The guitarist with the red strat which is not upside down is Doyle Bramhill II. His father was a blues drummer who worked with Stevie and Jimmy Ray Vaughn among others. Doyle later played with Jimmy Ray and also played on 3 Clapton albums. The Strart is weird....cool but weird. It has right handed neck bolted onto a lefty body.
@chivitajm YES , U R CORRECT!!! HE JUST HAS IT MODIFIED TO HIS PREFERENCE, HE IS ONE AMAZING GUITAR PLAYER, IT WAS ALSO UPSIDE DOWN.....HE'S GREAT ISN'T HE?
@chivitajm either way, its pretty damn impressive to me, very very talented young man, would love to know the story of how roger came to meet up with him and take him on tour with him, well....ya, he's amazing i know that....sounds like gilmour did back in the day too, to me this is an ALL STAR LINE UP!!!
this is for ALL MEMBERS OF FLOYD, sure sounds good, sounds like floyd to me, Roger is a HUGE part of Pink Floyd, hell ...might as well admit it, he is floyd. He very clearly says at the end, yes indeed ....how we wish THEY were here.
.. Following the loss of their principal songwriter, Pink Floyd bassist and vocalist Roger Waters became the band's lyricist and conceptual leader, with Gilmour assuming lead guitar and sharing lead vocals. With this lineup Pink Floyd achieved worldwide critical and commercial success with The Dark Side of the Moon, Wish You Were Here, Animals and The Wall.
Under Barrett's leadership they released two charting singles, "Arnold Layne" and "See Emily Play", and a successful début album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967). Guitarist and vocalist David Gilmour joined Pink Floyd several months prior to Barrett's departure from the group due to deteriorating mental health in 1968.
The band originally consisted of university students Roger Waters, Nick Mason, Richard Wright and Syd Barrett. Founded in 1965, they first became popular playing in London's underground music scene in the late 1960s.
@thetrumpetstar what an idiodic comment. Roger Waters has been selling the Wall Tour out everywhere he goes, and your saying he is nothing. Don't be such a moron. Roger Waters made Pink Floyd what it is today. Dave Gilmour will always be lucky that he was in Rogers good graces. Because Roger has proved time and time again he can do Pink Floyd Without Gilmour and Mason.
Former Pink Floyd member David Gilmour will make a surprise appearance during former bandmate Roger Waters's upcoming 30th anniversary tour for The Wall, announced Waters via his Facebook page on July 14. Marking a reconciliation after years of feuding, the two will perform together at an as-yet-unknown gig during the 2010-11 tour.
This is the all time best version of Wish You Were Here. Roger nails it. He sings it with feeling cause he knows what the song means since he wrote it.
Why the hell does ppl complain over how they play this song? Or any pink floyd's songs whatsoever? I mean, this is beautiful music, and i personally think this is the best version of this song ive ever heard.
Complaining over a pink floyd song is just...wrong...This concert was about what? 9-10 years ago?
So everything you say won't change anything.
In my opinion, i think Roger Waters did a great job on this, as well as the other musicians there.
@RingelhutsNiece The so-called ironic comparison with Richard Gere is simply NOT funny. We're talking about Roger Waters here, co-founder of Pink Floyd and one of the greatest lyricists and musicians of all time.
And all these Waters vs. Gilmour forum feuds are just a bunch of crap, bottom line is they are both great musicians who made mind-blowing music together
For me this is like a breath of fresh air ,hearing the real talent behind the Floyd doing the classics as he feels them,come on? how many times have you heard the original,absolutely love this,superb!
yeah, Roger is a pretty good singer, but as he is particually tone deaf, he's not singing verry musical... And he is good at singing false as well, listen to pink floyd live conserts before the wall. Gilmours guitar, voice and musicality is missing
you are at least too damn idiot to say that waters is a bad singer..he is half of the pink floyd's voce along with david gilmour who also is a great man and musician....
I saw roger waters live back in 2004 in Rock in Rio Lisbon....was the best concert of my life...even though i was so far from the stage....it was simply magical......long live Pink Floyd and long live Roger Waters
well thats ur opinion, i disagree. and derr i know it was credited to both of them but roger waters came up with the concept and wrote the lyrics, all david gilmour did was add a guitar solo and maybe he helped with the intro, and by saying that roger wrote it i meant he wrote the lyrics, its stupid when people sing someone else's lyrics because they dont know where its coming from and cant express any emotion or feeling towards the song, like gilmours version...
I can respect your opinion. However, Roger did not come up with the concept. David was playing a random guitar riff during a recording session which Roger was impreesed by. So, Roger wrote some lyrics to go with the tune. I still think that the better singer is David, at least in this case.
Your are dead wrong dude.... WYWH was already a complete song harmonically and melodically when Waters came up with the lyrics. No disrespect to Waters, the lyrics are genius, but the original idea and feeling are Glimours... this version must be the worst i have ever seen, it sounds almost country music... totally killed the emotion and the guitar solos are wack!! try the "In Concert" version by Gilmour, if you have any senstivity at all you will feel the diference
You say David's version is stupid cause he didn´t write the lyrics... isn't then, by that logic, this version stupid as well for using Gilmour´s chords and melodies, not knowing ¨where they came from¨? who´s stupid now¨?
who are you talking to? me? because i am not a dude...anyway, thats what me and CPMForce are saying, maybe you should read these posts again? so david came up with the concepts and roger wrote the lyrics, so david is still singing someone else's lyrics and what i say still stands. and i DIDNT say his version was stupid i said its stupid when people sing someone else's lyrics for reasons which i have already stated.
You didnt state no reasons by the way... you just made a plain judgemental statement. This song is about Syd Barrett,. he was the original inspiration for David as much as for Roger, and David was a friend of Barrett as much as Roger. They learnt to play guitar as kids practicing together for f*cks sake!! Sure Gilmour knew perfectly what he was feeling when he WROTE the beautiful harmonies and melodies that Waters PISSED ON in this awful version. David came up with it first... HIS song, period.
judgemental statements ARE reasons when im expressing my opinion.
and whats with all the swearing? if your that nervous that my good ideas are starting to sway you opinion then stop replying. anyway roger's aunt lived a few doors down from syd when they were young and david only knew syd when he was f-ed up on LSD and soon kicked out of the band
You need to get your facts straight. David and Syd knew each other long before Floyd existed. They even traveled together around France, when they were both established in Cambridge. Gilmour studied Highschool in Perse School, thats in Hills Road, same street where Barrett studied and lived during highschool. Its well known that they practiced together nearly every day after school, along with Bob Klose and Roger Waters.
But what the f+ck you know about Pink Floyd anyway?
hmm ok so im not a stalker, devoting my life to researching pink floyd, never leaving my computer, i do have a life, sorry if i didnt know what street it was that gilmours school was on and that i didnt know they had a holiday in f*cking France!
do you really want me to state every single fact i know about pink floyd? what would that prove? woah i know more information than some random guy on the internet, who f*cking cares you muppet,
and anyway i have only 3 characters left to comment.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
See how it's easy to run an ignorant mouth until reality checks? Now you're a poor, innocent girl, but before me, you were much more of a big mouth , weren't you?. Your age and gender is totally irrelevant to this discussion darling, so pretty please, with a cherry on top, back-up your argumentation!!!
I noticed you are not replying about the original subject, so thanks again for making my point...
Gilmour only strummed out a tune, something all guitarists are constantly doing, he gave the song some potential and roger's lyrics gave this song the potential and turned it into the great song that it is today, so i beleive that it is ROGER's song! and im sure the majority of people would also beleive that, period
What you call strumming out a tune is technically musical composition,and in that area,Waters has shit on David. Furthermore,not only David made the chords and harmonic sructure but also wrote the arrangement and vocal melody for this song,besides the vocal and guitar performances,which outrange anything Roger ever did technically.
Nevertheless,Roger did a wonderful job with the lyrics,some of the best in rock history,but that doesnt make it his song.
hahaha yes you have stated this point many times, if you are going to keep replying then at least come up with some new ideas lol.
haha im not following the majority, im an 18 yr old girl, none of my friends have even heard of pink floyd unless im talking bout them, i have formed my own opinions and not the opinions of anyone else, im far from a conformist or a "sheep".
and its not stupid because imo roger, snowy white and doyle bramhall play the music just as good as david does but like i have said roger sings it better...
You obviously have no ear for music whatsoever.... Waters can barely keep his breath. His voice is dry and maticeless. I wouldnt be surprised if his voice was backtracked... like he admitted it to be in his last tour. And no way the guitar work for this version will even get close to Gilmours. Other versions in this concert perhaps, like Dogs or Time.... but never this one. No disrespect to Doyle and Snowy, theyve been great... but they messed up this one big time.
haha you dont know anything about me, and certainly not enough to make statements like that about my musical ear, of course his voice is dry and he cant keep his breath he was around 57 years old! when he performed this song lol.
i can understand if his voice was backtracked, it sounded to me like he backtracked it on "every strangers eyes" on this tour.
and again, there is no right or wrong over who is the better guitar player, its ur opinion...
There is perfectly objective criteria over performance and composition skills on guitar, it´s just that an ignorant twat like yourself wouldn´t ever know of it. Same for singing: to your foremost stupid perception, it´s all a selfish matter of "what i like better"... sorry to pop your bubble, but serious music criticism is not based in subjectivities such as your sorry ass taste.
And well, yeah you are making my whole point admitting Waters is a weak singer and a backtracker......
haha, your calling me the twat? haha ur the one who is swearing at a young girl i think that is a closer definition of a twat than someone who is merely expressing their opinion.
i am not a music critic so why would i care? i like what sounds good for my reasons not reasons which have to be accepted by the whole community.
and what i said was roger is 57 in this video, if you did know anything about singing and vocal chords you would know that your voice weakens over time.
i like the way he changes the second chorus when he sings the last two lines, emphanising the 'have we found' and the 'you' in wish you were here. a bit different than the original but sounds kinda better
Gilmour's the guy who actually wrote the music and playd the guitar on this paticular song. So, thanks Roger for the lyrics and thanks Dave for the music. Together their perfect.
People are not going to like this comment, but this is one of the worst versions of this song i have seen. True, Waters wrote wonderful lyrics for this song, but its David Gilmour´s original composition, arrangement and performance, and this just shows he can´t be replaced in this one. His voice and his guitar are being desperately missed. Compare this version to DG´s "In Concert" (2002) and tell me what you think.
There are so many great versions of this song and so few bad ones, like the one with Roger Waters and Eric Clapton for some charity thing on live TV, that one was disastrous. See related videos --------->
It's Doyle Bramahll II, but he isn't that young. He'll be 40 in December. I met him last week after an Eric Clapton gig. Awesome dude - and OBVIOUSLY an awesoe guitarist!!!!
Ojala estuvieras aquí..
Rodristation 8 months ago
Doyle Bramhall II is among the 5 finest performers on earth today, IMHO.
May21Man 8 months ago
4:46 - 4:49
anagnog 8 months ago
I'M GOING TO SEE HIM LIVE TODAY !
ThebestofallisMJ 8 months ago
O.o
adanalonso1 8 months ago
O.o
adanalonso1 8 months ago
a tama bubinga drumkit i think the drummer plays on and if i am not totaly wrong then it is made from rainforest wood !!! =(
perkele181 9 months ago
come to greece Roger we expecting you
Metalgasparos 9 months ago
@Metalgasparos erxetai
666bafos 8 months ago
Foda!
perudeborracha1 9 months ago
11 people are lonely
HenriQueBskt 10 months ago
The guitarist with the red strat which is not upside down is Doyle Bramhill II. His father was a blues drummer who worked with Stevie and Jimmy Ray Vaughn among others. Doyle later played with Jimmy Ray and also played on 3 Clapton albums. The Strart is weird....cool but weird. It has right handed neck bolted onto a lefty body.
Avalanche1368 10 months ago
Red guitar is not upside down. The cutaway is on the bottom like it should be.
prezadent1 10 months ago
I don't understand what he said at the end... he said how I wish they were here?
EmAlval 11 months ago
@EmAlval he said it right: "how i wish you were here"
DrugsOfPeace 10 months ago
The guy with the red strat is playing his guitar upside down. His guitar is strung with the low E on the bottom and the high E on top.
IvanMtl 11 months ago
@IvanMtl It happens when a southpaw borrows a guitar from a right hand.
artu44 10 months ago
who is for another water and gilmour reunion
taylorracing9 11 months ago 4
wtf? i think that's a right handed guitar being played backwards?
chivitajm 11 months ago
@chivitajm Bloody amazing, isn't it? :)
BrunoSantosOrg 11 months ago 2
@chivitajm YES , U R CORRECT!!! HE JUST HAS IT MODIFIED TO HIS PREFERENCE, HE IS ONE AMAZING GUITAR PLAYER, IT WAS ALSO UPSIDE DOWN.....HE'S GREAT ISN'T HE?
babyjo21166 11 months ago
@chivitajm either way, its pretty damn impressive to me, very very talented young man, would love to know the story of how roger came to meet up with him and take him on tour with him, well....ya, he's amazing i know that....sounds like gilmour did back in the day too, to me this is an ALL STAR LINE UP!!!
babyjo21166 11 months ago
this is for ALL MEMBERS OF FLOYD, sure sounds good, sounds like floyd to me, Roger is a HUGE part of Pink Floyd, hell ...might as well admit it, he is floyd. He very clearly says at the end, yes indeed ....how we wish THEY were here.
babyjo21166 11 months ago
Comment removed
babyjo21166 11 months ago
@Noahman23431
do i give a fuck?
spaceace1337 1 year ago
@Noahman23431
what the fuck do u know about pink floyd anyways what r u fucking 10?
spaceace1337 1 year ago
@Noahman23431
roger was in befor gilmour
it started out syd mason write and waters
then gilmour joined and they kicked out syd because he had mental health issues
those are the facts ur dumb
spaceace1337 1 year ago
What is this perversion of this great song?? 1st off Roger waters...2nd off non acoustic guitar throughout the song..........
TheMetalmaniacX 1 year ago
@Noahman23431 WTF are you talking about?WAKE UP!!!!!!
GIG042 1 year ago
.. Following the loss of their principal songwriter, Pink Floyd bassist and vocalist Roger Waters became the band's lyricist and conceptual leader, with Gilmour assuming lead guitar and sharing lead vocals. With this lineup Pink Floyd achieved worldwide critical and commercial success with The Dark Side of the Moon, Wish You Were Here, Animals and The Wall.
austin27332 1 year ago
Under Barrett's leadership they released two charting singles, "Arnold Layne" and "See Emily Play", and a successful début album, The Piper at the Gates of Dawn (1967). Guitarist and vocalist David Gilmour joined Pink Floyd several months prior to Barrett's departure from the group due to deteriorating mental health in 1968.
austin27332 1 year ago
The band originally consisted of university students Roger Waters, Nick Mason, Richard Wright and Syd Barrett. Founded in 1965, they first became popular playing in London's underground music scene in the late 1960s.
austin27332 1 year ago
Comment removed
austin27332 1 year ago
DOYLE U R AMAZING!!
babyjo21166 1 year ago
Que buena cancion y no voy a ir a su concierto f...!!!!
luisfajardosanchez 1 year ago
Withouut David Gilmour, Roger Waters is NOTHING.
thetrumpetstar 1 year ago
@thetrumpetstar If thats was true then David is nothing without Roger. But they both have much to offer without being together.
Nope, I think they both are just awesome even without each other. I respectfully disagree sir.
marcusdolby1 1 year ago
@marcusdolby1 You are very wise, my friend.
thetrumpetstar 1 year ago
@thetrumpetstar what an idiodic comment. Roger Waters has been selling the Wall Tour out everywhere he goes, and your saying he is nothing. Don't be such a moron. Roger Waters made Pink Floyd what it is today. Dave Gilmour will always be lucky that he was in Rogers good graces. Because Roger has proved time and time again he can do Pink Floyd Without Gilmour and Mason.
austin27332 1 year ago
@austin27332 i think both are genius ...
cleotine 1 year ago
@cleotine I would have to agree there.
austin27332 1 year ago
crap version
jeeves899 1 year ago
damn that guy with red strat is very weird
k0stil 1 year ago 11
@k0stil he's a great guitar player.
desdemiventana81 1 year ago
@desdemiventana81
yes
k0stil 1 year ago
@k0stil the "guy with red strat" sort of reminds me of Syd
TatooineBoy 11 months ago
Roger Waters also writes Dark Side Of the Moon. He is a absolute leader like David Gilmour
Koalagangrenado 1 year ago
Former Pink Floyd member David Gilmour will make a surprise appearance during former bandmate Roger Waters's upcoming 30th anniversary tour for The Wall, announced Waters via his Facebook page on July 14. Marking a reconciliation after years of feuding, the two will perform together at an as-yet-unknown gig during the 2010-11 tour.
underpantswedgy 1 year ago
This is the all time best version of Wish You Were Here. Roger nails it. He sings it with feeling cause he knows what the song means since he wrote it.
Bondsback2325 1 year ago 2
@Bondsback2325 Agree! This is better than studio version sung by Gilmour
wupstorm 1 year ago
roger waters is great but no one can sing it like david can
mochs180 1 year ago 4
@mochs180 True that man
j0seph455 1 year ago
if not through the hands of david, as david is not roger. you can't shake truth.
Super429scj 1 year ago
Why the hell does ppl complain over how they play this song? Or any pink floyd's songs whatsoever? I mean, this is beautiful music, and i personally think this is the best version of this song ive ever heard.
Complaining over a pink floyd song is just...wrong...This concert was about what? 9-10 years ago?
So everything you say won't change anything.
In my opinion, i think Roger Waters did a great job on this, as well as the other musicians there.
RyoMultiMedia 1 year ago
this guy still into gerbals??!
1faastdad 1 year ago
just got two words for this guy: HOLY FUCK!
handyguy007 1 year ago
i didn't know richard gere wrote a song about syd and that he actually plays the guitar!!!
RingelhutsNiece 1 year ago 38
@RingelhutsNiece The so-called ironic comparison with Richard Gere is simply NOT funny. We're talking about Roger Waters here, co-founder of Pink Floyd and one of the greatest lyricists and musicians of all time.
And all these Waters vs. Gilmour forum feuds are just a bunch of crap, bottom line is they are both great musicians who made mind-blowing music together
melinda82 1 year ago
@RingelhutsNiece LOL.. nice observation!!
moovgirl 1 year ago
@RingelhutsNiece haha.
i was lookin, thinkin, 'hmm he reminds me of someone'
:)
Kingmatthewshaun 1 year ago 2
@RingelhutsNiece Thats Roger Waters.
GilmourWaters91 1 year ago
@RingelhutsNiece I laughed so badly :'D
endlesshonorfordream 1 year ago
@RingelhutsNiece LOL :D
stophiemeister 1 year ago 2
@RingelhutsNiece hahahaha! nice one!
body5436 1 year ago 2
@RingelhutsNiece OMG, THAT ISN'T RICHARD GERE, ROGER WATERS JUST LOOKS LIKE HIM! LMFAO!!
babyjo21166 11 months ago
@RingelhutsNiece what are you talking about dude. this is not richard gere! this is the god of rock music, Roger Waters! i know you are just joking.
shafieem 8 months ago
@RingelhutsNiece i once pulled up roger and gere on split screen and the resembelance was remarkable, though
roger beat him out. if see old pics of him in the early days he was really geeky.
seorasmac 8 months ago
That Guitarrist SUCKS he Damned all the Song and Fuck The Great Solo of Gilmour in Comfortably Numb
danieltsss 1 year ago
@danieltsss The guitarist doesn't suck, he just isn't Dave Gilmour.
Coppertunes 1 year ago
@Coppertunes but he doesnt have feeling!!!!! Theres a lot of Guitarrist that play 1000 times better he only play guitar because is his work...
danieltsss 1 year ago
For me this is like a breath of fresh air ,hearing the real talent behind the Floyd doing the classics as he feels them,come on? how many times have you heard the original,absolutely love this,superb!
musicfunkydude 1 year ago
rodger will always be one of the great founders of inovative music while others silently feed off of his lone talent
yalaya29 1 year ago
David gilmors voice still kicks it better
mandem89 1 year ago
master : )
tiagoribeirocorreia 1 year ago
i'm so glad i spent $180 for 2 tickets(O.o) to see the wall live in november :D
kingfelipe12 1 year ago 2
the guitar is backwards ,...... :O Doyle mother fucker :D
kharlos84 1 year ago
@kharlos84 Man he is left handed, to do what he does is something very bloody special you silly bloody shit.....
thegomez56 1 year ago
@thegomez56 oh ok...
kharlos84 1 year ago
i love the left handed guitarist
simkyle88 1 year ago
Graham Bob G says Hi !!
235068 1 year ago
dude, is waters being autotuned? it sounds like it! listen to the live 8 version to hear his REAL voice - his real voice is better.
thebigguyconnor 1 year ago
Dude's (Waters') real voice has finished. ;)
cobranonym 1 year ago
true...
lol all of that screaming on Careful with that Axe really killed his voice
thebigguyconnor 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Anybody know what pickguard is this ?
Exactly pattern, read pearl, tortoise red shell ?
Beautiful guitar!
Thanks!!!
diagonox 1 year ago
And Roger isn't tone deaf!
JohannesMarslew95 2 years ago
Viva doyle Bramhall ll, brilha muito na guitarra.
Mrdornelestonhonhoi 2 years ago
i want to be like doyle one day
pedrobr88 2 years ago
nostalgic!! wonderful!!
INOHOS 2 years ago
The chap at the start is using a variax, love it.
Foxzorz 2 years ago
Roger was the body and the soul of Pink Floyd...Fantastic man!!!
Elvio from Argentina
rimula01 2 years ago 4
@rimula01 no they all made pink floyd.
biggitykilla 1 year ago
I wish sexy bramhall didnt chew gum on stage lol
monequita3 2 years ago
yeah, Roger is a pretty good singer, but as he is particually tone deaf, he's not singing verry musical... And he is good at singing false as well, listen to pink floyd live conserts before the wall. Gilmours guitar, voice and musicality is missing
FenderMeddle94 2 years ago
@FenderMeddle94
Are you stupid?
Gilmour sung a lot more before The Wall.
And he joined the band many years befor that.
JohannesMarslew95 2 years ago
@JohannesMarslew95 what the fuck are you talking about? xD i haven't said anything about that
FenderMeddle94 1 year ago
@JohannesMarslew95 What the fuck are you talking about? xD
FenderMeddle94 1 year ago
Gilmour is better than Waters... Bad singing...
AndreRed90 2 years ago
@AndreRed90 but without waters there would be no Pink Floyd...
AkAjjAcobsz 2 years ago 3
you are at least too damn idiot to say that waters is a bad singer..he is half of the pink floyd's voce along with david gilmour who also is a great man and musician....
atrismalex 2 years ago
waters is bad singer
tangalanga21 2 years ago
@tangalanga21
bad singer...come on man...try to hear d emotion flowin out of his voice...roger is a charming man n a true rockstar
findme2day125 2 years ago 4
@tangalanga21 Waters is great, again and again I listen to him and each time is better
playabrisamar 1 year ago
i was 5 m from the scenen, when waters rock Augustenborg 2007, here in dk....great my best concert...ever...love it
christinamaria36DKQ 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Waters is a mediocre singer, but even so, his stuff is so much better than the other PF members' stuff.
SirPaladinxyz 2 years ago
Are you out of your mind.... he's a fantastic singer!
ThePowerofFritz 2 years ago
there all as good as each other to be fair
fuckingmetal4eva 2 years ago
in the end: "i wish they were here"
what did he mean? Pink Floyd?
vitinbarbosa33 2 years ago 42
Maybe Barrett?
jmc2990 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 good question and good answer
Diosdepunteos 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 probably I miss them. Roger if you ever read this you are a genius dont ever change :)
Kerri36982 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 the original band
hoplite46 1 year ago
Syd Barrett and ......
kianoshashkanizadeh 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 He said "I wish that you were here"
nmiguelsimoes 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 Syd Barrett and Richard Wright
Xaock 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 yes he meant the rest of the band
tornadomad 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33
i don`t think so.
k0stil 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 He is not saying that... "and i wish that you were here" he sings...
pises1992 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 That could be the heavy accent or it could mean the members of the band (not wanting to play or that have passed away).
galaxian00 1 year ago
@vitinbarbosa33 Syd Barrett
razhidiz 1 year ago
I saw roger waters live back in 2004 in Rock in Rio Lisbon....was the best concert of my life...even though i was so far from the stage....it was simply magical......long live Pink Floyd and long live Roger Waters
SjPedro 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
chciałbym żebyś tu była ,,, dziuba ...
szyszu1982 2 years ago
Wrong, Glmour created harmony and melody FIRST, then Waters made the lyrics.
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
1 put ur middle finger on ur nose
2 say the name of someone you like
3 tommarrow they will ask you out or say they love you
4 heres the catch post to 2 other vids this is true it tried it and it worked
shibly4 2 years ago
i like this version, but David Gilmoures version is much better. But sure, Roger Waters have a very special voice
BrynjulfsenInc 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Yeah..Wish You Guys Were Here!!
rockwolf3 2 years ago
Roger Waters' version craps all over David Gilmour's, he found a whole new way to sing it and its much better, Roger wrote it so he should sing it!
becdudek 2 years ago 2
WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOU? Gilmour sings it much better. Plus, You nee to look @ the songwrting credit again. This was writen by Gilmour/Waters.
CPMForce2000 2 years ago
well thats ur opinion, i disagree. and derr i know it was credited to both of them but roger waters came up with the concept and wrote the lyrics, all david gilmour did was add a guitar solo and maybe he helped with the intro, and by saying that roger wrote it i meant he wrote the lyrics, its stupid when people sing someone else's lyrics because they dont know where its coming from and cant express any emotion or feeling towards the song, like gilmours version...
becdudek 2 years ago
I can respect your opinion. However, Roger did not come up with the concept. David was playing a random guitar riff during a recording session which Roger was impreesed by. So, Roger wrote some lyrics to go with the tune. I still think that the better singer is David, at least in this case.
CPMForce2000 2 years ago 2
Your are dead wrong dude.... WYWH was already a complete song harmonically and melodically when Waters came up with the lyrics. No disrespect to Waters, the lyrics are genius, but the original idea and feeling are Glimours... this version must be the worst i have ever seen, it sounds almost country music... totally killed the emotion and the guitar solos are wack!! try the "In Concert" version by Gilmour, if you have any senstivity at all you will feel the diference
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
You say David's version is stupid cause he didn´t write the lyrics... isn't then, by that logic, this version stupid as well for using Gilmour´s chords and melodies, not knowing ¨where they came from¨? who´s stupid now¨?
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
who are you talking to? me? because i am not a dude...anyway, thats what me and CPMForce are saying, maybe you should read these posts again? so david came up with the concepts and roger wrote the lyrics, so david is still singing someone else's lyrics and what i say still stands. and i DIDNT say his version was stupid i said its stupid when people sing someone else's lyrics for reasons which i have already stated.
becdudek 2 years ago
You didnt state no reasons by the way... you just made a plain judgemental statement. This song is about Syd Barrett,. he was the original inspiration for David as much as for Roger, and David was a friend of Barrett as much as Roger. They learnt to play guitar as kids practicing together for f*cks sake!! Sure Gilmour knew perfectly what he was feeling when he WROTE the beautiful harmonies and melodies that Waters PISSED ON in this awful version. David came up with it first... HIS song, period.
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
judgemental statements ARE reasons when im expressing my opinion.
and whats with all the swearing? if your that nervous that my good ideas are starting to sway you opinion then stop replying. anyway roger's aunt lived a few doors down from syd when they were young and david only knew syd when he was f-ed up on LSD and soon kicked out of the band
becdudek 2 years ago
You need to get your facts straight. David and Syd knew each other long before Floyd existed. They even traveled together around France, when they were both established in Cambridge. Gilmour studied Highschool in Perse School, thats in Hills Road, same street where Barrett studied and lived during highschool. Its well known that they practiced together nearly every day after school, along with Bob Klose and Roger Waters.
But what the f+ck you know about Pink Floyd anyway?
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
hmm ok so im not a stalker, devoting my life to researching pink floyd, never leaving my computer, i do have a life, sorry if i didnt know what street it was that gilmours school was on and that i didnt know they had a holiday in f*cking France!
do you really want me to state every single fact i know about pink floyd? what would that prove? woah i know more information than some random guy on the internet, who f*cking cares you muppet,
and anyway i have only 3 characters left to comment.
becdudek 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
See how it's easy to run an ignorant mouth until reality checks? Now you're a poor, innocent girl, but before me, you were much more of a big mouth , weren't you?. Your age and gender is totally irrelevant to this discussion darling, so pretty please, with a cherry on top, back-up your argumentation!!!
I noticed you are not replying about the original subject, so thanks again for making my point...
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
Gilmour only strummed out a tune, something all guitarists are constantly doing, he gave the song some potential and roger's lyrics gave this song the potential and turned it into the great song that it is today, so i beleive that it is ROGER's song! and im sure the majority of people would also beleive that, period
becdudek 2 years ago
What you call strumming out a tune is technically musical composition,and in that area,Waters has shit on David. Furthermore,not only David made the chords and harmonic sructure but also wrote the arrangement and vocal melody for this song,besides the vocal and guitar performances,which outrange anything Roger ever did technically.
Nevertheless,Roger did a wonderful job with the lyrics,some of the best in rock history,but that doesnt make it his song.
but keep folowing the majority, b a sheep
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
hahaha yes you have stated this point many times, if you are going to keep replying then at least come up with some new ideas lol.
haha im not following the majority, im an 18 yr old girl, none of my friends have even heard of pink floyd unless im talking bout them, i have formed my own opinions and not the opinions of anyone else, im far from a conformist or a "sheep".
becdudek 2 years ago
no sorry, it's band's efford, sorry to disapoint you, douche
Rozq87 2 years ago
song is not only lyrics you fucking idiot
Rozq87 2 years ago 2
and its not stupid because imo roger, snowy white and doyle bramhall play the music just as good as david does but like i have said roger sings it better...
becdudek 2 years ago
You obviously have no ear for music whatsoever.... Waters can barely keep his breath. His voice is dry and maticeless. I wouldnt be surprised if his voice was backtracked... like he admitted it to be in his last tour. And no way the guitar work for this version will even get close to Gilmours. Other versions in this concert perhaps, like Dogs or Time.... but never this one. No disrespect to Doyle and Snowy, theyve been great... but they messed up this one big time.
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
haha you dont know anything about me, and certainly not enough to make statements like that about my musical ear, of course his voice is dry and he cant keep his breath he was around 57 years old! when he performed this song lol.
i can understand if his voice was backtracked, it sounded to me like he backtracked it on "every strangers eyes" on this tour.
and again, there is no right or wrong over who is the better guitar player, its ur opinion...
becdudek 2 years ago
There is perfectly objective criteria over performance and composition skills on guitar, it´s just that an ignorant twat like yourself wouldn´t ever know of it. Same for singing: to your foremost stupid perception, it´s all a selfish matter of "what i like better"... sorry to pop your bubble, but serious music criticism is not based in subjectivities such as your sorry ass taste.
And well, yeah you are making my whole point admitting Waters is a weak singer and a backtracker......
LYMBO2006 2 years ago
haha, your calling me the twat? haha ur the one who is swearing at a young girl i think that is a closer definition of a twat than someone who is merely expressing their opinion.
i am not a music critic so why would i care? i like what sounds good for my reasons not reasons which have to be accepted by the whole community.
and what i said was roger is 57 in this video, if you did know anything about singing and vocal chords you would know that your voice weakens over time.
becdudek 2 years ago
in this band...the only ones are in the same level to play with Gilmour are: Waters, Snowy white & the bass player...
triunp 2 years ago
and doyle bramhall...
stratguy1688 2 years ago
Don't even closer...
triunp 2 years ago
Aguante roger!! mucho mejor que gilmour
maximarcossss 2 years ago
gilmour = better singer than Waters
alexanderkok22 2 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
gilmour = piece of shit band stealer
Gilmour= Hunk of shit that hasn't made any good music after waters left
ToolandMAIDEN14 2 years ago
I love this concert!
So much talent was brought together.
A really artistic collaboration show-casing Pink Floyd songs.
Katie Kisson has an amazing solo in "Mother".
Doyle rocks the guitar and vocals (and, looks damn hot in those crushed velvet chaps!)
Leigha1972 2 years ago 3
I agree with you 100 and 20%..2bad this group didn't stay 2gether..the whole album is Great!!..........
rockwolf3 2 years ago
excuseme for the little english....there's anyone that have the guitar tab of this version???expecially the solo....thnx
Domzxz 2 years ago 3
Doyle Bramhall 2nd is in my eyes the real guitarist here, snowy white is also a real one, but doyle brings everything to a higher level:)
Nickjuuh1989 2 years ago 2
i like the way he changes the second chorus when he sings the last two lines, emphanising the 'have we found' and the 'you' in wish you were here. a bit different than the original but sounds kinda better
mcbawsack 2 years ago
I'm a Roger Waters fan but I must say that David Gilmour voice sounds more true to this song. Nontheless, still a very good version.
jmldspt 3 years ago
I second that jml........
Both are Legends but as far as this song goes Gilmour's version sounds much better although Water's version has a different feel to it ..
musicenf 2 years ago
Doyle Bramhall, esse é o nome do cara da guitara solo, muito bom!!
pedrodalmo 3 years ago
I just love Doyle's guitarsolo on this track!!
Man i wish i could find that sound in my guitar!
TheRatPack168 3 years ago
Why does he say "how I wish THEY were here at the end?
aquatiny 3 years ago
cuz of the members who arnt in the badn when they performed this
ufclover1 3 years ago
maybe he is talking about gilmour, rick and nick.. (:
Joyster2212 2 years ago
the best there is..who''is gilmour?? go roger. from the netherlands
sweetyXL 3 years ago
Gilmour's the guy who actually wrote the music and playd the guitar on this paticular song. So, thanks Roger for the lyrics and thanks Dave for the music. Together their perfect.
Trycruces 3 years ago
and the guy who sings pink floyd songs properly ^^
Kytchos 3 years ago 3
excellent
mcbawsack 2 years ago 4
Love this music!
=)
Quebramar24 3 years ago 3
People are not going to like this comment, but this is one of the worst versions of this song i have seen. True, Waters wrote wonderful lyrics for this song, but its David Gilmour´s original composition, arrangement and performance, and this just shows he can´t be replaced in this one. His voice and his guitar are being desperately missed. Compare this version to DG´s "In Concert" (2002) and tell me what you think.
LYMBO2006 3 years ago
Or in "Remember That Night" in 2006.. (or was it 2007?)
Karius7 3 years ago
There are so many great versions of this song and so few bad ones, like the one with Roger Waters and Eric Clapton for some charity thing on live TV, that one was disastrous. See related videos --------->
LYMBO2006 3 years ago
I agree. David sings this better. Still, I would rather that they would just reunite and play this song together.
CPMForce2000 2 years ago
i dont think they should have the beginning on electric guitar. kinda ruins it...great song overall!
Marluxia84 3 years ago
doyle at his best with roger,went to see roger waters,last week in landgraaf 'the netherlands'to bad he left the band,great guitar player!!
hooglander13 3 years ago
whats the name of the young guitarist?
SchenkerScorpions 3 years ago
It's Doyle Bramahll II, but he isn't that young. He'll be 40 in December. I met him last week after an Eric Clapton gig. Awesome dude - and OBVIOUSLY an awesoe guitarist!!!!
rsm0224 3 years ago