Would?
4:44
Added: 4 years ago
From: Rossi4ka
Views: 49,272
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (370)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • One of them is dead, one of them is alive. The alive one is the better one ;) HETFIELD AHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.

  • y would u guys do this to layne they never liked each other. and he fucks it up real bad.

  • Is James trying to look like Layne?

  • @MetaI4Brains are you crazy??

  • @DM25ful

    No, why?

  • How. dare. you.

  • It is impossible to reach Laynes voice

  • Alice In Chains has never sounded better.

  • @DetroitThrash hahahahahahahahahahahahaha..

  • Wow. James really has some balls to play this with the surviving members after all of the shit talking he did on Staley back in the 90's. Both him and Lars are unbearably prickish.

  • Layne drew the design on the bass drum. Its from his Mad Season days.

  • Wow James is really not a good singer. Horrible performance. Compared to Layne his voice is a joke!

  • EPIC!

    

  • James gave the best tribute to Layne by singing this song as Layne would have done. That doesn't make one better or worse than the other, but this is THE best version of this song that didn't have Layne actually singing that I've heard. Ever.  And calling James greedy or whatever....did you not watch the video? He couldn't have genuflected more than he did. Layne did a great job singing Jerry's lyrics, but make no mistake that this is Jerry's brain child. I love Layne as a singer.

  • Stop arguing... best part of this video is the crowd surfing bunny, 3:03

  • Way to ruin the song, James.

  • god awful. p l e a s e don't do that again james.

  • Alice in chains are bad fuckin ass no doubt... but what the hell is lola bunny doin in the crowd 1:54

  • Layne still sings better, and he's dead.

  • What a loser

  • WOULD. DICK. PLAY. WITH. PEOPLE WHO HATE HIM?

  • @T11LMG Wow, that was just lame as fuck.

  • Probably the best thing Hetfield has done since '88!

  • e voice of layne was so much better than the voice of james, that's for sure

  • @NegativeCreep06 in alice in chains songs yes :)

  • @NegativeCreep06 thats an opinion

  • @NHL12ForLife yeah, that's my personal opinion, i know that some people may think that james is better and I respect that.

  • anselmo did it far better

  • 01:54 WTF!!!!! xD

  • James trying to sing a great song like "Would" is like you trying to touch up your sister, hands off don't fucking do it!

  • Whoa... that was a terrible effort, hetfield.

  • know me... broken by my master, MASTER!

  • Its kinda obvious the lyrics have a meaning because they fit in with the Jason situation imo

  • Well, I love Metallica. I love Alice in Chains. I admire both singers. Hetfield is a capable singer but this song, and many MANY of Alice in Chains songs, has a lot of high notes. He may have been able to sing this in his hey-day but definitely not now/then. He did an okay job but that was more a tribute than anything of substance. Very forgettable.

    Clearly, Hetfield had to use far more of his head voice than Layne would have and that's what makes the performance sound off and sluggish.

  • Hetfield butchered this epic song what a fuck head!

  • His voice at the beginning is not great, but towards the end it gets better. So in my opinion, it wasn't perfect but not bad.

  • James Hetfield you're a big hell of a hypocrite or realized what Layne went through after you hit the bottom with booze. You made fun of Layne's misery on stage, in the tour of 1994. not one, not two but a couple of times. and also offstage he made some indirects. You should apologize to AIC fans who felt dissapointed at you and Metallica, fans that were also your fans. (Metallica also made their last lp in Laynes memory and wrote a song for him. concience eating them from inside or what?)

  • James you are a great musician but an awfull person! you made fun of Layne and then you sang his song! WHAT THE HELL???!!??? I love Alice in chains and Layne sang this song as no one !!! James continue singing your own style because you suck at this one!

  • @laww2010 Agreed

  • Because people move on and get over silly shit@alanraymondowens

  • @alanraymondowens they hated each other for a long time but became friends in the end, and this isnt alice in chains, its not alice in chains without Layne, and i hate this cover, Layne was the greatest singer of all time, and James does this anoying thing when he sings where he ends every word with an A, like "AHHHEHH YEAHHHA!" which hes done in every song since the black album, i like megadeth and metallica but James and Dave cant sing

  • @alanraymondowens He was an alkoholic these days, so maybe hes was damn drunk as always, I seen this video it made me angry, his behaviour and whole band was pretty shity and lame, but it's only way to explain this...

  • @alanraymondowens Metallica and AIC are friends. Yes, James and Layne were not good friends but they only make fun each other. AIC and Metallica are the best. R.I.P Layne Stayle and R.I.P Cliff Burton. they are the best. period

  • @alanraymondowens MONEY GREEDY LITTLE UNTALENTED CUNT!!! That's what's the matter with him!

  • @FecalMatter1988 are you mad ? They are two musicians honoring a fallen brother, shut the fuck up

  • EW! after james hetfield made fun of laynes herion addiction he shouldnt have been allowed to do this

  • I think the most offensive part about this is that Hetfield was known for talking shit about Staley and his drug addiction. It's just typical of him to posthumously "bury the hatchet" and perform with Layne's former bandmates. They should've lured him into it and then kicked the shit out of him backstage.

  • @dubq lol...

  • This is when hetfield begins to wish he could still sing. Layne has to be laughing in his grave seeing this douche that made fun of him try to sing his song. All respect to old metallica but since the 90's they sold out hard. Its songs like creeping death that cemented them as a real metal band

  • @reiddajuiceman you are a giant tool...crawl back into your parent's basement, where you belong.

  • Layne's is better but I give credit for James cause he actually did really good

  • just not the same....

  • I really hate to see this fucking-shit guy playing with my band!!! FUCK HERTFIELD!!!!

  • @chaiteli Learn how to spell first before talking shit

    Hetfield is an awesome guitarist/vocalist so stfu

  • This is so ironic, how James made fun of Layne and his addiction then sings with the band?

  • I am sorry but layne staley takes the cake

  • nice one

  • FUCK YOU JAMES HETFIELD you sold yourself in the name of fame and money, you made fun of AIC and now that you have the chance to play with them, everything's ok. SO IRONIC. At least show some respect for Layne, asshole.

  • @fofing13 After he made fun of AIC , they talked about them and they are friends now.

  • Hetfield takes the piss out of layne staley, then gets to sing his music? fucking asshole.

  • @27twolizards This is 13 years after the fact -_-

  • i actually liked it :D

  • James has really matured. He used to dog on Layne back when he was still alive. I think this truly was James' way of saying sorry.

  • Imagine all the rockstars who we idolize come back, peace Layne, we all love you

  • RESPECT! that's why rock is dying, instead of telling bullshit about James Hetfield or that Metallica songs are better, we should support and respect everyone that still rocks!!!

  • james has a random voice man. nothing compared to laynes. hes voices was unique so stfu

  • I'm a massive Metallica fan, but this just shows you that NOBODY can get close to Layne!!

  • 2:37 slash hat

  • this just an insult to allow a Piece of Drunken untalented trailor trash sing the song Would

  • well..that was terrible..

  • Metallica makes fun of Layne Staley and gets owned! /watch?v=uWYnSEZKcVw

  • This gave me shivers. Didn't expect it at all, but it did.

  • @tomanders1 Wherever bro, I know and respect Layne for his music and no for his personal adicction,its obvious, so fuck the haters, and fuck the who comments in here like a fucking chat , good vibes and good bye !

  • it's not that he's bad. It's just that his voice doesn't match with the song.

  • james sounds great

  • Respects. If any heard a cover of the same song in some bar, people WOULD be like " wow what a good job guys". Here is a great singer covering a great song vocally and instuMENTALly. Is James supposed to imatate Layne? James is James Layne is Layne. Respects

  • Anselmo dicks all over Hetfield on this tune.

  • This is just great stuff to watch.

    It's rarely often you see James in a position where he is not completely comfortable, I thought he pulled this one off really well but yeah! what a contrast to his live shows!

  • This song always gets me through hard times.

    When I hear that opening bass, everything is allright.

    Even with James on vocals. :)

  • Lol!!! why many people here hate james hetfield??? Some AIC members were actually influenced by Metallica including Layne Staley... Now Shut up and Listen to the music posers!!!! and if you don't like this... gtfo of here

  • he sings like a shitting cat on the desert :) sorry James but this song just doesn't fit you

  • i dont evn know what to think of this video, i guess its ok but james is not even cloes to the singer lane was

  • 0:59 mike to william "we'll be okay we got it...fuck what was that noise?!?"

  • How can they let James stand up there after being such a prick about Layne. I'm sure it's water under the bridge by now, but still... He's a dick.

  • uugghhhh.....give it up already.....like you should of 20yrs ago...uuggggh.

  • here are a lot of AiC fanboys......

  • If Hetfield did this back in his prime, it would pretty badass. This isn't bad, but it's not his style.

  • UUUghghghgh, that was awful. Go die James.

  • ...this sucks ! You wish you were born Layne, asshole.

    

  • Fuck James Hetfield ! This asshole make fun of Layne for drug addiction ..so Fuck James Hetfield !!

  • @MrAlfre1979 Layne was a fucking junkie. If Layne wasn't so selfish he would still be alive making good music. He also blew off tours with Metallica because he was too fucking strung out on dope. So fuck him.

  • @tomanders1 Some could say if he had not those demons, we would not have been gifted the music he gave to us. Metallica has put out nothing but shit since getting sober. Alcoholica > Metallica

  • @tomanders1 no, fuck you!

  • james = GOD!!!

  • Comment removed

  • what the hell is going on with all this assholes?? He is James Hetfield, he is a mith! Layne was a great singer too, but this sounds soo fucking good!! some people say that it sounds horrible just because james sings, that's all! well damm you haters!! JAMES HETFIELD and METALLICA gonna live forever too! Like Layne with AIC

  • Comment removed

  • I mean , shut up telling that james can't sing this song. I wanna see Layne sang Master of Puppets or Battery. He wouldn't be able to sing, because they are in different styles.

  • @p3druptt He just could have. Maybe he would have screwed it like Hetfield here. He really sucked in here. Maybe he didn´t get much money, I mean, we all know he (and the whole Metallica) did and does music just for money.

  • @dgemivm Oh man. You are so wrong. Metallica is a legendary and awesome band. Hetfield did his best. His best wasn't enough. If Layne sang master, he would screw that shit because they are in different styles.

  • @p3druptt Define "Legendary". I mean, "legendary" bands get that name cause of their comercial succes. We can´t say who is the best or the worst, cause there are great bands in every country, is just that they don´t make it to the top, cause the market just can´t reach them.

  • @p3druptt he can't

  • @kingjojothegreat Layne wouldn't make too if he sang Battery.

  • @p3druptt Well, unfortunately we'll never know right?

  • @kingjojothegreat Yeah but we can tell because they are in different styles. Layne's voice is really different than james voice

  • @p3druptt layne staley is the best singer ever walk this earth so im pretty sure he could sing any song there is

  • @MsJilsephonie Dont be a fanboy. He isn't the best singer.

  • @p3druptt first of all im a girl nd second sorry to break it down to you but nobody ever was or will be even close to layne

  • @MsJilsephonie Fangirl then. It a matter of opinions. You think he is the best, well i don't .

    In the 80's and early and mid 90's James Hetfield was the best singer.

  • @p3druptt well I think he could. Layne was a singer, unlike James that is a vocalist. singer and vocalist aren't the same :), the range vocals of Layne could archive and overpower Metallicas old songs.

  • Nice job of showing you have a cock in your ass hetfield you gay ass haircut wearing fagott motherfucker. YOU SUCK. Stick to enter sandman you fuck. Another shit 'tallica' tune...

  • Nice try Het!!! But this song is for a kick ass voice like the late Layne or even closer Mr Phil Anselmo.

  • Hetfield sings like a drunk fucking hillbilly... Layne Staley is a fucking god!!!!!!! We miss you Layne..rip

  • Fuck James Hetfield.  Punk ass bitch.

  • enjoy the music fuck haters

  • love metallica but Alice in Chains with Layne SHITS on them. Hey james, Layne ran circles around you on the mic. Layne is a motherfucking rock n roll GOD. RIP.

  • He was just drunk all of '94

  • I honestly think this is amazing. I'd rather have AiC with Hetfield instead of AiC with DuVall.

  • I still don't forgive Hetfield for the way he treated Layne... Being a drunk and alchoholic doesn't mean you become a different person, you're exactly the same, you just say and do the things you wouldn't do when sober...

  • Comment removed

  • poor jameses voice is gone ta fuk...40 years of roarin wud do that tya

  • lol, james is having a bit trouble with mic :D

  • this made me laugh

  • Whatever...I'm not sure Layne WOULD have liked it....anyway you can see the difference between a genius and some kind of singer..

  • metaldicka is full of over rated stupid dickheads. not just hetfeield.

    so give him a break. bwahahahaha!!!!!

  • @woodsplitter6 STFU

  • what if James was the one hired to sing for AIC? That would've been real badass!

    but DuVall's ok for AIC, he's doing a good job. No one can beat good ole Layne!

  • @ermonski phil anselmo would be even better

  • Metallica sucks

  • @brodemonz you are a pretty damn brave motherfucker when u have the urge to say kinda stupid thing, that has absolutely no fucking arguments.

  • @arenas00100 i got big balls of steel brotha, I like Metallica,but the last 3 albums were horrible.

  • @brodemonz and there is a band with better songs than metallica?

  • @arenas00100 Yeah there is and you should already know this. You shouldn't deprive yourself. Because if your asking me if there is,your just wanting someone to confirm it.

  • Everyone get over it and just listen to the music. If you don't like James, go watch a different video.

  • GET A VOICE FUCKER, LANE CAN TEACH YOU!

  • @aisidlait Totally agree. And also I can say that Metallca has no one deep hit as Would?. They have no tragic theme of creativity only the alcoholic tragedy of James's voice.

  • @Zhunezhen fade to black?

  • @tillman40 Return to alcohol theme. The only one man who's faded to black was Cliff Burton.

  • Well...Hetfield (slightly) redeems himself in my eyes.

    ...slightly.

    If they were friends...he wouldn't have called him out like he did. MY friends wouldn't mock my personal problems in front of thousands of strangers. If they did, I'd make sure they couldn't breed.

    I'm sick of meddle-dicka, and their constant, flagrant mocking of their peers in public.

    James, you are a dick. Dicks are good for nothing but fucking shit, and pissing on everything. That sums you up.

  • WTF WAS THAT EASTER BUNNY!? 1:48

  • Stop talking shits about James.

    Mount your own band and reach 1/5 of their sucess... and maybe you can talk some shits... MONKEY TALKING!!!

  • @pauloxe Alice in Chains didn't even have 1/5th of their success, doesn't make them worse.

  • @mashui99 absolutely... even because I like AIC. I said these comments to people that are cursing him...

  • James has sinced realized through his own achohol addiction that he was no better than other musicians he would make fun of who were on drugs. He said he use to pin that on everyone else never seeing his own problem. But one thing about him is that he's a work horse. He is probably the most dedicated rocker out there. No matter how bad he was, he never missed a gig and he always had the same expectation of others.

  • @ricadrew AMEN!!

  • Id rather a james hetfield than a axl rose aaany day........

  • James must really enjoy playing with a quality drummer...

  • @JaMeZBoNg1 Lars Ullrich is a good drummer.

  • @nopp1 Ive been drumming since I was 7 and Im 30.. He had fast feet back in the day but the dude never does anything on the rest of his set.. its all single stroke crap! Hes a average drummer at best! :)

  • @JaMeZBoNg1 yeah i admit hes not the best but he keeps up

  • @JaMeZBoNg1 Must be strange for him though, letting the drummer keep time for him rather than the other way round.

  • Wow you faggots are taking this way to personal. Metallica also made fun of Iron Maiden and Judas Priest, but 2 of these bands were one of their biggest influences.

  • I love James to death, he's my biggest influence and he's a role model to me. But when I heard this cover....

    Just no, James. No.

  • oh my fucking god oH MY FUCKING I CANT BELIEVE MY EYES WYH I HAVENT SEE THIS BEFORE

  • Hahahahahahahahah this is so funny, he made fun of Layne but he can never ever be as good as him.

  • @Nikolabetterman I couldn't have said it better myself. James is a bitch. He can make fun of people but has no balls. Example: James had a shoe thrown at him after he made fun of Staley. Instead of doing something about it, he just whined and said stop throwing shoes at us if you want us to play good. What a bitch. Layne attacked a "nazi supporter" at a show. He hit him off the stage (its all over youtube just look up Layne attacks nazi supporter). James can get fucked.

  • @GuitarRHCPfan James didn't make the guy get up there so he could punch him...James handled himself like an adult...He made the guy feel like a dumbass in front of everyone...and his "making fun of Layne" was a joke...Layne has said things about Metallica too

  • @capnkdawg Right, and making fun of someone with a disease in a kid "like" fashion is totally an adult thing to do. It wasn't a joke. It was out of spite. James was upset he lost some money because Layne was too messed up to perform with them. So he pulled a BITCH move and out of malice, made fun of him. You wouldn't punch a NAZI? If you had someone ruining your show and making racist remarks and stating "ARYIAN SUPREMECY" you wouldn't kick his ass? Sometimes you have to fight fire with fire.

  • @GuitarRHCPfan Dude...punching a nazi? If you have any intelligence, you can make them look like assholes and let the crowd deal with it themselves.....It was a joke, and it's not a disease...it's a choice...I know drug addiction fucking sucks, but Layne ruining shows and not being able to tour is bullshit...I love Layne, and I love James...they were friends and fans of one another's music who made fun of each other...get over it...if Layne had gotten clean, like he should've, you wouldn't care

  • ok heres what pisses me off, fuckin dip shit fans bitchin and fuckin moanin over something james said years ago, heres a question, did u personally know layne staley?! WHAT???!!! u didn't?!?! oh well then i guess its safe to say that if the guys who DID know him, ya know, the other alice in chains guys, if they don't have a problem with hetfield why the fuck do u?!

  • @SetAbominae88

    Exactly, these youtube losers are serious bitches.

  • @SetAbominae88 Hetfield is a complete asshole full stop, get over it.

  • @danathor99 So you personally know James Hetfield do ya?

  • @SetAbominae88 No, and good lord i hope never do... But it's well documented that he is an asshole. like i said get over it.

  • @danathor99 had you met Hetfield or known him at all and made your previous statement i'd say fine but for all you know he could be the nicest guy on the planet, and at the end of the day you are just tryin to defend a dead junkie. i can say layne staley is a dead junkie coz thats a fact i know to be true, he is dead and was a junkie. you sayin Hetfield or anyone you have never met or known personally is an asshole is complete bollocks coz you've first hand proof

  • @SetAbominae88 i don't need to know him on a personal level, there's plenty of first hand accounts from people that do and say he is a complete dick... no more need be said.

  • @danathor99 so you always believe what you hear/read comin from people that you don't actually know and probably have an agenda for sayin whatever they're sayin?! and i always thought that rock fans were intelligent and knew the truth about the media, guess i was wrong

  • Fuck you self righteous assholes man. Waah James said something mean when he was hammered. Get over it. Alice in Chains obviously has and if Layne was still alive he would be too.