"The words silly and unrealistic were redefined when I learned that Saint Nicholas travels with what was consistently described as six to eight black men." :DDDD
In Southern Germany they have devils night, where saint nick would comes Krumpus, guys where dressed in goat fur and wooden mask and go around whipping the sins out people. And these guys aren't nice age 12-60 are fare game.
as zwarte piet beats kids with branches, so does the central/southeastern european "Krampus". he is a winter demon going with st. niklas. in germany there is a similar figure called "knecht ruprecht". in france there is "pere fouettard", in scandinavia there is the "julbok".... the duality of this custom (good figure/evil figure) is common troughout western and central europe.
@toomanyaccounts black as in dark as the night(=scary). not black of skin. europeans in the middle ages hardly ever saw black ppl not to mention they had no slaves. they were slaves themselves to their feudal knight. besides that, the custom has to go way back before medival time, my guess is celtic origins, that would also explain why the slavic peoples in general dont have this dual winter figures.
It is interesting that the association of a black man with a former slave is exclusively an American prejudice. This asscociation simply does not exist in Western Europe, where the sight of an African was in mainly foreign, unknown, and mysterious.
"Zwarte Piet", or the men in black face who are Sinterklaas's man-servants, are Moors, and actually represented indepence from Roman Catholic Popery and the Spanish Monarchy. Zwarte Piet is a Moor, a shamanic god actually, that represents the Dutches pre-Catholic pagan past.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
He gets so much of this wrong...it's a bit distressing. Zwarte Piet's black because he's a chimneysweep (the willow branches aren't switches; it's a chimneysweep's broom). The 6-8 number came about during WWII and was introduced by Canadians when they helped out with post-war reconstruction. The old songs only mention one Zwarte Piet for the most part.
@hommeau that's part of the point, though. He's making fun of Americans and their ignorance and tendency to misunderstand, so why not misrepresent the entire concept?
The first time I heard this I was literally crying with laughter; my husband ran in from the next room to ask what was wrong. It took me a couple of minutes to get enough control to tell him I was laughing.
thats what he gets paid for. comidians take little things and blow them out of proportion for laoughters sake. get a snce of humor. im gonna give us all enough credit to realise that we sholdent take a comidians sketch realisticly
Dutch and Flemish people, cut out your revisionist crap - If you want Zwarte Piet to look like he went in a chimney then smudge his face, not give him bright red lips, afro, and black facepaint. Its disgusting how you brainwash your children with this racist crap, but I guess you can't help it. You're just holding on to your last racist tradition so you can still feel superior to blacks. Theres a black president of the US now, get over it. PS I'm not American, but from another Western country.
i belive that the outfit is modled after the acting group that dressed much in the same way during the equle rights movement. caracterizing the stereotype while at thesame time pushing for desegrigetoin. it was a means to an end.
Listen up kids, racist sterotypes are really cool Im a white guy in blackface so it must be ok! Racist stereotypes are awesome!! Lets all dress up like Chinese - just tape your eyes back and put in some funny teeth - haaa soooo!!! Also, why don't we dress up like Jews with big horns and claws!!! Racism is great fun for kids. P.S Im not American, the rest of the Western world got rid of blackface because its racist. Do you like everyone to call you racist?
let me guess, you vote for chauvenistic right-winged nationalists, right? Rita Verdonk and Proud of The Netherlands right?
the civil religion is an imagined community!
your identification is an attachment to a construct! lighten up, there is a cure! humour serves to break down the mental boundaries and confronts us with the funny irony of useless energy waste due to cranky moods!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Americans are simply jealous at Holland ^^.
We have an old culture (what does America have ? Oh ya, war and oil ;>) We have legalized drugs, Sinterklaas AND Christmas. Much more freedom ] Holland pwns. '
Live with it you fat americans!.
Btw .. Video wasnt that funny at all :. and sometimes there's backgroundlaughing while there is no humor at all.
Fat(do I even have to mention?) americans are strange.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This guy makes fun of a culture that is great and brings Joy to a lot of Children. All his points are not realistic or true. So it is actually a FACT that this documentaire is a cheap way of trying to be funny. BTW the public laughing sounds like a big overdub to me..
i believe that i learned in the second grade (as well as you probably did too) that something isn't a fact unless it is concrete or can be proven...so the things you say are very much OPINION.
you are indeed entitled to your own opinion, but lighten up a little buddy, it's satire. it's supposed to poke fun at society. and if you think it comes off sounding mean i suggest you read one of his books, they have a completely different feel than the live version.
For those who are interested in Dutch folklore: Sinterklaas arrives in the Netherlands in Nov., on a steamboot from Spain. On Dec. 5, he mounts his white horse, gallops over the roofs of the Dutch houses & throws presents through the chimneys for the children (like letters made out of chocolate), & the children leave a carrot at the chimney as a present for the horse (if the children have been sweet-otherwise Sinterklaas kidnapps & takes them to Spain). His aids are Zwarte Pieten (Black Pete).
Lordy, I lived with a Dutch flatmate as well as other Dutch people in our international community and this is true with a little bit of difference - Black Petes are actually supposed to be Turks I think but they used to come through the chimney/stove and got soot on their faces but they are not necessarily slaves. Our Santa Claus is based on Saint Nicolas reflecting the Dutch influence in early America (Peter Stuyvesant and New Amsterdam).
The best part of this is the wording.. It's so funny.
deathmonkey123 4 weeks ago
Santa doesn't speak Spanish? I'll have to tell my Mexican friends who spoke Spanish to Santa back home.
vickbond008 1 month ago
Santa was a slave owner!
Sharayai 1 month ago
What about 60 to 800 black men
brasman8 1 month ago
The Santa Claus is stolen by the American people from Sinterklaas.
Greetz, Some Dutchies
dannydemunk97 2 months ago
@dannydemunk97 That's true! The story of Santa Claus actually started as a Coca-Cola marketing idea, inspired by the Dutch Sinterklaas.
BakjeLeip 2 months ago 2
3:01 GARY COLEMAN! Makes sense now why people would think it was elves...
darknessofkrish 8 months ago
OK! American whites would barricade the doors and set up a lynch mob.
diepiriye 8 months ago
He may be one of the funniest people of all time.
jammastertyty 9 months ago 2
Hysterical!
hootowlholler 9 months ago
Santa needs some jodhpers ,riding lessons and a helmet next Christmas ,please !
bscondict 1 year ago
@bscondict - and a blind horse probably would be a good idea, too. :D
nameofthepen 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
So not funny!
wtp1981 1 year ago
"The words silly and unrealistic were redefined when I learned that Saint Nicholas travels with what was consistently described as six to eight black men." :DDDD
Drowfan 1 year ago
i am dutch too and we make suprises but this makes everyone laugh in my house!!!but i think there are more than 200 black man. :)
vettemuziek 1 year ago
In Southern Germany they have devils night, where saint nick would comes Krumpus, guys where dressed in goat fur and wooden mask and go around whipping the sins out people. And these guys aren't nice age 12-60 are fare game.
lugeperson 1 year ago
as zwarte piet beats kids with branches, so does the central/southeastern european "Krampus". he is a winter demon going with st. niklas. in germany there is a similar figure called "knecht ruprecht". in france there is "pere fouettard", in scandinavia there is the "julbok".... the duality of this custom (good figure/evil figure) is common troughout western and central europe.
kralle7611 1 year ago
@kralle7611
And the figure usually either looks like a devil or is considered a demon. In Middle Ages the devil was represented as a black man.
toomanyaccounts 1 year ago
@toomanyaccounts black as in dark as the night(=scary). not black of skin. europeans in the middle ages hardly ever saw black ppl not to mention they had no slaves. they were slaves themselves to their feudal knight. besides that, the custom has to go way back before medival time, my guess is celtic origins, that would also explain why the slavic peoples in general dont have this dual winter figures.
kralle7611 1 year ago
It is interesting that the association of a black man with a former slave is exclusively an American prejudice. This asscociation simply does not exist in Western Europe, where the sight of an African was in mainly foreign, unknown, and mysterious.
Dufuxing 1 year ago
@Dufuxing
Ah the stories of the helper in Dutch do state he was a slave from Africa.
toomanyaccounts 1 year ago
"Tapaz"?
It´s "Tapas"!
mrfoxtalbot 1 year ago
@mrfoxtalbot He's making fun of the Spanish accent. The "s" sound occasionally is pronounced as a "th".
tyredify 1 year ago
@tyredify I am spanish and I still don´t get it. Perhalps you mean the "z" letter which sounds like "th".
mrfoxtalbot 1 year ago
@tyredify no, david sedaris actually has a lisp. he tells a story of it in "Me Talk Pretty One Day."
GummiBear483 9 months ago
I stand corrected,
"Zwarte Piet", or the men in black face who are Sinterklaas's man-servants, are Moors, and actually represented indepence from Roman Catholic Popery and the Spanish Monarchy. Zwarte Piet is a Moor, a shamanic god actually, that represents the Dutches pre-Catholic pagan past.
3rdEYEbeHolder 1 year ago
the "6-8" he continuously says never stops being funny
jazwaz112 1 year ago
Dude, you cut the best part of the chapter in half!
jedwards0820 1 year ago
Hilarious. Also, the images you added are funny too--"Your breast is very beautiful," LMAO!
Missbeansontoast 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
He gets so much of this wrong...it's a bit distressing. Zwarte Piet's black because he's a chimneysweep (the willow branches aren't switches; it's a chimneysweep's broom). The 6-8 number came about during WWII and was introduced by Canadians when they helped out with post-war reconstruction. The old songs only mention one Zwarte Piet for the most part.
hommeau 2 years ago
@hommeau that's part of the point, though. He's making fun of Americans and their ignorance and tendency to misunderstand, so why not misrepresent the entire concept?
adrenalineflow 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this is the least funny shit i've ever experienced
bewlaybrutha 2 years ago
get over the "racial" thing. This stuff is soo funny, I couldn't stop laughing the first time I heard it. Comedy is taken so serious at times
charlesdaenen 2 years ago 7
The first time I heard this I was literally crying with laughter; my husband ran in from the next room to ask what was wrong. It took me a couple of minutes to get enough control to tell him I was laughing.
carolmelancon 2 years ago 2
saint nicholas and christmas are 2 apart holidays in holland in belgium.. they have double feast
ThePopups 2 years ago 3
OMG this is so funny.....
bavvy 2 years ago 6
idd heel grappig :-)
konin525 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This is so dumb.
Sinterklaas isn't the same guy as Santa Claus.
Just about all the Dutch people celebrate Christmas seperately from Sinterklaas.
MickyNL 2 years ago
He makes our tradition seem bad but it is really nice! he just makes everything bigger.
Deblijeegel 2 years ago
thats what he gets paid for. comidians take little things and blow them out of proportion for laoughters sake. get a snce of humor. im gonna give us all enough credit to realise that we sholdent take a comidians sketch realisticly
tailsprower18 2 years ago
Dutch and Flemish people, cut out your revisionist crap - If you want Zwarte Piet to look like he went in a chimney then smudge his face, not give him bright red lips, afro, and black facepaint. Its disgusting how you brainwash your children with this racist crap, but I guess you can't help it. You're just holding on to your last racist tradition so you can still feel superior to blacks. Theres a black president of the US now, get over it. PS I'm not American, but from another Western country.
Kingleopoldthesecond 2 years ago
i belive that the outfit is modled after the acting group that dressed much in the same way during the equle rights movement. caracterizing the stereotype while at thesame time pushing for desegrigetoin. it was a means to an end.
tailsprower18 2 years ago
Listen up kids, racist sterotypes are really cool Im a white guy in blackface so it must be ok! Racist stereotypes are awesome!! Lets all dress up like Chinese - just tape your eyes back and put in some funny teeth - haaa soooo!!! Also, why don't we dress up like Jews with big horns and claws!!! Racism is great fun for kids. P.S Im not American, the rest of the Western world got rid of blackface because its racist. Do you like everyone to call you racist?
Kingleopoldthesecond 2 years ago
hilarious!
Sparkart 2 years ago
instead of being slaves, they were just good friends! Oh my! This is so funny
coutterhill 2 years ago 2
I would hate to see what dutch christmas movies look like lol
Arcadefan419 2 years ago
Love the "tea cozy" and "tapa" comments!
my2livers 3 years ago 3
OMG, he is a genius!!!!!
ajquirky 3 years ago 2
"Hey mom, i got a baby" Merry x-mus
Sara595 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i need a man to sex me up tonight hehe. msg me on MSN. ID is in my C
any122 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This guy is trying to get this Dutch tradition for children to the ground.
Although his information is far from true.
Also, he is not telling that the well-known Santa-Claus is the American version of this very Dutch tradition.
Back in history, when Holland bought Manhattan for 30 gulden, which is about 22 dollars, they brought the Dutch Sinterklaas to America.
So of you try to make this childrensfest look like a tradition for fools, in fact you're laughing about yourself..
GITSVermeer 3 years ago
Het heet ironie. Get a life.
martiniisgood 3 years ago 6
it is called humor
Phished123 3 years ago 3
Wow....taking things a bit too seriously are we? Lighten up and enjoy it for what it is...you'll get a lot more out of life that way.
lrthorne 3 years ago 4
Laughing at ourselves is the point.
Boredgalva 3 years ago 5
let me guess, you vote for chauvenistic right-winged nationalists, right? Rita Verdonk and Proud of The Netherlands right?
the civil religion is an imagined community!
your identification is an attachment to a construct! lighten up, there is a cure! humour serves to break down the mental boundaries and confronts us with the funny irony of useless energy waste due to cranky moods!
tiesthijsthejs 3 years ago 4
thumbs up for the Benedict Anderson reference
unsung1984 2 years ago
haha!! you're totally right... I should made a reference... though i did not mean to sound like a show-off... but anyway, you're right...
tiesthijsthejs 2 years ago
I love the videos with it!
Kelvana 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Americans are simply jealous at Holland ^^.
We have an old culture (what does America have ? Oh ya, war and oil ;>) We have legalized drugs, Sinterklaas AND Christmas. Much more freedom ] Holland pwns. '
Live with it you fat americans!.
Btw .. Video wasnt that funny at all :. and sometimes there's backgroundlaughing while there is no humor at all.
Fat(do I even have to mention?) americans are strange.
PEACE
Snowwhite881 3 years ago
fat, culturless, and arguably, the wealthiest and most power nation in the world. "Live with" it we can.
Webby1788 3 years ago
webby1788, wealthiest nation in the world? Soon Im gonna wipe my ass off with dollars cause toiletpaper will be more expensive.
Snowwhite881 3 years ago
omg snowwhite, please, common, why the hatefull comment man? I am dutch and I actually do think this was very funny!
panne86 3 years ago 5
David Sedaris is an amazing essayist and humorist.
his essays are usually self-deprecating and rarely 'make fun' of anyone but himself.
this essay merely serves to poke fun at the differences between cultures as a lot of his humor is based in being an American in a "strange country"
Phished123 3 years ago 8
UR so right. I love "Me Talk Pretty One Day" et al. I can listen to him and read him over and over. And it never seems to get old.
my2livers 3 years ago 3
I am Dutch and as a kid I loved Sinterklaas, but this David Sedaris story is really funny!
johnnyjolijt 4 years ago 23
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This guy makes fun of a culture that is great and brings Joy to a lot of Children. All his points are not realistic or true. So it is actually a FACT that this documentaire is a cheap way of trying to be funny. BTW the public laughing sounds like a big overdub to me..
GITSVermeer 4 years ago
i believe that i learned in the second grade (as well as you probably did too) that something isn't a fact unless it is concrete or can be proven...so the things you say are very much OPINION.
you are indeed entitled to your own opinion, but lighten up a little buddy, it's satire. it's supposed to poke fun at society. and if you think it comes off sounding mean i suggest you read one of his books, they have a completely different feel than the live version.
cocolopez134 4 years ago 5
And for the grown-ups: At Sinterklaas' time, (mainly funny sarcastic) poems are written for friends, in which their past year has been summarised.
pieps78 4 years ago 2
For those who are interested in Dutch folklore: Sinterklaas arrives in the Netherlands in Nov., on a steamboot from Spain. On Dec. 5, he mounts his white horse, gallops over the roofs of the Dutch houses & throws presents through the chimneys for the children (like letters made out of chocolate), & the children leave a carrot at the chimney as a present for the horse (if the children have been sweet-otherwise Sinterklaas kidnapps & takes them to Spain). His aids are Zwarte Pieten (Black Pete).
pieps78 4 years ago 5
XD this guy is great. thanks for posting.
tomhansonlover 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
you all copied from the dutch so dont talk shit about our culture...
hollandbovenaan 4 years ago
This is all in good humour, with the idea in mind that American mythology about Santa Claus could be made fun of as equally ridiculous..
dbodiford 4 years ago 24
@dbodiford thats his argument. i love sedaris.
BurnlnHell 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
THIS SUCKS!
GITSVermeer 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
u suck!!!
SaraBear666 4 years ago
At least we';ve got a culture. I can't help America has only two cultures... what was it called? Oh yeah: Oil & war.
GITSVermeer 4 years ago
thats..not an original thought. like, when you play the dozens, you can't say 'yo momma is so fat she cant fit her clothes'
you have to say
yo momma is so fat that when she walks, her thighs say to each other 'excuse me, no..excuse me...excuse me...sorry, excuse me'
see
to say america is the culture of war and oil isnt satyre
to say
the people must be drinking it as fat as they are
now that ish is funny.
imalumpaheffaup 4 years ago
Santa Claus comes from Sinterklaas
lucaboris 4 years ago 2
Lordy, I lived with a Dutch flatmate as well as other Dutch people in our international community and this is true with a little bit of difference - Black Petes are actually supposed to be Turks I think but they used to come through the chimney/stove and got soot on their faces but they are not necessarily slaves. Our Santa Claus is based on Saint Nicolas reflecting the Dutch influence in early America (Peter Stuyvesant and New Amsterdam).
Chinamerican 4 years ago 5
they've fudged the story over the yrs but the role of the petes actually represents the reclamation of spain from the rule of north african moors.
dubhusain 4 years ago
Interesting. I always wondered why Sinterklass lived in Spain if he was the Bishop of Turkey.
Chinamerican 4 years ago
thank you for this.
johnk348 4 years ago