Horowitz had a mind and though he did spend some time with Cortot .I doubt that a Russian any Russians would give a. Rachm did not and it is infuriates me that anyone would think H . didn't have supreme confidence in his philosophy about Chopin. . Sokolov, many others I prefer but that's me and i lack much surely. Cortot is a different type of music making. There is wonderful sensitivity and dynamics ,and structure here but ...
I know many interpretations of this sonata but this is the best one in style interpretation and technique. and the most virtuous one too.... I understand better now why Dinu Lipatti was so good in technique and musicalement also....
Cortot was a milestone in the history of piano teachers,
Comparisons are always odious. Horowitz was unique, but he never played this sonata quite THIS well. In fact it was obviously a great challenge to him.
Though few would acknowledge it, Cortot provided the foundation for many of Horowitz's Chopin performances. Cortot had, possibly, the most vivid and fertile imagination of any figure in the history of piano performance.
Novaes' recording of Opus 35 exceeds them all -- an absolute wonder.
CORTOT gets more MUSIC out of this morbid masterpiece than anyone. His Presto with its unique spiked and spurred points of emphasis at odd, unpredictable intervals jars the nerves, then grabs and stabs at listener as as he gets whisked off and sucked down to hell in the dusky whirlwind.
There is something deliciously VICIOUS in Cortot's interpretation -- a quality I am certain Chopin fully intended.
Certainly very good. I think Rachmaninoff chooses the correct tempo for the funeral march. Cortot's is a good choice, better than most people who take it way to slowly (E.G. Nikolsky, Weissenberg). Sure it is lento but it is still a march.
I disagree the third movement is like the soul of the person diseased traveling at the speed of light to eternal life or oblivion, and then end seals the finality of it.
there is absolutely no way for me to describe what i just heard. oh this is the melody of life and death. this is the music that describes our lives. Cortot told us what Chopin wrote.
what a GREAT idea play the bass at 4:10 one octave lower! that sounds like a heavy and dark bell calling from the reign of death
newFranzFerencLiszt 3 weeks ago
With a voracious appetite for Beauty
I am most satisfied here ---> starting at 2:15
with Maestro Cortot.
MsSolonj 1 month ago
the video is freezes at 2:39 i dont know why
leo20789 9 months ago
Comment removed
leo20789 9 months ago
funeral march is amazing, the best music ever
leo20789 9 months ago
Amazing. Vicious, I agree. OTT?
Picasso said "The chief enemy of creativity is "good" sense." So it's not OTT, just amazing.
mdr23 9 months ago
Does anyone know the year of this wonderful recording?
ThePaczki 11 months ago
Cortot had great taste. Good taste is hard to come by...
zhangensprachen 1 year ago
Alfred... I don't care how people talk about you, you are one of the most original pianists ever.
I love how he drops the bass down an octave at the end, sounds so fucking sinister and bad ass!
cfwpiano 1 year ago
The really best version of this sonata! Amazing!
petrof4056 1 year ago
Who else hears Darth Vader here?!
mf2101 1 year ago 4
@mf2101
Lol, this could have been an influence for that Theme
sealkingdaniel 1 year ago
@mf2101
oh shit
youve ruined it for me
JimJimJimNL 1 year ago
CLASSIC!!!!!!
TalonusX 1 year ago
Horowitz had a mind and though he did spend some time with Cortot .I doubt that a Russian any Russians would give a. Rachm did not and it is infuriates me that anyone would think H . didn't have supreme confidence in his philosophy about Chopin. . Sokolov, many others I prefer but that's me and i lack much surely. Cortot is a different type of music making. There is wonderful sensitivity and dynamics ,and structure here but ...
lovesGenet 1 year ago
Cortot的演奏總是令我眼睛為之一亮!!
chopin sonata no.2在他手下...
音樂層次相當多變!!
不失為一介奇才。
seremerow 2 years ago
In the Funeral March, Cortot's playing makes death come alive. A true poet.
jcfs123 2 years ago 5
I know many interpretations of this sonata but this is the best one in style interpretation and technique. and the most virtuous one too.... I understand better now why Dinu Lipatti was so good in technique and musicalement also....
Cortot was a milestone in the history of piano teachers,
Eliane Richepin succeeded him.
uhartchristian 2 years ago 2
Cortot and Hoffman had the better Chopin before Horowitz changed the standard of performance. unforgettable performances, "les deuces"
Overlapse1000 2 years ago
Comparisons are always odious. Horowitz was unique, but he never played this sonata quite THIS well. In fact it was obviously a great challenge to him.
Though few would acknowledge it, Cortot provided the foundation for many of Horowitz's Chopin performances. Cortot had, possibly, the most vivid and fertile imagination of any figure in the history of piano performance.
Novaes' recording of Opus 35 exceeds them all -- an absolute wonder.
Pischnaholic 2 years ago 9
Muito boa interpretação embora o piano não ajude: Este nível de pianista deveria ser proibido tocar num instrumento tão ruim!
rwrsoares 2 years ago
CORTOT gets more MUSIC out of this morbid masterpiece than anyone. His Presto with its unique spiked and spurred points of emphasis at odd, unpredictable intervals jars the nerves, then grabs and stabs at listener as as he gets whisked off and sucked down to hell in the dusky whirlwind.
There is something deliciously VICIOUS in Cortot's interpretation -- a quality I am certain Chopin fully intended.
Pischnaholic 2 years ago 12
@Pischnaholic You are sooo right with your words. I would add 'remorseless' and 'relentless' too.
aardvaark069 2 years ago
Certainly very good. I think Rachmaninoff chooses the correct tempo for the funeral march. Cortot's is a good choice, better than most people who take it way to slowly (E.G. Nikolsky, Weissenberg). Sure it is lento but it is still a march.
morvensky 2 years ago
Лучшего исполнения я не слышал.
PavelAMamoushkin 2 years ago
I disagree the third movement is like the soul of the person diseased traveling at the speed of light to eternal life or oblivion, and then end seals the finality of it.
hdfhjasdofibafa 2 years ago
Anton Rubenstein once described the last movement as the night wind whipping through the gravestones. I think that's perfect.
aardvaark069 3 years ago 3
this is really so well played i can't believe it. Cortot really causes me to dream, and i'm not just saying that, that's really the feeling
munkybrain 3 years ago 2
there is absolutely no way for me to describe what i just heard. oh this is the melody of life and death. this is the music that describes our lives. Cortot told us what Chopin wrote.
ibclappin 3 years ago
epic Chopin. passion and poetry in one. Thanks
chad410 3 years ago