Added: 3 years ago
From: nateislegend
Views: 184,393
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,812)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Rock Band led to the demise of Guitar Hero so it is obvious which one is better.

  • Guitar hero

  • Wow bro. The drum on tock band 2. The bass pedal is the standard alesis dm5 hi hat pedal

  • rockbands guitar and drums suck

  • In Brazil, this battery costs U.S. $ 1800.00

  • rock band is more better. Real guitar real drumms ! And shut up fucking stupid gh fans.

  • @fifaworldcupitaly90 are you retarded? The new Rock Band drums use 7 notes. The guitar hero ones only use 5. You suck for playing a fake game. Rock Band 3 is as close to real drums as any game is going to get. And I suck? I've been playing real drums for 2 years, piano for 6, guitar for 1 1/2 years. What have you done? Bitch. Go troll to someone else. Because you're a loser pathetic pussy.

  • rock band drums has 6 pats and it only uses 4 so wtf?

  • Hei guys i have a question I wana buy gh:wt drums for PS2 and I want to know if they work on rock band.

    I mean GH has 5 buttoms and RB 4 . Plz tell me if GH drums work on rock band.

  • what song is this?

    

  • @vipercaw the name of the song is fuel from metallica

  • bbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb­iiiiiiiiiibbbbbbbbbbbbbaaaaaaa­aaaaaa eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeelllllllllllll gggggggghhhhhhiiiiiiitttttttaa­aaaaaar

  • -.-

    guitar hero |m|¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡¡­¡¡¡¡

  • is better rock band 2!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @dioteck11 no manches el rok ban es la copia barata de el ghitar

  • @knexcoaster fuck you. Rock Band 3 has Pro Mode and uses 3 symbols and 4 drums. Therefore Guitar Hero is actually for pussies. It uses 5 notes for drums. Rock Band now uses 7 bitch. So go play your fake game. Rock Band is closer to real instrument than guitar hero will ever be. Pro Mode wipes Guitar Hero away. It can't compete fag.

  • @TheMummy516 rock band use fucking 4 and guitar hero 5 so shut up you fucker you suck

  • i still think guitar hero is better....rockband is for pussys....rockband is wayy to fucking easy guitar hero fucking OWNZ

  • they aren't rock band drums

  • GUITAR HERO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! OWNS!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • it all about gh world tour

  • Hahaha it's funny you said guitar herd guitar is better the rock bands hahahahaha I'm srry rockbands guitar recks guitar Heros little guiatar

  • do rock band 2 guitar and drums works on guitar hero WT ???? and what should i buy rock band 2 or GHWT???PLZ PLZ ANSWER?

  • @MrNasoor1 Rock Band 2.

  • mate your an idiot, you said guitar hero has better guitar but rock band 2 drums destroy GH, you cant base it on this as your not even on about rock bands actual drum kit, thats a completely different kit that you have to pay fkin £250 for!! which prob 98% of rock band users wont have, so if your going to do a "vs" video then at least base it on the proper stuff, which guitar heros drum kit is better than rock bands STOCK drum kit.

  • @WHITEYxM hey faggot, this video was made before GHWT or RB2 even. At the time, the IONS were supposed to be the stock drums for RB2.

  • @nateislegend The ions were never supposed to be the stock drums for RB2.

    Don't believe everything you read on the internet...

  • When I read the ending (The p.s. part) I thought, "NO SHIT!!!"

  • @TheRacecarfan um... well, this was before the game came out. So yeah. No shit.

  • RB2 wins hardly, but GH is fun too, just got the VH GH and it's fun, but still RB2 wins anyways

  • lol i just read my own comment, i should have proof read it :p ohh well.

  • The people who got GH of the groud are now the creators of rockband, activison just like with MW2 is in it for the money and dont care about the gamers they play there product. Plus rockband comes out with DLC now fucking more games witch is 100000000000 times better the GH, GH is sham and i can't wait for rockband3. So anyone in the comments want to tell me what i just said is a lie prove it because you know im right.

  • @potwinkles ...i love you.

  • rock band pela webo

  • @RobedSithmaster was that a spanish fail

  • This guy heavily favors Rock Band, you can tell by his replies to peoples comments. He hasn't been bashing people who bash Guitar Hero, just those who bash Rock Band. Bias much?

  • @heavensjoke of course it's biased. Am I not allowed to prefer one over the other?

  • @nateislegend Sure you are but when someone is doing a review or a "vs" video reviewing two items or "comparing" two items, they generally aren't bias in their review of the item. Not on their own videos, at least. Especially so vividly in the comments. Then again it took me 2 days to reply to your message lol I couldn't really give a crap. :) Have a nice day.

  • @heavensjoke I understand where you're coming from, but it's 2:24 AM, and I'm in a good mood, so I don't feel like arguing about something as silly as this. And a lovely day to you, too :)

  • what a homo you are, change GH world tour for GH5 and you will end shiting yourself with the drums and the guitar that they have, tell me at least you have the drums you just show? (if anyone has them, Fuck!! 300$)

  • Rock Band 2 has better songs, instruments (except guitar), DLC is a lot of better!

    It has better graphics. It has better characters. I think almost everything is better on RB2 not GH

  • i like the design of the rb drums and guitar much more than gh, and so no one freaks out on me, i have played both

  • ur a fag thats not rock bands stock drum set u cant compare that

  • i would still play guitar hero if it was still only guitar now that they stole rockbands idea for all the instruments i dont care for it anymore

  • dude not every one has the ionic drum kit

  • Rock Band beats Guitar Hero any day.

  • I like GH better...instruments durable, drums durable, and its easier to play but yet some song difficulty is a pain...when i got rock band 2 the red pad broke the 2nd day i had it...and the rock band 2 guitar broke when my friends chiuahwah jumped on it...my 60 lb beagle jumped on my GH:WT guitar and did nothing....Still no issues with GH then there is Rock Band

  • The Ion has a LARGE hype, but it's not worst the money...

  • Both games are great, honestly.

    In my point of view, Rock Band 2 is better.

    1. Instrument Quality

    2. Songs(including DLC)

    3. Graphics

    4. It is easier to play online due to how many people own the game.

    5. Rock Band did not copy guitar hero, in fact, guitar hero copied almost all the songs from Rock Band 2.

    The drums aren't great on Guitar hero either.

  • well I have both, mm & i'll have to go for RB.. u dont have to buy all the fuckn games.. that's a plus! & i like best RB guitars ..they're a little bigger & cooler.

  • Can I have the name of this song?

  • ROCK BAND 4 EVER !!!!

  • The first two guitar Heros were amazing, but after that they suck... And I like rock band guitar better, it's easier to hit the buttons... Now tht I think of it, rb guitar destroys gh guitar

  • Lol i like Guitar hero way better rock band 2 drums are annoying? and guitar hero the the original..

  • GH always has better instuments but RB has better songs

  • @CarlosTevezNR1Fan no i broke my gh drums in 2 days i still have my drums from rockband 1, dont even try to say that crap

  • @spazykid1 ok but the guitar from GH is better

  • yeh but rockband 2 came out afta guitar hero, so you cant really compare them rockband had the advantage

  • Rock Band SMACKS DOWN Guitar Hero World Tour!!!

    Have You Seen World Tours Drums Highway?

    NO!

    You Should!!!

    The Notes Are Just Like You Have Cutted Them With Scissors!!!

    

  • thats not the rock band 2 drums the rock band 2 drums r like number 1

  • what about the micro?

  • MY GH WT drum set messed up my dam snare pad broke i modded my set now the snare is the right cymbol lol

  • rock band easy

  • I have both and I have to say Rock Band is WAY better. GHWT Drum set sucks so bad. They are way too laggy and unrealistic. You get what you paid for when you go Rock Band.

  • Rockband kills GHWT

  • i have both, i like rockband way better! the drums are way more realistic, and i play real drums so its a must

  • we pendejo guitar hero es lo mejor, el rock band me pela el webo

  • The drum set that you showed was the ion drum set, not the one that comes with the game. I personally think that the rb 2 drums beat gh because the rb drums can have 4 pads and 2 cymbols, but that is only if you buy the cymbols. Out of the box, I see the gh drums as a better set, only because it comes with the cymbols and you don't have to pay for them separately

  • @ChickenZilla12 if you look at the charts, rock bands are way more realistic

  • @ChickenZilla12 but the GH drum sets break faster.....wayyyyyy faster....

  • If your console is connected to the internet, Rock Band 2 is by far the better game, as the 1000+ downloadable song collection is insanely good. The stock drums suck, however, and the guitar's only decent function is the solo buttons. Offline, Guitar Hero is a better series, also with a lot of DLC available. I own all the games from both series, and a few spinoffs, and by far Rock Band 2 with a GH5 guitar and Ion drums are the way to go.

  • is that even a question rock band 2 all the way bro

  • rock band is much better than gh

  • ROCK fucking BAND!

  • Dude, why did you show that new cooler rockband drum rather then the old one? No one bought that one except for rich people. Next time put the original rockband drum set.

  • for a fair compairision compare ORIGINAL RB drumsto GH drums. I think RB stole the idea from GH, but GH stole drums and mic idea from RB i prefer GH over RB. There's what 4 Rb games. There's now around 10 GH games.

  • @Armageddon0Studios RB stole NOTHING from GH. The people who made the original GH games made RB. And more games doesn't mean a better game by any means. Guitar Hero spit out a lot of games last year, and the quality shows. They bit off more than they could chew.

  • @nateislegend i care not for quality but for songs. more games means more songs.plus we have gh metallica and van halen. they have beatles and green day. i like difficulty also. we have a winner gh.

  • @Armageddon0Studios ha! More songs?! You could put all the Guitar Hero games together and it STILL wouldn't amount to the amount of songs Rock Band offers as DLC. And Difficulty? Yeah right. Show me a Guitar Hero solo more difficult that Constant Motion's.

  • @nateislegend i dont have xbox live so i dont get DLC. Harder solo? Hmmmmmm maybe TTFATF (Through the Fire and the Flames), WTDWDTG (When the Devil Went Down to Georgia), and One. Custom songs: uber song 1, 2, and 3, and revolution deathsquad. reason for RD is that the solo is 2 min long and looks incredibly painful

  • @nateislegend Jordan / The Devil Went Down to Georgia

    And DLC is different than Standart Songs

  • @nateislegend

    1. Jordan by Buckethead

    2. Operation Ground and Pound

    3. The Devil Went Down to Georgia

  • @nateislegend That's what I have been trying to tell everyone and if they want to compare they should look at Rock Band 3's Pro guitar now whats harder TTFATF or Rainbow in the dark by Dio.

  • @nateislegend through the fire and flames....and solo in that song.

  • @Armageddon0Studios rock band had drums and mic before gh they got their idea stolen rockband is better

  • @Armageddon0Studios doesnt matter how many games there are it matters about the quality...errm how good the game is the mario franchise has over 30 games and do you remember the marior rpg?....yeah.....

  • @gaiaonlineisthebest yes i remember mario rpg and ive had my gh drumset for over a year. my freind had a RB drum set that was brand new. it short circuited in under a week

  • @Armageddon0Studios  and whos fault was it for short circuiting? it doesnt just short circuit by it self or by someone beating on it

  • @gaiaonlineisthebest we were playing and i just turned off and wouldnt turn on no matter what. and RB green day only has 44-in game tracks fall 2010's GH6 will not only be the only one this year, but also has 90+ in game tracks. like i said earlier, i cant get dlc so i only care for in game songs. it sucks. ive been getting a lot of negative feedback. im not hating. its constructive criticism. and were talking about it.

  • @Armageddon0Studios idk whats wrong with that drum set you had ive had mine well over a year now and its working just fine and i dont like guitar hero songs they dont have enough alternative or punk and stuff too much metal and like 90's.....blech

  • Oh please ... you didn't even compare the drum kits properly ... any 3rd party edition ones are awesome regardless of the games it's for ...

  • I personally prefer GH over RB, but I don't have GH:WT.

  • if only they could work together and create a ROCK HERO or GUITAR BAND?

  • wow, funny your comparing a 300$ drums set to a 50$ set thats pretty fair

  • Rockband drums but guitar hero guitars (:

  • I have both but i think rockband 2 is BETTER!!!!!

  • buahahha please ;] it's not fair. FAKE!

  • Me deciding factor on this epic debate is, RB2 has more songs. When playing a video game about playing music isn't variety the key factor? I mainly bang on my plastic drums. I find that faux drumming on RB more enjoyable and by no means easier b/c short two pads.

    And the death-blow to this debate. ROCK BAND NETWORK. Its just fucking awesome!!

    Again, I do the drums like 99.955% of the time when I play either so this might be a whole different argument in terms of the guitar & bass aspect.

  • Definitely GH

  • ROCK BAND 2, guitar hero world tour has no chance

  • ROCK BAND WINS DEFINETLY

  • u do know the cymbals are sold seperatly for rock band 2 but not on gh. if u dont get the cymbals 4 rb2 , it will look lese cool. but i still like rb better. i have rockband 1, lego rockband, and the beatles rockband. i also have gh wourld tour, but the drums broke. but the rb ones are less delacate.

  • ion drums are real midi drums

    i have them and they work on like all games with drums in them

  • how do you use all these drums when there is only 4 on the note chart

  • i agree that rockband is much better than guitar hero even though i still love guitar hero but the new band hero drums kicks rockband drums as the stock drums are shit and why would u pay $300 on drums to play a game? why not buy real drums!

  • All that you need to go out and buy for the Ion drum kit is a "drum brain" or something like that and it can function as a proper electronic drum kit. So it kinda is "real" drums.

  • you could buy a drum set guitar center for 250 but i heard that this functions as an electronic kit so thats still a good deal

  • yea

    Flag it

  • rock band wins.

  • u no maybe i think ill go buy a cymbal and stand for my REAL DRUM KIT.

  • rcok band is so much better then ghwt

  • the drums at 0:52 look beast and i have to get them how much are they?

  • @bloodvein3 about 6 dollars

  • are u serious? they look beast and are only $6?

  • nope. they're called Ions and they're $200 without cymbals and $300 with. There is also an upgrade kit you can use to turn them into an electronic drum kit. I'm sure if you look around a bit you could find the ions for a cheaper price.

  • I LOVE ROCK BAND!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I like rb because they have alot more songs and the guitar is the actual length were gh is smaller, plus the audio in ghwt sucks

  • the ion drum set is pretty good, but its pointless during gameplay, unless you know exactly when to hit what cimbol.

    i'm pretty much neutral for RB2 drums and GH:WT drums... they both can be used as electric drums, and they are both compatible with each game

  • guitar hero drums are better than rock band,, but i think th eion drum set is way better than the guitar hero

  • rockband 2 stock drums is better than WT's

  • No def not the GH drums are Sturdier,Cymbols not just pads,and the bass pedal is awsome.NTM double bass is possible

  • That is so gay they spend way too muchtime explaining the drums that dont come with rockband

  • Thats not the normal rock band 2 drums,so why do you show them? Ofc they are batter look at thier price.

  • i preffer ghwt because i never play the rockband

  • i prefer the rockband drums to GHWT cause there better with sturdiness

  • i will maybe buy one of these or band hero or rockband 1 which one should i buy

  • fuel!

  • first guitar hero drum set is better than rock bands and the ion drum set rocks but its also compatible with guitar hero so cant put the ion there sorry jajajajaj so post an other video with the real bundle stuff not some extra things you can bye for the game

  • rock band 2 wins

  • if your comparing stock hardware guitar hero kicks rock bands ass. if you wanna spend an extra 300 dollars on a fake plastic drumset for rock band, your a fucking loser

  • you can use the ion drum set as a real one you have to spend $200 more ajajajjaajjaja

  • Someone please give me ONE Reason why GHWT is better than Rock Band 2... I will be amazed.

  • 1 reason why ghwt is better than rock band2 is because ghwt has better songs and is more difficult. you probably like rockband2 because its easy for you, dont you. it doesnt matter how the looks are, its about the game you fukin dumbass.

  • asshole. Have you seen RB2's DLC? 1,000+ songs. Have you seen the hader RockBand songs? I find most GH songs easier

  • HATERZ

  • no GH is so easy for me.I like GH's hardware but rockband has more DLC and it's stock songs are 10x better than rockband

  • i disagree

  • All the hardware for GH kicks RBs ass.Oh and you put the fucking Ion drums in there to cover for the fact that they suck other than that your right

  • fail. My WT kit pads and cymbals where busted and cracked after 3 months. It took my RB2 stock kit 6 months, and thats only because the pads bubbled. Ion drum rocker is far more superior than both, and you can buy double bass couplers for it. RB wins

  • Ghwt rocks rock band 2

  • the rockband guitar is better than guitar heros

  • NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  • rock band 2 < Guitar hero world tour

  • I think what you meant to say was:

    rockband 2 > Guitar hero world tour

  • Yeppers.

  • rockband beatles is the bbest by far!!!!!!!!!

  • don't even break a sweat picking which one you should get, just get the better one, Guitar Hero: World Tour

  • rock band 2

    for

    the

    win

  • metallica rocks

  • i like rockbands guitar more than guitar heros.

  • i think rock band 2 iz better than gutiar hero world tour the drums for rock band 2 are a lot better in my upion

  • RB2 FTW

  • RB2 ftw

  • Is that solo frets on the Rock Band one?

    niiiiccee! :)

  • Rock band 2 pwns!

  • You can't be serious of course rock band 2 is better. The main factor is the drums. Rock band drums are a million times better than that guitar hero bullshit. That's why you can play World Tour with the Rock Band drums. Also the song list for Rock Band 2 is way better. Maybe guitar hero should have put more emphasis on the music as opposed to product placement and character models (Billy Corgan, Ozzy Osborne) and dug up some better tracks. No offense but Coldplay don't stack up to Disturbed.

  • i think world tour did alot of copying on rock band guitar and thay made the guitar hero 5/band hero drum set a little more like rock bands....my opinion, rock band is better. and an opinion can never be wrong so dont argue about it with me

  • how can you copy something you made first thats my ?

  • Thank you dude! lol

  • dont put the stock drums for the guitar hero and the ions for rockband you know guitar hero has ions to

  • this video was made July 13, 2008.

    No such thing was mentioned about Guitar Hero's "IONS" at that time.

  • Um does a Gutair hero world tour is wired or wireless?

  • Are you asking if the DRUMS are wireless?

    Yes they are...

  • no like the whole set.and like i think the wireless brakes easily.

  • i prefer rb idk the songs are less lame....

  • The song is Fuel, not Fuel of Fire :p

    Ask Metallica in person XD

  • If I asked them in person they would stand by me XD

    This is a different version of the song.

  • Youre a clown, this is a closed mic recording live.

  • All in all anybody who has had them both will DEFIANTLY prefer RB simply because... it's better.

  • i have both and i like gh more it has more songs and great songs and they are charted right and u can creat ur own song rock star instrument. have special apperences ex. ozzy osbourne, and ted nugent and real life croud reactions and rb1 and 2 are allmost the same exept diff songs

  • The crowd reactions are A LOT better in RB. also prefer how you have to hit the hammer ons dead on instead of whenever you want. The drums are just better. I think even you can admit that.

  • I've had both. I sold my GH4 for Rock Band 2 and RB2 is A LOT better. I'm not biased because I've had them both and I way prefer RB2. Rock Band in general is better than GH. Even the guitar in RB is better but what really sets it apart is the drums. RB drums are SO much better!

  • Rock Band 2 Drums are fake (not original)!