The X-Factor [12.22.2011] - Melanie Amaro - 'All I Want for Christmas Is You'

[ictph3]

SHE DID THIS BETTER THAN MARIAH CAREY take it from someone who listened to this song in walmart all christmas long!

[bumadafaka]

melanie sounded greeat!!! i dont know what these haters are talking about..she is sooo not lip syncing!!!

[deeajustme]

Haters gonna hate. Melanie sang amazingly! Glad she won.

[adizero50]

That made my nipples hard..

[AnGeL99729]

Man how could u say that.......she os not a lip syncer....she got talent that is why she won it......she desereves it......luv u melanie....(KVT GAL)........

[chrisak49]

MELANIE AMERO IS A LIP SYNCER. NO TALENT

[kelvinpyaeko]

@chrisak49 no talent? O_o

[oceaneyes997]

i so called this and she is so predictable. Seriously and if I had my eyes closed, I would have thought this was mariah... who wants two singers with the same exact voice. Not me. I like having mariah, just mariah. Chris Rene should have won because he actually WRITES his songs and last time I check an artist is someone who creates, not mimics. So next time you start think about how great melanie is, remember about how many songs she wrote on this show. Oh i am sorry... thats right. Zero.

[MrRalfbc]

@oceaneyes997 why dont we drop maria and forget her and think about melanie .. matia had her chance its for melanie .. if they have similar voices one of them should suicide ? kill yourself :)

[oceaneyes997]

@MrRalfbc oh thank you. and im pretty sure its MARIAH.... not MARIA. and i never said they should kill one of themselves but i think it was just not fair that melanie won because she was so similar to Mariah and idk I feel shes repeatative with her tone and song genre. but whatever. :)

[MrRalfbc]

@oceaneyes997 whats the difference beteen maria and mariah. its just an H -.- die.

[oceaneyes997]

@MrRalfbc just helping your grammer skills :)

[MrRalfbc]

@oceaneyes997 Just for your info its without an H in french :)

[oceaneyes997]

@MrRalfbc Thats cool bro. But I am pretty sure this X factor was an american addition, just for your info. But hey thanks, because I am taking french in school.

[Juliaama1]

''this is your night'' haha strike Paula

[wiwbib]

this song is for mariah....no one could sing better than Mariah

[wiwbib]

she got the right song choice

[Eatprayloveification]

Simon looks like a penguin some ppl say

[chrisak49]

Omg this is lipped...WTF?

[chrisak49]

They lowered the key a lot. Mariah is so much better.

[98RSabrina]

@chrisak49 Dont Be A Hater. Put The Hateration Away. . If It Was Lipped .They Would Know And Not Qualify It ... !

[chrisak49]

@98RSabrina There has been a lot of lip syncing on X Factor. Get out from under the rock you've been living under and read the news once in a while. X Factor has been caught with acts (almost everyone except the rapper kid) lip syncing

[mlise24]

She looks like Mariah :)

[MrMarhulka]

WOW WOW WOW!!!!! :*

[PeanutCookie]

Wow, I always thought that no-one can sing this song except Mariah herself. But this girl rocks it!

[norranun]

Fuck !!!

He drank beer at 1:18.

What a disrespect to the competitor.

[Masterkohatu]

Congrates to Mel I was hoping for Josh but thought that all 3 deserved a shot at that number 1 for their own talent that they brought to the show. Hard choice but it would never had been wrong one who ever had won...:))

[loveemilyyy3]

she did it perfectly<3

[joanwl]

HOT DANCERSS! 

[JARERE1]

Good miming Mariah!

[LiveFromVCR]

i had her picked to win after Judges Homes!

[2512196833sh]

Amazinnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn­nnnng voice

[KyleKleef]

She did the beginning riffs perfectly! Loved this!

[marymms84]

She looks like Raven Simone, doesn´t she?

[qtal2010]

I just love her voice!

[nemanjatosovic]

she actualy reminds me of mariah carrey.. kinda looks like her 2, wish her all the best

[AMCVI]

THIS IS ONE OF MY FAVORITE CHRISTMAS SONGS......THIS IS NOT MARIAH'S VOICE THIS IS ALL MELANIE

[mc1ate1mad1cow]

This is clearly pre-recorded and then lipped. Sad.

[swhatesjbfever]

@mc1ate1mad1cow & what is wrong with ONE pre-recorded performance , if it is, which it's not -_-, in an entire season ?!

[15md08lilylove]

me calling police

me: there's an emergency

Police:what?

me:there's 1 dislike on this video

Police: THAT IS NOT AN EMERGENCY, ITS ONLY ONE

me: Yah but it Melanie Amaro singing all i want for Christmas

Police: were on our way, and were bringing the FBA

i love you Melanie so glad you won. ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS THAT YOU WON AND MY WISH CAME TRUE. If only you sang the full song

[ayeeangie21]

It's so nice to hear Melanie sing and watch Nika dance... sucha treat :D

[ictph3]

SHE NAILED THIS SONG! RIGHT DOWN TO THE LAST FRIGGIN NOTE! i hear it playing 24/7 at walmart i should know

[TheXoxhottiexox]

I LOVE HER AND THIS SONG SHE IS DA BOOM AT THIS SONG

[cesarisaias95]

She did an amazing job!

[PaNdeM0niuM]

I was hoping Mariah would suddenly appear and join on stage.

[oceaneyes997]

@PaNdeM0niuM its because they sound so alike. We wouldn't know who was singing because Melanie is Mariahs little twin. 

[idolhollywoodhopeful]

@PaNdeM0niuM Well, to me it sounds like Mariah in disguise. WAY TO GO, MELANIE!!!

[PaNdeM0niuM]

where was Mariah :(

[candyblinggg]

@PaNdeM0niuM she is in aspen

[SeddieXFactorFan]

Amazing.. :)

[kariver22]

Her voice is AMAZING!!

[loanme2dollarz]

the only reason melanie won is bcuz shes on simons team, he fixed the vote of course.

[taylor26101]

@loanme2dollarz is that what people say whey they dont get there way. Did it occur a heck of a lot of us like her and voted for her!!

[1Sweetsexyflava]

@loanme2dollarz ...Josh is a good singer as well...he sang a tune from Etta James, does that mean he's an Etta James wannabe lmao!

[loanme2dollarz]

josh should have one he's more orginally,, melanie is a mariah wanna be.

[betternick99]

josh was better

[200damary]

@betternick99 she better sorry

[corrine58]

Shes awesome! Lovely Voice and character

[JanetFamily]

Glad she won!!!!!!(:

[shavanadofelinojulio]

Thumbs up if her would be on billboard next year...

[rameshdar]

Melanie Amaro!!!

[dannymimi]

The X Factor winner!!!!

[vivianaspi]

@dannymimi She definately deserved it! She's amazing :)

[Queenartep]

1st