i want to learn to play the piano and i have no background knowledge of how to read music or anything like that....does anyone have any tips for a good place to start?
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove beyond any doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove beyond any doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
@DeliveryManBoy do some research bro, taken straight from wiki:
''During the five years following the release of The Downward Spiral, Reznor struggled with depression, social anxiety disorder, and the death of his grandmother, who raised him. During this period of intense grief, Reznor began abusing alcohol and other drugs. He eventually became addicted to alcohol and cocaine''.
@DeliveryManBoy If Johnny Cash were still alive right now, he would label you as the biggest dumbass ever to watch this video. Please do some research before making an objection, and please...it's spelled Reznor.
One time some guy tried to tell me it was Johnny Cash who wrote this song and not Trent Reznor, which is ppular opinion. And I said that was bullocks. Bullshit. NIN wrote Hurt plain and simple. But then I did some research and turns out that crazy guy was right about it the whole time. I posted all the evidence up on my channel so you guys can learn the truth too. Turns out Johnny Cash really did write the song, and a lot of people collaborated to and make it seem otherwise.
bravo indeed, you really captured the pain of the song. This is THE song that has haunted me - its so simple yet so hard to perfect (you did btw). Jonny died just after the cover was released, peacefully. I think he was haunted by this song as it summed up his pain (the pain of growing old) and when NIN nails perfected the song / film clip he was able to let it all go and rest easy. You've honoured the late and great Johnny Cash, Nine Inch Nails and anyone thats ever felt the pain of growing old
I'm curious, since I've been wanting to learn this song. Are you playing the bass and the treble clefs, or the base and the vocals? The sheet music I have has all 3 on it and I'm not sure which one to pair with the base if I'm not going to sing.
awsome! is there any possibility of getting the notes to that? i really want to learn it as you play it. or would you even make a tutorial how to play it? :))) keep the good work up!
who the fuck posts such dumb shit.....no rythm????get a life....this piece is not a rythmic sound, its from a profound place of emotion and was played perfectly......WELL DONE SIR.....ps a piano does not produce off tone sounds....its the player and the off NOTES are suppost to be in this piece........such morons on this site......try supporting people for a change and next time try to sound like you know what your talking about......"im living for music LESSONS more like it dumb ass!!!!
@xxXxXLindsayXxXxx No that was to someone else who thought this didn't sound anything like the song. I think it's beautiful and is done spot on like it was done perfectly that is what I meant and yes, it's much better than I can do I can't play the piano at all!
I don't know which one I prefer, Johnny Cash did an excellent cover but NIN's version was so much darker and depressing Johnny Cash speeds it up a bit.
On the surface NIN version is more depressing until you realize that reznor was in the prime of his life when he wrote it and Cash was at th every end of an amazing one. Even Trent Reznor said Johnny took over that song and put it at a whole new level. Either way it comes down to opinion.
The Depressing factor (for me) is that Trent really fucked up his life for a while, so the song seems like it would have a more personal meaning to him.
He might have been young, but he was at rock bottom when he wrote The Downward Spiral. Cash didn't bring it to a new level, he covered it. It's up for speculation, but it could be taken that Trent was in a different place than he was when the song was written. When it comes down to it, it's still the same words and the same notes. They both sound equally depressed. Also, Trent DID write the song. I don't think he wrote the song without fully understanding its meaning.
@stickmymasta I "garentee" that the lyrics are not nearly as ambiguous as you make them out to be. Those of us with, at the very least, third or forth grade reading comprehension skills can understand the meaning of the song.
@kohldstayr I think cash did a little more than cover it. In an interview, Trent said after watching Cash's music video for "Hurt", he walked outside, sat on the curb, and cried. Plus it had a lot more meaning for Cash if you know his background, about the drug abuse, and his religious side, not to mention the death of his wife. AND, Cash covered it just before his death. Thats a little more than a cover, thats bringing it to an entirely new level.
@llaformer whilst Trent wrote it im sure he was more than complimented by the fact cash covered it I mean come on what an honor that must have been xD
the best songs ever written stems from what the writer has experienced, and I think Hurt is a very moving song. Plus, who has the right to say someone had a more meaningful experience singing it? The song is about the same thing, no matter who sings it and the meaningless banter from fans on either side. That's not fair to either Johnny or Trent to say one is better than the other..
Absolutely beautiful... wow, it sounds way better when played on honky-tonk piano, along with the pedal. Right notes, no big deal--- it's exactly like how Trent would sing it.
The beauty of this song, and pretty much 85% of Trent Reznor's compositions, is that it is dischordic yet beautiful. It is imperfect, irregular, irrational, yet oh so beautiful. The music is almost human. It's supposed to sound like that.
Nine Inch Nails isn't your usual music. It is raw human emotion, with every little scar and bruise left intact and bared for the world to see.
You played the song perfectly, Thumphrey05. 5 stars.
can't press replay fast enough....
WhiteAngelWings14 3 days ago
au Scheiße, kann der die Qwetschkommode vielleicht mal stimmen?
das ja grausam.....*fggg*
TrollyAdd 2 weeks ago
Thumbs up if you used this for your own private Karaoke!!!
papincampos 2 months ago 2
so melancholic and beautiful! love it! <3 :D
mjacksonisperfect 3 months ago
i want to learn to play the piano and i have no background knowledge of how to read music or anything like that....does anyone have any tips for a good place to start?
johnkickass27 3 months ago
@johnkickass27 just Google stuff U need to learn.
sitharhero 3 months ago
@johnkickass27 reading music is always good start. find a good chord chart too. REALLY helpful
paigeANN23 3 months ago
@johnkickass27 Find a local music store and ask about lessons. If they don't provide lessons, they'll likely point you towards someone who does.
OneWhoHatesToSleep 3 weeks ago
damn, i thought i was bad ass at piano but guess not.
Trainwreck1415 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove beyond any doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
DeliveryManBoy 5 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I can not believe that people actually think that Nine Inch Nails wrote this song. This is not at all the type of song a man like Trent Resnor would right. Trent Resnor never wen't through pain like this. Only a man like Johnny Cash could have written a masterpiece such as this. Go ahead and argue with me. I have proof that I am right on my channel. You will admit I'm right after you have watched the videos on my channel that proove beyond any doubt that Johnny Cash wrote the song Hurt.
DeliveryManBoy 5 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy do some research bro, taken straight from wiki:
''During the five years following the release of The Downward Spiral, Reznor struggled with depression, social anxiety disorder, and the death of his grandmother, who raised him. During this period of intense grief, Reznor began abusing alcohol and other drugs. He eventually became addicted to alcohol and cocaine''.
MrSupermick16 5 months ago 2
@DeliveryManBoy If Johnny Cash were still alive right now, he would label you as the biggest dumbass ever to watch this video. Please do some research before making an objection, and please...it's spelled Reznor.
dza94 5 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy you're a fucking r-tard
sbt200224 4 months ago
@DeliveryManBoy Johnny Cash did a cover of this smart one.... >.>
EssenceEvans 4 months ago in playlist EssenceEvans's favorites
@DeliveryManBoy One word, Dumbass
Painintheax 3 months ago
Haha sweet. I NEED to learn how to play this :P <3 NINE INCH NAILS
holographicplanet 6 months ago
i love listening to this vid and playing along on my guitar. amazing job dude! best ive seen
ROCKxNEVERxDIES 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
One time some guy tried to tell me it was Johnny Cash who wrote this song and not Trent Reznor, which is ppular opinion. And I said that was bullocks. Bullshit. NIN wrote Hurt plain and simple. But then I did some research and turns out that crazy guy was right about it the whole time. I posted all the evidence up on my channel so you guys can learn the truth too. Turns out Johnny Cash really did write the song, and a lot of people collaborated to and make it seem otherwise.
DeliveryManBoy 7 months ago
i'm gonna do a cover of this song :D i love you for making this ^_^ i promise i'll credit you! :)
EssenceEvans 8 months ago
so great man!
zona604 8 months ago
bravo indeed, you really captured the pain of the song. This is THE song that has haunted me - its so simple yet so hard to perfect (you did btw). Jonny died just after the cover was released, peacefully. I think he was haunted by this song as it summed up his pain (the pain of growing old) and when NIN nails perfected the song / film clip he was able to let it all go and rest easy. You've honoured the late and great Johnny Cash, Nine Inch Nails and anyone thats ever felt the pain of growing old
davidpertatUQ 9 months ago
Very cool. I love this song.
rollainm 9 months ago
I'm curious, since I've been wanting to learn this song. Are you playing the bass and the treble clefs, or the base and the vocals? The sheet music I have has all 3 on it and I'm not sure which one to pair with the base if I'm not going to sing.
derek96720 9 months ago
Bravo!! =]
Carlit0Tit0 10 months ago
who the hell disliked this i swear anybody who dislikes this is tone deaf
sgtmjames 11 months ago 3
i love your covers :) keep it up! and by the way:very nice taste of music.
Kunimitzu 11 months ago
Beautiful.
I had this song on loop when I broke up with my ex few month ago...
trentikaa 1 year ago
favorite!!!! =D
spider5001 1 year ago
awsome! is there any possibility of getting the notes to that? i really want to learn it as you play it. or would you even make a tutorial how to play it? :))) keep the good work up!
Idontlikereligion 1 year ago
Beautiful... *tear tear*
harliquin737 1 year ago
I will make you hurt...
parchesi 1 year ago
Great Job! I want to play this.
TmarkN 1 year ago
if you have ever suffered from depression you don't need to debate the meaning of the song, one or the other. Well played.
nofxwraith 1 year ago
@nofxwraith depression AND drugs that you take to feel happy bro
brendeninchauspe 1 year ago
Man, you nailed it! Perfect! Just perfection at its finest. :)
OsodeCaram3lo 1 year ago
does anyone know where i can find the sheet music?? i've searched everywhere...
ariana67890 1 year ago
best hurt piano cover on youtube!
punkishh 1 year ago 3
wow, beautiful. nice one.
pickleby 1 year ago
These people are idiots. Arguing about nothing. Anyways....job well done. I really enjoyed it.
YKX77 1 year ago
I love this. Thumbs up!!!!
xxXxXLindsayXxXxx 1 year ago
this bitch spelled guarantee gerentee
scoretosettle 1 year ago
BEAUTIFUL!!!!!!!
I love this song so much it's like I wanna bite it or eat it or something XD
ImNOTanOLIVE 1 year ago
better than the original
this has actually motivated me to learn how to play piano...
xxXxXLindsayXxXxx 1 year ago
nice! please watch to my piano cover of johnny cash, you'll like it!
zitronesaft 1 year ago
gorgeous
Born2Run22 1 year ago
its not supposed to be in tune.. thats how the original song is :) and great job dude
DJKBELL 1 year ago
amazing . i liv this songh, nd jus learned it myselff . imma play it widd my band hopefully this upcomming friday
iiLyUnasBomberas 1 year ago
Like it very much, good job! Just a little strange finalle. I think it should fade to silence somehow.
waabladeeble 1 year ago
<3 :D
vietandflipasain 1 year ago
who the fuck posts such dumb shit.....no rythm????get a life....this piece is not a rythmic sound, its from a profound place of emotion and was played perfectly......WELL DONE SIR.....ps a piano does not produce off tone sounds....its the player and the off NOTES are suppost to be in this piece........such morons on this site......try supporting people for a change and next time try to sound like you know what your talking about......"im living for music LESSONS more like it dumb ass!!!!
paech2 1 year ago 2
i thought it was played just as it should be, good job.
pmm1350 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
sorry but no rythm und sometimes off tone
ImLivingForMusic 2 years ago
shutup no
longcut88 1 year ago
You must not have ever heard this song if you think this isn't pretty much spot on...
xSOURxSKITTLExLOVERx 1 year ago
You must not have ever heard this song if you think this isn't pretty much spot on...
xSOURxSKITTLExLOVERx 1 year ago
@xSOURxSKITTLExLOVERx who cares. I'm damn sure it's better than what you can do.. I mean, c'mon. Give the guy some credit for trying!
xxXxXLindsayXxXxx 1 year ago
@xxXxXLindsayXxXxx No that was to someone else who thought this didn't sound anything like the song. I think it's beautiful and is done spot on like it was done perfectly that is what I meant and yes, it's much better than I can do I can't play the piano at all!
xSOURxSKITTLExLOVERx 1 year ago 2
Rythm. Try playing with the song
illbeurbaby4eva 2 years ago
Damn, well played!
AnimaisMecanicos 2 years ago
so good!
GlovesGloves 2 years ago
do you have sheet music for this
MrAlcatrazDick 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Dude!
you said that newton falkners skills are ridiculous!
you even dont have fucking skills!!!
my little brother is 11 and he is better in playing piano than you!
nab! nab! nab! noob!
DuSpOaStI 2 years ago
Dude my brother is 5 and he has better punctuation and spelling than you shut up you merv
richaphobia 2 years ago
fuck you, this is amazing bro!
07ducks 2 years ago 2
lol i learned how to play this by just carefully watching you(had to rewind alot of times though!)
guess i should learn how to sight-read. =P thanks though! BTW, you play beautiful!
grievous5226 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great cover check out mine in my channel !:D
mox23 2 years ago
You can have it all. My empire of dirt. I will let you down. I will make you hurt.
spicyMcHAGGIS9green 2 years ago 49
@spicyMcHAGGIS9green Yes... Those are the lyrics alright...
SETHWANTSAHUG 1 year ago
@spicyMcHAGGIS9green thats what i keep rewinding to
sgtmjames 11 months ago
can you make a tutorial on how to play the singing part?
MrManson123 2 years ago
Sad Kermit also covered it.
And it is a beautiful song as well.
TheChaymesonBros 2 years ago
Speechless...
Words cannot describe this, the word "amazing" is all I can seem to utter. This song is even more powerful without lyrics.
Ikeisenhower 2 years ago 4
Completely agreed!
heypunkiey 2 years ago
You made me happy :) ...
Baneheart666 2 years ago 2
awesome dude! great job!
gpdaddy1 2 years ago
beautiful beutiful beautiful!!!!
whatfeedsyou 2 years ago
man this is powerful
atom755 2 years ago
NIN wrote the original. Cash covered it.
Both are beautiful songs - you can't really compare the two.
So stop arguing.
dashboardforfire 2 years ago 6
Wow . . .
derek96720 2 years ago
lol actually I'm about as white as it gets, and you sir, are a racist.
derek96720 2 years ago 3
You're an idiot. NiN created this song and let Cash use it.
derek96720 2 years ago 3
is that really true???
DanGarwood2406 2 years ago
is that true and how do u know if it is??
DanGarwood2406 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Both are amazing! And yes Johnny Cash sang and played the original, but that's no reason to offend
others...
Trivalis 2 years ago
hahahahha no he didnt
neilnorg 2 years ago
Um, no he didn't, try harder.
omarawad 2 years ago
perfect
smashingpumpkins4 2 years ago
beyond words
atom755 2 years ago
Flawless!!!!!
phemohilia 2 years ago
Something beautiful.
SolaFideII 2 years ago
2:55 gave me goosebumps...well the whole thing did but that part really hit me hard...beautifull playing
MCRjetblackmirror 2 years ago 7
Freaking amazing
drygon98 2 years ago
Absolutely wonderful!
darkartiste78 2 years ago
amazing
wendy1493 2 years ago
ohh shit where can i download the sheet?
this version, and the original ??
???
csipi89 2 years ago
This is the original. Nine inch nails is teh original
snakeo113 2 years ago
not the Jonny Cash version the original???
by the way i already found the sheet ;)
(the NIN version)
csipi89 2 years ago
That was fantastic! I loved it from beginning to end. A wonderful song covered flawlessly.
mshatswell 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
there is a hurt version on my profil, pleas check it !!! Johnny High - hurt
meiner23 2 years ago
badASS
acwann118 2 years ago 3
so beautiful
oOlashOo1 2 years ago
F**king awesome!
kawaiinoir 2 years ago
In a word:
Superb.
SanGuevara 2 years ago 2
gotta love those famous last three chords! wooot
idioticgerbil 2 years ago
excellent! Have really struggled to learn this on the piano after your vid I was golden. Thanks alot!
bpatrice49 2 years ago
AWESOME
damiandes89 2 years ago
Very, very beautiful.
Well done!
UnabridgedComics 2 years ago
thanks for uploading this badass video. great job!!! hope you becoming the touring keyboardist when trent decides to become a 5 man group again.
djberg 2 years ago
freaking awsome man!!!!!!!!
biwi1994 3 years ago 2
I'm learning how to play this song, its really hard... You did a fantastic job playing it, its the best one I've heard!
FunniFungi 3 years ago
Dude.
Gave me goosebumps.
The ending was amazing!
rgstandard1 3 years ago
Very, very cool... must be the saddest song in the world I recon...
feedme112 3 years ago
perfection
jdnsgdmthr 3 years ago
nice song and best piano cover ever heard =)
keep rulin' babee ;)
At1Ks 3 years ago 3
Epicly cool dude. =]
demonicgrinch 3 years ago
slightly off man
jzirpoli 3 years ago 3
Its an interpritation
alanjayee 3 years ago 3
And you can nail it?
I think it's really good - great job.
weily68 3 years ago
that wasnt one of those asshole comments it was made to help, and yes I can play this song.
jzirpoli 3 years ago
good job
wcash13 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Although i love how he put in the chorus, your gona need a friend to play it for you. and alot of the chords and melodies were really off
theyareAs 3 years ago
i like how the first time he plays the chorus, you can see he can't decide what octave to play the vocal part in
AlexanderK91 3 years ago
dude you are just simply amazing. this is probably the best cover ive heard.
crazymario3 3 years ago
I can honestly say I have fallen in love with you through your music.
You're reallllly talented.
And your hands are extremely appealing... I have a thing for hands. I draw and notice a lot of that stuff lol.
Sorry, this is really weird haha.
EbbsIsOdd 3 years ago
excellent cover, do you have a source for your tab?
daveymcmillan 3 years ago
i love you....lol jk
but really your amazing.!!
Cheyannewhore 3 years ago
WOW!
KalliopeLove 3 years ago
one of my favorite NIN songs and you Nailed it. Its truly beautiful to hear
RockFanatic319 3 years ago
that was seriously amazing.
FireAngelPyra 3 years ago
Incredible. Very well done, you captured the song perfectly.
ZedxElite 3 years ago
that's greeeeaaaaaat :)
mlSean 3 years ago
Jeez, I forgot how to play it but you reminded me how I did bro, thanks :D
Carlosmr1984 3 years ago
It's very beautiful
iiovefruit 3 years ago 2
5*'s
Fantastic.
metalmail19 3 years ago 2
=] AWSOME
trentsgod666 3 years ago 2
Love it =)
XxAgentJackxX 3 years ago
It's beautiful - great work
rkwyckoff 3 years ago 2
Beautiful. No words can do this justice.
phoeberose93 3 years ago 2
:O GZ!!!!!!! :D:D:D:D:D <3
Patus182 3 years ago
very nicely done
nignatz 3 years ago 2
N1c3
RioOt 3 years ago
AWEASOME
vegeta6937979 3 years ago 5
Excellent.
ZedxElite 3 years ago 5
Amazing.
Joshload 3 years ago 4
Beautiful.
EvilKukka 3 years ago 3
I love it. So beautiful, brings a tear to my eye
Toadmaster89 3 years ago 3
I don't really like the NIN version of this song but your playing is unbelievable.
birdmankustomz666 3 years ago
I don't know which one I prefer, Johnny Cash did an excellent cover but NIN's version was so much darker and depressing Johnny Cash speeds it up a bit.
videogame12345 3 years ago 3
On the surface NIN version is more depressing until you realize that reznor was in the prime of his life when he wrote it and Cash was at th every end of an amazing one. Even Trent Reznor said Johnny took over that song and put it at a whole new level. Either way it comes down to opinion.
birdmankustomz666 3 years ago 11
The Depressing factor (for me) is that Trent really fucked up his life for a while, so the song seems like it would have a more personal meaning to him.
prophetoftru7h 3 years ago 6
He might have been young, but he was at rock bottom when he wrote The Downward Spiral. Cash didn't bring it to a new level, he covered it. It's up for speculation, but it could be taken that Trent was in a different place than he was when the song was written. When it comes down to it, it's still the same words and the same notes. They both sound equally depressed. Also, Trent DID write the song. I don't think he wrote the song without fully understanding its meaning.
kohldstayr 3 years ago 31
It's not my opinion that Cash took it to a new level, its Reznors. TRENT said that the song belongs to Cash now.
birdmankustomz666 3 years ago 3
@kohldstayr he didnt understand the meaning i garentee it allot of people don't...
stickmymasta 1 year ago
@stickmymasta I "garentee" that the lyrics are not nearly as ambiguous as you make them out to be. Those of us with, at the very least, third or forth grade reading comprehension skills can understand the meaning of the song.
DrFlaxWebFLOO 1 year ago
@kohldstayr I think cash did a little more than cover it. In an interview, Trent said after watching Cash's music video for "Hurt", he walked outside, sat on the curb, and cried. Plus it had a lot more meaning for Cash if you know his background, about the drug abuse, and his religious side, not to mention the death of his wife. AND, Cash covered it just before his death. Thats a little more than a cover, thats bringing it to an entirely new level.
llaformer 1 year ago 11
@llaformer whilst Trent wrote it im sure he was more than complimented by the fact cash covered it I mean come on what an honor that must have been xD
amevilee 1 year ago
@kohldstayr
the best songs ever written stems from what the writer has experienced, and I think Hurt is a very moving song. Plus, who has the right to say someone had a more meaningful experience singing it? The song is about the same thing, no matter who sings it and the meaningless banter from fans on either side. That's not fair to either Johnny or Trent to say one is better than the other..
chanchan773 1 year ago
Fucking class
conorgillespie92 3 years ago
fuckin....CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP . Gold!!
paulcheeze 3 years ago
damn you're really good
love this song by them
inMYpants0 3 years ago
good job
emiemi2 3 years ago
Absolutely beautiful... wow, it sounds way better when played on honky-tonk piano, along with the pedal. Right notes, no big deal--- it's exactly like how Trent would sing it.
w00ts0rbet 3 years ago
Honky-tonk?...I'm pretty sure it's not a honky tonk...
MaliciousFingers 3 years ago 2
How long have you been playing the piano now to create such an intensive atmosphere?
AlteSchuhsohle 3 years ago
ive been playing 10 or 11 years
thumphrey05 3 years ago
do you have any sheet music for this?
swillett25 3 years ago
nope sorry i played it by ear
thumphrey05 3 years ago
I absolutely LOVED how you played it, i wanna play how you play it. i tried playing it but i sound crap..
smelypenny 3 years ago
To everyone saying he's playing it wrong;
The beauty of this song, and pretty much 85% of Trent Reznor's compositions, is that it is dischordic yet beautiful. It is imperfect, irregular, irrational, yet oh so beautiful. The music is almost human. It's supposed to sound like that.
Nine Inch Nails isn't your usual music. It is raw human emotion, with every little scar and bruise left intact and bared for the world to see.
You played the song perfectly, Thumphrey05. 5 stars.
MonickerL 3 years ago 8
Very well played indeed.
spiderziggy 3 years ago 2
Best NIN piano cover on the net, but I couldn't download it, the server seems busy or someting like that..
atihosz 4 years ago
one of the best songs ive ever heard
great cover =)=)=)=)
BleakWolf 4 years ago