Added: 3 years ago
From: rihannaforever2009
Views: 16,517
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (134)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • OH-MY-GOD O.O

  • all of you guys SUCK! she was a little girl! and she sing amazing here! i love her... and her voice is really cute... obviously her voice is so much better now... but this is great.. so SHUT UP!

  • I love Riri. But really, she sounds like a cat who's dying. And yes, she improved a lot. Cause nowadays she really isn't that bad. But this performence was horrible. 2:38 she really hurt my ears...

  • i dont get what the whole clap thing is about but she is amazing

  • Haters you can kill yourselves ....

  • @SiobhanRiriNavy LOL..how could disliking this horrendous singing be equal to 'hating'? you can drown yourself out in dictionary ahaha

  • putz ela cantava mal pra caralho

  • Get back to selling your body, because your voice sure as hell isn't good enough. The only way you can sell records to the mindless sheep out there.

  • @0StrangeReality0 U JUS FUCKED UP JUS BECAUSE U DO IT DOES NT EVERYONE DOES WE DONT NEED TO NO U OCCUPATION

  • @0StrangeReality0 Phaha what a retarted ass are you Rihanna is the best now so stfu ur making fool of urself and btw WHen did Rihanna sell her body wtf phah ...

  • Mariah should slap the shit out of her for doing this...

  • @nippyluv she sounds horrible herself...

  • Combermere school to the flipping world.....

  • I lol'ed

  • She had a shoulder lenght hair and somewhat of a fashionable dress that does not look like anything she wore in Pon de replay or Its the loving that you want. I think that image was made up by the record company - I truly believe Rihanna´s true self is coming out now. As for her singing - yes its bad but then again - Rihanna a great singer - not really - a pop star - definately.

  • horrible

  • chile please !!!

  • it wasnt that bad tbh it was good in the beginning and god worse ye but she was young

  • You got issues. Go get some professional help. *wipes hands*

  • wow her singin techniqe is comin from a place full of pain and sorrow.. its okay god's tone deaf anyways

  • i really cant believe you people dont know. i guess its like to be in our feet. i was once like rhi at the age of 15- now i get paid to sing everywhere. dont even try to say the talent wasnt there. it was always there sometims gpd wamts ppl to work harder for there destiny. and im sure she did i used to be like her. but i know wen u earn it u are able. i dont see as "b4 she couldnt sing" i see it as "she always culd sing she had to push extra hard and wen she deserved it god expanded her gift.

  • Damn ! She worse than Mariah at a Jackson funeral and Whittney singing on crack. That why Chris whipped that ass, he's more talented and she gettin the glory. The Bitch sucks. I wouldnt burn a song of hers

  • that dont mean she didnt hav talent..if beyonce sung thru her throat she'd sound bad too. i cnt believe how much ppl dont know..gain sum experience and become a singer. ull learn god opens up certain abilities in this case it was using the diaphram. god wants u to work harder for something rather than jus getn it all at once for some ppl its just there becus they can handle it either way god makes it so that u can be sucessful look at rhianna today.. her talent was always there u hav to recieve

  • Comment removed

  • w0o0o0o0oo0w

  • I mean your talking shit about a video from (at that time) a 15 yr. old girl who grew up with no vocal coach & lived in the Caribbean. Yeah. For the fact that she didn't have a vocal coach, it wasn't that bad. It's the truth. Secondly, if you don't know that lip singing is called lip syncing, you probably don't know the difference of when an artist is doing it or not. When Rihanna sings, she sings live. She's not lip syncing. I'm not saying she hasn't lip synced but for the most part she doesn't

  • there ignorant thats why rhianna is making millions and she laughin in ya'll face now.

    i see you "HIGH HATA"

  • you know, regardless of her abilities as a 15 year old...she sounds way better than a lot of other bitches out here...and whether or not YOU think she can sing, she's still getting money..because in order for your voice to get edited...you have to HAVE a voice..i think that's jus basic knowledge..i mean i could be wrong..but like really..what artist doesnt use some studio touchups? her voice is unique...and it may not be comparable to mariah carey and that's just fact of life.. Grow up & move on

  • not being a hater but DAMN! she can not sing. 15 or not that was terrible. and improve over the years my ass. she just learned to yodel . and as far as being one of the best vocalist thats a damn lie. everybody know this girl can't sing. don't get mad thats just my opinion.

  • BOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!! bahahahaha terrrrrribleeeeeeee! bitch CANNOT SING! & she STILL sounds like this... it's called AUTOTUNE. lmfaooo #fail

  • Excuses, excuses. Just admit that she CANNOT sing. It's really simple. Just like you would judge anybody else who can't sing. smh.

  • whoa shes fifteen here?

  • This was horrible. And she hasn't improved much over thee years either. If only you knew how much voice editing they do in thee studio. That is why she doesn't do many live performances and when she does, she lip sings.

  • What ??? Rihanna never used playback. Her voice has ABSOLUTELY improved. Also HBO named her the 39th best female vocal ever and she is on top 10 vocalists today. And you can watch Rihanna's Abilities...you got it all wrong...

  • back then she sung thru her throat u cant get through a song like that thas y she sounded better in the begginig her throat got irrated u can only use ur throat voice for so long. but that dont mean she didnt hav talent..if beyonce sung thru her throat she'd sound bad too. i cnt believe how much ppl dont know..gain sum experience and try 2 become a singer. she already had the gift god made her work harder rather than getting it all at once.you guys are soooo ignorant wow..

  • maybe ppl don't understand because they have never been in a studio so they think we are "hating"..but you guys would be surprised! they make her sound amazing!! i have personal expereince in the studio and i know what they do!

  • HATER

    

  • @snoop981 stfu

  • @kelvinpyaeko symc

  • @Rique716 she doesnt lip sync alot these days.

    She hasnt improved ALOT but still she has.

  • @Rique716 She actually does sing live a lot, she just does it poorly... I don't think they edit her much in the studio, I think she sings better standing still and with very little distraction. She's not a "performer," I guess...

  • Omg thats terrible. Shitting hell! She wrecked that song man! Lets jst say that she defo improved ova the years.

  • GREATTTTTT!!!JOB well DONE!!!

  • I love the fake-@** applause track! Hilarious!!  Wow. That was just terrible.

  • 2:24 lmao

  • she was good during the first verse but when it came to going higher is where she began to mess up. But you gotta think this is a MC song

  • she should be arrested for this hot mess her fans are calling good.

  • I will write something after my ears stop bleeding SMH

  • LMFAO wut is this was she serious?

  • do y'all know tht this was actualy a beauty pagent too?and she ended up winning both.the talent part n pagent. . .so apparently the judges thought different.

  • she didn't get better that's what technology is for

  • that was so bad Lmao

  • you guys are just some very cruel people everything you guys say have to be negative. Why cant you guys just give someone a break she is only 14 here and is from out of this country so just shut the hell up.

  • It's wrong for people to say bad singing sounds bad? Where they do that at?

  • I really have no idea

  • thats terrible now i know i could get a record deal !!!! lol

    mattxx

  • i'm glad she got better as she got older. . .n the crowd went wild 4 a dumb part.

  • thank you for being nice and not talking about her that bad

  • your welcome,honey. i am nice.

  • You to

  • i think it was great she was great then and she is greater now...How come she is in the spotlight now and you all arn't? funny huh I<3 you Rihanna

  • It sounds like drunken karaoke. lol

  • It was awful. I don't care if she is only 14. I am a 14 year old singer who can do way better. There are way younger and way talented singers out there.

    Come on, she's trying to hard and getting off key. It's so wrong.

  • Are you from Barbados singing a song in english asshole?

  • She can't sing. Stop making excuses for Rihanna.

  • What 15 year-old you know sounds prefect singing?Can you sing?.....Exact! Stop being a hater!

  • Actually I can sing. I'm not being a "hater", I'm just telling it how it is. She cannot sing.

  • child please! i kno a lot of 15 year old sang good! thats just terrible!!!

  • BEYONCE... UMMM YEAH...

  • it's not about whether WE can sing or not..were not signed to label and paid to sing. SHE is the "singer" and she can't. and don't use the 15 excuse..tiffany evans was 15 in her tyler perry movie and could BLOW! she sounded amazing..why?..becuz she is real singer that can actually sing!

  • come on, rihanna was only 14 in this video. i mean her voice hasn't really changed but she hits the notes so much better now.

    and you also gotta remember, she is singing a mariah carey song. mariah is a ledgend, and when rihanna sang this she wasn't even a real singer.

    so come on, we all know this is not her best performance but you have to admit she is much better now.

  • her accent comes out in her music. it makes her sound really bad.

  • wow this has to be the worst version of hero i have ever heard doesnt matter how old u r voice dont change that much so stop tryin to make xcusses 4 her!!! n now half her songs r not even her full voice, its messed w, so her vocals sux, n chris brown they jus both need to STOP n now!!!

  • interesting

  • the beginning isnt even that bad...

  • Come on you guys she was 14 her voices is soo much stronger at 21

  • WHAT THE FUCK....

  • LOL

  • FODASSE

  • DUDE;; STOP HATiN SHE WAS LiKE 14 Y.O WEN SHE DiD THiS & iKNO iF SHE DiD iT AGAiN RiGHT NOW iT WOULD BE MUCH BETTER CUZ SiNCE SHE GOT FAMOUS, SHE HAS GOTTEN VOCAL COACHES ETC.. DAMN HATERS NOW A DAYS.. iLY RiRi <3

  • She still sang the song badly first time round. It doesn't change that if she sang it again.

  • OH. MY. GOD. lol This is so awful it's like torture. What in hell was she thinking? Where's the clown to sweep her off the stage? I can't put my cat through this again.

  • I know why ya'll hating everyone has had a bad performance before and the quality of the sound is baddd !!

  • ok

    like

    her runs are pretty good....but the tone of her voice is just awful...when she tries to put more power into her voice you hear the strain....and as far as the last high note...err....it was nice...just kind of awkward after all that she did before that...lol

  • she wasnt that bad during the first verse n u gotta remember shes singing mariah carey!! but she does need sum more vocal training

  • Jasmine Villegas and Kayla sang this song better than her and they were younger than her when they sang it. It's sad but looks will get you almost anything. There are more important things. Let's start with the man in the mirror.

  • Rihanna can't sing this song... She'll never be like Mariah... She is TERRIBLE. Poor Mariah... If she saw this, she'd kill her.

  • look at 1:51 : her legs are horrible !!!!!! (n) I think that it's quite good she has not the voice to sing mariah carey

  • have u seen her leggs now? idk why they looked like that but her legs r gorgeous! she won gilettes legs of a godess n 2007 but in this video they look fat

  • yeah u're right I totally agree she has beautiful legs right now because she worked on it but in this vid they are...........................­.

  • all am sayin iss if shes famous with a voice liek this we all should be despite talent or not cos she dont have nonee she cant singg now neitherr not live at all!!

  • u're right

  • i like her shes a good singer but not mariah she cant do this song at all but its not here fault

  • flat chest

  • yall hating BUT SHE STILL RICHER AND MORE FAMOUS THAN YALL MOTHAFUCKERS

  • She is terrible, particularly towards the end.

  • she can sing just not this song ... wow.

  • Why is she famous?????? There are many many more beautiful talented black women in this world. Why her???

  • she is hot and stuff..

  • that's life man she beautiful and she makes a lot of lil girl dream that's life I don't think she has no talent but it's sure that there is a lot of women who sing better than rihanna

  • man the end i HORRIBLE RIHANNA DON'T DO THIS AGAIN PLEAAAAAASE!!!

  • woww... she did an okay job, i still think she has a good voice and i love most of her songs... but there are wayyyy better sings out their... shows the power of image,marketing and hype in the industry overruling pure talent and vocal ability.

  • She starts off well, but then her adlibs go abit out of hand. Yea she needed to control her adlibs a bit more, and be stronger in certain areas. But am sure she's improved a lot more, but then again auto-tune does wonders...

  • this is crap

  • and to the people here saying that this is beautiful, its not! This is horrible singing. if you say that I'm wrong and I know nothing about music and that this is wonderful, then you must be tone deaf =)

  • false claping or what? xD That's maybe the worst I've heard since the nabour cat was stepped on 63234234 times...

  • She can't sing at all. End of story.

  • I can listen to alot of things. But this time I heard this, I actually started to wonder, why this woman is a recording artist..

  • Sorry Rihanna.. That song doesn't fit your voice. Started out fine, but u couldn't handle the high tones, or the powerful tones. Stick to your own music where u don't have to strain your voice...

  • ohh - where did your great voice go ? one thing is for shure - it is not here on this song!

  • omg !

  • she's perfect.

  • people come on!!! you know nothing about jusic and singing! HERO is really difficult song, very complicated...try people sign it and then comment on youtube!!!!!!!!!! pseudospecialists!!!!!

  • wtf was u thinkin girl?

    stick 2 'singin' crappy devil music like disturbia and leave the real singing to legends like pcd, beyonce mariah and whitney!

  • y is pcd on this list?

  • Melody and nicole are way better singers than rihanna

  • of course they are

  • Rihanna sounds like a goat being shagged from behind when she sings. This video illustrates my point perfectly: THE BITCH CANNOT SING!

  • hey now....she can sing...this video is from when she was like 16...jus cus she doesnt hav a power house like j hud, doesnt mean she cant sing

  • whenever she sing live (actually, scratch that- even on her albums) she sounds terrible. unfaithful anyone? and take a bow and disturbia is terrible live.... and umbrella. and sos. and hate that i love you....

  • compare unfaithful to russion roulette...she has improved soooooooooo much...they can only do so much with auto tuning

  • horrible....she sucks

  • 33 seconds was all I could take :o(

  • same here! AWFULL!

  • i like rihanna but this was bad

  • Sings from the nose AWFUL VOICE !!!

  • bullshit u know nothing about the rignt singing in this song

  • you can't say that she can't sing in this vid!!!

    such a beautiful voice

  • Love her!

  • How the hell did she ever get where she is today! That was truly awful.

  • i wonder who give you an access to the Internet, boy

  • TERRIBLE

  • your bad knowledge about singing  is terrible too

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more