 4 years ago